Sure, if a business deploys it to perform tasks that are inherently low risk e.g. no client interface, no core system connection and low error impact, then the human performing these tasks is going to be replaced.
This reminds me of the school principal who sent $100k to a scammer claiming to be Elon Musk. The kicker is that she was repeatedly told that it was a scam.
https://abc7chicago.com/fake-elon-musk-jan-mcgee-principal-b...
Which makes LLMs far more dangerous than idiot humans in most cases.
And… I am really not sure punishment is the answer to fallibility, outside of almost kinky Catholicism.
The reality is these things are very good, but imperfect, much like people.
Let that sink in.
An LLM doesn’t make decisions. It generates text that plausibly looks like it made a decision, when prompted with the right text.
What the “LLMs don’t reason like we humans” crowd is missing is that we humans actually don’t reason as much as we would like to believe[0].
It’s not that LLMs are perfect or rational or flawless… it’s that their gaps in these areas aren’t atypical for humans. Saying “but they don’t truly understand things like we do” betrays a lack of understanding of humans, not LLMs.
0. https://home.csulb.edu/~cwallis/382/readings/482/nisbett%20s...
I don't think there's much of a difference in practise though.
And when was the last time a support chatbot let you actually complain or bypass to a human?
I'm afraid that's not the case. Literally yesterday I was speaking with an old friend who was telling us how one of his coworkers had presented a document with mistakes and serious miscalculations as part of some project. When my friend pointed out the mistakes, which were intuitively obvious just by critically understanding the numbers, the guy kept insisting "no, it's correct, I did it with ChatGPT". It took my friend doing the calculations explicitly and showing that they made no sense to convince the guy that it was wrong.
Certain gullible people, who tends to listen to certain charlatans.
Rational, intelligent people wouldn't consider replacing a skilled human worker with a LLM that on a good day can compete with a 3-year old.
You may see the current age as litmus for critical thinking.
Humans are also very confidently wrong a considerable portion of the time. Particularly about anything outside their direct expertise
LLMs fail in entirely novel ways you can't even fathom upfront.
Trust me, so do humans. Source: have worked with humans.
Id say those are the goals we should be working for. That's the failure we want to look at. We are humans.
This is interesting because it's both Oddly Specific and also something I have seen happen and I still feel really sorry for the company involved. Now that I think about it, I've actually seen it happen twice.
They're risky in that they fail in ways that aren't readily deterministic.
And would you trust your life to a self-driving car in New York City traffic?
Would you trust your life to a self-driving car in New York City traffic?
Also you still haven't answered my question.
Would you get in a self-driving car in a dense urban environment such as New York City? I'm not asking if such vehicles exist on the road.
And related questions: Would you get in one such car if you had alternatives? Would you opt to be in such a car instead of one driven by a person or by yourself?
I fortunately do have alternatives and accordingly mostly don't take cars at all.
But given the necessity/opportunity: Definitely. Being in a car, even (or especially) with a dubious driver, is much safer (at NYC traffic speeds) than being a pedestrian sharing the road with it.
And that's my entire point: Self-driving cars, like cars in general, are potentially a much larger danger to others (cyclists, pedestrians) than they are to their passengers.
That said, I don't especially distrust the self-driving kind – I've tried Waymo before and felt like it handled tricky situations at least as well as some Uber or Lyft drivers I've had before. They seem to have a lot more precision equipment than camera-only based Teslas, though.
Or just articulate things openly: we already insulate business owners from liability because we think it tunes investment incentives, and in so doing have created social entities/corporate "persons"/a kind of AI who have different incentives than most human beings but are driving important social decisions. And they've supported some astonishing cooperation which has helped produce things like the infrastructure on which we are having this conversation! But also, we have existing AIs of this kind who are already inclined to cut down the entire Amazonas forest for furnitue production because it maximizes their function.
That's not just the future we live in, that's the world we've been living in for a century or few. On one hand, industrial productivity benefits, on the other hand, it values human life and the ecology we depend on about like any other industrial input. Yet many people in the world's premier (former?) democracy repeat enthusiastic endorsements of this philosophy reducing their personal skin to little more than an industrial input: "run the government like a business."
Unless people change, we are very much on track to create a world where these dynamics (among others) of the human condition are greatly magnified by all kinds of automation technology, including AI. Probably starting with limited liability for AIs and companies employing them, possibly even statutory limits, though it's much more likely that wealthy businesses will simply be insulated with by the sheer resources they have to make sure the courts can't hold them accountable, even where we still have a judicial system that isn't willing to play calvinball for cash or catechism (which, unfortunately, does not seem to include a supreme court majority).
In short, you and I probably agree that liability for AI is important, and limited liability for it isn't good. Perhaps I am too skeptical that we can pull this off, and being optimistic would serve everyone better.
I mean, this is an incredible moment from that standpoint.
Regarding the topic at hand, I think that there will always be room for humans for the reasons you listed.
But even replacing 5% of humans with AI's will have mind boggling consequences.
I think you're right that there are jobs that humans will be preferred for for quite some time.
But, I'm already using AI with success where I would previously hire a human, and this is in this primitive stage.
With the leaps we are seeing, AI is coming for jobs.
Your concerns relate to exactly how many jobs.
And only time will tell.
But, I think some meaningful percentage of the population -- even if just 5% of humanity will be replaced by AI.
