News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:28AM (#37085724)
There's a lot of hate any Firefox and the "blessed apps." But come on, chrome and Safari don't sorry add-ons at all!

I know there are other apps that support add-ons but the fact is that Firefox is __the only__ "mainstream" browser that does this (quotes because it's 0.25% in the US, as the 4th most popular, behind Samsung fucking Internet).

It's popular to hate on Firefox, but this is the nerdiest of nerd issues and if we're being honest, all this has accomplished in the last decade is a decrease in market share and keeping Safari and (more so) Chrome dictate the Internet and user experience. Firefox being so low puts no pressure on Chrome to add add-ons. Firefox being so low just means Chrome can continue pushing the ad first Internet.

Yeah, it's fun to complain, but which do you hate more? That Firefox only provides 80-90% of what you want (when major competitors provide __0%__), or Google dictating the Internet (like AMP)? Complain, but maybe tone it down a bit. This is not the holy war you want.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by drozycki on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:41AM (#37085797)
iOS Safari has supported declarative content blocking extensions since iOS 9 in 2015 and a full extension API since iOS 15 released about two years ago.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by the_gipsy on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:25AM (#37086048)
Declarative blocking is the weakest, it barely removes the simplest ads.

uBlock doesn't exist for iOS because it is made impossible by apple, their extension API is not a "full" API.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by drozycki on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:38AM (#37086124)
I haven’t seen ads on mobile Safari for as long as I can remember. Whether you choose to believe that is up to you. Can you point to an example where an extension like AdGuard would let an ad slip through?

Precompiled declarative blocking is more performant and power efficient than running a content script in a JS VM at page load, which matters on a CPU and battery constrained device.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by _thisdot on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:43AM (#37086151)
If anything, my problem is sometimes it’s too strong. Searching for a product on Google and clicking the Amazon links don’t work
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by ghostcluster on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:10AM (#37086283)
What's the best ad blocker for iOS Safari?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by eipi10_hn on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:33AM (#37086396)
It's not only the ads slipping through. Safari is so lacking in terms of API that for many sites with anti-adblock, the only way to bypass those are allowing tracking / ads connections.

Check the `@@` filters for `ios` here: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/AdguardTeam/AdguardFilters...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by the_gipsy on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:13AM (#37086653)
> Can you point to an example where an extension like AdGuard would let an ad slip through?

Yes, see Twitter.

I have AdGuard installed on iOS and I do see ads. I do not see them when opening on Firefox desktop with uBlock Origin. If I disable uBlock then I do see them like on Safari.

As I said, precompiled declarative blocking only works for the weakest of blatant ads. Of course it's "more performant and power efficient" because it only runs on the bare HTTP requests. That's not what I want.

> I was responding to a comment claiming that mobile Safari doesn’t support add-ons. Which is simply not true!

Fair enough. But personally I don't count Safari's extensions as real extension, just like I don't count Firefox' approach of a handful of "blessed" extensions for Android as real extensions.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by lapcat on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:33AM (#37087109)
> Yes, see Twitter.

Safari content blockers aside, Safari web extensions are capable of blocking Twitter ads.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by the_gipsy on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:59AM (#37087254)
AdBlock does not, so which one does?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by lapcat on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:01AM (#37087693)
Well... my own Safari extension Tweaks for Twitter does, but I recently discontinued it because I got sick of Twitter's shenanigans such as the strict usage limits, and I have no interest in supporting X, the so-called "everything app".

There may be other extensions, I don't know. In any case, the technical capability of the API is there.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by wildrhythms on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:01AM (#37089477)
You say

> Safari web extensions are capable of blocking Twitter ads

and then

> my own [discontinued] Safari extension [...] There may be other extensions, I don't know

So which one is it? And why the hell are you carrying water for Safari? I don't care that it's 'technically' capable of blocking ads, I just want the ads blocked!

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by lapcat on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:16AM (#37089641)
This is an unduly harsh reply. Please refrain from emotional outbursts against other HN commenters.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mst on Friday August 11, 2023 @07:57AM (#37087665)
Note that you've been able to use custom collections to get extra extensions on FF-for-Android for a while provided you put the browser into developer mode first.

It's a pain in the arse and certainly doesn't count as 'released' by any means but it's been at least just about possible for a while.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by eptcyka on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:56AM (#37086887)
I see ads on Safari on my iOS device all the time, whether you choose to believe that is up to you.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:30AM (#37086377)
uBlock doesn’t, but plenty of browsers have built-in adblocking, with one of the very browsers missing it being.. drumroll.. iOS Firefox!

Mozilla refuses to address how having no adblock is a security risk, so I have moved all my friends and family over to iOS Brave.

Firefox built its own demise by having a bizarre focus on woke stuff instead of features that users direly need.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by prmoustache on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:19AM (#37086688)
I think you reached the new modern Godwin point.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:38AM (#37088024)
I'm not sure what you mean by this (I do know Godwin's law).

The fact that HN is so full of dogmatic clowns they'll send a fact-based comment to -4?

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:31AM (#37089828)
Maybe your comment isn't fact based after all
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:16PM (#37093472)
- Firefox has been pumping out bizarre woke-language filled blog messages, the annoyance at this has even been upvoted to #1 on the frontpage of HN

- Firefox iOS has no real adblocking

- Mozilla has an issue for this open on both their Github and Bugzilla for years

- Firefox Focus does have real adblocking built in

Maybe trolls like you should leave HN :)

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by the_gipsy on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:20AM (#37086697)
iOS Firefox is just a re-skinned Safari, just like iOS Chrome because Apple has some rule against "dynamic code execution" in their AppStore.

Which sure is nice to combat some malware but not really MY problem.

It also coincidentally happens to also rule out ANY browser engines. Firefox and Chrome can only use the provided webkit "WebView" component. Apple has effectively crippled Browsers on iOS to Safari, or a worse re-skinned version of Safari.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:34AM (#37087979)
I don't really care. My less tech-knowledgeable social circle wants a browser that syncs across platforms and is safe. That immediately rules out Firefox for everyone with an iOS device.

Worse is that there is an iOS Firefox with full adblocking already built in: Firefox Focus.

So yeah, fuck Mozilla. You don't deliberately leave a segment of your users out in the cold like that

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Saturday August 12, 2023 @09:28PM (#37105762)
I have a huge grin on my face because you assholes got my other response to this flagged. Such an incredible feeling to know you guys can’t actually do anything meaningful. Enjoy plummeting to 0.000001% market share and fuck you :)
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by michaelmrose on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:26AM (#37086725)
Brave's adblocking seems decidedly worse than ublock origin. https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/16935 except on iOS where apple's restrictions are drastically limiting.

You are so insistent that the feature built in primarily because the platform you've chosen has limited your ability to do what literally every other platform can do. I know there are some benefits privacy wise to the Apple ecosystem but it appears that Apple continues to "refuse to address" the need for actual browsers other than safari on iPhone rather than skins on top of Webkit.

So neither party is doing what you please but you gave hundreds to thousands of dollars to one and nothing to the other so perhaps go ask the fellow who has all of your money if they can implement the feature.

Alternatively wait for some combination of law and or technology to work around Apple.

https://www.theregister.com/2023/02/03/googles_chromium_ios/...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:37AM (#37088010)
I've actually recently switched from using uBlock in Brave (desktop Brave) to the built-in blocker.

They both use the same selectable filter lists, so I notice barely if any difference.

I'll also scuttle Cookiebro once Brave's cookie auto-delete moves out of beta.

Less extensions means less attack surface.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:53AM (#37089354)
Selectable filter lists isn't close to uBlock equivalency, that's just table stakes for any adblocker. As far as I've been able to determine, in Brave there is no way to view a list/grid/matrix of which domains are being blocked and which sort of content is being blocked; this is a feature I use in ublock origin / umatrix a lot and don't wish to go without. (For this matter, ublock origin in advanced mode is claimed to have equivalency to umatrix in this regard, but if that's true I can't figure out how.) Also missing from Brave adblocker, as far as I can tell, is an interface for creating cosmetic filters. I use these frequently for removing things like floating headers and footers, and other obnoxious first-party elements that aren't ads but nevertheless degrade websites to satisfy some web designers random whims.

Here is an example of Brave's filtering falling short: http://0x0.st/H_YB.jpg

Do you see that wide gray box that says "Youtube Featured, RELEASED this week!" I consider that an ad for trashy commercial popculture slop, I hate it and want it gone. How do I remove it with Brave's blocker? I have ad blocking turned up to aggressive but it's still there. I can't figure out how to create a new cosmetic filter, Youtube is unusable to me without this. If I scroll down further I see similar boxes for "Trending", "Shorts", and "Celebrate World's Indigenous People's Day." All of this needs to go; in Firefox I don't see any of it because, with ublock origin, I created a cosmetic filter for ytd-rich-section-renderer. "Rich section" indeed...

Anyway, I didn't downvote your above comment, which is now flagged as well. Near as I can figure the "modern godwin" accusation leveled against you is either because you mentioned brave (is Eich claimed to be a nazi now?) or because you said Mozilla is being woke. Either way, a very stupid reaction to your inoffensive comment. This place is becoming orange reddit.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by antonok on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:46PM (#37093109)
FWIW, in Brave you can create cosmetic filters using the right-click context menu. `Brave > Block element`. There's a shortcut to the page where you can manage your custom filters in that menu, too.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:17PM (#37093493)
> Do you see that wide gray box that says "Youtube Featured, RELEASED this week!" I consider that an ad for trashy commercial popculture slop, I hate it and want it gone. How do I remove it with Brave's blocker? I have ad blocking turned up to aggressive but it's still there

I have literally never seen this box. Something might be wrong with your config, either manually or due to Brave. Could be worth it to hit up Brave on their Github.

