News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by doe_eyes on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @10:40PM (#41855092)
By borrowing against their holdings. The framing is deceptive. You can do this too: there is no requirement to have billions in collateral. If you own stocks, your brokerage will lend you money at a very low rate, secured by the equity - typically up to about half of your stocks' worth.

The gotcha is market risk. If there's another crash akin to the housing crisis - and there will be - the bank will liquidate your holdings and possibly leave you on the hook for more. The difference is that Elon may be diversified enough to survive, while less savvy margin-surfers might not.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by hn_throwaway_99 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:17PM (#41855269)
I disagree the framing is deceptive. A big reason this is done is to avoid paying taxes altogether - borrow against your equity, and then when you die your heirs receive a step-up in basis, so the gains are never taxed. To make it worth while you need to have a crap ton of money, such that the interest on your loans is less than the estate taxes you'd pay. Only very, very rich people pay any estate taxes in the first place because a couple's estate tax exemption is currently over $27 million.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by creer on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:40AM (#41855659)
> avoid paying taxes altogether

At some stage in wealth, perhaps, and not avoid but postpone. More important probably are cases where actually selling the shares means giving up control over a business, or having to settle things with the rest of the family whose "destiny" it is to hold these shares in common.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by deepsun on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:02AM (#41855775)
Not postpone -- avoid. The base price of the asset is adjusted at the time of your death, so if bank sells the asset immediately, they pay no taxes.

https://www.reddit.com/r/BuyBorrowDieExplained/comments/1f26...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by creer on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:27PM (#41861548)
There is confusion between capital gains tax and estate tax (and estate planning devices like trust law). And that matters.

Is the problem capital gains tax as some people claim or is it elsewhere?

In the process described, capital gains tax is not even postponed (and that write up does not provide for Peter's major expenses during life). That write up works (when it does) because of bypassing estate tax.

The need for realizing capital gains is eliminated through trust, estate planning and other estate tax law (seems to me). The whole of the procedure is in that side of the equation. Not in capital gains tax law.

So the question: Does this all call for a change in capital gains tax law or changes in estate planning (trusts) and estate tax law?

When you use margin loan or pledged assets lines of credit, you are postponing. Which you can potentially kick all the way into estate tax (which your estate may pay if it's large enough). That write up is different still and describes working around even that estate tax. And then the question does matter of which law you are asking to change. (Besides the traditional method of making a law, any random law, thereby solving all problems for eternity - or at least gaining some voter satisfaction.)

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by deepsun on Friday October 18, 2024 @04:42PM (#41883313)
Yep. The link above says:

> The conventional wisdom is that you can avoid income tax (via the basis adjustment at death) or you can avoid estate tax (via lifetime gifting and estate freezing strategies) but you can’t do both. This conventional wisdom is wrong, and I’ll explain why below.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by scoofy on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:12AM (#41856090)
No.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Zenzero on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:07AM (#41856057)
At the time the estate tax is being considered isn't that usually down to a single surviving individual? I imagine it's uncommon for a couple to die at once to qualify for the 27m exemption.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by NotYourLawyer on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:17AM (#41857424)
You don’t have to die at the same time. If you leave everything to your surviving spouse, it’s also possible to transfer the benefit of your remaining estate tax exclusion.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:01PM (#41865430)
Search for "estate tax exemption portability".
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by zeroonetwothree on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:30AM (#41856179)
You still need income to pay the interest.

Moreover, unless you are nearly dead, it doesn’t make sense to optimize for far off estate tax avoidance since (a) you will be dead anyway, (b) tax laws change all the time, and (c) it would have to be discounted appropriately so it may not even be a win.

Personally I think we shouldn’t have capital gains taxes at all so this avoidance method doesn’t bother me.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by gambiting on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:50AM (#41857636)
>>Moreover, unless you are nearly dead, it doesn’t make sense to optimize for far off estate tax avoidance since

It's the other way around. This strategy allows you to not pay any taxes during your lifetime, so you have more money to play with and enjoy. Your inheritors might not have to pay tax on this money, but that's not your concern because like you said - you're dead at this point.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by eadmund on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:51AM (#41856276)
The issue is the step-up in basis, not borrowing against assets. The step-up in basis really is a giveaway. I think that it would make a ton of sense to transfer the basis rather than step it up.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by roenxi on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:51AM (#41856622)
Or the issue is the money printing that tends to be going on. This strategy should be too risky to work. They'd be losing interest on the money each month and they'd go bankrupt in the long term due to eventually borrowing money into a market downturn.

If interest rates are too low though then they wouldn't pay interest each month and the market will keep inflating - so the strategy will work.

Basically, this looks like a tax-effective strategy to stand in front of the money hose. If the money hose wasn't there it would be a tax-effective path to near certain ruin and much less attractive.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by KingOfCoders on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:24AM (#41857137)
One of the best things when you are rich, you can buy when everyone wants to sell, and sell when everyone wants to buy.

At one level of money you are not impacted by a market downturn or crisis.

Many very rich people in Germany became very rich during or after WW2 - but they already were rich. Normal people just get poor in a crisis or market downturn.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vintermann on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:18AM (#41857429)
Piketty's point in a nutshell, wasn't it? Only he talked about it in terms of insurance.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Dracophoenix on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:03AM (#41858620)
You don't need to be rich to do that, just wise enough to keep savings and live below your means.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by from-nibly on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:35AM (#41858888)
No you need to be really long term liquid and thats what poor people really don't have ( liquid assets to throw at buying stock)
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Jensson on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:36PM (#41861071)
Most people are between poor and rich, he said not rich not that the poor could do it.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by KingOfCoders on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:52AM (#41859744)
You can't buy cheap houses when everyone wants to sell and there are loans. But if you are rich, you buy when everyone sells.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bushbaba on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:58AM (#41859093)
And many very rich people in Germany got very very rich in ww2 by stealing Jewish assets and businesses.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by KingOfCoders on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:00AM (#41859862)

  A. Yes. Plus selling to the Wehrmacht ("war is a racket"), often with forced labour - or both, first stealing from Jews then selling to the Wehrmacht (like the current owners of BMW, ancestors sold to the Wehrmacht, profited from forced laber and additionally stole from Jews [1]). In communist East Germany Jews even couldn't get back their assets after the war, because Jews where "capitalists".

  B. The vast majority of Germans profited from stealing from Jews (see book "Hitlers Volksstaat"), e.g. Germany was out of money before Kristallnacht and Jews had to pay 1 billion Reichsmark after the progroms, which helped the German state. Also jewish furniture etc. was auctioned off to all Germans - people too often only talk about arts and houses.
[1] The Quandts already were rich selling to the Prussian army, then during hyper-inflation of the economic crisis bought struggling companies, then "bought" companies from Jews who were forced to sell, then used forced labour in their companies, sold to the Wehrmacht, after WW2 got everything back and the debt they accumulated to buy all of that had evaporated because of the war. Today they own large chunks of BMW for example.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by caeril on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:12PM (#41861976)
> One of the best things when you are rich, you can buy when everyone wants to sell, and sell when everyone wants to buy.

Generally untrue, since most rich people hold their assets in what's being sold. There are a handful value investors left, who bother holding cash equivalents when PE ratios get absurd, but they are few and far between. Tech billionaires, in particular, are very unlikely to be sitting on much cash.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by KingOfCoders on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:53PM (#41866262)
"Generally untrue"

I know several people who bought vast amount of real estate during the financial crisis.

You don't need to "sit on cash" to buy things.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by hackernewds on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:05AM (#41856338)
transfer the basis to whom? better not inherit anything
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Shaanie on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:39AM (#41856555)
If I buy something for $10 and it's worth $10,000 when you inherit it, you should (obviously?) be taxed on the increase in value from $10 -> $10,000 if/when you sell. The purchase price shouldn't be "reset" to $10k.

It'sutterly insane to me that the step-up basis exists in the US, it's such an obvious loophole that can fairly easily be closed without many adverse effects.

In my country (Sweden) if you don't know the purchase price, you can use an approximate purchasing price (e.g. for equities you are allowed to assume that it was acquired for 20% of the current value, so you'd be taxed on 80%).

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by nobodywillobsrv on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:45AM (#41856942)
Why should you be taxed on it at all?tax is policy. You tax things you want people to consume less of.

Inflation makes nominal values to up.

More inflation more capital gains. Gov is now incengltivized to inflate to pull tax out of realized assets that have not even gained real value

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by scotty79 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:54AM (#41857307)
What you tax is not really relevant as long as it doesn't disrupt some activity you want to continue happening. If it was up to me I'd tax spending not income. Regardless of what you are spending on. Bread? Sure! Employee? Yes! 10% of Tesla? Same!
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:37AM (#41858365)
> If it was up to me I'd tax spending not income. Regardless of what you are spending on

Under this system the poor who spend the majority of their income just to survive pay the highest effective tax rate while the wealthier who save most of their income have the smallest effective tax rate. That sounds like a fair and equitable system to you?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by orionsbelt on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:02AM (#41859143)
Sure, you can have transfers back to the poor.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:08AM (#41859192)
You're just moving the point a little along the scale though. So now instead of the super poor paying a higher rate, now it's the slightly less poor. And the slightly less poor as you keep moving that transfer cutoff point. You're still going to have some point where the wealthier are paying a significantly lower rate than those who make a good bit less than them.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by scotty79 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:28AM (#41859422)
At appropriate level of transfers the cutoff point is at millionaires you no longer can call poor in good conscience.

And people below cutoff point thanks to transfer effectively pay negative tax.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:37AM (#41859552)
I absolutely agree on this point, and that curve adjustment would just continue into people we'd definitely agree are wealthy. But in the end those millionaires are paying a higher tax rate than those wealthier than them. Is that fair?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by scotty79 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:53AM (#41859762)
It's fairer than what we have today. Nothing is absolutely fair.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by scotty79 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:26AM (#41859403)
And yet the rich spend vastly more money than poor. You can see it trivially by noticing that the poor have all their money from the work that they do for the rich.

Taxing spending would be way more equitable than whatever we are now doing.

We are already doing some taxation of spending. VAT, sales tax, social security fees. All of those are paid by buyers of goods, services and labor. If we did the same for investments government would have so much more money to deal with the problems instead of borrowing it from commercial banks at interest.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:35AM (#41859512)
> And yet the rich spend vastly more money than poor

You're just totally ignoring the effect of effective tax rates.

Sure, the billionaire spent way more money than the poor person. But who spent a higher percentage of their income? And who had vastly more opportunity to spend that in a place outside of that sales tax jurisdiction? Are the poor people flying to other countries to buy their luxury goods?

To you, is society fairer for poor person and the billionaire to pay the same nominal amount or the same tax rate? Is it even fair/good for the poor and the wealthy to pay the same for either of these values?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by scotty79 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:46AM (#41859673)
> But who spent a higher percentage of their income?

Everybody knows. That's because we tax income. And income, unlike spending is easier to muddle. You can always fabricate a loss or at least a temporary loss to avoid paying taxes on your income. It's harder to hide spending.

> And who had vastly more opportunity to spend that in a place outside of that sales tax jurisdiction?