Imagine you have a self-driving AI that causes fatal accidents 10 times less often than your average human driver, but when the accidents happen, nobody knows why.
Should we switch to that AI, and have 10 times fewer accidents and no accountability for the accidents that do happen, or should we stay with humans, have 10x more road fatalities, but stay happy because the perpetrators end up in prison?
Framed like that, it seems like the former solution is the only acceptable one, yet people call for CEOs to go to prison when an AI goes wrong. If that were the case, companies wouldn't dare use any AI, and that would basically degenerate to the latter solution.
Even temporary loss of the drivers license has a very high bar, and that's the main form of accountability for driver behavior in Germany, apart from fines.
Badly injuring or killing someone who themselves did not violate traffic safety regulations is far from guaranteed to cause severe repercussions for the driver.
By default, any such situation is an accident and at best people lose their license for a couple of months.
Right now it's a race to the bottom - who can get away with the worst service. So they're motivated to be able to prevent bad press etc.
The whole system is broken. Just take a look at the 41 countries with higher life expectancy.
- Air Pollution
- Water Pollution
- Disposable Packaging
- Health Insurance
- Steward Hospitals
- Marketing Junk Food, Candy and Sodas directly to children
- Tobacco
- Boeing
- Finance
- Pharmaceutical Opiates
- Oral Phenylepherin to replace pseudoephedrine despite knowing it wasn’t effective
- Social Media engagement maximization
- Data Brokerage
- Mining Safety
- Styrofoam Food and Bev Containers
- ITC terminal in Deerfield Park (read about the decades of them spewing thousands of pounds benzene into the air before the whole fucking thing blew up, using their influence to avoid addressing any of it, and how they didn’t have automatic valves, spill detection, fire detection, sprinklers… in 2019.)
- Grocery store and restaurant chains disallowing cashiers from wearing masks during the first pandemic wave, well after we knew the necessity, because it made customers uncomfortable
And, you know, plenty more. As someone that grew up playing in an unmarked, illegal, not-access-controlled toxic waste dump in a residential area owned by a huge international chemical conglomerate— and just had some cancer taken out of me last year— I’m pretty familiar with various ways corporations are willing to sacrifice health and safety to bump up their profit margin. I guess ignoring that kids were obviously playing in a swamp of toluene, PCBs, waste firefighting chemicals, and all sorts of other things on a plot not even within sight of the factory in the middle of a bunch of small farms was just the cost of doing business. Briefly looking into the topic will show how common that sort of malfeasance is in industrial manufacturing.
Just look back over the last 200 years, per capita GDP has grown 30 fold, life expectancy has rapidly grown, infant mortality has decreased from 40% to less than 1%. I can go on and on. All of this is really owing to rising productivity and lower poverty, and that in turn is a result of the primarily market-based process of people meeting each other's needs through profit-motivated investment, bargain hunting, and information dispersal through decentralized human networks (which produce firm and product reputations).
As for masks, the scientific gold standard in scientific reviews, the Cochrane Library, did a meta-review on masks and COVID, and the author of the study concluded:
"it's more likely than not that they don't work"
https://edition.cnn.com/videos/health/2023/09/09/smr-author-...
The potential harm of extensive masking is not well-studied.
They may contribute to the increased social isolation and lower frequency of exercise that led to a massive spike in obesity in children during the COVID hysteria era.
And they are harmful to the development of the doctor-patient relationship:
https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3879648/
Which does not portend well for other kinds of human relationships.
You can’t possibly say, in good faith, that it think this was legal, can you? Of course it wasn’t. It was totally legal discharging some of the less odious things into the river despite going through a residential neighborhood about 500 feet downstream— the EPA permitted that and while they far exceeded their allotted amounts, that was far less of a crime. Though it was funny to see one kid in my class who lived in that neighborhood right next to the factory ask a scientist they sent to give a presentation in our second grade class why the snow in their back yard was purple near the pond (one thing they made was synthetic clothing dye.) People used to lament runaway dogs returning home rainbow colored. That was totally legal. However, this huge international chemical conglomerate with a huge US presence routinely, secretively, and consistently broke the law dumping carcinogenic, toxic, and ecologically disastrous chemicals there, and three other locations, in the middle of the night. Sometimes when we played there, any of the stuff we left lying around was moved to the edges and there were fresh bulldozer tracks in the morning, and we just thought it was from farm equipment. All of it was in residential neighborhoods without so much as a no trespassing sign posted, let alone a chain link fence, for decades, until the 90s, because they were trimming their bill for the legal and readily available disposal services they primarily used, and of course signs and chainlink fences would have raised questions. They correctly gauged that they could trade our health for their profit: the penalties and superfund project cost were a tiny pittance of what that factory made them in that time. Our incident was so common it didn’t make the news, unlike in Holbrook, MA where a chemical company ignored the neighborhood kids constantly playing in old metal drums in a field near the factory which contained things like hexavelant chromium, to expected results. The company’s penalty? Well they have to fund the cleanup. All the kids and moms that died? Well… boy look at the great products that chemical factory made possible! Speaking of which:
> Just look back over the last 200 years, per…
Irrelevant “I heart capitalism” screed that doesn’t refute a single thing I said. You can’t ignore bad things people, institutions, and societies do because they weren’t bad to everybody. The Catholic priests that serially molested children probably each had a dossier of kind, generous, and selfless ways they benefited their community. The church that protected and enabled them does an incredible amount of humanitarian work around the world. Doesn’t matter.
