News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by honkdaddy on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:16PM (#30675118)
If you want an inside look of what that area is actually like (I left Seattle in 2021 after being disgusted by the state of the city), this article has some great interviews. People on that block steal and then sell anything from diapers to beer to drugs to socks; all for a couple dollars.

https://www.thestranger.com/slog/2022/03/04/67776468/the-peo...

I think it's great reading for anyone who believes homelessness is an issue that can be solved by throwing free housing at people.

Here's an excerpt -

>Andre said he has struggled with homelessness on and off since he was 14. That’s when he started selling at 3rd and Pine. He’s been there almost everyday since. He’s 30 now.

“You get caught up,” Andre said when I asked him why he’s spent half his life on this corner. “You make your first sale, you get a little money. Then you’re 30 and you’re still at 3rd and Pine.”

>Andre lives in an apartment thanks to a city-run housing program, but he doesn’t have a job other than selling flipped merchandise. Over the last two years, the government has forked over financial relief to taxpayers with formal jobs, but people like Andre, who work informal jobs, have not seen such benefits.

By "informal jobs", they actually mean selling stolen merchandise.

>I asked Andre what the city could do to get people to stop selling at 3rd and Pine. He said the city could give them something else to do: “Maybe build a basketball court? Somewhere to shoot hoops?”

The logic being presented here is that because the government has only given them free housing and not a free place to play basketball, it's reasonable to expect that they'll fill their days selling stolen goods. By building somewhere to shoot hoops, the problem could be solved.

This is a city where nearly any deli or corner-store has a We're Hiring sign and will gladly pay people under the table. Homelessness is a social phenomenon, not an economic wart caused by expensive housing.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:47PM (#30675538)
He'd been homeless on and off since he was 14. The vast majority of his life he was not being given a free place to stay. Do you think if, at 14, had he not ever experienced homelessness, that he might be a more productive member of society?

Yes, for some people it's too late for "just" a free place to live to solve their problems. But I think it will absolutely make a difference for people on the brink, families, and future generations.

No one is going to solve homelessness in a generation. The damage it does to people is so significant. But we should work to assure that people like Andre never exist to begin with.

You say that delis should hire them. Do you expect delis to hire homeless people? Who can't shower? Who have no address? A home is a critical step to getting hired. It doesn't mean you'll suddenly get a job and be productive, but without it you're absolutely fucked.

Yes, we should give everyone housing. We should also pay them to go to school, give them free health care, etc, so that they have the opportunity to actually move forward.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by honkdaddy on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @09:52AM (#30685242)
I live in a shitty area of NYC now. I walk past people like Andre every single day, and you can call me cynical, but I'm unconvinced that the problems they face are outside of their control to stop. These are guys with a new blanket of merch, often hundreds of dollars worth, every single day on my corner. This is merchandise usually stolen from Mom & Pop pharmacies without any security, so there's quite literally 0 repercussions from walking in and taking as much as you can carry. I see that happen at least once a week, as well. You can make at least $100/day selling stolen crap on the sidewalk. For perspective, a shelter (with beds and a shower) is $20/night.

There are also countless places in this city you can get clean for either free or a couple dollars [1]. As I mentioned in my post, there are quite literally thousands of restaurants, warehouses, cleanup crews in the city you can work under the table for if you show up sober and willing to work. I say this because I personally know individuals that do this. Don't believe me? Go to /r/homeless and look up cash jobs. Thousands of other people have figured it out, why can't Andre?

I'm all for societal change which ensures that individuals like Andre don't end up in that situation in the first place, but I'm of the opinion those changes start in the classroom and with ones parents, not by the state giving away free apartments. The fact of the matter is that if Andre's already been stealing from Target's and selling the goods on the sidewalk for fifteen years, maybe he doesn't want a minimum wage job in the first place?

I don't doubt that a free place to live would help Andre, I mean hell, not having to pay rent would help me as well. But surely there's a better strategy than housing life-long criminals for free, indefinitely?

There's a program in New York called ACE [2] which guides homeless people from the street to a job to eventually subsidized rent or a temporary free place to live. Every year they move a couple thousand individuals out of poverty. It's worth watching some of their success stories. All it will do is resonate the point I've been making this entire time - homelessness is an incredibly complex problem and the strategy of 'free houses for anyone who asks' is misguided, expensive, and ultimately fruitless. I don't doubt it works for some, but for others, it's at best an incredibly expensive band-aid, and at worst a point of enablement of their already destructive behaviour.

I've seen it remarked before on this site that the real solution to the Fermi Paradox is that every other intelligent civilization in the universe is forever held back because of its need to provide for its members that have collectively decided they no longer feel like contributing. In the words of Ned Flanders, "taxes pay for trees, sunshine, policemen, and the folks who just don't feel like working - god bless 'em!"

[1] https://www.dare2bnyc.org/showers [2] https://acenewyork.org/

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by adamredwoods on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:42PM (#30675468)
You've formulated a policy from one anecdote? Homelessness is complex. That is why no single policy can remedy it, because people try to see it or treat it as one-solution-fits-all.

https://www.seattle.gov/homelessness/the-roots-of-the-crisis

http://archive.kuow.org/post/tenants-risk-homelessness-were-...

http://archive.kuow.org/post/community-talk-about-jungle

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by honkdaddy on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:48PM (#30676445)
I haven't formulated a policy, nor would I be very good at it if I tried. You're absolutely right, homelessness _is_ complex, that's sort of what I was getting at, though I could've phrased it much better.

I think the viewpoint I find frustrating is that if we could "just" solve the housing affordability issue, that everything else would fall into place. There are places with very affordable housing with lots of homeless people. There are places with very expensive housing and almost no homeless people. The issue is multi-faceted and complex, but I personally think it's better to start by looking at the social factors than it is the strict economics.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by woodruffw on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:06PM (#30676738)
> I think the viewpoint I find frustrating is that if we could "just" solve the housing affordability issue, that everything else would fall into place.

This is not a viewpoint that I've ever heard earnestly expressed by anyone involved in homelessness/housing policy.

Housing is something we should provide for two reasons: because it is the humane thing to do, and because it lowers the ceiling for other restorative/rehabilitative efforts. It can't on it's own solve every social ill that comes with homelessness or privation, and it isn't intended to.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by noahtallen on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:14PM (#30676849)
I think people talk about housing a lot for a few reasons. Firstly, it is impossible to help someone out of an addiction and to help them land on their feet if they don’t have somewhere to live. Secondly, the cost of housing means that someone could end up on the streets for a short period of time just because they couldn’t make ends meet for a month. That can easily turn into something worse. Third, and maybe most importantly, housing is something which impacts everyone. When it’s very hard to find for the average person to find a decent place for a good price, everyone starts caring about it more. As an example, lower housing prices immediately benefits folk’s lives here more than addiction services would. Finally, the perceived changes required for housing are easier to make than other changes. For example, people mostly seem to talk about upzoning, reducing NIMBYism, and making the permitting process faster. Relatively speaking, it’s easier to make those changes than it is to solve drug use and crime.

So that’s why I believe people focus on housing a lot.

Of course the other aspects (mental health and drug use) are extremely important as well. Because someone who is mentally unwell might not want to live in that cheap apartment. But how do you solve that problem? If we have a group of people who can’t or don’t rely on a family support system (which was probably more common 50-100 years ago), we need to create a support system for them. And that is extremely challenging to do compared to “change the zoning laws” or “pay a developer to build a new building.”

So I think it makes sense that people fixate on housing, even if the other parts of it are also very impactful. (But again, how do you solve the social factors if someone doesn’t even have somewhere to live?)

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by MartinCron on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:55PM (#30675636)
People don't formulate policies from anecdotes, silly. They adopt policies that align with their existing world view and then anecdotes to back up these policies.

I strongly doubt it was the article from the Stranger's blog that completely turned around honkdaddy's thinking on this subject.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by unsupp0rted on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:15PM (#30675916)
> This is a city where nearly any deli or corner-store has a We're Hiring sign

But then Andre would need to work for somebody else and with somebody else, on somebody else's own schedule.

If you're amoral and see having a criminal record as a cost of doing business, then selling stolen merchandise on a street corner lets you be your own boss on your own schedule, which, as we on HN know, lots of people are willing to give up a third to half of their paycheck to achieve.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by 30367286 on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:45PM (#30677246)
This is one aspect of homelessness that I never see addressed by those advocating for liberal policies like free housing. What do we do with the people who simply prefer not to work at all? Even giving them Basic Income would not stop them from selling stolen merchandise.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by pas on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:27PM (#30677814)
Giving them housing doesn't mean they also get immunity from criminal laws.

Recidivism itself is seen as a factor during sentencing, which means that even for the same isolated criminal act the same perpetrator gets longer and longer sentences.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by honkdaddy on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @09:55AM (#30685298)
In theory yes, in practice, no. Here in New York people aren't reprimanded for petty theft anymore, and even if they are, they're not usually charged.

The Yonkers man who brutally beat a 67yo Asian woman [1] had already been arrested 14 times. Only now, after they beat a harmless elder half to death for no reason, will they see any level of punishment.

[1] https://pix11.com/news/local-news/northern-suburbs/yonkers-m...

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by 30367286 on Monday March 14, 2022 @09:14PM (#30680686)
> Giving them housing doesn't mean they also get immunity from criminal laws.

All evidence to the contrary. SF, Seattle, LA… seems like the free housing people are indeed immune to at least petty crime laws.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by TulliusCicero on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:15PM (#30675931)
Housing First is about housing first — not “housing is the conclusion”. Obviously you need other programs to help people, and for the ones who can’t or won’t be helped voluntarily, you need institutions and prison, respectively.

I don’t want people to go to prison, that should be what happens as a sort of last resort. People should have plenty of options before you get there, but yeah there’s always gonna be some number of dickheads that are better just kept away from the rest of society.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by nemothekid on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:21PM (#30676029)
>The logic being presented here is that because the government has only given them free housing and not a free place to play basketball, it's reasonable to expect that they'll fill their days selling stolen goods. By building somewhere to shoot hoops, the problem could be solved.

This is a strawman - expect the strawman here is Andre. When, during the course of this interview, did Andre become a city planner? Why are you taking his suggestion so literally?