It's just as easy today to move your profits to another country if you are rich.

If you tax spending, you can just tax money transfers to other countries as spending. Rich can fly wherever they like but they still had to pay taxes on the plane they bought, fuel they put in and all the money they spent on their trip.They could buy crypto, but guess what, on crypto purchase, also a spending tax. They can even move to live in another country till they die, but still their money transfered outside of their home country into their new one, taxed on exit.

You brought the money into the country because you are in the business of exports? Great, here's a tax credit. You may deduct it from the tax you pay on your excursions abroad.

The problem is not what is the moral thing to tax. The problem is how to do it efficiently with no loopholes without affecting desirable behaviors negatively and promoting undesirable ones.

Taxing spending would also help with vast empires that cosist of inherited money. Income was already done, century ago so there's nothing to tax. If you try to tax wealth, so many people would equate it to theft. But if you tax spending ...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:24AM (#41860184)
> Taxing spending would also help with vast empires that cosist of inherited money

Or we just finally actually tax inherited wealth like other kinds of income instead of giving wealthy many many millions of handouts and tax subsidies.

> with no loopholes

We've both shared examples of lots of ways one can have loopholes on spending money. If the standard is to find a way of "no loopholes", well, spending money outside of the tax jurisdiction away from the knowledge of the tax jurisdiction is a loophole. One wealthier people will have a far easier time exploiting than the poor. Expecting the wealthy are going to report their sales taxes on goods purchased overseas is as hopeful as back in the day states hoping people would report their online purchases. We both agree there's countless ways to obscure your income, if they can obscure their income why is it now impossible for them to obscure their purchases?

> You brought the money into the country because you are in the business of exports? Great, here's a tax credit. You may deduct it from the tax you pay on your excursions abroad.

So those who make money on exports pay even lower tax rates than those working domestically, by design? And who in that "business of exports" actually gets that benefit? The shift worker in the factory making the widgets, the marketing director making the campaign for the widget overseas, the salesperson making the actual sale to the foreign distributor, or the owner of the corporation? Me thinks that benefit isn't going to the shift worker or the marketing person or the salesperson. Cool, even more handouts for the wealthy here. Great ideas. They'll get a tax break on their expensive foreign vacation while us plebs here pay full tax rates.

I'm not trying to make the argument that what we have today is good. There's so much wrong with it. But thinking that throwing it all away and just taxing spending is somehow itself a good and just way of doing it also doesn't make much sense to me. Having poorer people pay more effective tax rates than wealthier people doesn't strike me as fair.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by scotty79 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:16PM (#41862015)
> spending money outside of the tax jurisdiction away from the knowledge of the tax jurisdiction is a loophole.

Yeah, but how? How do you carry it or send it across the border? Cash? Gold? Good luck with that. You'd basically have to set up a smuggling operation for cash like people now do for drugs. With the risk of cash going missing and every step of the road. Becasue it's not hot and whoever steals it can use it as they please immediately.

> Expecting the wealthy are going to report their sales taxes on goods purchased overseas is as hopeful as back in the day states hoping people would report their online purchases.

I'm not expecting anyone to report that they bought something abroad. I expect their bank to to report they made a transfer abroad and deduct spending tax automatically.

> So those who make money on exports pay even lower tax rates than those working domestically, by design?

Yes, because exports are desirable for building wealth of a country. There's a single country on Earth that benefits from exporting not goods or services but dollars. That's because they are printing them for free and the world for one reason or another wants them. Any other country benefits from exports and it's an activity every government tries hard to promote to get purchasing power in the global economy for the stuff the country can't make themselves.

> And who in that "business of exports" actually gets that benefit?

That's the question. In case of VAT burden is transferred along the chain. In spending tax, tax credit could be similarily propagated. Everyone could have tax credit on their sales and tax to pay on their purchases. This already works for companies for purposes of VAT. All transactions between companies are tracked so purchases could be taxed and sellers can be taxcredited (the opposite of VAT). In case of individual people, they make many transactions that are not specifically linked to them (and we want to keep it that way for privacy). Their spending tax can be collected and paid by the companies that sell stuff directly to consumers. The tax credit for individuals could take a form of direct cash transfer from the governement budget to supplement their salary. There's of course incentive for this companies to not report their sales to customers and not pass the tax paid them by the consumers to the country budget. But that's the same thing as we have now that companies have incentive to hide sales income to not pay income tax on it so exisitng solutions to combat that should perform no worse than they do now (mystery customers, recipt lottery, comparing income+financing with spending).

Tax credit wouldn't be 100% of sales (because companies on average earn more than spend so they would never pay tax while operating normally) and transfers to individuals could be shaped freely. They could be associated with their salaries or not or a mixture of two. This way governement could very effectively promote specific economic activities with tax credits to companies and keep the poorest out of poverty with direct money transfers but also promote job seeking and career advancement by paying some addtional money to workers, less as their salary level approaches societally desired "middle class".

I don't have all the kinks ironed out. It's just an idea that I had about a month ago. I haven't written my own tax code. Yet. ;-)

> They'll get a tax break on their expensive foreign vacation while us plebs here pay full tax rates.

Well, if somebody operates a successful company, especially an exporter they should be rewarded. But the reward should be transparent and controlled and not up to their weaseling, tax dodging tax and fabricalting fictional losses. As you know they are already getting the handouts. If the system is tight and clean we can decide how much of a reward they actually deserve through a political process. I am aware that our political system is terrible for that, but it's terrible for what we have now too so that's beside the point.

The point of my idea is mostly to introduce transparency and control and vastly simplify and integrate the myriad of tax systems we use in parallel in one country. Income taxes, VAT, duty, social security, health premiums, captial gains tax, fuel tax, excise. All of that could be replaced with one framework of taxes on spending. This would also be good for migrating to economy that's not reliant on infinite growth because doing more with less would be promoted by the tax structure. You are taxed on what you use, you are 100% taxed on what you waste or consume.

> Having poorer people pay more effective tax rates than wealthier people doesn't strike me as fair.

That's not at all what I'm advocating for. Poor people mostly don't matter from tax perspective. If tax credit for them is set up in a way that they pay effectively very little or zero tax or even get money for nothing it wouldn't matter for the govermenet budget and there would be strong, popular opposition to lowering their tax credit as that would be direct hard cash on their accounts recieved every month. In modern system it's vastly easier to give tax cuts for the rich than for the poor and nearly impossible to give anything to the totally destitute.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:11PM (#41862688)
> I expect their bank to to report they made a transfer abroad and deduct spending tax automatically

So we're not taxing spending, we're taxing bank transfers as well. Maybe they just put it in a savings account overseas. Maybe they're paying off a loan for money sitting elsewhere. Who says it was a sale? Prove they bought something.

>> Having poorer people pay more effective tax rates than wealthier people doesn't strike me as fair.

> That's not at all what I'm advocating for.

But that is what you're advocating for, by pushing it to just an extremely complicated sales tax and complicated system of fractically more complicated credits for exports and subsidies for the poor to hopefully reduce their tax burdern and what not. Inherently the wealthy will spend a smaller percentage of their income. The wealthiest practically can't spend it as fast as they get it even flying private jets around the world, but tons of middle-class people seem to barely have anything in savings. You just keep ignoring it and offering half measures to address it.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by scotty79 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:35PM (#41864545)
> So we're not taxing spending, we're taxing bank transfers as well

No. We are taxing spending. Transfering money abroad counts as speding. Transfering within the country doesn't.

> Maybe they just put it in a savings account overseas.

Doesn't matter. Once it leaves the system it's treated as spending.

> Maybe they're paying off a loan for money sitting elsewhere.

Paying off a loan is spending. Both abroad (as everything else abroad) and within the country too.

> Prove they bought something.

No need. Spending is something defined not something natural that needs proving. What I'm proposing is defining spending as reduction in amount of owned currency due to either transfer abroad or due to any agreements between companies or companies and customers.

> But that is what you're advocating for, by pushing it to just an extremely complicated sales tax and complicated system of fractically more complicated credits for exports

If you think that's complicated don't ever read on current taxes, fees and procedures.

My idea is comparably simple. General rule is that spending gets taxed. Tax credits are awarded to promote certain activities (like exporting or living). Nothing else. No need for income tax, corporate tax, VAT, sales tax, social security fees, health premiums, import tariffs, excise taxes and so on.

> Inherently the wealthy will spend a smaller percentage of their income.

At this point I don't think you can imagine it being any other way. I think you are fixating that we all have same stomachs and since poor people earn less feeding ones stomach will always be a larger percentage of money that available for them to spend (so higher percentage of tax).

But the rich don't spend money on what they eat alone. They spend it on cars, yahts, luxury, and what's way more impactful real estate, companies, assets, investments in general, even lobbying ... things that they must do because those are the things that bring them money ... those are the things purchasing which made rich rich in the first place and make them keep getting richer ... all of those would be taxed. I don't think you can say the same for any other proposed or real system for taxing the rich that relies on accounting for income or wealth.

Musk buying Twitter would be taxed on this purchase.

If giving the poor tax credits so that they have negative tax doesn't solve the conundrum for you I don't think anything ever will.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:58PM (#41864732)
> Paying off a loan is spending.

Talk about "double taxation" and wealthy being able to avoid taxes. I need a loan to buy a car. Taxes at the purchase, taxes as I pay back the loan. I take out a mortgage. Taxes on the sale, taxes on the mortgage payment. Meanwhile someone able to drop several hundred thousand in cash pay taxes once.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by scotty79 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @03:32AM (#41867266)
Paying back a loan is spending but taking a loan is income and taken as individual might award you tax credit.

But yes, if you use a service, you pay for tax. Even a service of renting some capital.

Again, as a poor person you can get tax credits on your income or just because you are alive that offsets that if the government thinks poor people buying things with loans is societally beneficial or not. Today government does this by raising or lowering the rates which affect so many other things in the economy.

Fine grained control is better.

And what's wrong with double taxation? If you earn money today, you pay income tax, and use it to buy fuel then you also pay VAT and excuse tax. That's triple tax on the same money. Spend your money in societally undesired ways and you are getting it taxed multiple times even today. But just with a myriad opaque systems that don't play nice with each other and are full of loopholes.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by koolba on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:57AM (#41857324)
> If I buy something for $10 and it's worth $10,000 when you inherit it, you should (obviously?) be taxed on the increase in value from $10 -> $10,000 if/when you sell. The purchase price shouldn't be "reset" to $10k.

There’s nothing “obvious” about tax policy. It’s an arbitrary determination of what’s in and what’s out.

Taxing capital gains at all is not “obvious”.

Taxing transfers of assets to your children, whether it’s while you’re alive or after you die is not “obvious”.

> It'sutterly insane to me that the step-up basis exists in the US, it's such an obvious loophole that can fairly easily be closed without many adverse effects.

The same law is the one that lets the surviving spouse or children to continue to live in a home rather than be forced to sell due to a sudden realized capital gain. You can argue that you don’t care about keeping multi millionaires in their childhood homes after their parents die, but it’s hardly “obvious” that it should be taxed.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by impossiblefork on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:55AM (#41857655)
Yes. As a Swede, I don't even think of individual ownership of assets.

