This is not a technical problem but a policy problem. The solution is changing the policy. The current policy is to drive up housing prices by creating completely artificial scarcity. All the land is owned and earmarked. Just not for housing. This problem exists in most wealthy nations. There is no shortage of space. Just of access to that space. Mostly that's completely intentional and reinforced by generations of politicians acting on the will of the people they represent to ensure that can never change.
You have NIMBYs and vested financial interests basically. Nobody wants their property devalued. So, social housing always is unpopular with the locals. Places like San Francisco where the homeless take dumps on Market Street are of course a bit extreme. But same principle. No shortage of space there.
But it's all reserved and off limits. So, the homeless are camping out there. In the middle of a city full of some of the richest NIMBYs on this planet. That's not a temporary solution. That's a slum and it is growing. Complete with people just shitting all over the place. Slums are what happens when you let things escalate.
This is true but not in the way that you mean. As you said there is no shortage of space. But it's important to point out that on a global scale there is no housing shortage either. Vacant dwellings outnumber homeless people by far in most industrialized countries where homelessness is rampant (for example: 3 million empty dwellings here in France).
You seem to imply the problem is housing regulations and NIMBY preventing new constructions, but who cares when the houses are already there. I agree with you the problem is that of policy, but i would say the policy responsible for that immense suffering is "private property", the religious belief that land should be owned and that a piece of paper should dictate whether you can sleep under a roof or not and/or have access to food/healthcare/education.
We can eradicate homelessness in under 48h: it's just that no politician cares at all about poverty from their ivory tower! Just give the police instruction not to intervene for "breaking and entering" in *vacant* housing (or even better, abolish police entirely) and we can rehouse every homeless person in the next two days. Of course it would take a few weeks to rehabilitate some of the housing unit and make them real decent, but even in the meantime old housing would be much better than no housing.
There’s a massive housing shortage in the United States and it’s acting like a vacuum, sucking up wealth and diverting it to landowners.
Good point, although i would like data to back that claim. For example in France, 200k empty dwellings are in Paris alone: this does not account for vacant industrial/office space which could also be converted to housing. In all cases, *proposing* (without coercion) homeless people a house somewhere does not sound inhumane at all.
> there are far more people living in overcrowded housing
Good point, too. Although as i said i would like to see data suggesting that the current real estate market (accounting for all vacant units) can't house everyone decently.
> There’s a massive housing shortage in the United States and it’s acting like a vacuum, sucking up wealth and diverting it to landowners.
To be clear, i'm not saying we should stop building houses entirely. But as long as you allow housing to remain vacant, prices are driven by speculation not by actual supply. I believe we should both rehouse homeless people immediately and keep investing in eco-friendly collective, affordable housing.
Source? A quick search only turns a figure half of that: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1290578/number-homes-par...
Also, just because it's "vacant" doesn't mean it can actually be used to house homeless people. It could be undergoing renovations, or on the rental market.
> Parkmerced is a neighborhood in San Francisco, California, designed by architects Leonard Schultze and Thomas Dolliver Church in the early 1940s. Parkmerced is the second-largest single-owner neighborhood of apartment blocks west of the Mississippi River after Park La Brea in Los Angeles. It was a planned neighborhood of high-rise apartment towers and low-rise garden apartments in southwestern San Francisco for middle-income tenants. It contains 3,221 residences (after sale of five blocks to San Francisco State University (SFSU)) and over 9,000 residents, and is one of four remaining privately owned large-scale garden apartment complexes in the United States.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Park_Merced
On my block, just on my street, there are over a dozen empty garden apartments, 2- and 3-bedrooms, that have been empty since (more-or-less) the beginning of the pandemic lockdowns. Folks started leaving and no one has moved back in. Next to my house there are three empty apt.'s to the left, one to the right, and four across the street.
The owners haven't lowered rents though.
The theory is that they would rather keep the rents high and the apartments empty than lower the rents because if they do that it affects their ability to raise rents later on (rent control is the only way I afford to still live here. For better or worse my family pays less than half the market rate. However, as I am describing, the market rate is not "clearing the demand" or whatever the economic jargon would be. No one is renting at "market" rate right now.) The other problem is that rents going down affect the valuation of the property, something like that. IANAEconomist.
Anyway... There are literally hundreds of perfectly fine apartments ready to rent here in Park Merced, with the M line light rail going directly to downtown SF in about 20-30 minutes and a BART station in walking distance.
- - - -
Get this.
Some folks moved in to the place across the street on Monday, but then Wednesday the staff was here kicking them out: they were squatters. I spoke to one of the staff who told me that this was a group of people who were breaking in and squatting in units all over the property, that they had changed the locks on the house they tried to squat in, and that he had called the police, who asked if anyone was being violent (no) and then still hadn't shown up an hour later! They never did show up. The squatters moved all their stuff and their two dogs back into their vehicles and left.
We need to make it easy to use the the housing we have, build more housing (of any kind) and subsidize those who need assistance.
Isolating price controls as some kind of glaring inefficiency in an otherwise rational system sounds like ideology, not reason.
It should be manifestly clear that an unregulated market has not served us well for the issue of housing, not just for the indigent but for all non-wealthy individuals and families who spend well over 50% of their income now on rent or mortgage payments.
Attacking rent control in isolation is irrational. Yes it can create a bad situation for landlords in the absence of any other policies designed to mitigate the disaster we are in. But saying that "market efficiency" is the answer is just sticking your head in the sand.
Anyway, the OP's point stands: there are perfectly good homes going empty. They aren't out in the woods. They are right here in SF.
The bottom line (no pun intended) is that the corporation that owns Park Merced has (presumably) done the math and they expect to make more money by keeping the apartments empty and eating the losses now (and paying the overhead of evicting gangs of squatters) so they can rent them later at the "correct" market rate (a pretty likely speculation, I'll grant them) than by renting them at a market rate that fills them up again now and getting locked in to rent control at the new, lower rates later on.
So, in other words, the poor people can't live there because someday soon the rich people will almost certainly want to live there again.
What you suggest would instead let the poor people stay in the apartments until the rich people wanted back in, so I guess that's an improvement?
But I don't follow how getting rid of rent control would incentivize supply increases?
Leaving units empty, or locked into lower-than-market rates are going to reduce the average profitability of investments. Investment in new units is in part a function of how profitable they will be sell, or to rent out.
But honestly the incentive for bay area real-estate is there, what really is needed is the ability to build with fewer encumbrances.
> That seems like it would make for a pretty precarious living situation for people who can't find ways to pay the correct market rate, eh?
Yes, this is generally referred to as gentrification. But, renting, even to poorer people, nevertheless is still usually profitable, albeit with more risk requiring a larger portfolio.
