News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by helsinkiandrew on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:48AM (#31201853)
I'm not an immigration/tax lawyer and could be completely wrong but if you're from EU/US/UK/AUS etc I'm fairly sure you can work in another one of those countries for up to 90 days (and sometimes upto 183) without paying tax there or getting a work visa - as long as you're still resident and being paid in your home country under the Visa Waiver program.

I've worked in NY offices and got paid in UK (admittedly a while ago and for less than 90 days) - but can't see why working in an Airbnb would be different.

Has anyone experience of this recently?

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by joshvm on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:03AM (#31202221)
You can visit for 90 days but what you're allowed to do is restricted to tourism and "temporary business".

The US substantial presence test is actually something like 31 days in the current year, and ~180 calculated as a weighted sum of presence over all visits in the preceeding few years. That's just to determine if you should pay tax, and note that vacations to the US contribute. Whether you can legally work in the US is another matter. I had to get a a J1 visa for a two week stay in the US because I was being paid remotely by a US organisation. So in this case I was working but paying taxes elsewhere.

Most Europeans have access to things like cross border permits e.g. Switzerland/Germany and within the EU freedom of movement means it doesn't really matter much. You just register with the City Hall or wherever in your target country.

It comes down to how honest you are. Lots of digital nomads illegally claim they're on holiday, and who's checking? I'm sure a lot of people would be happy to pay a fee for a temporary work permit though.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by oxfordmale on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:19AM (#31202701)
90 days is the number agreed upon by company lawyers. Company lawyers do not have a sense of adventure, so this is a relatively watertight figure for most countries in the world and not dependent on your honesty.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by dheera on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:19PM (#31207162)
Personally I'm curious about how they have rights to even know where you are at any given time.

If you're an in-office employee, your responsibilities are (a) show up at the expected work hours (b) get your tasks done.

If you're defined as a fully remote employee, your responsibilities are (a) be online and available at the expected work hours (b) get your tasks done.

Besides that you're just an amorphous black box, a person that has been placed in the cloud, much like a website placed on Cloudflare, where the input is money and the output is work. They don't need to know where you are, and I'd say they shouldn't even have a right to know -- that would be quite stalkerish, IMO. All that's really important is that this black box gets tasks done.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by schrodinger on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:37PM (#31207388)
You can't just legally avoid taxes by not letting your employer know. Sure, they prob won't know and you'll get away with it, but you're technically breaking the law and an employer won't knowingly condone that.

So it's not that they have a right to know where you are, it's that if they do notice and not act on it that's a legal risk to them as well since they're enabling it. (IANAL but this feels common sense.)

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by dheera on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:51PM (#31207580)
I wasn't saying avoid taxes -- mostly just that the "90 day" thing is nonsense, because if you're a remote employee, you're effectively just a really intelligent amoeba on the face of the Earth without a well-defined location.

Pay your taxes, but if you say 153 days in Thailand or wherever you can get a long enough tourist visa, and use a VPN to the US and get your work done, I'm not sure why anyone would, should, or even has a right to care.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by schrodinger on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:13PM (#31207922)
Thailand has a right to care. You're earning money and not paying taxes to their roads, police, fire department, etc—all the things govt provides. When you're a true tourist, you are likely making up for this by boosting the local economy.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by dheera on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:01PM (#31209324)
Usually by being someone with money and spending it on rent, food, etc. you're already making up for this.

Countries with tourist visa stay limits are usually just to make sure you have the funds to leave. In general, if you come back the next day on another flight, with the intention of continuing to stay and spend money, they'll generally have no problem with it.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by refurb on Saturday April 30, 2022 @02:53AM (#31213966)
The company cares because they have legal obligations as well. Just because you pay for you taxes doesn't mean the employer is in compliance. Just like the US, many employers are obligated to pay additional fee/taxes/payments such as social security etc.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bonoboTP on Monday May 02, 2022 @10:55AM (#31235888)
Why do you think you have the right to just settle in other people's countries and ignore their laws (on taxes and other things)?
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by throwawayboise on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:31PM (#31208238)
The simple answer is to do away with the notion that earning income should be taxable. Tax on the consumption side, it's easier to enforce and harder to avoid.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by techdmn on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:28PM (#31210217)
The problem with taxing consumption is that it's pretty regressive. Not to say that there aren't solutions, but the existing sales tax, gas tax, etc aren't it.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by darioush on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:53PM (#31210985)
Taxing income is also regressive because most rich people have trust funds (and pay a flat 15% tax) or push luxury purchases under the guise of business expenses (and pay no tax).
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by notch656a on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:25PM (#31210747)
Taxing consumption instead of investments and savings seems like it would guide society more towards saving and investment instead of short-term consumption, though, no? Personally I'd rather not have taxes at all, but if you forced me to pick on of the three I'd pick consumption every time.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by adgjlsfhk1 on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:25AM (#31213330)
how do you want to pay for roads?
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by notch656a on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:31PM (#31217183)
Tolls. Privatize the roads.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by midasuni on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:35AM (#31223816)
It’s funny how anti government people tend to like socialised roads, police and military, but the socialised education and housing.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by notch656a on Sunday May 01, 2022 @05:29PM (#31228862)
Really depends on the person. I'm for privatizing all those things. No public spending on education, housing, roads, police, or military. Minarchists tend to prefer some services while anarchists may not want any government at all, thus no government expenditures.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by CryptoPunk on Saturday April 30, 2022 @09:05AM (#31215767)
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by phantomathkg on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:56PM (#31208582)
That would be simple if AirBnB wrote the law. But sadly, they aren’t.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by jacobr1 on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:48PM (#31207539)
Because the black box for legal purposes still presumes you are in-office. When you are remote, you are structured as working from your "home office" not anywhere.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by dheera on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:54PM (#31207621)
Hm. What if my home office was a van, or a private jet?

Couldn't one just structure it as a consultancy? I mean, if I hire a consultant to do something for me, I could just pay them through PayPal or Venmo or even Ethereum and wouldn't need to know where their office is. Onus is on them to be legally able to work and pay their taxes.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by wombatpm on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:27PM (#31208151)
That works because it’s a 1099 situation. But FICA, tax withholding and health care benefits are all tied up in your place of residence. Assuming you have a driver’s license and a voters registration, there is someplace you call home otherwise you are just a hobo
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by dheera on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:18PM (#31208843)
Hm. So what legal framework do "hobos" use?

Surely it's not illegal to be homeless with a lot of money and skills.

(a) Let's say you spend 1 week in each state for 50 weeks of the year. Where do you file your taxes?