I see a line of descent as the unit which holds property, rather than individuals from that line, and from that PoV inheritance tax of course makes no sense, but similarly, disinheriting somebody, and some other notions, don't make sense either, so it's a different perspective.

I think the Swedish state actually takes my perspective on this, because in Swedish inheritance law you can't disinherit somebody, and we don't have inheritance tax.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by NotYourLawyer on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:15AM (#41857413)
Getting rid of the stepped up basis doesn’t require that we realize the gain at death. Just transfer the basis to the heirs, and if/when they sell, then realize the gain.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by echoangle on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:25AM (#41857470)
> The same law is the one that lets the surviving spouse or children to continue to live in a home rather than be forced to sell due to a sudden realized capital gain. You can argue that you don’t care about keeping multi millionaires in their childhood homes after their parents die, but it’s hardly “obvious” that it should be taxed.

So make an exception for a single home the inheritor personally lives in and tax everything else.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Scoundreller on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:26AM (#41860205)
We have this in Canada, but it also means the richer you are, the bigger the subsidy you get.

Also means people over-invest in their homes and remain in homes that are larger than necessary for themselves instead of downsizing.

And renters get squat.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Hikikomori on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:11AM (#41857398)
Is it obvious that we should have roads, running water, someone that builds up the basics of society?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mschuster91 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:18AM (#41857428)
> The same law is the one that lets the surviving spouse or children to continue to live in a home rather than be forced to sell due to a sudden realized capital gain. You can argue that you don’t care about keeping multi millionaires in their childhood homes after their parents die, but it’s hardly “obvious” that it should be taxed.

Well, "homestead" exemptions are usually already a thing in most countries' inheritance laws. There is no need to draw stocks into the mix.

> Taxing transfers of assets to your children, whether it’s while you’re alive or after you die is not “obvious”.

It actually is obvious, at least if you want to prevent a return of feudalist eras.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mcculley on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:45AM (#41857979)
Most parents don’t want meritocracy. They want their children to have an advantage over the children of others. They just have not squared this instinct with political ideology.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mschuster91 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:24AM (#41858791)
> Most parents don’t want meritocracy. They want their children to have an advantage over the children of others.

Thing is, "meritocracy" doesn't exist on its own either. Even if a poor person's child is among the more intellectually gifted in school, it's hard to compete against the children of those who are blessed in money. And that extends to adult life as well: those born to academic parents are much more likely to go into higher education themselves and have an easier time there (both due to connections as well as the simple opportunity of having parents to ask how to best format a paper or to proofread one), those born to rich parents can simply afford to "try themselves out" - for someone with millions to burn, they can easily afford to seed-fund whatever scheme their kid comes up while most other potential founders depend on sheer luck meeting someone in a random elevator.

And the importance of children being "advantaged" ruthlessly is a recent trend too. Up until 30, 40 years ago, most kids worked in farms or the trades and they were happy with it. But ever since employers demanded higher education and everything else became decried as "something for immigrants" aka low economic lifetime perspective, that shifted... funny, cities would drown in garbage in a matter of weeks when there would be no garbage haulers, but they would continue to be livable if Wall Street went up in flames.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by next_xibalba on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:42AM (#41858957)
This is a kind of odd framing. I have children and I don’t see it as zero sum, as in your description. I want my children to do well. I don’t want other children to do worse, necessarily. I don’t care about other people’s children because I don’t know them and I’m not raising them. I want my kids to do well because I have put huge amounts of labor and love into them. The great beauty of most western systems is that they don’t have to be zero sum and they empower individuals and families.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mcculley on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:12PM (#41860817)
Certainly some parents are proponents of the estate tax. I did not say that all parents are opposed to it.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by next_xibalba on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:25AM (#41869992)
You have projected your bias onto my comment. I do not advocate for an estate tax and don't necessarily support it. And claiming that opposition to an estate tax is an opposition to the success of other people's children is also definitely not anything I believe or claim. Our economy is not zero sum. Everyone can win. Also, redistributive policies almost always fail and waste vast sums while failing.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mcculley on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:57AM (#41870268)
I did not argue in favor of redistributive policies. If I am arguing anything, it is against people lying to themselves about their ideology.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by 8note on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:03PM (#41862616)
I think you've misunderstood what they're suggesting - they're considering the transfer from parent to child to not be a realization, so there's no taxes, and no change in basis.

The child who sells the house, then has to pay gains from when the house was first purchase, rather than against the value when they inherited it

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mackman on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:17AM (#41857423)
If you exceed the inheritance tax exemption then you are taxed on the $10k so LTCG would be double taxing. You could argue that the inheritance tax should have a much lower exemption but double taxation is harder to justify.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by cool_dude85 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:13AM (#41858174)
What is "double taxing" and why is it bad?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:34AM (#41858348)
So much stuff has several layers of taxes on it but "double taxation" is really only used when discussing inheritance taxes.

It's a term wealthy people made up to trick poor people into feeling sorry for ultra wealthy actually paying taxes on things.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:59AM (#41859116)
> "double taxation" is really only used when discussing inheritance taxes

It’s a common concept, e.g. in the double taxation of corporate earnings and dividends.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:11AM (#41859224)
You're right, its pretty common for the wealthy to try and trick poor people into feeling sorry for the wealthy actually paying taxes on things.

As my other post pointed out, tons of things have multiple layers of taxes. But the things people suddenly have some big moral issue with "double taxation" are things like estate taxes and corporate earnings and dividends and capital gains.

Few people bat an eye at us double taxing the low income nicotine addict. Everyone seems to want me to shed tears for the billionaire having to pay "double taxation" on their third vacation mansion they're inheriting.

Argue the rates are too low or too high for a given transaction. I can get behind that. But just crying because there's two different taxes being applied to a given transaction? Really?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:13AM (#41859246)
> people suddenly have some big moral issue with "double taxation" are things like estate taxes and corporate earnings and dividends and capital gains

People get plenty mad about sales taxes double taxing taxed income, too. Nobody likes paying taxes.

This isn’t a localised term.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:29AM (#41859444)
> People get plenty mad about sales taxes double taxing taxed income, too.

Yeah, and it's a dumb position to take. Like what, we can only apply one tax from one source to a given dollar bill's serial number after it leaves the fed, and after that point that dollar can never be taxed again? Otherwise, gasp, double taxation!

The company shouldn't pay payroll taxes, they charged sales taxes to get that income to pay the salaries. I shouldn't pay any income taxes, the company paid payroll taxes on the money that had sales taxes on it. I shouldn't pay sales taxes, I paid income taxes on the money that had already had payroll taxes that had already had sales taxes that had...

Suddenly nobody pays any taxes anywhere because somewhere up the chain someone else already paid taxes on that dollar!

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chgs on Friday October 18, 2024 @06:49PM (#41884193)
But not when you pay income tax and then buy something and pay sales tax.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:13AM (#41858178)
> double taxation is harder to justify

Bullshit. "Double taxation" is such a weak argument to me.

When I buy gas at the pump it's taxed multiple times. State sales tax. City sales tax. Federal gas taxes. State gas taxes. Quadruple tax on me there.

My wage income has several taxes. FICA taxes. Payroll taxes. Federal income taxes. Potentially state income taxes. Potentially city income taxes.

When I pay for a hotel there's often a bevy of different taxes on that. When I pay my phone bill there's a bunch of different taxes on that.

Oh but boo hoo ultra wealthy get their massive inheritance "double taxed". Get bent crying over your "double taxed", I'm quadruple taxed and more all the damn time. Weak argument.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by commandlinefan on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:24AM (#41858787)
> Quadruple tax on me there.

We have a problem with that, too.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:35AM (#41858893)
But like, why? It's a worthless point. If there were five taxes of one percent each versus one tax of 20% how is the one tax somehow better? Which one would you choose, getting taxed five times or once?

It doesn't really matter that there's a FICA and an income tax and a payroll tax in the end, what really matters is the overall tax rate and if that's fair given some moral decision of fairness of sharing costs of society.

If a city chooses to levy sales taxes and hotel taxes to capture more revenue from visitors because their town is a tourist destination and want to collect from tourists more than locals that's fine. I won't weep a tear for those getting "double taxed" on their vacations.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by oceanplexian on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:19AM (#41860121)
Payroll tax is a problem because it’s not accounted for in your overall tax rate, it’s accounted for via lower wages. So you have no idea what your actual income would be if not for all the taxes your employer is paying.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:38AM (#41860337)
> So you have no idea what your actual income would be

Payroll taxes aren't some secret things which are impossible for an employee to calculate on their own. You're right, it's not usually directly shown to an employee on their paystub, but it's pretty trivial to do the math and see what your employer paid (or was at least originally liable before any weird tax handouts, but typically rare) for your salary.

I do think payroll taxes should be required to include on paystubs if even just as an informational aspect to people. People should have a real understanding of how much labor is taxed compared to capital. People see "capital gains is 15%? Gosh that seems high..." without realizing how much of their W2 income was taxed. Most people I talk to can't even ballpark what their effective income tax rate was, I often hear "oh I had to pay like $800 in taxes this year, that sucked!" No, you paid a lot more than that, you just didn't pay attention.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by caeril on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:23PM (#41862092)
> how is the one tax somehow better?

Local and state taxes generally actually help you. Your local infrastructure is maintained, and your kids go to schools funded by your taxes.

Federal taxes, however, are largely transfer payments from the productive to the unproductive, as well as funding wars in areas that have absolutely nothing to do with you.

It's pretty easy to make the distinction between "good" and "bad" taxes.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:03PM (#41863238)
Completely ignoring the actual question.

>> If there were five taxes of one percent each versus one tax of 20% how is the one tax somehow better?

Would you rather pay five different tax authorities a 1% tax each or a single tax authority 20%? Not asking about the morality of those five tax authorities, in this example they're all the same.

The argument is against this idea "double taxation" is something inherently wrong. In the end it's not a matter of how many different taxes actually apply to a given transaction, what matters is the tax amounts and where those taxes are going to.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by 8note on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:08PM (#41862660)
I'm generally helped by my federal taxes going to help feed students in poor areas. Both from a feel good standpoint and that those students have a better chance at becoming more productive, which means they can buy stuff from me.

I also benefit from those foreign wars because they keep the US empire of cheap shipping open, so I can buy stuff for cheap from countries who've specialized in manufacturing

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by carlosjobim on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:20AM (#41857821)
> It's utterly insane to me that the step-up basis exists in the US, it's such an obvious loophole that can fairly easily be closed without many adverse effects.

Who do you think writes the laws and the tax code?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by presentation on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:41AM (#41859613)
Yup, here in Japan inheritors have to pay 10-55% (progressive based on the amount) of the value of all inherited property globally within 10 months.

