News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:31AM (#37088507)
> They got one billion dollars and they're reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead

Where have they announced that they're focusing on "agenda pushing"? Mozilla's "agenda" feels like a very tiny part of what they do, it's just that people talk about it endlessly.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by timtom39 on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:10AM (#37088860)
https://blog.mozilla.org/en/

Just read their blog. Latest three: - EU's AI Act - Fakespot school supplies? - Making trustworthy chatbots to support women plagued by violence and abuse

The first one might make sense? Second one WTF? And third is disgusting (I know people effected and the LAST thing they want is some chatbot).

None of these are related strongly to Firefox. I quit donating to them years ago after it was obvious they have their priorities messed up.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by dralley on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:41AM (#37089219)
The third one isn't something they're doing, it's the winner they selected in a "responsible AI challenge" competition.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:12AM (#37089594)
> the winner they selected in a "responsible AI challenge" competition

How is hosting "responsible AI" competitions not something they're doing? Sounds like a huge waste and a distraction from what should be their core mission of protecting the web by making the best browser they possibly can. If they want to dip their toes into the AI space to stay trendy and relevant, they could at least do it in a way that constructively relates to creating a web browser. Their local translation extension is a good example of this, they did a great job with it. They could do more, like maybe experiment with AI-guided adblocking or something. But a competition to create responsible chatbots? How is that relevant to Firefox? Besides the winner of the competition being stupid, the whole competition was stupid. What did they even hope to accomplish with such a competition, to sway the development of commercial chatbots from the likes of OpenAI or Facebook? They gave out $100k to the top 3 winners and not one of them has anything to do with making a better browser. If I'm wrong, then please explain how any of this relates to making Firefox better. Don't copy-paste their vapid corporate rambling explanation to me, if you can't explain it in plain normal english then it's bullshit.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:39AM (#37089937)
> what should be their core mission of protecting the web by making the best browser they possibly can

In your opinion. I disagree. They could spend a billion dollars on making the best browser the world has ever seen and it would still be used by next to no-one. People use the browser they're given, especially in the smartphone era we're in now. Android users use Chrome. iOS users use Safari, Mozilla isn't even allowed to make a real version of Firefox for iOS.

So they've clearly decided to expand their mission to protect the web. Ensuring AI is used ethically strikes me as relevant to the topic, a little too much like chasing buzzwords to my taste but it's clearly an area of current interest. And hey, maybe a few more people will learn about the Mozilla brand and consider converting to Firefox some day.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:53AM (#37090116)
> "They could spend a billion dollars on making the best browser the world has ever seen and it would still be used by next to no-one. [...] So they've clearly decided to expand their mission to protect the web."

Seems like you're now conceding matheusmoreira's point you disputed before:

> They got one billion dollars and they're reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead.

And you haven't bothered to answer my question, so I'll put it to you again: How does rewarding the development of a chatbot to talk about sexual violence relate to furthering their mission to "protect the web"? It's nothing more than the predictable synthesis of AI hype and a popular social cause, it has nothing to do with the web at all. If the best you can come up with is people will hear about this chatbot and then maybe they'll use Firefox, then why don't you just admit the whole thing is a farce?

And as for it being an effective promotion of firefox and "clearly an area of current interest", then where, besides Mozilla's corporate blog, have you ever heard of this chatbot competition or any of the three winners? The winner of the competition is "Sanative AI", never mentioned on HN before this comment. Do a general web search for "Sanative AI" tell me if any of the results you find are likely to inform people of Firefox's existence and benefits. I feel confident in asserting that this competition has not brought a single new user to Firefox, and was not in earnest ever meant to.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:00PM (#37090201)
> Seems like you're now conceding matheusmoreira's point you disputed before:

...no? I'm saying that no matter what amount of money they spend they won't make a browser that'll take over the world. It's an entirely theoretical point, not a statement about what Mozilla is doing.

> And you haven't bothered to answer my question

> If the best you can come up with

> why don't you just admit the whole thing is a farce

I'm out, man. Not interested in engaging in a discussion with this kind of shitty tone, there are a dozen better things to do with a Friday. Have a good weekend.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:08PM (#37090303)
You've lost the plot. matheusmoreira said they have a billion dollars but they're cutting back on development to focus on agenda spending. You disputed this, but a few comments later concede that they've deprioritized development because:

> "They could spend a billion dollars on making the best browser the world has ever seen and it would still be used by next to no-one"

And increased agenda spending because:

> So they've clearly decided to expand their mission to protect the web. Ensuring AI is used ethically strikes me as relevant to the topic, a little too much like chasing buzzwords to my taste but it's clearly an area of current interest. And hey, maybe a few more people will learn about the Mozilla brand and consider converting to Firefox some day."

