They may be coming down the pipe, after the soft version gets people macerated.
> at which point you won't be living in a democracy
But you will be hearing from talking heads that you are, and Russia and North Korea are the real dictatorships.
And maybe they will be right, because what is democracy? The word has different meanings to different people, and it won't be difficult to shape the discussion about what our liberal democracy is all about. Maybe it's about accepting who has power now and about protecting the vulnerable. We have seen a bit of this stance and real capabilities in recent years.
Point is that dangerous people will use specialty devices/services and being legal is certainly not one of the requirements.
How can you maintain such a position? At some point you’ll have to explain your reasons for draconian measures like this.
That’s why I’m spamming people with “it won’t work” because so many seem fooled by this. You will catch exactly zero people with this. The only people you’ll catch will be the ones that you would have caught anyway, because of their nonchalance.
I don’t know anything about law but I know tech.
Why a law is enacted is more complex than just the here and now. Some of these law-and-order types dream of the day they can order Apple or Samsung to completely lock down their smartphones and forbid any user controlled cryptography. Some just want to be able to feel that they are doing everything in their power to prevent children from being harmed, even if the measures only cover naive users. Some just want people to know that they are being watched, and have these laws act as deterrent.
And as a bonus: some parents really like the idea that none of their children or any of their mates are sharing (their own) underage nudes and that this is enforced automatically.
The law will likely work for some of these points, to some extent. It's still a bad law, but the people pushing it aren't idiots; just dangerous.
This world confused me sometimes.
This is about making it hard (or impossible) for some perceived group of miscreants to communicate privately. People sharing CSAM (however you define that) or dealing drugs, and stuff like that. Anyone can encrypt their communication, but most people don't do this consciously; the masses just use WhatsApp and Signal and what have you.
You and your special keyboard are not of interest, and unless you start selling these along with a service to route the encrypted messages to thousands of users, you are not the target of this legislation. Take away Signal and WhatsApp and sending an end-to-end encrypted message to your drug dealer without exchanging keys and agreeing on a protocol suddenly isn't as easy as just opening an app. That's the point of this law.
It's a dumb law, but you won't make it go away by playing silly semantic games.