For what its worth, I was an uMatrix user in the past, but I got tired of the churn of constant tiny breakage (even if my regular set of sites was beautifully set up after a while). I know very well the ins and outs of blocking.

I did a trial run for a few weeks, alternating between uBlock and Brave blocking, and the difference was so unnoticeable that I just went cold turkey.

Brave has honestly been on a roll with their built-in security features:

- HTTPS upgrading

- configurable adblock

- fingerprinting protection

- WebRTC protection

- (soon) port-scanning protection, the first browser to do so

- (soon) cookie auto-deleting

> Anyway, I didn't downvote your above comment, which is now flagged as well. Near as I can figure the "modern godwin" accusation leveled against you is either because you mentioned brave (is Eich claimed to be a nazi now?) or because you said Mozilla is being woke. Either way, a very stupid reaction to your inoffensive comment. This place is becoming orange reddit.

Thanks for saying so! And yep. The funny thing is, all these dogmatic people do is strengthen the opinion of regular tech users like me. The more vindictive they get, the harder I try to steer away more and more people from Firefox.

Funnily enough its the opposite with Thunderbird. Since they had their split, their management is a lot more neutral and tech-focused and thus I try to get as many people back on that train as possible. I've even donated to Thunderbird, as those donations are specifically earmarked for Thunderbird only.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by endemic on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:50PM (#37090842)
I don't believe Mobile Safari has built-in adblock; IIRC you have to install a 3rd party content blocker. Funnily enough, Firefox Focus works as a content blocker, so when I browse with iOS Firefox it blocks the majority of ads.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by veave on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:33AM (#37086398)
>Declarative blocking is the weakest, it barely removes the simplest ads.

That's misinformation. It may not be as good as ublock origin (I don't know) but in my experience it removes practically everything.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by rpgbr on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:48AM (#37088107)
I’ve been using 1Blocker since day one and have nothing but praise for their product. Not as powerful as uBlock Origin, but pretty good nonetheless.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by cubefox on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:13AM (#37085976)
Doesn't count.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by drozycki on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:39AM (#37086126)
Does too.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by tbossanova on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:23AM (#37086342)
Oh I'm sorry, is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by boredumb on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:20AM (#37087027)
I laughed entirely way too hard at this for it being 6am
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Dalewyn on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:23AM (#37086035)
>It's popular to hate on Firefox,

I don't hate Firefox, I hate Mozilla.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by autoexec on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:00AM (#37086224)
I'll always love Mozilla, or at least some fictional idealized version of it, so I'm stuck being increasingly disappointed in Mozilla while holding out for the times they do something right. Giving add-on support back to firefox users is a good thing so here's hoping it won't be done in a way that disappoints me. I hope they bring back about:config next.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:15AM (#37086664)
> or at least some fictional idealized version of it

This might be the most real comment here. All our perceptions are some fictionalized version of <insert company/product here>. Doesn't matter if it is Apple, Google, Mozilla, or whatever. Our judgements are based on narrow experiences and highly affected by the PR generated around them.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:13AM (#37088901)
> Our judgements are based on narrow experiences and highly affected by the PR generated around them.

When it comes to Firefox, a lot of users' judgements might be from actual experience using the product back in its heyday (before it was lobotomized), as opposed to PR?

However, bringing PR into the discussion is a good point. Mozilla turned from a browser/web tools maker into a PR agency with unclear profit motives that happens to make an increasingly-lackluster browser.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by kibwen on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:43AM (#37089234)
> I hope they bring back about:config next.

I've never had to use about:config on mobile before, but I just checked and it works fine for me.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by cpeterso on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:43PM (#37091542)
Which settings would you like to change in about:config?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by autoexec on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:34PM (#37092188)
There's an ever increasing number of settings I need to change every single time I install firefox. I disable things like prefetch/seer, service workers, WebRTC, autorefresh, normandy, experiments, shield, redirects, searching from the address bar, autoplay, webgl, webassembly, autofill, etc.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Dalewyn on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:28PM (#37096392)
>normandy

Do I even dare ask WTF William the Conqueror has to do with Firefox...? :V

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by cpeterso on Saturday August 12, 2023 @03:19PM (#37103332)
Normandy is the name of Mozilla’s system to run A/B experiments in Firefox. You can check if you are or have been enrolled in any experiments by entering about:studies in your Firefox address bar. Here are instructions for opting out of experiments:

https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/shield

https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/how-opt-out-studies-fir...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by asu_thomas on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:00AM (#37086225)
Why?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by DoingIsLearning on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:12AM (#37086296)
- They lost focus with just about every other project other than Firefox & Thunderbird which were the actual products I donated money for

- They are (recently) very top heavy for a non-profit foundation and are spending non-negligible amounts of money on C-level and execs

- Ideologically I disagree with them taking money with strings attached from Alphabet

- (Personally) their recent trends of UX with 'dummyfication' and mimicking chrome is a terrible loss

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by maleldil on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:37AM (#37086425)
> They lost focus with just about every other project other than Firefox & Thunderbird which were the actual products I donated money for

> Ideologically I disagree with them taking money with strings attached from Alphabet

How would they get more sources of funding if not exploring other projects? Firefox would never pay for itself.

I totally agree with the exec thing, however.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by input_sh on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:53AM (#37086530)
You see, Mozilla is stuck in this limbo where people criticise them for taking money from Google, but also criticise them when they explore alternate funding sources (Pocket, Mozilla VPN, Firefox Private Network, MDN Plus) because they're not focusing on Firefox and Thunderbird. Sometimes literally in the same comment, as the one above.

In other words, HN crowd will shit on them regardless of what they do.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by DoingIsLearning on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:31AM (#37086759)
> where people criticise them for taking money from Google, but also criticise them when they explore alternate funding sources

What aggravates me is nobody is asking why do you need so much cash?

- Why has it become so big that it needs to spend 81M on Management payroll per year? [0]

- Why has it grown so big that it needs to spend 21M in external consultants per year? [0]

- Why do you need 1000+ staff to roll out an open source browser engine / browser and an email client?

Mozilla had almost 8M in no strings attached donations in 2021. If I go to most open source projects and say you can burn through 8M a year, most of them would agree they could build amazing things. This is even without taking into account Investment returns.

The cow grew too fat and too close to SF's money vortex.

[0] https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2021/mozilla-fdn-202...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by maleldil on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:46AM (#37086836)
I think this is valid criticism, but it's more nuanced than the usual "mozilla bad because google money" and "mozilla bad because not firefox". Thank you for providing data.

Is there a more sustainable path where they don't rely on Google so much? Maybe? Developing a browser doesn't seem to be cheap. Do we know how many resources are used in Firefox versus the rest? I'd like to see a strong argument that Mozilla could be fully/more independent while still developing Firefox.

The thing is, even if they're badly managed today, they're still the best agent fighting for the open web. Apple helps, but I don't think they care much about it and would happily change if it were better for their bottom line.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:28AM (#37089079)
> Do we know how many resources are used in Firefox versus the rest?

Well the C-suite sure isn't writing code, so that's already a few million going to "the rest" as opposed to Firefox.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by input_sh on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:50AM (#37087214)
That's a whole lotta words to avoid addressing the contradictions in your statements: do you want them to keep being funded mostly by Google or do you want them to venture out into other funding opportunities?

It's one or the other, you can't have neither. 8 million is tiny in comparison to who they're trying to compete with. Thank god that's not their only revenue source, otherwise they'd be dead a decade ago. I guarantee you Edge has a higher yearly budget than that without even having their own engine.

> If I go to most open source projects and say you can burn through 8M a year...

Go ahead and do that, nothing's stopping you. You've been beating this same drum for the past three years[0], don't you get tired of it? I'm begging you, do something useful for the future of the web instead of shitting on those that do. It doesn't have to be Mozilla, donate to FSF, Ladybird, Internet Archive, Wikimedia, and so on and so on. Get involved, be the change you want to see, create your own NGO that will do something better and I'm gonna be the first one to throw money your way. Just do something useful with your time instead of chasing internet points by behaving like a parrot.

> On thing I feel we are still missing is for FSF, Wiki, Archive.org, etc. to effectively gather enough cash to start lobbying in politics and in industry much in the same way Meta and Alphabet do.[1]

Guess who's been doing that? Mozilla[2], the same NGO you've been shitting on for hours in this thread! Pick. A. Lane. Stand for something that's not downplaying work done by others.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24654676

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36981953

[2] https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/clients/bills?c...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by PurpleRamen on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:50AM (#37089303)
> - Why do you need 1000+ staff to roll out an open source browser engine / browser and an email client?

Writing fast moving mature Software for multiple platforms, is not something you can do with three nerds in your spare-time. Web browsers are highly complex, and Firefox has still many historical grown baggage to improve and maintain. And let's be fair, their software has a very high quality-level, even we can dispute on the details. Whether 1000+ people are necessary for this, I don't know, but considering everything they do even in their core-area, it's not something which can be done with small budget.

> If I go to most open source projects and say you can burn through 8M a year, most of them would agree they could build amazing things.

Amazing by their perspective, but not by the standards of end-users. And 8 Millionen, that's around 666k per month, meaning you have either around 3-5 well paid workers who are worth that price, or 10-20 poorly paid workers, who are probably average competent at best. And this is nowhere near the number of people necessary for such a big project.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by herewulf on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:06PM (#37091034)
I think you're mixing up annual and monthly salaries/employee expenses. At 666K/month the 3 "well paid" workers are costing 222K/month and the 20 "poorly paid" workers are costing 33K/month. I'd be rather okay getting paid this poorly!

