This is true but not in the way that you mean. As you said there is no shortage of space. But it's important to point out that on a global scale there is no housing shortage either. Vacant dwellings outnumber homeless people by far in most industrialized countries where homelessness is rampant (for example: 3 million empty dwellings here in France).
You seem to imply the problem is housing regulations and NIMBY preventing new constructions, but who cares when the houses are already there. I agree with you the problem is that of policy, but i would say the policy responsible for that immense suffering is "private property", the religious belief that land should be owned and that a piece of paper should dictate whether you can sleep under a roof or not and/or have access to food/healthcare/education.
We can eradicate homelessness in under 48h: it's just that no politician cares at all about poverty from their ivory tower! Just give the police instruction not to intervene for "breaking and entering" in *vacant* housing (or even better, abolish police entirely) and we can rehouse every homeless person in the next two days. Of course it would take a few weeks to rehabilitate some of the housing unit and make them real decent, but even in the meantime old housing would be much better than no housing.
There’s a massive housing shortage in the United States and it’s acting like a vacuum, sucking up wealth and diverting it to landowners.
Good point, although i would like data to back that claim. For example in France, 200k empty dwellings are in Paris alone: this does not account for vacant industrial/office space which could also be converted to housing. In all cases, *proposing* (without coercion) homeless people a house somewhere does not sound inhumane at all.
> there are far more people living in overcrowded housing
Good point, too. Although as i said i would like to see data suggesting that the current real estate market (accounting for all vacant units) can't house everyone decently.
> There’s a massive housing shortage in the United States and it’s acting like a vacuum, sucking up wealth and diverting it to landowners.
To be clear, i'm not saying we should stop building houses entirely. But as long as you allow housing to remain vacant, prices are driven by speculation not by actual supply. I believe we should both rehouse homeless people immediately and keep investing in eco-friendly collective, affordable housing.
Source? A quick search only turns a figure half of that: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1290578/number-homes-par...
Also, just because it's "vacant" doesn't mean it can actually be used to house homeless people. It could be undergoing renovations, or on the rental market.
> Parkmerced is a neighborhood in San Francisco, California, designed by architects Leonard Schultze and Thomas Dolliver Church in the early 1940s. Parkmerced is the second-largest single-owner neighborhood of apartment blocks west of the Mississippi River after Park La Brea in Los Angeles. It was a planned neighborhood of high-rise apartment towers and low-rise garden apartments in southwestern San Francisco for middle-income tenants. It contains 3,221 residences (after sale of five blocks to San Francisco State University (SFSU)) and over 9,000 residents, and is one of four remaining privately owned large-scale garden apartment complexes in the United States.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Park_Merced
On my block, just on my street, there are over a dozen empty garden apartments, 2- and 3-bedrooms, that have been empty since (more-or-less) the beginning of the pandemic lockdowns. Folks started leaving and no one has moved back in. Next to my house there are three empty apt.'s to the left, one to the right, and four across the street.
The owners haven't lowered rents though.
The theory is that they would rather keep the rents high and the apartments empty than lower the rents because if they do that it affects their ability to raise rents later on (rent control is the only way I afford to still live here. For better or worse my family pays less than half the market rate. However, as I am describing, the market rate is not "clearing the demand" or whatever the economic jargon would be. No one is renting at "market" rate right now.) The other problem is that rents going down affect the valuation of the property, something like that. IANAEconomist.
Anyway... There are literally hundreds of perfectly fine apartments ready to rent here in Park Merced, with the M line light rail going directly to downtown SF in about 20-30 minutes and a BART station in walking distance.
- - - -
Get this.
Some folks moved in to the place across the street on Monday, but then Wednesday the staff was here kicking them out: they were squatters. I spoke to one of the staff who told me that this was a group of people who were breaking in and squatting in units all over the property, that they had changed the locks on the house they tried to squat in, and that he had called the police, who asked if anyone was being violent (no) and then still hadn't shown up an hour later! They never did show up. The squatters moved all their stuff and their two dogs back into their vehicles and left.
We need to make it easy to use the the housing we have, build more housing (of any kind) and subsidize those who need assistance.
Isolating price controls as some kind of glaring inefficiency in an otherwise rational system sounds like ideology, not reason.
It should be manifestly clear that an unregulated market has not served us well for the issue of housing, not just for the indigent but for all non-wealthy individuals and families who spend well over 50% of their income now on rent or mortgage payments.
Attacking rent control in isolation is irrational. Yes it can create a bad situation for landlords in the absence of any other policies designed to mitigate the disaster we are in. But saying that "market efficiency" is the answer is just sticking your head in the sand.
Anyway, the OP's point stands: there are perfectly good homes going empty. They aren't out in the woods. They are right here in SF.
The bottom line (no pun intended) is that the corporation that owns Park Merced has (presumably) done the math and they expect to make more money by keeping the apartments empty and eating the losses now (and paying the overhead of evicting gangs of squatters) so they can rent them later at the "correct" market rate (a pretty likely speculation, I'll grant them) than by renting them at a market rate that fills them up again now and getting locked in to rent control at the new, lower rates later on.
So, in other words, the poor people can't live there because someday soon the rich people will almost certainly want to live there again.
What you suggest would instead let the poor people stay in the apartments until the rich people wanted back in, so I guess that's an improvement?