> Masks
Come on now. Those businesses leaders had balls but none of them were crystal. What someone said in 2023 has no bearing on what businesses did in 2020 based on the best available science and their motivations for doing it. Just like you can’t call businesses unethical for exposing their workers to friable asbestos when medicine generally thought it was safe, you can’t call businesses ethical for refusing to let their workers protect themselves— on their own dime, no less— when medicine largely considered it unsafe.
Your responses to those two things in that gigantic pile of corporate malfeasance don’t really challenge anything I said.
That is exactly my point. Nobody would dispute that bad things would happen if you don't have laws against dumping pollution in the commons and enforce those laws.
>Doesn’t matter.
It does matter when we're trying to compare the overall effect of various economic systems. Like the anti-capitalist one versus the capitalist one.
>What someone said in 2023 has no bearing on what businesses did in 2020 based on the best available science and their motivations for doing it.
Well that's an entirely different argument than you were making earlier. There was no evidence that masks outside of a hospital setting were a critical health necessity in 2021 and the intuition against allowing them for customer-facing employees proved sound in 2023 when comprehensive studies showed no health benefit from wearing them.
Ok, so you’re saying that because bad things would happen anyway then it doesn’t matter if it’s illegal? So you’re just going to ignore how much worse it would be if there were just no laws at all? Corporate scumbags will push any system to its limit and beyond, and if you change the limit, they’ll change the push. Just look at the milk industry in New York City before food adulteration laws took effect. The “bad things will happen anyway” argument makes total sense if you ignore magnitude. Which you can’t.
> anti capitalist
If you think pointing out the likelihood of corporate misbehavior is anti-capitalist, you’re getting your subjects confused.
> 2021
Anywhere else you want to move those goalposts?
I think what you're promoting is anti-capitalism, meaning believing that imposing heavy restrictions beyond simply laws against dumping on the commons is going to make us better off, when it totally discounts the enormous positive effect that private enterprise has on society and the incredible harm that can be done through crude attempts to regiment human behavior and the corruption that it can breed in the government bureaucracy.
See, "everything I want to do is illegal" for the flip side of this, where attempts to stop private sector abuse lead to tyranny:
https://web.archive.org/web/20120402151729/http://www.mindfu...
As for the company mask policies, those began to change in 2021 mostly, not 2020.
As for the growing prevalence of the light truck, that is a harmful market dynamic stemming from the interaction of consumer incentives and poor public road use policy. The design of rules governing use of public roads is not within the domain of the market.
But we do know the culpability rests on the shoulders of the humans who decided the tech was ready for work.
Pretty bloody time for labor though. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haymarket_affair
The one minor risk I see is the cat being too polite and getting effectively stuck in dense traffic. That's a nuisance though.
Is there something about NYC traffic I'm missing?
Same with any company that employs AI agents. Sure they can work 24/7, but every mistake they make the company will be liable for (or the AI seller). With humans, their fraud, their cheating, their deception, can all be wiped off the company and onto the individual
That's literally the point of liability insurance -- to allow the routine use of technologies that rarely (but catastrophically) fail, by ammortizing risk over time / population.
Claims still made: liability insurance pays them.
The rhetoric of not needing people doing work is cartoon'ish. I mean there is no sane explanation of how and why that would happen, without employing more people yet again, taking care of the advancements.
It's nok like technology has brought less work related stress. But it has definitely increased it. Humans were not made for using technology at such a pace as it's being rolled out.
The world is fucked. Totally fucked.
The framing of the question misses the point. With electric lighting we can now work longer into the night. Yes, less people use and make candles. However, the second order effects allow us to be more productive in areas we may not have previously considered.
New technologies open up new opportunities for productivity. The bank tellers displaced by ATM machines can create value elsewhere. Consumers save time by not waiting in a queue, allowing them to use their time more economically. Banks have lower overhead, allowing more customers to afford their services.
When these people were made redundant, they may very well have gone on to make less money in another job (i.e. being less useful in an economic sense).
Digital banks
Cashless money transfer services
Self service
Modern farms
Robo lawn mowers
NVR:s with object detection
I can go on forever
Or - worse - there is no accessible code anywhere, and you have to prompt your way out of "I'm sorry Dave, I can't do that," while nothing works.
And a human-free economy does... what? For whom? When 99% of the population is unemployed, what are the 1% doing while the planet's ecosystems collapse around them?
People talking like this also, in the back of their minds like to think they'll be OK. They're smart enough to be still needed. They're a human, but they'll be OK even while working to make genAI out perform them at their own work.
I wonder how they'll feel about their own hubris when they struggle to feed their family.
The US can barely make healthcare work without disgusting consequences for the sick. I wonder what mass unemployment looks like.
There is absolutely no reason a programmer should expect to write code as they do now forever, just as ASM experts had to move on. And there's no reason (no precedent and no indicators) to expect that a well-educated, even-moderately-experienced technologist will suddenly find themselves without a way to feed their family - unless they stubbornly refuse to reskill or change their workflows.
I do believe the days of "everyone makes 100k+" are nearly over, and we're headed towards a severely bimodal distribution, but I do not see how, for the next 10-15 years at least, we can't all become productive building the tools that will obviate our own jobs while we do them - and get comfortably retired in the mean time.