I always wonder about public transportation. It never really took off in the US, but it IS way more efficient. If we had very fast subways / trains, we could theoretically stretch housing way out away from the city. Then there is more equal opportunity for jobs / attending universities without living on campus.
I know this is a bit off topic, but it always seems to me like having QUALITY public transportation is efficient, but I can't quite defend it.
Not even to the exclusion of cars. For example I know a lot of workers who drive their car to the subway station in Toronto (and other cities) and then spare themselves the traffic and gas cost of sitting on the highway for 2 hours. And this is the ONLY solution for a big city, since most can't afford to live by the jobs/colleges (even suburban single-bathroom costs are over a million 40 mins out from downtown).
EDIT: I can see residents downtown paying the most taxes being against it though - all it does for them in personal terms is erode their power. Makes their real estate cheaper (removes exclusivity of quick access to offices / educational facilities) and makes the downtown areas accessible to people who can't live there.
> I can see residents downtown paying the most taxes being against it though - all it does for them in personal terms is erode their power.
It could also help subsidize their taxes to some extent since commuters are occupying offices and spending money in the city without occupying housing. Depends how things are set up. I don't think the people living in Manhattan resent people commuting from Jersey or Queens for work.
I spent some time in the Soviet Union before the wall fell. It sucked. Idealistic ideas like this destroy housing for everyone.
I think that in order to protect it's ability to offer a first world living by it's communities, the US needs to fatten up it's middle class with better wages. There could be a number of ways to do that, but the basic goal is to get more money into the hands of the average American so they can spend it in the community and make the whole country better.
A better way would be to protect people by not making policy decisions that reward bad behavior and punish those who avoid debt and save. Rewarding terrible behavior may get you elected but it’s bad for society. Like giving candy to pacify a cranky baby.
But such opinions have become verboten now, and actually censored.
That's not the problem either, the scarcity is (with the exception of foreign - i.e. Chinese and Russian - money laundering) natural and not artificial. The true problem is that following mechanization in agriculture many people emigrated from rural areas, resulting in a lack of infrastructure because it was unsustainably expensive for the low population density - particularly high speed internet and accessible (=walkable or within reach with a bicycle) basic infrastructure such as a grocery store, a GP and pharmacy and schools. That lack drives more people away, it's a vicious cycle that will need enormous amounts of money to break through.
If you want to work a modern service-oriented job or even a manufacturing/industry type job, you have to move to an urban or suburban area, and even if you have money and want to provide gainful employment you simply can't because there is no high-speed Internet for your business.
What needs to be done is that the government aggressively invests into "flyover" states to provide perspectives for the people living there and considering moving to a better place - but unfortunately I don't see that happening, not in the US and not in Europe where we have similar problems.
Fix the policy and house prices will drop. That creates a new problem of course for those who then end up with a Mortage that is under water. That's the real reason the policy does not get fixed.
Thanks but no thanks. I'd rather like if people can move towards rural areas where possible.
That's counterproductive. Infrastructure for rural areas costs way, way more.
That happened at the latest 40 years ago (in fact it happened more than a century ago), while house prices went crazy roughly after 2000.
It began earlier, the problem (why the situation in urban areas exploded) was that after ~2000-2005 it simply became apparent that the future was the Internet and there was no way government or much less the private companies would ever put up the money to provide actual high speed Internet to rural areas - and so all the new "digital" companies set up shop in urban areas, and people flocked to where the new jobs were.
Had the US government taken care to make sure that the companies not pocket literal billions of funds without providing the service that the government funded [1] you would not be in the mess you are now.
[1] https://eu.jsonline.com/in-depth/news/2021/07/14/weve-spent-...
Essentially, a big corporation could buy cheap rural land close to a big city, develop a small city there and reap the "overpricing" benefits.
But it's very expensive to build the basic infra. And even more expensive to convince enough people to move there and create minimum network effects for it to become a "real" community and livable space.
Yes, we can and should regulate markets, and we probably all agree that the purpose of the housing is for people to have a roof over their head, as opposed to use housing as an (speculative) investment market. This can easily be regulated via taxes (on ownership and transactions), but it comes with a caveat: if something is over-regulated to benefit the user, then there is less incentive for investor/landlord to build housing, which makes housing scarcer and drives prices up.
There are some commodities we choose to operate as natural monopolies because competition and profit seeking leads to bad outcomes for society. My argument is fundamentally that housing is the same.
No, not at all. We don’t choose natural monopolies. We recognize them. The whole point is they are naturally occurring whether we want them or not. Housing shares nothing in common with the other services you mention which are anything but commodities!
The natural monopoly of the electrical company isn’t electricity, it’s distribution. Power is a commodity, and delivery is anything but.
Your argument that housing is the same is not well informed.
Public services are not a "natural monopoly". They are a deliberate political choice (that was paid in blood by the lower classes, see also Haymarket Affair for example). We could very easily make housing free for all, or just affordable (see also HLM program in France).
As you note, there are other ways to pay for things than money. Whether it's "paid in blood" or other barter system, there is always a cost to pay.
> We could very easily make housing free for all, or just affordable (see also HLM program in France).
Would love to hear your very easy solutions. Affordability is relative. If you have more demand than supply (as we do with housing) the only way to increase affordability in real terms is to shift the supply curve. This shift is not free, and somebody has to pay for it. This is where the "omg it's so easy" arguments typically fall apart.
I meant the social rights/protections had to be paid in blood. But nothing in itself requires payment. We just happen to live in a society which commoditizes everything. If everyone worked some field they're passionate about (and people are passionate about many things) and we evenly shared the work for undesirable jobs (eg. cleaning) we could have everything for free.
> If you have more demand than supply (as we do with housing)
This is highly uninformed. In many countries around the planet, empty dwellings easily outnumber homeless people so we don't need to build anything at all to house everyone. Moreover, if we just stopped tearing down housing and started renovating them, that's also much less work/resources. Finally, if you really want/need more housing, a government run program (such as the HLM i mentioned before) shows you can build affordable housing for 10-30k€/appartment and rent them for a final user cost (after government help for housing) of under 100€/month.
It's a shame like all public services across France the HLM system is being corrupted and coopted into money-making machine. The buildings in popular neighborhoods go unmaintained while administrators pocket all the money, and the little that's left goes into developing higher-classes "HLM" housing which we popular classes can't afford.
Nothing is free. As you say yourself, everything requires work. This is just physics.
> This is highly uninformed.
Ok sure, I'll bite. Your understanding of supply and demand is extremely naive. An empty dwelling does not mean excess supply. If I own two houses, it's because I want two houses. It's not because we have too many houses. In fact, hoarding is a classic sign that we don't have enough of something.
