News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by CobrastanJorji on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:26PM (#39298127)
I'm disappointed in all the folks immediately blaming the cyclist without further information, and I'm similarly disappointed in all the folks blaming Waymo for the same reason.

But, unless they somehow have extra information we're not privy to, I'm much more disappointed in the S.F. Supervisor quoted in the article, Shamann Walton, for immediately going online to say "so much for safety." Us internet weenies are always going to have our hot takes, but someone in charge of the city has a responsibility to at least try to be better.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by rahimnathwani on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:02AM (#39298416)
Nothing should surprise you about Shamann Walton. This is the man who refused to adhere to the City Hall's security procedures (on camera) and allegedly threatened the person who asked him to comply: https://sfstandard.com/2022/08/05/video-supervisor-shamann-w...

He also bought a home outside San Francisco, with a mortgage condition that says it must be his principal residence. But if doesn't live in SF, how can he represent the people of SF?

https://susanreynolds.substack.com/p/where-does-shamann-walt...

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:13AM (#39298489)
I'm not surprised by the content of your links, but I can say I'm disappointed. After all, surprise and disappointment are different things.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Terr_ on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:51AM (#39299430)
> After all, surprise and disappointment are different things.

Hmmm... I think I gave it a honest try, but I'm still having trouble making that fit. I mean, both are when the unexpected occurs, one is just more-specific, where the unexpected leads to a negative emotional response.

Perhaps shocked versus disappointed?

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:46AM (#39299751)
In a similar comment I gave an example and maybe that'll help. I can leave my food in the oven too long and I will not be surprised to find that it is burnt, but I will definitely be disappointment that I ruined my meal. I think this should clarify and why I was a bit snarky lol. While they often correlate they are not the same.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Terr_ on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:30PM (#39310732)
> I can leave my food in the oven too long and I will not be surprised to find that it is burnt, but I will definitely be disappointment that I ruined my meal.

Wading deep into the philosophical weeds here, my instinct is saying that's not an apples-to-apples scenario, because each term is being used in connection to different sets of events. For example, "when I realized my alarm hadn't gone off" versus "when I got home and opened the oven door."

Perhaps the easiest way to illustrate that is to imagine the opposite scenario, where all discoveries and all self-analysis occur at the same moment in time:

1. You ask someone else to bake a pie, let it cool, and deliver the result to you later in the day.

2. A few hours later, an opaque and airtight box arrives, on time. (No clues, no warnings.) You still anticipate it contains your favorite pie.

3. You open the box to discover a blackened stinky mess!

4. At this moment you are experience both surprise (in general) and also a specific sub-type of surprise which is disappointed surprise.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by soraki_soladead on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:35PM (#39298198)
Agree that's not a great look for the supervisor.

Cyclists have a bad rep in SF because many (not all) ride quite dangerously. It's a common sight to see cyclists running four-way stop signs and lights without even yielding. I live adjacent to a four-way stop and there's an incident where a cyclist fails to yield nearly hourly.

Meanwhile, Waymo has millions of incident-free miles and of all the self-driving car companies generally takes safety seriously, even if they will act to protect their interests here.

Until more evidence comes out I'll be taking Waymo's side here. I want safer vehicles and Waymo is currently the best bet.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by armada651 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:00AM (#39298393)
> Cyclists have a bad rep in SF because many (not all) ride quite dangerously.

Cycling in the US is almost by definition riding dangerously, since there are very few places with actual safe bicycle infrastructure. This is a self-selecting pressure, because it means that the only cyclists that actually dare to cycle in the city are risk-takers.

> I live adjacent to a four-way stop and there's an incident where a cyclist fails to yield nearly hourly.

You can blame the cyclist or perhaps a four-way stop with a nearly hourly cyclist incident needs to be redesigned.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by alvah on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:23AM (#39298558)
"> I live adjacent to a four-way stop and there's an incident where a cyclist fails to yield nearly hourly.

You can blame the cyclist or perhaps a four-way stop with a nearly hourly cyclist incident needs to be redesigned."

Or, bear with me here, just maybe the cyclists failing to yield is kind of the big issue here?

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by shuckles on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:27AM (#39298580)
No it’s not. AB122 passed the legislature to legalize the California roll for cyclists, because coming to a full stop at a stop sign makes no sense for riders with high visibility. Newsom vetoed it for stupid culture war reasons. It’s a law that doesn’t make sense so it’s not a big issue if it isn’t followed.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by groggo on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:49AM (#39298713)
I'm a cyclist and support these types of laws. But I could imagine someone making the same case for a car (or a motorcycle?). You can have high visibility and come towards a 4-way stop in the middle of nowhere and there's not another car in sight. It doesn't really make sense. For cycling of course it's super annoying to lose your momentum.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zx8080 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:32AM (#39298946)
Considering:

> annoying

Vs

excess CO2 from engines (does not matter if electric or not, as efficiency is still a thing to consider) after a full stop,

would it make more sense to make cyclists to yield always and not cars?

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by blululu on Thursday February 08, 2024 @11:51AM (#39304245)
I see cars in the city roll through stop signs all the time, but I never heard of a bicyclist killing someone while blasting through a stop sign. The difference between bicycles and cars is based on the potential for harm.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by yuliyp on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:03AM (#39298798)
Failure to yield is a separate question from should they be required to stop if nobody is present.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:49AM (#39298714)
> because coming to a full stop at a stop sign makes no sense for riders with high visibility.

For anyone wondering why I give an explanation here[0]. The tldr is you need to move to be safe and it is harder to get a bike moving than it is a car. It's best to contextualize any such arguments around the operations that go into operating the vehicle and cars and bikes have a lot of differences. Those differences are why cars are more popular (Sure, more energy but motor vs legs. If you want to make the argument that it is easier for a bike you better not get frustrated when a bike is slow to get to speed when you're behind them at a stoplight or stop-sign).

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39298376

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by resolutebat on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:01AM (#39299118)
The comment you link to has been flagged.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:43AM (#39299727)
Thanks for the notice, I'm not too concerned though. I didn't violate any rules. People must be upset that I made an argument that it can be safer to not come to a full and complete stop. But I'm not making the argument that it is safe to blindly blow throw an intersection either. Given the comments I'm seeing, it appears that it is difficult to differentiate these two things.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by alvah on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:33AM (#39299339)
California roll != failure to yield. I swear some in here would argue water isn’t wet and the sky isn’t blue…
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by 7e on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:46AM (#39298697)
It's simple selfishness. Cyclists don't want to lose their momentum. Coasting is fun and exertion is not; humans evolved to minimize their energy expenditure. To fix that, you'd need to redesign the bicycle to be completely battery powered. Even then, acceleration will be slower than not stopping. Cyclists will try to rationalize their behavior in all kinds of ways, but they're just lying to themselves (and you).
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by nativeit on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:02AM (#39298788)
Not like the altruistic endeavor that is driving a car in a dense urban environment. Those are the real heroes.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by 0xfaded on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:03AM (#39298797)
The fix is really quite simple, develop separate routes for cyclists and motor vehicles. Where those routes unavoidably cross have proper intersections. The person you are replying to is right, four-way-stops are a travesty, both for cyclists and cars.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by manualdriver3 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:25AM (#39298907)
Incorporating manual vehicle operation into the driving test could significantly alter driving habits, a change I've personally experienced after learning to drive a manual as an adult. As GP notes, the desire to conserve energy and avoid stopping and then starting again is common among cyclists, and this principle applies to manual vehicles as well. Having been raised in the U.S., I understand the potential chaos of having no stop signs or traffic lights at busy four-way intersections. However, this system functions effectively in major cities globally, where drivers, perhaps more accustomed to manual vehicles, approach and navigate intersections with greater awareness and negotiation skills.