(b) Let's say you spend 1 week in each of 50 countries and work for AirBNB. You have no house, and no lease on a residence. Let's say it's mutual, e.g. you want to do this, and from their perspective, it's helping them because you're dogfooding their product. How do you deal with the legal side of it?

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by notch656a on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:39PM (#31209078)
The government generally doesn't recognize having no fixed address whatsoever. I was caught 20 miles from the nearest road once 'illegally existing' in a wilderness area in Oregon 'without a permit.' The officer of course had nowhere to take me because there was no prison or way to extract me out, we literally randomly found each other on a mountain. When I told him I had no address he literally had no way to enter that on his form. He told me it was impossible and he had to put _something_. I'm not sure what he ultimately wrote. Of course he let me go, because what the hell are you going to do someone 20 miles from the nearest road short of calling a helicopter.

Having no address makes the government's brain explode.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by refurb on Saturday April 30, 2022 @02:55AM (#31213975)
Look at California residency requirements. They don't care if you're out of state for most of the year. If your license is from CA, or maybe you vote there, or you opened a bank account years back in CA, they will send you a tax bill.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ghaff on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:31PM (#31209677)
wrt a.

My understanding is that it's not illegal but it basically makes it impossible to get government-issued ID, file taxes (which are legally required), open a bank account, get a credit card, etc.

So as a practical matter you probably get some traveling mailbox type service--in a state with no income tax presumably.

wrt b.

You're already a citizen somewhere. You'll still need an address there. See above. Then it's up to you and, perhaps to some degree, your employer to get appropriate visas. That said, for one week stays, an Airbnb stay during which you work an unknown amount of time remotely as opposed to being a tourist seems pretty doable so long as you keep a low profile and the company is cool with it.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ghaff on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:20PM (#31208863)
And your home address is going to determine your default state/local tax situation in the US. (Though above certain thresholds you may be supposed to file multiple state taxes that are reconciled with each other. This mostly comes into play with business travel which companies are tracking.)
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ericmay on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:54AM (#31204458)
I'm not sure when this 90-day rule was written, but I imagine it was written in a time before now with high-performance laptops, video conferencing, common jet travel, and people wanting to work 30 days here, 90 days there, 120 days over there, etc.

This should be revisited. Also I think this is a good example of the need to have expiration dates on new laws and regulations. This should be something that expires and has to be changed to reflect how people live today.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by MikeTheGreat on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:42PM (#31209779)
> the need to have expiration dates on new laws and regulations.

This is a terrible idea. Here in the US the ever more hyper-partisan political environment makes it hard to do _anything_, even once. The idea that our Congress critters are going to re-pass all legislation for everything every (say) 5 years is ridiculous.

Those of us who like knowing that our food is safe to eat, our cars aren't firebomb death traps waiting to explode, that planes won't fall out of the sky onto our houses that aren't going to spontaneously collapse / flood from shitty plumbing / burn down from an electrical fire will disagree that all legislation should be repealed (either directly or via repeal-by-expiration), but please - let's be honest about what the effects of an 'expiration date' on legislation would actually accomplish.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by tdy_err on Saturday April 30, 2022 @03:05AM (#31214017)
Maybe this is an indicator that we need a legal infrastructure that supports a progressive, scientific governance Rather than thumbing our noses at new approaches on behalf of defunct political parties
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by JusticeJuice on Friday April 29, 2022 @09:52AM (#31205078)
90 days is the standard tourist visa length for most countries, so it would be to match that.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ericmay on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:27AM (#31205585)
No need to match
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by rat9988 on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:39AM (#31205755)
It needs to matchs.Otherwise you'd need a work visa.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by kieloo on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:03PM (#31208658)
But isn’t it illegal to work on a tourist visa anyway?
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by Retric on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:29PM (#31210778)
Most countries have many exceptions. A UK “tourist visa” is called a “Standard Visitor visa.”

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...

Remote working

Visitors are permitted to undertake activities relating to their employment overseas remotely whilst they are in the UK, such as responding to emails or answering phone calls. However, you should check that the applicant’s main purpose of coming to the UK is to undertake a permitted activity, rather than specifically to work remotely from the UK. Where the applicant indicates that they intend to spend a large proportion of their time in the UK and will be doing some remote working, you should ensure that they are genuinely employed overseas and are not seeking to work in the UK.

PS: Actual rules are here: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/immigration-rules but the general intent seems to be if your there to do something very temporary like compete in a sports tournament or do something for someone outside the UK that requires you to briefly visit the UK it’s fine.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by refurb on Saturday April 30, 2022 @02:50AM (#31213947)
"the applicant’s main purpose of coming to the UK is to undertake a permitted activity, rather than specifically to work remotely from the UK"

That's doesn't seem like an exception? That sounds like saying "hey, I'm going to fly to the UK and work remotely from there" is against the law.

What that paragraph says to me is "If someone comes to the UK as a visitor, and happens to do some work - responding to email and/or answering phone calls" that's ok. But actually work full time in the UK remotely, is not legal.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by tluyben2 on Saturday April 30, 2022 @05:29AM (#31214588)
I believe this is the case in many countries; you can do some work like signing contracts and indeed answering emails and the phone for work purposes, but you cannot just take out the ol' laptop and write code for 90 days. Many people do because you cannot really check but it's not allowed, at least not in places I have been. Especially if you keep travelling (so 2-3 months here, 2-3 months there) then there is very little point in doing all this trouble unless you cannot stand technically doing something illegal although no-one will find out.

Anecdotal example; when I was young and naive (well, more naive than now), I went to Canada (Vancouver) to help some guys out with some software. I read up on it a bit, but not enough (naive!) so at the border I told that I was going to do a bit of sight seeing and a bit of 'work'. Wrong word; was immediately taken apart and spent 1 hour explaining that no, no not work, just a bit of light consultancy; no programming, no actual managing people etc and no money changing hands (this was all true, I just shouldn't have used the word 'work'). They let me enter and there were no further issues, but I guess most people would just say 'vacation!' even though this was allowed; it can/does add stress and you might be unlucky and be sent back.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by Retric on Saturday April 30, 2022 @07:44AM (#31215265)
> That doesn’t seem like an exception?

The person I was responding to asked:

>> But isn’t it illegal to work on a tourist visa anyway?

It’s clear there are many ways it’s legal to be working in the UK on a Visiter visa. That doesn’t mean it’s ok to go if your only reason to be in the Uk is to be a remote worker for 90 days.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by vladvasiliu on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:06AM (#31203026)
> Most Europeans have access to things like cross border permits e.g. Switzerland/Germany and within the EU freedom of movement means it doesn't really matter much. You just register with the City Hall or wherever in your target country.

This isn't as easy as it seems, even inside the EU. There are talks going on about laws regarding what constitutes "local hiring".

