Seems to be targeting platforms. Will it be illegal to send encrypted texts, what is keeping anyone from using crypto on top of existing messaging?
While I do not want to dive into any details on adverse effects of such stupidities, the EU seems to be actually taking a strange road to tech dependent overengineered regulation. It seems that this mostly driven by lobbyists that want to sell compliance services. Also it seems that there is more value in creating regulation rather than making sure it is enforcible.
Seems about right for the EU.
Maybe there's an unintended upside to all this regressive business legislation. With all the focus on the "platforms", then maybe, just maybe, this will be yet another nail among the thousands of nails needed to finally kill them off.
Strange times indeed.
Perhaps if the platforms made more of an effort to block the bad behaviour there would be an argument against laws targeting this kind of stuff..
0 - you know what conflict I mean. Will we have to resort to coded messages wherever we go?
1 - https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/oct/21/uk-governme...
Compromising everyone's privacy will eventually mostly affect innocent people. Or even cause the platforms to cease existing altogether, which looks like a real possibility with Signal. Pedos will just move on to whatever service isn't compromised yet. You can outlaw or hamper secure encryption in some jurisdictions, but due to the generic nature of computers you can't in principle stop people from using secure encryption.
This might only be a temporary state, though. Smartphones are, in that sense, not generic. PC might follow.
Though given how incredibly clueless politicians have become I wouldn't be shocked if they tried.
And the problem keeps getting worse.
So either it's just not working whatsoever and this is useless and should stop. Or it's never really about child exploitation.
Just like "temporary measures" against terrorism which have been temporary for 30+ years now (no, it didn't start on 9/11).
Almost like it was never about terrorism.
You're swallowing the propaganda. The problem hasn't changed to speak of.
One way that would put down lots of exploitation and support privacy of adults would be video and online surveillance of all children when not alone, using a parent-controlled computer to detect bad things happening. This could start in kindergarden and school and gradually expand to all spaces that are not home. Children have some right to privacy, but not as strong as adults.
On the 16-th year, if the child wants so, surveillance gets turned off and he/she is granted more privacy. Like with age limits on car driving or working, at some point the state says, you are old enough to take responsibility, we won't protect you from harsh life anymore.
This is a targeted, reasonable solution with little collateral damage, that upholds the right to privacy for adults. It's what parents would want, instead of the bureaucrats. And who really, actually cares about safety of the children, parents or bureaucrats?
> video and online surveillance of all children when not alone
So, you want children to have no privacy just to get a tiny bit more privacy to adults? Are adults really this horrible towards children, do you really think you would like this as a child?
> Children have some right to privacy, but not as strong as adults.
Why the hell not? Do you really think it is ok that your daughter gets constantly video surveilled all throughout puberty? Do you really think that is a lesser evil than your text messages being scanned for some keywords? Would you be happy if there was a camera constantly watching you as you jerked off as a kid?
Only parents would have access to surveillance records. Children often do not like stuff their parents make them do, and their power over them, this would be one more thing, with great benefits.
> Why the hell not?
Because they are children, they do not have full responsibility for their actions, and they are more vulnerable to abuse, and protecting their safety is more important than protecting their privacy. I want to keep the status quo, where children are protected, and adults have rights. The way stuff is going, we're all getting more like children with one parent called Big Brother.
> Would you be happy if there was a camera constantly watching you as you jerked off as a kid?
That is not what I'm suggesting. I'm talking about public spaces (including online) where adults are present. If the kid wants to jerk off, or two or more kids want to make love, they can go home or use some private space like a bathroom.
You do realize parents create a lot of the CP out there? Especially if you include non-biological parents, who are legally parents.
> That is not what I'm suggesting. I'm talking about public spaces (including online) where adults are present.
So you wouldn't stop basically anything? What kind of child porn do you expect to catch using this? It isn't like anyone is creating child porn in public, they do it in the privacy of homes.
I assumed you would suggest something that could stop child porn, not just cameras in public places.
Easier solution, remove and replace the politicians.
What we see is a shift of power. Electronic communications started out as private enterprises, then mostly taken over by states because of the need centralization, and now almost completely taken over by private enterprises one layer above. Governments are still trying to make sense of what happened and find their role in this new world.