I think you ought to step back and understand why the things you mention exist. You will find out more by doing that than you will shouting into the void on HN. If it were as easy as you proclaim, we would be doing it. The world is not stupid.
You can have a regulated market that still has prices. OP only proposed incentives to build and disincentives to hoard. Homes would still have prices, there would just be less scarcity.
You could reward developers for lots that have long wait lists and lots of interest, incentivizing developers who build places people want to live.
Start from a position of "everyone gets a home" and then ask "in that case, how do we make sure folks who end up in less desirable homes are compensated?"
I suppose you could frame it in the language of prices, but in this case the price is paid to the tenant.
Yes.
And now they are “clawing back” future price appreciation because it’s literally like winning the lottery if you get a place in a prime location as public housing is heavily subsidized.
If you get selected for a prime area apartment it’s a huge financial win 5 years down the road when you sell at market prices.
And oh yes, Singaporeans game the hell out of the system. From carefully falling under household income limits, to bidding on a new public housing unit despite owning one now.
The government is constantly trying to keep up with all the new incentives each new rule creates.
I would also hope that we would tend to build fewer mansions in favor of more multi family complexes, cohousing, coops, and small community oriented housing on the beach.
We can improve things, we can do social good, and never slide to authoritarianism. (I assume you are talking about authoritarian communism vs, eg, council communism.)
I think it's easy (well reasonably) to do if resources are plentiful, but what do you do if there are more people than resources available to support them, who starts making the hard choices?
On the basis of geography alone, housing can not be a commodity.
When you take the other things, like job and where you want to send your kids to school it becomes a hell of a lot more fungible.
Given that commoditization is a scale, I would say it could be toward that end of the spectrum if we wanted it to be.
Commoditization is only a scale inasmuch as the underlying goods are fungible. Corn is a commodity because nobody cares about differences between individual kernels, but if some process came around that only worked with super-specific kernels, then you'd be reducing the commoditization of corn.
I can, however, think of nothing that would make housing even close to fungible. Views, neighborhoods, neighbors, noise, history, location -- the list of things which are entirely unique per property is higher than basically any other market I can think of.
If you're without a home, one house is very much like another. It's only once you have money and ambition that you might want a better view, better schools.
You might say "your right to choose between houses is a privilege", but literally every culture in the world is going to observe differences between two houses, regardless of how they're allocated.
Even considering buildings where every unit has an identical layout, and all residents have access to the exact same amenities, one unit might be closer to the elevator and one unit might be closer to the garbage chute. These are fundamental differences between these units which make them not interchangeable.
> Endless rows of apartment buildings, each identical, supplying everything you could need.
"Providing everything you could need" is not how we define commodities. Fungibility is how we define commodities. One can argue that we should just be thankful with whatever home we get, but trying to act as if they're equivalent is just wrong.
Particularly if you're poor, location matters a lot.
The very rich will build a mansion in a beautiful but inaccessible area and commute to work by helicopter. The merely rich have the nice cars to get to work. But the poor have no car so need to be either very close or within public transport (mostly nonexistent in the US) to get to that job.
Fungibility is the absolute incontrovertible likeness of two separate units to the point where they are entirely interchangeable across all parties in the economy.
US dollar bills are fungible. Even BTC are not entirely fungible anymore. Houses are not even remotely fungible.
That's why houses a priced individually. When you go to the grocery store, they don't individually price each cob of corn. There might be two different buckets with a differentiator (organic vs non organic), but within the bucket each cob is fungible. It doesn't matter which one you grab.
Each house gets its own bucket.
Similarly, one unit of electricity from solar is the same as a unit of electricity because a kilowatt hour is a kilowatt hour. You could say well my unit of electricity is better because Elon Musk sold it but for the most part they do the same thing.
Housing is not that very interchangeable. For example, in the Denver area in Colorado apparently the Cherry Creek area commands a higher sticker price because of the school district.
Some homes are just more desirable than others. For me, I desire:
* Excellent public transit
* Excellent symmetric high speed fiber optic Internet connection to the home
* Costco or Sam's Club within half an hour or inexpensive grocery stores within walkable distance
And there are unspoken assumptions like somewhere an ambulance can get to me in time if I am dying and take me to a hospital so good roads and proximity to a good hospital.
Those payments are the equivalent of rent in the housing market. The thing that isn't a market and isn't being bought and sold is the right to provide those services, it's the power grid and generation plants, or the garbage infrastructure. The monopoly on those is what is anti-market and is the equivalent of not being able to buy and sell property.
I'm not making a political point there, I happen to thing some thing are natural monopolies and that markets have their limit. Housing is a complex issue in this respect. Flats in big city blocks are much like a commodity and limited urban building space naturally reduces competition, while nice houses in the suburbs or country are very much a market with lots of options suiting different needs.
It's not a market for you, but it is to your provider. And it naturally impacts the cost that's layed upon you, whether directly through electricity bills or through taxes if it's subsidised.
This doesn't ring true, it just moves the incentive to people to build housing to live in them selves, and with less competition in the market it would drive prices down.
It's helped a lot here.
I don't think that social housing is a good solution. It's a complete disaster here in Sweden, with 12+ year waiting times, and massive inequality between those who have those rent-fixed privileged first hand contracts and those stuck in the unregulated wild west of second hand renting. Often resulting in the working poor effectively subsidising wealthier, older people to keep their very cheap flats in the city centre, etc.
To expand on this point, and a similar system in Finland called asumisoikeus:
Municipalities have a pool of housing units. The tenants do not buy the house itself, they buy a right to live in that house, which usually costs about 10% of the price of the house, reimbursed when they move out. They also pay a rent that takes care of the energies and depreciation of the house. Socio-economic status is taken into account when figuring out who's eligible
Now, there are some criticisms of the system, mainly that the rents aren't that much lower than commercial properties. However, it does keep house prices in check. 100m^2 (~1100 sqft) house in the capital region is about 9 years of average take-home income - or 5 years for a couple
In the BRF system, you literally do not "buy the place you live in", you instead buy the right to live there. The actual ownership of the property is with the BRF.
The word is "bostadsrättsförening" [1] which roughly translates to "living rights association" or something (Wikipedia uses "housing cooperative" so I guess that's the best).
The word "förening" is hard to translate, the closest seems to be "voluntary association" [1], it is a formal collection of people with some common purpose (like managing a house). There are legally various types with varying requirements, and so on.
Edit: spelling, more linkage.
It would have been a massive financial burden and personal inconvenience if I had to buy/sell every one of those times.
I swear some of the policies people on here come up with are so poorly thought out.
We ended up paying the same price for relatively similar flats, but in BCN that's much harder to achieve, and they are older and need renovation - and there are thousands of AirBnB slumlords buying up everything.
