News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chgs on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:48AM (#41856957)
> in many cases this can't be paid without selling the asset.

Ok. And?

Why should someone get $5m for doing bugger all. If they were paid $5m for cleaning a car they would lose a fortune in tax.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bruce511 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:23AM (#41857130)
They're not getting 5m, that's the point. They're inheriting an asset which may be valued at 5m. Like a farm, or a house, or a painting or whatever.

Forcing the sale of family property or assets does not serve any good in the long term.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by dataflow on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:37AM (#41858368)
> Forcing the sale of family property or assets does not serve any good in the long term.

How is carrying the cost basis forward without stepping it up "forcing a sale"?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by saltcured on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:52PM (#41863754)
It is under a system where ownership transfers are treated as taxable events. The recipient needs to pay the taxes, but cannot afford to without liquidating the inherited asset.

I think you just need to propose a set of related rules changes. Replace the inheritance basis step-up with a similarly scoped rule that says this inheritance does not count as a taxable ownership transfer, so taxes are not due at that point.

You may also need new rules for estimating the basis when records are lost across multiple inheritance events?

The current system is a bit like a tax foregiveness jubilee, but dribbled out to individual families rather than synchronized across the whole economy. It resets things so that regular people can function in this system, without requiring all the family accounting and records keeping of some aristocratic dynasty.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by mikeyouse on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:03PM (#41861885)
Forcing people to "Sell the family Farm" has been used by estate-tax detractors for so long that there are multiple special programs in place to ensure it never happens (interest-free loans, etc). Given that the current limits are over $13M per person or $26M/couple where zero tax is owed, I don't think this "woe is us" routine resonates any more.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bruce511 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:15PM (#41866100)
That's exactly my point. The current system is working. We explicitly don't want to go to the place where inheritance forces a sale.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by rijoja on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:07AM (#41857369)
idk, maybe because their parents liked them? Do you really want to incentivize against people working hard to make sure their offspring, has a good life? Also a family-home might have sentimental value, and this really doesn't only apply to rich people, quite the contrary actually.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by carlosjobim on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:02AM (#41858080)
> Do you really want to incentivize against people working hard...

You mean by taxing labour and taxing commerce?

Sorry for the snark, but come on...

The Roman empire was built on never taxing labour, because that was seen as an atrocity (never mind the slavery). Instead they taxed luxury goods and debased their currency. The United States was built on never taxing labour, because that was seen as an atrocity (never mind the slavery). Instead they taxed importations and debased their currency.

Since all land was created by God and everything else was created by people's labour, the really unjust thing is to tax labour instead of taxing land. But "territory" is an instinct so deeply ingrained that it's probably been with us for millions of years. However, which other mammals allow members of the same species living on their territory which are not family? As in renting.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by rijoja on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:12PM (#41862698)
> You mean by taxing labour and taxing commerce?

> Sorry for the snark, but come on...

> The Roman empire was built on never taxing labour, because that was seen as an atrocity (never mind the slavery). Instead they taxed luxury goods and debased their currency. The United States was built on never taxing labour, because that was seen as an atrocity (never mind the slavery). Instead they taxed importations and debased their currency.

Interesting, even though I don't see if you are for or against taxing labour, commerce or inheritance.

Inheritance tax is a way for the establishment to take land from small landowners. The state isn't a good counterbalance to "greedy" corporations, the state is there to support big business.

> It'll be sold to a mega-corp because they have more money to spend. So in a couple generations you kill off areas that are primarily small farms.

Please see Bruce511's comment above, he explains it better than me.

The thing is that with an inheritance tax, you make it impossible for someone to live with little or no money, and caring for their off-spring, by giving them a place to stay.

> Since all land was created by God...

Aha, but in the commandments it says that you shouldn't steal, so having property doesn't seem to be forbidden?

> But "territory" is an instinct so deeply ingrained that it's probably been with us for millions of years

So, is caring for your off-spring, kindness and brotherhood. What is your point?

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:10PM (#41863323)
> Inheritance tax is a way for the establishment to take land from small landowners

In the USA, you must have a net worth of at least US$13M per person to be subject to the inheritance tax.

Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by bruce511 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @11:17PM (#41866114)
That's exactly the point. We don't want to change anything that leads to these inheritance tax problems.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by rijoja on Thursday October 17, 2024 @06:14AM (#41868114)
That's interesting, I know that other countries do the same, however, but I was thinking about it as a general principle.
Re:The richest people borrow against their stock (2021) by chgs on Thursday October 17, 2024 @05:08AM (#41867760)
My employer likes me and gives me $100k and I have to pay tax.