Platforms are centralization at work, and it's not that far fetched to think that states could do a better job than Twitter or Facebook. Platforms have immense power. After all, we mostly agree that Facebook very literally facilitating genocide was not good for society. What we disagree on is how much they knew and how much was circumstantial.
There is also this idea that jurisdictions matter for platforms. The Chinese connections with Tiktok owners are problematic since we know for a fact that they have the power to influence elections. The American ownership of Facebook is not similarly problematic, largely because the CIA and other institutions interests mostly align with ours.
It would not surprise me if the Saudi money financing Twitter/X would turn out to be just as important as the financing of 9/11.
In light of that, it should not be surprising that EU states wants to play the game too, even if it will have very little practical effect.
Tech is not good or bad but it does have unintended consequences and open new ways for abuse. This is tough to swallow for us who work in tech but is obvious to everyone else. If we stay in denial and do not volunteer to help use tech smartly to compensate for bad side effects, they will vote in some dumb law and some bad guys will exploit it for surveillance later.
The track record of such societies is rather terrifying.
But I think you not being able to state what a saner solution is is enough for this conversation.
Either your communications are spied on to weed out unapproved material, or they're not. And there is no way to make the system architecture care about which material is allowed to be "unapproved".
The right answer here is just to accept that, beyond a certain point, further reducing the amount of circulating child porn requires unacceptable tradeoffs. Then stop whining and wishing for impossible technical solutions.
The app has thus not violated end-to-end encryption, nor has that content been exposed to external parties.
Platforms could definitely do more.
You can design a system where false positives are so rare they are insignificant and can be properly handled. The only reason we don't is because we don't think it's that much of a problem.
You can keep the false positive level reasonably low for copies of already known and flagged images. You can't do it for new images.
But flagged known images was the point of Apple's algo, for example. Still everyone just went "forget abuse, my privacy is more important for me". Really at this point techbros deserved any dumb law that lets the government read their chats.
Maybe I actually know something about it.
> But flagged known images was the point of Apple's algo, for example.
You whined at me a little while ago about how all this was about "abuse, not just porn". Yet you're using that to justify a system that, as you describe it, could only find old, known images that have been circulating around the Internet and made it into a database. Meaning images of past abuse that cannot be prevented, by third parties who would not be caught by this.
Pick a threat model, because the measures you defend don't address the threats you claim justify them.
... and if you start talking about "grooming" or "normalization" or other silly bullshit that hypothetically might have a third-order effect, but probably doesn't have any meaningful effect at all in real life, I'm not going to bother to answer it.
> Still everyone just went "forget abuse, my privacy is more important for me".
Everybody's privacy is important to me. Including the privacy of the children whom you want to have grow up in an ever-expanding panopticon. Because this isn't just about stupid bullshit like your embarrassing disease. It's about people ending up in prison. It's about building infrastructure that can trivially and secretly be repurposed to hurt people, including children, in serious, life-changing, and potentially life-ending ways.
The Stasi were not a child-friendly institution.
If you know then you'd agree that with the right setup ML can do this with a very high precision. We're talking about a highly customized system trained exactly for this one purpose not some chatbot.
> You whined at me a little while ago
You're the one whining here buddy-- remember this is about a law about to be forced on you that you find inconvenient ;) I find it suboptimal but in some sense it might be better than nothing.
> this was about "abuse, not just porn".
These are related. If you have this material, you obtained it from somewhere even if you didn't make it yourself. Some police work and it may lead to some dark web exchange marketplace and actual producers.
That said yes, there's difference. The EU law being discussed is probably more fit to counter realtime abuse, compared to Apple's algo for example.
> Because this isn't just about stupid bullshit like your embarrassing disease. It's about people ending up in prison.
I actually agree with these two sentences, but not in the way you probably intended.
> The Stasi were not a child-friendly institution.
I was waiting until Hitler gets invoked in a discussion about using tech to combat and prevent child abuse facilitated by tech, I was not disappointed.
No, it cannot.
Not with a model that you can run on a phone, no matter how specialized it is. Serious ML takes actual compute power (which translates to actual electricity).