So yeah, the price increases have been a problem (and hit me badly combined with the interest rate increases) but it's still better than most of Western Europe.
Heavy taxation on NPD (non-primary domicile) housing solves this by itself. It's just that convincing people this is in their best interest will take a lot of effort - not to mention that there's a fairly ubiquitous problem of local politicians being in the pockets of property developers in the areas where these problems are at their worst.
People still believe that their home is a good investment, without any thought given to who's going to buy it from them later or where that person will be getting the financing.
There’s no need to micromanage tenant-landlord relationships or setup governmental panels on who historically deserves to live where, if the government can just make sure there is an oversupply of decent housing at all affordability levels.
The rest really takes care of itself at that point.
Markets and competition work really well on frontiers in a situation where basic things are covered, because like this more people can participate freely.
There are many things that we have figured out to a pretty high degree and that benefit from collaboration and (very) long term thinking. I think housing, transport, basic medicine/treatment and perhaps to some degree food and water belong to that category. You can always have the luxury/explorative version on top with markets and that model works pretty well where it is applied.
To contrast, if your under such financial stress so you constantly worry whether some big bill is coming your way or you cannot even afford the very basics, then your stuck in a perpetual loop. Landlords, collectors and even police come knocking. It takes a lot of courage, discipline and enough luck and stamina to get out of this. In my opinion this is a a monumental task and effort _wasted_ on a inefficient and short sighted system of power relations.
The labor that the farmer puts in should absolutely be rewarded. But the labor of a farmer is absolutely nothing like a landlord who makes money purely because they had enough money to buy housing. Plenty of landlords hire property management firms, and do little to no labor at all, but still make a profit.
That modality doesn't exist in farming and food the same way it does in housing today.
People mischaracterize the ease in which landlords make money. Take the past two years and eviction moratoriums for example. Landlords in the United States in many areas had to allow tenants to rent without being able to remove them for non-payment.
Landlords inherently have to be well capitalized in order to properly maintain the house as most individuals are not experts in all trades.
I wouldn't have called you a hypocrite even if you didn't pay back anything. Living in the real world™ doesn't mean you can't criticise it. If we can't challenge things we take part in, how do we improve anything?
The nominal assumption is that they must have earned that by providing someone with something of value to them. The money they receive is a formal/cultural recognition of their indebtedness -- that they have provided something useful but have not receive anything of material value in return. Money is a way of claiming something useful in return for something they had provided, but separated in time and place.
Of course this is the theoretical and intended mechanism. It does get subverted in many ways when one earns money without providing anyone with anything materially useful. Inheritance can be interpreted as one such. Although it can be interpreted charitably too -- dont compensate me for the goods and services I provided , I am dead, compensate Saul instead.
whence did the money originate? from loot or labor?
Living in a teepee is looking more attractive by the day haha.
Reality is landlords are in all different situations, some have spare money above costs of interest, rates, insurances, rental agent fees, etc etc and can use that to pay for maintenance. Many are putting in their own money to pay for maintenance, the same way they put in their own money to afford the deposit and purchase costs.
And when there's a problem a landlord can't just ring the first inflate-a-quote contractor and open up the unlimited checkbook you seem to be ascribing to them, they will be bankrupt very quickly if they did. Instead, they have to assess the issue, try to find a economical solution, get multiple quote and spend time finding a contractor who can do it reasonably well the first time at an affordable cost. That is not the same work as a farmer, but it sure is work. If it's not done the house quickly becomes unlivable with a broken toilet or whatever and being unlivable is also unrentable and produces no value to anyone. It's work, and it's important to keep the house functioning.
Really as you seem to think landlords do nothing but profit, similar to gnomes and underpants, perhaps you should give it a try yourself. If nothing else it will be quite a learning opportunity!
However no matter what, no landlord can maintain all aspects of the house alone. You think a single person can be a master of all trades and have all equipment on hand all of the time in an apartment, for instance?
Why does it even matter if someone pays others to maintain the house? Do you think there are people who build modern houses alone with no machinery?
Overpriced or not, people still buy.
If he wrote "immoral", then you could ask why he thinks that.
But good point, immoral is probably more correct.
The problem is, that is outright impossible in urban areas where almost all space is already built out, not to mention it is immensely wasteful (8% of all CO2 emissions is caused by the manufacturing of concrete!).
Governments should rather look into making rural areas livable again (by subsidizing basic infrastructure such as internet, grocery stores, doctors and public transport).
If you have a pastoralist dream, feel free to build rural housing units. But for the government to spread out the country and then try to connect it using extractive transportation technologies (gas, batteries etc) just seems like roundabout / inefficient way to achieve the same goal.
And schools, churches, youth soccer leagues, parks, and playgrounds
Government 10 bedroom, 9000 sqft seaside mansions? Not just no, but hell no!
I do not support government assurance nor ownership for the high-end or luxury levels of affordability.
In an actual market, margins are competed away and prices drop over time, there's elasticity in supply and demand, and people don't view their 15-year old cars or whatever as "investments", they trade them up for a newer model and pass down the older stuff to people who can't afford them as much.
In housing, we artificially constrain supply with zoning laws and building codes, and we stimulate demand with subsidized mortgages and rent control laws. It's pretty much the opposite of what you want to do if you want there to be more affordable housing.
Also odd is how these HN threads on housing often devolve into redesigning a socialist utopia from scratch in America, as if such a radical revolution has any chance, when Californians can't even organize enough to get Prop 13 repealed. Removing red tape and zoning to get to a more efficient market is much more achievable.
Housing is already barely a market. An actual market would be much better.
We artificially restrict the construction of new housing supply by policy and then act all surprised when demand exceeds supply and prices skyrocket.
The same thing is happening in medicine: we artificially constrain the training of new MDs and then act all surprised when demand exceeds supply and prices skyrocket.
Then people come out of the woodwork with "oh look markets aren't working!" -- but in fact the markets are working exactly as designed: those with control over the supply are acting to constrain the supply, in the process enriching themselves at the expense of all others. But instead of recognizing this fact, we look for other reasons. Sure, there are other reasons and interactions, too, but the primary drivers are supply constraints!
Imagine if we explicitly forbade the construction of new grocery stores, forced farms not to use modern agricultural techniques, causing reduced yield, and then bought up a bunch of farmland just to take it out of commission. What would happen? Food prices would, obviously, skyrocket! That's exactly what we're doing with housing.
Your proposed solutions probably won't hurt, but aside from making it easier to build housing, they're noise. In particular:
> upzone neighborhoods
This is the only one that matters -- and it needs to come with other changes too, including construction "by right", that is, without needing to go through a 3-year process of fighting with neighbors who will try whatever they can to prevent new construction because they've been convinced it will destroy their neighborhood and/or property values.