You have successfully quoted the problem ("he has struggled with homelessness on and off since he was 14"), but then refuse to actually address it. Someone who has been homeless since 14 is not going to magically become better without significant resources expended. Someone who has been homeless since 14 is probably someone who is very difficult to reintegrate into society and likely has problems holding down an actual job. The "solution" for Andre is likely therapy and education, the latter which he missed during his developmental years. To try and fix issues like these is very expensive and can only be done on a case by case basis.

The people who believe "homelessness is an issue that can be solved by throwing free housing at people" are looking to avoid creating these types of individuals instead of "fixing" them post-hoc. You aren't going to fix a problem exacerbated over 20 years by a policy change in 2.

I don't blame those who live there (or in any cities like SF), as I personally don't believe the problem was caused by Amazon or any other tech company; I understand the frustration of dealing with people who think homelessness was personally caused by Jeff Bezos. Both are just side effects of policy changes and tech advancements that happened decades ago; and in the same vein I think solutions to homeless must consider approaches on the same time scale.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by klyrs on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:37PM (#30675398)
> Homelessness is a social phenomenon, not an economic wart caused by expensive housing.

It can be both, and you can cherrypick anecdotes to support whatever narrative you prefer. Alternatively, one can seek data and look for trends in the statistics.

https://www.zillow.com/research/homelessness-rent-affordabil...

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Tiktaalik on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:19PM (#30675986)
It would not be an improvement if Andre didn't have an apartment. Then you'd have the same problem as now, except that Andre would have no option but to sleep in a tent in a park, which would make life worse for everyone that uses that park.

Creating affordable low income housing makes the city better for everyone and it's a necessary first step towards solving the sort of problems Andre has.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by honkdaddy on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:51PM (#30676492)
I think the part that many people find frustrating is that Andre is still _choosing_ a life of crime, despite being given the incredible gift of a free place to live, when it's unarguable that both under the table and formal employment is bountifully available in a place like Seattle.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by blacksmith_tb on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:20PM (#30676939)
I am skeptical that someone who has no job history in his adult life (and a rap sheet) can easily find formal employment - even if he had an absolute change of heart, it would take a pretty big-minded boss to trust him with the keys to the register. And it's a hard sell as a career change - sweeping out a fast food joint for hours and hours is not exactly living by your wits, even if you don't have to worry about getting arrested for doing it.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by honkdaddy on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @10:05AM (#30685430)
Would it surprise then that a massive, massive chunk of Americans have never had formal employment and have worked under the table their entire lives? It's far more common than we like to think in our cushy tech bubble. These places aren't running background checks or taking SSNs, these are gigs where you unload trucks or chop vegetables for 8h and get paid at the end of your shift.

Workers who are undocumented actually make up almost 5% of America's workforce - cash pay workers are probably an even higher percent.

It's an almost comically bourgeoisie myth that one needs an SSN and job history to get paid in America. Go to any Home Depot outside the city around 6am and ask any of the hard-working, skilled, day labourers making $100/day to support a family of five if they think the government of Seattle should be happily giving out free apartments to life-long criminals.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by blacksmith_tb on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @05:12PM (#30691766)
I'm sure that's true. But then working under the table makes them 'life-long criminals' also? If anything they should be able to take advantage of social services that having to hide your income probably locks you out of? And clearly the undocumented are 'illegal' too, though I think it'd benefit everyone to establish a formal guest-work program that would cover them better, since the demand for their labor isn't going away.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by AnimalMuppet on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:21PM (#30678513)
"Choosing" is a bit strong. He's more just kind of drifting along, and that's his default behavior. (Yes, ideally he would have enough moral backbone to not do that behavior, but that's asking a fair amount.) What he needs is to be encouraged to change defaults, and a new default that is better than the old one. And he needs someone to help him see the value in the new default, and to encourage him to consistently choose the new over the old.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by woodruffw on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:46PM (#30676422)
The point of housing isn't to "solve" every single problem caused by homelessness or indigence. It's to give people housing, because it's the humane thing to do.

It sounds like Andre's problem isn't homelessness (he's housed, per the article), but that he's a petty thief with no other real prospects or skills. Those aren't problems that housing can solve, but housing does eliminate some of the barriers in the way of those problems (such as Andre being robbed while sleeping on the street).

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by sershe on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:35PM (#30681109)
I think Andre the petty thief being robbed (or freezing to death, or ODing) while sleeping on the street is not ideal, but better than the status quo where we actively support and encourage his activities in the city. Why would we be humane to someone who fundamentally doesn't respect others' rights?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by woodruffw on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @08:58AM (#30684663)
Not letting someone die of exposure or crime is not supporting or encouraging his activities.

> Why would we be humane to someone who fundamentally doesn't respect others' rights?

This is a deeply dispiriting and reactionary way to look at the world. You do it because humane treatment is an end in itself, not a reward we give people for being “good.” It’s not earned, it’s due.

Edit: And, to be absolutely clear: there’s no world in which pointlessly punishing Andre gets what you what you want. Giving caffeine to a drunk doesn’t make them less drunk; it turns them into a wide awake drunk. Punishing someone with homelessness and exposure doesn’t make them into less of a petty criminal; it turns them into a more desperate and jaded one.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by sershe on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:19AM (#30699141)
There's space between "punishing" and "rewarding". In my book, giving someone free housing when they came somewhere to steal as a career, is "rewarding". That is why e.g. immigration systems in Canada and Australia have point systems where they want to encourage good workers to come to them - keeping them out would not be "punishing" - letting them in is "rewarding" them for planning to do useful work in e.g. Canada.

Also "humane treatment is an end in itself, not a reward we give people for being “good.” It’s not earned, it’s due." this is a deeply naive and childish view of the world. The humane treatment is not "earned", yes - it's the default. But it can be "unearned" - if someone doesn't give others the "humane" treatment, they don't deserve one either. Social contract, sorta.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by RobertMiller on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @09:14AM (#30684802)
> Why would we be humane to someone who fundamentally doesn't respect others' rights?

From a purely pragmatic standpoint: because it's good for general morale.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by sershe on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:15AM (#30699104)
Dozens of homeless die in Seattle per year from ODs, cold, fights, etc. The general morale doesn't appear to be affected very much. On the other hand, it does seem to be affected by crime and 3rd-world conditions on the street... so, on the margins, death of a career criminal would improve general morale.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by RC_ITR on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:40PM (#30676316)
The problem that isn't solved by housing is 'streetscape attractiveness.'

Whether they like to admit it or not, the thing that is appealing to most people about authoritarianism is the aesthetics (look at the meme of Singapore and gum, something that is reflective of a decades-long policy of corporal punishment for minor antisocial behaviors). Homelessness is related to this, because authoritarian governments are happy spend resources to jail the homeless (or otherwise hide their existence).

Whether or not they realize it, the US used to be a lot more authoritarian about streetscape attractiveness (at least in areas where the wealthy would congregate) - tents would be taken immediately by police, people would sit in jail for camping, etc. Then COVID caused a one-time burst in anti-authoritarian compassion, but now people are grappling with how much of that should become permanent vs. temporary (if you think the WFH debate is hot, ask a local unhoused person about a return to group shelters vs. relaxed camping laws).

The trend you're identifying is that people conflate the broad problem of streetscape attractiveness with one of its causes (also a broad problem). We as a society can solve homelessness, but that does not mean that streetscapes will immediately become attractive.

My bet is that a lot of streetscape attractiveness laws get passed/enforced now that the trauma-induced compassion of the pandemic is fading (because as you so rightfully point out, people like clean safe streets), and my hope is that improved housing policy coincides with that to limit the impact on society's most vulnerable.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Aunche on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:55PM (#30675638)
> This is a city where nearly any deli or corner-store has a We're Hiring sign and will gladly pay people under the table.

To be fair, I doubt any corner store would hire him. Any real job is probably more lucrative than peddling stolen goods off the street, so there's likely a good reason for why he doesn't have another option (e.g. mental health or substance abuse).

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by asdff on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:25PM (#30679871)
a real job is only paying $15/hr. You can honestly probably make a lot more just selling cigarettes on a train, that's like a couple sales, or panhandling outside a bunch of restaurants, if people are giving $5's on avg thats only 3 people, and I've seen people give $20s to panhandlers. An hour is a lot of time to only come up with $15. Plus theres taxes too. Maybe child support or alimony garnishes wages earned traditionally too.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tryitnow on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:58PM (#30675684)
Well, there's a lot to comment on here, I'll address just your last sentence.

If you owned a deli or corner-store would you be willing to hire someone with criminal record?

Would you be willing to hire someone who doesn't have a home?

Keep in mind that not having a home means they probably have no way to consistently keep themselves clean. And what do they put on the employment application for their address? And how good of an employee is someone going to be when they don't know where they're going to sleep at night?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by sydbarrett74 on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:07PM (#30676760)
Incarceration would be an act of mercy for people like this. Three hots and a cot. They could while their days away watching TV in the rec room and jerking off in their cells.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by 0xbadcafebee on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:14PM (#30675905)
> steal and then sell anything ... all for a couple dollars

When people's socioeconomic situation is so incredibly messed up and they know the system doesn't care about them, they'll do whatever they have to to survive. The cracks in the system have always been pushed to the fringes of society where the middle and upper class didn't have to pay attention to them, but now the cracks are visible downtown.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by raxxorrax on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @06:49AM (#30683797)
You need to provide a perspective, not a distraction. Free housing is good, but people will want to make money in any case to satisfy their needs. Of course that alone won't serve the problem. Crime decreases where there are better opportunities to earn money honestly. Of course providing employment is easier said than done.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by stonogo on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:43PM (#30675492)
The logic being presented here is that the guy selling stolen socks on a street corner should have all the answers?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Centigonal on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:42PM (#30675463)
These are people. They don't disappear if you crack down on them. How do you propose Seattle treat them?

Hassle them with repeated arrests and releases? When has this approach ever worked?

Put them in prison and make them an expensive, institutionalized ward of the state? I don't want that on my taxes.

I know you don't like this interviewee's attitude, but think about it for a second. This is a man who has spent most of his life flipping small-dollar goods outside on a street corner and being looked down on by many. This is not a life most people would envy. I don't condone petty theft, but I don't think Seattle would benefit from this person losing their housing or being prosecuted either.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by honkdaddy on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:53PM (#30676528)
All I think is that if the city is in the business of giving out free homes (great!), maybe they shouldn't start by giving them to criminals who openly say they're not interested in real work? Maybe single-mothers, veterans, or the physically disabled could be at the front of the line?

