News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by the_gipsy on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:25AM (#37086048)
Declarative blocking is the weakest, it barely removes the simplest ads.

uBlock doesn't exist for iOS because it is made impossible by apple, their extension API is not a "full" API.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by drozycki on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:38AM (#37086124)
I haven’t seen ads on mobile Safari for as long as I can remember. Whether you choose to believe that is up to you. Can you point to an example where an extension like AdGuard would let an ad slip through?

Precompiled declarative blocking is more performant and power efficient than running a content script in a JS VM at page load, which matters on a CPU and battery constrained device.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by _thisdot on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:43AM (#37086151)
If anything, my problem is sometimes it’s too strong. Searching for a product on Google and clicking the Amazon links don’t work
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by ghostcluster on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:10AM (#37086283)
What's the best ad blocker for iOS Safari?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by eipi10_hn on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:33AM (#37086396)
It's not only the ads slipping through. Safari is so lacking in terms of API that for many sites with anti-adblock, the only way to bypass those are allowing tracking / ads connections.

Check the `@@` filters for `ios` here: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/AdguardTeam/AdguardFilters...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by the_gipsy on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:13AM (#37086653)
> Can you point to an example where an extension like AdGuard would let an ad slip through?

Yes, see Twitter.

I have AdGuard installed on iOS and I do see ads. I do not see them when opening on Firefox desktop with uBlock Origin. If I disable uBlock then I do see them like on Safari.

As I said, precompiled declarative blocking only works for the weakest of blatant ads. Of course it's "more performant and power efficient" because it only runs on the bare HTTP requests. That's not what I want.

> I was responding to a comment claiming that mobile Safari doesn’t support add-ons. Which is simply not true!

Fair enough. But personally I don't count Safari's extensions as real extension, just like I don't count Firefox' approach of a handful of "blessed" extensions for Android as real extensions.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by lapcat on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:33AM (#37087109)
> Yes, see Twitter.

Safari content blockers aside, Safari web extensions are capable of blocking Twitter ads.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by the_gipsy on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:59AM (#37087254)
AdBlock does not, so which one does?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by lapcat on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:01AM (#37087693)
Well... my own Safari extension Tweaks for Twitter does, but I recently discontinued it because I got sick of Twitter's shenanigans such as the strict usage limits, and I have no interest in supporting X, the so-called "everything app".

There may be other extensions, I don't know. In any case, the technical capability of the API is there.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by wildrhythms on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:01AM (#37089477)
You say

> Safari web extensions are capable of blocking Twitter ads

and then

> my own [discontinued] Safari extension [...] There may be other extensions, I don't know

So which one is it? And why the hell are you carrying water for Safari? I don't care that it's 'technically' capable of blocking ads, I just want the ads blocked!

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by lapcat on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:16AM (#37089641)
This is an unduly harsh reply. Please refrain from emotional outbursts against other HN commenters.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mst on Friday August 11, 2023 @07:57AM (#37087665)
Note that you've been able to use custom collections to get extra extensions on FF-for-Android for a while provided you put the browser into developer mode first.

It's a pain in the arse and certainly doesn't count as 'released' by any means but it's been at least just about possible for a while.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by eptcyka on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:56AM (#37086887)
I see ads on Safari on my iOS device all the time, whether you choose to believe that is up to you.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:30AM (#37086377)
uBlock doesn’t, but plenty of browsers have built-in adblocking, with one of the very browsers missing it being.. drumroll.. iOS Firefox!

Mozilla refuses to address how having no adblock is a security risk, so I have moved all my friends and family over to iOS Brave.

Firefox built its own demise by having a bizarre focus on woke stuff instead of features that users direly need.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by prmoustache on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:19AM (#37086688)
I think you reached the new modern Godwin point.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:38AM (#37088024)
I'm not sure what you mean by this (I do know Godwin's law).

The fact that HN is so full of dogmatic clowns they'll send a fact-based comment to -4?

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:31AM (#37089828)
Maybe your comment isn't fact based after all
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:16PM (#37093472)
- Firefox has been pumping out bizarre woke-language filled blog messages, the annoyance at this has even been upvoted to #1 on the frontpage of HN

- Firefox iOS has no real adblocking

- Mozilla has an issue for this open on both their Github and Bugzilla for years

- Firefox Focus does have real adblocking built in

Maybe trolls like you should leave HN :)

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by the_gipsy on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:20AM (#37086697)
iOS Firefox is just a re-skinned Safari, just like iOS Chrome because Apple has some rule against "dynamic code execution" in their AppStore.

Which sure is nice to combat some malware but not really MY problem.

It also coincidentally happens to also rule out ANY browser engines. Firefox and Chrome can only use the provided webkit "WebView" component. Apple has effectively crippled Browsers on iOS to Safari, or a worse re-skinned version of Safari.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:34AM (#37087979)
I don't really care. My less tech-knowledgeable social circle wants a browser that syncs across platforms and is safe. That immediately rules out Firefox for everyone with an iOS device.

Worse is that there is an iOS Firefox with full adblocking already built in: Firefox Focus.

So yeah, fuck Mozilla. You don't deliberately leave a segment of your users out in the cold like that

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Saturday August 12, 2023 @09:28PM (#37105762)
I have a huge grin on my face because you assholes got my other response to this flagged. Such an incredible feeling to know you guys can’t actually do anything meaningful. Enjoy plummeting to 0.000001% market share and fuck you :)
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by michaelmrose on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:26AM (#37086725)
Brave's adblocking seems decidedly worse than ublock origin. https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/16935 except on iOS where apple's restrictions are drastically limiting.