Not with a model that you can train on the number of positive examples that are actually available. Current ML is massively hungry for training data.
Not with any model that's out there on people's phones and therefore subject to white-box attack. Adversarial examples are not a solved problem, especially not in the white-box environment.
Probably not with any model. You would need maybe a 0.0000001 false positive rate. That rate falls asymptotically with both model size and training.
> that you find inconvenient ;)
The last refuge of the fanatic is to call anybody who raises inconvenient objections a pedophile.
> I was waiting until Hitler gets invoked in a discussion about using tech to combat and prevent child abuse facilitated by tech, I was not disappointed.
The Stasi did not have anything to do with Hitler, and did not exist at all until after Hitler was dead. They were not part of the Nazi apparatus. Your ignorance of history helps to explain your willingness to give dangerous powers to untrustworthy insitutions, though.
> The last refuge of the fanatic
Between us two there's one with maximalist and absolutist views.
> call anybody who raises inconvenient objections
The actual objections are dealt with. Properly implemented (like Apple's algo) it's not spying, inconvenience and detriment of an individual is a fact of life in any society etc. We just trade personal attacks now.
> a pedophile
Putting words in my mouth.
> The Stasi did not have anything to do with Hitler, and did not exist at all until after Hitler was dead
Thanks for correcting me. So basically Stalin then. Wow, such difference.
You know exactly what you intended to convey with that little smiley, so do I, and so does everybody else.
You're reading too much into this. The smile is there because you called me whining and I did the same to you.
> The right answer here is just to accept that, beyond a certain point, further reducing the amount of circulating child porn
Not porn, don't delude yourself. Actual abuse.
> requires unacceptable tradeoffs
And whether tradeoffs are acceptable or not depends on tradeoffs. If you refuse to help find solutions that don't involve spying, don't get all flustered when a law is adopted that does involve spying!
> Either your communications are spied on to weed out unapproved material, or they're not.
Exactly. Apple's solution did not involve any spying. People have spoken against, now we have solutions that do involve spying. Let's see where this goes yeah?
Spying by your own device is still spying.
Upon detecting a suspect image, it takes action. The action isn't really part of the "algorithm". Depending on the score, Apple's whim of the day, and/or outside compulsion which would probably be applied to Apple, it refuses to allow the image to be sent in messages or to "the cloud", deletes the image, and/or reports the image to Apple (which would presumably report it further). They can change what it does at any time.
In other words, it examines data on your device, on behalf of others, in a way that you don't control, and uses the resulting information to your potential detriment, again on behalf of others and again in a way that you don't control.
Apple examining your data in a way you don't control, to implement policy that you don't control and may oppose, is spying. It doesn't matter whether they do the spying using you CPU or their CPU.
The only scenario where you don't need to accept things that are to your potential (and very real) detriment is if you don't live in society.
And no, what you described is not spying. Look up what it means: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Espionage.
You are doing mental gymnastics. It's like calling a speeding fine "robbery", at best it's noise and not a useful contribution to discussion.
Where I live, police can't just randomly "check your documents" unless they already have some independent evidence supporting the idea that you might be involved in a crime. Which is how it should be.
It wouldn't be spying, though, since they'd be doing it openly and presumably not doing it on a continuing basis. It'd still be obscene authoritarian overreach.
> or speed/traffic camera is not "to your potential detriment",
These should of course be banned.
> or waiting in line to board the bus, etc.
This has nothing at all to do with anything and is just you trying to muddy the waters.
Yeah, then how about you match the description of a criminal. But it was an example and if you don't get the point then it's a waste of time.
> These should of course be banned.
Are you protesting them?
What if your kid gets run out by one of them speeders while walking out of school gates, will you still think speeding cameras are unnecessary?
> muddy the waters
These are all examples of having to suffer detriment due to living in a civilized society. You can pretend you don't but you do.
Why does this issue get techbros all up in arms-- I don't see them out protesting airport security checks etc. Somehow when their own lives are on the line then it's acceptable to require privacy invasive checks.
Nobody falls for that crap. We all know that CP is being presented as a scapegoat here because, "how can you be against something that MIGHT help against CP!?!?!" while in fact and in the end it'll be used to spy on everything.