You've as much admitted that matheusmoreira is completely right.

> "shitty tone"

Right back at you, buddy. Did I call you shitty? Not until now, to throw your insult back at you.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:42AM (#37089231)
How many software engineering resources do you think were taken up with writing those blog entries? Would it help if they posted a weekly blog entry entitled "Yes, we're still working on Firefox"?

I don't understand why everyone keeps talking about this as if it's an either/or.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by seneca on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:56AM (#37089402)
Because the things an organization talks about gives you an idea of their priorities and their values. If a technical org you otherwise supported suddenly started posting blog entries about how Hitler wasn't such a bad guy, and maybe they could write a chatbot to help correct misconceptions about Nazis, you would probably change your opinion about them, regardless of how much effort it took to write the post.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:45AM (#37090016)
Equating any of the three examples the OP gave with "Hitler wasn't such a bad guy" is... an interesting take. But nevertheless, you're only looking at one thing. Why not look at the Firefox release notes?

https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/116.0/releasenotes/

Three releases so far this month! Look at that technical organization iterating on its core product!

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by whatshisface on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:54PM (#37091673)
Someday HN may learn the difference between equation and comparison...
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by deprecative on Friday August 11, 2023 @08:18PM (#37095601)
Humans in general haven't so we'll hope for a better tomorrow, together, tomorrow.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by tuukkah on Sunday August 20, 2023 @05:13AM (#37197446)
It seems more likely that a part of HN needs to learn the difference between mathematics and human language.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by UtopiaPunk on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:56PM (#37091693)
Well today, the Mozilla blog is talking about extensions in the Firefox Android browser, so that seems cool?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Rebelgecko on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:48AM (#37089288)
I dunno if it's their "focus" but it's a big part of their PR. eg their lobbying to get Amazon and NextDoor to cooperate less with law enforcement. The Mozilla incubator has a goal of spending 40% of its money on social justice initiatives. Meanwhile they're cutting staff and resources for browser development, which IMO should be their bread and butter.
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:42AM (#37089978)
> eg their lobbying to get Amazon and NextDoor to cooperate less with law enforcement

Maybe that's a great example of the different ways you can look at the exact same thing. To me that's a privacy cause, and it's one I agree with. What percentage of Ring customers are aware they're providing the police with a direct feed of their front yard?

"Ring Reveals They Give Videos to Police Without User Consent or a Warrant"

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/07/ring-reveals-they-give...

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:19PM (#37092001)
The claim above, disputed by you: "They got one billion dollars and they're reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead"

"Privacy cause" is an agenda they're pushing. An agenda I happen to agree with, but promoting that privacy agenda is not software development spending no matter how you look at it. You can't reasonably claim these are equivalent just because you like them both. Telling people that Ring is bad isn't software development, a "different way of looking at it" doesn't cut it.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:39PM (#37092250)
Perhaps there was a time when Mozilla's sole monetary focus was development of the Firefox browser but if there was it was a long time ago.

There aren't only two pots of money in the Mozilla budget, one labeled "software development" and another "agendas", they do all kinds of things. An increase in "agendas" does not automatically mean a decrease in software development. Case in point: Mozilla used to have a "Mozilla Science Lab" from 2013-18[1]. When it was shut down there was presumably extra cash made available. Maybe it went to "agendas", maybe it didn't. And hey, maybe it couldn't: the foundation receives donations for specific projects, they're not able to just say "thanks for the money, we're actually going to spend it on something totally different".

To interpret this as a binary choice is an oversimplification.

[1] https://wiki.mozilla.org/ScienceLab

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by mcpackieh on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:56PM (#37092455)
Nobody said it's a binary. The claim is that they've reduced development spending, which is factual. They laid off a ton of developers, are you forgetting that? Or do you think that doesn't count as reduced development spending?
Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by afavour on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:23PM (#37092797)
> The claim is that they’ve reduced development spending

The claim was more specific than that: it was “reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead”.

Two factual statements:

1) the Mozilla Corporation laid off engineers

2) the Mozilla Foundation spent money pursuing “agendas”

I am suggesting that those two events are not necessarily connected to each other.

Re:Firefox desktop extensions coming soon for the upcoming A... by Vinnl on Monday August 14, 2023 @07:02AM (#37119593)
Mozilla is a non-profit, and Firefox is explicitly a means (one of them) to an end, i.e. a healthy internet as described in the Mozilla Manifesto: https://www.mozilla.org/about/manifesto/

There's definitely an agenda. It's one that's good for users IMHO though, as opposed to the agendas of the for-profit browser makers.