> changing tax incentives so developers are incentivized to build more housing and less luxury housing
We don't need to change tax incentives to get developers to build more housing, we just need to stop preventing them from building more housing. Developers are not sitting around waiting for incentives, they're actively being denied the ability to build. Let's fix that.
How do you or we decide it's not a market?
If people are paying money for housing, it's a market. And it's not just money, but the largest lifetime expense by an order of magnitude and more.
> I'm also of the much more radical opinion that we should protect tenants over landlords in nearly every case
That's already the case, at least in many places (I know not all). If you take it too far the result is no landlords, thus no rentals. Perhaps that's ok if everyone wants to buy, but if there is anyone who wants to rent, it's useful to have rentals.
That's where everything went wrong. At 0-1% interest you can get insane mortgages for 90-95% of the value of the property, pushing the price up to where people spend every last cent they can on mortgages, but at $xxxx per month you can easily afford hundreds of thousands of dollars in mortgages.
Raise interest rates (happening), go into recession, crash the market, stop people getting mortgages, house prices will drop insanely fast and hard.
Of course no government wants to do this because it will panic the home owning class. Well - you have to chose at this point. Make it impossible for young people to buy a home, or piss off homeowners.
All the forfeited houses from the people who cannot serve their mortgages will flood the market and drive down prices.
Additionally, all the surplus construction infrastructure will be there, fighting for every project, which will make new houses cheap.
I used to think this.
How does your model change if there is a large pool of private equity, ready to buy properties for cash, and turn them into rental units?
Assuming this pool can easily handle the flood (which it looks like it can).
Private equity can only make a profit if they corner the market and hold back units until prices massively increase.
This is possible to some extend but at its core it is most likely illegal because it requires collusion or a monopoly. So if that's an option, then there is a bigger problem than just housing prices.
But even in an entirely corrupt market, private equity cannot beat the market after Covid. Home office has become fully acceptable so huge fractions of the population are not bound to a specific city. People are free to choose where they live. There will be some municipalities that offer an abundance of housing so that prices will stay down.
Then, once people move there, companies will be founded there or move there, too. Wages will be lower because costs are lower, which will be a huge problem for the companies that didn't move.
So if the established municipalities allow the private equity companies to profit, they risk their own demise.
However, this depends on the willingness of the people to move. It is also contradicted by silicon valley being able to maintain its large housing prices.
My guess is that prices will rise for a while but some Asian city will crack the code and offer cheap housing despite being a cultural center which would make it the technological capital of the world.
If we are talking about a recession caused by fed tightening, PE won’t have any money. Especially as higher interest rates will mean they also can’t borrow lots to finance purchases or anything
It is a mess.
If you like your house and your neighborhood, you probably don’t want demolitions and construction, even if it’s not your house. It’s noisy, it brings uncertainty, and maybe when your neighborhood won’t be the same after buildings get replaced. Maybe the new buildings are too ugly or the residents undesirable or the infrastructure unable to keep up. Or maybe none of those are true but you personally are anxious from the thought of change so you don’t want to risk it.
In any case, the no-change crowd holds all the power except when those pursuing change have a lot of money. This further reinforces negative impressions of what it means to allow change in your neighborhood.
One solution to this would be to guarantee a unit in any multi family or apartment building to the current resident, and pay for their relocation while the new unit is being built.
Alternatively, buy units from people who are leaving or who have passed away.
We do need to knock down some houses to build more housing, but we can do it in a way that is minimally disruptive.
You are just increasing the cost of the building's rent with this stuff. You'll have a few birthright units and everything else will be luxury to cover costs. This is the same problem we currently have with affordable units, huge missing middle.
We can choose to pay for housing for everyone, we just have to adjust the formulas we use to decide who benefits.
We’ve also seen, during this pandemic, what happens to rental prices when landlords are powerless over tenants. They go up. And landlords discriminate harder against tenants who look like they’ll be bad tenants if they can’t easily evict.
And just as my ability to get sued is what allows me to enter contracts, my ability to get evicted is what lets me pay cheap rent.
That's just a loopback to where you started. When government pays, you pay.
Today, if I cannot pay, I get no housing. Taxes allow us, as a community, to decide that we should all chip in a little bit extra (commensurate to our means) to make sure everyone has a roof over their heads.
Also, government operated facilities do not have a profit motive, so there's less incentive to maximize the cost of housing.
Great, so the shit-show we have now, except without any incentive to efficiently spend. Sure that will go over swimmingly. Everyone knows that government construction projects are known for coming on-time and on-budget, and for the best value.
Additionally, there are numerous governmental restrictions on minimum square footage, sometimes onerous building codes, impact fees, and zoning restrictions to name a few.
Yes, there are many artificial constructs that prevent true free market, but I still do not believe that capital accumulation by capital overs is not an property of this idealistic system. Do You have any real example of invisible hand working (by which I mean not ending with the top dogs holding all the bones) ?
I do not believe that this is it - there have to be other better constrains combinations. It just that there is so much vested interest in current system that no one will dare to contest it enough to really try something different.
Is this a rebuttal to turtledove for introducing the notion of 'profit motive?' His introduction is the source of our discussion on 'profit motive.'
>(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charging_Bull).
The beautiful thing about art is you can interpret it however you want. You interpret it as a "golden idol" of the profit motive. I could interpret it as an angry bull sick of the ways of capitalism; a bull that wants to inspire free health care for all.
The advantage of a market in this context is two-fold 1) Private-losses, mispent investments should have the investors bear the cost of losses. Granted, we often bail out investors or banks, but that isn't a market phenomena, it is a political one. 2) Where there is more profit to be had (high prices) there is more incentive for more investment.
Now, one could argue that a market system is more likely to be corrupted such that the connected get bailed out or other advantages. But if you don't trust the political system to regulate the market, why would you expect it to better regulate a bureaucracy that more directly controls the relevant resources?
I think You are underselling it - that's just the mechanic through which it works. But at the same time too mamy people treat it as idealogy and sell it as a silver bullet and not merly a tool which it should be.
My main point is that we should not see markets as an end game - this is just a primitive human made system that should be evolved.
But I specifically believe in building more, smaller units. Places with eg 20 apartments. By building smaller scoped projects, costs are better understood up front, maintenance costs are lower, and you need less specialized construction expertise.
Building 50 20-unit complexes to house a thousand families is going to serve everyone better than building one mega project to house a thousand families.
[0] "Light-rail cost soars $1 billion" https://archive.seattletimes.com/archive/?date=20001213&slug...
--------
Edit: here's another one
"Sound Transit’s light-rail system, called Link, has also had its share of challenges. The 25 miles of light rail that voters were told would be completed by 2006 at a cost of $1.7 billion, have resulted in 23 miles of track which, when completed, will end up costing $5.2 billion."