I like where you were going with your comment but the math doesn't support the specific argument.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by cpeterso on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:02PM (#37090972)
> Why do you need 1000+ staff to roll out an open source browser engine / browser and an email client?

How many people do you think work on the Chrome team? Then include companies like Microsoft, Samsung, Igalia, and others that contribute to Chromium.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:26AM (#37089051)
Firefox would actually pay for itself. The Enterprise spends insane money on (potentially dubious) security products.

The browser is the primary interface to untrusted and often-malicious code, as well as a window to the outside world. It's the perfect place for security features that would actually make a difference.

Sell an enterprise-focused browser with built-in ad & tracker blocking (important for security), website restriction policies (which are currently implemented via various hacks such as DNS blocking), logging and data loss prevention and centralized management. Use that to subsidize the free version.

Mozilla has a huge competitive advantage here - they have brand recognition (especially among IT folks which would help sell it to the enterprise), a competent and up-to-date rendering engine (no small feat these days) and at least some skill left to work on said rendering engine. They're in the perfect position to actually be able to offer a browser product (as opposed to a Chromium reskin which is all that the competition does).

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:00PM (#37090202)
Oh fuck off. How is Mozilla supposed to build a browser that outcompetes two companies that literally build all in one corporate environments? Firefox could literally provide regular oral sex to the CEO and still be less attractive to businesses than whatever shlock microsoft has bought and re-sold.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:13PM (#37091128)
> How is Mozilla supposed to build a browser that outcompetes two companies that literally build all in one corporate environments?

Do any of those companies' browsers actually come anywhere close to the feature set I just outlined? Chrome is functionally a very good browser but lacks those features, and Edge is malware disguised as a browser that needs a full-time sysadmin to keep on top of the group policies to disable whatever bullshit "feature" they release every few weeks.

None of them have ad/tracker/malware blocking, logging or data loss prevention. Not sure if any have website/domain blocking capabilities. All of these are features that big enterprises currently use expensive third-party solutions (such as TLS intercepting proxies) for. A browser that has that built-in would actually be an upgrade.

> Oh fuck off

Shall we keep it civil? I think we’re both ultimately on the same side in wanting a browser that puts users’ interests first instead of adtech or dubious corporate interests (I’m not even sure of Mozilla’s current strategy because the user-hostility and annoyance of Firefox isn’t even due to actual ads).

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by asu_thomas on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:21AM (#37086333)
Thanks for explaining. I can't help but ask why you believe these things have happened? What went wrong and what is the alternative to Firefox?

I am approximately as cynical as they come, and I'm not sure how Firefox could even exist if Google weren't keeping Mozilla alive (on life support), so I am intrigued by your criticism. I'd like to understand your viewpoint and what ideology is behind it, if any. In your view, what should be done?

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by benterix on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:38AM (#37086428)
Yeah, I'm asking myself the same questions, too. It's obvious they have been trying many options. Some of them worked, some didn't. I criticized some of them in the past but objectively, if I was in their position, I might have made worse mistakes.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:23AM (#37086710)
That's actually pretty big to say. All I have to say is really just make sure you make criticisms rather than complaints. They need to be constructive (__actionable__) and less emotional. Otherwise the truth is that you may be just throwing fuel onto the fire rather than water. It's easy to get these two confused.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by blackoil on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:09AM (#37086632)
> money with strings attached from Alphabet

What are those strings, apart from being default search engine?

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:20AM (#37086694)
Have you considered that they are doing some of these things to survive? That Chrome nearly killed them? Literally the strings attached from Alphabet are that they give you Google as a default search engine. Default, as in... you can change it... trivially. This isn't like they are installing a keylogger into your browser and using it to learn about your behaviors. It isn't like they are making their browser the default on your phones and devices. It isn't like they are focused on selling ads and generating long URLs that have tracking data attached to them. Sorry, I got a little side tracked, but I guess that makes two of us.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:22AM (#37089005)
What made Firefox originally successful (and gave it significant marketshare against a preinstalled incumbent) was the features. They simply made a better browser than the status-quo at the time.

I don't understand nor approve their current strategy of trying to make a Chrome clone - even if they actually make a perfect copy, why would people use it instead of Chrome itself?

The only way for Firefox to survive and thrive is to differentiate itself from the incumbents and offer features that those incumbents can't offer due to conflicts of interest such as built-in ad blocking. Make a better browser and people will come.

At the moment there is no reason for any non-technical user to use it over Chrome, since in its default configuration it's no better (and being non-technical means they are not aware of add-ons/etc). Give non-technical users an actual reason to pick it over Chrome.

Worse, their current strategy is actually alienating their current (mostly-technical) users, effectively working against their already-tiny marketshare.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:59AM (#37090178)
>Make a better browser and people will come.

With magic money? Do you think mozilla employees and firefox employees should starve? Should they be making firefox entirely as charity?

The other browsers are made by a GigaCorp that extracts a tax from pretty much everything on the internet, especially if you want to do any advertising, and another Megacorp that has billions upon billions of dollars in cash just waiting for a need and also extracts 30% on ANY financial transaction using their hardware.

Imagine people pushing stupid hard for everyone to use Meta's MetaVerse instead of VRChat because VRChat once had an advertising ID in their code or something. Like sure, that's not awesome, but like, what the fuck is the alternative?

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:16PM (#37091180)
> With magic money? Do you think mozilla employees and firefox employees should starve? Should they be making firefox entirely as charity?

Well they've got enough magic money considering the salaries of their C-suite, so short-term needs are absolutely covered.

Long-term the Google subsidy will eventually dry up but focusing on an enterprise-grade browser (see my other comment here) is worth a shot.

Charity isn't actually that bad of an idea either, since Mozilla Foundation is actually a non-profit (but somehow owns a for-profit company that pays insane salaries to execs? Shady as fuck). Developing a browser that is actually focused on the user fits with their purported mission and will do more to improve the web than all the auxiliary projects/initiatives they've done so far.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by PurpleRamen on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:30AM (#37089098)
> Have you considered that they are doing some of these things to survive?

How many Managers does one need to negotiate prices for VPN and Pocket? So far, the excessive management does not make the impression to be very valuable for making money, or even let Mozilla survive one day longer.

Of course do they need to make money, but at no point so far did they make the impression that they made any serious attempt beyond some lip service. Well, except VPN, which is just a resale of a popular service, with a natural chemistry for their philosophy.. And I'm not sure how much money their VPN really made so far.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by gmerc on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:24AM (#37086714)
So basically you want them to fund the top end engineers working on it … how?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by iakov on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:55AM (#37087236)
Do you think that the funds go to the top end engineers? I'd say that most of it goes to the bloated management structure and C-level employees.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by gmerc on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:02AM (#37087703)
The top end engineers are currently paid competitively. That’s a fact.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by probably_wrong on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:25AM (#37087060)
I believe that the Mozilla execs have no faith in Firefox and instead are using whatever branding remains to position themselves as a champion of digital rights.

And I mean sure, it's not a bad goal, but they are letting Firefox die in the process. And once you lost your place at the standards negotiating table, then what? They already capitulated when Google decided that browsers needed DRM, and I don't see them stopping WEI either.

I don't need yet another VPN. I need a strong browser to rival Chrome.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by OfSanguineFire on Friday August 11, 2023 @07:55AM (#37087647)
> I believe that the Mozilla execs have no faith in Firefox and instead are using whatever branding remains to position themselves as champions of digital rights.

That’s a charitable interpretation. An uncharitable one would be that, due to flaws in American 501c3 legislation, at least some people involved in Mozilla view their job as a sinecure. Capture of a non-profit for personal benefit is a longstanding phenomenon in the USA.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by asu_thomas on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:50AM (#37090073)
> Capture of a non-profit for personal benefit is a longstanding phenomenon in the USA.

No. Capture of a non-profit for personal benefit is the express purpose of non-profits in the USA.

The foremost purpose of non-profits in the US is to displace community organizations, especially democratic worker organizations which remotely resemble a workers' political party like you can find in other countries. Non-profit law in the US makes such organizations perfectly illegal while providing anti-democratic resemblances of them instead.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:55AM (#37090131)
Ah yes, meanwhile I still get to use the only browser not made by the Gigacorp trying to put advertising anywhere they can.

People get so pissy about mozilla pissing away a few dollars here and there, or maybe is full of people just extracting cash from the brand.

Meanwhile google as a corporation extracts a tax on pretty much anything that touches the internet.

But sure, mozilla is the bad guy here and we shouldn't use their browser......

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by OfSanguineFire on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:23PM (#37090496)
> People get so pissy about mozilla pissing away a few dollars here and there

It’s more than a few dollars. For years now, the majority of the Mozilla Foundation’s income goes to things other than developing Firefox.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:30PM (#37090584)
Yes, mozilla is desperate to diversify income so google can't shut them down, and if you are a manager who can usefully direct improvements and plans for a web browser project, google can afford to pay you basically any dollar amount to keep you out of the hands of mozilla, so they probably don't have stellar management.

Meanwhile firefox works well, is plenty performant, and isn't pushing "standards" that try to make it easier to advertise to me, against my wishes. Why would you use the browser made by an advertising company instead?