As an American, knowing that I could have gotten away without this tax had I decided not to live in Japan long-term, and knowing that I will have considerable inheritance when my parents pass is a bit of a downer; but logically speaking, the step-up basis loophole is BS and it probably ought to be this way, or some variant of it, everywhere.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by refurb on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:15AM (#41856757)
This sounds like a great idea but really fails the sniff test:

- you’d need to borrow for decades, where, even at low interest rates were burn through significant capital (more than taxes would)

- you’d need low interest rates to exists for decades which we know doesn’t happen

- finally, all these Uber rich (Bezos, Musk) have all sold significant portions of their equity and paid taxes on it

This seems like nothing more than a hypothetical idea.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by moralestapia on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:21AM (#41856793)
Careful, you might be put into the HN cooler, lol
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by SuchAnonMuchWow on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:08AM (#41857373)
The article goes into great detail and gives several example of several CEOs borrowing for actual decades, so it passes the sniff test because it does actually happen.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by silotis on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:55AM (#41858543)
The article gives examples of CEOs borrowing against their shares. The article provides no examples of CEOs rolling those loans over until their death.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by nobodywillobsrv on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:43AM (#41856931)
Yes but that is because taxes are incoherent and abhorrent

Why do we tax realized capital gains at all and why based on the ruler of fiat which is controlled by those who tax (they keep making the ruler shorter)

If the goal is to creat drag on multiplicative dynamics then do so coherently

Tax should make sense at least in core targets. Yet there are no core targets.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by CPLX on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:31AM (#41857896)
Because realized capital gains are income and we tax income.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by technothrasher on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:04AM (#41857719)
> Only very, very rich people pay any estate taxes in the first place because a couple's estate tax exemption is currently over $27 million.

That's federal estate tax. State tax can be different. Massachusetts, for example, has estate taxes on over $2M ($4M for a couple who manages their estate plan wisely).

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by potato3732842 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:32AM (#41858335)
State estate tax is just a tax on people who are ignorant of it, unwilling to plan for it or who's relationship with their heir(s) is too dysfunctional to dodge it. The rich almost always avoid it. The poor are never subject to it.

It's like greasing a couple rungs in the middle of the economic ladder IMO. I'm not a fan.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vel0city on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:58AM (#41859095)
Massachusetts requires estates worth $1M+ to report for estate taxes. There's something like a $60k exemption and then it's a progressive rate system.

Based on what I'm seeing, a $2M Massachusetts estate would have $50k of estate taxes to pay, a 2.5% effective tax rate.

In the end though only 12 states have an estate tax, and Massachusetts has the lowest threshold and highest rates.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by atmavatar on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:21PM (#41862812)
Borrowing against the current value of your stocks should automatically cause any gains to become realized for tax purposes.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by valval on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:32PM (#41862926)
Funny that you’d take this route. I’d just lower capital gains tax rates.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by beezle on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:29PM (#41855335)
Keep in mind that the bench mark rate is almost always something akin to bills so is a very short time horizon. That may be great or not so great compared to what rate you might get on say a 5/10/15 yr collaterlized loan.

ref: https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/trading/margin-rates.p...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by throwaway2037 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:25AM (#41856145)
Nice link. Thank you to share. This notice bothers me a bit:

    > IBKR will assess a surcharge of 1% on large loan balances unless otherwise prearranged with IBKR. The 1% surcharge would apply to all balances in the highest tier.
I wonder what exactly "prearranged with IBKR" means. Call them up... "I need to borrow 50M USD, and pledge my Meta stock." Them: "Hang on. <muzak> Yeah, sure."

My guess, if the loan is large enough, the want to coordinate with their internal stock-borrow lending (SBL) desk to ensure proper liquidity.

<<(Not A) Shill Warning>> I am continuously blown away by the institutional-like level of services (and prices) available to plebs like me. IB is really built to grow with you: From the first 10K USD saved as a 25 year old, to a 50 year old with millions in liquid assets. I still cannot believe they don't have any minimum balance for individual account. Ref: https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/accounts/required-mini... To be clear for other readers, that cost cannot be zero on their end. I don't know how it works, other than crazy levels of automation.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by tomatocracy on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:44AM (#41857241)
I think it's probably more about hedge funds etc where they will negotiate bespoke terms/pricing across the board (including assessing risk which at that level might partly be based on track record, identity of the underlying investors, strategy etc).
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by beezle on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:01AM (#41859136)
Once the amounts get lumpy there needs to be complete assessment of counterparty risk (you). IB can't assume that you are only borrowing from them and that the collateral in your account won't first be liened by another party, etc.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by beezle on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:59AM (#41859111)
For many things, IB is great. Certainly if you are a futures trader it is very good, same for most equity/option trading. But for bond trading, expect a complete nightmare at tax time. Their "tax department" has no clue how to properly and consistently amortize bond premiums and quite honestly (personal experience) does not give a rats.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @04:38AM (#41867596)

    > bond premiums
Does this mean you are buying bonds with a price greater than 100%? If yes, can you explain why? On the institutional side, there is an allergy to premium bonds; they only want to buy at par (100%) or less, so normally the coupon rate is adjusted just before issuance to meet their needs.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by dataflow on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:16PM (#41855262)
This explanation never made sense to me. Say someone gives you a $1M loan. Holy cow, it's not taxed, what a loophole!

But wait, this was a loan, not a gift. So don't you eventually have to pay back the >$1M later from taxed income? So you still end up paying taxes on $1M either way? How in the world does this bypass taxes?

Edit: To people bringing back the "buy, borrow, die" story:

(a) Yes, I saw that a couple months ago too. It was very hand-wavy in some crucial places. And there were quite a few people pointing out flaws with the reasoning. [1] [2]

(b) If dying is part of the the strategy then why is it omitted so often? (My whole point with the comment here is that the aforementioned explanation is inadequate.)

(c) If having enough money to pay off your collateral-secured debts until your death is a requirement for this to work then why do so many people claim "you can do it too"? Who has that kind of money sitting around? The "Buy, Borrow, Die" post explicitly said you can't get that kind of loan until you have $300M in assets.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41411737

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41410808

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by lesuorac on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:21PM (#41855295)
You just delay selling the stocks until death.

At that point your stocks (and other assets like houses) have their cost-basis adjusted to the current price. So the capital gains tax on your assets are $0 as their cost basis is the same as the price so the appreciate is $0. If _you_ sold the stocks before your death then likely there would be a large gap between the cost-basis (price you bought the stock) and the current price resulting in a large capital gains tax.

So, when your estate sells the stocks to pay back the loan they pay the applicable taxes on the $0 and then uses the remaining proceeds to pay back the loan.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by blast on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:00AM (#41855469)
> At that point your stocks (and other assets like houses) have their cost-basis adjusted to the current price.

Is this a special provision that kicks in only on death (and not before)? How long has that been in place?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:28AM (#41855604)
> Is this a special provision that kicks in only on death

To my knowledge, yes [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepped-up_basis

> How long has that been in place?

Since 1921 [1]. When the estate tax was in force, it was meant to avoid double taxation. In 1976, the Congress replaced the step-up basis with a carryover basis (you don't pay taxes on death but neither do you step up the basis). In 1980, it repealed the carryover basis "due to the record-keeping problems associated with reconstructing what a long-deceased relative might have paid for properties that had been held for generations," but didn't re-instate the step-up basis. In 2010, the estate tax was repealed. (EDIT: It was reinstated in 2011 in a neutered form [3].)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepped-up_basis

[2] https://greenleaftrust.com/missives/stepped-up-basis-a-short...

[3] https://itep.org/federal-estate-tax-historic-lows-2023/

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:46AM (#41855693)
The USA still has an estate tax.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:54AM (#41855745)
> USA still has an estate tax

You're correct. Fixed. Would note that it's famously flouted, though usually not in entirety [1].

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2014-01-30/only-idio...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:53AM (#41859768)
That Bloomberg article is provocatively named.

You need to have assets about US$13M per person to be subject to the estate tax. So if "only idiots pay" the tax, they are rich idiots.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by PopAlongKid on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:06AM (#41859173)
The Wikipedia article does a poor job of explaining that it is not "step up basis", it is "basis adjustment to fair market value", which may be up or down. They do have a paragraph further down about "stepped down basis", but it still doesn't make the point clear.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mikeyouse on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:33AM (#41855626)
It’s called the stepped up basis and yes, only applies to your estate.

A married couple who bought a house in Palo Alto for $250k that’s now worth $5.25M and who bought $250k of Apple stock that’s now worth $20.25M would have a Federal tax bill of ~$5 million if they sold those assets and gave the cash to their kids. If however they were hit by a bus on the way to their accountants office, and the kids inherited the assets and sold them the next day, they would owe zero tax.

There’s a popular myth that estate taxes are a second tax on income but many assets for the very wealthy are never taxed..

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:45AM (#41855692)
This is because for a long time, the USA does not tax assets other than real estate.

Our tax system is structured around the fundamental idea of taxation occuring on transactions, whether that's income in exchange for labor, income resulting from the sale on (non-real-property) assets etc.

I'm not sure if this is a good thing (it might be, it might not) but it's the way it is.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bruce511 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:52AM (#41855997)
The reverse approach has issues as well, primarily for assets that aren't easily divisible.

The obvious example is family farms, or indeed the family house. Capital taxing the asset on death means a (potentially large) tax bill happens in many cases this can't be paid without selling the asset.

If the sale was to another family looking for a farm, then that could be argued is neutral. But it won't be. It'll be sold to a mega-corp because they have more money to spend. So in a couple generations you kill off areas that are primarily small farms.

This doesn't just apply to property. The family silver collection, the family business, the list goes on.

Inheritance tax is tricky. Just passing money down entrenches an aristocratic class. Taxing it though destroys value in all kinds of areas.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chgs on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:48AM (#41856957)
> in many cases this can't be paid without selling the asset.

Ok. And?

Why should someone get $5m for doing bugger all. If they were paid $5m for cleaning a car they would lose a fortune in tax.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bruce511 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:23AM (#41857130)
They're not getting 5m, that's the point. They're inheriting an asset which may be valued at 5m. Like a farm, or a house, or a painting or whatever.

Forcing the sale of family property or assets does not serve any good in the long term.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by dataflow on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:37AM (#41858368)
> Forcing the sale of family property or assets does not serve any good in the long term.

How is carrying the cost basis forward without stepping it up "forcing a sale"?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by saltcured on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:52PM (#41863754)
It is under a system where ownership transfers are treated as taxable events. The recipient needs to pay the taxes, but cannot afford to without liquidating the inherited asset.

I think you just need to propose a set of related rules changes. Replace the inheritance basis step-up with a similarly scoped rule that says this inheritance does not count as a taxable ownership transfer, so taxes are not due at that point.

You may also need new rules for estimating the basis when records are lost across multiple inheritance events?

The current system is a bit like a tax foregiveness jubilee, but dribbled out to individual families rather than synchronized across the whole economy. It resets things so that regular people can function in this system, without requiring all the family accounting and records keeping of some aristocratic dynasty.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mikeyouse on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:03PM (#41861885)
Forcing people to "Sell the family Farm" has been used by estate-tax detractors for so long that there are multiple special programs in place to ensure it never happens (interest-free loans, etc). Given that the current limits are over $13M per person or $26M/couple where zero tax is owed, I don't think this "woe is us" routine resonates any more.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bruce511 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:15PM (#41866100)
That's exactly my point. The current system is working. We explicitly don't want to go to the place where inheritance forces a sale.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by rijoja on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:07AM (#41857369)
idk, maybe because their parents liked them? Do you really want to incentivize against people working hard to make sure their offspring, has a good life? Also a family-home might have sentimental value, and this really doesn't only apply to rich people, quite the contrary actually.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by carlosjobim on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:02AM (#41858080)
> Do you really want to incentivize against people working hard...