"The $2.6 billion spent so far on the starter light-rail line takes the rider from Westlake Station downtown to an airport station 0.4 mile from the terminal in 37 minutes. "
https://seattlebusinessmag.com/article/why-sound-transits-pr....
This is the project I'm describing: https://mynorthwest.com/24890/university-link-light-rail-to-...
Zoning is your problem, not who is building.
Developers and landlords are working in the insanity that are municipal governments. Do you understand why we write people off when they say they want more of their involvement?
Loosen zoning and I'll take advantage of it. We don't need to pay some bureaucrat who has no incentive to do their job efficiently to sit in the middle of this. Zoning office budgets should be tied to number of permits approved or units built. Right now they get the same money for being impediments.
Oh, I almost forgot, I also need to have 14+ parking spaces if I build out fully. Again, zoning problem. Developers don't just love parking lots.
Private enterprise is good at projects where the project owner can (directly) capture the majority of the value created and is responsible for the majority of the costs involved in that creation. The mis-alignment is that this creates strong incentive to shift the costs outside the organization.
Government is better at projects where the majority of value created is diffused across a large share of the population and/or over a long time frame. They do have a strong incentive to keep costs down, because costs are paid by taxes and taxes are unpopular and lead to revolution.
This is simple economics.
There are numerous examples of government projects which may or may not have been under budget, but which created 10x or 100x or 1000x returns. Things like "public roads", "internet", "education" spring to mind.
>This is simple economics.
I'm sorry, but simple economics from where? By what authority is that some immutable 'simple economics?' I reject your thesis. Regarding 'costs' being 'taxes' and them going 'down', I invite you to study the change in federal taxes as a proportion of GDP in the past say 130 years.
>There are numerous examples of government projects which may or may not have been under budget, but which created 10x or 100x or 1000x returns. Things like "public roads", "internet", "education" spring to mind.
Yes now think about how much better return, and many other projects may have emerged, had the government not sucked that money out of the economy. "Muh roads" sounds nice but you can privately build a road without taking money at gunpoint from peoeple, and also get good returns. If I take $20 from you and buy you a $1 pen, I don't get to brag that because I bought you the pen you wrote a multimillion dollar book (even then it is true in some perverted sense the pen [road] had 1000x+ returns).
You’re basically taking a market that has an artificially constrained supply and trying to replace it with an entirely planned system.
Why?
And to be clear, I've proposed a system of adjusted incentives followed by but not necessarily required to be followed by a more planned system.
It's like rent control in SF or public housing in Singapore. Design a new system and you'll create loopholes to be exploited. Fix those and new loopholes are created. And on and on.
Easier to just remove government restrictions to supply and build until prices come down.
Which is a huge success.
Singapore is unique in that they have a massive well (proportionally much bigger than US) of workers paying taxes who are ineligible for much of the fruits of those taxes. Only the 2/3 with Citizenship or PR can meaningfully get public housing.
I'm sure about any nation could have more affordable housing if they have endless wells of guest workers who can shoulder the cost without yielding that benefit for themselves.
If you're talking about providing housing in a country that had little quality housing 70 years ago, then yes, it's successful.
If it's providing affordable housing for young people, then I'd challenge that. You can't even apply for public housing unless you are married (otherwise wait until after you are 35). The government overbuilt before, so now it's a 4-5 year wait after you win a lottery to get a house. People are still pumping real estate like crazy and the average home in the resale market is >$1M now (which is a 3 bedroom, 100 sq m apartment with a 99 year lease).
Singapore is stuck in the exact same situation as every other developed country - housing is an asset that the middle class expects a healthy return on, yet increasing costs are a barrier to new owners.
Haha.
But memes aside, no, there are many, many examples of public and social housing that are not concrete slums. Look at Singapore, Paris, the Marxhof in Vienna. Quayside Village in Vancouver.
If you'd like, I can provide links to many examples from many countries around the world of successful public housing that isn't Soviet bloc housing.
But I suspect you most likely just glean all of your political opinions from memes, which could explain some things.
There's a lot of people building straw men in the comments, and then pointing out how flimsy those straw men are, I'll grant you that.
We can make incremental progress here by just tweaking incentives. We can go further by reducing profits. It's not some binary all or nothing affair.
Manipulating people to buy stuff they don't need (advertising, marketing, hollywood) is immoral in so many ways. Weapons are very questionable, massive markups on basic stuff (cosmetics) etc etc if you go on about 80% of our economy is actually immoral. Even foods which are a basic good, are generally bottom dollar hollowed out poisons compared to what they could be if health was the primary concern. Don't get me started on the corruptions of profit to the medical process.
I don't know what your problem is about housing but it seems out of perspective if you're not going to campaign against profit from just about everything.
Oh, and to add to the utter inanity of what you're proposing, make sure that you sell it at your purchase cost and not the 200%ish extra that they tack on to a 30 year loan at 4% interest.
Go ahead. Chalk it up to a personal experiment and let us know how it turns out in 30 years.
And I've done what you describe. I was a landlord for a decade.
I paid back each of my tenants all the profit I made from them, thousands and thousands of dollars per tenant. Adjusted upwards by the amount the property had appreciated.
I now rent in a sliding scale, capped at the cost of the unit.
Granted, it's only been ten years, not the thirty you suggest, but it's worked out great. Nearly every tenant has used their time with me to build a nest egg or savings that enabled them to move into a house they owned.
You are discussing an entirely different issue.
This also means deadbeat tenants get kicked out, but I think that is intrinsically a good thing. Occupying somebody else’s home and not moving someplace you can afford is just immoral.
Mandatory parking minimums are going away in cities across the US, and units are getting more housing as a result.
Washington State is considering removing single family zoning.
Cities like Paris have many smaller apartment complexes that are public housing.
Everything I've suggested either exists or is being discussed seriously in some capacity. But, by all means keep your head in the sand rather than try to engage with actual housing policy.
All of the things you mention exist in the US to much larger degrees (do you know how much the US spends on social housing??) You are slinging insults to other commenters but you are really out of your depth here and have picked a couple of things and hailed them as solutions. You know not what you speak of.
Source: American expat currently living in London, previously Singapore.
No, no they are not.
Washington state has more than Seattle in it. It has rural areas, and mountainous regions, and no, every house in a rural area is not on agriculturally zoned land.
Nor does it make sense to have multidwelling houses, miles apart from each other.
I think, as others in this thread have stated, you are mistaking musings, ponderings, and "feelz good" ideas for serious discourse.
I support public housing, but that has zero bearing on changing the housing market. Which, I may add, is in a tiny, temporary inflated bubble. A decade ago, it was still recovering from the largest crash in modern history.