The only way to ensure that can't happen is to inspect the code and compile it yourself, or at least validate the hash of the binary you're installing. But we've also recently learned with the xz fiasco that you'll need to be sure to add checks all the way down.
Of course, you could always encrypt before entering the text into signal, but at that point why use signal?
Yes, Whatsapp is in a position to act unethically and steal information, but that does not make Whatsapp the owner of anything.
It is their client. Any data you enter into the client is data they 0wn.
Security researchers analyze software in order to third party attack vectors. They do not analyze first or second party attack vectors, because that would be silly. There's simply too many of them.
The next steps are leo seizing your device(s) or leo having WhatsApp start sending all your messages to them for review.
What happens when leo adds the hash of a state-loathed meme?
Obviously, the moment these platforms lose privacy, the criminals cease communication on them immediately. So they're the last group this is aimed at.
The solution to crime is the same investigation and detective work and anonymous tip offs and so on that it's always been. People going undercover and infiltrating these groups and then bringing them down.
By chasing the criminals off this platforms, all that happens is the detective work gets harder. Now they've got to go find where to start their infiltration, all over again.
This outcome is so obvious that the only conclusions available are that the lawmakers are either IQ 60 morons, or that they have malicious intent.
Well, we went in billions to these chat apps. The state just follows.
As sceptical as i am, i think, i want the state to resolve online crimes.
You overestimate how smart they are, you forget how a lot of crime is opportunistic, that if abuser has to convince a child to install a shady app they would have much lower success rate and set off many alarms, etc.
Ban all “non-intelligible” content?
Who can stop me from hiding information in very normal looking sentences?
If you want privacy, there will always be a way.
You can just send anyone you want an encrypted e-mail or message, but Signal can't facilitate that without the required provisions set out in those laws. If these dumb laws get enacted, Signal cannot get away with just pretending you are sending gibberish whilst providing true end-to-end encryption without any client-side scanning or whatever to you, but you are well within your rights do so yourself on top of Signal (if that's even possible); they just can't provide an automated means to do that for you.
What I'm wondering is whether two separate applications can be set up to communicate automatically, with one handling messaging and the other being responsible for encrypting and decrypting the data.
What would be against the law in that case? The messaging app? The encryption app? Or the interaction you are doing in that moment?
Of course these laws are dumb, but that doesn't mean they can't be (mis)used to get the desired effect.
Actually police and various agencies do, because when most people aren't encrypting, the few that do are suddenly interesting. Some of them will turn out to be organized crime, but some of them are just adults who want to communicate privately.
Does Android facilitates IPC and services?
You can already install a mail client with PGP-support. Will K-9 Mail get in to trouble if a million users in the EU started privately exchanging keys and using GPG with K-9 Mail? Who knows. These laws are not about such practical details. This is about unlocking massive amounts of signal intelligence to do… who knows what, and those large communication platforms are juicy targets. All it needs is a law to coerce them to cooperate.
Don't expect reasonable arguments from the proponents of such laws, and don't expect to be able to avoid them for millions of users with clever tricks; you'll still fall foul of the spirit of the law, if not the letter.
That might be the next step. Banning encryption. We live in a strange world right now.
What some law-and-order types (globally) want, is the means to scan, peek, or otherwise access private communication, especially if that communication is provided by a service used by millions. You can encrypt all you like, but if you use WhatsApp or Signal, laws like these force those services to create a way to eavesdrop. How is probably not defined in the law. Client-side scanning before encryption, having those services act as men-in-the-middle for each conversation; this is all fine, and can use encryption as usual. As long as certain agencies get to have a peek somewhere between those strongly encrypted tunnels.
I understand Signal is handicapped now, but I couldn’t care less about Signal. I only care about being able to communicate in private. Why don’t we implement this stuff at a lower layer?
Surely the guys on top must see this is an endless game that they will never win? It’s not an arm’s race, it’s fundamentally impossible.
This is about making it hard (or impossible) for some perceived group of miscreants to communicate privately. People sharing CSAM (however you define that) or dealing drugs, and stuff like that. Anyone can encrypt their communication, but most people don't do this consciously; the masses just use WhatsApp and Signal and what have you.