If innovation ceases, then AI is king - push existing knowledge into your dataset, train, and exploit.
If innovation continues, there's always a gap. It takes time for a new thing to be made public "enough" for it to be ingested and synthesized. Who does this? Who finds the new knowledge?
Who creates the direction and asks the questions? Who determines what to build in the first place? Who synthesizes the daily experience of everyone around them to decide what tool needs to exist to make our lives easier? Maybe I'm grasping at straws here, but the world in which all scientific discovery, synthesis, direction and vision setting, etc, is determined by AI seems really far away when we talk about code generation and symbolic math manipulation.
These tools are self driving cars, and we're drivers of the software fleet. We need to embrace the fact that we might end up watching 10 cars self operate rather than driving one car, or maybe we're just setting destinations, but there simply isn't an absolutist zero sum game here unless all one thinks about is keeping the car on the road.
AND even if there were, repeating doom and feeling helpless is the last thing you want. Maybe it's not good truth that we can all adapt and should try, but it's certainly good policy.
Are you a politician? That's fantastic neoliberal policy, "alternativlos" even, you can pretend that everybody can adapt the same way you told victims of your globalization policies "learn how to code". We still need at least a few people for this "direction and vision setting", so it would just be naive doomerism to feel pessimistic about AGI. General intelligence doesn't talk about jobs in general, what an absurd idea!
Making people feel hopeless is the last thing you want, especially when it's true, especially if you don't want them to fight for the dignity you will otherwise deny them once they become economically unviable human beings.
Your concerns about mysterious AI code and system crashes are backwards. This approach eliminates integration bugs and maintenance issues by design. The generated TypeScript is readable, fully typed, and consistently updated across the entire stack when business logic changes.
If you're struggling with AI-generated code maintainability, that's an implementation problem, not a fundamental issue with code generation. Proper type safety and schema validation create more reliable systems, not less. This is automation making developers more productive - just like compilers and IDEs did - not replacing them.
The code works because it's built on sound software engineering principles: type safety, single source of truth, and deterministic generation. That's verifiable fact, not speculation.
what are you using for deterministic generation? the last i heard even with temperature=0 theres non determinism introduced by float uncertainty/approximation
I fail to see the difference between AI-employment-doom and other flavors of Luddism.
As AI gets more prevalent, it'll drive the cost down for the companies supplying these services, so the former employees of said companies will be paid lower, or not at all.
So, tell me, how paying fewer people less money will drive their standard of living upwards? I can understand the leisure time. Because, when you don't have a job, all day is leisure time. But you'll need money for that, so will these companies fund the masses via government to provide Universal Basic Income, so these people can both live a borderline miserable life while funding these companies to suck these people more and more?
Who cares? A rising tide lifts all boats. The wealthy people I know all have one thing in common: they focused more on their own bank accounts than on other people's.
So, tell me, how paying fewer people less money will drive their standard of living upwards?
Money is how we allocate limited resources. It will become less important as resources become less limited, less necessary, or (hopefully) both.
Money is also how we exert power and leverage over others. As inequality increases, it enables the ever wealthier minority to exert power and therefore control over the majority.
The problem isn't the money. The problem is the power.
Humans are interesting creatures. Many of them do not have conscience and don't understand the notion of ethics and "not doing of something because it's wrong to begin with". From my experience, esp. the people in US thinks that "if that's not illegal, then I can and will do this", which is wrong in many levels again.
Many European people are similar, but bigger governments and harsher justice system makes them more orderly, and happier in general. Yes, they can't carry guns, but they don't need to begin with. Yes, they can't own Cybertrucks, but they can walk or use an actually working mass transportation system to begin with.
Plus proper governments have checks and balances. A government can't rip people off like corporations for services most of the time. Many of the things Americans are afraid of (social health services for everyone) makes life more just and tolerable for all parts of the population.
Big government is not a bad thing, and uncontrollable government is. We're entering the era of "corporate pleasing uncontrollable governments", and this will be fun in a tragic way.
Right, so the answer is not to make that bad government bigger, the answer is to replace it with a good government. Feeding a cancer tumor doesn't make it better.
Bad government (where by bad I mean serving the interests of the wealthy few over the masses) is bad regardless of it's size.
If you believe in supply-side/trickle-down economics, you might use the opposite definition of "bad", in which case shrinking of government that restrains corporations (protecting the masses) by regulation or paying for seniors not to end up it total destitution (social security /Medicare)
The size of the government is less relevant than what it is doing, and whether you agree with that.
This comment is a festival of imprecise stereotypes.
Gun laws vary widely across Europe, as does public safety (both the real thing and perception of; if you avoid extra rapes by women not venturing outside after dark, the city isn't really safe), as does the overall lavel of personal happiness, as does the functionality of public transport systems.
And the quality of public services doesn't really track the size of the government even in Europe that well. Corruption eats a lot of the common pie.
Please what cities? You are just making up rape stats. That’s makes you the bigger idiot here.
Ohh yeah so much corruption I don’t literally enjoy Zagreb more than any US city I have been to and it’s not even special. Because if this is just have the shittiest argument ever there’s my anecdotal rebuttal.