I believe that mandating manual driving lessons for all learners could foster improved driving behaviors and heightened road awareness. This approach could encourage drivers to be more attentive and considerate of other road users, enhancing overall safety and efficiency on the roads.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by 7e on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:09AM (#39298831)
Sure, have fewer stops. But even if you separate the routes, cyclists will eventually have to stop somewhere (even for other cyclists), and they won’t want to.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by armada651 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:08AM (#39299170)
You'll see a lot more cyclists acting safely if it's actually safe to cycle. Dangerous cycling infrastructure scares away safe cyclists, so all you're left with are the daredevils who won't stop for anything.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by 7e on Thursday February 08, 2024 @08:11AM (#39301532)
It's actually more tha bikes don't have license plates, and aren't pulled over and ticketed by cops. The anonymity drives lawlessness.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:55AM (#39298746)
> It's simple selfishness.

This is a weird characterization of what's going on given you have an apt description. I've only been struck by cars (twice) when stopped at a stop sign. It's no question that an intersection is one of the most dangerous locations for a cyclist and it is also no question that an intersection can be cleared significantly faster when starting with __any__ amount of momentum vs a complete stop. Specifics will be necessary for making adequate conclusions here. Someone blindly blowing through an intersection certainly clears the intersection faster but that alone doesn't mean the behavior is appropriate or any less idiotic. And someone doing that is very different from someone slowing down and treating the stop sign like a yield sign. An over generalization is just going to lead to irrational conclusions because context is necessary.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by philistine on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:04AM (#39298805)
Don't give them the time of day. I never understood why cyclists acted the way they act until I started commuting to work. I felt unsafe at intersections when stopped. I felt unsafe at intersections when starting slowly. I read online about some road rules making my trips more dangerous for ME, not the cars. Now I know what I can do that's totally illegal that's keeping me safer.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by 7e on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:10AM (#39298836)
Cycling is dangerous when mixed with cars, for sure. But blazing through at an intersection full of cars which are expecting you to stop is even more dangerous. Stop sign rules exist for a reason (to slow vehicles down enough that everyone can see and negotiate everyone else) and it's safer for all if you obey them. This is an example of the rationalization I alluded to earlier. Cyclists lie to themselves.

Next you will be telling me that changing lanes without signaling or looking, swerving through traffic, ignoring stop signs on bike paths, riding while looking at one's phone, riding the wrong way, riding without a helmet, or at night without lights (all of which I observe all the time from cyclists) are evolved safety behaviors.

This is not to excuse drivers, who do lazy and selfish things all the time, like looking at their phones. The root cause is the same--human nature. It just so happens that the incentives are worse when cycling.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by armada651 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:45AM (#39299015)
> Next you will be telling me that changing lanes without signaling or looking, swerving through traffic, ignoring stop signs on bike paths, riding while looking at one's phone, riding the wrong way, riding without a helmet, or at night without lights (all of which I observe all the time from cyclists) are evolved safety behaviors.

You've just described the average cyclist in Amsterdam. They'll do all of that at the same time with a passenger sitting on the rear baggage carrier.

Yet the Netherlands has one of the lowest mortality rates per mile cycled and the US has one of the highest. Despite the US having very strict full stop laws for cyclists.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by 7e on Thursday February 08, 2024 @08:23AM (#39301627)
28% of vehicle fatalities in Amsterdam are cycling related. Deaths do happen. If you’re arguing that these behaviors are, in fact, safe, I would disagree strongly. The U.S. drives large trucks at high speeds because the U.S. isn't very dense, even in cities, and car centric. And bike infrastructure is lacking. I agree, making cycling safer makes cyclists safer. But none of this explains why cyclists bike like a*holes in every country, which is the point I was making. In addition to the physics of bikes encouraging selfish behavior, there is the lack of license plates and ticketing.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by armada651 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @10:20AM (#39302926)
> 28% of vehicle fatalities in Amsterdam are cycling related. Deaths do happen.

Of course, none of those behaviors are safe. And mandating lights, a helmet, high visibility jacket, kneepad protectors and a license plate would make a cyclist safer. (And lights are mandatory even in Amsterdam)

But it would also discourage people from cycling by making that mode of transportation even more inconvenient than it already is compared to the car. And so because, as you noted, humans seek convenience; they will take the car instead.

> But none of this explains why cyclists bike like a*holes in every country, which is the point I was making.

Again it's self-selecting, since there is no bike infrastructure and you ride in between large trucks you have to be very assertive in traffic. Which tends to select for the more stand-offish types.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:04AM (#39298426)
> I live adjacent to a four-way stop and there's an incident where a cyclist fails to yield nearly hourly.

When I see systematic things like this I often get suspicious and think there is something more going on (or selection bias. We are human). I think the common model is attributing actions to reckless behavior and people not thinking. This very well may be true! But if people are consistently engaging in a specific behavior (reckless or not) there's usually a reason to it. Reason doesn't mean good reason btw, and it can be as dumb as the previous chimps getting hosed every time they try to get the banana, but that's still a reason. I think if the underlying reason can be found it significantly increases the chances of rectifying the situation.

> Until more evidence comes out I'll be taking Waymo's side here.

Until more evidence I'm holding out on taking a side. I think Waymo's safety record is orthogonal to the conversation as with the general safety record of driverless cars (which I am a big fan of fwiw).

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:27AM (#39298583)
Even with a cyclist disregarding the law, it shouldn't be possible for a law abiding autonomous vehicle to collide with anything if it had confirmed the intersection was clear of traffic. Seems like it assumes an unoccupied slot behind trucks that won't always be true. What if this was a T-intersection where a cyclist wasn't obligated to stop?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by klyrs on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:06AM (#39298816)
Ah, but people yelled because waymo was too timid. They probably did that because it's how people are expected to drive in California. Bit of a sticky wicket for waymo isn't it?

I tried this line of reasoning with a judge once. If you break the law just because people expect you to, it's still your traffic violation.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by midtake on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:25AM (#39298573)
Because stopping with 4000-lb cars lined up behind you is safer?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by operatingthetan on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:37AM (#39298655)
>I live adjacent to a four-way stop and there's an incident where a cyclist fails to yield nearly hourly.

You should try paying attention to the cars. I live near one (elsewhere) as well and I see cars driving straight through it all the time. Why have a double standard?

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by seanmcdirmid on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:41AM (#39298673)
I think all of us agree that cars shouldn’t blow through intersections, neither should bicycles. It definitely raises my eyebrows more if cars do it (rare but sadly increasingly less rare) vs if bicycles do get it (fairly common).
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by DeRock on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:49AM (#39298715)
> It definitely raises my eyebrows more if cars do it (rare but sadly increasingly less rare)

It is extremely common, the default really, for cars to roll through 4-way stops.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by seanmcdirmid on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:08AM (#39298822)
Maybe where you live? It isn’t as common here in Seattle, although as I said it is definitely becoming less rare.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by cma on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:02AM (#39298786)
A rolling stop is not blowing through which he was talking about I think.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by esoterica on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:51AM (#39299059)
When cars do a “rolling stop” what they are really doing is slowing down to 10-15mph, which is the same speed as a cyclist “blowing” through a stop sign at full speed.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by seanmcdirmid on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:30PM (#39306428)
I live in Seattle, so you’ll see bikes mostly blow through stop signs going down a decline, they can faster than 10-15 even without e-assist. Cars, when they do ignore the stop sign, can be going up or down, however. If I see a bike going downhill approaching a stop sign, I assume they are going to try and ignore it if it won’t obviously get them killed. Uphill, bikes care more about stopping since they aren’t losing momentum.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by rahimnathwani on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:41AM (#39298674)
> Cyclists have a bad rep in SF because many (not all) ride quite dangerously. It's a common sight to see cyclists running four-way stop signs and lights without even yielding.