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by OfSanguineFire on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:37PM (#37090668)
Yours is a false dilemma. Being aghast at Mozilla’s non-profit mismanagement does not mean that one is using any other browser. A lot of us here are using Firefox but hoping and praying that the Foundation will be called to account or development will be taken over by some more benevolent and competent force.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by asu_thomas on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:41PM (#37093057)
Your efforts come across as facile to me. You're wanting a democratic organization, or at least one capable of acting in the interests of the consumers despite the fact that more consumers does not necessarily benefit the organization. This is an unrealistic expectation given the political economic circumstances, being those of late-stage capitalism. Even the most benevolent leader is constrained by their circumstances and hard power. You cannot resolve this through the consumer marketplace; you need to engage in politics one way or another.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by OfSanguineFire on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:09PM (#37093374)
Look, I’ve only seen two comments from you (with your very new account), but both of them are trying to introduce an element of political battle beyond the subject of discussion here. Not interested, sorry.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by dralley on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:08PM (#37093367)
>the majority of the Mozilla Foundation’s income

The Mozilla "Foundation" does not develop Firefox at all. In fact they cannot do so. Because that would be tantamount to a nonprofit devoting resources towards the service of a for-profit business.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by dralley on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:00AM (#37089458)
I'm just going to copy/paste my comment from the other day, because this thread is a perfect example.

HN loves to simultaneously criticize Mozilla for

1) being financially dependent on Google

2) spending resources on literally anything except Firefox

3) doing anything that smells like monetizing Firefox, no matter how innocuous

Spoiler alert: They have essentially no hope of avoiding 1 without doing at least a little bit of 2 or 3. Unlike Google, Apple, and Microsoft, they don't have billions of dollars coming through the backdoor from other business units. The money can't just magically appear, so either they make it from Google, from Firefox, or from alternative services.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by bmacho on Friday August 11, 2023 @07:17AM (#37087379)
They actively screw up Firefox (which I love).
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:33AM (#37086095)
The other browsers you mention though don’t pretend to be on your side and don’t use every possible opportunity to tell you about it.

Firefox on the other hand, despite having a lot of user-hostile functionality and design decisions, will constantly nag you pretending to be on your side, misleading you into a false sense of security.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by cycomanic on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:09AM (#37086275)
Those arguments always remind me of this comic: https://www.cjr.org/wp-content/themes/cjr2017/images-body/NY...
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by veave on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:28AM (#37086375)
Most of Firefox's publicity is based on the fact that they are "on your side". That means that they are held to a much higher standard. Pretending to be on the side of the user and then screwing users up over and over seems like wanting their cake and eating it too?

It's funny because, you know, I expect chrome to screw me over while I expect firefox not to screw me over but chrome has screwed me over fewer times than firefox over the years.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Gud on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:41AM (#37086448)
How exactly has Firefox “screwed you over”? I’ve used Firefox since it was called Phoenix… although I don’t like the governance of the project, I would hardly say I’ve been screwed over.

Firefox has been an amazing product since day one.

Meanwhile, Chrome has literally been developed to probe your ass for data they can sell to advertisers.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by veave on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:46AM (#37086484)
Last time it was 2 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36077360

In that thread there are a few more examples, most of them somewhat recent: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36077683

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:07AM (#37086619)
I have never seen these myself, being on FF for most of it's life, but I also fail to see how these "screw you over." Oh my god an ad! I better instead use a browser that has a built in keylogger and created the ad based internet! That'll show those assholes!
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by gmerc on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:23AM (#37086711)
Google: Let’s put DRM in the browser, hijack the address bar, webmanifest

Omg, firefox screwed me over by showing me an ad.

I see. I think no further illustration needed.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by iakov on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:59AM (#37087259)
Textbook whataboutism. Google is objectively evil, what that has to do with Firefox, my "user agent", showing me Disney ads?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by programmer_dude on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:28AM (#37088473)
Textbook idiocy. Whataboutism is not a phallacy when the discussion is about comparing things.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by CatWChainsaw on Monday August 14, 2023 @09:46AM (#37120953)
I have to ask... did you deliberately spell it "phallacy" because you mentioned 'comparing things'??
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by programmer_dude on Monday August 14, 2023 @10:20AM (#37121333)
No comment :)
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:37AM (#37089913)
When you choose to continue using the browser from the "objectively evil" company, helping them continue to push those objectively evil goals, because "firefox showed me A ad", because for some reason that is more screwing over your users than literally fucking the open internet....

It's astounding how far people bend over backwards just to not change browsers for the good of the internet as a whole.

"Yeah I could stop hanging out with a serial baby stabber, but the other guy once said my hat was funny, so that's terrible and I will stay with the baby stabber"

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by iakov on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:33PM (#37091407)
I choose to use Firefox, for more than a decade. It does not mean I am a happy user, and it does not mean that I can't complain about Mozilla being shittifed year after year.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Gud on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:07AM (#37088830)
Yes, the people in charge of Mozilla have been doing dumb stuff like this, eroding our trust.

Hardly screwing us over, though. They’ve been doing even worse things, for example constantly opting us in for “anonymous statistics” etc.

If it one day comes out they’ve been sharing this data deanonymized with 3rd parties, then you can say you’ve been screwed over.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by shinryuu on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:40AM (#37086439)
Perhaps that is because they screw you over in secret? Whenever Firefox makes a mistake it gets very publicised, but whenever chrome does it it's just business as normal so no one really publicises it.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:11AM (#37088873)
As far as I know Chrome doesn't use every possible opportunity to nag you about self-righteous BS on how they're better and more private than everyone else?

It's one thing to make a mistake or do user-hostile decisions inline with your business model. But it's another to loudly shout about how "good" you are (and everyone else is bad) and then do the exact same thing.

Same reason why a policeman or some law-enforcement figure gets more outrage for committing a crime than a normal citizen.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:48AM (#37090045)
Are you pretending that chrome doesn't advertise? Every single fucking day for a decade now, google.com told me to install chrome, and would even render "pop up" dialogs to that effect on google properties!!

What are you all smoking?

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:51AM (#37090085)
An ad telling you to install Chrome is one thing. I don't believe any Google nor Chrome ad had self-righteous BS about privacy, "improving the web" or similar like Mozilla constantly does.

Also, ads on websites are one thing. Ads/nags within the browser itself (which I'm already using) are another. I'm pretty sure Google doesn't bother advertising Chrome to users who already use Chrome.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:32PM (#37090611)
Okay, then how should mozilla fund firefox? They don't have billions upon billions in advertising revenue to backstop a project that exists only to exert more influence and control of the internet.

God damn, people act like money grows on trees when it comes to firefox. I don't care if they flub an attempt at advertising, like the Mr Robot nonsense, because mozilla isn't actively pushing "standards" meant to prevent me from some day being anonymous on the internet or blocking advertising

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:21PM (#37091228)
> Okay, then how should mozilla fund firefox?

Virtue-signalling and wasting people's times does not contribute to funding either. I'd disagree with but understand actual ads, or promotions for Pocket/VPN/etc... but wasting users' time on virtue-signalling or "Colorways"?

(look at my other comments for actual long-term funding ideas for Firefox)

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:02PM (#37093305)
> I don't believe any Google nor Chrome ad had self-righteous BS about privacy, "improving the web" or similar

I constantly see Chrome ads about privacy and security. Your argument also isn't consistent. Your complaint is that Mozilla has "failed" to achieve their stated goals. The quotes because they've definitely made progress towards that, but just not to your expectations. That is fine to have higher expectations, but you're literally discouraging Mozilla from working in that direction, where others aren't making those moves __at all__. Don't bite the hand that feeds you.

And can we stop copy pasting that line? You're starting to sound like a bot.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KyUIEYE13jE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfXnLAa6zWc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_u9_3umb5LY

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by BiteCode_dev on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:43AM (#37086462)
I've yet to notice any event where firefox "screw users over" that was not vastly overblown, especially compared to the competitors.

People tend to just judge Mozilla way more harshly.

It's very unfair: they do good, and we ask even more of them.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by worble on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:36AM (#37086788)
I know that its against the rules to imply this, but seriously, there is always so much vitriol that I just don't understand thrown towards Firefox every update that it really gets the old noggin get going.

Can we seriously not even contemplate the idea that there might be a certain corporate entity out there with a vested interest in ensuring that Firefox usage is kept deliberately low while at the same ensuring they _just_ enough funding to keep going so they can point to it and say "look, we're not a monopoly!"

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:42AM (#37089980)
How many members of this very forum are straight up google employees, complete with regular internal propaganda efforts to reassure employees that aktually, google is the good guys protecting you from the evil, politically driven mozilla?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:49PM (#37093148)
Honestly in my original comment I almost tried to make a joke about how this website calls conspiracy on far less. But I didn't know how to properly do it and so removed it. But yeah, you're not alone in thinking this looks like astroturfing. But I'm not entirely convinced it is not-natural. FF did fuck up in the past, but I think people are still angry about the browser 10 years ago and not updating their beliefs. I think there is also a bias because Mozilla is 501c and so their fuck-ups and everything is out in the open. It's like comparing a democracy to an autocracy, and thinking the autocracy is better because you hear that the people are doing well and never hear about things going wrong.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by FeepingCreature on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:16PM (#37106354)
I'm seeing a lot of "boo Mozilla" in this thread, but honestly I'm seeing pretty much zero "yay Chrome"/"yay Google". I think it's more like saying "this democracy has a lot of issues that make me angry" and getting the reply "so you prefer the autocracy? Damn fascist."
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:12AM (#37086652)
There's no better way to get someone to stop listening to you than to turn everything they do into evil. Which is an implicit point I was getting at in my original comment. The more people make mountains out of molehills, the more they are actively training Mozilla to just not give a fuck and ignore them. You can't have it both ways. You can't have a company that listens and works with you while you also vehemently attack it at every opportunity. I mean look around at the comments. There are people just taking the opportunity to attack them unrelated to the topic and people that are happy are "this is nice, but it could be better." It's amazing that people are more passionate about hating Mozilla than they are about airlines or their ISP. Or... you know... the people who scrub up all their data and turn it against them to sell shit, ideas, and make them hateful balls of anxiety.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by serf on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:34AM (#37087113)
they're the best game in town, but they've also gone against long term user-base wishes again and again to either 1) try to create wider popularity with feature parity (didn't work) and 2) to capitalize in inappropriate ways that are against the ideals first set forward.