Basically, the issue is that some companies hire people from Eastern Europe, and pay them EE salaries there. But those people are then physically working from Western Europe, where they are "visiting workers" (don't know the exact term). This allows the companies to, among others, 1. pay lower salaries than the local going rate and 2. avoid paying payroll taxes locally.

I don't know how this works when applied to freelancing or remote working, but, as others have said, it's probably best to ask a lawyer or two.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by moonchrome on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:12AM (#31203071)
I don't see a problem with this if the visiting workers are there less time than it takes to be considered a tax resident, eg. you have 3 months on-site onboarding and then proceed to work remotely.

After some time you're considered a resident so it doesn't make a difference compared to a local hire ?

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by vladvasiliu on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:13AM (#31204151)
That's the thing, I don't think there's a clear duration after which you're automatically considered a tax resident.

The thing with these employees was that they never became local hires. So they would get their salary through their home country branch, with taxes paid over there, etc. The whole point is that these companies were trying to dance around the limits of employment law. What they were doing was technically legal, hence the will of the government to change the law.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ptsneves on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:38AM (#31204341)
In Poland you are a tax citizen automatically if you have been there more than 183 days[1]. The exact same 183 in Portugal[2]. It is an automatic thing so quite simple.

[1] https://taxsummaries.pwc.com/poland/individual/residence [2] https://taxsummaries.pwc.com/portugal/individual/residence

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by vladvasiliu on Friday April 29, 2022 @09:33AM (#31204877)
I beg to differ. Those look like the "default" rules. For the example of Poland (picked one of your two examples) it's not so simple.

The "default" rules for tax residency are superseded by a convention between the two countries, and there are a bunch of them, with many countries, on the site of the French government. There are specific conventions with Germany, Belgium and Switzerland, for example, that apply only to people living close to the border and working in the other country. If you take the train from Paris to work in Geneva, it doesn't apply.

Basically, it can be debated. It says that if you have a "permanent home" in both countries, you're a resident of the country "with which you have the most attachments". So for the hypothetical Polish worker who's "detached" in France, it could be argued that the "attachment" is to Poland, because their family is likely there, among other things. In the case of a freelance moving from country to country, who is likely unattached, this can probably be easily argued (though I'm not a lawyer).

Concerning remote-working freelance: For "independent workers", you're taxed in the country where you do business, except if you have a "fixed base" in the other country, from which you conduct your business. In that case, you're taxed in the country where the base is, but only for the part of income that is attributable to the work done from that base.

Source, in French: https://www.impots.gouv.fr/sites/default/files/media/10_conv...

Conventions directory: https://www.impots.gouv.fr/les-conventions-internationales

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by skocznymroczny on Friday April 29, 2022 @09:58AM (#31205154)
> "visiting workers" (don't know the exact term)

the term is 'posted workers'

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by frankfrankfrank on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:45AM (#31202870)
I propose people start reconsidering this imposed situation that exists between the people who do the work and the government, i.e. the parasitic ruling class. And to clarify, I say that as someone who is not at all “leftist” oriented, even though it may seem so at first glance of reading that to some.

This situation we currently essentially globally have, at least in the west, is quite an abusive system that is really just the bait and switch type pivot off what most people know as slavery, into a differently structured model of the same fundamental thing, one which really just spreads the total amount of enslavement across more people rather than getting rid of it altogether.

The parasitism of the ruling class that is far more obvious through slavery, is far harder to recognize in todays world because rather than taking, for argument’s sake, ~70% of 10% of people’s labor to support and enrich the ruling class; the shift/pivot off the slavery model was to introduce taking ~40% of the labor from 90% of the population and therefore enrich and empower the ruling parasitic class even more.

It’s precisely why a certain segment of the ruling class were all for “ending slavery”, because they knew “ending it”, i.e. spreading it over most people, would be far more lucrative and profitable. Life tip: Always be extremely leery of what the ruling class is promoting, and even more so re-examine things if they start supporting what you support.

The point is, we need to all start coming to a realization that the income tax and the whole tax system of fractional slavery enforcement needs to end. I do not claim to know the right answer, but I and any other rational and sane person know that this bait and switch slavery that exists needs to stop. What else do you call it, e.g. when hedge fund managers make billions per year and pay next to zero taxes, but some middle class person has huge sums of the value of their labor taken/ stolen to supply the hedge fund manager’s lifestyle?

Some have proposed things like the Fairfax.org, essentially a consumption tax through sales tax that captures taxes on illegal/harmful activities and ill begotten wealth, e.g., drug dealers buying their flashy things, while at the same time also taxing polluting activities in a direct correlation, e.g., buying new shiny-object over keeping something maintained and repaired. This would be a radical and arguably positive impact for all of humanity … except the parasitic ruling class which very much likes and has been working hard to expand its parasitism. See currency inflation at the press of a button for reference, which defrauds workers and savers through the worst tax, fraud.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by robertlagrant on Friday April 29, 2022 @06:14AM (#31203396)
> that exists between the people who do the work and the government, i.e. the parasitic ruling class. And to clarify, I say that as someone who is not at all “leftist” oriented, even though it may seem so at first glance of reading that to some

I definitely wouldn't say that criticising big inefficient government is a leftist talking point at all.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by illiac786 on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:48AM (#31204415)
100% agree. reading "parasitic ruling class" makes me think of a Trumpist rather than a socialist, for sure.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by robertlagrant on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:23PM (#31207222)
That would also be wrong (or disastrously incomplete).
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by la6472 on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:10AM (#31205334)
Using tax to build roads , fund schools , maintain community parks , allocating to providing care for the poor and defense funding is not “slavery” and there is no “ruling class”. You can be a burecrat or become a politician if you want. The system may not be perfect but certainly better that half assed solutions that makes no sense.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by notch656a on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:12PM (#31210628)
>You can be a burecrat or become a politician if you want.

You can become those things if you manage to navigate a social and possibly economic process and succeed in entering those positions. By using your own definition, a slave wasn't a slave because people like William Ellison [0] who were once slaves went on to become a slaveholder. A slave can become a slaveholder -- that doesn't cancel out them taking part in a system of slavery.

>there is no “ruling class”.

A couple weeks ago when I entered the US I was forcibly shackled and cuffed without being even 'arrested' nor formally charged with a crime and held for 16 hours while taken to hospitals against my will on the most flimsiest accusation of being suspected as a "drug mule." Do you really think a common armed citizen could have held me like that against my will without repercussion? There is most definitely a 'ruling class' who can get away with things others can't. The border patrol in fact is 'allowed' to violate the constitution within 100 miles of the 'border' (which debatably is either actual border or even just international airports) and stop people without probable cause of having committed a crime.