Pick any stop sign in SF. Watch it for an hour and count the number of cars that come to a complete stop. The denominator doesn't matter because the numerator will be ~0.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by anon373839 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:53AM (#39298738)
> count the number of cars that come to a complete stop

You’re conflating two different phenomena, perhaps purposefully.

California drivers do often fail to come to a technical stop at intersections, but they first slow to a near-zero speed that very nearly accomplishes the same purpose.

In contrast, a large number of cyclists do not slow at all, and blast through red lights at full speed.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by rahimnathwani on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:09AM (#39298830)
I've lived in San Francisco for over 4 years. I cycle, walk, drive, and take public transport. If I were about to cross at an intersection with a stop sign, the sight of an approaching car would create more fear and caution in me, than would the sight of an approaching bicycle.

> California drivers do often fail to come to a technical stop at intersections, but they first slow to a near-zero speed that very nearly accomplishes the same purpose.

It very nearly accomplishes the same purpose only from the point of view of other drivers. When a driver in SF approaches an intersection, they're looking out for other cars, working out whether they'll be able to slow down and continue, or they'll need to stop. If they don't see another car that will have priority, they won't stop. So:

- they may not see the pedestrian that's just reached the intersection, and/or

- the pedestrian that's just reached the intersection won't know whether the car is going to stop, so they won't attempt to cross

When I drive, I'm sometimes frustrated when I stop at an intersection, wait for a pedestrian to start crossing, and they're slow to get started. Then I remember it's the behavior of drivers that has conditioned pedestrians to yield even when they have right of way.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:06AM (#39299160)
> Then I remember it's the behavior of drivers that has conditioned pedestrians to yield even when they have right of way.

I similarly have mixed mode of transportation. I'll admit that when walking I will frequently fully stop in the middle of crossing an intersection. Many people do come to abrupt stops at stop signs and from the perspective of a pedestrian it is difficult to differentiate, especially when it is unclear that a driver sees you. I sure am not going to risk it, so I stop, and am sure to make sure that driver sees me. But similarly, it makes me more sympathetic to pedestrians and cyclists and I will approach intersections differently when they are around and do my best to make sure they know I see them. When driving, walking, and cycling you are operating in very different environments despite being in the same place. People tend to do things for reasons and if an action is common within a group it would be naive to not consider why this behavior develops.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by azinman2 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:20AM (#39298883)
> If they don't see another car that will have priority, they won't stop.

There's a difference between stop and slow down. There are some people who barely slow down and that's totally illegal and blatantly bad. It's also a minority of the time. Most people do significantly slow if not stop at intersections, regardless if there's another car with the right of way or not.

This is a big mischaracterization. That said, I do see cyclists blowing through stop signs ALL THE TIME, often totally dangerously with other cars (including me) at the intersection with them.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by rahimnathwani on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:27AM (#39298918)
> There's a difference between stop and slow down.

Yes, that's exactly my point!

Going 2mph through a stop sign is materially different from stopping at the line. When you stop, you can confirm that the intersection is clear (and that there are no pedestrians about to cross).

> It's also a minority of the time.

If you had to guess, what would you say is the median speed of cars across the lines at stop signs in SF?

> That said, I do see cyclists blowing through stop signs ALL THE TIME, often totally dangerously with other cars (including me) at the intersection with them.

I guess we drive in different parts of the city. I see this, but not often.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by azinman2 on Friday February 09, 2024 @01:52PM (#39318753)
I’d say the median speed is 0, since probably a majority of the time there are other cars.

I see bikes blowing through all over the city, not just where I live. Just yesterday I was in the Richmond and a bike not only didn’t stop but it was AFTER I was fully stopped at the stop sign and about to start driving.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:04AM (#39298803)
You're restating their point but I don't think you get it. "a large number" is a vague term and I think we would be apt to say "a large number of cars run stop signs." The big issue at hand is selection and perceptual biases. If we're just going on intuition here we're going to make bad decisions. You will not notice the "large number of" cyclists that have appropriate behavior because this will be normal behavior that is non-disruptive and your brain is designed to not take special notice of this. But your brain is designed to take special notice of rare and/or disruptive events. So you always over inflate those numbers and it is hard to accurately quantify. See "Perceptual vigilance" for more.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by iknowstuff on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:03AM (#39298796)
The full speed being, of course, about the speed of a car doing a california roll.

Google “cyclist stop sign safety”

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:07AM (#39298820)
> In 1982, Idaho was the first State to pass such a law, commonly known as the “Idaho Stop Law.” The law allows bicyclists to yield at stop signs and proceed when safe, rather than come to a complete stop. After Idaho adopted the law, bicyclist injuries from traffic crashes declined by 14.5% the following year (Meggs, 2010). In 2017, Delaware adopted a similar, limited stop-as-yield law, known as the "Delaware Yield.” Traffic crashes involving bicyclists at stop sign intersections fell by 23% in the 30 months after the law’s passage, compared to the previous 30 months.

https://www.nhtsa.gov/sites/nhtsa.gov/files/2023-03/Bicyclis...

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by dang on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:58AM (#39299098)
Please let's not do the bikes vs. cars flamewar all over again. It's surprisingly nasty and always the same.

We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39298127.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ehsankia on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:45PM (#39298287)
I think more impressively, even in this seemingly worst case scenario where everything lined up as poorly as it could have, the car was still able to react quite aggressively and the situation ended only with minor scratches it seems?

Honestly, if anything, this is probably proof that self-driving is the future, as I would bet any human would've most definitely done much worse in the same scenario.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by gnicholas on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:25AM (#39298909)
I wonder if a human driver would have (for better or worse) swerved to avoid hitting the cyclist. That is, the Waymo might be programmed to only execute certain types of evasive maneuvers, whereas a human would instinctively do other things as well. Of course, if there were someone in the vehicle's blind spot, it's possible this would have resulted in a worse accident, since there would have been no time for a human driver to double check.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by shadowgovt on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:01AM (#39299123)
Broadly speaking (and this is a very broad brush, details may differ), autonomous vehicles will resolve collision avoidance by doing something legal.

Swerving is not legal and it's not legal because you might hit something you can't see. On the other hand, an autonomous vehicle maintains perpetual 360° situational awareness so it already knows whether it's safe to swerve.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by lozenge on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:11AM (#39299532)
Can you provide a source that swerving to prevent a collision is not legal?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by gnicholas on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:34PM (#39304883)
> Swerving is not legal and it's not legal because you might hit something you can't see.

If I'm driving down the road and someone pushes a kid in front of my car, I'm very likely to swerve, even if I'm not 100% sure if there is someone next to me. If I hit a car next to me and cause damage/injure people, there is a good chance that a jury would find in my favor because a "reasonable person" (the relevant legal standard in a civil case) would seek to avoid the certain death of a faultless child, even if it means a chance of injury to passengers in a vehicle that might be nearby. I wouldn't swerve if I thought a bicyclist were there, but I would likely swerve into a vehicle, which affords occupants significant protection.

And I certainly would not be found guilty of a crime ("beyond a reasonable doubt", the standard in a criminal trial) because it is not criminally negligent to swerve when faced with the certainty of killing a child. Under the "defense of self/others" doctrine, you can do many things that would normally be illegal, if you are doing them to prevent the imminent death of yourself or someone else. (These analyses are not super detailed, but IAAL.)

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by shadowgovt on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:16PM (#39305462)
AVs aren't doing near enough calculus to make a decision like that; they have obstacles and they avoid them. Their avoidance can allow for lane departure (that 360 situational awareness is handy), but they aren't going to solve a trolley problem in realtime if boxed in.

The thing is... Neither are people. A kid darts out on front of you and you won't have time to make a conscious decision. The maneuver you make will be too fast for rational thought, and your brain will explain to itself why it did that later.