It doesn't take a lot of mental effort to realize that the userbase left doesn't want telemetry and third party partnerships; Mozilla knew this, they tried to get away with it and lost goodwill.

It's not the thing, it's the attempt to get away with it that irks me. No one except The Paid wanted pocket integration and Mr Robot promotions.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:46AM (#37090023)
Oh you were definitely harmed by the company using their money to buy a semi-popular bookmarking alternative for their users, that someone probably thought their users would like to use, with zero requirement to ever use pocket. My firefox install hasn't even had the pocket icon in however long, I can't remember.

Meanwhile google is pushing an attempt to strangle the open internet to death, in the open, for all eyes to see.

But no, lets keep pretending that mozilla doing a poorly executed ad is comparable to THAT

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:06AM (#37088824)
> People tend to just judge Mozilla way more harshly.

It's a self-inflicted problem though. Mozilla uses every opportunity to claim they're on your side and want to protect you from the evil guys.

The nagging itself is annoying to begin with (and incomprehensible - at least ads make sense from a business point of view - but why interrupt my workflow to let me know about Colorways?), but it's made even worse with all their self-righteous BS about privacy while the browser actually being pretty poor (and not GDPR compliant due to default-on telemetry) in its default configuration.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:38AM (#37089184)
This opinion might differ from others but my main complaint is with their useless and sometimes hostile UI changes rather than the occasional ad for other Mozilla services. For example recently the change to tabs floating disconnected from the pages, which I had to use userchrome to override. Next problem I am trying to tackle right now is favicon being hidden when the audio playing icon is on a tab that seems to have been done in a recent update.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:43AM (#37089987)
>the change to tabs floating disconnected from the pages

What does this mean? My experience using tabs in firefox has not changed in like twenty years!

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by cpeterso on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:12PM (#37091111)
The "user hostile" tab design change was the addition of a space of a few pixels between the tabs and address bar: https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/1/22463321/firefox-design-re...
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:51PM (#37093178)
If they had just thickened the continuous bar connected to the tab a few pixels I probably wont even have noticed. Instead introducing a gap between the tab and its page completely changes its look making it seem like its floating separately and the tabs are independent buttons. But the point is either of these makes no sense at all. What even was the point of this weird change from the perfectly functional and normal looking tabs before?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Sunday August 13, 2023 @04:28AM (#37107834)
https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1339535 https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1386107

Look what an unholy mess the new change to audio playing status has caused.

To summarize, in compact mode you will get the audio playing icon on a tab but it will hide the favicon in that case.

In normal mode, and only if you have a small number of tabs, you will find a tiny 'PLAYING' text instead. If you hover over it, you will find the playing icon...which will have hidden the favicon then.

UX geniuses with too much time on their hands.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by batrat on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:30AM (#37086378)
>behind Samsung fucking Internet

Supports adblock (addons) and shows tabs on top just like desktop so it's easy to switch, dark mode for all websites, etc. It's relative fast and lots of options. I use FF with no addons for some websites.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:31AM (#37086757)
> shows tabs on top just like desktop

Honestly, I hate this on the phone. But I get it. I had that initial cognitive disruption when FF did this. But once that was gone (idk, like 30 minutes?) I realized it was a lot nicer because I could actually reach the address bar and tabs without needing to stretch my hand. Or if I have a bigger phone, use a second hand. I mean there's a reason navigation buttons on the phones (for the OS) were always on the bottom. It's just easier. But yeah, you gotta get through the initial cognitive disruption. But you know what? I also got used to when Android switched the time from being at the top right to top left and I'm willing to bet most people did too and don't really think about it anymore. As for the dark mode... well you got a point there. Though dark reader was one of the first add-ons on FF mobile. Though as much as I love dark mode, some websites are just unreadable with it and it drives me nuts. Specifically anything with a transparent background...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by solarkraft on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:21AM (#37087035)
I don't mind cognitive disruption at all, as long as I'm getting something better. While the mobile switcher scales much better (how many can the desktop tab bar hold, like ten?), it can take a while to open and sometimes loses your scroll position or puts a tab in a random place in the list. The previews are also so large that it's hard to get an overview. This can make it much slower to switch tabs than on desktop.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by ZeroGravitas on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:29AM (#37087083)
Note you can slide over the URL bar to switch tabs left or right.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:27AM (#37089784)
>it can take a while to open

Uhhh how many tabs do you keep open? I have 16 or so in the background on firefox on an old ass Pixel 2 phone and it never has any sort of delay.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by solarkraft on Thursday August 17, 2023 @10:04PM (#37170681)
It won't tell me, it just shows the infinity sign. I guess that means something over 99.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by hadrien01 on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:44AM (#37087174)
You can change the tabs and address bar positions (independently) in the Samsung Internet settings. You can also choose to display them always, on scroll, or never (for the tabs).
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by MaxMatti on Friday August 11, 2023 @07:16AM (#37087370)
Same for Firefox on Android
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by MikusR on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:15AM (#37088322)
Firefox on Android has no tabs.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by zrobotics on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:49AM (#37088655)
Umm, what? No, this is absolutely not accurate. They're laid out differently than desktop, but at least on android Firefox does have tabs. Not sure on iOS, but that's basically reskinned safari anyway.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by cbsks on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:42AM (#37089223)
Firefox on iOS also has tabs
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by MikusR on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:48PM (#37093812)
I am writing this from Firefox on android. Neither phone nor tablet version has tabs. It has list of open websites ordered in a scrolling window as squares (and for sync reasons call them tabs), but no tabbar and no actual tabs. Chrome and Samsung internet has actual tabbar and tabs.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:19PM (#37095607)
Are you using firefox focus? Because otherwise idk what to tell you. You can even see it in the images on this engadget post. In both images that they show...

https://www.engadget.com/firefox-for-android-update-08000789...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by MikusR on Saturday August 12, 2023 @10:31AM (#37100555)
Can you poit to the picture where Firefox has tabbar?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by dralley on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:50AM (#37089307)
Firefox on Android absolutely has tabs.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by matheusmoreira on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:35AM (#37087989)
I see people hating on Mozilla, not Firefox. They absolutely deserve it too. They got one billion dollars and they're reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead. One would think they'd try to fix the web by making Firefox the dominant browser.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by flutas on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:50AM (#37088129)
Half that billion has probably been spent on interviews that they randomly decide they no longer are hiring for right before they take the entire company to Hawaii.

I'm not salty about the 6+ interviews or anything.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by nfriedly on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:57AM (#37088176)
Ha, you made it to 6, that's impressive! I only got scheduled for one interview, the interviewer was a no-show, and they never answered any of my attempts to reschedule or even find out what happened.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by flutas on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:37AM (#37088550)
I honestly don't remember the total number, but it was up there. I know they said it was the final interview before an offer would be given.

The manager of the team I would have been going on (FF for Android funnily enough) knew of some of (and said he actively used) my past work which was probably a leg up.

In the end they were far from the worst interviewers (hello Hopper for that title*), but it soured me against Mozilla after putting that much time and effort into it and just getting a "we're no longer hiring for this position" form email.

*: Never paying out their tech screening "payment", to rejecting me over an answer I never gave (we didn't like when you said "XYZ").

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by stevehawk on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:20PM (#37092008)
what the eff do they need more than 6 interviews for
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by deprecative on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:20PM (#37095615)
What does any company need more than 2? They don't but we inflate the process to make people exhausted just thinking about interviewing.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by pmontra on Sunday August 13, 2023 @09:07AM (#37109669)
On the plus side, interviews work both ways. You got lucky to need less than one interview to understand that they would be a bad fit for you.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by kramerger on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:40PM (#37090707)
Didn't they let go the curl guy?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:31AM (#37088507)
> They got one billion dollars and they're reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead

Where have they announced that they're focusing on "agenda pushing"? Mozilla's "agenda" feels like a very tiny part of what they do, it's just that people talk about it endlessly.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by timtom39 on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:10AM (#37088860)
https://blog.mozilla.org/en/

Just read their blog. Latest three: - EU's AI Act - Fakespot school supplies? - Making trustworthy chatbots to support women plagued by violence and abuse

The first one might make sense? Second one WTF? And third is disgusting (I know people effected and the LAST thing they want is some chatbot).