You and your special keyboard are not of interest, and unless you start selling these along with a service to route the encrypted messages to thousands of users, you are not the target of this legislation. Take away Signal and WhatsApp and sending an end-to-end encrypted message to your drug dealer without exchanging keys and agreeing on a protocol suddenly isn't as easy as just opening an app. That's the point of this law.
It's a dumb law, but you won't make it go away by playing silly semantic games.
They may be coming down the pipe, after the soft version gets people macerated.
> at which point you won't be living in a democracy
But you will be hearing from talking heads that you are, and Russia and North Korea are the real dictatorships.
And maybe they will be right, because what is democracy? The word has different meanings to different people, and it won't be difficult to shape the discussion about what our liberal democracy is all about. Maybe it's about accepting who has power now and about protecting the vulnerable. We have seen a bit of this stance and real capabilities in recent years.
Point is that dangerous people will use specialty devices/services and being legal is certainly not one of the requirements.
How can you maintain such a position? At some point you’ll have to explain your reasons for draconian measures like this.
That’s why I’m spamming people with “it won’t work” because so many seem fooled by this. You will catch exactly zero people with this. The only people you’ll catch will be the ones that you would have caught anyway, because of their nonchalance.
I don’t know anything about law but I know tech.
Why a law is enacted is more complex than just the here and now. Some of these law-and-order types dream of the day they can order Apple or Samsung to completely lock down their smartphones and forbid any user controlled cryptography. Some just want to be able to feel that they are doing everything in their power to prevent children from being harmed, even if the measures only cover naive users. Some just want people to know that they are being watched, and have these laws act as deterrent.
And as a bonus: some parents really like the idea that none of their children or any of their mates are sharing (their own) underage nudes and that this is enforced automatically.
The law will likely work for some of these points, to some extent. It's still a bad law, but the people pushing it aren't idiots; just dangerous.
This world confused me sometimes.
Or ... they develop their own darknet webrtc based chat lol, like its silly to enforce this on the general populace when its so obviously circumvented by the people looking to do scary shit.
“The semester begins in three more weeks. We've obtained 19 confirmations for studies in the faculty of law, the faculty of urban planning, the faculty of fine arts and the faculty of engineering.” — Mohamed Atta
“Two sticks, a dash and a cake with a stick down. What is it?”[2] — Mohamed Atta
“The first semester commences in three weeks. Two high schools and two universities. ... This summer will surely be hot ...19 certificates for private education and four exams. Regards to the professor. Goodbye.”[2] — Abu Abdul Rahman
Even in China with extreme surveillance and censorship in place, Chinese people have been quite creative in their ways of circumventing censorship. An example approach is cutting and pasting official political videos together in a way that changes their meaning ever so slightly. Automatic censorship algorithms are fooled, and human analysis and censorship are necessary and very expensive to carry out. Other examples are playing with the sounds of words, or using memes or rapidly-changing euphemisms.[3] It's too difficult to automatically censor stuff where people have taken a normal word such as "chair" and send each other images of chairs as a sign of protest. An image of a chair and a birthday cake with a number of candles could indicate a date of protest. Or a chair in a picture with a number of ducks in the background, or a number of chairs stacked on top of each other. And if censors start blocking all chairs, everyone just shifts to buses, or pieces of paper, or bananas, or whatever.
[1] https://community.apan.org/cfs-file/__key/docpreview-s/00-00...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2004/12/20/business/technology/on-th...
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_COVID-19_protests_in_Chin...
If this sort of surveillance stuff gets accepted, in time, you're gonna get noticed, put into database, and maybe called for questioning. Why are you using encryption, people that have nothing to hide do not use it.
Half of the reason Microsoft is pushing "AI PCs" with special hardware is so they can push their spying to on-device and reduce all the extra costs the data processing they're imagining for things like automatic-screenshot-analysis-every-x-seconds will need.