You mean by taxing labour and taxing commerce?

Sorry for the snark, but come on...

The Roman empire was built on never taxing labour, because that was seen as an atrocity (never mind the slavery). Instead they taxed luxury goods and debased their currency. The United States was built on never taxing labour, because that was seen as an atrocity (never mind the slavery). Instead they taxed importations and debased their currency.

Since all land was created by God and everything else was created by people's labour, the really unjust thing is to tax labour instead of taxing land. But "territory" is an instinct so deeply ingrained that it's probably been with us for millions of years. However, which other mammals allow members of the same species living on their territory which are not family? As in renting.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by rijoja on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:12PM (#41862698)
> You mean by taxing labour and taxing commerce?

> Sorry for the snark, but come on...

> The Roman empire was built on never taxing labour, because that was seen as an atrocity (never mind the slavery). Instead they taxed luxury goods and debased their currency. The United States was built on never taxing labour, because that was seen as an atrocity (never mind the slavery). Instead they taxed importations and debased their currency.

Interesting, even though I don't see if you are for or against taxing labour, commerce or inheritance.

Inheritance tax is a way for the establishment to take land from small landowners. The state isn't a good counterbalance to "greedy" corporations, the state is there to support big business.

> It'll be sold to a mega-corp because they have more money to spend. So in a couple generations you kill off areas that are primarily small farms.

Please see Bruce511's comment above, he explains it better than me.

The thing is that with an inheritance tax, you make it impossible for someone to live with little or no money, and caring for their off-spring, by giving them a place to stay.

> Since all land was created by God...

Aha, but in the commandments it says that you shouldn't steal, so having property doesn't seem to be forbidden?

> But "territory" is an instinct so deeply ingrained that it's probably been with us for millions of years

So, is caring for your off-spring, kindness and brotherhood. What is your point?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:10PM (#41863323)
> Inheritance tax is a way for the establishment to take land from small landowners

In the USA, you must have a net worth of at least US$13M per person to be subject to the inheritance tax.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bruce511 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:17PM (#41866114)
That's exactly the point. We don't want to change anything that leads to these inheritance tax problems.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by rijoja on Thursday October 17, 2024 @06:14AM (#41868114)
That's interesting, I know that other countries do the same, however, but I was thinking about it as a general principle.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chgs on Thursday October 17, 2024 @05:08AM (#41867760)
My employer likes me and gives me $100k and I have to pay tax.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Panzer04 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:10AM (#41855813)
It's mostly practical, I think. Not all assets can be valued, or are liquid. Once a transaction occurs though you have both a price to tax on and the money to pay the tax.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mikeyouse on Friday October 18, 2024 @01:10PM (#41881398)
It’s awfully convenient that this ambiguity in asset prices leads to a massive an unprecedented tax break to the richest people in the country — many of whom are literal experts in valuation.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mixmastamyk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:39AM (#41855654)
^^^ This is the real loophole, the rest is a distraction.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by js2 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:34AM (#41855633)
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:42AM (#41855675)
> the current price resulting in a large capital gains tax.

There's nothing special about the capital gains tax rate on such a sale. It's likely to be the long term one, and compared to income tax and taxes in most other parts of the world, it's low.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:25PM (#41855312)
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by vineyardmike on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:26AM (#41855599)
The "loophole" that people often complain about is specific to the "buy, borrow, die" tax exemption opportunity. And it's mostly about the VERY wealthy who can really use this until they die.

(1.1) Different parts of America have additional taxes on estate - eg. MA is $2M not $13M, - about 10% of the state has $1M today.

(1.2) Estate tax rate and capital gains rates are different.

(1.3) You can take a tax-deduction on the interest of the loan - if you use it to buy investments. Which is something the ultra-wealthy can easily do.

(1.4) Different assets (eg. Real Estate) have vastly different loans compared to Margin/Portfolio lines of credit

(2) Because the people in question are alive. If you complain about a billionaire not paying taxes because they live off loans, presumably you want that to change. No one complains that Vanderbilt isn't taxed anymore.

(3.1) You definitely don't need 300M to do it, but if you're actually part of the bottom 95%, you'd probably need to liquidate some funds to make it to death, so you can only do this with a small amount of money or you risk margin calls.

(3.2) The "big portfolio" benefit is termed loans instead of margin - banks are way more likely to give you a huge chunk of cash for a fixed time/life if you have a lot more assets.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by cryptonector on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:32AM (#41855621)
> But wait, this was a loan, not a gift. So don't you eventually have to pay back the >$1M later from taxed income?

No, you just borrow against yet more stock. You need never sell any, much less pay yourself any significant income, provided you have enough stock. Since you don't sell the stock, you need not pay capital gains taxes. Since you have no real taxable income, you need not pay much in income taxes either.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by attentive on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:51AM (#41856624)
Pay taxes once vs pay interest forever? At what point it'll break even and go negative?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by cko on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:08AM (#41857056)
Let's say every year your portfolio goes up 10%. Every year you borrow 3%. You never pay down the principal, and I think you can just let the interest payment get added to the principal. Also, the interest is tax-deductible.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by cryptonector on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:59AM (#41859115)
Let's say you're worth $100bn. You don't need to spend $1bn a year, just even a few tens of $ millions will be plenty, so you're borrowing a minute portion of your net worth. And your stocks will be going up in value, typically, so... you'll never run out of money. Plus you'll be a great customer for the banks that lend you money, so you'll get preferential interest rates. You'll never run out of money. You'll die and still have the lion's share of your wealth, only now it will pass to your heirs and charitable foundations.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chii on Thursday October 17, 2024 @02:39AM (#41867003)
> You'll die and still have the lion's share of your wealth

and i don't see anything wrong with that at all.

It seems, recently at least, that a lot of people believe they're somehow entitled to the wealth that these high networth individuals have managed to accumulate.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by cryptonector on Thursday October 17, 2024 @11:16AM (#41870461)
> and i don't see anything wrong with that at all.

Read my comments on that post. I never said there was anything wrong with that.

IMO we should stop double taxing dividend income.

> a lot of people believe they're somehow entitled to the wealth that

Do not count me among those.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by attentive on Friday October 18, 2024 @10:34PM (#41885212)
So, same as never selling your stock?

None of that matters. What matters, is if interests paid is more than taxes paid. Which at some point it will be. And at some point both loans and interests will be paid in full. Because its secured by stocks. And assuming there is no other assets, it'll be stocks sold and capital gain taxes paid.

Unless the argument here is that lender will be fleeced due to borrower's death. Which, if correct assumption, is fucked up.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by yieldcrv on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:34AM (#41855634)
what you’re missing is that its not controversial or a loophole

sometimes they pay it off, they just dont have to do that every year

yes, you can do it too, but you would need income to pay it

they already have other assets post tax to pay with, if it ever comes down to that

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by nobodywillobsrv on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:46AM (#41856948)
It's leverage. That is all. And tax efficient.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by dang on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:58PM (#41855463)
Ok, we've replacing accessing billions by borrowing against stock in the title above. Thanks!
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by petermcneeley on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:35PM (#41855358)
If I have 1 million in some stock can I go get a 1 million loan from the bank with this as collateral? If so can I reinvest this million in the same stock again and then goto the bank again etc?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by blasphemers on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:11AM (#41855524)
No. You are not allowed to use these loans for investments, you would need a different type of loan for margin trading.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by basementcat on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:51PM (#41855433)
There is usually a margin requirement (25 to 75% depending on type of equity). And yes, you can.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by kelnos on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:55AM (#41856657)
Usually they will not give you the full value. Depending on how "safe" they deem the security, they might only allow you to borrow 50%-70% against it.

And most (probably all) of these forbid you from using the loan proceeds to buy more securities.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by s0rce on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:06PM (#41855208)
I used this when Chase closed my bank account because of a typo. Just borrowed cash from Fidelity to float for a month until everything got sorted.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @10:53PM (#41855152)
> If you own stocks, your brokerage will lend you money at a very low rate, secured by the equity - typically up to about half of your stocks' worth.

This should be illegal of course... You cannot for the purposes of paying taxes say "hey, I don't actually have this money, this is unrealized gains" and then turn around (to brokerage house or anyone else) and say "hey, look I actually do have this 'money' - lemme borrow against it."

Unrealized gains should never be taxed. However, as soon as you try to use it as realized in ANY way you should be taxed immediately.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by eadmund on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:10PM (#41855230)
Why should it be illegal? It’s not a realised gain. It has to be paid off … with money which has to come from somewhere (and be taxed as income or realised gains or whatever).

What reason do you have for wanting it to be illegal, other than not liking it?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:17PM (#41855271)
How is it not realized? When I can use it as "realized" to borrow against it? When it comes to paying taxes I go "sorry Uncle Sam, this is fictitious, I don't really have this" but then I head over to the bank and go "look at my brokerage accounts, I have ALL THIS MONEY, lemme borrow against this now all-of-sudden realized money..."
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by WillPostForFood on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:25PM (#41855309)
Home equity loans also taxed as realized gains?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:39PM (#41855375)
You are paying property tax on that money you are using for that HELOC.

If I bought a house at $300k, I owe $250k and house is now worth $750k the County will be slapping me with $10k/year property taxes whereas before I was paying like $3k. My gains are realized each year via property tax assessments :)

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:42PM (#41855392)
> My gains are realized each year via property tax assessments

This strongly depends on jurisdiction. In many (today I learned, not all) assessed value is explicitly different from market value.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:14AM (#41855536)
The fact is though if you live in America are paying property taxes on your home, you are NOT hiding from the IRS the fact that you do - you are not saying "sorry, I don't really own this home and I won't be paying anything to you until such later time when my ownership will be revealed at the grand sale at which point I'll pay some taxes"

With "unrealized" stock gains you are doing just that - hiding ownership so you don't have to pay taxes while enjoying the perks of the ownership when it suits you

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mixmastamyk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:28AM (#41855603)
Property tax raises are capped in CA by Prop 13.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:38AM (#41855646)
> if you live in America are paying property taxes on your home

I own in Wyoming. My property's assessed value is like 1/10th the market rate. My neighbour--just checked!--who owns a property like ten times my size, across two plots, and far more lavish than my own has an assessed value similar to mine. The real estate records even have a line item for "actual value" separate from assessed value.