Andre doesn't represent all homeless people; I'm aware of that. But I think he represents a much larger population than people would like to believe.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Centigonal on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:17PM (#30678459)
I can agree with that, as long as the process for detemining who gets to be at the front of the line isn't so onerous or expensive to the that it outweighs the benefits.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by culpable_pickle on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:48PM (#30678857)
99% Invisible did an amazing series on exactly that, how do you pick who gets what.

It's called "According to Need"

https://99percentinvisible.org/need/

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by sydbarrett74 on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:11PM (#30676808)
Petty theft times a hundred or a thousand equals grand theft. He's a habitual offender, ergo, he belongs in prison. He knows exactly what he's doing.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Centigonal on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:31PM (#30678629)
If we put Andre in prison, Seattle's taxpayers would be paying $3,400/mo to keep him there[1]. I think that's a waste of money.

You might say that putting Andre in prison is worth it, because it would discourage him from stealing in the future. Looking at the research around the topic, the US Sentencing Commission found that there is no statistically significant deterrent effect from sentences under 5 years [2]. Other studies have found no deterrent effect from any length of sentencing [3]. So now we're looking at a minimum 5 year sentence for an uncertain positive effect.

If prison were a drug or a program that cost $3,400/mo and had to be taken for 5 years for an effect that may not even be real, we would call it a scam.

I'm not saying Andre is in the right. I'm saying the carceral way of dealing with poor people who commit petty crimes is expensive and ineffective (maybe even more so than giving someone a free apartment and letting him loiter on the street corner), and we need to consider a different way forward.

[1] https://www.doc.wa.gov/docs/publications/reports/200-AR001.p...

[2] https://www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/research-and-pu...

[3] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/003288551141522...

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by RobertMiller on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @08:22AM (#30684397)
> If we put Andre in prison, Seattle's taxpayers would be paying $3,400/mo to keep him there

He and his ilk do much more damage to the city than that, when they're allowed to continue their criminal lifestyles.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by lostmsu on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:35PM (#30679950)
Oh, but you are not counting the cost of goods he steals per month unless he is incarcerated.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by sershe on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:39PM (#30681136)
The approach seems to work quite well in many other cities, as close as 5 miles away from Seattle. If you hassle them, they'd go somewhere else. Does it solve THE problem? No. Does it solve A problem? Yes. The hassled people will mostly move somewhere without the hassling. Hence, dumb people who refuse to use the hassling approach will get what they want - endless opportunities to be humane. If absolutely everyone starts hassling them, the problem will become less concentrated and hence easier to address; plus the incentives would change for the people themselves, definitely having effect on the margins.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by baby on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:48PM (#30676444)
At this point they should just do loosely regulated street markets a thing. There's plenty of that in the rest of the world.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by monksy on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:56PM (#30675662)
From the drug selling, I wonder how much this guy pays tax on the sell. I wonder what his power bill is.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by dixie_land on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:23PM (#30675213)
Exactly. Some of those troubled neighborhoods (belltown) were home to me when I first moved to Seattle. It’s sad seeing liberals ruining it by legalizing and encouraging crimes (no persecution). Seattle is worse than downtown Detroit by a large margin now. Probably crime capital of the nation. And they’re actively exporting the problems to the east side.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by torbTurret on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:31PM (#30675325)
I’ve lived in both Seattle and Detroit and many other cities as well.

Painting Seattle as the crime capital of the nation is the most hyperbolic thing I’ve ever read on this site. By miles. Get real lol.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by GoodJokes on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:29PM (#30675285)
You are not describing homelessness. Andre has a home. You are describing a class that has resorted to this type of activity due to inequities in society.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by lliamander on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:47PM (#30675540)
He is the kind of person who would have been homeless were it not for a government program. Many people assume the problems associated with homelessness (e.g. crime) will go away if you give people free housing and other social support.

Andre is evidence that simply giving people what they need is not enough to stop criminal behavior.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by shkkmo on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:12PM (#30675884)
> Andre is evidence that simply giving people what they need is not enough to stop criminal behavior.

But who is to know what Andre's life would have been like if he had been given what he needed when he was 14? You can't expect someone to spend some of their most formative years on the street and then bounce back just because they suddenly have a roof over their head.

Providing housing certainly is not always sufficient to solve everyone's problems. Plenty of people who've never been homeless commit crimes, develop drug habbits and find other ways to destroy their lives.

Housing is however, necessary, if you want to have any luck helping people. Fixing economic, psychological, substance, or emotional problems becomes many times harder. When people are desperate and are treated liked outcasts regularly, deterring criminal behavior also becomes several times harder.

So yes, housing does not fix everything. It is however a necessary first step in any plan to deal with the homelessness and its comorbidities. Any approach that doesn't start with housing is doomed to fail.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by MartinCron on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:58PM (#30675694)
By "the kind of person who would have been homeless were it not for a government program" you mean someone who chose their parents badly and was homeless at 14, a literal child?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by filoleg on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:24PM (#30676067)
I think they literally mean “they receive government assistance that allows them to have a roof over their head”. Where does the part about “choosing parents” even come from?

The comment you were replying to wasn’t making any sort of a judgement, what they said was straight up just factually describing the current situation. They weren’t blaming Andre for becoming homeless. They were using him as an illustration that just giving free housing isn’t some magic pill that will solve everything, and the effective solutions need to be more comprehensive than that.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by immibis on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:05PM (#30677513)
"Choosing parents" is mocking a frequently-held attitude that when people do bad things, it's 100% of the time 100% their own fault and nobody else ever had anything to do with it. "Andre steals stuff because he makes bad choices. If he'd just stop making bad choices, he wouldn't be in trouble so much. It's all his fault."

The reality is that people often do make reasonably good decisions from the set of decisions available to them - and that set is often quite bad. Andre's only source of income is selling stolen goods. If he'd stop doing that, wouldn't it be worse for him because he'd have no income? People will say "he should just get a job" but have you tried getting a job? Like, ever? It's far from trivial, especially if you have a criminal record! So, given the choice between A (easy and effective) or B (difficult and probably ineffective) or C (having no money) the best decision is obvious. Choosing A is a good decision. And if we don't want Andre to choose A, we need to give him a better option.

Oftentimes it starts with growing up:

> Andre said he has struggled with homelessness on and off since he was 14. That’s when he started selling at 3rd and Pine. He’s been there almost everyday since. He’s 30 now.

If Andre had a computer at 14 he could be commenting on Hacker News today. Or with other factors he could be an athlete, an artist, an entrepreneur, idk, anything. But he got started on the "petty crime to pay bills" path and that constrained his options from then on.

When we combine this known fact - that his crime begins with not having a stable childhood, which is largely determined by who you have as a parent and how your society treats them - with the attitude that "everything you do is your fault" - we come to the conclusion that it must be Andre's fault that his parents were poor and homeless, which is absurd.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by MartinCron on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:32PM (#30677858)
And in this case, the takeaway of “See? Exactly as I would have argued before I read this story, government intervention just doesn’t work!” feels so myopic. Plenty of interventions do work, you just don’t see them on 3rd Avenue.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by lliamander on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:56PM (#30678192)
Which has nothing to do with what I actually wrote.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by lliamander on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:36PM (#30677147)
Are you actually asking a question here?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by watwut on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:15PM (#30675930)
Then you changed the original task "how to stop homelessness" into "how to stop literally all crime".
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by lliamander on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:26PM (#30677794)
Of course goal is not "stop all crime".

But "end homelessness" was never only about simply providing shelter.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by mdoms on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:09PM (#30675833)
Why do they keep using the euphemism "flipped" in place of "stolen". It's stolen merchandise they're selling. Stolen.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tonguez on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:27PM (#30675261)
"I think it's great reading for anyone who believes homelessness is an issue that can be solved by throwing free housing at people."

By definition, if you give someone a home, they are not homeless.

"Andre lives in an apartment"

So he's not homeless.

"Homelessness is a social phenomenon, not an economic wart caused by expensive housing."

The problem with Andre is that he steals stuff. He's not homeless. Not every homeless person steals stuff or is an evil person.

The problem is the money is going to the wrong people. There are a lot of good and honest people that are homeless and/or struggling to pay their rent. Andre isn't one of them. Andre gets his housing for free while other people freeze and are basically forced to kill themselves. Why is that?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by amatecha on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:40PM (#30675433)
I'm not sure what would solve things for Andre now, but what would have helped him in childhood was having a home and not being driven to sell stolen property to make ends meet. Some of the deepest solutions to societal problems take a long time to really see the results of.

To shift it the other way, I grew up pretty privileged and never felt the need to steal things and steal them. However, I can easily determine that if I was homeless and poor I absolutely would have. There's no question. You do what you need to do to survive. To look at a 30-year-old guy and be like "what can we do" is missing the timeline by 20 years or whatever. His personality is now deeply invested in a "steal to live" mindset and it will be a constant struggle even if he got arrested and jailed repeatedly.

Wait, I missed one piece of your message, "the money is going to the wrong people" -- it doesn't make a difference. You help people and some people take advantage but society gets a massive net boost all around. You WANT everyone in your society to be doing decently and not driven towards crime.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by nemothekid on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:09PM (#30675834)
>I'm not sure what would solve things for Andre now, but what would have helped him in childhood was having a home and not being driven to sell stolen property to make ends meet. Some of the deepest solutions to societal problems take a long time to really see the results of.

This is one of the most difficult things to get across with solutions like this. The GP is a prime example of this kind of thinking; it's a refusal to look at systemic problems and apply systemic solutions and only focusing on the individual. The implication that if you gave someone a house they would turn around and stop stealing the next day is mindboggling for everyone. No one (should) advocate for housing as a magic wand to undo 20 years of rot.

Andre's "problem" isn't going to be fixed by anything other than likely expensive therapy and/or apprenticeships. The system has already failed him and it will be very expensive to fix. A cheaper solution is to not create "Andre" in the first place - a homeless 14 year old cannot possibly be expected to get an education or even begin integrating into society.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by colechristensen on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:46PM (#30676409)
When Andre is caught stealing, put him on house arrest in his apartment, allow him work release with training and education for an appropriate job, when he violates the conditions of his gentler conditions, send him to jail for a while.

Remove people from society who steal instead of contribute, give them the opportunity and tools to rejoin productively repeatedly until they can.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by throwawayboise on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:18PM (#30675965)
But a lot of people do advocate for exactly that. They say that to solve homelessness we should just give people a place to live and that it's ultimately cheaper than any other solution (implying that all their other problems, such as addiction and criminal habits will just go away if they have a place to live.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by nemothekid on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:28PM (#30676117)
Again, you are missing the point, or the people who are advocating that are misleading you. I do believe if you give people a place to live it is cheaper than any other solution. On 20 year time frames.

