News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by veave on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:28AM (#37086375)
Most of Firefox's publicity is based on the fact that they are "on your side". That means that they are held to a much higher standard. Pretending to be on the side of the user and then screwing users up over and over seems like wanting their cake and eating it too?

It's funny because, you know, I expect chrome to screw me over while I expect firefox not to screw me over but chrome has screwed me over fewer times than firefox over the years.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Gud on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:41AM (#37086448)
How exactly has Firefox “screwed you over”? I’ve used Firefox since it was called Phoenix… although I don’t like the governance of the project, I would hardly say I’ve been screwed over.

Firefox has been an amazing product since day one.

Meanwhile, Chrome has literally been developed to probe your ass for data they can sell to advertisers.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by veave on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:46AM (#37086484)
Last time it was 2 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36077360

In that thread there are a few more examples, most of them somewhat recent: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36077683

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:07AM (#37086619)
I have never seen these myself, being on FF for most of it's life, but I also fail to see how these "screw you over." Oh my god an ad! I better instead use a browser that has a built in keylogger and created the ad based internet! That'll show those assholes!
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by gmerc on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:23AM (#37086711)
Google: Let’s put DRM in the browser, hijack the address bar, webmanifest

Omg, firefox screwed me over by showing me an ad.

I see. I think no further illustration needed.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by iakov on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:59AM (#37087259)
Textbook whataboutism. Google is objectively evil, what that has to do with Firefox, my "user agent", showing me Disney ads?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by programmer_dude on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:28AM (#37088473)
Textbook idiocy. Whataboutism is not a phallacy when the discussion is about comparing things.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by CatWChainsaw on Monday August 14, 2023 @09:46AM (#37120953)
I have to ask... did you deliberately spell it "phallacy" because you mentioned 'comparing things'??
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by programmer_dude on Monday August 14, 2023 @10:20AM (#37121333)
No comment :)
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:37AM (#37089913)
When you choose to continue using the browser from the "objectively evil" company, helping them continue to push those objectively evil goals, because "firefox showed me A ad", because for some reason that is more screwing over your users than literally fucking the open internet....

It's astounding how far people bend over backwards just to not change browsers for the good of the internet as a whole.

"Yeah I could stop hanging out with a serial baby stabber, but the other guy once said my hat was funny, so that's terrible and I will stay with the baby stabber"

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by iakov on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:33PM (#37091407)
I choose to use Firefox, for more than a decade. It does not mean I am a happy user, and it does not mean that I can't complain about Mozilla being shittifed year after year.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Gud on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:07AM (#37088830)
Yes, the people in charge of Mozilla have been doing dumb stuff like this, eroding our trust.

Hardly screwing us over, though. They’ve been doing even worse things, for example constantly opting us in for “anonymous statistics” etc.

If it one day comes out they’ve been sharing this data deanonymized with 3rd parties, then you can say you’ve been screwed over.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by shinryuu on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:40AM (#37086439)
Perhaps that is because they screw you over in secret? Whenever Firefox makes a mistake it gets very publicised, but whenever chrome does it it's just business as normal so no one really publicises it.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:11AM (#37088873)
As far as I know Chrome doesn't use every possible opportunity to nag you about self-righteous BS on how they're better and more private than everyone else?

It's one thing to make a mistake or do user-hostile decisions inline with your business model. But it's another to loudly shout about how "good" you are (and everyone else is bad) and then do the exact same thing.

Same reason why a policeman or some law-enforcement figure gets more outrage for committing a crime than a normal citizen.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:48AM (#37090045)
Are you pretending that chrome doesn't advertise? Every single fucking day for a decade now, google.com told me to install chrome, and would even render "pop up" dialogs to that effect on google properties!!

What are you all smoking?

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:51AM (#37090085)
An ad telling you to install Chrome is one thing. I don't believe any Google nor Chrome ad had self-righteous BS about privacy, "improving the web" or similar like Mozilla constantly does.

Also, ads on websites are one thing. Ads/nags within the browser itself (which I'm already using) are another. I'm pretty sure Google doesn't bother advertising Chrome to users who already use Chrome.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:32PM (#37090611)
Okay, then how should mozilla fund firefox? They don't have billions upon billions in advertising revenue to backstop a project that exists only to exert more influence and control of the internet.

God damn, people act like money grows on trees when it comes to firefox. I don't care if they flub an attempt at advertising, like the Mr Robot nonsense, because mozilla isn't actively pushing "standards" meant to prevent me from some day being anonymous on the internet or blocking advertising

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:21PM (#37091228)
> Okay, then how should mozilla fund firefox?

Virtue-signalling and wasting people's times does not contribute to funding either. I'd disagree with but understand actual ads, or promotions for Pocket/VPN/etc... but wasting users' time on virtue-signalling or "Colorways"?

(look at my other comments for actual long-term funding ideas for Firefox)

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:02PM (#37093305)
> I don't believe any Google nor Chrome ad had self-righteous BS about privacy, "improving the web" or similar

I constantly see Chrome ads about privacy and security. Your argument also isn't consistent. Your complaint is that Mozilla has "failed" to achieve their stated goals. The quotes because they've definitely made progress towards that, but just not to your expectations. That is fine to have higher expectations, but you're literally discouraging Mozilla from working in that direction, where others aren't making those moves __at all__. Don't bite the hand that feeds you.