Not familiar with the specifics, but I know California and New York similarly have assessed values that are entirely unmoored from what the property is actually worth.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by 0xBDB on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:00PM (#41862569)
This is most states, because the increases are capped for existing property owners especially for first homes - the homestead exemption. If you own a house you live in for a long time in a hot market your assessed value can be very low relative to market.
[dead]
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by dang on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:38PM (#41875910)
Personal attacks will get you banned here, regardless of how doltish another comment is or you feel it is, so please don't post like this again.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by 0xBDB on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:55PM (#41862510)
You do not pay property taxes to the IRS, or report the value of your property to them unless you sell it. Federal property tax is unconstitutional. It took an amendment for the feds to be able to do income tax, which has been broadly interpreted to include things like capital gains and income taxes.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by WillPostForFood on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:55PM (#41855451)
Also, totally irrelevant to the capital gains tax you may owe the federal govt when you sell you house.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by jjav on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:06AM (#41856056)
> My gains are realized each year via property tax assessments :)

You are confusing two very different things. You'll realize the gains (and have to pay taxes on) your house value increase only when you sell it. The fact that you were paying property taxes on it all along while owning it has nothing to do with that.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by eadmund on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:45AM (#41856938)
> How is it not realized?

Because of the definition of what realized income is. Borrowing is not income.

You mention below that you own a Washingtonian condo and a Virginian home. Let’s imagine that they are both $100,000 and that you have no other money or debts. Your net worth is thus $200,000.

You go to your bank and say ‘I would like to borrow against the value of my assets please,’ and they say, ‘certainly, here is $90,000.’ Your bank account now goes up $90,000, your condo is still worth $100,000 and your home is still worth $100,000. Your net worth is still $200,000 (not $290,000) because you also now have $90,000 of debt. You did not realise any income, even though your bank account is now full of money, because your debt account is now negative.

‘But I am paying property taxes!’ you might say. Sure, property taxes are a form of wealth tax, and there is no similar tax on stocks — but that is irrelevant to this discussion (although it could be relevant in a different one).

To illustrate why, let’s use another example. You still have the Washingtonian condo and the Virginian home, and they are both still worth $100,000 apiece. This time, you only borrow $45,000 against the value of the condo. That money moves from a bank on Washington to your bank account in Virginia. Do you owe Virginia income tax on that money? No, because it’s not income. But Virginia is not getting paid any property taxes for the property backing that loan! Irrelevant, again because a loan is not income.

Likewise, you can imagine owning another property in some state or country without property taxes at all. You borrow against it, is that loan income? Nope.

Now, let’s imagine the counterfactual, where loans count as income. You go to buy your $100,000 condo, put down $20,000, borrow $80,000, spend all $100,000 on the condo — and now you would owe income taxes on that $80,000. Gosh, that doesn’t seem fair. You had $20,000, spent it all borrowed the rest, and now you own a condo, owe property taxes and owe income taxes on $80,000, even though you have no money.

Does any of this help you understand? Owning an asset is not fictitious, it’s just not income. An income tax is levied on income, so an asset is not relevant to an income tax (relevant to an asset tax, of course!).

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by gpderetta on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:14AM (#41858707)
Well, taxing borrowing as income is not what is being discussed here though.

It would be workable to make borrowing against an asset at a certain value equivalent to crystallizing any gain on that asset, pro-rated on the amount borrowed: you own a 2M house, that you paid 1M. You borrow 500k against it, it would be as if you sold 1/4th of it and you would pay CGT immediately on the 1/4th of (2M-1M); the basis would be adjusted so that when eventually you sell the house you pay CGT only on the yet-unrealized gain.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by 1123581321 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @10:55PM (#41855160)
That does not track for me. If someone has $20k in Schwab and chooses to use their credit card instead of selling stock and paying cash, I don't think they should have to pay taxes on that or suffer a criminal penalty. Same for taking on a car loan or a mortgage.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by creato on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @10:59PM (#41855176)
If that's what was happening you'd be right but it isn't. Credit cards have high rates and low limits for a reason: they are unsecured credit. Loans with collateral are secured by the collateral, and it makes some sense that should be considered a realized gain for that collateral (or loss for that matter).
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by __turbobrew__ on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:10PM (#41855236)
My bank will give me a 6 figure line of credit at prime+0.5% because they see all the assets I have (savings, cash, investments, mortgage). The line of credit is indirectly secured against all of the assets my bank can see.

Should I be taxed when I use the line of credit my bank extends to me?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:37PM (#41855371)
What OP is missing is the role of collateral. It becomes more important the more perilous the borrower is or might be.

Apple borrows for 20 years unsecured at 31 bps above the U.S. [1][2]. That wouldn't contract much if they offered collateral, because the difference in relative risk is modest to the point of immateriality. Similarly, someone with a century of living expenses in marketable securities really only needs to be restricted from blowing their stockpile--other risks are absorbed by that wealth.

TL; DR The rich don't need collateral as much as the middle class and poor. Penalise the use of collateralised loans like that, and you just make collaterised lending go away or become much more expensive.

[1] https://www.bondsupermart.com/bsm/bond-factsheet/US037833AT7...

[2] https://home.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:03AM (#41855490)
> TL; DR The rich don't need collateral as much as the middle class and poor.

You really buy this? Elon could just go fetch $44bn from a bank to buy Twitter without anything to back it?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:22AM (#41855583)
> Elon could just go fetch $44bn from a bank to buy Twitter without anything to back it?

Collateral "becomes more important the more perilous the borrower is or might be." It's immaterial to "someone with a century of living expenses."

Elon Musk could probably have borrowed even $100mm unsecured on terms damn close if not identical to that which he could get on a secured loan, ceteris paribus. But Elon is uniquely leveraged. That makes him a more perilous borrower. And $44bn isn't lifestyle borrowing, either.

Nevertheless, he could still probably get a hundred million lent unsecured on terms quite close to his secured rates--there are groups who would do that for relationship building alone.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by consteval on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:47AM (#41860474)
Yes, I would imagine it would be much easier for Elon to get 44bn as opposed to someone who is homeless.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by 1123581321 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:12PM (#41855248)
No difference if secured. You could add to my list of examples a home equity loan. Should that be taxed as a partial sale of the house? No.

Ask your credit union about the variety of loans they offer to regular people.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by gpderetta on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:05AM (#41858639)
It gets more complicated. If you remortgage an house, should you pay CGT on any unrealized increase in value?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @10:56PM (#41855161)
> as soon as you try to use it as realized in ANY way you should be taxed immediately

You're trying to define a rule based on intent. That's doable. We do it all the time. But it tends to get messy, fast. How do you differentiate investment leverage from realizing gains through borrowing? If you track distributions, does a commensurate reduction in contributions count? What if the borrowing is done against the portfolio at large, or unsecured?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:02PM (#41855184)
It is not messy at all if you use KISS. You do not differentiate ever - ANY usage of unrealized gains makes them realized. Very simple to implement but of course won't ever happen :)
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:03PM (#41855192)
> ANY usage of unrealized gains makes them realized

What does "usage" mean? If you write a covered call, did you "use" the asset? If your broker lends your shares out, are they being used? What about presenting your brokerage statement as proof of assets to a mortgage banker? What about--I've done this--showing your brokerage statements to American Express to get a better rate?

I'm still only talking about publicly-traded common stock, mind you.

> simple to implement but of course won't ever happen

Possible, but stupid. You'd raise taxes on the middle class who can't afford advice (or personal attention from lenders) while doing little to those who can dance in the ambiguity offered by what seems simple from a distance but is devilishly complex up close. Because at the end of the day, what you're trying to differentiate is intent. And intent is easy to hide and expensive to uncover.

The core problem in this scheme isn't so much the deferred taxes as much as the eliminated ones: capping the step-up basis to e.g. $10mm, the EPA's statistical value of a human life, would do the trick. Unlike ascertaining "usage," whether or not someone has died is generally simple to determine.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:14PM (#41855257)
I think this is the core issue for me in these discussion - it is not complex at all. If you sell your securities - you pay a tax - that part is simple. Until they it is "unrealized" - right?

> If you write a covered call, did you "use" the asset? Yes

> If your broker lends your shares out, are they being used? Yes

> What about presenting your brokerage statement as proof of assets to a mortgage banker? Of course not

> What about--I've done this--showing your brokerage statements to American Express to get a better rate? Of course not

> You'd raise taxes on the middle class who can't afford advice This is always funny to me, middle class :) For sure it would not affect the middle class and there.is not need to "afford advice" when there is nothing complex about this that needs an advice of anyone.

> Because at the end of the day, what you're trying to differentiate is intent Not at all, it is not "intent" at all - it is just very, very simple... You can own stock and keep it there - no problems. You want to use it for ANYTHING, you pay taxes on it.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:21PM (#41855294)
> What about--I've done this--showing your brokerage statements to American Express to get a better rate? Of course not

You say "there is nothing complex about this" after conceding this loophole the size of a planet.

For starters: loan with a covenant that governs further borrowing and requires you to instruct the lender if your marketable assets fall below a certain value. Not technically secured. But not relevant if you're lending tens of millions to a billionaire--plenty of firms will provide this. Next up: loan to heirs. Next up: unsecured loans at preferential rates if you store your securities with the lender. (This is already a thing.)

> want to use it for ANYTHING, you pay taxes on it

Swapping "use" for "usage" doesn't address the fundamental issue.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:35PM (#41855363)
I see where you are going with this but you are changing parameters here. > For starters: loan with a covenant that governs further borrowing and requires you to instruct the lender if your marketable assets fall below a certain value.

You did not say anything like this, you said "What about presenting your brokerage statement as proof of assets to a mortgage banker?" - this is like me showing my bank account balance during speed dating to flex a bit :) Your example would be 1000000% taxed as you are obviously using it as realized gain.

> Next up: loan to heirs.

If you are using real money, loan all you want. If you are using "money" you are telling Uncle Sam you do not have then you pay tax before you borrow that.

> Next up: unsecured loans at preferential rates if you store your securities with the lender. (This is already a thing.)

This is up to the lender... If they want to use my skin color or my gender or my zipcode (all of which they do) they can also use other stuff as well

I get that I am oversimplifying this but surely a system can be put into place that prevents current madness :)

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:40PM (#41855385)
> Your example would be 1000000% taxed as you are obviously using it as realized gain

How? There is nothing different from the Amex example.

In both cases I'm showing assets held elsewhere as proof that I'm rich. In neither case am I pledging anything. In both cases the letter of the contract requires me to notify the lender of material changes in my financial condition, and in both cases I get a favourable rate--sometimes equal to the pledged asset rate.

> is up to the lender

Yes, and they'd rationally replace secured loans to anyone with unsecured loans to the very rich which automatically accelerate on the borrower's death and carry on as usual. In the end, the behaviour stays the same: the rich let their stock appreciate while they borrow, personally, to fund spending, all the way until they die when the bases step up, they cover the loans and then the heirs get to do the same thing.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:54PM (#41855449)
You are very convincing and have swayed my opinion on this issue for sure. I do not agree with a lot of it but good disagreements :)

> How? There is nothing different from the Amex example... In both cases I'm showing assets held elsewhere as proof that I'm rich.

but you are saying to Uncle Sam that you are not rich... so you are just a big fat liar here and your punishment should be cap gains taxation!!!!

> In the end, the behaviour stays the same: the rich let their stock appreciate while they borrow...

This is exactly what needs to be stopped except of course it won't be cause you know...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:32AM (#41855624)
> you are saying to Uncle Sam that you are not rich

No I'm not. I'm reporting all of those assets as held. They've gained in value, and if and when I sell them I'll pay tax on those gains. In the meantime, they're just sitting there. Appreciating unrealized. And making me look rich to potential lenders.

