Andre doesn't represent all homeless people; I'm aware of that. But I think he represents a much larger population than people would like to believe.
It's called "According to Need"
You might say that putting Andre in prison is worth it, because it would discourage him from stealing in the future. Looking at the research around the topic, the US Sentencing Commission found that there is no statistically significant deterrent effect from sentences under 5 years [2]. Other studies have found no deterrent effect from any length of sentencing [3]. So now we're looking at a minimum 5 year sentence for an uncertain positive effect.
If prison were a drug or a program that cost $3,400/mo and had to be taken for 5 years for an effect that may not even be real, we would call it a scam.
I'm not saying Andre is in the right. I'm saying the carceral way of dealing with poor people who commit petty crimes is expensive and ineffective (maybe even more so than giving someone a free apartment and letting him loiter on the street corner), and we need to consider a different way forward.
[1] https://www.doc.wa.gov/docs/publications/reports/200-AR001.p...
[2] https://www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/research-and-pu...
[3] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/003288551141522...
He and his ilk do much more damage to the city than that, when they're allowed to continue their criminal lifestyles.
Hassle them with repeated arrests and releases? When has this approach ever worked?
Put them in prison and make them an expensive, institutionalized ward of the state? I don't want that on my taxes.
I know you don't like this interviewee's attitude, but think about it for a second. This is a man who has spent most of his life flipping small-dollar goods outside on a street corner and being looked down on by many. This is not a life most people would envy. I don't condone petty theft, but I don't think Seattle would benefit from this person losing their housing or being prosecuted either.