None of these are related strongly to Firefox. I quit donating to them years ago after it was obvious they have their priorities messed up.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by dralley on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:41AM (#37089219)
The third one isn't something they're doing, it's the winner they selected in a "responsible AI challenge" competition.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:12AM (#37089594)
> the winner they selected in a "responsible AI challenge" competition

How is hosting "responsible AI" competitions not something they're doing? Sounds like a huge waste and a distraction from what should be their core mission of protecting the web by making the best browser they possibly can. If they want to dip their toes into the AI space to stay trendy and relevant, they could at least do it in a way that constructively relates to creating a web browser. Their local translation extension is a good example of this, they did a great job with it. They could do more, like maybe experiment with AI-guided adblocking or something. But a competition to create responsible chatbots? How is that relevant to Firefox? Besides the winner of the competition being stupid, the whole competition was stupid. What did they even hope to accomplish with such a competition, to sway the development of commercial chatbots from the likes of OpenAI or Facebook? They gave out $100k to the top 3 winners and not one of them has anything to do with making a better browser. If I'm wrong, then please explain how any of this relates to making Firefox better. Don't copy-paste their vapid corporate rambling explanation to me, if you can't explain it in plain normal english then it's bullshit.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:39AM (#37089937)
> what should be their core mission of protecting the web by making the best browser they possibly can

In your opinion. I disagree. They could spend a billion dollars on making the best browser the world has ever seen and it would still be used by next to no-one. People use the browser they're given, especially in the smartphone era we're in now. Android users use Chrome. iOS users use Safari, Mozilla isn't even allowed to make a real version of Firefox for iOS.

So they've clearly decided to expand their mission to protect the web. Ensuring AI is used ethically strikes me as relevant to the topic, a little too much like chasing buzzwords to my taste but it's clearly an area of current interest. And hey, maybe a few more people will learn about the Mozilla brand and consider converting to Firefox some day.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:53AM (#37090116)
> "They could spend a billion dollars on making the best browser the world has ever seen and it would still be used by next to no-one. [...] So they've clearly decided to expand their mission to protect the web."

Seems like you're now conceding matheusmoreira's point you disputed before:

> They got one billion dollars and they're reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead.

And you haven't bothered to answer my question, so I'll put it to you again: How does rewarding the development of a chatbot to talk about sexual violence relate to furthering their mission to "protect the web"? It's nothing more than the predictable synthesis of AI hype and a popular social cause, it has nothing to do with the web at all. If the best you can come up with is people will hear about this chatbot and then maybe they'll use Firefox, then why don't you just admit the whole thing is a farce?

And as for it being an effective promotion of firefox and "clearly an area of current interest", then where, besides Mozilla's corporate blog, have you ever heard of this chatbot competition or any of the three winners? The winner of the competition is "Sanative AI", never mentioned on HN before this comment. Do a general web search for "Sanative AI" tell me if any of the results you find are likely to inform people of Firefox's existence and benefits. I feel confident in asserting that this competition has not brought a single new user to Firefox, and was not in earnest ever meant to.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:00PM (#37090201)
> Seems like you're now conceding matheusmoreira's point you disputed before:

...no? I'm saying that no matter what amount of money they spend they won't make a browser that'll take over the world. It's an entirely theoretical point, not a statement about what Mozilla is doing.

> And you haven't bothered to answer my question

> If the best you can come up with

> why don't you just admit the whole thing is a farce

I'm out, man. Not interested in engaging in a discussion with this kind of shitty tone, there are a dozen better things to do with a Friday. Have a good weekend.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:08PM (#37090303)
You've lost the plot. matheusmoreira said they have a billion dollars but they're cutting back on development to focus on agenda spending. You disputed this, but a few comments later concede that they've deprioritized development because:

> "They could spend a billion dollars on making the best browser the world has ever seen and it would still be used by next to no-one"

And increased agenda spending because:

> So they've clearly decided to expand their mission to protect the web. Ensuring AI is used ethically strikes me as relevant to the topic, a little too much like chasing buzzwords to my taste but it's clearly an area of current interest. And hey, maybe a few more people will learn about the Mozilla brand and consider converting to Firefox some day."

You've as much admitted that matheusmoreira is completely right.

> "shitty tone"

Right back at you, buddy. Did I call you shitty? Not until now, to throw your insult back at you.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:42AM (#37089231)
How many software engineering resources do you think were taken up with writing those blog entries? Would it help if they posted a weekly blog entry entitled "Yes, we're still working on Firefox"?

I don't understand why everyone keeps talking about this as if it's an either/or.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by seneca on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:56AM (#37089402)
Because the things an organization talks about gives you an idea of their priorities and their values. If a technical org you otherwise supported suddenly started posting blog entries about how Hitler wasn't such a bad guy, and maybe they could write a chatbot to help correct misconceptions about Nazis, you would probably change your opinion about them, regardless of how much effort it took to write the post.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:45AM (#37090016)
Equating any of the three examples the OP gave with "Hitler wasn't such a bad guy" is... an interesting take. But nevertheless, you're only looking at one thing. Why not look at the Firefox release notes?

https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/116.0/releasenotes/

Three releases so far this month! Look at that technical organization iterating on its core product!

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by whatshisface on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:54PM (#37091673)
Someday HN may learn the difference between equation and comparison...
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by deprecative on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:18PM (#37095601)
Humans in general haven't so we'll hope for a better tomorrow, together, tomorrow.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by tuukkah on Sunday August 20, 2023 @05:13AM (#37197446)
It seems more likely that a part of HN needs to learn the difference between mathematics and human language.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by UtopiaPunk on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:56PM (#37091693)
Well today, the Mozilla blog is talking about extensions in the Firefox Android browser, so that seems cool?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Rebelgecko on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:48AM (#37089288)
I dunno if it's their "focus" but it's a big part of their PR. eg their lobbying to get Amazon and NextDoor to cooperate less with law enforcement. The Mozilla incubator has a goal of spending 40% of its money on social justice initiatives. Meanwhile they're cutting staff and resources for browser development, which IMO should be their bread and butter.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:42AM (#37089978)
> eg their lobbying to get Amazon and NextDoor to cooperate less with law enforcement

Maybe that's a great example of the different ways you can look at the exact same thing. To me that's a privacy cause, and it's one I agree with. What percentage of Ring customers are aware they're providing the police with a direct feed of their front yard?

"Ring Reveals They Give Videos to Police Without User Consent or a Warrant"

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/07/ring-reveals-they-give...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:19PM (#37092001)
The claim above, disputed by you: "They got one billion dollars and they're reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead"

"Privacy cause" is an agenda they're pushing. An agenda I happen to agree with, but promoting that privacy agenda is not software development spending no matter how you look at it. You can't reasonably claim these are equivalent just because you like them both. Telling people that Ring is bad isn't software development, a "different way of looking at it" doesn't cut it.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:39PM (#37092250)
Perhaps there was a time when Mozilla's sole monetary focus was development of the Firefox browser but if there was it was a long time ago.

There aren't only two pots of money in the Mozilla budget, one labeled "software development" and another "agendas", they do all kinds of things. An increase in "agendas" does not automatically mean a decrease in software development. Case in point: Mozilla used to have a "Mozilla Science Lab" from 2013-18[1]. When it was shut down there was presumably extra cash made available. Maybe it went to "agendas", maybe it didn't. And hey, maybe it couldn't: the foundation receives donations for specific projects, they're not able to just say "thanks for the money, we're actually going to spend it on something totally different".

To interpret this as a binary choice is an oversimplification.

[1] https://wiki.mozilla.org/ScienceLab

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:56PM (#37092455)
Nobody said it's a binary. The claim is that they've reduced development spending, which is factual. They laid off a ton of developers, are you forgetting that? Or do you think that doesn't count as reduced development spending?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:23PM (#37092797)
> The claim is that they’ve reduced development spending

The claim was more specific than that: it was “reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead”.

Two factual statements:

1) the Mozilla Corporation laid off engineers

2) the Mozilla Foundation spent money pursuing “agendas”

I am suggesting that those two events are not necessarily connected to each other.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Vinnl on Monday August 14, 2023 @07:02AM (#37119593)
Mozilla is a non-profit, and Firefox is explicitly a means (one of them) to an end, i.e. a healthy internet as described in the Mozilla Manifesto: https://www.mozilla.org/about/manifesto/

There's definitely an agenda. It's one that's good for users IMHO though, as opposed to the agendas of the for-profit browser makers.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by driscoll42 on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:30AM (#37089089)
Can someone elaborate why Mozilla gets hate? I don't pay much attention to that and just use Firefox.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by matheusmoreira on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:42AM (#37089230)
Check out this news post from 5 days ago about Mozilla's finances:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37015592

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by maverick74 on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:29PM (#37090564)
I was not aware of this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This just made my mind blow up...

If it's true, then it's REALLY BAD!!!

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by dralley on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:06PM (#37093349)
You really, really, really should not take anything Brian Lunduke says at face value.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by maverick74 on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:56AM (#37089397)
Well... there are a few reasons but i believe the biggest ones are that

- they fired lots of good devs to cut on expenses but then keep paying more and more to top execs (and we're not getting any anomalous good results that justify it iyam)...

- from what i understood, they also "kind of" kicked Brendan Eich (yeah, Brave's CEO, the guy that invented JS, etc...) out over some "personal" things that had nothing to do with Mozilla (but then again... you should go read about this and take your own conclusions)

- Firefox, also start following the herd and that led to it cutting lots of features people loved (e.g.: Firefox had tab grouping addons - and then a native feature - way before we had Chrome browser... now everyone complains firefox is the only browser that does not support tab groups... kind of ironic!)

- some more .......

All in all it's a love-hate relation! We love and need Firefox because it's the only good thing left around, but people are very pissed up with "Mozilla's attitudes and decisions"

then again... this is just what i understand from the "news"!!! You should really go out and see what others think about it!!!

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by johnnyanmac on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:19PM (#37094170)
>Firefox had tab grouping addons - and then a native feature - way before we had Chrome browser... now everyone complains firefox is the only browser that does not support tab groups... kind of ironic!