The homeless people who cause problems are now are, for a lack of a better word, fucked. It would cost tons of money to get these people the rehab, therapy, and education they need to reintegrate into society. It would be politically impossible (and probably financially unfeasible) to implement these changes. A better solution is just not creating these people in the first place. That is what housing first policy tries to achieve.

The vast majority of these people stories are the same - due to systemic poverty issues they weren't able to have stable housing and could not go to school or land a stable job. It was then they started petty crimes like doing drugs/stealing, and once they had a dependency on that lifestyle, they became a regular criminal over 10-15 years. Anyone who tells you they are going to undo 15 years of trauma within the next 3 years is selling you a lie.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by eftychis on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:44PM (#30677240)
I agree. These people are going to give birth to kids. How do you ensure these kids are not going down the same path?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:20PM (#30676007)
Who out there advocates for "give them a house and them stop, that's it, nothing else" ? I've never seen that, ever.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by slg on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:21PM (#30676032)
EDIT: Never mind I misread someone's comment and it is too late to delete since I got a response.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:24PM (#30676057)
I don't read it that way at all. They're very clearly criticizing the idea that it would.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by slg on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:26PM (#30676096)
Oops, you are right. I read that again and I misread it the first time.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by giraffe_lady on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:03PM (#30676700)
There is a lot of evidence that it's very effective and cost-efficient just in practical terms, but that is not why I support those policies. I support them because everyone deserves a home. Choosing not to provide one to someone who needs it when we have the ability is vicious and immoral.

What they do after that isn't really relevant to be honest. I'm not trying to polish people into perfect rule following members of society and anyway homeowners get addictions and commit crimes all the time as it is. We don't generally leap to questioning their right to have a place to live though.

If giving homeless people houses solved no other problems it would still be correct and morally necessary.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by katbyte on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:56PM (#30676579)
people like Andre have more kids, creating new Andre's. you need to help people like Andre to prevent it from continuing. Also "too expensive" is a pretty poor reason not to help. regardless whatever is being done is not working, its time to try new things (and imho that is UBI so people like andre have enough to have shelter and food if they so desire, or whatever they need)
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by immibis on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:34PM (#30677118)
Children are significantly influenced by their parents, but not 100%. How many children of religious conservative parents become liberal atheists? A lot, because of their environment, and that's despite the parents deliberately trying to prevent it. I doubt that thieving parents would deliberately try to prevent their children growing up into good productive jobs.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by kn0where on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:19PM (#30675983)
Having housing (whether prison or an apartment) is a prerequisite to get Andre to stop stealing, but it's not sufficient alone. If our prison system was rehabilitative in the slightest, it would be a good place to keep Andre from harming society. Instead, it's a highly expensive way of temporarily keeping him from harming society until he gets out, and returns to stealing.

The left doesn't seem to have any well formed ideas on actually replacing/reforming the current prison system with something that doesn't have horrible recidivism rates. Obviously there are alternatives but they don't seem politically viable in America. Instead, cities have focused on prosecuting less, which avoids inflicting more cruelty but allows other injustice to persist. At least in the short term, ignoring the problem uses a lot fewer tax dollars than actually implementing solutions.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by dillondoyle on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:33PM (#30676193)
Or have a minimum basic income. + free addiction services/drugs. Probably too far for almost everyone but I think it'd solve a lot of problems and be cheaper in the end.

Maybe not UBI but anti-prohibition for sure would be cheaper

[dead]
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by amatecha on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:19PM (#30675988)
I didn't say that. I said he was "driven to sell stolen property to make ends meet". Your disingenuous argument is insulting at best. Take your inflammatory rhetoric elsewhere.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by ALittleLight on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:32PM (#30676173)
You wrote "You do what you need to do to survive". That seems to imply he needed or needs to steal to survive.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by amatecha on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:30PM (#30677070)
I wrote that in reference to "if I [grew up] homeless and poor". You're making a straw-man argument against two unrelated statements I wrote about different things.

"I grew up pretty privileged and never felt the need to steal things and steal them. However, I can easily determine that if I was homeless and poor I absolutely would have. There's no question. You do what you need to do to survive." I wasn't talking about Andre.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by ALittleLight on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:50PM (#30677330)
Oh, I see. You were just making a completely unrelated comment about what you personally would do if you were in Andre's situation. You never meant that to be read as a justification for Andre's actions - of course.

If you didn't mean to defend or justify Andre's behavior, or minimize his guilt and responsibility for his crimes, then you and I are on the same page. He is a criminal who should be held responsible for his crimes. If you disagree with that then I suggest that's a more meaningful disagreement between us than whether or not you meant to say that Andre had to steal to survive.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by aperrien on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:24PM (#30676992)
A 14 year old is a child. Children are not known for coming up with well thought out long term plans, especially in trying circumstances.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by mcguire on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:48PM (#30676454)
Is food the only thing you need to survive?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by ALittleLight on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:54PM (#30676549)
I suppose you also need water, shelter, healthcare, and clothes - but these things are all provided free to people who can't afford them.

I think people who blame "the system" are basically ignorant and harmful. They are ignorant because they ignore all the services, benefits, and charities that currently exist and remove the "I had to steal to survive" defense. They are harmful because they distract well intentioned people who believe their nonsense into not solving the problem and they leave the drug addicted and mentally ill to decay in the streets causing problems for the rest of us.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by 131012 on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:08PM (#30676771)
You need status. A place in a criminal hierarchy gives that.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by ALittleLight on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:25PM (#30677019)
If you get status from being a drug addicted vagrant reselling stolen merchandise and living off of charity then I suspect you could get "status" from a wide variety of things - many of which are legal and preferable.

I don't believe there is a "criminal hierarchy" here. It's not like this guy is a level 2 fence working a theft team. I assume it's a loose association of drug addicts, drug dealers, petty thieves, dumpster divers, and resellers with lots of overlap on every category.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by RobertMiller on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @08:28AM (#30684440)
He may want status, but nobody is entitled to it. Some people are born into circumstances that gives them undeserved status, which is unfortunate. But for those born without status, earn it if you want it. You aren't owed status by society.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by coolso on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:39PM (#30676283)
> To shift it the other way, I grew up pretty privileged and never felt the need to steal things and steal them. However, I can easily determine that if I was homeless and poor I absolutely would have. There's no question.

OK, and I grew up the complete opposite and neither did I.

Do you actually believe that the under”privileged” simply can’t help stealing? That the poor are innately thieves? I find this astounding.

The problem is parenting and lack of family values, plain and simple.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by amatecha on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:35PM (#30677122)
No, I don't believe that at all. Your straw-man argument is disrespectful and not a productive addition to the conversation. You've fabricated a narrative I didn't communicate nor suggest.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by coolso on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:14PM (#30677646)
Would you mind, then, further explaining what you meant when you said there was “no question” you’d resort to stealing if you were poor, and how you can “easily determine” this? To me that implies one of two things: either you believe the only thing stopping you from stealing is not being poor - or you believe the same, but for everyone else who is poor as you observe them from afar in your state of comfortable privilege, to use your own term. (It also strangely implies that stealing is the only option for the poor in this country.)

Either way your statement as it stands is highly disrespectful of the millions who are fully capable of being dirt poor without resorting to theft and other crimes.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by morelisp on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:41PM (#30676326)
> The problem is parenting and lack of family values, plain and simple.

So we agree that Andre is blameless and should be given assistance, not punishment. Or is your position more like "obviously this guy's parents didn't love him, why should I?"

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by coolso on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:53PM (#30676530)
Perhaps I missed something in the article, but I believe Andre is already being assisted, which is simply resulting in his criminal behavior being subsidized by you and I. (Because we didn’t give him a basketball court too or something.)

The justice system simply needs to play the role his parents never did, disciplining him for his actions and then assisting him in making the right choices when his sentence is complete.

But blameless, no, he is not a child, much as you might like the system to treat him as one.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by mcguire on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:50PM (#30676481)
Do you mean real "family values" or is that the code-word version?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by seanmcdirmid on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:53PM (#30675619)
> The problem is the money is going to the wrong people. There are a lot of good and honest people that are homeless and/or struggling to pay their rent. Andre isn't one of them. Andre gets his housing for free while other people freeze and are basically forced to kill themselves. Why is that?

Actually, the easy homeless cases (people who lack housing but can still work because they are not addicted to drugs/mentally ill/etc...) can already handled fairly effectively by social services. But as you point out, they aren't able to discriminate between them and the harder homeless cases (people who are addicted to drugs/mentally ill/etc...), and treating homeless problems homogeneously means throwing a lot of money away.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by gruez on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:43PM (#30675476)
>By definition, if you give someone a home, they are not homeless.

>"Andre lives in an apartment"

>So he's not homeless.

Sounds like "homeless" in this context means "can't be a productive member of society to fund his own living", not literal homelessness.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by formersquatter on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:06PM (#30675789)
Well, at some level he is homeless. Statistics use things like "crashing in a friend's spare room" or "renting a cheap motel week by week" in their homeless numbers. They're not lacking a roof over their head, but they do lack standard, stable accommodation.

However, you're getting at the truth - "homeless" here is an "emotional baggage" word, and so often conveys that implied image of some poor, struggling, but otherwise "good" people just trying to make it. Except that's largely a solved problem, folks actively trying to end their homelessness will spend an average of three months or less in some sort of "homeless" criteria (on a friends couch, a hotel, a temporary accommodation). The bulk of the issue is folks dropping out of society and causing trouble for their surrounding communities.

Personally, I come from this community. I spent a majority of my middle and high school years bouncing around motels, squats, and friends spare rooms with my father. We were statistically homeless at some level, just not "sleeping rough." My father was and remains that way over a decade later - he cannot and will not be helped other than taking money for his own ends from an occasionally week-willed family member. He works under the table (an otherwise reasonably skilled plumber), pays no tax, bounces around a series of motels in a one-stoplight town along I-95, drinks, drugs, gets DUIs in a series of unregistered junk vehicles. At one point he did a few months for burning down our squat in a drug-bender gone wrong.