... Incidentally, this is one of the things that scares me about human drivers. Put a human on the stand to testify and most will say they never saw that kid, no matter what physical process happened to their eyes and neurons. I think most even actually believe it.

In any case, I'm glad that in this incident they'll be able to do a full NHTSA workup, pull logs, and reprogram the machine to avoid an accident like this in the future. Can't do that to a human driver.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by petre on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:32AM (#39298945)
In a recent accident that happened in my country, a human driver swerved to avoid a cyclist that was quickly switching lanes without signaling in order to cross from one side to another. The swerving car went over the sidewalk and killed a pedestrian. You should draw your own conclusions.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by viraptor on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:46AM (#39299021)
This is my pet peeve with people being so sure online about their abilities of avoiding things on the road. Yeah, maybe you could avoid it with your super human reflexes, but there physically no way you could check that side of your car, register what's there, decide whether you can move that way and then did it. The kneejerk avoidance reaction may be extremely dangerous on its own.

(Also in Oz, rolling your car when you try to swerve to avoid a kangaroo is so common that you're normally taught to just break instead)

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by panopticon on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:57AM (#39299090)
I swerved into another lane to avoid another car cutting me off during rush hour once. It all happened so fast, and I will always remember how incredibly lucky I was that no one was in the lane I moved into.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by cgriswald on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:53AM (#39300166)
Do people really not mentally track the vehicles around them? I remember in driver’s ed even before we were behind the wheel to have “exit strategies” for situations exactly like this. Cars don’t just appear magically next to you.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by viraptor on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:20AM (#39300320)
> Cars don’t just appear magically next to you.

They don't, but: 1. Your perception is not perfect. 2. A truck passing you means there was a blind spot and you have no idea what was there. 3. There are areas with many lanes merging / splitting, where it takes most of your attention to know where you're going; little left to track everything around.

Tracking your surrounding is great. Accepting that you're going to make mistakes, adjusting for that and also allowing assistive tech is even better.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by gnicholas on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:26PM (#39304762)
People try to, but are imperfect at doing so. For example, most people do not closely track what is happening 2 lanes away. But someone can move from your blind spot 2 lanes away into your blind spot right next to you.

Also, if something potentially dangerous/important is happening to your left, you will focus your attention there and not be aware of things happening to your right, even if you normally would have seen those things had you been looking straight ahead.

I try to know what is going on around me, for the reason you describe (exit strategies), but I'm aware that sometimes I simply do not know what is to my left — and would not want to swerve there.

Having seen friends driving Teslas, I can see how the surround-view could be useful for situations like this. However, I have also seen that cars appear/vanish for no reason, and it is clearly not reliable at this point.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zx8080 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:26AM (#39298914)
Thare's a, probably not very obvious, situation when human could have no such accident in the same scenario. At all. Preventing an accident does not leave any trace. No one knows about the scenario if there's no accident.

How many similar (and others) accidents are being prevented by human drivers daily, and no one knows about them, at all? We just don't know.

That's why I take any stats of "human vs AI" driving with a grain of salt.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by bluecalm on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:10AM (#39299530)
On the other hand there are many human drivers who will endanger cyclists on purpose because they either don't like them or are inconsiderable aaaholes in general and engage in dangerous behaviours like speeding, overtaking when there is incoming traffic from that other direction (cause they think it's safe to squeeze in as cyclists are small) or not paying attention to right of way signs.

Speeding alone is a huge problem. I would take self driving cars even if far from perfect just because of it. It will be safer if they don't speed even if they sometimes randomly drive into other vehicles. Everything is secondary when it comes to safety. It really is obvious when you move from a place where people don't respect speed limits to one where they do. I think not speeding solves 95%+ of serious safety problems.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by CityOfThrowaway on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:42AM (#39299004)
We can compare this statistically by looking at accidents per 1,000,000 miles driven of autonomous cars vs humans. Over long mileage, the rate of prevented accidents shows up in the data as a lower overall accident rate.

I don't have the stats at hand but Waymo does great on this stat.

Now, that's not to say that Waymo would avoid any specific accident better than a human. But from a public health standpoint, that's not really the right way to think about it anyways.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by talldatethrow on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:53AM (#39299071)
IMO these are a slightly fake stat. You're comparing to overall stats, that include the drunk, the high, the sleep deprived, and the crazy wild aggressive wreckless.

If you compare to my mother driving, the injuries per mile are higher in autonomous.

You can argue that I'm making an unfair distinction since those people exist, but I'd say the people driving under those conditions are commiting a crime and shouldn't be counted the same.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by resolutebat on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:59AM (#39299104)
You're making a classic is-ought fallacy here. Drunk, high, sleep deprived or "crazy wild aggressive reckless" human drivers ought not to exist, but they do, and thus it's absolutely fair to compared autonomous drivers against them.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by eurleif on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:19AM (#39299251)
If GP's mother switches from driving for herself to having Waymo drive for her, her risk of injury will increase. Therefore, if her goal is to avoid injury, it would be counterproductive for her to make that switch. That conclusion does not require any is-ought fallacy.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by hot_gril on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:06AM (#39299509)
Exactly. I know that my odds are different from the average.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by resolutebat on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:32AM (#39299657)
So are you one of the 88% who know they are better than average, or one of the 12% who are worse?

https://www.smithlawco.com/blog/2017/december/do-most-driver...

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by eurleif on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:38AM (#39299690)
>Obviously, not everyone can be above average. Exactly half of all drivers have to be in the bottom half when it comes to driving skills and safety.

This page is confused about the difference between mean and median. The 88% of drivers who think they are above average are not necessarily correct, but there would be nothing logically inconsistent about them being correct.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by dns_snek on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:50AM (#39300147)
This has nothing to do with being "a better driver" than average. If you simply don't drive while intoxicated, extremely tired, or distracted with your gadgets, you're already beating the average when it comes to collisions and injuries.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by pooper on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:29AM (#39300374)
> If you simply don't drive while intoxicated, extremely tired, or distracted with your gadgets, you're already beating the average when it comes to collisions and injuries.

It still does not make you a good driver. I've personally been in situations where I'm on the right lane, going slightly below the speed limit, when the vehicle (usually a pickup truck) passes me from the shoulder on the right, often blaring it's horns in disapproval as if they were on their way to save lives.

> Rules for Using the Shoulder. The laws for using a shoulder vary in each state, but it is illegal in all states to use the shoulder to bypass traffic or to pass another driver.

I can't wait to make it illegal for humans to drive on public roads.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by hot_gril on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:34PM (#39304881)
It's mostly that. I don't think I'm more skilled or something. Also, using a smartphone while driving is illegal, but somehow using a 17" touchscreen that mirrors your smartphone and shows incoming texts is OK and common in newer cars.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by lupusreal on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:52AM (#39300509)
Being better than average is easy because the average is dragged down by people who drive drunk/tired/etc. An average safety robocar would be a downgrade for most responsible people.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by hot_gril on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:37PM (#39304915)
Yeah, I have 0 accidents, so nobody is going to convince me the AI is safer. Meanwhile my car's ESC has tried to send me off a cliff before.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by concordDance on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:31AM (#39299650)
That may be true, but I expect there's no scalable way to assess drivers for GGP mother-ness. So for public policy purposes we should encourage and allow self driving. And possibly even ban manual driving if we can't distinguish GGP mothers from poor drivers.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by TeMPOraL on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:53AM (#39300160)
All self driving > Reckless drivers only self-driving > current situation > small random population only self-driving > GGPs-mom-likes only self-driving.

