Markets and competition work really well on frontiers in a situation where basic things are covered, because like this more people can participate freely.
There are many things that we have figured out to a pretty high degree and that benefit from collaboration and (very) long term thinking. I think housing, transport, basic medicine/treatment and perhaps to some degree food and water belong to that category. You can always have the luxury/explorative version on top with markets and that model works pretty well where it is applied.
To contrast, if your under such financial stress so you constantly worry whether some big bill is coming your way or you cannot even afford the very basics, then your stuck in a perpetual loop. Landlords, collectors and even police come knocking. It takes a lot of courage, discipline and enough luck and stamina to get out of this. In my opinion this is a a monumental task and effort _wasted_ on a inefficient and short sighted system of power relations.
The labor that the farmer puts in should absolutely be rewarded. But the labor of a farmer is absolutely nothing like a landlord who makes money purely because they had enough money to buy housing. Plenty of landlords hire property management firms, and do little to no labor at all, but still make a profit.
That modality doesn't exist in farming and food the same way it does in housing today.
People mischaracterize the ease in which landlords make money. Take the past two years and eviction moratoriums for example. Landlords in the United States in many areas had to allow tenants to rent without being able to remove them for non-payment.
Landlords inherently have to be well capitalized in order to properly maintain the house as most individuals are not experts in all trades.
I wouldn't have called you a hypocrite even if you didn't pay back anything. Living in the real world™ doesn't mean you can't criticise it. If we can't challenge things we take part in, how do we improve anything?
The nominal assumption is that they must have earned that by providing someone with something of value to them. The money they receive is a formal/cultural recognition of their indebtedness -- that they have provided something useful but have not receive anything of material value in return. Money is a way of claiming something useful in return for something they had provided, but separated in time and place.
Of course this is the theoretical and intended mechanism. It does get subverted in many ways when one earns money without providing anyone with anything materially useful. Inheritance can be interpreted as one such. Although it can be interpreted charitably too -- dont compensate me for the goods and services I provided , I am dead, compensate Saul instead.
whence did the money originate? from loot or labor?
Living in a teepee is looking more attractive by the day haha.
Reality is landlords are in all different situations, some have spare money above costs of interest, rates, insurances, rental agent fees, etc etc and can use that to pay for maintenance. Many are putting in their own money to pay for maintenance, the same way they put in their own money to afford the deposit and purchase costs.
And when there's a problem a landlord can't just ring the first inflate-a-quote contractor and open up the unlimited checkbook you seem to be ascribing to them, they will be bankrupt very quickly if they did. Instead, they have to assess the issue, try to find a economical solution, get multiple quote and spend time finding a contractor who can do it reasonably well the first time at an affordable cost. That is not the same work as a farmer, but it sure is work. If it's not done the house quickly becomes unlivable with a broken toilet or whatever and being unlivable is also unrentable and produces no value to anyone. It's work, and it's important to keep the house functioning.
Really as you seem to think landlords do nothing but profit, similar to gnomes and underpants, perhaps you should give it a try yourself. If nothing else it will be quite a learning opportunity!
However no matter what, no landlord can maintain all aspects of the house alone. You think a single person can be a master of all trades and have all equipment on hand all of the time in an apartment, for instance?
Why does it even matter if someone pays others to maintain the house? Do you think there are people who build modern houses alone with no machinery?
Overpriced or not, people still buy.
If he wrote "immoral", then you could ask why he thinks that.
But good point, immoral is probably more correct.
The problem is, that is outright impossible in urban areas where almost all space is already built out, not to mention it is immensely wasteful (8% of all CO2 emissions is caused by the manufacturing of concrete!).
Governments should rather look into making rural areas livable again (by subsidizing basic infrastructure such as internet, grocery stores, doctors and public transport).
If you have a pastoralist dream, feel free to build rural housing units. But for the government to spread out the country and then try to connect it using extractive transportation technologies (gas, batteries etc) just seems like roundabout / inefficient way to achieve the same goal.
And schools, churches, youth soccer leagues, parks, and playgrounds
Government 10 bedroom, 9000 sqft seaside mansions? Not just no, but hell no!
I do not support government assurance nor ownership for the high-end or luxury levels of affordability.
There’s no need to micromanage tenant-landlord relationships or setup governmental panels on who historically deserves to live where, if the government can just make sure there is an oversupply of decent housing at all affordability levels.
The rest really takes care of itself at that point.