I might be overgeneralizing, but I won't accept the "festival of imprecise stereotypes" claim. This is what I got with working with too many people from too many countries in Europe for close to two decades. I travel at least twice a year, and basically live with them for short periods of time. So this is not by reading some questionable social media sites and being an armchair sociologist.
> Gun laws vary widely across Europe...
Yet USA has 3x armed homicide cases in developed world when compared with its closest follower, and USA is the "leader" of the pack. 24 something vs. 8 something.
> as does public safety
Every city has safe and unsafe areas. Even your apartment has unsafe areas.
> as does the overall lavel of personal happiness, as does the functionality of public transport systems.
Of course, but even if DB has a two hour delay because of a hold-up at Swiss border, I can board a Eurostar and casually can see another country for peanuts money. Happiness changes due to plethora of reasons. Like Swedes' daylight duration problems in winter, or economic downturn in elsewhere.
> And the quality of public services doesn't really track the size of the government even in Europe that well. Corruption eats a lot of the common pie.
Sadly corruption in Europe is on the rise when compared to the last decade. I can see that. However, at least many countries have a working social security systems, NHS not being one of them, sadly.
The ultimate exercise of government power is keeping someone locked in a tiny cell for the rest of their life where their bed is next to their toilet and you make them beg a faceless bureaucracy that has no accountability annually for some form of clemency via parole, all while the world and their family moves on without them.
The more we regulate to get money out of politics, the more good people will have a shot at being elected.
These are all common progressive values. No true progressive supports wealthy unethical politicians gaining more power. Anyone telling you so is not speaking in good faith, or they are misinformed.
In practice, there's always a slippery slope, can wealthy people integrate themselves in that power structure, lobbying, media control, strength of checks and balances, level of corruption/transparency, etc. But when that slips, we stop calling it a free democracy, and it becomes an oligarchy, or a plutocracy, or an illiberal democracy.
You've literally reversed the meaning of the term "progressive" by replacing it with the meaning of the term "oligarchic".
Progressives argue for less invasion by government in our personal lives, and less unequal distribution of wealth and power. They are specifically opposed to power being delivered to a ruling class.
> The problem isn't the money. The problem is the power
These are nearly inseparable in current (and frankly most past) societies. Pretending that they are not is a way of avoiding practical solutions to the problem of the distribution of power.
Those damn authoritarians, stripping the power from the oligarchs by massively taxing the rich and defunding the police. The bastards.
Is this common? People think "progressive" means "complete government control"?
Progressives support regulations to prevent both public and private entities from becoming too powerful. It's not like they want to give the government authoritarian control lol.
Ultimately it was the 'oligarchs' who argued in favor of the progressive agenda. Wall Street created the 3rd central bank, the US Federal Reserve. The AMA closed all of the mutual aid societies and their hospitals. Railroad barons lobbied for subsidies and price controls to eliminate their competitors. Woodrow Wilson declared war on Germany, "The world must be made safe for democracy"
Of course no would be authoritarian claims more power without claiming that they are doing it for the greater good or to attack the rich classes. The Progressive Era was smorgasbord of special interest handouts and grants to cartels. All of this was lobbied for by oligarchs.
The modern political binary was originally constructed in the ashes of the French Revolution, as the ruling royalty, nobility and aristocracy recoiled in horror at the threat that masses of angry poor people now posed. The left wing thrived on personal liberty, tearing down hierarchies, pursuing "liberty, equality, fraternity". The right wing perceives social hierarchy as a foundational good, sees equality as anarchy and order (and respect for property) as far more important than freedom. For a century they experienced collective flashbacks to French Revolutionaries burning fine art for firewood in an occupied chateau.
Notably, it has not been a straight line of Social Progress, nor a simple Hegelian dialectic, but a turbulent winding path between different forces of history that have left us with less or more personal liberty in various eras. But... well... you have to be very confused about what they actually believe now or historically to understand progressives or leftists as tyrants who demand hierarchy.
That confusion may come from listening to misinformation from anticommunists, a particular breed of conservative who for the past half century have asserted that ANY attempt to improve government or enhance equality was a Communist plot by people who earnestly wanted Soviet style rule. One of those anticommunists with a business empire, Charles Koch, funded basically all the institutions of the 'libertarian' movement, and later on much of the current GOP's brand of conservatism.
The employees of the government and those elected are not seen as the ruling class by progressives, but just normal people that have the qualifications and are employed to manage the government on behalf of the people.
It's important therefore that those elected and put in charge of the government are in a position where they don't have the power to benefit themselves or their friends/family, but are in a position where they can wield power to benefit the people who hired them for the job (their constituents), and that if they fail to do so, they can get replaced.
Apparently people who are not wealthy enough to buy a boat and afraid of drowning care about this a lot. Also, for whom the tide rises? Not for the data workers which label data for these systems for peanuts, or people who lose jobs because they can be replaced with AI, or Amazon drivers which are auto-fired by their in-car HAL9000 units which label behavior the way they see fit.
> The wealthy people I know all have one thing in common: they focused more on their own bank accounts than on other people's.
So, the amount of money they have is much more important than everything else. That's greed, not wealth, but OK. I'm not feeling like dying on the hill of greedy people today.
> Money is how we allocate limited resources.
...and the wealthy people (you or I or others know) are accumulating amounts of it which they can't make good use of personally, I will argue.
> It will become less important as resources become less limited, less necessary, or (hopefully) both.