There exists a large, and growing subset of the population who have no interest in playing ball, in straightening up and flying right. No amount of "free housing" or "free healthcare" or "free _" is going to solve a cultural rot. When no one cares they will simply abuse the good-natured systems that fail to take into account ill intent.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by dash2 on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:39PM (#30676300)
There’s also a third category of people who have really serious problems, which can’t be fixed by resources, but who aren’t necessarily just “bad guys”. I worked with some long term homeless guys as a volunteer, and many had problems going back to tragic episodes in their childhood, long term addictions, and other stuff that needed more than (a) materially-based “charity” or (b) punitiveness.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by formersquatter on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:51PM (#30676496)
> which can’t be fixed by resources, but who aren’t necessarily just “bad guys”.

You're correct, the problem is certainly mosaic and does not fall into a binary "good guy" vs. "bad guy" ... and I'll never understand our nation and its response to long-term mental health facilities that were cesspool levels of bad. Instead of rebuilding them and reforming them, we just did away with them in their entirety. Some strange blend of anti-tax Reaganite and bleeding-heart ACLU-led progressivism combined into creating a hell we all have to suffer, or at least those of us in cities.

I have a soon-to-be FiL with a schizophrenic brother he cares for. The FiL is a man of means, and purchased a home for his brother many years ago in a nice neighborhood. He has family to take him to all appointments, address all of his needs... yet in spite of his absolutely ideal condition he is a menace to his community and would be on the streets were it not for this brotherly love. The standard behaviors, pacing around in the neighborhood muttering to himself, smoking crack, and just general nuisance behaviors. He has accidentally burned down two of his homes through smoking / sleeping in bed but miraculously survived both incidents.

This is a real issue, but a fractional amount, and orthogonal to the issue of the societal drop-outs that are mentally sound, capable of contributing, but choose the path of the drop-out and burn-out. We could solve that problem, we just don't.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by honkdaddy on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:57PM (#30676594)
This is a much more substantive comment than mine, thanks for sharing your experience.

In your case, what brought you from the situation you were in before to wherever you are now?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by formersquatter on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:30PM (#30677072)
If you guessed "programming" ...

I had one "normal" parent, in the sense of having a home and a stable job, living in a decent community. I was just persona-non-grata in that household by middle school age, as there were some issues with an abusive live-in-boyfriend of my mothers. So I had a stable schooling, and if I needed something like a TI-83 for school I would be furnished it. I wasn't truly destitute, but at the same time had an unstable living arrangement and frequently had to be used as some sort of sympathy bait in the second-hand bread line.

I befriended a student fiddling with a hex editor and a NES ROM in a typing class and that was a bridge into programming for me. Got into a mess of languages and systems (Java, PHP, Javascript, graphic design, etc.) Met some more classmates that were of good means, and of similar interests and so I just sort-of aped their bleeding-edge interests, whether it was PHP, Web 2.0 CSS / jQuery wizardry, or general systems administration.

Following high school, I landed a job out of high school as an intern programmer for $10 / hour on a 1099, getting some number of promotions and raises to $75K full-time with benefits with a little over two years. From there, I'm pretty much just any other programmer.

I told my father if he ever wanted to get his shit together, to reach out and we'd figure it out... but that has never happened. I have some contacts that through their daily lives end up keeping tabs on him, he still scrapes by living his itinerant life.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Izkata on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:40PM (#30676306)
Yeah, it's one of those annoying ways language doesn't mean what it literally says, so it doesn't make a lot of sense if you don't know the idiomatic usage. Ever hear the phrase "feed the homeless"?

"Homeless" in this context really means something like "doesn't live normally" or "can't support themselves the right way".

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by mbesto on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:37PM (#30676258)
> "can't be a productive member of society to fund his own living"

But he can fund his ability to physically live...in an apartment? Is there another word for a person that "can't be a productive member of society to fund his own living" other than homeless?

Seems like a weird colloquialism to try to adopt.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by gruez on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:16PM (#30676870)
>But he can fund his ability to physically live...in an apartment?

From the article:

>Andre lives in an apartment thanks to a city-run housing program, but he doesn’t have a job other than selling flipped merchandise.

His apartment is partially funded by the government.

> Is there another word for a person that "can't be a productive member of society to fund his own living" other than homeless?

Not that I know of. Of the ones that come to mind:

"Poor" just implies you can't afford nice things, not necessarily that you can't hold down a job to sustain yourself

"jobless" just implies you currently don't have a job (ie. unemployed), not necessarily that it's a long term thing.

"NEET" is closer, but is more associated with people living in their parent's basements than of the people profiled in the article.

I guess you could use the term "long term jobless" or something, but it doesn't exactly roll off the tongue.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by WillPostForFood on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:04PM (#30675772)
Andre is an addict and/or has mental issues. If we avoid discussing that we can’t make progress on a solution.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by kingcharles on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:56PM (#30676585)
This is the answer. As someone who has been to jail with hundreds of thieves, a large proportion of it is addiction or undiagnosed/untreated mental-health issues.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by morelisp on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:07PM (#30675812)
What evidence do you have that the greater part of his "mental issues" are not trauma responses from being homeless since childhood?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by ativzzz on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:31PM (#30676163)
A trauma is often a precursor of mental illness. PTSD is an obvious example. Giving someone a house to live in doesn't magically cure it.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by WillPostForFood on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @05:07PM (#30691727)
Does it matter at this point? You can't undo the damage with housing, it is a mental issue regardless of cause.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by spywaregorilla on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:30PM (#30675301)
So what should happen to andre?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:38PM (#30675415)
He should go to jail for theft and selling stolen merchandise.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by krnlpnc on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:19PM (#30675980)
Americans are happy to foot the bill to house, feed, provide medical care, education, etc by throwing homeless people in jails.

Cut out the jail. Put the exact same dollar amount towards universal health, food, income, and education programs.

Let's see which one produces a healthier outcome for our society as a whole.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by dahfizz on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:37PM (#30676244)
Yeah, its so cheap and easy for the government to take care of the homeless. It has been working wonders so far.

https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory/la-spending-837000...

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by woodruffw on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:55PM (#30676565)
This is a particularly egregious example of editorialization-by-headline:

> Most of the units are studios or one-bedroom apartments. The audit found 14% of the units build exceeded $700,000 each, and one project in pre-development is estimated to cost almost $837,000 per unit.

So it's one unit that doesn't exist that might cost $837,000, not the average unit. Indeed, the average unit is nowhere near that.

Edit: For comparison, it costs $100k per year to support each prisoner in California's system[1]. Even if the average unit costs $400k (which still seems high), it pays for itself after less than half a decade.

[1]: https://lao.ca.gov/policyareas/cj/6_cj_inmatecost

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by dahfizz on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:04PM (#30676712)
The $100k per year for incarceration includes food, medical care, counseling, maintenance, facilities, etc. The cost just for housing is dramatically lower than $100k/year. You are comparing just the cost of housing with the cost of taking care of all a person's needs.

Those $700k units that LA built will also require constant repairs, and the inhabitants will still need food, medical care, counseling, etc.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by woodruffw on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:41PM (#30677200)
> The $100k per year for incarceration includes food, medical care, counseling, maintenance, facilities, etc. The cost just for housing is dramatically lower than $100k/year. You are comparing just the cost of housing with the cost of taking care of all a person's needs.

I wouldn't start by saying that the US prison system takes care of any inmate's needs, even if they spend a fabulously large amount of money seemingly earmarked for that task.

Long term, permanent housing is always going to beat incarceration, when we're talking about the same population. It might cost more at first, but those costs are overwhelmingly fixed and then much smaller future variables. The variables that aren't covered (food, medical care, etc., as you've correctly observed) can often be transferred from carceral programs. Fewer people in prisons also means less money spent on maintaining the physical and human plant; some 20% of the individual costs listed above.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by krnlpnc on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:52PM (#30677354)
Comparing a fixed property purchase price to a yearly estimated recurring cost isn't a direct comparison

Assuming a $700k unit has an estimated lifespan of 50 years. That's $14k/year, we could say $20k/year with a generous maintenance allowance over the life of the home.

So in this example that's $80k/yr remaining for food, utilities, care, etc.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:13PM (#30676834)
It's probably not accurate to say that jails are adequately taking care of all a person's needs, and certainly not to match any sort of expectation that they'd have outside of the walls of the jail. Being in jail means you've given up a lots of rights that would be required outside of those walls (such as privacy).
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by HWR_14 on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:31PM (#30677081)
You left out that the one development may not be one-bedroom apartments and that one-bedroom apartments can easily hold 2-4 people. I also think expecting an ROI in 4 years is very aggressive. The housing can easily last decades, and the upkeep costs combined with the depreciated costs should be quite affordable compared to incarceration.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by woodruffw on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:35PM (#30677132)
Thanks for pointing that out. I'm not an LA resident, and it was frankly difficult to find the actual local law that's funding the construction efforts (Prop. HHH).

5 years is indeed aggressive, and probably unrealistic. My goal was to show that even with contrived (and conservative) numbers these programs look great; with longer outlooks, they look fantastic.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by gpvos on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:54PM (#30676554)
Putting them in jail is more expensive and less effective.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tiahura on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:30PM (#30676147)
We stopped putting them in jail in the 70s and adopted your approach.

The results have been abysmal.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by gpvos on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:53PM (#30676538)
The US is the country with the highest incarceration rate and you want to make it even higher? Clearly incarceration is not helping and you should try something different.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:13PM (#30676842)
Sorry, when did the war on drugs start again?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:50PM (#30675578)
Sending someone to jail is a surefire way to turn them into a more serious threat when they're released. You could just give the money you'd spend incarcerating them directly to the person or via food stamps, access to education, etc.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by seanmcdirmid on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:55PM (#30675639)
At some point, compassion has failed and incarceration is the only solution. You are simply claiming that compassion with additional resources can still have a positive effect on Andre. Maybe that's the case.

But whenever I wait for the bus at 3rd and Pine (we did on Saturday), I don't see much hope like you do.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by danShumway on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:11PM (#30675864)
> is the only solution

But is it a solution?

If Andre gets out of prison and goes back to stealing, then that process may well have wasted more money than many social programs for the exact same outcome. Imprisoning people is really expensive.

If Andre never gets out of prison at all, then we're committing to indefinitely spending a ton of money on him for the rest of his life, which also is not an amazing outcome. And that's only a theoretical possibility anyway, selling stolen goods (even habitually) is probably not going to get you a life-sentence in prison.