I think tab containers are way better after getting used to them. But they are much jankier and feel they needs a UX pass to really make it shine. There were a half dozen instances where I wanted to do something, thought it wasn't a feature, and then found it in a weird context menu. Which includes the fact that the feature itself is behind an add-on! A add-on with native level support, but an add-on nonetheless.

All the ideas of tab groups and much more is there but scattered all over the place.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by paulmd on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:51PM (#37095792)
> - from what i understood, they also "kind of" kicked Brendan Eich (yeah, Brave's CEO, the guy that invented JS, etc...) out over some "personal" things that had nothing to do with Mozilla

Was it for public statements that might be construed as creating a hostile work environment?

I don’t know why it’s so hard for leadership to just keep their nose clean, avoid making any sweepingly bigoted statements, do their jobs, and make their millions. If you’re an embarrassment for the company as an IC you’re gone, even if it happened in your personal life and not at work. Why should leadership be held to a lesser standard, especially when they actually do hold power over people’s lives and careers?

Its 2023 and we’re still doing the “blizzard defense”, employees just need to live with the hostile work environment, it’s personal beliefs/not serious, right? And while some companies might let you get away with it, the law is not exactly on your side either.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by FeepingCreature on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:08PM (#37106305)
Any political statement might be construed as creating a hostile work environment. CEOs have the right to voice political opinions off work just as much as anybody.

I mean, I realize that's a lost cause, but I still believe it.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Vinnl on Monday August 14, 2023 @07:03AM (#37119604)
Because it's the only non-profit browser maker, and the only one that explicitly has a mission to protect the free and open internet, so people care about it. There's just the risk of people killing it with love though.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by KingOfCoders on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:02AM (#37089487)
Mozilla got something of 6(!) billion(!) dollars if my mind serves me right.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by UtopiaPunk on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:53PM (#37091657)
What agendas are Mozilla pushing?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by johnnyanmac on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:12PM (#37094097)
> They got one billion dollars and they're reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead.

What else do you do with a billon dollars? Even a browser on FF's scale doesn't need a billion to operate properly. Most of that would go towards advertising and lobbying for stuff to secure their place.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by synergy20 on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:42AM (#37088052)
why hate firefox? I use it rarely on linux desktop but I use it a LOT on my android as it eliminates so many ads for me, from websites to youtube, it worked well.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by captainmuon on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:43AM (#37088067)
I think Firefox's addon policy is one of the reasons they lost market share. Moving from oldscool extensions to webextensions they lost their unique selling point. Firefox was the only browser that you could really theme. It's adblock existed earlier and was better than others (and is soon again due to Manifest v3?).

Especially for non-tech-savvy people, who don't know what a browser is, if they need a certain feature then you just replaced their chrome with firefox + this feature and they were happy. But if Firefox is just another Chrome clone, then it is neccessarily an inferior one.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mgbmtl on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:11AM (#37088295)
Firefox lost power-users because 1) performance was bad 2) Chrome does very aggressive marketing and various Google sites break randomly on Firefox. And performance was very often bad because of extensions.

Perhaps anecdotal, but whenever I ask a Chrome user why they don't use Firefox, that's the main two reasons they cite. I do ask often though.

What "certain features" do non-tech-savvy people need? I know lots of devs who rarely even know or care which browser they're using. Not to mention non-tech-savvy people..

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Firmwarrior on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:22AM (#37088407)
Firefox randomly broke all my extensions and workflows one day in the pursuit of some obscure technical goal, via forced update that I couldn’t roll back. I asked about it, and they banned me from their subreddit, so I deleted that stupid browser and never went back
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:32AM (#37088515)
And their constant user hostile redesigns. Suddenly tabs are floating separately from their pages. And now if a page is playing audio you can no longer see its favicon, etc

Speaking of mobile firefox where did Save as PDF vanish and why? and so on

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jamienicol on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:49AM (#37088654)
you can save as PDF from the "share" menu
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:30AM (#37089096)
Ah I see so it went into the "useless UI shifting" bucket rather than the "deleted features" bin. But I am happy to know it still exists thankfully.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:44AM (#37090001)
It's because of the salaried "UX experts". Paying somebody 6 figures to bikeshed the precise size and color of the home button is obviously farcical so they pretend to be more useful by making more dramatic changes, which amount to shuffling things around to make users relearn the software. They're ostensibly supposed to make things better for users, but in reality there's little to do on that front so they make themselves look productive by sabotaging users instead.

They can never provide rational justification for any of it. Their "data" arguments are farcical. Have you ever tried to push back against a UX expert's decrees? They can't rationally defend their changes with the data that supposedly informs them so it rapidly devolves into "your opinions on UX are invalid because you're an engineer. I'm an expert so you need to trust me." Salaried "UX experts" are a blight on software development; if their services are ever needed at all, they should be given a short contract with clearly defined goals.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:20AM (#37089700)
"The favicon will show a special icon to show you which tab started autoplaying some stupid video"

The utter horror. It's so user hostile to make an easy way to see which tab is the source of the annoying sound you are hearing.

Oh, and it doesn't hide the favicon unless you have so many tabs open each tab can only fit the favicon. So for probably the vast majority of users who don't spend their days with 300 tabs they never check constantly open, they don't see this.

So user hostile

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:38PM (#37093004)
Whats the point of it? The previous design showed both the favicon and the sound playing icon together? The new one does not show the favicon anymore. The old design never felt cramped or tiny or anything like this, so I call bs on this.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:46PM (#37093114)
SO I checked on a fresh profile with the floating separated tabs and all and there it shows some text underneath the tab saying playing, and the playing icon only when you hover the tab, taking the place of the favicon...which...is an even stranger behavior compared to the older design. It looks like the userchrome work to remove the gap between tab and page had caused the playing icon to show under it, which means i will have to work hard some more to combine both behaviors back to the older style ie no tab gap and both playing icon and favicon visible at same time. Either case I see no justification for this borderline bizarre change.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Sunday August 13, 2023 @04:30AM (#37107844)
https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1339535 https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1386107

Look what an unholy mess the new change to audio playing status has caused.

To summarize, in compact mode you will get the audio playing icon on a tab but it will hide the favicon in that case.

In normal mode, and only if you have a small number of tabs, you will find a tiny 'PLAYING' text instead. If you hover over it, you will find the playing icon...which will have hidden the favicon then.

UX geniuses with too much time on their hands.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Monday August 14, 2023 @07:01PM (#37127906)
Revisiting this comment to reiterate and make clear: the audio playing icon was always shown...but under the website favicon...the new design makes it so that only one of the audio icon or favicon is visible at a time.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by daveguy on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:47AM (#37088641)
I didn't go to Reddit, but extensions breaking was the reason I left on the desktop.

On mobile though... I switched back about a year ago, when I got sick of the ads on chrome.

If the choice is between being able to install uBlock Origin and Privacy Badger vs not being able to... I'll definitely stick with Firefox on mobile.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by kibwen on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:31AM (#37089113)
> some obscure technical goal

A multi-process architecture is not an obscure technical goal, it's an essential for modern browsing, and something that Chrome had from the outset, and is a large part of the reason that Chrome originally clobbered Firefox in both security and perceived speed.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by kasabali on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:12AM (#37098126)
That's misleading. Multi process support was implemented in Firefox 48. XUL extension purge was in Firefox 57.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:15AM (#37089627)
Ah, you mean the extension type that chrome NEVER supported? How does switching help here?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by herewulf on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:46PM (#37090785)
"Sam Adams stopped making the beer I like so I went into a random pub to complain loudly and got thrown out. Now I just drink Bud Light!"

Today Mr. Firmwarrior stands in the public square shouting about Firefox some more.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Firmwarrior on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:38PM (#37093006)
Yeah, I'm done with Firefox. The company is completely rotten and dysfunctional, and getting personally attacked by fanboys when I'm unhappy with something they do isn't going to change my mind.

If Chrome actually tries to force some crazy user-hostile breaking change like Manifest V3, we'll probably get enough pushback to see a really polished Chromium fork take off. Worst case, I can use LibreWolf as my daily driver

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by FeepingCreature on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:10PM (#37106321)
Making beer people like is the only job of a beer company.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by wintermutestwin on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:01AM (#37088766)
>Firefox lost power-users

There is no better vertical tab solution than FireFox + Sidebury.

If you are using horizontal tabs, you are not a "power-user" of a browser.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by hiatus on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:00AM (#37089451)
Sure there is, check out Arc browser.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by wintermutestwin on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:36PM (#37090659)
I hadn't even heard of that one until today. Thanks - I'll check it out.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:22AM (#37089721)
>If you are using horizontal tabs, you are not a "power-user" of a browser.

This is just such absurd, elitist, gatekeeping. WTF. How about just not have 400 tabs open? Am I really not a "power user" of my browser because I utilize the bookmark feature.

Get over yourself man

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by wintermutestwin on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:33PM (#37090613)
>How about just not have 400 tabs open? Because it allows me to access 400 tabs worth of information at a glance.

I am not "gatekeeping," I just think that you aren't using the "power" of the browser if you have <10 tabs open and limited tab name space. What's your definition of browser "power user?"