Perhaps 'debt bondage' is a better word to describe what the government imposes on its citizens (especially noted in the high percentage of black men thrown in debtor's jail for merely owing money a la child support enforcement). Debt bondage is considered a form of slavery by some, although distinct and perhaps less egregious from chattel slavery.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Ellison

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by kingaillas on Friday April 29, 2022 @09:54AM (#31205102)
>What else do you call it

Something other than slavery, which is humans literally owned and treated as property. Maybe what it actually is, a skewed taxation system.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by helsinkiandrew on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:38AM (#31204337)
Sales taxes predominantly tax the lower paid more - who spend more of their earnings.

I'm not sure how this would make hedge fund managers who's net worth and amount invested might go up billions in a year but don't get paid or spend that amount.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairTax#Distribution_of_tax_bu...

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by cyberlurker on Friday April 29, 2022 @07:34AM (#31203854)
I’m all for talking about tax policy but stop comparing our modern workforces to slavery (unless you are referring to the actual slaves of today). Slavery was/is barbaric and nothing even close to the relative bliss that is the modern workforce. I happily pay taxes, after stuffing every penny I have into tax advantaged investing accounts. At the end of the day I see a lot of government waste, but I also see the necessity of government. We can reign in government spending and taxation but don’t give me this garbage about how I’m in slavery.

If you want a perspective on how bad slavery was, search for this: Hardcore History Ep68 - Human Resources

Also, I knew immediately you were some libertarian/right, red pill person because I see this kind of talk all the time from old friends. Ya ya, the ruling class is so bad. Why are you preaching your gospel on HN? Do you want some ruling class VC money for your startup or not?

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by pedrosorio on Friday April 29, 2022 @11:48AM (#31206682)
People work because they need money to survive (pay bills, rent, food, etc.), not because "the ruling class is imposing taxes through government".

A consumption tax will do nothing to reduce the power of the "ruling class" since their consumption is a much smaller fraction of their income compared to the working man.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by throwawayboise on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:36PM (#31208315)
Consumption as a fraction may be smaller but as a number it's much larger. Wealthy people own larger homes (often more than one), more and more expensive cars, boats, private aircraft, any number of other toys. They spend more on clothes, entertainment, virtually every other category of spending is higher if you are wealthy. Maybe they spend about the same amount on toilet paper.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by pedrosorio on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:35PM (#31210296)
> Consumption as a fraction may be smaller but as a number it's much larger.

The current status is one with progressive tax rates where people with higher incomes pay a higher percentage of their income in taxes. This is still not enough due to loopholes, etc.

The person I replied to complains about "ruling class" and proposes (presumably as a way to mitigate the ruling class' accumulation of wealth) tax on consumption.

Since the fraction of income used for consumption decreases with income, a consumption tax corresponds to a regressive income tax (higher income -> lower tax rate). This is much worse, penalizes the poorest and leads to much worse wealth inequality than the existing system.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by midasuni on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:25AM (#31214328)
That’s assuming you charge consumption taxes equally. If you exempt basic items it evens up far more.

I don’t pay consumption taxes in the U.K. on food, rent or public transport, that’s the majority of expenses.

My neighbour does pay them on eating out at a restaurant, a kitchen refurbishment, and a new mercedes

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by muaytimbo on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:42PM (#31209104)
I get the analogy many others here intentionally miss. Usurping the value of your labor by force. Most of us in America work >4 months a year with all that value stolen by the parasite class. How many months will we accept until, instead of theft, we call it slavery?
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by midasuni on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:29AM (#31214346)
Those taxes pay for societies various needs, schools, roads, defence

You can go live in a society with few taxes if you want, look at moving to the Bahamas for example. Have fun.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by hervature on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:22AM (#31204218)
Many others have chimed in, but this is very important to highlight. Meeting with clients, going to conference, having important meetings, these are things we consider work. However, from the eyes of the law, these are temporary things that need to be done in person for business that has already occurred. That is, if you come to a conference, meet a potential client, and then set up a sales meeting before you leave, you have conducted new business in the US and violated your B1 visa. See [1] for the actual exemptions. Technically, if you check your email while on B1, this could be construed that you are conducting unauthorized business in the US. Of course, these laws never foresaw technological progress and so the world governments look the other way because they do not know how/what to enforce.

I'm going to put it here as this is what an immigration person put it to me, just ask yourself "where are my feet?" That is the country/entity you should be paying your taxes to by default unless there is an explicit reciprocity agreement that may apply to you. So, if you're traveling Europe as an American while working remotely, you are violating tax law in every single country. From the law's point of view, there is no difference than as if you had contracted out your work to someone in each one of those countries. Don't worry, no one is going to come after you for those 10 hours but just know you are intentionally (or grossly negligent) making use of the inaction of enforcement.

[1] - https://www.uscis.gov/working-in-the-united-states/temporary...

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bell-cot on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:44AM (#31205822)
> ...Of course, these laws never foresaw technological progress and so the world governments look the other way because they do not know how/what to enforce...

Other than the current scale of activity, the law has no "never foresaw technolo..." excuse for failing to cover such things. Centuries ago, it was perfectly normal for authors, composers, painters, etc. to travel to and work in other countries - "for their health" as they worked on their next masterpiece, or for inspiration, or to give paid lectures, or to perform or conduct music, or to paint portraits of locals, or several of those things.

It'd be rather interesting if a lawyer or few (who were fond of dusty tomes) did some real research on how those activities were handled back in the day, the old case law, etc.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by hervature on Friday April 29, 2022 @11:16AM (#31206225)
I'm not sure I agree. With computers, people can literally teleport around the world which would have been ridiculed even 50 years ago. Probably something like "Haha, you think one day you'll be able to reach into the telephone and fix the thing on the other side, haha". I think it is an open question whether or not a sysadmin working on servers around the world is any different than paying the sysadmin to travel to each server and work locally while continuing to work on the global servers. The former is fine whereas the latter would legally require work authorization in each country.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bell-cot on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:25PM (#31207246)
Let's say it's 1937, and I'm a successful author enjoying life at a hotel in Italy. And writing my latest novel. Mailing chapter-by-chapter draft copies of that back and forth with my literary agent in London. Occasionally calling that agent on the (then-expensive) telephone with both questions, and instructions for him to execute on my behalf. Occasionally calling editors at various publishers (perhaps in several countries) to discuss business. Or to argue about how they destroyed the beautiful cadence of my dialog in Chapter 8 of my prior novel. Maybe I send telegrams to another agent I employ in New York, asking questions and giving instruction.