> exactly what needs to be stopped except of course it won't be cause you know

No, I don't.

I see an analogy with the corporate death penalty. It's an appealing but ultimately stupid concept. Yet it serves a rhetorical purpose: it distracts us from debating massive, debilitating fines. Divide and conqueer. Similarly, we eliminated the step-up basis partly in 1976 and completely in 1980, and then repealed the estate tax in 2010. Those--restoring either the estate tax or, at the very least, the carryover basis in some form--are the real policy wins.

(Likewise appreciated the discussion.)

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Qwertious on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:16AM (#41855833)
>Divide and conqueer.

Heh.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by throwaway2037 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:53AM (#41856283)
First, you are making lots of great points in your posts. Thanks for your comments.

You wrote:

    > Not technically secured.
This raises a very interesting question. When institutional clients use a "repo" trading desk to pledge liquid assets for cash (or vice versa), from a legal perspective, it is not treated as a secured loan. (Yes, it is bizarre. Truly, looks like a duck, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck... but not a duck!)

For these private bank-style loans backed by liquid equity stocks, are they considered secured or unsecured? Honestly, I don't know.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:57AM (#41859085)
> from a legal perspective, it is not treated as a secured loan

Repos are collateralized and thus secured [1]. Legally, they don’t need to be because if the borrower defaults they just don’t buy back the asset; the seller has no further obligation to sell it to them and carries on their merry way.

Repos do however, require special exemptions to avoid being traded as purchases and sales by the IRS, so this is unlikely a valid workaround to a continuous step-up basis czar.

[1] https://www.icmagroup.org/market-practice-and-regulatory-pol...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by jjav on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:24AM (#41856138)
> If you write a covered call, did you "use" the asset? Yes

This wouldn't make any sense, you didn't use it (unless the call gets exercised).

So you have 200 shares and write 1 call, you'd pay tax on the appreciation of just 100 shares? Then sell another call next week, pay taxes again?

> What about presenting your brokerage statement as proof of assets to a mortgage banker? Of course not

I though it was simple. Now the loopholes start to appear.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by splintercell on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:13PM (#41855253)
No offense, but I don't believe you understand the nuance of the thing you're talking about.

It is very easy to say 'any attempt by a murderer to flee the state, and he should be thrown back into the jail' for someone with limited education about western law and order.

This is exactly how you sound.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:19PM (#41855284)
This is exactly what the billionaires have been able to convince the masses :) It would be "very hard, impossible" to implement a system in which you cannot for the purposes of paying taxes claim you do not have some sht while turning around and heading over to the bank to get a boatload of money borrowing against that same sht - need a genius to figure that out...
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by ywvcbk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:36AM (#41856532)
No, the fact that your proposal isn’t thought through at all and is entirely impractical doesn’t mean that solving this problem is "very hard, impossible". That seems entirely unrelated..
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by jjav on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:15AM (#41856098)
> ANY usage of unrealized gains makes them realized

I don't feel like you're thinking this through.

Can you define (precisely enough to write into the tax code) what is "usage"?

For example, let's say I go to get a second loan for a vacation home. The Uniform Residential Loan Application asks me to list all significant assets. Such as my first house.

Am I "using" the value of my primary home? The second loan is not a lien against the first home, I'm not borrowing anything against it. They are unrelated. But the lender will probably consider my equity there as additional net worth which can be a factor in approving that second loan.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by ywvcbk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:29AM (#41856492)
So if you take out a small business loan and use any type of collateral you now have to pay taxes on it?

Significantly increasing the cost of borrowing for most non large companies is certainly a great idea.. it obviously won’t lead to less competition and more concentration.

> It is not messy at all

If you ignore the consequences and implications (or can’t grasp them at all) then sure..

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by gruez on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:04PM (#41855198)
>This should be illegal of course... You cannot for the purposes of paying taxes say "hey, I don't actually have this money, this is unrealized gains" and then turn around (to brokerage house or anyone else) and say "hey, look I actually do have this 'money' - lemme borrow against it."

Do you think the same should apply to HELOC loans? It's basically the same thing but with your home rather than stocks.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:58PM (#41855462)
Your home gains are being taxed already via ever-rising assessments on property taxes. So you are not hiding that and pretending that it is unrealized. You additionally do not pay real estate gains taxes on first 250k as well as...
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by gruez on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:39AM (#41855949)
>Your home gains are being taxed already via ever-rising assessments on property taxes.

it's a separate tax that's on the value, not the gains. Moreover, if we're allowed to bring in other taxes as offsetting factors, do capital gains on companies get a pass because corporations pay corporate taxes as well?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by zeroonetwothree on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:46AM (#41856246)
From the point of view of the IRS you aren’t paying any taxes on your home’s appreciation until you sell.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mindslight on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:50AM (#41860514)
Yes why not, in the general case. With an exception when the loan funds are being reinvested in the property itself. But in the general case where home equity from appreciation is being turned into cash that's then used for other purposes, that looks an awful lot like realizing a gain to me.

In fact this might even be advantageous to certain homeowners who live in a property as their primary residence and then convert it to wholly rental use. Before you move out, take a loan to easily realize of 250k/500k gains which you can then deduct before it's no longer your primary residence.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by lxm on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:06PM (#41855211)
What's your take than on HELOC?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by betaby on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:10PM (#41855234)
Capital gains on a primary residence is not taxes in most the cases anyways, so HELOC changes nothing tax wise.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by zooq_ai on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:10PM (#41855231)
this is an extremely dumb take from the progressive infested HN.

You can literally take Home Equity at an extremely low rate right now.

Millions of Americans sit on appreciated home asset. Should they be taxed?

Brainwashed progressives are worse than QAnon

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bdangubic on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:00AM (#41855475)
> Millions of Americans sit on appreciated home asset. Should they be taxed?

You live in China and you do not pay property taxes on your home? If you live in America baby, you are not allowed to own anything - especially not homes. For that "right" you have to pay these things called property taxes and you have to pay them all the time...

Once we get some same thing going for securities maybe we can do some comparisons like that - until then ... :) you are too funny mate, I needed this laugh

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by unethical_ban on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:18PM (#41855277)
One could argue stocks be handled differently than homes. Or, to better capture the spirit of the proposal, one would progressively tax unrealized gains used for collateral.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by dang on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:39PM (#41875913)
We've banned this account for breaking the site guidelines and ignoring our requests to stop.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40858697

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40515896

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bertjk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:08AM (#41856067)
The key difference here is whether your investment remains at risk. As long as the value of your investment is at risk, then the investment is considered unrealized.

Once you cash in your chips (sell) then the investment becomes realized.

Someone getting a loan against their stock portfolio is still at risk of loss of value of their holdings, therefore the investment gains remain unrealized.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by ywvcbk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:23AM (#41856452)
What about reverse mortgages or any type of loan with any collateral? It’s more or less exactly the same..
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mixmastamyk on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @10:44PM (#41855109)
Yes, margin can be dangerous at times and is not that cheap. About 6% over fed rates, or 11-13% right now. Over $500k you'll probably get a better deal.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by taxman22 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @10:53PM (#41855148)
Schwab Pledge Asset Line (PAL) is SOFR + (2.40% to 4.4%). SOFR today is 4.81%.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by TMWNN on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:10PM (#41855227)
Is Schwab known for being unusually low with its rate for this product? Vanguard is 11-13%, consistent with what mixmastamyk said. <https://investor.vanguard.com/client-benefits/margin?msockid...>

In any case, my Amex line of credit charges 6%, and I am preapproved for an Amex personal loan for 8.98%. I presume others on HN can get comparable or better.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:36AM (#41855640)
> Is Schwab known for being unusually low with its rate for this product?

The Schwab rate sounds high. Fidelity, for instance, charges SOFR + 190 to 310bps [1]. I haven't had an SBLOC for a few years, but I remember Stifel charging no more than 200 bps over Libor.

[1] https://www.fidelity.com/lending/securities-backed-line-of-c...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mixmastamyk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:38AM (#41855651)
8ish percent is good but not fantastic, after years of mortgages lower than that.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by TMWNN on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @11:08PM (#41855220)
What taxman22 says makes me wish I kept my holdings in my Schwab account. (I guess there is nothing stopping me from doing an asset transfer.)

But I agree with you about margin borrowing's interest rate not being that amazing, although it is of course cheaper than most credit cards. Vanguard is, as you said, 11-13%. <https://investor.vanguard.com/client-benefits/margin?msockid...> By contrast, my Amex line of credit charges 6%, and I am preapproved for an Amex personal loan for 8.98%. I presume others on HN can get comparable or better.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by ywvcbk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:38AM (#41856544)
It’s like people complaining about savings accounts with 0.5% interest rates. Just switch to a different broker…

IBKR is +0.5% at >$200k (It starts at +1.5%)

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by yieldcrv on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:32AM (#41855625)
Your broker isn't letting you withdraw margin lending. You cant use it for consumptive purchases.

But its true, you can find a real lender for your stocks. You dont have to be rich.

Its not controversial, you have to pay it back. There are other quirks the rich have:

Already post-tax assets to pay something off

They are in control of the stock, they can issue more new shares for themselves or cause the corporation to do a stock buyback to pump their holdings more if market conditions are favorable.

Borrow more against the increased value or just sell something and pay the taxes that year.

Purchases of primary issuances are taxed differently than secondary market purchases.

But who cares when you can be a neocolonialist for a year in Puerto Rico too, 0% capital gain for new positions and prorated against old ones

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:34AM (#41855632)
> broker isn't letting you withdraw margin lending. You cant use it for consumptive purchases.

There is no rule prohibiting the withdrawal of margin cash. Or, for that matter, short selling and withdrawing that cash. As long as you're Reg T compliant, the Feds don't care. (If you're a family office, even better--you might get to be treated as an institution.)

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by yieldcrv on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:50AM (#41855721)
right, it just hampers the broker’s collection efforts and economic viability if things leave their walled garden

good to know there is no statutory road block

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by creer on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:37AM (#41855644)
Your brokerage will likely lend you money but you will be disappointed by the rate. It is not "very low". Not even "low". At least not where we are now in the interest rates cycle.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by christophilus on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:19AM (#41857813)
Interactive Brokers is 6%. Not low, but not bad.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by creer on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:53PM (#41861233)
5.8 - 5.6% above 100k now indeed, and that's for margin (which you can live on OR re-invest)! Not low but improving yes!

Roughly in line with a 15 yr fixed rate mortgage but not tax deductible at least if you live on it. Might be tax deductible if you re-invest.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Apreche on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:41AM (#41855663)
There is another difference that is related to risk.

Larger loans allow access to lower risk opportunities.

If I had many millions in stocks, and I was greedy for more, I would borrow against it to develop residential real estate in a high rent neighborhood. Yes, there's some risk, but it's as close as you can get to buying a money fountain. I'd be very confident that the rents from the building would pay back the money I borrowed and then some.

Even if I borrow against all my holdings, I can't afford to make that kind of investment. The only options I have are much higher risk. And as you said, I won't survive a failure. Therefore, while the bank would let me do it, I would be very foolish to try.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bruce511 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:41AM (#41855950)
I've owned property to rent in the past. I feel it's worth pointing out to folks keen on this route that, while profitable, it's a Lot of work.