On my MBP, I have 10 windows (each with a title representing general category). In each, I have: up to 24 pinned tabs that take up three tab slots up to 30 regular tabs open that I can see without scrolling each of my tabs has 40 characters of name space, which is plenty to know exactly what the tab is

I'm sorry if my post came off as acerbic. I will admit that I am annoyed as hell that:

1. Chrome has such market share when it doesn't have a descent vertical tab solution

2. Safari's vertical tabs are a total joke and Brave's are barely better

3. Firefox doesn't have native vertical tabs so I have to rely on an extension and they make it a total pain to get rid of the horizontal tabs

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by II2II on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:13PM (#37091138)
Point 3 is why I don't use vertical tabs on Firefox. While I don't think that vertical tabs is a necessary feature, facilitating modifications to the UI via addons would be a huge win for anyone who wants to implement such features, or even experiment with different forms of user interaction.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by CWuestefeld on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:50AM (#37090082)
I'll look at that, but I really have to recommend TreeStyleTab.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by wintermutestwin on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:35PM (#37090635)
Sidebury has trees too, but you can turn it off, which I do because I want 40 characters of tab name space for each tab.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by FeepingCreature on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:12PM (#37106334)
Firefox + TabMixPlus. Multi-row scrollable dynamic width tabs.

Even still works on newest Firefox, assuming you install a sketchy extension and disable signature checking. Thanks for your contribution, Firefox, I guess, though I can't help but notice that you spent the past decade trying your hardest to make this addon not work.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by dawidpotocki on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:48AM (#37088108)
FF has had better adblocking capabilities than Chromium before Manifest v3 was announced

https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-b...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by dralley on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:48AM (#37089283)
No offense but you could only come to this conclusion if you've looked at literally zero data and are just shooting from your hip based on sporadic HN conversations.

Their market share was dropping for a long time before, and it was dropping for a long time after. And to the extent that switching addon models helped them improve performance during their big marketing push in 2017, it probably got them a few users back if anything.

A full half of Firefox users (even at the time) didn't use addons, and the majority of the rest only used one or two adblockers.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by aleph4 on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:53AM (#37089356)
Seriously, there's an amazing amount of shooting from the hip happening here.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by OkayPhysicist on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:42PM (#37091517)
I'd be extremely careful about using Firefox's analytics data. I can't find Firefox's telemetry coverage numbers (they gather the info, so it's probably out there somewhere), but it's not at all unreasonable to suspect that a lot of the "power user"-type interactions are correlated with an unwillingness to enable telemetry. Couple that with the fact that Firefox, as a relatively niche browser these days, has a selection bias for more techy-savvy users, and you have a recipe for extremely misleading statistics.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by paulryanrogers on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:41PM (#37090717)
Firefox can still be themed. Albeit less than before. IMO it was the right choice for security, even if it makes things more limited or awkward than before.

It also remains more blocking capable than Chrome, for those so inclined.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by nfriedly on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:55AM (#37088161)
I've complained a lot about the crippled add-on support on Android and other poor decisions Mozilla has made, BUT I also donate monthly and encourage everyone who asks to just use Firefox.

So I think that on the balance, I'm a supporter.

This decision, to finally re-enable add-ons on Android, is a good one and I applaud Mozilla for making it!

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by causi on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:58AM (#37088179)
all this has accomplished in the last decade is a decrease in market share

You are confusing cause and effect. We've been saying the same things as we watch Mozilla slowly strangle Firefox to death for a decade.

That said, this is great news. I'm very much looking forward to being able to capture embedded videos on Android and maybe even get back my precious DownThemAll.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:34AM (#37089867)
Here's the thing: Mozilla could literally be shipping 2012 firefox, and I wouldn't give a fuck, and I would still use it. Why? Because they don't spend their days trying to make the internet a more ad infested dumpster fire and prevent me from blocking ads.

Google is actively doing that every single fucking day with thousands of people working towards this goal, with Chrome being an essential tool in that process, as whatever chrome does, everyone else will be forced to do.

Why the fuck would you enable that, even for a little "convenience"?

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by FeepingCreature on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:13PM (#37106344)
> Mozilla could literally be shipping 2012 firefox

That's called "Waterfox Classic".

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:35PM (#37092952)
> We've been saying the same things as we watch Mozilla slowly strangle Firefox to death for a decade.

Absolutely not true. I still hear people talking about FF as if it is pre-quantum. They complain about how slow it is. But quantum made it faster and more secure overnight. There's still a lot of people who are complaining and have just never tried it after the big issues were fixed. Or they try it, there's a small cognitive dissonance because checks notes "the interface is horrible", and so they call it slow attempting to justify why they dislike it rather than making an actual criticism or giving it a fair shot. Come on, the UI is almost identical across the board with browsers.

And we're doing this for what... to give Google more power over the internet? I'm sorry, I think it is you who are confusing cause and effect. You participated in the monopolization of browsers and are suffering the consequences of it. Because of a little convenience. The path to hell is indeed paved with "good intentions." Little steps is all it takes to make progress over decades. Unless you can tell me there's a huge major problem with FF that outweighs the ad focused internet, then you have it backwards.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by causi on Monday August 14, 2023 @08:00AM (#37120035)
I'm sorry, I think it is you who are confusing cause and effect. You participated in the monopolization of browsers and are suffering the consequences of it. Because of a little convenience. The path to hell is indeed paved with "good intentions."

Firefox has been my browser of choice since v1.5. If I didn't use it I wouldn't need to complain about it. Its slide ever-closer to Chrome-hood is why we're disappointed.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by shultays on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:27AM (#37088468)

  all this has accomplished in the last decade is a decrease in market share
A crazy idea but maybe Mozilla also have some fault on that
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jauntywundrkind on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:58AM (#37089440)
It feels like Chrome's original protest was that extensions would be too slow.

But phones are so much faster now! And with MV3 chrome claims they have prevented a variety of ways extensions might be slow.

I don't know how Chrome can keep justifying this old old choice.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by KingOfCoders on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:00AM (#37089461)
With Web DRM this is over. Firefox dropped the ball and would only be useful with a high market share. As soon as there is Web DRM in most major sites, Google controls what browser is allowed to view a website and Firefox is out, Chrome will drop ad blockers. This is the long con.

(~30y Mosaic/Netscape/FF user)

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by robertoandred on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:12AM (#37089603)
Haha what? Since when does Safari not offer add-ons?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by paulryanrogers on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:49PM (#37090825)
On mobile? From 2007-2022, and it's still not as fully featured as FF.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by robertoandred on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:10PM (#37094684)
Anything is more fully featured than Firefox, since it didn’t have them at all.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by paulryanrogers on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:19PM (#37102287)
Did you mean "Safari"? Because it was Firefox that had them the whole time, albeit significantly fewer after Quantum update.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by robertoandred on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:07PM (#37102708)
Except the story you're commenting on is Firefox getting them soon.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by paulryanrogers on Saturday August 12, 2023 @03:58PM (#37103700)
Firefox is restoring access to more add-ons. Most were actually available to folks running Nightly or Fennec, yet with no guarantees all APIs had been ported.

Regardless, my point stands, Safari mobile lacked extensions for over a decade while Firefox was offering some on Android. Can iOS browsers even offer meaningful extensions so long as Apple forces them to be a skin on Webkit? (With Safari getting privileged access of course.)

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donatj on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:59AM (#37090190)
> Safari don't sorry(sic) add-ons at all

iOS and iPadOS Safari has supported extensions for a while now.

https://support.apple.com/guide/ipad/get-extensions-ipada7ca...

https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/get-extensions-iphab0...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by paulryanrogers on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:36PM (#37090660)
Only 11 years after the competition! Courage
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by lapcat on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:26PM (#37091296)
This comment makes no sense. The competition is mobile Chrome, which has no extensions, and mobile Firefox, which has only a limited number of chosen extensions. Literally from the linked article:

> For the past few years Firefox for Android officially supported a small subset of extensions

If you're referring to desktop, on the other hand, Safari has had extensions since 2010.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by paulryanrogers on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:37PM (#37094358)
Firefox Android had broader extension support before it was temporarily restricted, in response to an architecture shift. Still, there has been an addon capability for many years before Safari mobile saw any.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by lapcat on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:59PM (#37094572)
3 years is "temporarily"? https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/introducing-a-n...

And again, mobile Chrome, a much bigger competitor than Firefox, has no extensions.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by paulryanrogers on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:14PM (#37103832)
My point was that Safari iOS lagged behind the competition. Firefox was and remains a viable alternative, despite the anticompetitive measures that ensure Chrome's dominance.

3 years is a long time, yet for the impatient there is an escape hatch. I've been using it for years to get more add-ons into my Firefox install. And there were some extensions available during that period, which is more than none. Mozilla has been offering more choice and customization than a trillion dollar competitor for over a decade, and for some cases still does.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by barbariangrunge on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:32PM (#37090607)
My wishlist for firefox on ios: just make the important addons built-in: ublock origin, facebook containers, cookie auto-delete... really, that's about it.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by dzek69 on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:55PM (#37092444)
I'd love 50% of the world use Firefox. I personally can't - had some visual issues with it (each time I tried it, on different machines - sounds like unbeliveable bad luck, eh), I just don't like it, all the small annoyances just piles up.

I'm sad that Vivaldi uses Chromium under the hood, but that the only thing that has UX I need (and I don't even care about its slow UI and random crashes every few days).

But I'm always happy to hear someone uses Firefox.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by CatWChainsaw on Monday August 14, 2023 @10:22AM (#37121357)
(Samsung Internet isn't too bad for another forum website I use. At least it has the option to do tabs in lists as opposed to the unwieldy grids Chrome forced on users, deprecating tab lists...)
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by scoliosis on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:26PM (#37136738)
Samsung Internet is actually a shockingly good browser for Android, with native adblocking and dark mode for websites (that isn't atrociously slow like Dark Reader on FF)