The modern, computerized version of this is faster, cooler, and sexier - but (IANAL) I see little basis for saying that there's a legal difference in kind.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by hervature on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:03PM (#31209352)
The example you give is a clear violation, both in the past and the present. The author's feet are clearly in Italy and hence subject to Italian taxation (unless reciprocity agreement). That's not up for debate. This corresponds to the "latter" option I proposed before where the sysadmin travels around. This we are definitely aligned.

Upon reflection, I should not have said "an open question". Rather, I should have said that many feel that the spirit and intent of the law should be revisited. For many, the feet test is about resources utilization. Using electricity, internet, housing, etc. In the author example, the author is clearly making a choice to live at that hotel. Back when the law was written, I think this would have covered most cases. However, now, the modal case are "digital nomads" where the normal thing is to not spend more than 1 week - 1 month in a single place. Oftentimes, the destination doesn't matter, but the journey. In the extreme, imagine spending 2 days in every country in the world, in perpetual motion. This has always been a possibility and the law covers this case (as we both know) but I think people are beginning to question if it makes sense given the new distribution brought by the internet. To come back to the sysadmin example, the point was that the sysadmin is utilizing the same global resources except for maybe an additional epsilon as they move around to the different localities. Many feel that the locality does not provide anything in return for the right to tax the income.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bombcar on Friday April 29, 2022 @11:45AM (#31206628)
That's an interesting case - if you write a book on holiday, but not on contract, and then sell it later when you return, where did the work occur? Where did the taxable event occur?
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bell-cot on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:47PM (#31207531)
For that specific case, it is tempting to look to securities law, and the "when did something clearly become valuable?" concept.

If you're a well-established author of (say) steamy romances, writing yet another steamy romance - then the value is created (work is done) when you write the book.

If you're a nobody, dreaming of success as an author - then the work is done when you somehow convince a publisher to take a risk and buy your manuscript.

(And in between those cases it would get messy:)

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bombcar on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:56PM (#31209269)
I bet the only industry that has some guidance on this is the movie/tv industry - and even then I bet a lot of it falls on the incomes of the employees actually filming on location, etc.

It would be interesting to watch California try to claim income tax on book royalties that were first started in CA but then the author moves elsewhere.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by schrodinger on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:43PM (#31207471)
There must be some exception to this. I am a US citizen working for a London company and a few times a year I go over, explicitly telling the immigration officer it's for "business meetings," and that's explicitly allowed. I couldn't just go work for the hell of it but as a manager of a team it makes sense I make special occasion trips. Technically they could ask me to produce a letter from my employer explicitly confirming the reason for my travel but I've never had any friction at all. But my company was very explicit that I explain it's for "business meetings" and not regular work.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by hervature on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:08PM (#31209424)
Yes, business meetings (and the things in this spirit) are the exceptions. However, you certainly cannot say "I feel like doing my normal job in London this week". Now, let's say you go to London for one important meeting and spend the rest of the day working as you don't want to waste your time, ok, no one is going to ask questions. But, if you go to London for one meeting and work there for the rest of the month, you are in clear violation. Is anyone going to hunt you down? Probably not. Are you breaking the intent of business visas? Definitely.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by throwawayboise on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:40PM (#31208380)
There are exceptions of some sort for meetings and conferences.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by umutseven92 on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:05AM (#31202621)
Nope, unless your country has a special arrangement with the country you are visiting, you cannot work with a tourist visa, at all. Does not matter if the company is local or not. No work visa = no work.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by oxfordmale on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:23AM (#31202724)
This is a legal loophole for digital nomads. If I am connected to my work via a VPN, I am technically still working in the country of employment. I am not producing any commercial output in the country I am staying that I or my employer benefits from beneficially. I am 100% confident this has been reviewed by well paid lawyers at AirBnb who have zero sense of adventure, and that this is all water tight.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by maxlamb on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:11AM (#31203064)
I believe that’s not what government laws says (for any country). Someone can correct me if I’m wrong but pretty much all countries/states consider you working there if you are physically present there. Your VPN or where your “commercial output” is, is not considered a factor at all by governments.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by oxfordmale on Friday April 29, 2022 @06:32AM (#31203494)
Most countries only care if you are taking a job that a local could have done. That is clearly not the case if you work remotely. If anything you are increasing local jobs by paying for your accomodation and food.

Once again this has been reviewed by laywers at different companies who have deemed this risk to be acceptable.

There might be countries that will arrest you if you read your corporate mail while on holidays, however, these generally not on the green list of safe countries to travel too.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by digianarchist on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:29AM (#31205611)
Mexico is one of the few countries that legally allows remote work on tourist visas and a common complaint is that remote workers are driving up rents.

Allowing unrestricted access to your country by remote workers will have economic impact.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by maxlamb on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:27AM (#31205589)
I understand that it would make sense for governments to not care since it’s money coming in and not displacing local workers. But the laws are still there, saying it’s illegal. If they weren’t, governments wouldn’t come up with special “digital nomad visas” for that specific situation.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by jefftk on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:23AM (#31204237)
> deemed this risk to be acceptable

Acceptable to the company. That doesn't necessarily mean that it's acceptable to you, especially if penalties would primarily fall on you for illegally claiming the wrong immigration status.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by refurb on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:03AM (#31204070)
No, that's not how it works at all.

There are several ways tax codes can categorize income:

- the country the person was hired in (e.g. US)

- the country for whom the work is complete for (say if US employee delivered code for a Canadian office)

- the country the company who hired the person is located in

- the country the company paying the employee is located in

- the country the person was originally hired in (same as #2)

- the country where the work is actually done

A lot of countries just look at the last one. Doesn't matter if you were hired in the US, paid in the US dollars and US taxes are taken from your pay check. If you complete your work in country X, country X wants their taxes according to their laws.

There is a separate aspect for the company. You as an employee might comply with all tax regulations - hired in the US, US taxes deducted, but you file your taxes in a separate country and pay taxes owed.

But your employer may be out of compliance as well - they may need to be registered in the that country, have obligations for employer tax and social security payments, etc.

It's mostly their own obligations companies are worried about. If the employee pisses off and breaks tax law in another country, well that's on them.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bombcar on Friday April 29, 2022 @11:49AM (#31206686)
The reality of what the law says and what countries and companies do in this case are often very disconnected.

But when it's a big or noticeable deal, then things come into play. US baseball players have to file Canadian taxes when they play in Canada, and if an exposition game occurs in Japan or London, taxes are filed there, too.

If you're not trying to evade taxes, and aren't making much anyway, most places don't actually do anything, but if they decided they wanted to they could.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by refurb on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:41AM (#31213399)
"If you're not trying to evade taxes, and aren't making much anyway, most places don't actually do anything, but if they decided they wanted to they could."