And they're pretty much experts on spying on users. They've been collecting so much data for so long that apparently they've found a way to utilize what they collect in a way that makes the costs balance out in the end. Whether thats with government access, preferential antitrust treatment, or some actual financial method that directly affects the bottom line, I don't know. Somehow it's worthwhile for them. BUT -- when even Microsoft is looking for more efficient ways to spy on people, and forcing new hardware to support that effort, you know the data collection and analysis technique is definitely not ready to be made a legal mandate.
It doesn't make sense at all for some EU decision makers to decide it's acceptable for their citizens to bear the cost of so much data processing.
....wait, how much do large players in AI contribute to these politicians campaigns? Or if not them, who is really pushing this? It seems like someone should really try following the money on this one.
It's just a matter of lesser evil in my humble opinion.
At least on a mass scale, if we worry about back doors.
This SaaS fad is the underlying technical enabler of the spying and need to go away.
I guess Google is the main culprit by making P2P coms hard.
Asking faceless corps to open their users' mailboxes willy nilly is way easier then asking the voters to.
We don’t own our devices anymore and we now have very limited control of what is executed or not so there is nothing stopping developers to run those legal spywares on the device since our only option if we don’t like what an app does is to not use it.
The problem is not going away, we in tech are partly responsible and we should promote good ways to deal with it. If we don't then a solution will be found anyway, it'll just be a bad one.
We have linux phones these days, caly, and grapheneos. There really isn't reason to give up on general computing. (Ignoring the propriety baseband blobs.)
Sadly, nothing else comes even close to Apple in terms of security and privacy, especially for someone who is not an infosec specialist and doesn't have time to read CVEs all day.
The slope is so slippery that it's ot worth the risk, imo. It paves the way to reduce general computing even further, which is already quite restricted on apple devices to begin with.
Even for someone that is not an infosec specialist, they should be using something like Graphene for phones and something like Qubes for their OS.
Apple isn't great at all honestly, at least in terms of MacOS security - they mostly benefit from not being worth the time to target.
I want to see the riots when EU cell phone consumers have to pay for text messages again.
Some men just want to watch the world burn...
In fact, most of the protests seem to neatly fall into the "police violence" (usually against minorities) and "austerity" buckets.
But the Internet is largely a magic box and at this point the common understanding seems to be that it is both private and also under massive corporate and state surveillance at the same time. And that's not even mostly wrong.
> €0.022 per minute of voice calls made
> €0.004 per text message
> €2 per GB of data (cap in 2022, decreasing over time to €1 / GB, which will be the maximum surcharge from 2027 onwards) https://www.google.com/amp/s/europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/c...
They are free to say texts are free (included in plan), or texts are charged at 10 euros each, whatever.
The EU only limits surcharges when roaming to other EU countries.
Jeez, guys.
Edit:
I am not backing away from anything, I was rephrasing to sustain your strange cross-examination. You guys are being unecessarily aggressive and argumentative over a simple point.
"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."
"don't cross-examine."
It's Sunday, guys. Do something positive with your time. Bye.
"I don't think the EU says anything about how much texts should cost."
Into a weaker form of "The EU only limits surcharges when roaming to other EU countries.". This was my only comment because your first position is factually incorrect, there are situations in which the EU defines how much texts can cost.
edit: not sure where you see the aggressiveness
Occasional war here and there not directly involving any of the member states is incomparably better than what came before.
Thats a LOT of compute.
Finally, free from WhatsApp voice notes, stickers and images clogging my phone storage. Adieu.
If this law passes, bye bye.
dont misrepresent
dont misrepresent
And I disagree. You take for granted all the good regulating and all the things enabled by the EU, and focus on the one bad regulation we're discussing, which is not even a law yet. I, personally, am not looking forward to the future without EU (I remember my country before it joined and the progress is immense).
I think elsewhere online this may happen.
Also, some public broadcasters use the "far right" word group suspiciously often, almost as if it was some kind of effort to softly suggest to people how not to vote, but I must be imagining things, because they would never do that:)
Try the largest German-speaking subreddit, for example.
No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honour and reputation. Everyone has the right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks.
Bugging communications by investigators with special approval is already an exception to this principle. Government bodies that make sure that laws conform to the constitution should veto any exception broader than that, so this draft should basically be pointless.