In terms of public housing, as land value increases, so do property taxes.
Thus, municipalities then have more funds to... build and maintain public housing! Which means that housing costs do not change the percentage of a city's budgetary costs, to build and maintain public housing.
Yes, Washington State is considering this. Yes, it's back on the drawing board, but it's very much in active discussion at the state level.
They have "area zoning", which says "only single family homes may exist here".
Thus, changing this won't ban single family dwellings. Only enable other types of dwellings.
A strange concept, but OK. Understood, thanks.
The hdb scheme is worth look into: government build apartments sold to people with medium income and racial quotas.
If 'Success' is your metric, the Singapore analogy to America would be to import way more Canadians and Mexicans, ban them from public housing and then make them pay for it.
I notice you didn't mention Berlin's rent control fiasco btw
That necessarily means having more money than everyone else. If you don't, the people who do can and probably will make things very uncomfortable for you.
I now rent at cost, choosing to believe that it's better to help the people who live with me establish themselves and build financial safety.
Be very careful. If you are in the US, you might want to speak to a tax attorney.
The IRS treats property rented out at less than fair market value as a personal residence.
Your tenants may have to treat the difference as income, and you are not eligible for many of the usual deductions for investment property.
are you saying you and them live under the same roof? i.e. they're your roommates?
I tend to be broader about community then many folks in the States. Imo, you live with the people in your local area, whether that's house, apartment building, or block.
If you are going to make that business unprofitable then no one will do it. People won't sign up for the risk, cost, effort and frustrations of being a landlord with no upside.
While we're on the topic, why not prevent programmers from putting their salary up? After all software is essential to society these days?
Housed people need parking lots though. Tons of places are not, and never will be accessible with public transports. I live in a city with a great public transport network but I still need a car, as much as I'd love not needing one: I need to visit friends or family outside the city, I have to make bulk grocery shopping sometimes and bags are not enough, I sometimes buy big housing furniture, I even had to retrieve parcels outside of the city sometimes... Heck, even to go to work, sometimes I'm late, or I missed my bus, or public transports are on strike, or anything can happen that I need my car to save 1 hour.
> abolish mandatory minimum parking
Same as above, that's an awful idea.
Almost all the problems you present can be solved by planning differently. You don't need bulk grocery shopping with a shop open nearby in walking distance, available at least once every 3 day. Big housing furniture is a rare occurrence and can be delivered, or you can rent a car capable of transporting it. Punctuality can be solved socially. The main problem is density, and cities certainly don't have a shortage of population density.
Car ownership is a huge luxury with a giant price tag, and it's finally catching up to society.
Your experience doesn't match mine. I also live in a city with a good public transport network, but I've never had a car, or felt much need to have one, or even to learn how to drive. For your examples (except the parcel one, which hasn't happened to me and I have no idea how it would happen):
> I need to visit friends or family outside the city
The friends or family I have which live outside the city actually live in other nearby cities. To visit them, I'd take a bus to their city, and then a bus or taxi within that city.
> I have to make bulk grocery shopping sometimes and bags are not enough
Every store large enough that I'd do "bulk grocery shopping" in it has a taxi stop next to it, sometimes even within the store's underground parking floor. So whenever I do bulk shopping on one of these stores, I simply take a taxi.
> I sometimes buy big housing furniture
Every store which sells big housing furniture has the option to send the furniture to your home using their own truck. You might have to wait for the next day (since they batch the deliveries - it's a big truck), but for big furniture, you usually aren't in a hurry.
> Heck, even to go to work, sometimes I'm late, or I missed my bus, or public transports are on strike
If I missed my bus, I wait less than 10 minutes for the next one. If I'm late, public transport is still faster than a car (or a taxi). And if there's a strike, it's true that having your own car might help, but when that happens (and it's not common enough to make it worth it to have a car just for that), the traffic slows to a crawl.
Or use a bike?
The problem isn't supply. We have (practically) unlimited supply. People just don't want to live in Pennsyltucky.
ad. "not a market" - When you do that are you going to also forgive my crazy large mortgage?
ad. "protect tenants" - In Czechia we protect the tenants more than landlords. If you mean that this should scare people from renting that works quite well. People do not have much leverage here to kick out tenants who are problematic or skip payments.
Then how would you recommend houses trade ownership?
>so developers are incentivized to build more housing
How do you prevent the development of shitboxes (it's a technical industry term)? Because that's what builders build when they need to hit a particular price point at scale. Houses that are quickly built out of low end materials and will decay over about twenty year period unless a homeowner invests considerably in upgrades.
>one shouldn't be "priced out" of the home they've lived in for 20 years
I'm in full support of the concept, but when you start to look at the causes of this, it gets complicated quickly and many of the causes aren't even directly related to housing. It's not just as simple as property tax moratoriums.
At least you understand this is radical. Developers/landlords are the ones providing and maintaining housing, not tenants. The government is incapable of doing this themselves which is why it’s left to the free markets.
The only real issue is that the ‘free markets’ are anything but. Governments overly try to dictate policy which continues to hurt us (a well known feature is state run economies)
Examples of this are zoning restrictions (NIMBY) and rent control.
Broad, idealistic government policies are a disease; they will never be as efficient as entrepreneurs.
Maybe you should take a trip to Eastern Europe one of these days to see the final result of what you're advocating. Pros: everyone is given an apartment to live in. Cons: your city's skyline looks like this: https://i.imgur.com/5X1sIeP.jpg
"We collectively decide" just means you decide for me. You think you know better than everyone else and want to impose your values on others.
It's impossible to get an apartment in Stockholm unless you have a 20-year waiting time, buy an illegal third-hand contract or have the wealth to buy an apartment. The housing crisis in Sweden is extreme.
>Due to excellent renters rights meaning the majority of people rent long term
This backfires spectacularly once you realize landlords continue to hold the reigns and put up huge demands to avoid "bad renters". As long as the rights don't cover the entirety, landlords will continue to pressure renters in different, more obscene ways.
And in today's society, renting long term also isn't as great as people make it out to be, when your long term rent is a glorified broom closet and there's a great job opportunity a few cities over.
The parent's position is "housing shouldn't be a market", and I am showing an example of what soviet-style state control over housing looks like in practice.
But "homes have costs" does not axiomatically lead to "housing must therefore be a market."
I'm far from right wing, but let's not pretend the issue here is a market not working. It's that we rigged the whole system and then blame "the market" for the results...
And yes it’s possible to be capitalist and agree with sensible regulations. I’d rather we focus on building amazing companies and utilizing labor effectively.
Mixed economies are not capitalism.
You can say you're a bit capitalist - that's an easy one, we have plenty of data to show that positive economic effect for everyone are linked to free markets - but still believe fairy tales about the government being moral and caring about something which is not being re-elected and stealing money from people.