Unfortunately, identifying people like GGP's mother and excluding them from requirement for self-driving is prohibitively expensive (and icky in all kinds of ways), and so would be predicting reckless driving behavior (approximately every driver is reckless at some point anyway, GGP's mom included). So it's all self-driving or no self-driving, and all self-driving is strictly better for all of us, even if GGP's mom has to briefly accept slightly elevated risk.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by mh- on Thursday February 08, 2024 @11:42AM (#39304130)
> identifying people like GGP's mother and excluding them from requirement for self-driving is prohibitively expensive (and icky in all kinds of ways)

Not sure I follow the thinking here. We already have ability tests in driver's license exams.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by TeMPOraL on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:22AM (#39312652)
Yes, and every mad or reckless driver passed them with flying colors, kind of by definition, otherwise we'd be talking about drivers illegally operating road vehicles. Approximately all traffic accidents involving drivers is involving drivers with valid license, who passed ability tests.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by eurleif on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:35PM (#39321336)
A simple Google search reveals that the number of accidents caused by unlicensed drivers is ~20%, not ~0%: https://usclaims.com/educational-resources/non-licensed-driv...

Moreover, the requirement to receive a license is only to pass, not to pass "with flying colors".

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by shadowgovt on Friday February 09, 2024 @09:15AM (#39315048)
Those tests are dangerously insufficient to keep unsafe drivers off the road.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by QuadmasterXLII on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:35AM (#39302361)
If your mother is a decent driver, then almost all the danger she faces while driving comes from other people being shitty.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by scott_w on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:59AM (#39299831)
Others have made better points but I want to add another thing to point out you can also be making the same "is-ought" mistake yourself:

Impaired drivers (drink, drugs, sleep), bad drivers, dangerous drivers, etc. who ought to use the self-driving function are exactly the kinds of people who won't and continue to drive badly.

What this means is the safer drivers leave it off (because they outperform the system), while dangerous drivers also leave it off because they mistakenly believe they outperform the system. The traits that it's meant to protect people from are the very traits that ensure it can't do its job.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by pooper on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:30AM (#39300380)
When it is good enough, we should remove the ability for humans to drive cars manually in all new cars after that point.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by shadowgovt on Friday February 09, 2024 @09:18AM (#39315071)
Or even migrate the testing schema to more frequent re-checks and a harder pass condition.

If people don't have to drive to thrive in society, we can make driving far more of a privilege. Contrast what a private pilot has to do to get certified.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by kaba0 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:32AM (#39299331)
In no possible future would we see an immediate change from human drivers to 100% self-driving, so self-driving ought to co-exist with human drivers, both the better than average, and the drunk ones.

I’m absolutely not convinced that an AI would fair better at handling a drunk driver’s driving style compared to a competent human. The statistics help AI due to them being good at handling monotony, but that doesn’t necessarily translate to safety in complex situations.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by hot_gril on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:10AM (#39299528)
In a few places, driving too passively (as AI cars seem to do) will cause aggressive drivers to create dangerous situations for you. They don't want to be stuck behind someone who's letting people in. I also wonder if the AI cars go the speed limit on freeways, cause sometimes that's worse than matching traffic that's speeding a bit.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by cm2187 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:58AM (#39299825)
But your mother is still better off with the drunks not driving (they may crash into her car). So she may still have less accidents in a world where everyone goes self driving.

This will still leave us with the random and dangerous behaviours of cyclists and motorcycles though.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:19AM (#39299250)
You're in the write direction but I think you don't have the right words to describe what you're trying to describe. I made a sister comment, but if I correctly understand you, then it would be more accurate to say that the averaged statistic removes important variables for making accurate conclusions. We need not look at your mother, but we can consider different environments. I think most of us would say it would be silly to compare accidents on the highway to accidents to those in an urban street, but an "average by mile" is doing precisely this. We'd call this "marginalization" and it is why you should be suspicious when anyone discusses averages (or medians!). (On that note, the median and average are always within one standard deviation of another. It's useful because if you have both and they are far apart you know there's a lot of variance). I hope I accurately understood you and can help make a clearer message.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by littlestymaar on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:31AM (#39299326)
> why you should be suspicious when anyone discusses averages

I like to say that the average human being has one testicle and half a vagina, which is not very representative of anyone around.

> On that note, the median and average are always within one standard deviation of another

Oh really? That's cool.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:40AM (#39299709)
Haha yeah that is accurate. The right language is situational though haha. People are generally overconfident in their ability to mathematically describe things. There's a clique "all models are wrong" and like all cliques it is something everyone can repeat but not internalize lol
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by agos on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:36AM (#39300041)
you should not forget the second part: all models are wrong, some are useful
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by littlestymaar on Thursday February 08, 2024 @06:21AM (#39300683)
Yes, but unfortunately the second part is usually employed by people who want to put under the rug the fact that their model is dubious.

All models are wrong, only some of them are useful, and only when handled with care.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:05PM (#39305310)
The second part is the obvious part that often doesn't need restating. Models can be incredibly powerful tools.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by dxbydt on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:14AM (#39302128)
> It's useful because if you have both and they are far apart you know there's a lot of variance

ummm. I would refrain from using nonparametric skew to make a comment about the magnitude of variance.

Essentially, the gap between mean and median will always be bounded by 1 sigma. The ratio abs(mean-median)/sigma is nonparametric skew. It is atmost 1, for any distribution( hence nonparametric, no distributional assumption required).

For unimodal distributions, especially symmetric unimodals, this ratio is 0. As the gap between the mean and median grows, the data gets more spread out, and the ratio captures that spread and consequent nonsymmetry. But you are using the value of this upper bound to make a comment about s^2. Which is very clever, but inaccurate. Say you standardize the rv and you have a nonsymmetric dist. Then mean 0, say median 100. Then stdev can be atmost 100, so variance can be atmost 10000. Which looks like “a lot of variance”. But is it really? Variance has a scaling problem, precisely why we take the square root, so the stdev remains in the scale of the mean. So at best one can say the stdev can be as big as the median. But that’s not very informative- because if the mean is -50 and median is +50, we are left with the same absolute gap of 100, so the same statement applies to the stdev even now.

I guess if I had to compare the variance of some sample X to another sample Y to make some claim that variance of X is much larger than Y, I would use a standard F test. Cooking up a test based on the gap between mean and median in a single sample seems somewhat shaky. It is very creative though, I grant you that.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:58PM (#39307594)
Perhaps I gave the statement too much strength, far more than intended. But I don't view any metric as anything more than a guide. The reason I use parametric skew in this way is explicitly for a quick and dirty interpretation of the data. Essentially trying to understand if I should take someone's data at face value or not. It's about being a flag. The reason is because when going about the world in an every day fashion I am generally not going to have access to other data like variance (which if we did, we wouldn't need this hack) and can't really do an F-test on the fly. Usually you're presented with the mean and it can still be hard to find a median but it is usually more obtainable than the variance or any other information. So I get your concern and I think you are right for bringing it up because how I stated things could clearly be mistaken (I'll admit to that) but wanted to assure you that no strong decisions were being made using this. I only use it as a sniff test. I do think it helps to give people a bunch of different sniff tests because it is hard for us to navigate data and if you're this well versed I'm sure you have a similar frustration in how difficult it can be to make informed decisions. So what tools do we have to can set off red flags and help us not be deceived by those who wish to just throw numbers at us and say that this is the answer?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by darkwater on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:02AM (#39299124)
But one of the points of self-driving cars is to remove those bad drivers from the driving seat.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by xorcist on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:58AM (#39299467)
I have never once heard self-driving cars sold with the argument "they're great for sleep deprived and alcoholics".

Maybe they should be.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by willvarfar on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:24AM (#39299609)
I have always wanted a self-driving car so there's no more "designated driver" hassle with going out.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by cm2187 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:48AM (#39299768)
Same, there are few places I go to I may not come back drunk!

