News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:57PM (#39298376)
It always amazes me how quick internet forums are to hate cyclists. We're talking about a person vs a one ton+ machine made of plastic and metal. There's always critiques about laws, but who does not similarly break laws when driving, walking, or whatever? Laws are also incomplete and anyone who has ever ridden a bike is probably quite aware of how often following laws would place one in substantial danger. (Not to mention that laws vary and most people don't know the laws) Bikes just aren't cars and they aren't motorcycles either.

I'll give a simple example that is quite common: not fully stopping at a stop sign. At first glance it seems quite reasonable to enforce stopping fully. But in practice this can actually be dangerous. In my personal experience, the only 2 times I've been hit by a vehicle were actually when I was stopped at a stop sign! On a bike momentum is your key to safety the same way it is often the case in a car. You have good stopping power but a lot of danger comes from behind. When stopped, you can't maneuver. When you can't maneuver, you are in danger. You are far slower to accelerate than cars, who are extremely upset by your presence and even more so when stuck behind you at a place such as a stop sign. Now I'm not advocating for someone to just blindly blow through a stop sign without looking, but coming to a complete stop with your feet on the ground and counting to 3 is not going to place you in the safest conditions. Not to mention that you will expend far more energy than were you to even just do a "california roll" because static friction is much higher than kinetic.

Realistically, people determine their actions from their experiences. There are definitely idiots and people doing stupid shit that does put them in danger, and I want to make it clear that this behavior is idiotic and reckless. I'll still have sympathy for a human being injured, but in the "stupid games, stupid prizes" kinda way. If you're advocating for the death of any human you should probably evaluate carefully. But there are many illegal and "illegal" things that people do because there's always exceptions to every rule, since rules are imprecise descriptions (including what I said in the previous sentence. I know you all can infer reasonable exceptions). Just make sure when evaluating situations like these you consider how the roads are not designed with non-car/truck traffic in mind and that this is often an afterthought. Also consider that The Bay is probably one of the most accommodating areas in the country for cyclists. And make sure that you aren't falling victim to selection bias. You probably don't even notice all the pedestrians and cyclists that are acting sanely, so are you accurately attributing qualities to the generalized group?

> I'm much more disappointed in the S.F. Supervisor quoted in the article, Shamann Walton

Same. Politicians especially should not be engaging in sensationalism. I recognize that they often do, but that does not mean I have to like it or support it. It muddies the waters and I want representatives to be doing their best to make the best city/country/environment they can for us. They are human too, but roles come with responsibilities. Muddying the waters just makes it harder for us to work together to make a better place for us all. So I fully agree with differentiating "us internet weenies" and "someone in charge of the city"

Edit: To be explicitly clear, I'm not saying cyclist right and Waymo wrong, nor am I saying Waymo right cyclist wrong. The article has very little information and I'd be a fool to make a conclusion in either way. I won't be surprised if the cyclist is in the wrong, nor would I be surprised if Waymo was (or the more likely some combination of both). I just intended to convey some extra information to consider when making these types of judgements as I think many judgements are made from the perspective of being in a car and experiencing idiotic cyclists. I will make one judgement though: if you are celebrating or rejoicing in the injury or death of a cyclist, you are not a good person. But this view isn't unique to "cyclists" and for me applies to humans. (I do believe there are reasons to kill people and that there are people that need to be killed, but celebration is not the right word to describe these situations)

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by TulliusCicero on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:33AM (#39298954)
I don't hate cyclists, I've used a bike as a primary form of transport for much of my life.

But especially in the US, dangerous behavior from cyclists seems to be proportionally much more common than dangerous behavior by Waymos. So yeah, it's easy to believe that a cyclist just kind of blew the stop sign when they shouldn't have.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:49AM (#39299774)
> behavior from cyclists seems to be proportionally much more common than dangerous behavior by Waymos

I'm not trying to take any position to this notion. I don't know the facts. I only know that not coming to a complete stop (different from blowing throw an intersection!) does not equate to dangerous behavior. You'll find another link that shows evidence otherwise. "Stop-as-yield" laws would be worth looking into if you're interested.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by TulliusCicero on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:01PM (#39318874)
I'm well aware of the Idaho stop, I'd advocated for it on many occasions.

However, I'm also aware that a lot of cyclists don't 'yield' so much as 'continue at full speed through the 4-way stop sign'.

So far, Waymo seems to have a culture of playing things very by the book and safely, or at least as safe as possible given the constraints of developing self-driving cars on public roads. I think it's very unlikely they'd lie, knowing that they'll have to hand over footage of the incident over to the authorities, and especially given what recently happened with Cruise semi-lying and being absolutely thrashed in the press because of it.