It feels like there are social/political mechanisms at work that allow that to however happen. They pave the road to Hell little by little, one stone at a time, and this is neither strange nor entertaining. To me, the beginning of this century has similarities with the beginning of the previous, which is quite worrying.
the reality is, if anyone is seriously determined to commit what they know are crimes then there are many solutions, of admittedly varying quality, for having private communications outside of the mainstream apps available on the app store. even signal itself has an apk you can install on android from their website.
so, it's unlikely this will indeed help in the fight against CSAM or whatever else is purportedly motivating this legislation. the end result will be mass surveillance 24/7 on the vast majority of the population who aren't commiting any crimes at all. it seems to me like big brother's wet dream. ironic that this is exactly the thing the US/EU political leadership have been bashing the chinese for since forever.
there's a good reason for that. it's not controlled by and for the benefit of our oligarchs.
It could be text, audio, video, raw signal bitstream from an IoT sensor, or a full duplex async combination of anyone of those.
It wouldn't be a "chat service" to an outside observer, it would just be seemingly random, opaque bits between two endpoints.
At end of day, if someone wants to do this, there is no way, afaik, it can be detected. so, all these laws won't really help combating serious criminals who have some savvy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog_hole
If you're running a criminal organization, a bigger threat than a wiretap can be someone wearing a wire, so to speak. Talking about anything over text creates a ton of evidence about the criminal conspiracy that you are currently engaged in. That evidence can be screencapped or recorded or whatever else by the person at the other end of the conversation. Since you don't have physical control over that person, it's possible they could be compromised.
If you keep everything in-person, even if someone becomes a snitch, you can still check them for hidden recording devices. At best, this means the evidence against you is that person's recollection of your conversation.
This is the same reason why it's much harder to pirate a movie in theatres than one released on streaming. Physical control over the environment that information is disseminated in is the gold standard, just look at the US military:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitive_compartmented_inform...
Of course. Your "privacy" is very important for Microsoft, Google and Apple because of the "geopolitical situation". /s
As far as I know, most messaging platforms allow you to send regular files too. Wouldn't "the bad guys" simply use that as a loophole and continue with their day?
I know the real reason behind the law isn't to actually protect children, but, you know...
So it won't stop CP, or any other criminal activity that's in the slightest bit cluefull.
They must know this, so I'm left scratching my head wondering what they are actually up to.
Shit criminals will just meet and swap usb drives lol, like i don't get how this solves the crime issue. This is like banning monero or crypto because its used illegally.. meanwhile CP and other crimes have used Euro and USD paper money for long before crypto lol but yet "crypto seems shady" is enough reason to point at it as the reason crime exists lol.
I took that as a given and therefore described what I would see as scan-creep of the gov implementation regardless of the exact verbiage of the law.
My point was that anyone expecting to use the file type as a loophole would likely ne compromised, and the only way to ensure bypass of the scan would be to locally encrypt before transmission, as any text or binary entered into an app affected by this law should be assumed to be fully mined, scanned, and reported to the gov regardless of its contents.
Additionally, it says photos, videos, links, but you can make any data represented as other files e.g. text, slowscan, steganography, etc.
If true, then it seems unnecessary to "leave the EU market" with respect to text messages and voice calls.
----
According to the latest draft regulation dated 28 May (Council document 9093/24), which is presented as “upload moderation”, users of apps and services with chat functions are to be asked whether they accept the indiscriminate and error-prone scanning and possibly reporting of their privately shared images, photos and videos. Previously unknown images and videos are also to be scrutinised using “artificial intelligence” technology. If a user refuses the scanning, they would be blocked from sending or receiving images, photos, videos and links (Article 10). End-to-end encrypted services such as Whatsapp or Signal would have to implement the automated searches “prior to transmission” of a message (so-called client-side scanning, Article 10a). The initially proposed scanning of text messages for indications of grooming, which is hardly being used to date, is to be scrapped, as is the scanning of voice communication, which has never been done before. Probably as a concession to France, the chats of employees of security authorities and the military are also to be exempted from chat control.
----
Strange times we live in. Entertaining, but strange.
[1] - https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/majority-for-chat-control-p...