I think people have this perspective on incarceration that it's the final catch-all solution, and the reason we avoid it is purely compassion. And compassion is part of it, sure, but also if prison sentences don't reduce recidivism, then they're not a working solution. You should look at prison recidivism rates and apply the same level of skepticism and hold prison spending to the same standards that you apply to social programs and public housing. You should have the same expectations for both public housing and for what is essentially a much more expensive form of "coerced housing".

Asking how far we should go to reform someone before we give up and incarcerate is kind of begging the question -- it assumes that incarceration is always solution that just blanketly works and the only reason we avoid it is out of compassion and morality. In reality, incarceration is just another tool in the toolbox, and sometimes it might solve a problem, and sometimes it won't -- sometimes it's a complete waste of time and money.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by seanmcdirmid on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:29PM (#30676140)
> Asking how far we should go to reform someone before we give up and incarcerate is kind of begging the question -- it assumes that incarceration is always solution that just blanketly works and the only reason we avoid it is out of compassion and morality.

What is the alternative? Just let them keep taking dumps on society until they finally go too far and bash someone's head in with a baseball bat (like that poor girl in Belltown a few months ago)? Incarceration shouldn't be the first answer, but it might very well be the tenth or eleventh...if only to actually protect everyone else.

If all your compassion does is allow for someone to destroy themselves (like decriminalize drugs and provide safe places for people to pursue their addictions), then is that the alternative?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by danShumway on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:23PM (#30677771)
> Incarceration shouldn't be the first answer, but it might very well be the tenth or eleventh...if only to actually protect everyone else.

Again, this assumes incarceration works, which you don't get to just assume.

If someone comes out of prison and then bashes someone's head in with a bat, then the incarceration didn't work. You're still looking at this from a perspective of, "we have an answer that will work, but we want to avoid it when possible." And that's not the reality, sometimes incarceration doesn't fix the problem.

> What is the alternative? [...] If all your compassion does is allow for someone to destroy themselves (like decriminalize drugs and provide safe places for people to pursue their addictions), then is that the alternative?

I think that part of looking for an alternative should be trying to find out if the alternative produces better results than what we're already doing. If prison doesn't produce lower recidivism rates than social programs, then yeah, obviously the social programs are the correct alternative even if some people take advantage of them -- because we're not looking at a scenario where either system (social programs or prison) has 100% effectiveness at preventing crime.

Let me flip your own question back: if all your cruelty does is drive people into harder crime and more desperate actions when they get out of prison, then is that the alternative? The alternative to social programs is something that is wildly expensive and that is often ineffective at reforming behavior?

You have to look this stuff more pragmatically and less emotionally. We can have a conversation about the ethics of prison, and that can be an important conversation, but it really has nothing to do with the separate question of whether or not prison is practical and cost effective at keeping down crime levels. Both ethics and practicality matter for policy, but they are not dependent variables with each other -- something feeling harsher or crueler to you does not magically mean it works better.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:16PM (#30676872)
Do you believe that incarceration makes people better going out than coming in?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by seanmcdirmid on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:23PM (#30676975)
No not at all. But at that point it is less about them and more about everyone else.

For petty crime like fencing stolen goods, they are looking at a few weeks in jail at most. Not going to change their outlook very much, but will probably discourage them from fencing goods out in the open (at least in Seattle). This focus on petty crime works well for Bellevue (but forces the problem on Seattle).

The current crackdown, the cops aren't arresting anyone for fencing goods even when it's obvious what they are doing. Instead they are just telling them to leave (this happened a few times while we were waiting for the bus at 3rd and Pine a couple of days ago)...not a solution, they will definitely be back.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:02PM (#30677467)
Given that the problem moved from Bellevue to Seattle, that sounds less like "about everyone else" and more like "more about me". Just punish people enough until they move and become a problem elsewhere isn't making life better for anyone but the residents of whatever county they came from and only as long as they don't come back.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by seanmcdirmid on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:08PM (#30677547)
No, it is more of a "not being able to solve a regional/national problem" locally. If Seattle (or "Freattle" as it is called in grifter circles) is the best place to go and set up a tent, do decriminalized drugs, and shoplift with impunity, then...yes, they will attract a disportioncate part of the problem.

And yes, if the problem can't be solved locally (too harsh, push the problem somewhere else; too soft, attract more of the problem), why should be in the latter category? Is Seattle just a convenient sacrifice?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by danShumway on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:33PM (#30677882)
> but will probably discourage them from fencing goods out in the open (at least in Seattle)

Do you know beyond intuition what the stats are on that? If we take an average person and put them in prison for fencing goods, statistically what is the most likely outcome when they come out?

- What are the odds they stop doing this in the open?

- What are the odds they stop doing this entirely?

- What are the odds they move on to something worse? How much worse will it be and are there ways to mitigate that outcome?

- On average, what is the ratio of percent reduction in visible crime to the amount of money we would spend per-person? Are those numbers better/worse than other alternatives that we've looked at?

- Is this a constant across multiple types of crime? Do the numbers become different when we look at petty crime or violent crime?

Have you looked into that stuff, or are you just assuming on intuition that the numbers are good? We're all kind of talking past each other here; I suspect most people on HN know in theory why prisons should work, and I suspect most people know in theory why social programs should work. So explaining the theory is not particularly valuable at this point.

These numbers are really complicated, they're difficult to measure because of confounding variables and implementation details. There are ways of running prisons that make recidivism rates higher or lower, so it's not even an across-the-board single statistic. But that should be the baseline of where any conversation about this stuff starts.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:16PM (#30675947)
Completely agree. I'm not sure how people are so short sighted as to think prison is a "solution" - prison sentences are temporary.

Also, you used "begging the question" properly! I'm weirdly refreshed by that having just seen it misused in another comment.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by koolba on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:33PM (#30676201)
We as a society accepting the high costs of long term incarceration is an answer. It might not be a pleasant answer, or even an answer that everyone accepts. But we don't make that decision individually, we do it as a whole of society.

I'd bet the percentage of people that would rather pay to imprison people, rather than deal with the treatment / relapse loop is at least 25%. Likely even higher if you take it as a percentage of the gainfully employed.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by danShumway on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:46PM (#30678031)
> We as a society accepting the high costs of long term incarceration is an answer.

But that logic, anything society accepts is an answer. You could just as easily say that society accepting high crime rates is an answer.

You're right that policies often reflect public opinion, but when we're debating policy ideally the conversation would go deeper than that. Public discussions about policy in the open, on forums, etc, is a big part of how public opinion gets formed, and those discussions should probably dig into underlying goals and identify the costs and benefits of different approaches beyond just checking what the current majority preference is. Things can get a little circular when being popular is the justification for why something is popular.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Camas on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:55PM (#30676569)
Jails do not exist to rehabilitate prisoners, they exist to separate them from society.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by danShumway on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:43PM (#30678003)
Are jails a cost-effective way of separating people from society?

I see a couple of problems:

- most prison terms are limited (any prison term for petty theft is going to be).

- prisons often release people into the same communities they came out of.

- it is tremendously expensive to even get someone into prison, you have to arrest them and either get them through a trial or at least pay for sentencing if they just plead guilty.

If the entire goal of prison is to separate offenders from society (which could be its own conversation, but whatever, we'll take it for granted that's the goal), we still kind of need to ask if prison is the best way of doing that.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by RobertMiller on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @08:33AM (#30684481)
> Are jails a cost-effective way of separating people from society?

Optimizing for cost is not what you want. The most cost effective way of separating people from society is a summary execution with no trial. Prisons aren't meant to be the cheapest solution, they're meant to be a more humane compromise.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by danShumway on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @11:38AM (#30686640)
We optimize for cost alongside other factors. Let me rephrase:

Are jails a cost-effective way of separating people from society, even if we only look at solutions that are at least as humane as prison?

I'm sort of jumping around the main issue, which is that I don't think prisons only exist to separate people from society and I don't think most people think about them that way, not really. I think Camus up-thread is just wrong, prisons are about more than isolation. People think about prisons in terms of punishment/justice, and deterrence, and about organization/holding during trials, and yes, people also think about prisons as a rehabilitation effort.

If you look at prisons only through the lens of "this is where we put people we don't want to be around", then the system kind of stops making sense. It's not optimized for that.

I mean, if nothing else, you really have to grapple with the fact that most people don't get life sentences. If the person being discussed in this thread gets arrested and given 4 months in jail and then comes out back into the same community, then the public housing solution only really needs to keep him off the street for 5 months in order for it to be a cheaper and more effective solution -- unless prison is serving some other set of goals beyond just separating people from society temporarily, unless it's also trying to keep people outside of prison from committing crime, through both deterrence and rehabilitation.

But if you're just worried about removing people from society, prison is an awful way of doing that for low-level offenses; it's both incredibly stressful and cruel for the person being imprisoned, and incredibly expensive, and doesn't actually keep them separated from society for more than a few months to a year.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by immibis on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:47PM (#30677270)
In a way that's more expensive than if you just gave them a free home and a bunch of free spending money. Right?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:59PM (#30675704)
Sure, at some point. A guy who's just flipping stolen goods going to prison though is just totally stupid. You'll accomplish the opposite of your goals - you will increase crime with that sort of policy. And it'll cost you more.

edit: To elaborate, the "at some point" is like... where a person has to be removed from society because they're an imminent danger to themselves or others.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by seanmcdirmid on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:35PM (#30676213)
That guy isn't just flipping stolen goods, he is providing an outlet for a bunch of people to go through the downtown Target and clear it out, those people often get into altercations with people who work at that Target and even customers like me. Oh, "did my kid look at that homeless guy (actively stealing Legos in the toy section) wrong?" is not something most parents want to deal with.

We'd like our city back please.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:52PM (#30676508)
You're not really saying much. I also don't want someone to steal legos, that isn't a controversial statement.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by seanmcdirmid on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:06PM (#30676753)
People that fence goods are the reason shoplifting is viable. I think that is obvious, and why it shouldn't be allowed (and should be prosecuted).
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by long_time_gone on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:22PM (#30676035)
> At some point, compassion has failed and incarceration is the only solution.

The US has a higher incarceration rate than other developed countries, while also maintaining higher crime/violence rates. It doesn't seem to be a good solution to the crime problem. Does Andre get out of prison? What then?

It may be more accurate to say, "At some point incarceration has failed and compassion is the only solution."