This, and freeing up the streets from parked cars. If cars are self driving they can go park themselves into some big, far away car parks instead of clogging the streets. In europe it can easily multiply by 2 or 3 the throughput of most big cities.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by lupusreal on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:55AM (#39300528)
"Going out" is synonymous with drinking? You could just... not drink.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by willvarfar on Thursday February 08, 2024 @08:25AM (#39301646)
There's a cultural dimension.

In general south europe culture it is normal to drink wine to food, and enjoy it, but also embarrassing to get publically drunk.

Whereas in northern europe, though, it's all beer or spirits and the aim is to get as drunk as possible as quickly as possible.

These generalisations are based on my own observations. There's doubtless a lot of variation.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by kaba0 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:33AM (#39299341)
How? There will be multiple decades of self-driving — human driver co-existence. I’m not convinced that this phase would be safer than the human-only one, as AI might very well handle bad human drivers much worse (as it is an edge case).
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by littlestymaar on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:19AM (#39299254)
Maybe in theory, but then you have a bigger social/psychological/economic problem because these populations are necessarily the ones that are going to be compatible with the business model for autonomous cars.

And if you get a bigger proportion of “good drivers” in autonomous cars than there is in the overall population, you're on fact increasing the overall number of accidents.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by darkwater on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:07AM (#39300241)
I agree that a very probable outcome is that the real bad drivers will, for one reason or another, keep using non-self-driving cars way longer than good drivers. But also a good self-driving car should have faster reflexes than a good human driver, so it might mitigate anyway the damage done by a drunken driver.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by shadowgovt on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:59AM (#39299107)
Unfortunately, we can't replicate your mother and put her behind the wheel of every vehicle in America. But we can crank out thousands of autonomous vehicles with thousands of identical copies of highly tuned safety algorithms.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by talldatethrow on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:48AM (#39299410)
If you had a new born to take home from the hospital and were 20 miles from home.. would you take an autonomous car or have you or a family member drive you home?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by resolutebat on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:35AM (#39299679)
The closest I've come to killing another human was when I was driving to the hospital at night to pick up my wife & newborn, sleep-deprived and high on adrenaline, and came this >< close to taking out a cyclist I completely failed to see.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by fragmede on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:54AM (#39299445)
With emotions running high surrounding this newborn, me, or a family member, is likely to be stressed, under-slept, possibly drinking. Why wouldn't I want this hypothetical autonomous car to take us all home safely?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by talldatethrow on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:58AM (#39299468)
Because the math shows that currently it drives about as bad as a sometimes high, drunk, sleepy, angry person. If you had a family member that cared about you available to drive, they would be much safer than the typical ai car right now.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by concordDance on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:33AM (#39299665)
> Because the math shows that currently it drives about as bad as a sometimes high, drunk, sleepy, angry person.

This is surprising. Got a cite for that?

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by cycomanic on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:05AM (#39299152)
The problem will all of these stats (although some like Waymo are better than others like Tesla), is that the bare number is quite misleading because they compare apples to oranges. Firstly Waymo (and others don't often don't operate in places that they have excluded or they don't know. Humans drive in unfamiliar places (which I'd bet changes the chances of accidents). Moreover, waymo might decide to not operate in some places at all because they deem the traffic/road conditions to dangerous (and I think that's a good thing), however human accidents in those areas (which are by the condition are more accident prone) still go into those statistics.

It's similar for weather, self driving cars might refuse to operate in some weather conditions (I don't think it's by accident that most companies mainly operate in the relatively warm and sunny places of the US), human accidents under bad conditions are still part of the statistics.

And again drunk/impaired drivers also go into the statistics, if we disregard them and humans become safer, than this is not an argument that self driving is safer than humans, but an argument that there isn't enough enforcement around riving impaired.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by xorcist on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:01AM (#39299486)
That's terrible statistics. Let children drive and the self-driving cars would be, on average, even more safe!

Comparisons should be made 1) with the median, not the average, and 2) under the same conditions.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:13AM (#39299213)
> We can compare this statistically by looking at accidents per 1,000,000 miles driven of autonomous cars vs humans.

This is extremely limited and really not relevant to the topic at hand. You've marginalized out the type of accidents. Most miles driven are on highways and this is a different environment than urban. The information you've marginalized out is essential for making reasonable conclusions about safety. It isn't important to just know the ratio of TP/TN/FP/FN but more specifically where and when these errors happen. The nuance is critical to this type of discussion and a simplification can actually cause you to make poor decisions that are in the wrong direction rather than naive decisions but in the correct direction.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by resolutebat on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:37AM (#39299689)
I can guarantee you there are more accidents per 1,000,000 miles driven in dense urban areas, and that's where Waymo has been driving as well. Last I checked they're not even operating on freeways.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by disillusioned on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:27AM (#39300360)
I highly recommend reading through Waymo's own publications that addresses these exact concerns: https://waymo.com/safety/

Specifically "Framework for a conflict typology including causal factors for use in ADS safety evaluation" and "Comparison of Waymo Rider-Only Crash Data to Human Benchmarks at 7.1 Million Miles"

It may not surprise you to know that they have given a LOT of consideration to these factors and have built a complex model that addresses these to demonstrate their claims.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by belorn on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:59AM (#39300199)
If we are going to use flawed statistics of autonomous cars vs humans, we should first look at even better examples then waymo. Im pretty sure Mercedes Level 3 driving automation for the Autobahn is safer, as well as autonomous cars that park cars at airports. Their accidents per 1,000,000 miles should be 0, a statistic which is hard for humans to beat.

The more restricted and environment controlled we can make it, the few accidents we see machine controlled cars do, and the worse a adaptive human driver does in comparison (barring extreme situations).

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by dotancohen on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:53AM (#39300168)
The converse argument is that human drivers hit cyclists everyday, and we never hear about them because they are not unusual.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by qwertox on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:02AM (#39299127)
Yet it makes me wonder how the car would react if it came to a stop on top of the leg of the cyclist or in some situation where a normal driver would notice that he should get into the car again and back up a couple of feet.

I'm not against Waymo.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Mageek on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:01PM (#39310536)
My mom was hit by a driver when she was biking and fell with her arm in front of the wheel. The driver then decided to pull forward and drove over her arm. So humans don’t really solve that problem.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by smcl on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:54AM (#39299804)
Getting big "this is actually good for Bitcoin!" vibes from this. I don't think we can fairly assess who was at fault, given that none of us were there. But it is insane to just assume a manned vehicle would've been worse, and declare it a victory for driverless cars.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by dmix on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:48PM (#39298305)
The supervisor is up for election in SF so probably trying to sound important or useful.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by orange_county on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:05AM (#39298433)
No he's not. He's termed out.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by pb7 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:00AM (#39298394)
You must not live in SF if this is unexpected for you. SF supervisors are known morons that hate tech despite squandering billions in tax revenue from it on failed policies and deteriorating conditions. They can't even build a toilet for less than multiple millions and they have the nerve to criticize one of the most advanced technologies created in the last century. Very rich talking about safety as the person in charge of the second most dangerous district in SF.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:10AM (#39298472)
> You must not live in SF if this is unexpected for you.

OP didn't say surprised, they said disappointed. For example: I am not surprised that I burn my food because I left it in the oven too long, but I am disappointed that my food is ruined. Be careful not to conflate the two and impose beliefs on another person that they may or may not have. If you're talking politicians, I would say that such notions (pinning fictitious ideals to a person or group) are common tactics and this seems explicitly what you are upset about (as I think many are). So let's not engage in similar behavior, it only enables those tactics.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:57PM (#39298376)
It always amazes me how quick internet forums are to hate cyclists. We're talking about a person vs a one ton+ machine made of plastic and metal. There's always critiques about laws, but who does not similarly break laws when driving, walking, or whatever? Laws are also incomplete and anyone who has ever ridden a bike is probably quite aware of how often following laws would place one in substantial danger. (Not to mention that laws vary and most people don't know the laws) Bikes just aren't cars and they aren't motorcycles either.