But I don't follow how getting rid of rent control would incentivize supply increases?
Leaving units empty, or locked into lower-than-market rates are going to reduce the average profitability of investments. Investment in new units is in part a function of how profitable they will be sell, or to rent out.
But honestly the incentive for bay area real-estate is there, what really is needed is the ability to build with fewer encumbrances.
> That seems like it would make for a pretty precarious living situation for people who can't find ways to pay the correct market rate, eh?
Yes, this is generally referred to as gentrification. But, renting, even to poorer people, nevertheless is still usually profitable, albeit with more risk requiring a larger portfolio.
I always wonder about public transportation. It never really took off in the US, but it IS way more efficient. If we had very fast subways / trains, we could theoretically stretch housing way out away from the city. Then there is more equal opportunity for jobs / attending universities without living on campus.
I know this is a bit off topic, but it always seems to me like having QUALITY public transportation is efficient, but I can't quite defend it.
Not even to the exclusion of cars. For example I know a lot of workers who drive their car to the subway station in Toronto (and other cities) and then spare themselves the traffic and gas cost of sitting on the highway for 2 hours. And this is the ONLY solution for a big city, since most can't afford to live by the jobs/colleges (even suburban single-bathroom costs are over a million 40 mins out from downtown).
EDIT: I can see residents downtown paying the most taxes being against it though - all it does for them in personal terms is erode their power. Makes their real estate cheaper (removes exclusivity of quick access to offices / educational facilities) and makes the downtown areas accessible to people who can't live there.
> I can see residents downtown paying the most taxes being against it though - all it does for them in personal terms is erode their power.
It could also help subsidize their taxes to some extent since commuters are occupying offices and spending money in the city without occupying housing. Depends how things are set up. I don't think the people living in Manhattan resent people commuting from Jersey or Queens for work.
I spent some time in the Soviet Union before the wall fell. It sucked. Idealistic ideas like this destroy housing for everyone.
I think that in order to protect it's ability to offer a first world living by it's communities, the US needs to fatten up it's middle class with better wages. There could be a number of ways to do that, but the basic goal is to get more money into the hands of the average American so they can spend it in the community and make the whole country better.
A better way would be to protect people by not making policy decisions that reward bad behavior and punish those who avoid debt and save. Rewarding terrible behavior may get you elected but it’s bad for society. Like giving candy to pacify a cranky baby.
But such opinions have become verboten now, and actually censored.
That's not the problem either, the scarcity is (with the exception of foreign - i.e. Chinese and Russian - money laundering) natural and not artificial. The true problem is that following mechanization in agriculture many people emigrated from rural areas, resulting in a lack of infrastructure because it was unsustainably expensive for the low population density - particularly high speed internet and accessible (=walkable or within reach with a bicycle) basic infrastructure such as a grocery store, a GP and pharmacy and schools. That lack drives more people away, it's a vicious cycle that will need enormous amounts of money to break through.
If you want to work a modern service-oriented job or even a manufacturing/industry type job, you have to move to an urban or suburban area, and even if you have money and want to provide gainful employment you simply can't because there is no high-speed Internet for your business.
What needs to be done is that the government aggressively invests into "flyover" states to provide perspectives for the people living there and considering moving to a better place - but unfortunately I don't see that happening, not in the US and not in Europe where we have similar problems.
Fix the policy and house prices will drop. That creates a new problem of course for those who then end up with a Mortage that is under water. That's the real reason the policy does not get fixed.
Thanks but no thanks. I'd rather like if people can move towards rural areas where possible.
That's counterproductive. Infrastructure for rural areas costs way, way more.
That happened at the latest 40 years ago (in fact it happened more than a century ago), while house prices went crazy roughly after 2000.
It began earlier, the problem (why the situation in urban areas exploded) was that after ~2000-2005 it simply became apparent that the future was the Internet and there was no way government or much less the private companies would ever put up the money to provide actual high speed Internet to rural areas - and so all the new "digital" companies set up shop in urban areas, and people flocked to where the new jobs were.
Had the US government taken care to make sure that the companies not pocket literal billions of funds without providing the service that the government funded [1] you would not be in the mess you are now.
[1] https://eu.jsonline.com/in-depth/news/2021/07/14/weve-spent-...
Essentially, a big corporation could buy cheap rural land close to a big city, develop a small city there and reap the "overpricing" benefits.
But it's very expensive to build the basic infra. And even more expensive to convince enough people to move there and create minimum network effects for it to become a "real" community and livable space.
This is not a technical problem but a policy problem. The solution is changing the policy. The current policy is to drive up housing prices by creating completely artificial scarcity. All the land is owned and earmarked. Just not for housing. This problem exists in most wealthy nations. There is no shortage of space. Just of access to that space. Mostly that's completely intentional and reinforced by generations of politicians acting on the will of the people they represent to ensure that can never change.
You have NIMBYs and vested financial interests basically. Nobody wants their property devalued. So, social housing always is unpopular with the locals. Places like San Francisco where the homeless take dumps on Market Street are of course a bit extreme. But same principle. No shortage of space there.
But it's all reserved and off limits. So, the homeless are camping out there. In the middle of a city full of some of the richest NIMBYs on this planet. That's not a temporary solution. That's a slum and it is growing. Complete with people just shitting all over the place. Slums are what happens when you let things escalate.