These are not zero sum games, and people that think they are probably have no skin in the game. Even the people with lots of wealth and resources worry about losing them, and in order to maintain it you need to make concessions when necessary and be pragmatic.
1 and a half year later, we had decided we were going to buy a house in the new city and stay there. I wrote the tenant to inform them, I had decided to sell the apartment, come the 2 year date.
"OK", replied the tenant, "it's just that, I've decided I don't want to leave this nice cheap apartment anyway, and prefer to stay.."
So I start to read up on the law in my country regarding these things. It turned out, in my country it is nearly impossible to make a pre-determined time-limited rental. In fact, there are only 4 scenarios where it is possible. It turns out, our contract should have had the specific wording "I rent out this apartment for a period of 2 years, because after 2 years I am going to move back to it myself, on this date, because I have the following specified timelimited activity I'm doing at location X". Because my contract only stipulated the duration, but not specified the exact legal grounding for the limitation, it was not valid. TL;DR. I ended up having to 'bribe' the tenant with a huge sum of money, to get their written consent to leave the apartment by the originally agreed-upon date. I also ended up losing a significant amount of money on the sale, because the presence of the previous tenants hurt the price I could negotiate on the sale.
In fact, I would have made 5x more money on the sale,
than I made from received rent for renting out.
(ie I received maybe 50000 some-currency in rent (without expenses subtracted, so in practice it may have been more like 10-20000).
But the reduced salesprice was ~300000 lower, because I ran the sale while the tenants were still present (in hindsight, I should not have put it up for sale until the tenants were gone, but I paid a huge price to learn that lesson :-(.So if I had let the appartment stay empty for 2 years instead of renting it out, I would have made 300k instead of 20-50k. Apart from the fact, that those 50k ended up being what I had to pay in "bribe money" to get the tenants to leave. So I basically let two strangers live for free for 2 years in my apartment, in return for them making it very difficult for me to sell my own apartment. A final caveat is, that technically it's even illegal to leave the apartment empty in my country - if it's empty for a prolonged period of time, you have to register it for "public rental", at a reasonable rent price.. So, yes, I definitely want the rights of tenants in place and protected, but it is possible to protect them so much, you actually make the life of people who have bought a single property miserable.
A postscript: I know many won't buy my arguments about "losing money" here, since the money I would potentially earn or lose here, are exactly the sort of 'board game monopoly money' we are arguing about whether anybody should have or be entitled to. IE the money I would make back on the sale of the apartment I have owned for 20 years, are exactly those 'the game is rigged' money, that appear out of thin air, for not exactly doing anything (apart from maintaining my apartment against wear and tear.)
Rent-seeking isn't the same as collecting rent as part of being a landlord.
It's a pretty fleshed out concept:
I think you'll find if you increase housing supply and density you're likely to end up with more natural spaces, not less.
Cars are bad, you see, and therefore, let's pick some irrelevant problem (parking lots), and conflate it with housing issues.
First, most places have zero housing issues. Mostly, certain tiny areas(with large populations) of California do, but the rest of North America has no shortage of land to build on.
And unlike California, most of the world doesn't seem to have issues with zoning for new builds.
In fact, in most of NA housing is quite affordable, with the exception of a current bubble, which exists due to COVID issues, a once in a century event.
This has only been going on for a year or so, and is already starting to cool.
Californians: a note. Your issues are not nation wide.
Others: stop trying to solve other pet peeves, by conflating issues. I assure you, you just end up sounding uninformed.
It has nothing to do with "cars bad", and everything to do with "why are we letting all this precious resource go so poorly utilized?"
You also act as if there is a land shortage. There is not, with exceptions stated above.
If my objective is "maximize housing" then step one is too evaluate the space and find areas where housing does not exist in quantity.
Those are places like parking lots, parks, commerical only buildings, single family homes, hospitals, schools, etc.
To increase supply, we must tear down existing sites. Parking lots have the most limited positive upsides.
Where would you build a new, 1000 unit apartment building downtown?
Living where one has historically lived is interesting, take London - you're implying it should be a birth right for natives - what about the immigrant flow into such cities, how would you reconcile the "right of natives" with human capital?
As for tenants v landlords, I believe it should be difficult to evict tenants except in cases where the tenant is clearly a danger to others or to the home itself. If they are vandalizing the property, that should be an eviction. Likewise if they are cooking meth. But I think tenants should be protected if, eg, their income drops due to a layoff or unforseen medical expense.
They should stay if they can't pay? Who takes the loss? It would be sensible to have a government program to help people in such circumstances. But if you'd be asking for the landlord to just take the loss, that's not sensible. The owner is probably barely breaking even on rent vs. costs, so they can't afford it.
That seems like a statement that feels good, but what should be the desired outcome for the benefit of society?
If you make taking a loss being the norm for a landlord, the outcome won't be having landlords grin and bear it and a city full of happy renters.
No, the outcome will be landlords will stop renting out since it doesn't make sense to take a loss. So the availability of rental units will dry up.
This also assumes good faith on behalf of the renters.
Landlords always say that they should be compensated for the risk of homeownership. If that's true, then some landlords need to lose money.
The system you purpose is not a loss some times, it is a system that can be abused all the time.
Who says landlords aren't losing money?
I am currently taking a loss. Two units are rent control at 600 per month, the third at 2300 hasn't paid in ten months with an eviction trial next week, I am in the last unit. I will be shutting down the property and using it as a single family home due to this loss. If you remove the incentive you remove housing or prices rise to cover the risk.
I see rent control as privatizing the cost of a social problem. You create restrictive zoning then say random landlords will subsidize people's rents. The single family home owners should share in the cost, and to a lesser degree, so should the renters who benefit.
Now you purpose an expansion on that same idea. Just remove zoning so housing can be built. Don't add more impediments like relocation fees and guaranteed housing in new construction for old residents and price controls. Then you will just have legacy units and luxury housing, an exacerbation of the current system.
1. https://www.newsweek.com/fact-check-are-pharmaceutical-compa...
Practically that means paying to build and maintain housing stocks, changing tax incentives so developers are incentivized to build more housing and less luxury housing, charging a premium for unused land in desirable areas (parking lots don't house people), abolish mandatory minimum parking, and upzone neighborhoods (eliminating the "single family home" neighborhoods as a zoning type.)
I'm also of the much more radical opinion that we should protect tenants over landlords in nearly every case, that we should protect the rights of people to live where they've historically lived (eg, one shouldn't be "priced out" of the home they've lived in for 20 years), and we should offer extensive public housing (built as many geographically distributed small apartment buildings and 5 over 1s, not giant tenements or projects.)