Skirting gray areas is fine - working while on a 3 week vacation is likely not worth chasing down.

Staying in a country for 4 months knowing that after 3 months you should pay taxes, but just pretending you're a tourist? That's pretty clearly trying to evade taxes.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by afavour on Friday April 29, 2022 @09:21AM (#31204732)
> If I am connected to my work via a VPN, I am technically still working in the country of employment.

I hope this is sarcasm. A VPN is a technical detail that would never stand up, legally. The only situation where I can see a VPN being useful is within your own company: if they don't want you working remotely a VPN might help cover up the fact that you are. But aside from that it won't help you.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by mensetmanusman on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:05PM (#31209387)
Law is all technical details and abstractions though.

Where are you working if you are flying above various states and countries while VPNd?

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by midasuni on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:39AM (#31214386)
There are international conventions and it could be the country you are going to, flying over, or where the plane is registered. Or a mix of all 3.

A better analogy would be if you worked remotely from a boat on the high seas on your own boat.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bkor on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:48AM (#31202896)
> I am 100% confident this has been reviewed by well paid lawyers at AirBnb who have zero sense of adventure, and that this is all water tight.

I hope you're being sarcastic here, no?

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by JCharante on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:51AM (#31202923)
absolutely not that gets people in trouble if you get attention from the cops (source: been in south east asia for a while)
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by te_chris on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:29AM (#31202055)
As far as I know this is incorrect. In most countries working is entirely different to touristing and ‘doing business’ (i.e. selling). Just ask musicians - they have to get performance work visas for every country.

As far as their tax authorities are concerned, yeah, you normally have 90 days or so where they don’t care about your income, but immigration? Almost never. Most digital nomads just get away with it because it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things that customs and immigration authorities have to care about - witness the Thai visa tours etc.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by JWlrCk9PkipFTDq on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:45AM (#31202871)
I don't think is true for the Schengen zone/Schengen adjacent countries.

I'm a musician and have toured Western Europe a couple of times (and know a lot of others who have). Apart from the UK noone I know ever gets working visas, and this is never a problem crossing borders honestly saying to immigration that we're there on tour in a van full of music equipment and merchandise.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bkor on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:53AM (#31202940)
> we're there on tour in a van full of music equipment and merchandise

There are separate arrangements for touring groups. However, if you're not from the EU then good luck. You'll notice that there are huge complications after brexit. That said, likely nobody will check, care or notice.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by dfxm12 on Friday April 29, 2022 @11:42AM (#31206579)
That said, likely nobody will check, care or notice.

Even if noone cared, relying on the apathy of others seems like a poor part of a business model. Unfortunately, they do seem to care at the US-Canadian border entering the US. There have been a few Canadian professional wrestlers, like Mike Bailey and Super Smash Bros., who were barred entry to the US entirely for 5 yrs because they were caught trying to work in the US without a visa.

More on the topic of musicians: https://www.huffpost.com/archive/ca/entry/us-border-canadian...

I think this is all silly, of course, especially because American acts have seemingly no trouble working in Canada. I shouldn't take for granted when I saw the Canadian band badbadnotgood in the US last month...

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ghaff on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:05PM (#31208688)
>trying to work in the US without a visa.

Yes, but that is a case where they're getting paid in the US to work.

The one conference horror story I recall from a few years back was someone was going to speak at some small UK(?) conference and they were getting an honorarium or something like that. And they told immigration and I think were denied entry for that reason. But I've spoken at dozens of events for free and it's never been an issue.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by JWlrCk9PkipFTDq on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:52AM (#31205941)
Sorry should have clarified, I'm not from the EU. This is on an Australian passport on the visa waiver program, and American friends have had the same experience (including some biggish bands who tour Europe a couple of times a year).

Maybe it's a "noone cares" thing, but this includes some American friends who were caught with weed in their tour van at the Norwegian border and still didn't have any visa issues (and somehow still managed to get into the country!)

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by hocuspocus on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:52AM (#31202927)
Schengen has nothing to do with freedom of movement for workers.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by pvtmert on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:37AM (#31202104)
This only works if you are holder of passport of the origin country. As a third world country national, I cannot legally work anywhere except the country I got my work visa.

PS: Even if company is multinational corporation.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by krzyk on Friday April 29, 2022 @06:43AM (#31203544)
Laws are still written for those doing manual labor.

What's the difference if I do some work in the evening at home or during my holiday in e.g. Greece?

The only added cost in given country is energy. Problems start to appear if I get sick, but that should be on myself - and in most cases (for EU citizen) it is most appropriate to return home to cure/hospitalize (unless it is something needing immediate help).

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by CorrectHorseBat on Friday April 29, 2022 @07:40AM (#31203909)
There are also other issues.

What with labor laws? Should you follow the laws from the country from where you work or where the company is located? Companies would just get a post box in the country with the weakest labour laws.

The simplest solution stays that the laws where you physically are apply.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by mensetmanusman on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:06PM (#31209403)
This already happens, that’s why every company is incorporated in Delaware.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by renewiltord on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:49AM (#31202515)
No one’s gonna know if you are a tourist in Japan for 90 d and you work there remotely. Literally no one. No one will know.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by umutseven92 on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:05AM (#31202616)
The next time you try to enter or leave Japan after staying for 90 days, they would ask you how you are able to stay 3 months without working. If you cannot show significant savings, then you would get deported and banned for 10 years. Happens all the time.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by kjksf on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:50AM (#31202911)
Does it really happen all the time?

Any references to this happening all the time?

Because to me it seems like border patrol doesn't have the authority to check your bank account or demand that you "show significant savings".

Sure they can refuse to let you in but does it really happen all the time?

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ClumsyPilot on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:39PM (#31212250)
You are showing a bit of naivete and entitlement - if you are visiting a foreign country, you often have to apply for a travel permit. If you are applying from Russia/China/Mongolia to UK/US they ask you for bank statements, evidence of having a stable job or holding any property in your home country, you travel itienary, and ask whether you are a person of good character. Lying on the application form results in a 10 uear or lifetime travel ban.

After all that, when you arrive at the border, they ask questions and US border guards in particular may ask for access to your phone and laptop.

So it does happen all the time, it's just thay typically rich tourists from America are subject to less scruitiny than folks from poorer or politically messier places

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by Symbiote on Friday April 29, 2022 @09:01AM (#31204537)
I've seen a student required to show a bank balance and withdraw sufficient money before being granted a tourist visa for a different country. (He was in front of me in the queue.)

The UK requires some visitors to show bank statements when applying for a visa.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by el-salvador on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:32PM (#31207349)
Germany for example, requires a "Blocked Bank Account" for certain type of student, work and other kinds of visas.