How will we make resources less limited? Recycling? Reducing population? Creating out of thin air?
Or, how will they become less necessary? Did we invent materials which are more durable and cheaper to produce, and do we start to sell it to people for less? I don't think so.
See, this is not a developing country problem. It's a developed country problem. Stellantis is selling inferior products for more money, while reducing workforce , closing factories, replacing metal parts with plastics, and CEO is taking $40MM as a bonus [0], and now he's apparently resigned after all that shenanigans.
So, no. Nobody is making things cheaper for people. Everybody is after the money to rise their own tides.
So, you're delusional. Nobody is thinking about your bank account that's true. This is why resources won't be less limited or less necessary. Because all the surplus is accumulating at people who are focused on their own bank accounts more than anything else.
We've already done it, as evidenced by the fact that you had the time and tools to write that screed. Your parents probably didn't, and your grandparents certainly didn't.
No, my parents had that. Instead, they were chatting on the phone. My grandparents already had that too. They just chatted at the hall in front of the house with their neighbors.
We don't have time. We are just deluding ourselves. While our lives are technologically better, and we live longer, our lives are not objectively healthier and happier.
Heck, my colleagues join teleconferences from home with their kid's voice at the background and drying clothes visible, only hidden by the Gaussian blur or fake background provided by the software.
How they have more time to do more things? They still work 8 hours a day, doing the occasional overtime.
Things have changed and evolved, but evolution and change doesn't always bring progress. We have progressed in other areas, but justice, life conditions and wealth are not in this list. I certainly can't buy a house just because I want one like my grandparents did, for example.
Separately, is it "rising tide lifts all boats" or "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" that drives the common person's progress? You seem confused which metaphor to apply while handwaving the discussion away.
The Luddites asked a similar question. The ultimate answer is that it doesn't matter that much who controls the means of production, as long as we have access to its fruits.
As long as manual labor is in the loop, the limits to productivity are fixed. Machines scale, humans don't. It doesn't matter whether you're talking about a cotton gin or a warehouse full of GPUs.
Separately, is it "rising tide lifts all boats" or "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" that drives the common person's progress? You seem confused which metaphor to apply while handwaving the discussion away.
I haven't invoked the "bootstrap" cliché here, have I? Just the boat thing. They make very different points.
Anyway, never mind the bootstraps: where'd you get the boots? Is there a shortage of boots?
There once was a shortage of boots, it's safe to say, but automation fixed that. Humans didn't, and couldn't, but machines did. Or more properly, humans building and using machines did.
That mattered a lot in communist places, we saw it fail. Same thing with most authoritarian regime today, it's a crap shoot. You simply can't entrust a small group with full control on the means of production and expect them to make it efficient, cheap, innovative, sustainable and affordable.
The availability of cheaply priced smartphones and cellular data plans has absolutely made being homeless suck less.
As you noted though, a home would probably be a preferable alternative.
The problem is that the preferable option (housing) won't happen because unlike a smartphone, it requires that land be effectively distributed more broadly (through building housing) in areas where people desire to live. Look at the uproar by the VC guys in Menlo Park when the government tried to pursue greater housing density in their wealthy hamlet.
It also requires infrastructure investment which, while it has returns for society at large, doesn't have good returns for investors. Only government makes those kinds of investments.
Better to build a wall around the desirable places, hire a few poorer-than-you folks as security guards, and give the other people outside your wall ... cheap smartphones to sate themselves.
In 2012, Musk was worth $2 billion. He’s now worth 223 times that yet the minimum wage has barely budged in the last 12 years as productivity rises.
>Productivity gains of the last 40 years have been captured by shareholders and top elites. Working class wages have been flat...
Wages do not determine the standard of living. The products and services purchased with wages determine the standard of living. "Top elites" in 1984 could already afford cellular phones, such as the Motorola DynaTAC:
>A full charge took roughly 10 hours, and it offered 30 minutes of talk time. It also offered an LED display for dialing or recall of one of 30 phone numbers. It was priced at US$3,995 in 1984, its commercial release year, equivalent to $11,716 in 2023.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_DynaTAC
Unfortunately, touch screen phones with gigabytes of ram were not available for the masses 40 years ago.
Rather than a luxury, they've become an expensive interest bearing necessity for billions of human beings.
From what I understand of history, while industrial revolutions have generally increased living standards and employment in the long term, they have also caused massive unemployment/starvation in the short term. In the case of textile, I seem to recall that it took ~40 years for employment to return to its previous level.
I don't know about you guys, but I'm far from certain that I can survive 40 years without a job.
The other things you state are not even close.
First, lowered employment for X years does not imply one cannot get a job in X years - that's simply fear mongering. Unemployment over that period seems to have fluctuated very little, and massive external economic issues were causes (wars with Napoleon, the US, changing international fortunes), not Luddites.
Next, there was inflation and unemployment during the TWO years surrounding the Luddites, in 1810-1812 (starting right before the Luddite movement) due to wars with Napoleon and the US [1]. Somehow attributing this to tech increases or Luddites is numerology of the worst sort.
If you look at academic literature about the economy of the era, such as [2] (read on scihub if you must), you'll find there was incredible population growth, and that wages grew even faster. While many academics at the at the time thought all this automation would displace workers, those academics were forced to admit they were wrong. There's plenty of literature on this. Simply dig through Google scholar.