Owning stocks is zero effort. You might glance at your results from time to time. Your fund manager does the heavy lifting (and gets a small % fee for it.)

Owning a property is a pretty constant stream of work. Organizing maintainence. Dealing with complaints. Occasionally evicting non-payers. Finding new tenants. Filtering applicants to filter out the non-payers.

It's so much work you'll likely offload this onto someone rise to do. The cost is not insignificant. (Neither is maintainence.)

The returns may be good, but its not "passive income".

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by throwaway2037 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:01AM (#41856030)
I agree with most of your comments. However, most tax authorities in highly advanced countries view income earned from rental property as passive income, regardless of how much work you need to do. This might be some minor deductions if you act as a real estate agent, but that is a lot of work in most jurisdictions, as real estate agency is normally a highly regulated area of work.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bruce511 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:24AM (#41856137)
For many reasons, including tax and liability, any serious property owner will have a company structure to own the building, collect rent, pay bills etc. Doing it in your personal capacity is pretty insane.

So yeah, you have all the paperwork to run the business as well.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by throwaway2037 on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @10:12PM (#41921054)
"[S]erious property owner" -- This phrase sounds like a "no true Scotsman" test. What exactly qualifies as "serious"? I know numerous people who own a bunch of properties and don't have a separate company structure, as there is no tax advantage (in my jurisdiction). They use local real estate agents to find new renters when old renters leave. It's pretty simple. And, the agent also coordinates monthly payments (to the owner) and any repairs.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chgs on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:44AM (#41856936)
Indeed. Passive income is taxed at a much lower rate than working income in the U.K, and that includes property rents (after paying expenses like a managing agent) and dividends

Capital gains is taxed even lower than that.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by yzydserd on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:28AM (#41858305)
> Passive income is taxed at a much lower rate than working income in the U.K, and that includes property rents (after paying expenses like a managing agent)

Is that right? I thought that income from property rents (after paying expenses like a managing income) had income tax levied like any other income.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chgs on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:10PM (#41861393)
But honest day’s work income has an additional payroll tax which totals about 20% marginal for the majority of people (plot about 60/40 between employer and employee).

Far better to be paid in shares.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by yzydserd on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:52PM (#41861784)
Oh yes National Insurance Contributions. They’re a bit messed up imho.

The employee pays 8% to NICS on earnings between 12.5 and 50k. For income over 50k, it’s 2%.

The employer pays 13.8%, and some people assert the employee ultimately pays the cost through a lower salary.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chgs on Thursday October 17, 2024 @11:02AM (#41870332)
Well at my company it comes from the same budget. Doesn’t matter how you hide it.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chgs on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:43AM (#41856927)
Or you just pay a property management company, which comes off pre tax.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by RickJWagner on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:47AM (#41858004)
I had a friend that bought a second house as a rental.

One day he described what happened when his renter left. They had money troubles, so they quit paying bills (including the rent). When they were evicted, he found that they had been throwing their garbage down the stairs into the basement so they didn't have to pay the trash service. The stench was unbearable, and the mess horrendous.

It is not easy money to be a landlord, I figured.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by dullcrisp on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:56AM (#41855750)
Wanna go halfsies on some residential real estate in a high rent neighborhood?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by throwaway2037 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:03AM (#41856035)
Everything that I read about real estate investing says you should aim for middle class housing, as the return-on-investment from rental cashflow is (normally) higher that more expensive housing. To be clear: My statement is only looking at rental cashflow, not capital appreciation. To me, there are both important, but separate concerns.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Apreche on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:37AM (#41858916)
Sure, but we'll have to go thousandsies, or at least hundredsies.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by tightbookkeeper on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:56AM (#41855752)
Rich people having more options, and being more insulated from risk, is not news.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Apreche on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:38AM (#41858919)
It's not news to the world, but it's news to many.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by tightbookkeeper on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:46AM (#41860458)
I don’t think so. Stronger and attractive people have more options and opportunity too! This is the kind of thing you can’t lose sleep over.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by jjav on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:57AM (#41856014)
> your brokerage will lend you money at a very low rate, secured by the equity

I have not found one that will offer a very low rate, have you?

For example here are Schwab's rates for a loan against equity:

https://www.schwab.com/pledged-asset-line/rates

For 500K-1M rate is SOFR + 3.4%, so about 8.2%

For multimillionaires it gets better at SOFT + 2.4%, or about 7.2%

Not bad in this market but not one I'd call "very low"

Possibly there's an unpublished rate for billionaires, there usually is.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by ywvcbk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:21AM (#41856438)
Switch to a different broker? e.g. it’s just +0.5%

https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/trading/margin-rates.p...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by jjav on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:14AM (#41856750)
The linked page is margin, not equity backed loans.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by ywvcbk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:20AM (#41856780)
Is there a difference?
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Kon-Peki on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:10PM (#41861395)
Yes. In a margin loan, the "things of value" never leave the institution handing out the loan. The borrower buys stock, for example. And the institution giving out the loan has the right to sell whatever you bought to prevent losses on the loan, without your permission if certain conditions are triggered.

In a loan backed by collateral, all the money can leave into some external account controlled by the borrower. To get some or all of it back requires an expensive and lengthy process that doesn't guarantee success.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by ywvcbk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:08PM (#41861932)
IBKR claims that you can establish a margin loan by:

“Withdrawing funds in excess of settled cash in the denomination of the currency being withdrawn;”

So as long as you have enough collateral it’s effectively the same?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mixmastamyk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:03PM (#41864303)
Sounds like the GP is saying that there are additional protections with the equity loan. Such as portfolio liquidation prevention if you move assets to another bank.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by nicolas_t on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:26AM (#41856153)
My bank in Hong Kong (where I live) lends in USD against bonds or stock at around SOFR. If they lend in JPY it's around 0.8%
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by FireBeyond on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:44PM (#41861143)
I think Adam Neumann and a couple of others notably got zero interest loans from banks from the bank wanting to court their business income too.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by theshrike79 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:14AM (#41856396)
You can also buy art.

  1) buy a painting for X
  2) have it evaluated, sometimes the price is higher than X
  3) put it in storage or a tax loophole between countries
  4) use said painting as collateral for low interest loans
Now you have money to invest, as long as you make more than the low interest loan, you're making profit.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by Shaanie on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:25AM (#41856475)
But then you have X money tied up in some presumably illiquid art with questionable value. Seems better to just invest the X money from the start.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by ThinkBeat on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:03AM (#41857040)
but then you do not get the tax benefits discussed above.

The market for "investment art" I huge and everyone involved has an upside by art appreciating in value.

> The artist may get more money (since the artist only gets paid in the initial transaction the artist may only get a fraction of the value as it increases. The artist may find that later work will become more valuable as other investors want more of his art.

>The gallery gets more money, and it may attract more art investors

> and the auction house gets more money if it ends up there.

How much art is worth is difficult to estimate on its own. I mean a white canvas painted uniformly white is worh a lot of money if a famous artist does it.

It is worth entirely nothing if I do it.

I expect then that the market decides the value. All investors want art to get more valuable and are in on it.

As an art lover, this is such a tragic scheme. Unknown amount of art that will never been seen by the public. Locked up inside a storage facility in a big box Often the investor has no interest in the art at all, just an investment made by some form of a broker.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by theshrike79 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:57AM (#41857326)
Art is like Schrödinger's cat, its value is only determined when it changes owner.

If someone pays 1M€ for a piece of art, it is "valued at $1M" and you can use it for collateral for a loan at some percentage of its valuation.

Will it actually be 1M€ if it needs to be liquidated? Nobody knows. It can be worthless or it can be worth 10M€ - it all depends on what the next person is willing to pay for it. But until that point it's "worth" 1M€.

---

This is why there are so many empty (commercial) properties, they were valued at a specific €/m2 price and were used to take loans based on that value.

Until they're rented/leased again, that is their worth and value. Could the owner get someone in the property by lowering the price? Definitely.

Would that also cause a rolling cascade of loans not having enough collateral to back them up? Yup.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by gadders on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:27AM (#41857489)
>> 3) put it in storage or a tax loophole between countries

I think some of the Swiss Freeports would be up there with some of the world's best museums: https://medium.com/@girivasishta07/switzerlands-freeports-se...

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by kwere on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:18PM (#41864407)
there was a loophole that allowed wealthy people to donate to museums works of arts in exchange of a write off on the value of the artwork. to limit abuses they patched it so that you can writeoff only the purchase price not the market value. I heard a workaround is having living artist create a artwork directly for you and getting it appraised to a crazy amount for writeoffs.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by tomatocracy on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:29AM (#41857167)
For very large stakes, the terms tend to be much more bespoke though - an automatic sale of collateral amounting to a large % stake is probably not in either borrower or lender's interest.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chx on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:55AM (#41857314)
It's not at all simple what they do.

https://reddit.com/r/BuyBorrowDieExplained/comments/1f26rsf/...

Important quote:

> this type of planning is generally not economically feasible unless the taxpayer has a net worth exceeding around $300M.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by creer on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @01:01PM (#41861314)
To be fair, there are very accessible options like margin loan or pledged assets which you can also keep going indefinitely - possibly all the way into estate tax which - as a "little guy" - you wouldn't owe. They are higher interest rates (to the point of not being all that interesting - depending on what you want to do.) And they don't have the same features.

But if you are high assets and low income, they might still allow you to buy a house with a loan - if it's what you want.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by traceroute66 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:25AM (#41857471)
> The framing is deceptive.

Indeed the framing is very deceptive.

Yes, it helps to have a relationship with a private bank. But as pointed out, some brokerages will let you do it too if you are too poor to be allowed to enter through the door of a private bank.

BUT

The main thing that is skirted around in the article is that it still needs to go through the financial institution's credit committee.

So, for example, you cannot just rock-up with a million in Tesla shares and expect a loan against them, or at least not at a sensible LTV ratio.

The financial institution will want a boring portfolio with government bonds and low-risk corporate shares.

Any bank that would be willing to lend against a high-risk portfolio is probably not the sort of bank you want to do business with anyway.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by SomeHacker44 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:39AM (#41857569)
This is not true: "very low rate." My brokerage starts at 12+% which I would not call low. It never even reaches prime at millions of borrowing, and I do not have remotely enough to get much better a rate.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by kman82 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:44AM (#41857600)
Wrong brokerage. Interactive Brokers lends at 5% on large amounts and around 6% on small amounts.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by dranudin on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:46AM (#41857991)
You can also lend money from the options market with a box spread for around 4-5%. See e.g. boxtrades.com
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by red-iron-pine on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:59PM (#41861293)
options are a whole different box of worms, and playing that game has a lot more risk.

"but uh its a box trade it can't go wrong because bla bla bla bla" -- then things proceed to go wrong

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by htrp on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:56AM (#41857668)
you need to look at the Lombard landing products offered by banks, not margin loans on brokerage or personal loans
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mixmastamyk on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:53PM (#41864221)
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mason_mpls on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @12:53PM (#41861240)
Even if there’s risk, this is still clearly realizing market gains