I'll give a simple example that is quite common: not fully stopping at a stop sign. At first glance it seems quite reasonable to enforce stopping fully. But in practice this can actually be dangerous. In my personal experience, the only 2 times I've been hit by a vehicle were actually when I was stopped at a stop sign! On a bike momentum is your key to safety the same way it is often the case in a car. You have good stopping power but a lot of danger comes from behind. When stopped, you can't maneuver. When you can't maneuver, you are in danger. You are far slower to accelerate than cars, who are extremely upset by your presence and even more so when stuck behind you at a place such as a stop sign. Now I'm not advocating for someone to just blindly blow through a stop sign without looking, but coming to a complete stop with your feet on the ground and counting to 3 is not going to place you in the safest conditions. Not to mention that you will expend far more energy than were you to even just do a "california roll" because static friction is much higher than kinetic.

Realistically, people determine their actions from their experiences. There are definitely idiots and people doing stupid shit that does put them in danger, and I want to make it clear that this behavior is idiotic and reckless. I'll still have sympathy for a human being injured, but in the "stupid games, stupid prizes" kinda way. If you're advocating for the death of any human you should probably evaluate carefully. But there are many illegal and "illegal" things that people do because there's always exceptions to every rule, since rules are imprecise descriptions (including what I said in the previous sentence. I know you all can infer reasonable exceptions). Just make sure when evaluating situations like these you consider how the roads are not designed with non-car/truck traffic in mind and that this is often an afterthought. Also consider that The Bay is probably one of the most accommodating areas in the country for cyclists. And make sure that you aren't falling victim to selection bias. You probably don't even notice all the pedestrians and cyclists that are acting sanely, so are you accurately attributing qualities to the generalized group?

> I'm much more disappointed in the S.F. Supervisor quoted in the article, Shamann Walton

Same. Politicians especially should not be engaging in sensationalism. I recognize that they often do, but that does not mean I have to like it or support it. It muddies the waters and I want representatives to be doing their best to make the best city/country/environment they can for us. They are human too, but roles come with responsibilities. Muddying the waters just makes it harder for us to work together to make a better place for us all. So I fully agree with differentiating "us internet weenies" and "someone in charge of the city"

Edit: To be explicitly clear, I'm not saying cyclist right and Waymo wrong, nor am I saying Waymo right cyclist wrong. The article has very little information and I'd be a fool to make a conclusion in either way. I won't be surprised if the cyclist is in the wrong, nor would I be surprised if Waymo was (or the more likely some combination of both). I just intended to convey some extra information to consider when making these types of judgements as I think many judgements are made from the perspective of being in a car and experiencing idiotic cyclists. I will make one judgement though: if you are celebrating or rejoicing in the injury or death of a cyclist, you are not a good person. But this view isn't unique to "cyclists" and for me applies to humans. (I do believe there are reasons to kill people and that there are people that need to be killed, but celebration is not the right word to describe these situations)

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by TulliusCicero on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:33AM (#39298954)
I don't hate cyclists, I've used a bike as a primary form of transport for much of my life.

But especially in the US, dangerous behavior from cyclists seems to be proportionally much more common than dangerous behavior by Waymos. So yeah, it's easy to believe that a cyclist just kind of blew the stop sign when they shouldn't have.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:49AM (#39299774)
> behavior from cyclists seems to be proportionally much more common than dangerous behavior by Waymos

I'm not trying to take any position to this notion. I don't know the facts. I only know that not coming to a complete stop (different from blowing throw an intersection!) does not equate to dangerous behavior. You'll find another link that shows evidence otherwise. "Stop-as-yield" laws would be worth looking into if you're interested.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by TulliusCicero on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:01PM (#39318874)
I'm well aware of the Idaho stop, I'd advocated for it on many occasions.

However, I'm also aware that a lot of cyclists don't 'yield' so much as 'continue at full speed through the 4-way stop sign'.

So far, Waymo seems to have a culture of playing things very by the book and safely, or at least as safe as possible given the constraints of developing self-driving cars on public roads. I think it's very unlikely they'd lie, knowing that they'll have to hand over footage of the incident over to the authorities, and especially given what recently happened with Cruise semi-lying and being absolutely thrashed in the press because of it.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by repeekad on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:34AM (#39298636)
Based on waymos description, it seems pretty cut and dry that this was literally an “accident” where the biker maybe should have waited until the lane cleared and any car would have hit them in the same situation. If anything they can use this data to see how it maybe could be prevented in the future.

Maybe waymo was still in the wrong for some reason? Sadly the article that goes in depth after we have more details and can more clearly report if waymo is to blame will likely not get nearly as much traction as this headline.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by rob74 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:49AM (#39299042)
Maybe the accident could have been avoided completely if the Waymo car drove more defensively? The article doesn't mention how fast it was travelling before it applied the brakes, but maybe it would be better to drive extra slowly while it can't "see" to the left because of a truck when driving through an intersection? Or not proceed into the intersection at all before it has a clear field of view?

Of course there is also a balance between safety and practicality here. Above a certain level of traffic congestion, I assume even Waymo cars have to be a bit "assertive", otherwise they would wait for hours at a stop sign...

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by incompatible on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:43AM (#39299005)
I'd like to see a video. If a car is turning, it would presumably be travelling slowly, and wouldn't be trying to cut right behind a passing truck when there's no visibility.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by MobiusHorizons on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:11AM (#39299203)
I believe based on the description that no one was turning. The truck and the waymo vehicle were traveling parallel to one another, and the cyclist was at 90 degrees. If this is correct the “behind the truck” would mean occluded by the truck rather than following the rear of the truck. If that is true the cyclist and the waymo vehicle couldn’t see one another due to the truck, and both began entering the intersection. My guess is the cyclist was also unable to come to a stop when they saw the waymo vehicle. I think we would need to know a lot more to assign fault though.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by teekert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:10AM (#39298835)
I’m happy that in the Netherlands it’s ALWAYS the car driver’s responsibility (she always pays).
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Someone on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:54AM (#39299440)
It isn’t ALWAYS.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strict_liability#Bicycle–motor...

“In a nutshell, this means that, in a collision between a car and a cyclist, the driver is deemed to be liable to pay damages and his insurer (n.b. motor vehicle insurance is mandatory in the Netherlands, while cyclist insurance is not) must pay the full damages, as long as 1) the collision was unintentional (i.e. neither party, motorist or cyclist, intentionally crashed into the other), and 2) the cyclist was not in error in some way. Even if a cyclist made an error, as long as the collision was still unintentional, the motorist's insurance must still pay half of the damages. This does not apply if the cyclist is under 14 years of age, in which case the motorist must pay full damages for unintentional collisions with minors. If it can be proved that a cyclist intended to collide with the car, then the cyclist must pay the damages (or their parents in the case of a minor.).”

For more detail, see https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2013/02/21/strict-liabili...

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by flakes on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:30AM (#39298934)
I don't agree with most laws that impose absolutes. The courts exist to deal with grey areas.

A large number of pedestrians struck by cars each year (at least in North America), are themselves intoxicated, and not fit to walk along roadways. There are many cases where the driver should not reasonably be at fault for a pedestrians erratic behavior.

There's also the "hit-to-kill" phenomenon in China, where it can be financially devastating to leave a person living with significant injuries, but affordable if you had simply killed them (50K USD vs 1M over a lifetime). In extremely sad circumstances, this has motivated people to hit the victim multiple times.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by CalRobert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:09AM (#39299522)
A lot of pedestrians are kids, who by their nature are erratic. Saying that it's the kid's fault for getting hit because they were "erratic" is effectively banning children from walking places, which is exactly what the US has done ("WHy don't kids play outside anymore???")