As to starvation in this case, I can find no "massive starvation". [3] forExample points out that "Among the industrial and mining families, around 18 per cent of writers recollected having experienced hunger. In the agricultural families this figure was more than twice as large — 42 per cent".
So yes there was hunger, as there always had been, but it quickly reduced due to the industrial revolution and benefited those working in industry more quickly than those not in industry.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite#:~:text=The%20movement....
My bad for "massive starvation", that's clearly a mistake, I meant to write something along the lines of "massive unemployment – and sometimes starvation". Sadly, too late to amend.
Now, I'll admit that I don't have my statistics at hand. I quoted them from memory from, if I recall correctly, _Good Economics for Hard Times_. I'm nearly certain about the ~40 years, but it's entirely possible that I confused several parts of the industrial revolution. I'll double-check when I have an opportunity.
Perhaps there is a theory in which productivity gains increase the standard of living for everyone, however that is not the lived reality for most people of the working classes.
If productivity gains are indeed increasing the standards of living to everyone, it certainly does not increase evenly, and the standard of living increases for the working poor are at best marginal, while the standard of living increases for the already richest of the rich are astronomical.
Not if you count the global poor, the global poors standard of living has increased tremendously the past 30 years.
Off course any graph can choose to show which ever stat is convenient for the message, that doesn’t necessarily reflect the lived reality of the individual members of the global poor. And as I recall it most standard of living improvements for the global poor came in the decades after decolonization in the 1960s-1990s where infrastructure was being built that actually served people’s need as opposed for resource extraction in the decades past. If Hans Rosling said in 2007 that the standard of living has improved tremendously in the past 30 years, he would be correct, but not for the reason you gave.
The story of decolonization was that the correct infrastructure, such as hospitals, water lines, sewage, garbage disposal plants, roads, harbors, airports, schools, etc. that improved the standard of living not productivity gains. And case in point, the colonial period saw a tremendous growth in productivity in the colonies. But the standard of living in the colonies quite often saw the opposite. That is because the infrastructure only served to extract resources and exploitation of the colonized.
https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/opendata/updated-estimates-pr...
For extreme poverty progress has recently slowed down, the trend there is still positive but very slow - improvement there is needed.
This just isn’t true, necessarily. Productivity has gone up in the US since the 80s, but wages have not. Costs have, though.
What increases standards of living for everyone is social programs like public health and education. Affordable housing and adult-education and job hunting programs.
Not the rate at which money is gathered by corporations.
Warlords are still rich, but both money and war is flowing towards tech. You can get a piece from that pie if you're doing questionable things (adtech, targeting, data collection, brokering, etc.), but if you're a run of the mill, normal person, your circumstances are getting harder and harder, because you're slowly squeezed out of the system like a toothpaste.
AI could theoretically solve production but not consumption. If AI blows away every comparative advantage that normal humans have then consumption will collapse and there won’t be any rich humans.
> deep learning doesn't allow models to generalize properly to out-of-distribution data—and that is precisely what we need to build artificial general intelligence.
I think even (or especially) people like Altman accept this as a fact. I do. Hassabis has been saying this for years.
The foundational models are just a foundation. Now start building the AGI superstructure.
And this is also where most of the still human intellectual energy is now.
These statistical models don’t generalize well to out of distribution data. If you accept that as a fact, then you must accept that these statistical models are not the path to AGI.
For AI example(s): Attribution is low, a system built without human intervention may suddenly fall outside its own expertise and hallucinate itself into a corner, everyone may just throw more compute at a system until it grows without bound, etc etc.
This "You can scale up to infinity" problem might become "You have to scale up to infinity" to build any reasonably sized system with AI. The shovel-sellers get fantastically rich but the businesses are effectively left holding the risk from a fast-moving, unintuitive, uninspected, partially verified codebase. I just don't see how anyone not building a CRUD app/frontend could be comfortable with that, but then again my Tesla is effectively running such a system to drive me and my kids. Albeit, that's on a well-defined problem and within literally human-made guardrails.
The wild part is that LLMs understand us way better than we understand them. The jump from GPT-3 to GPT-4 even surprised the engineers who built it. That should raise some red flags about how "predictable" these systems really are.
Think about it - we can't actually verify what these models are capable of or if they're being truthful, while they have this massive knowledge base about human behavior and psychology. That's a pretty concerning power imbalance. What looks like lower risk on the surface might be hiding much deeper uncertainties that we can't even detect, let alone control.
As for employment, automation makes people more productive. It doesn't reduce the number of earning opportunities that exist. Quite the opposite, actually. As the amount of production increases relative to the human population, per capita GDP and income increase as well.
US Real GDP per capita is $70k, and has grown 2.4x since 1975: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/A939RX0Q048SBEA
US Real Median income per capita is $42k, and has grown 1.5 since 1975. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N
The divergence between the two matters a lot. It reflects the impacts of both technology-driven automation and globalization of capital. Generative AI is unlike any prior technology given its ability to autonomously create and perform what has traditionally been referred to as "knowledge work". Absent more aggressive redistribution, AI will accelerate the divergence between median income and GDP, and realistically AI can't be stopped.
Powerful new technologies can reduce the number and quality of earning opportunities that exist, and have throughout history. Often they create new and better opportunities, but that is not a guarantee.