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by seanmcdirmid on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:08PM (#30676774)
> The US has a higher incarceration rate than other developed countries

Oh, we really suck at this, I admit! First, it should never have gotten to this point, and second, prisons should focus on fixing rather than punishing people. We are in agreement. But I don't think there are many options for Andre at this point (we should have done a better job 15 years ago). Washington state prisons are also a bit more on the reform side than other states in the country.

> It may be more accurate to say, "At some point incarceration has failed and compassion is the only solution."

Compassion should always come first, incarceration is a last ditch effort and means we have basically failed this person.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:49PM (#30676455)
> Does Andre get out of prison? What then?

He either accepts the help again (housing, food, job, education, etc) and actually makes something of himself, or he commits more crimes and goes back to prison. Seems like a fairly straightforward deal to me.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by long_time_gone on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:11PM (#30676820)
So, the current system? The same strategy that's gotten us the high incarceration and crimes rates we have today doesn't seem like a solution to anything. Seems like a straightforward way to changing nothing.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:20PM (#30676930)
The part that is missing is the personal responsibility. If the guy doesnt change his direction with all the help thats available to him thats his own fault, not the system's.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by long_time_gone on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:28PM (#30677052)
>The part that is missing is the personal responsibility.

Where is that missing? It is there today. The fact is that society bears the financial burden of someone spending a life in prison (and also the emotional/financial/physical burden of the person's actual crimes). You seem to be dismissing that to make an ideological stance.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:45PM (#30677252)
Thats not the case anymore in cities like Seattle/SF/LA that have removed funding from police and discouraged police to arrest for crimes like theft, breaking into cars, etc. In the cases where they are arrested they are released on no-bail hours later to do the same thing.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by long_time_gone on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @09:33AM (#30685022)
Now, to test the ideology, do Miami/Jacksonville/Ft. Worth. All Republican cities in Republican states, all with surging crime. They didn’t take the actions you mentioned, but have the same result. Maybe it’s an opportunity to re-visit baseline assumptions.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by mbesto on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:42PM (#30676339)
> compassion has failed and incarceration is the only solution.

That's because the problems are much more systematic and large parts of the population approach the solution with monkey patching. So of course you'd think we've run out of solutions.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by angst_ridden on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:41PM (#30676336)
Right. Incarceration is the only possible solution. Which is why the US has the highest percentage of incarcerated population of any "civilized" nation in the world and zero crime.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by monksy on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:00PM (#30675724)
Want to go into the experience that is the near by Target?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by seanmcdirmid on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:02PM (#30676676)
Ha ha! We still go there because my kid likes the toy section. It has gotten better since the current crackdown has taken place, it doesn't feel like a dystopian retail establishment anymore.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by humanwhosits on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:21PM (#30676030)
Maybe we need a different sort of jail, one where things are kinda nice
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by dylan604 on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:27PM (#30676103)
That just pushes the can down the road. What does Andre do when he is released from jail?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:33PM (#30676184)
Uses the services available to him (free housing, food, job programs, transportation etc) to get a real job, leave his life of crime behind him, and eventually pay back his debt to society through the same taxes he utilized.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by spywaregorilla on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:37PM (#30676250)
Seems to me he's in the same spot he is now, except materially less employable due to a prison sentence. Do you think your idea here really seems probable to work?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:41PM (#30676320)
It gets him off the street (as well as others like him) and stops the hemorrhaging of businesses from those cities. This is the exact thing that leads to food deserts that will impact poor people actually doing the right thing with their lives and leads them to commit crimes of their own because why should they obey the social contract when guys like this are obviously not and making much more from it?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by immibis on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:48PM (#30677289)
If he will be the same when he gets out, and you know this, why let him out?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by RobertMiller on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @08:40AM (#30684524)
Suppose your roof leaks and you can't afford to fix it. Or maybe you pay some professionals to come fix it, they faff around for a bit, say they 'rehabilitated' your roof, but a while later it starts leaking again.

So you get a bucket and put it under the dripping hole. The bucket doesn't fix the roof. The bucket will eventually fill up and you'll have to empty it down a drain before trying it again. Again and again. The bucket isn't solving anything, but would you be better off without the bucket? No, the bucket at least keeps your floor dry some of the time. That's better than nothing. Prison is a bucket. Prisons collect criminals for a while until they eventually fill up. But they're better than dumping all those criminals straight into the streets.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:51PM (#30677338)
Because we don't have a long term mental health committal system like we should and the criminal system cant hold him forever on small charges.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by immibis on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:48PM (#30679538)
Can you imagine any circumstance whatsoever, under which you might develop a habit of stealing things?

Would you like to be committed to a mental institution forever, in that circumstance?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by sydbarrett74 on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:20PM (#30676934)
What most of us ignore is that people have to want to help themselves. Otherwise, their lives will never permanently improve. And unfortunately, this desire doesn't usually happen until people hit bottom. Simple human nature.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:25PM (#30677020)
If he doesn't want to help himself I see only 2 options then, either A) cut him off of all services and let him hit bottom to the point where he will want help or B) go to prison, get out and get better himself (if not, repeat)
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by AlvieH on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:45PM (#30675515)
And would that stop other people from stealing in the future? What's the return on investment for sending someone to jail over diapers stolen from a Walgreens?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by monksy on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:07PM (#30675814)
The lack of prosecution means that they continue to do that. Having a low stock on things at the store for known shoplifting sends a signal to the people at the store that there are 2 prices for their goods: Pay nothing or pay the price on it.

The store has to be able to recuperate the loss there. That means either:

1. Higher prices (and for a region that isn't doing well.. they can't afford it and are pushed futher to steal more to survive)

or

2. The store can't survive in that region (Good bye Target on the south side of chicago.. hello food desert once again..also job losses of people trying to make it legitmately) https://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-biz-target-closin...

When you punish someone for shoplifting sufficently enough: That means for the time that they're now occupied they can't shoplift, and others do not see continued shoplifting for them. (This is also how violent crimes work as well..)

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by catlifeonmars on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:22PM (#30676041)
> When you punish someone for shoplifting sufficently enough: That means for the time that they're now occupied they can't shoplift, and others do not see continued shoplifting for them. (This is also how violent crimes work as well..)

Honest question: how do we know that this works? And more importantly, where does incarceration as a deterrent not work (e.g. where are the bounds)? Do you have a source?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by monksy on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:55PM (#30676566)
> how do we know that this works?

Well when they're locked up.. they can't go to walgreens and steal a bucket of tidepods.

Sources: No unfortunately I don't. Most of the articles I've seen on this tend to have a bias against punishment for crime and tend to over inflate "corrupt enforcement". (Rather than to discuss the full situation, statistics and societal cost)

My understanding is that crime is mostly a young person's thing. The older people get the less likely they're to commit crime. Prison as a way of aging people out is effective. At best it can prevent people from falling back with the people who go them in the situation.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by catlifeonmars on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:42PM (#30677209)
> My understanding is that crime is mostly a young person's thing. The older people get the less likely they're to commit crime.

This makes sense; younger people tend to be less risk averse. Not sure if “aging people out” is the right solution: people who get out of prison usually have worse prospects than when they go in, so (assuming older people are in fact less likely to commit crime) we’d be trading one social problem for another (health/welfare/homelessness).

Also, from an ethical standpoint, I don’t think I could get behind long incarceration times and strict punishments for petty crimes just to reduce the rate of crime. These are real (young) people with lives that are being upended for some mistakes.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by BitwiseFool on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:04PM (#30675765)
>"And would that stop other people from stealing in the future?"

Yes. Consequences are a deterrent. You will never be able to know for sure how many acts of theft weren't carried out because the person decided the reward wasn't work the risk of getting caught and going to jail. It seems self-evident that theft will rise when deterrents are dramatically curtailed. No one was suggesting that the threat of jail/prison would prevent all theft.

>"What's the return on investment for sending someone to jail over diapers stolen from a Walgreens?"

This is intangible. There will never be a satisfactory answer because there are just too many variables. How much theft was prevented by merit of being in jail? Is it possible going to jail made this person re-evaluate their life? Maybe some cashier's life was saved because a confrontation never took place. The theoreticals are endless.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:13PM (#30675891)
> Yes.

Until they're released. At which point they'll have an even harder time getting a job, they'll be even more alienated and broken, and they'll likely only be able to associate with other criminals. Sounds like a recipe for increasing crime.

> Consequences are a deterrent.

Not really. If your options are "die" or "face potential consequences" you choose the latter every time.

I really doubt that "I don't want to go to prison" is why most people don't commit crime. They don't commit crime because... crime sucks, it's not fun, and it's not really necessary for most people. The people who do crime aren't like "haha they won't prosecute me, sweet, finally I can go commit crimes". They're desperate.

This seems so obvious.

> This is intangible.

Kind of a cop out. The reality is that people who go to prison have an extremely high rate of ending up back in prison, often for even worse crimes.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by BitwiseFool on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:31PM (#30676162)
>"They don't commit crime because... crime sucks, it's not fun, and it's not really necessary for most people."

This doesn't explain vandalism, joyriding, or kleptomania. Additionally, the notion that "it's not really necessary for most people" is true, but misleading. But have you considered that some people realize theft is an easier alternative to being gainfully employed? Why bother putting up with a boss and paying taxes when I can steal a single catalytic converter and make $2K under the table? That's like a month's worth of salary gained in 20 minutes.

>"The people who do crime aren't like "haha they won't prosecute me, sweet, finally I can go commit crimes". They're desperate."

I don't think you have ever met a criminal. Some are desperate, but why can't you recognize that crime is lucrative and a preferable alternative for these people? For lots of people, if they can get away with it, they'll do it. Their conscience doesn't bother them like it would for you and I.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joyride_(crime)

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:50PM (#30676476)
> This doesn't explain vandalism, joyriding, or kleptomania.

These are pretty minor crimes lol I'll be really happy if we get to a point where we have to worry about these things.

> But have you considered that some people realize theft is an easier alternative to being gainfully employed?

I mean, yes, I've considered it. I dismissed it because it's sort of idiotic. Is it better than working a job with no healthcare, benefits, a minimum wage, and the chance to be fired at any time with no safety nets? Sure, yeah. We should fix that.

> why can't you recognize that crime is lucrative and a preferable alternative for these people?

We both agree that crime is preferable for some people. We just disagree about why.

> Their conscience doesn't bother them like it would for you and I.

