News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by paisawalla on Friday May 06, 2022 @02:43AM (#31282031)
How will you be deciding who gets to have a view of the ocean, and who gets to sleep next to the overpass? First come first serve? Birthright?
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by nivenkos on Friday May 06, 2022 @02:48AM (#31282054)
Pricing? You can have the government / housing co-ops sell properties and just forbid private renting out in absentia.
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by paisawalla on Friday May 06, 2022 @02:55AM (#31282123)
The point is that 1 KWh is 1KWh, but your home on the top floor of Millennium Tower is not equivalent to my home across from the 680 overpass. Housing is not a commodity like electricity, it's not fungible.
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by aqme28 on Friday May 06, 2022 @06:13AM (#31283438)
Is anyone in this thread proposing this kind of system? This is kind of an insane strawman.

You can have a regulated market that still has prices. OP only proposed incentives to build and disincentives to hoard. Homes would still have prices, there would just be less scarcity.

Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by dahfizz on Friday May 06, 2022 @08:11AM (#31284215)
OP is claiming that housing is a commodity. If treated as a commodity, all houses would be priced the same. Then the reality sets in and you have to deal with the fact that some houses are more desirable than others, so you need to distribute them somehow without changing the price.
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by turtledove on Friday May 06, 2022 @02:55AM (#31282122)
You could have a lottery, adjust prices within a regulated range, offer incentives for less desirable lots.

You could reward developers for lots that have long wait lists and lots of interest, incentivizing developers who build places people want to live.

Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by marvin on Friday May 06, 2022 @03:12AM (#31282243)
Offer incentives for less desirable properties, eh? That sounds suspiciously like having different prices, just with extra steps.
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by turtledove on Friday May 06, 2022 @03:36AM (#31282406)
I suppose, in the same way negative interest rates are just interest rates with extra steps.

Start from a position of "everyone gets a home" and then ask "in that case, how do we make sure folks who end up in less desirable homes are compensated?"

I suppose you could frame it in the language of prices, but in this case the price is paid to the tenant.

Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by sokoloff on Friday May 06, 2022 @05:52AM (#31283314)
Indeed, it would be a tragedy if someone’s taxpayer-provided housing was insufficiently desirable that we must create a bureau to determine how much additional largess they should receive. That system seems likely to end well.
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by paisawalla on Friday May 06, 2022 @03:02AM (#31282171)
Ah hmm, that's interesting. How have lotteries for highly desired goods worked out in other centrally planned regimes? Did we find a pretty broad socioeconomic distribution among dacha owners in the USSR?
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by p1esk on Friday May 06, 2022 @03:12AM (#31282242)
Did we find a pretty broad socioeconomic distribution among dacha owners in the USSR?

Yes.

Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by headsoup on Friday May 06, 2022 @03:14AM (#31282266)
What if someone less fortunate 'wins' the mansion on the beach. How do they afford the future upkeep?
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by refurb on Friday May 06, 2022 @04:44AM (#31282876)
That’s exactly what Singapore does with new public housing - it’s a lottery.

And now they are “clawing back” future price appreciation because it’s literally like winning the lottery if you get a place in a prime location as public housing is heavily subsidized.

If you get selected for a prime area apartment it’s a huge financial win 5 years down the road when you sell at market prices.

And oh yes, Singaporeans game the hell out of the system. From carefully falling under household income limits, to bidding on a new public housing unit despite owning one now.

The government is constantly trying to keep up with all the new incentives each new rule creates.

Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by turtledove on Friday May 06, 2022 @03:49AM (#31282513)
This is a fair question, and one I'm not entirely satisfied that I have the answer for. Ideally, in my mind, I wouldn't own my home but I'd also be on the hook for maintenance and upkeep. But I recognize this does not meet everyone's needs and needs more thought.

I would also hope that we would tend to build fewer mansions in favor of more multi family complexes, cohousing, coops, and small community oriented housing on the beach.

Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by headsoup on Friday May 06, 2022 @04:25AM (#31282754)
You know this kind of leads towards communism... Which I think is the key problem with any kind of shared equality by force system, it will work nicely so long as no one running things decides they don't want it to, then it works really poorly.
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by turtledove on Friday May 06, 2022 @09:11AM (#31284693)
Looking at any single step on a path and rejecting it because the extreme end of the path isn't desirable is a quick way to never make any progress.

We can improve things, we can do social good, and never slide to authoritarianism. (I assume you are talking about authoritarian communism vs, eg, council communism.)

Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by headsoup on Friday May 06, 2022 @11:38PM (#31291964)
Of course we can, but doing it at a society scale is very difficult and you have to be vary careful about who is on charge - or ends up with most influence - as history has consistently shown.

I think it's easy (well reasonably) to do if resources are plentiful, but what do you do if there are more people than resources available to support them, who starts making the hard choices?

Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by carom on Friday May 06, 2022 @03:54AM (#31282541)
How often would people have to move?
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by turtledove on Friday May 06, 2022 @09:12AM (#31284705)
When they wanted to. Forcing people to move is, imo, needlessly cruel.
Re:Homes in 97% of U.S. cities are overvalued, Moody's says by carom on Friday May 06, 2022 @09:44AM (#31285000)
Isn't that unfair to someone else who wants to live there? It just seems like the first to arrive is the lucky one.