You are so insistent that the feature built in primarily because the platform you've chosen has limited your ability to do what literally every other platform can do. I know there are some benefits privacy wise to the Apple ecosystem but it appears that Apple continues to "refuse to address" the need for actual browsers other than safari on iPhone rather than skins on top of Webkit.

So neither party is doing what you please but you gave hundreds to thousands of dollars to one and nothing to the other so perhaps go ask the fellow who has all of your money if they can implement the feature.

Alternatively wait for some combination of law and or technology to work around Apple.

https://www.theregister.com/2023/02/03/googles_chromium_ios/...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:37AM (#37088010)
I've actually recently switched from using uBlock in Brave (desktop Brave) to the built-in blocker.

They both use the same selectable filter lists, so I notice barely if any difference.

I'll also scuttle Cookiebro once Brave's cookie auto-delete moves out of beta.

Less extensions means less attack surface.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:53AM (#37089354)
Selectable filter lists isn't close to uBlock equivalency, that's just table stakes for any adblocker. As far as I've been able to determine, in Brave there is no way to view a list/grid/matrix of which domains are being blocked and which sort of content is being blocked; this is a feature I use in ublock origin / umatrix a lot and don't wish to go without. (For this matter, ublock origin in advanced mode is claimed to have equivalency to umatrix in this regard, but if that's true I can't figure out how.) Also missing from Brave adblocker, as far as I can tell, is an interface for creating cosmetic filters. I use these frequently for removing things like floating headers and footers, and other obnoxious first-party elements that aren't ads but nevertheless degrade websites to satisfy some web designers random whims.

Here is an example of Brave's filtering falling short: http://0x0.st/H_YB.jpg

Do you see that wide gray box that says "Youtube Featured, RELEASED this week!" I consider that an ad for trashy commercial popculture slop, I hate it and want it gone. How do I remove it with Brave's blocker? I have ad blocking turned up to aggressive but it's still there. I can't figure out how to create a new cosmetic filter, Youtube is unusable to me without this. If I scroll down further I see similar boxes for "Trending", "Shorts", and "Celebrate World's Indigenous People's Day." All of this needs to go; in Firefox I don't see any of it because, with ublock origin, I created a cosmetic filter for ytd-rich-section-renderer. "Rich section" indeed...

Anyway, I didn't downvote your above comment, which is now flagged as well. Near as I can figure the "modern godwin" accusation leveled against you is either because you mentioned brave (is Eich claimed to be a nazi now?) or because you said Mozilla is being woke. Either way, a very stupid reaction to your inoffensive comment. This place is becoming orange reddit.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by antonok on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:46PM (#37093109)
FWIW, in Brave you can create cosmetic filters using the right-click context menu. `Brave > Block element`. There's a shortcut to the page where you can manage your custom filters in that menu, too.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by jorvi on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:17PM (#37093493)
> Do you see that wide gray box that says "Youtube Featured, RELEASED this week!" I consider that an ad for trashy commercial popculture slop, I hate it and want it gone. How do I remove it with Brave's blocker? I have ad blocking turned up to aggressive but it's still there

I have literally never seen this box. Something might be wrong with your config, either manually or due to Brave. Could be worth it to hit up Brave on their Github.

For what its worth, I was an uMatrix user in the past, but I got tired of the churn of constant tiny breakage (even if my regular set of sites was beautifully set up after a while). I know very well the ins and outs of blocking.

I did a trial run for a few weeks, alternating between uBlock and Brave blocking, and the difference was so unnoticeable that I just went cold turkey.

Brave has honestly been on a roll with their built-in security features:

- HTTPS upgrading

- configurable adblock

- fingerprinting protection

- WebRTC protection

- (soon) port-scanning protection, the first browser to do so

- (soon) cookie auto-deleting

> Anyway, I didn't downvote your above comment, which is now flagged as well. Near as I can figure the "modern godwin" accusation leveled against you is either because you mentioned brave (is Eich claimed to be a nazi now?) or because you said Mozilla is being woke. Either way, a very stupid reaction to your inoffensive comment. This place is becoming orange reddit.

Thanks for saying so! And yep. The funny thing is, all these dogmatic people do is strengthen the opinion of regular tech users like me. The more vindictive they get, the harder I try to steer away more and more people from Firefox.

Funnily enough its the opposite with Thunderbird. Since they had their split, their management is a lot more neutral and tech-focused and thus I try to get as many people back on that train as possible. I've even donated to Thunderbird, as those donations are specifically earmarked for Thunderbird only.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by endemic on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:50PM (#37090842)
I don't believe Mobile Safari has built-in adblock; IIRC you have to install a 3rd party content blocker. Funnily enough, Firefox Focus works as a content blocker, so when I browse with iOS Firefox it blocks the majority of ads.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by veave on Friday August 11, 2023 @04:33AM (#37086398)
>Declarative blocking is the weakest, it barely removes the simplest ads.

That's misinformation. It may not be as good as ublock origin (I don't know) but in my experience it removes practically everything.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by rpgbr on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:48AM (#37088107)
I’ve been using 1Blocker since day one and have nothing but praise for their product. Not as powerful as uBlock Origin, but pretty good nonetheless.