This account is opened remotely from the students' home country in a German bank, before the visa applicstion. And savings cannot be withdrawn for a period of time.

I had an acquaintance that studied in Germany that had a visa problem for withdrawing more money than allowed from his "Blocked bank account".

https://www.fintiba.com/moving-to-germany/studying/requireme...

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by notch656a on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:52PM (#31207600)
Lol they're not gonna deport you on your way out. I'd like to see one example of deportation orders for someone already at the airport to leave the country, purely based on accusation of having worked remotely in Japan.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by Nextgrid on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:45AM (#31202874)
Say that you're using PTO?
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by chrisseaton on Friday April 29, 2022 @11:02AM (#31206043)
Lie to immigration? People in this thread are insane. Going to get yourselves banned from counties.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by notch656a on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:55PM (#31207646)
I've been to many nations including for months and including illegally overstaying. No one gave one fuck to ask whether I was working not. The only people that have ever grilled me like this is my own country, the USA, where returning as a citizen the last time I entered I was forcibly taken to a hospital to be anally probed (with even a warrant, although after 16 hours they could not find a doctor to execute it) based on a wild and false accusation they thought I was a drug smuggler. Only the USA and a few other insane nations are dumb enough to pull these kind of stunts.

Somewhere like Brazil/Paraguay/Mexico/Philippines/Iraq no one is gonna ask you if you worked remotely while on your way out. No one. Half the time they don't even bother to ask what you're doing while entering, they just stamp your passport and you're on your way. Japan may be different, but there is no way they're gonna deport you on your way out.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by chrisseaton on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:57PM (#31207666)
Every non-European country I visit very specifically asks me ‘are you going to be working’ every time I visit.

I think they do this for the quite clever reason that then if you work they can get you for lying to an official rather just for working.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by notch656a on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:03PM (#31207783)
I'm sure some ask. The risk of being deported or caught seems incredibly low, especially if you pick a country in South America or southeast Asia. I cannot think of a nation there that ever asked me if I was working. When I was caught overstaying in Iraq they immigration guy was visibly pissed but he couldn't speak English so I juts handed him <fine for overstay>, and went on my way.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ClumsyPilot on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:45PM (#31212277)
You were just visiting more chaotic places.

All European cointries have records of your entry/leaving, and if you overstay you will likely end up with a lifetime travel ban. The only exception would be like a medical emergency.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by notch656a on Friday April 29, 2022 @09:03PM (#31212389)
Hasn't infamous 'hacker' Weev been hiding out in European nations/territories of Transnistria/Maldova/Ukraine for like 4 or 5 years now without any residence authorization?
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by renewiltord on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:54PM (#31209905)
Same experience, sans probing. I have also, interestingly, overstayed in the West including using a residence permit to enter that was no longer valid. Japan they checked my baggage, same smuggler thing, but I only had my host of bootleg (not really, I just like being equipped so I just get them from generics factories) antibiotics + pharma and they don't really care about those personal quantities.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by michaelt on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:07AM (#31202633)
Ah, but consider if you're a multinational corporation, and your employee asks for permission to work remotely from Japan for 90 days.

Will your policies allow you to give permission for something illegal?

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by kjksf on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:51AM (#31202920)
Why should they care? The liability is with the person, not the company.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bkor on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:19AM (#31203112)
> The liability is with the person, not the company.

Why would the liability be solely with the person? Especially if that company has a representation in the other country I highly doubt this.

In e.g. NL the company has to "take care" of the employee. A company cannot just ignore such a question, or take it as "not my problem".

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by refurb on Friday April 29, 2022 @08:12AM (#31204146)
Of course not. Employers have regulations as well. If you are paying someone working in Japan your employer should follow Japan laws on employer regulations.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by jandrewrogers on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:31AM (#31205652)
I do not know about Japan specifically, but some developed countries do quietly monitor people that spend significant amounts of time in their country for violations that would require a proper work visa. It is not safe to assume no one will know -- I know of cases like this where people were flagged.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by digianarchist on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:34AM (#31205695)
As long as we are acknowledging that this isn’t allowed.

I know a lot of countries turn a blind eye to enforcing immigration and labor laws. Thailand being one of them.

Even Pieter Levels works out of Thailand and I’m pretty sure he doesn’t have a Thai work permit.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ycombinator_acc on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:38AM (#31202824)
Border control and ice will know.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by frederikvs on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:10AM (#31202270)
Tangent, but it turns out terms like "third world" are no longer accurate. If memory serves, this is explained in the book Factfulness. A highly recommended read, by the way.

A few decades ago, there was a group of wealthy countries, a group of poor countries, and a large gap between them. Back then it made sense to see them as 2 separate groups, first world and third. Right now however, they're no longer separate groups - there's a continuous spectrum. A growing number of countries have been crawling out of poverty.

Some countries are rich, some are poor, and some are in between. They're no longer separate groups.

(This of course does not mean that there isn't a poverty problem in the world. Just that "third world" no longer accurately describes the situation.)

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by strangeattractr on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:17AM (#31202313)
Weren't the terms used to connote alliance with the US (first world) or the USSR (second world) and third world meant non-aligned?
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bryanrasmussen on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:49AM (#31202907)
so, the poster is wrong on the specifics but correct on the general idea that the term third world no longer makes much sense.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by frederikvs on Friday April 29, 2022 @07:34AM (#31203855)
I stand corrected, thank you!

To clarify, I misremembered Factfulness. The book actually talks about "developed" versus "developing". In my memory I jumbled that up with "third world".

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by jdenning on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:22AM (#31202341)
I think you're wrong about this -- as I understood it, the term is a relic of the cold war. "First World" nations were aligned with the US, "Second World" were communist or communist-aligned, and "Third World" were not associated with either.

After the collapse of the USSR "Third World" became primarily associated with impoverished nations.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by DonHopkins on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:38AM (#31202446)
And Trump was trying to convert the US into a "second world" nation.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by helge9210 on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:21AM (#31202337)
First world -- NATO member states

Second world -- Warsaw Pact member states

Third world -- all other states

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bbarnett on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:47AM (#31203267)
Some dude coined these terms, and they caught on for a while during the cold war. Third world typically being of little interest to first and second, and often poor.

So eventually "third world" came to just mean "poor countries". After all, there has now been as much time, post WWII, without the cold war, as there was with one!

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by midasuni on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:43AM (#31214411)
Which would make Ireland, Sweden, Switzerland, Australia, Japan etc third world.