And can we stop copy pasting that line? You're starting to sound like a bot.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KyUIEYE13jE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfXnLAa6zWc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_u9_3umb5LY

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by BiteCode_dev on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:43AM (#37086462)
I've yet to notice any event where firefox "screw users over" that was not vastly overblown, especially compared to the competitors.

People tend to just judge Mozilla way more harshly.

It's very unfair: they do good, and we ask even more of them.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by worble on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:36AM (#37086788)
I know that its against the rules to imply this, but seriously, there is always so much vitriol that I just don't understand thrown towards Firefox every update that it really gets the old noggin get going.

Can we seriously not even contemplate the idea that there might be a certain corporate entity out there with a vested interest in ensuring that Firefox usage is kept deliberately low while at the same ensuring they _just_ enough funding to keep going so they can point to it and say "look, we're not a monopoly!"

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:42AM (#37089980)
How many members of this very forum are straight up google employees, complete with regular internal propaganda efforts to reassure employees that aktually, google is the good guys protecting you from the evil, politically driven mozilla?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:49PM (#37093148)
Honestly in my original comment I almost tried to make a joke about how this website calls conspiracy on far less. But I didn't know how to properly do it and so removed it. But yeah, you're not alone in thinking this looks like astroturfing. But I'm not entirely convinced it is not-natural. FF did fuck up in the past, but I think people are still angry about the browser 10 years ago and not updating their beliefs. I think there is also a bias because Mozilla is 501c and so their fuck-ups and everything is out in the open. It's like comparing a democracy to an autocracy, and thinking the autocracy is better because you hear that the people are doing well and never hear about things going wrong.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by FeepingCreature on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:16PM (#37106354)
I'm seeing a lot of "boo Mozilla" in this thread, but honestly I'm seeing pretty much zero "yay Chrome"/"yay Google". I think it's more like saying "this democracy has a lot of issues that make me angry" and getting the reply "so you prefer the autocracy? Damn fascist."
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by godelski on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:12AM (#37086652)
There's no better way to get someone to stop listening to you than to turn everything they do into evil. Which is an implicit point I was getting at in my original comment. The more people make mountains out of molehills, the more they are actively training Mozilla to just not give a fuck and ignore them. You can't have it both ways. You can't have a company that listens and works with you while you also vehemently attack it at every opportunity. I mean look around at the comments. There are people just taking the opportunity to attack them unrelated to the topic and people that are happy are "this is nice, but it could be better." It's amazing that people are more passionate about hating Mozilla than they are about airlines or their ISP. Or... you know... the people who scrub up all their data and turn it against them to sell shit, ideas, and make them hateful balls of anxiety.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by serf on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:34AM (#37087113)
they're the best game in town, but they've also gone against long term user-base wishes again and again to either 1) try to create wider popularity with feature parity (didn't work) and 2) to capitalize in inappropriate ways that are against the ideals first set forward.

It doesn't take a lot of mental effort to realize that the userbase left doesn't want telemetry and third party partnerships; Mozilla knew this, they tried to get away with it and lost goodwill.

It's not the thing, it's the attempt to get away with it that irks me. No one except The Paid wanted pocket integration and Mr Robot promotions.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:46AM (#37090023)
Oh you were definitely harmed by the company using their money to buy a semi-popular bookmarking alternative for their users, that someone probably thought their users would like to use, with zero requirement to ever use pocket. My firefox install hasn't even had the pocket icon in however long, I can't remember.

Meanwhile google is pushing an attempt to strangle the open internet to death, in the open, for all eyes to see.

But no, lets keep pretending that mozilla doing a poorly executed ad is comparable to THAT

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Nextgrid on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:06AM (#37088824)
> People tend to just judge Mozilla way more harshly.

It's a self-inflicted problem though. Mozilla uses every opportunity to claim they're on your side and want to protect you from the evil guys.

The nagging itself is annoying to begin with (and incomprehensible - at least ads make sense from a business point of view - but why interrupt my workflow to let me know about Colorways?), but it's made even worse with all their self-righteous BS about privacy while the browser actually being pretty poor (and not GDPR compliant due to default-on telemetry) in its default configuration.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:38AM (#37089184)
This opinion might differ from others but my main complaint is with their useless and sometimes hostile UI changes rather than the occasional ad for other Mozilla services. For example recently the change to tabs floating disconnected from the pages, which I had to use userchrome to override. Next problem I am trying to tackle right now is favicon being hidden when the audio playing icon is on a tab that seems to have been done in a recent update.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:43AM (#37089987)
>the change to tabs floating disconnected from the pages

What does this mean? My experience using tabs in firefox has not changed in like twenty years!

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by cpeterso on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:12PM (#37091111)
The "user hostile" tab design change was the addition of a space of a few pixels between the tabs and address bar: https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/1/22463321/firefox-design-re...
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:51PM (#37093178)
If they had just thickened the continuous bar connected to the tab a few pixels I probably wont even have noticed. Instead introducing a gap between the tab and its page completely changes its look making it seem like its floating separately and the tabs are independent buttons. But the point is either of these makes no sense at all. What even was the point of this weird change from the perfectly functional and normal looking tabs before?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by donkeybeer on Sunday August 13, 2023 @04:28AM (#37107834)
https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1339535 https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1386107

Look what an unholy mess the new change to audio playing status has caused.

To summarize, in compact mode you will get the audio playing icon on a tab but it will hide the favicon in that case.

In normal mode, and only if you have a small number of tabs, you will find a tiny 'PLAYING' text instead. If you hover over it, you will find the playing icon...which will have hidden the favicon then.

UX geniuses with too much time on their hands.