Years of living in an abusive society, learning that crime is a survival mechanism, etc, will naturally do that to anyone.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by BitwiseFool on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:02PM (#30676687)
>"These are pretty minor crimes lol I'll be really happy if we get to a point where we have to worry about these things."

"Pretty minor crimes, lol". I sense you live in a nice area and have lived a sheltered life. You may not have to worry about such things, but plenty of people are not so fortunate. Have you ever had your home broken into? Your family's car stolen and joyridden? I have, multiple times. It's easy to write these things off as minor concerns when it's not happening to you.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by staticassertion on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:36PM (#30677145)
I'm laughing because your points are so bad, to be clear, not at the crimes.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by BitwiseFool on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:50PM (#30677321)
Haha, I guess that makes me feel better.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by oh_sigh on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:53PM (#30678138)
An even harder time finding a job? Finding a job for Andre is impossible already, because he doesn't want a job.

Even though fencing shit is exactly the same as many retail jobs, except for the source of the goods

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by sydbarrett74 on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:22PM (#30676963)
If it's a one-time occurrence, the RoI is negligible or even negative. If it's a lifestyle for someone, then the RoI to society is significantly higher.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by kansface on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:33PM (#30677103)
Walgreens, drug stores, and grocery stores continue to exist in your city. People continue to open new businesses. People and their families remain in your downtown areas, etc etc.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by amatecha on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:53PM (#30675616)
right? I never understand this. the diapers are worth essentially ~nothing. the loss to society is nil. everyone is so hyper-focused on the momentary trivial material theft aspect and not realizing what society is actually losing is a person truly partaking in the rest of society in a productive or positive way.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:01PM (#30675729)
The person they describe in the article is providing nothing to society. Only taking handouts and not using those handouts to better themselves, but instead continuing their life of crime and theft. No amount of extra help will lead them down a better path other than a long term mental institution (which we dont have anymore). They have betrayed the good will of the public providing those programs and jail is the only thing that will stop them at this point from continuing to lead a life of crime and theft.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by amatecha on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:13PM (#30675893)
Receiving free housing doesn't obligate him into bettering himself. I know most people totally disagree with this, and people usually get angry when I say things like that. But I don't care. The government has far more than enough money to literally just give everyone a free apartment, or a basic income (and I already pay so much income tax, I am totally fine with some of it going to help support others who are struggling). Maybe if Andre's parents had received that 20 years ago it would have made a serious difference in his life. He's figured out how to survive on his own in the meantime, and spent the past 15-20 years living that way, so it's not going to be easy for him to change from that way of living. Throwing him in jail is not going to make that happen -- in fact he's more likely to end up with a far worse psychological outlook after spending time in jail for... stealing a pack of diapers?

Here's a very relevant paper on the issue, where the researcher concludes a number of suggestions, including "we need to consider ceasing to use prison as punishment" and "we should draw on the research of what we know works to prevent recidivism, especially literacy programs, skills training and GED, as well as educating prisoners to associate’s degree level in higher education and restore financial support for these successful practices": https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258834307_On_the_Ef...

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:20PM (#30676012)
So in what case in your mind is Andre responsible for his own actions here? It sounds like your solution is only to give him more and more handouts and expect a different result, when it doesn't sound like anything has worked for him in the past.

> spending time in jail for... stealing a pack of diapers?

That's disingenuous at best. These people steal hundreds of items and setup tables selling them. This isn't a mother stealing formula or diapers for her child. It's a criminal operation stealing stuff by the trash bag (as we have seen in many videos over the past few years) in cities with very loose theft laws (mostly on the west coast).

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by amatecha on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:24PM (#30676056)
My overall argument is, I don't know what to do about Andre right now, but throwing him in jail isn't going to help (I'd be willing to bet he's already spent time there actually). What will help reduce future "Andres" right now is ensuring people aren't living in a destitute situation and missing out on a decent education and generally partaking in society. That's like the absolutely fundamental first step to having a functioning society. You can't throw people by the wayside, but we (NA) do it in droves.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:29PM (#30676132)
We have been throwing money, education opportunities, food and everything else at the poverty problem since LBJ passed the great society act in the 60s. By all metrics, things have gotten way worse even with those programs. So throwing more resources at the problem isn't the answer IMO. It's parenting, a focus on education (not turning teachers into babysitters but actual focus on passing), keeping fathers in the household as a role model for their young sons, and a focus on a community relying on each other instead of being dependent on the government.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by BitwiseFool on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:09PM (#30675839)
>"what society is actually losing is a person truly partaking in the rest of society in a productive or positive way."

I must beg the question, if nothing is being done to address this person's asocial behavior, how on Earth will they become a productive and positive member of society? Many of these people have learned they can get more of what they want by breaking the law than by living within it.

People like me who are gainfully employed, pay taxes, and don't steal look at the lawlessness and genuinely start to wonder why we even bother upholding the social contract when there seems to be no interest in applying it anymore.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by toast0 on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:09PM (#30675827)
The diapers aren't worth much, but when theft drives retailers to reduce their hours or close their stores, that's a cost to society.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:24PM (#30676069)
Also they aren't stealing one pack of diapers. They are filling trash bags and walking out of the store because they know the loss prevention can't physically stop them and west coast cities have implemented policies that make it useless for police to arrest them (charges get dismissed by activist DAs).
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by sydbarrett74 on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:26PM (#30677025)
Diapers are worth essentially nothing? Tell that to anyone responsible for an infant.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by rlewkov on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:46PM (#30675525)
That's up to Andre. If he makes better choices in his life he may stop selling stuff on the street corner.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Fatnino on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:52PM (#30675600)
Go after the buyers. Word gets out that if you buy from Andre you get hassled by the law and Andre's money dries up.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tomschlick on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:54PM (#30676545)
Or confiscate Andre's stolen property and give it back to the retailer. In cases where that's not apparent who the retailer is, give it to shelters.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by humanwhosits on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:27PM (#30676104)
They could put a police officer right next to him on the street, that'll keep the customers away
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by immibis on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:48PM (#30677300)
Why does Andre make bad choices?
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by rlewkov on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:49PM (#30678078)
Because, as of yet, there has been little penalty for making bad choices
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by immibis on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:47PM (#30679532)
Really? That's it? Bad choices are made by default?

How did caveman society ever survive without a strong police force?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by themaninthedark on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @06:05PM (#30692475)
Before police there was mob justice, lynching and exile(often a death sentence)
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by mkoubaa on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:25PM (#30676076)
The only reliable technology humans invented that could cause a step change in someone's mentality is religion. But it's not a perfect technology and there isn't really a free market
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by tiahura on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:29PM (#30676129)
What used to happen was that he’d be sent to “the farm” for a few months to sober up and decide if he wanted to continue down the path he was on, or get his ** together. Alternatively, he’d get a bus ticket out of town.

This was highly effective until activists decided that present-day Market Street was something to aspire to.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by morelisp on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:57PM (#30675679)
Obviously, like OP said, he should be committing tax fraud ("gladly pay people under the table") instead of petty theft. That's a respectable crime.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by carabiner on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:39PM (#30675416)
He should be arrested and prosecuted for his crimes. This is how Houston took care of its homeless problem: more housing (thanks to liberal zoning laws) and strong prosecution for even minor crimes. This is hard to implement in other places because conservatives do not want to build more housing, while liberals do not want either of these things.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by klyrs on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:04PM (#30675764)
He should get UBI just like everybody else.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by EricE on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:43PM (#30676360)
"By definition, if you give someone a home, they are not homeless."

See, you start from the false assumption that all these people lack is a home. Even if you gave them a home 90% (or more) wouldn't be interested.

The problem of homelessness is far more complex and it's not just about money "going to the wrong people" (you mean people motivated to earn it?!?) or a lack of housing.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by j_walter on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:16PM (#30677678)
>The problem is the money is going to the wrong people.

I could not agree more. Not only is it going to the wrong people, it's going to the wrong organizations and government programs that have no real drive to reduce homelessness since that would be self-defeating. What they do is end up spending $60K/tent or $650K/unit on housing the homeless only to have rundown everything within a few years.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by immibis on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:32PM (#30677095)
Because a very large percentage of the population wants housing to be solved for the minimum number of people necessary, instead of for everyone.
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by katbyte on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:53PM (#30676539)
give people a free home, someone is now making money/profit off it with all the incentives that creates, and you need more than a home to live and thrive.

just give people money so they can decide what they need to be happy, as well pay regular businesses, restaurants, and landlords instead of the poverty industry.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by immibis on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:49PM (#30677306)
(landlords are part of the poverty industry FWIW)
Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Supermancho on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:01PM (#30675735)
> By definition, if you give someone a home, they are not homeless

That is incorrect. The definition of "home" is not uniformly defined nor equivalent to shelter. Often the homeless are given shelter (with or without restriction, usually the latter) and choose not to utilize it. They are still homeless.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Arubis on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:08PM (#30675816)
How, then, would you define "homeless"? And does it have a different meaning from "does not have a home"?

edit: Perhaps clarifying, are you using the term "homeless" to define a _state_ or a _trait_ of the person to whom you're applying it?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by Supermancho on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:31PM (#30677086)
> How, then, would you define "homeless"?

If someone has no secure[1] residence[2] that they rely on as their own.

[1] Secure is a relative term, uniquely attributed to individuals

[2] This is necessarily one legal residence, but practically may be a set of locations.

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by krnlpnc on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:06PM (#30675797)
>Andre said he has struggled with homelessness on and off since he was 14.

You overlooked this part.

> The problem is the money is going to the wrong people. There are a lot of good and honest people that are homeless and/or struggling to pay their rent. Andre isn't one of them. Andre gets his housing for free while other people freeze and are basically forced to kill themselves. Why is that?

Because American society judges a persons value based on their ability to "work."

Not everyone is capable of working a 9-5. Some people have physical illness, mental illness, disabilities or addictions.

The social and medical support structures in the united states are clearly not adequate, nor successful in helping the vast majority of these people.

Other first world countries don't have these problems. Why is that?

Re:Amazon moves employees out of downtown Seattle office due... by anaccountexists on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:16PM (#30675936)
If you have a permanent disability, there’s definitely government programs to support you indefinitely- I have several relatives on those programs (one for muscular dystrophy, one for autism) and they haven’t worked for a long time.

There’s more challenges around the short term disabilities, but pretty much every US state has a low-income / zero-income healthcare program that helps cover those individuals.

And as for overall homeless numbers, the US is pretty much middle of the pack per-capita with a lot of European countries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_homeless_...