That’s not how the term is used.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by hocuspocus on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:59AM (#31202986)
In the EU and FoM countries you're still supposed to pay social contributions where you work. There are many complex rules for people who are regularly on the road (like truck drivers, artists on tour) and dispatched workers, but as the average tech worker you can definitely get your employer in trouble if you work more than 20% outside the country of employment. That's why cross-border commuters can't work from home more than one day of the week, technically.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bitschubser_ on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:21AM (#31203123)
The 20% rule only applies to Switzerland and the "Doppelbesteuerungsabkommen" with the neighbor countries or EU. This was the reason I quit my job in switzerland and moved back to germany (without taking a huge pay cut ;), more vacation days and only 35hour/week), now the 183day rule for social contributions and tax apply as long as I live in germany. So now I can work from portugal during winter :)
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by hocuspocus on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:40AM (#31203226)
Not only Switzerland, no, see Luxembourg.

Most employers won't allow what you're doing.

There's no EU-wide 183 day rule for social contributions. If you stay more than 3 months in a country you need to be registered as a posted worker, and there are some legal implications.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bitschubser_ on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:56AM (#31203301)
you're right, depending on the country/company there are some additional implications, in my case it helps that we have a subsidiary in most EU countries, so it can work via an "entsendung". I really hope that these things will change (social and tax wise) in the future within EU to make it easier for work setups like this.
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ChuckNorris89 on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:49AM (#31205894)
>without taking a huge pay cut ;), more vacation days and only 35hour/week

Would you mind sharing in which area) industry one can get such a good deal in Germany? All i found was 40h/week, some with overtime.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bitschubser_ on Friday April 29, 2022 @07:06PM (#31211634)
The 35h workweek is quite common in companies with an "IG Metal Tarifvertrag" in place, most companies in the automotive industry and their supplying industries provide such contracts, but also a lot of medium size companies... Don't expect FANG salaries ;)
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:10PM (#31218853)
Aren't those IG Metal companies shit in the SW dev department due to outdated mentality thanks to German boomer management, heavily birocratic, with poor pay?

I'm asking since the companies in Austria with IG Metal equivalent are terrible in those regards: poor pay for SW devs as their main money making products are some automotive/mechanical widgets instead of SW, boomer management insists on commuting to the office to some remote village because if the guys in the machine shop need to be in the office to do their work then so should the devs and everyone else, outdated SW, tooling and dev practices, poor equipment (some cheapo underpowered Dell/HP/Lenovo bogged down by corporate spyware that the pensioners in IT insists everyone must have, including SW devs).

Kinda confusing to me, since you said you're getting nearly swiss money and it's not what I imagine at IG Metal companies :)

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bitschubser_ on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:49AM (#31245084)
Hi, most of them yes, but they are und er pressure to good people and in a lot of companies a generation change happens with new ideas. But you're right for every innovative company there are dozen quite old fashioned :(. The big ones usually get it, Daimler, trumpf to name a few...

From my personal experience a lot of companies in Switzerland are more conservative

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by mensetmanusman on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:43PM (#31209785)
Not a day goes by where someone fails to mention Doppelbesteuerungsabkommen!
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by nivenkos on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:45AM (#31203259)
> I've worked in NY offices and got paid in UK (

If you're doing ordinary work I think that violates the terms of the B-1/B-2 visa - even if under 90 days.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by midasuni on Saturday April 30, 2022 @05:08AM (#31214506)
Like most law it’s vague and subject to whims, there’s no flow chart to give you a definite answer.

If you go to meet team members in your NY office, interview some new staff, and look for a new building to move the office to, that’s all fine.

If you happen to do some unrelated sysadmin work on your servers in london while you’re there, that’s probably fine too, as your primary reason to visit is quite clearly fine.

If you went for a holiday for 2 weeks(on a B2 or esta) and happened to answer a phone call from work that’s fine.

If you went on holiday for 2 weeks and spent 10 days working remotely that’s probably not fine. If you went on a family holiday for 4 weeks but did a few days work remotely that’s might be ok. If you did it several times a year though it probably wouldn’t be.

There’s no hard and fast rule in law, and doubly so in immigration where the power to allow you in sits with the guy at the airport.

https://legalservicesincorporated.com/immigration/what-activ... has a good overview.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by trash3 on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:48AM (#31202505)
My understanding is, for an American in a EU country, is they can go and work remotely there for the 90 days as long as they are not conducting business in said country. This means face to face business meetings with clients. When you log in remotely to your job based in the USA and not interacting with people directly during the tourist stay, you're in the clear... I think?
Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by bkor on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:51AM (#31202918)
> My understanding is, for an American in a EU country, is they can go and work remotely there for the 90 days as long as they are not conducting business in said country.

That's not legal. To work in the EU you need a work visa. Though they ignore the business trips. What's legal and what's checked are different things.

E.g. new foreign colleagues need to get a tax id in The Netherlands before they do any work. Doesn't matter if they came from the US.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ghaff on Friday April 29, 2022 @10:16AM (#31205420)
I (from US) can't speak to the actual laws. But with respect to "what's checked," I've been asked the purpose of my visit at immigration in countless countries around the world and I'm always completely open about attending conferences and meeting with customers and no one over decades has batted an eye. (Of course in the handful of countries I did explicitly need business visas--like China--I got one.)

Of course, there are a lot of unenforced laws on the books, but I'm a little skeptical that the millions and millions of people who travel cross-border on business trips every year are all mostly breaking immigration laws.

To be fair, my experiences are all on relatively short trips--a few weeks at most and usually less. Perhaps there would be more issues if I were staying 90 days and was open about workationing the whole time.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by el-salvador on Friday April 29, 2022 @12:54PM (#31207626)
> I'm always completely open about attending conferences and meeting with customers and no one over decades has batted an eye.

Attending conferences is usually ok, but it's a complicated topic because it depends on the traveller's passport, the visited country and how strict rules are enforced.

As a foreign national, for example a U.S. B1 visa allows attending conferences and close business deals. But it doesn't explicitly allow working remotely for a non-US company.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by ghaff on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:21PM (#31209568)
Of course, even a B1 isn't a tourist visa. A B2 (US tourist visa) specifically doesn't include non-social events.

In any case, in most countries whether explicit or implicit that distinction is probably the right one. Of course, no one is going to care or know if you check some emails and do some work--just like no one cared if you made some phone calls and did some work years ago.

But, in most places, you probably shouldn't show up and say you'll be spending the next 90 days working remotely.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by nivenkos on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:47AM (#31203266)
No, if you're performing paid work like that it's still violating the visa.

Just that normally no-one ever checks or cares.

It could be a problem if you later try to become a resident in the same country though.

Re:Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere by akvadrako on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:19AM (#31202323)
This is not correct. There is probably a special deal between the UK and USA, but there isn't anything similar for Americans working in most EU countries, and the rules are per country.