It's just a matter of lesser evil in my humble opinion.
At least on a mass scale, if we worry about back doors.
This SaaS fad is the underlying technical enabler of the spying and need to go away.
I guess Google is the main culprit by making P2P coms hard.
Asking faceless corps to open their users' mailboxes willy nilly is way easier then asking the voters to.
We don’t own our devices anymore and we now have very limited control of what is executed or not so there is nothing stopping developers to run those legal spywares on the device since our only option if we don’t like what an app does is to not use it.
The problem is not going away, we in tech are partly responsible and we should promote good ways to deal with it. If we don't then a solution will be found anyway, it'll just be a bad one.
We have linux phones these days, caly, and grapheneos. There really isn't reason to give up on general computing. (Ignoring the propriety baseband blobs.)
Sadly, nothing else comes even close to Apple in terms of security and privacy, especially for someone who is not an infosec specialist and doesn't have time to read CVEs all day.
The slope is so slippery that it's ot worth the risk, imo. It paves the way to reduce general computing even further, which is already quite restricted on apple devices to begin with.
Even for someone that is not an infosec specialist, they should be using something like Graphene for phones and something like Qubes for their OS.
Apple isn't great at all honestly, at least in terms of MacOS security - they mostly benefit from not being worth the time to target.
Half of the reason Microsoft is pushing "AI PCs" with special hardware is so they can push their spying to on-device and reduce all the extra costs the data processing they're imagining for things like automatic-screenshot-analysis-every-x-seconds will need.
And they're pretty much experts on spying on users. They've been collecting so much data for so long that apparently they've found a way to utilize what they collect in a way that makes the costs balance out in the end. Whether thats with government access, preferential antitrust treatment, or some actual financial method that directly affects the bottom line, I don't know. Somehow it's worthwhile for them. BUT -- when even Microsoft is looking for more efficient ways to spy on people, and forcing new hardware to support that effort, you know the data collection and analysis technique is definitely not ready to be made a legal mandate.
It doesn't make sense at all for some EU decision makers to decide it's acceptable for their citizens to bear the cost of so much data processing.
....wait, how much do large players in AI contribute to these politicians campaigns? Or if not them, who is really pushing this? It seems like someone should really try following the money on this one.