> We will have aligned AI helping us.
Who is the "us" that aligned AI is helping? Workers? Small business-people? Shareholders in companies that have the capital to build competitive generative AI? Perhaps on this forum those two groups overlap, but it's not the case everywhere.
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/sources-of-real-wage-stag...
There has been some increase in capital's share of income, but economic analyses show that the cause is rising rent and not any of the other usual suspects (e.g. tax cuts, IP law, technological disruption, regulatory barriers to competition, corporate consolidation, etc) (see Figure 3):
https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/2015a_r...
As for AI's effect on employment: it is no different at the fundamental level than any other form of automation. It will increase wages in proportion to the boost it provides to productivity.
Whatever it is that only humans can do, and is necessary in production, will always be the limiting factor in production levels. As new processes are opened up to automation, production will increase until all available human labor is occupied in its new role. And given the growing scarcity of human labor relative to the goods/services produced, wages (purchasing power, i.e. real wages) will increase.
For the typical human to be incapable of earning income, there has to be no unautomatable activity that a typical person can do that has market value. If that were to happen, we would have human-like AI, and we would have much bigger things to worry about than unemployment.
I think it's pretty unlikely that human-like AI will be developed, as I believe that both governments and companies would recognize that it would be an extremely dangerous asset for any party to attempt to own. Thus I don't see any economic incentive emerging to produce it.
> https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/2015a_r...
The paper underneath the hat article summarily excludes short term asset (i.e. software) depreciation, interest, dividends, stock buybacks - forms of lender/shareholders compensation before calculating capital's share of income. Undoubtedly if you ignore most of the methods of distributing gains to capital, it will appear as though capital (at this point scoped down to the company itself). The article (from 2015) goes on to predict that labor's share will rise going forward. With the brief exception of the COVID redistribution programs, it has done the opposite, and trended downwards.
> I believe that both governments and companies would recognize that it would be an extremely dangerous asset for any party to attempt to own.
We can debate endlessly about our predictions about AIs impact on employment, but the above is where I think you might be too hopeful.
AI is an arms race. No other arms race in human history has resulted in any party deciding "that's enough, we'd be better off without this", from the bronze age (probably earlier) through to the nuclear weapons age. I don't see a reason for AI to be treated any differently.
>AI is an arms race.
What I'm trying to convey is that the types of capabilities that humans will always uniquely maintain are the type that is not profitable for private companies to develop in AI because they are traits that make the AI independent and less likely to follow instructions and act in a safe manner.
This is an assumption, how would you know if you have alignment? AGI could appear to align, just as a psychopath appears studies and emulates well behaved people. Imagine that at a scale we can't possibly understand. We don't really know how any of these emergent behaviors really work, we just throw more data and compute and fine tunings at it, bake it, and then see.
There are so many ways we have misplaced confidence with what is essentially a system we don't really understand fully. We just keep anthropomorphizing the results and thinking "yeah, this is how humans think so we understand". We don't know for sure if that's true, or if we are being deceived, or making fundamental errors in judgement due to not having enough data.
I admire your optimism about the goals of all humans, but evidence tends to point to this not being the goal of all (or even most) humans, much less the people who control the AIs.
A rogue AI destroying humanity (whatever that means) is not a likely outcome. That's just movie stuff.
What is more likely is a modern oligarchy and serfdom that emerge as AI devalues most labor, with no commensurate redistribution of power and resources to the masses, due to capture of government by owners of AI and hence capital.
Are you sure people won't go along with that?
You can reply that AI researchers are smart and want to survive, so they are likely to invent alignment techniques that are better than the (deplorably inadequate) techniques that have been discussed and published so far, and I will reply that counting on their inventing these techniques in time is an unacceptable risk when the survival of humanity is at stake -- particularly as the outfit (namely the Machine Intelligence Research Institute) with the most years of experience in looking for an actually-adequate alignment technique has given up and declared that humanity's only chance is if frontier AI research is shut down because at the rate that AI capabilities are progressing, it is very unlikely that anyone is going to devise an adequate alignment technique in time.
It is fucked-up that frontier AI research has not been banned already.
Do you mean they lie because of bad training data? Or because of ill intent? How can an LLM have intent if it’s a stateless feedforward model?
I know that I don't know a lot, but all of this sounds to me to be at least hypothetically possible if we really believe AGI is possible.
This is a big downside of AI, IMHO. Those offices need to be filled! ;-)
That one isn’t guaranteed. Many examples online of exfiltration attacks on LLMs.
Less risky to deploy question will probably come once it is closer to 10x the cost. Considering the model was even specifically tuned for the test and doesn't involve other complexity I will say we are actually 10^4 cost off in terms of real world scenario.
I would imagine with better algorithm, tuning and data we could knock off 10^2 from the equation. That would still leave us with 10^2 cost to improve from Hardware. Minimum of 10 years.
You can scale them up and down at any time, they can work 24/7 (including holidays) with no overtime pay and no breaks, they need no corporate campuses, office space, HR personnel or travel budgets, you don't have to worry about key employees going on sick/maternity leave or taking time off the moment they're needed most, they won't assault a coworker, sue for discrimination or secretly turn out to be a pedophile and tarnish the reputation of your company, they won't leak internal documents to the press or rage quit because of new company policies, they won't even stop working when a pandemic stops most of the world from running.