The person operating the dangerous machinery where there could be people walking bears responsibility for not hitting people.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by flakes on Thursday February 08, 2024 @08:04AM (#39301462)
This is all true. As a driver, you are definitely expected to be aware at all times. Things like schoolzones enforce drivers being more aware and slowing even more. We have rules to not pass school buses when children are departing. We have speed limits that are lower in suburbs.

Even if you follow all of these rules, theres not too much you can do about someone suddenly staggering infront of your car. Obviously if you see them ahead of time, be even more cautious.

(also drunk people are in-part banned from roadways- public intoxication is a misdemeanor)

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by teekert on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:09PM (#39318970)
Sometimes it’s unavoidable, and then your insurance will take care of it as will the care system. You are responsible but you won’t pay, your obligatory insurance will.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by teekert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:34AM (#39298957)
You mean laws that forbid pedestrians from crossing roads? It’s just a matter of where you put your priorities. Here we prioritize our bike based transportation. Drivers just have to be careful, also insurance is obligatory so drivers don’t really feel it financially. They just pay collectively for all the other traffic participants they hit.

We have a very different system, nobody goes bankrupt from causing an accident or from healthcare related costs.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zilti on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:24AM (#39299285)
I am a cyclist myself, and let me tell you... cyclists are the fucking worst. Many of them drive so recklessly, like going full-speed through an intersection while their traffic light is red. There is just no way in many cases for a car driver to avoid hitting such idiots, no matter how much attention they pay. Neither cars nor bicycles can just stop on a whim, they need a couple meters to do so.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by teekert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:32AM (#39299338)
That is a US perspective. We don't have "cyclists" everybody uses a bike from time to time, our infrastructure is build for it [0], and when you get your driver’s license your learn how to deal with it.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynwMN3Z9Og8

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by lolc on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:06PM (#39305322)
I hate the thought of being restricted to that slow speed. But my look at the throughput!
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Symbiote on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:30AM (#39299642)
If there are intoxicated people around, or children, it's necessary to reduce driving speed.

That can mean moving at walking pace, or remaining stopped entirely, if you happen to be driving past a concert hall as everyone is leaving, for example.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by vlz on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:14AM (#39299221)
I call bullshit on "unfit to walk along roadways". This is victim blaming from people who want to go fast, fast, fast.

The one moving a ton of metal is the one to pay attention. And the US needs to build roadways actually usable by pedestrians.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zilti on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:22AM (#39299272)
Pay some fucking attention in traffic, even if you are on two feet instead of on wheels, for fuck's sake!
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by CalRobert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @07:22AM (#39301099)
Would you say this to bereaved parents?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zilti on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:53AM (#39302585)
Sure, yes.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by _dain_ on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:57AM (#39300187)
>A large number of pedestrians struck by cars each year (at least in North America), are themselves intoxicated, and not fit to walk along roadways. There are many cases where the driver should not reasonably be at fault for a pedestrians erratic behavior.

Excuse me? How can someone be unfit to just walk somewhere just because they're drunk? You don't need a license to walk!

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by CobrastanJorji on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:24PM (#39305537)
You don't need a license to go downhill skiing, but you still shouldn't do it while intoxicated.

But yes, if it is unsafe to walk home while drunk, that's an infrastructure and safety problem more than it is a failing of the drunk person.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zilti on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:21AM (#39299265)
No, that is absolute bullshit. So so often, it is obviously the reckless cyclist's fault.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by teekert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:34AM (#39299346)
That's a US perspective you have a car-first culture. If you have a bike first infrastructure you wouldn't talk like that. Here Bikes and cars are often even on different roads, where they need to cross, it's made very clear how that will work (traffic lights, clear lanes).
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by LtWorf on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:13AM (#39299545)
I mostly go on foot and… I'd go for a bicycle is always at fault law to be honest. Meek with cars and assholes with pedestrians is how cyclists mostly are.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by teekert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:55AM (#39299813)
You obviously are not from a culture where everybody is a cyclist. We have more bikes than cars in our country because you can use them at all ages and get to more places using a bike. My kids learned to ride a bike at 2.

We have some research [0], on average anybody over 6 rode a bike 232 times and an average of about 1000 km in 2022.

[0] https://www.cbs.nl/nl-nl/visualisaties/verkeer-en-vervoer/pe...

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by LtWorf on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:54AM (#39300519)
I'm from a culture where mountains exist. Geography isn't a culture.

Having said that. In Sweden this routinely happens:

To clear the bike and car paths from snow, a mountain is of snow is made over the pedestrian path, then INEVITABLY bicyclists angry ring at pedestrians all the time… because pedestrians should walk in 1 meter high piled up snow of course?

The same also happens if there is a digging in progress and there is a 2 meter hole… cyclists still expect pedestrians to jump down in a hole and then climb up.

However where there is no bicycle path, they will go on the side walk (which is not allowed).

Of course a good % of them actually have an electric engine and zoom around very fast.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by teekert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @08:23AM (#39301628)
You are an angry person. Most people are kind, something is not adding up here.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by LtWorf on Thursday February 08, 2024 @11:57AM (#39304318)
I am not angry until some person on the bicycle tells me to go to hellvete (hell, but it's more insulting in swedish than english) because I dared to walk on the cleared up bicycle path when there was no alternative.

After, I do tend get angry, yes.

You are probably just set in your own ways and refuse to internalize that there's more to the experience of the human race than your little bubble.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by teekert on Friday February 09, 2024 @04:54AM (#39313241)
He man we all know Klingons have anger management issues.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by LtWorf on Sunday February 11, 2024 @04:54PM (#39339148)
Victim blaming at its best.

Perhaps it's time to do some serious self evaluation.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zilti on Thursday February 08, 2024 @07:09AM (#39301008)
No, that is the perspective of a sane person. God damn it. I am European, and I - without a driver's license, so just a cyclist and pedestrian btw - have to deal with the behaviour of the entitled cycling shits every day, especially since I moved to Berlin. Occasionally also with pedestrians that just suddenly step onto the street without even looking. Surprisingly, the car drivers - even though they are assholes in Berlin, too - have been by far the most sane traffic participants to me so far.

I have seen quite a few situations with cyclists behaving so ridiculously recklessly that the only reason I can see is that they must have a death wish. But yeah, sure, blame the car for running into a cyclist who runs a red light over an intersection at full speed, suddenly appearing between two lanes of standing cars. Or for running into a cyclist driving on the left side of the road into an intersection without looking. Or blame me for running into a pedestrian who suddenly steps in front of me. Ah no, wait - you're a hardcore cycling apologete, I am sure the pedestrian would be at fault in this particular case, right?

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by teekert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @08:22AM (#39301619)
You have a perspective I don't recognize.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zilti on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:54AM (#39302602)
My sincere condolences. I hope there will one day be a treatment available for your condition, then.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zilti on Thursday February 08, 2024 @07:12AM (#39301031)
How often are you gonna copy-paste your arrogant nonsense?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by hot_gril on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:56AM (#39299089)
Maybe "so much for safety" refers to the cyclist turning left without looking.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by SllX on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:16AM (#39299233)
I appreciate your optimism.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by apapapa on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:42AM (#39299379)
I'm disappointed with all the folks like you who blame no one but an SF employee
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by CalRobert on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:06AM (#39299508)
As somebody who uses a bike as primary mode of transport for myself and my entire family, it's pretty normal for American officials to immediately blame people on bikes for getting killed. I would be thrilled to see them be as concerned about humans killing people with cars as about computers doing it.

Honestly I'd feel much safer if all cars were not driven by humans.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by infecto on Thursday February 08, 2024 @06:25AM (#39300704)
I was struck by that supervisor comment too. I don’t live there anymore but when I did that was always the looming issue.