News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by profmonocle on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:07PM (#21307539)
> desktop Linux and many Android devices only support level 1. In this case e.g. Netflix will not offer full HD or 4k resolutions

And yet 4K webrips of recent Netflix shows are readily available on torrent sites.

I don't understand who these higher levels of DRM are trying to target. They obviously don't stop the serious pirates from ripping and sharing the content with everyone. Yet the lower levels are "good enough" to stop average users from trivially downloading and keeping the file, like you might do with an plain, embedded MP4 file.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by turblety on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:22PM (#21307660)
DRM punishes paying customers and does nothing to stop piracy. It reminds me of those "you wouldn't kill" segments at the start of DVD's that you couldn't skip, but just moaned at you to not pirate the DVD. But the only people they were telling this to was paying customers who bought the DVD. People who pirated the DVD, just plugged it into their computer, ripped out the content then published.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by giancarlostoro on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:02PM (#21308208)
What makes matters worse is they inform the consumer that yes you can just steal the film. I was involved in the Private Server scene in my younger days and a game had a campaign against private servers. Ever since like 90% of the people in that private scene have told me they only knew about it cause of the campaign. You spark the human curiosity and screw yourself.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:00PM (#21308497)
It's the Streisand effect in action.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by ojilles on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:18AM (#21309995)
We really should remove all definition and references to the Streisand effect. Then everyone will know about it!
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by dredmorbius on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:47PM (#21314382)
Medieval moralists discovered that they could not express in too much detail proscribed sins for the obvious reasons.

The DRM industry has yet to learn this lesson. Thankfully.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by hombre_fatal on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:27PM (#21308647)
> DRM punishes paying customers and does nothing to stop piracy.

I would think DRM stops trivial tools like a Chrome extension that adds a "Download" button on anything you're watching on Netflix.com.

Which is good enough. Because piracy is confusing to most people. Piracy sites are scummy and require tech-savyness just to navigate them and download the right thing.

For example, my girlfriend knows "The Pirate Bay" by name though a torrent client is still confusing to her. First google result for that is https://thepiratebays3.com.

It has a scary and scummy banner at the top: "Official The Pirate Bay Warning. Do NOT download torrent files without hiding your IP! With a VPN you can Hide your IP & stay anonymous, avoid fines and lawsuits, especially in USA. <Link to NordVPN affiliate link>". And searching anything doesn't work for me.

So, I think the war against piracy is more or less won due to how relegated it is to a tiny part of the population that's capable of navigating it.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by kuon on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:57PM (#21308790)
I know some not very technical people that bought some HDMI network restreamer on ebay, it's basically an HDMI splitter with an ethernet port that will act as a (I think rtmp) server. I didn't check the technicals details, and he uses VLC on his desktop computer to record movies he wants to keep. He does it at night with TV luminosity and volume at near 0.

Of course you have to play the movie/serie in mirror on the TV, but he can record HD (not sure about 4k) movies of whatever plays on the TV. The cherry on top is that he bought 3 IR mirrors (well, it was just aluminum sheets) that he placed strategically to be able to control the IR stuff of the TV from his bedroom.

He was a but uneasy when he showed that to me, but I didn't mock him, I was genuinely fascinated by that setup. For someone who has near zero technical knowledge, this was very good.

I don't really have a point, I just thought of it when you mentioned your girlfriend fear of the pirate bay.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by P_I_Staker on Monday October 21, 2019 @01:35PM (#21314955)
It's not even really about stopping your friend, although I'm sure they'd like to do that too. They want to prevent there from being a zero effort "download button". That's the only advantage of DRM (same with DVD/digital delivery). Even the act of having to insert a DVD, or hit play and manually record is enough to stop people.

If they went entirely DRMless, you'd just be able to copy the content to a thumb drive, and share with friends. Instead, you have to mess around with other software (or in your friends case hardware), that does sometimes "breaks", or is otherwise inconvenient.

It's the same as DRMless games; people absolutely go crazy making copies (even back in floppy disk days). As much as the pirate community likes to pretend they're in it for moral reasons, some of the DRMless games by smaller developers became the most pirated games out there.

It is a very minor deterrent, for people that are too lazy. That's one area where streaming has prevailed over pirating. People can be extremely lazy, and having a convient streaming platform with decent content, is enough for some people not to bother.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Lammy on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:38PM (#21318793)
Get your friend an HDMI dummy plug and he should be able to turn off the TV. No affiliation with this particular item but just sorted Amazon by lowest price to find an example: https://www.amazon.com/Emulator-Headless-Display-3840x2160-G...
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by stiray on Monday October 21, 2019 @02:07AM (#21309701)
You are right to some extent. Which is good for the copyrighted works but it is also sad. People, with all this beautiful technology are uncapable to understand or use it. Everything today goes down to "simplify usage even if you remove some features as people wont be able to use it".

I still remember days when I was kid, smuggling c64 under car seat into Slovenia (former Yugoslavian republic). All the sofware was sold on flee markets by known pirats. No internet, no manual. But still we were more than capable to grasp software usage, learn to develop in basic, even asm (after getting some book from Austria, german and translated line by line with help of dictionary - I was 12).

It comes down that resourcefullness is coming from lack of something. But today everything is available and no one tries to be resourceful. Probably the decadent part of human evolution.

Anyway, piratebay is part of known torrent scene, but there is also less known part, at least to the public: https://wiki.installgentoo.com/index.php/Private_trackers#Wh...

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by wolco on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:44AM (#21309411)
You don't need a torrent client to watch movies on piratebay.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by oblio on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:02AM (#21309925)
You don't?
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by rinchik on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:42AM (#21312792)
latest uTorrent is just a webapp that streams torrents, there are also a bunch of others.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by sli on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:55AM (#21313703)
That's contributing to the death of torrent ecosystems in the same way as Popcorn Time: all leeching, zero seeding.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by rinchik on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:03PM (#21318968)
Yep. 100%. At the same time, torrent ecosystem is a lot larger than piracy and movies/TVshows and actively used to share big data among researches and individual "archivists".

r/datahoarder lives in torrent ecosystem (there are a lot more things there besides linux ISOs)

internet archive is also big with torrent files that have nothing to do with streaming.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by gsich on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:04AM (#21309938)
why not?
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by geofft on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:50PM (#21307858)
Sure, but why? Do the rightsholders believe that these mechanisms are effective at making them money somehow? How correct are they - are these mechanisms effective at stopping some amount of casual piracy and converting that into purchases?
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by jaimex2 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:00PM (#21307907)
It's pretty simple: They pay a hot shot company to try and stop piracy and thats the best they can come up with.

Piracy can't be stopped but thats not what they want to hear.

Piracy can be greatly reduced by distributing the content via Netflix but thats not what they want to hear.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:17PM (#21308583)
> Piracy can't be stopped but thats not what they want to hear.

It can be stopped. All they have to do is destroy the computing and internet freedom we all enjoy today. Can't do subversive things like copy a file if they don't let us run our software. Governments around the world are also trying to erode these same freedoms by pushing encryption regulation.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Freak_NL on Monday October 21, 2019 @02:50AM (#21309867)
It seems to me that the approach Netflix and Disney et al are taking is accomplishing just that.

DRM in the browser was step one. No Widevine, or whatever crapware is needed, no Netflix. Next came the limit on higher resolutions. You want Full HD? Stop using a free operating system. You want 4k? Get Internet Explorer, or better yet, get our app on one of the approved operating systems.

The next step is probably to diminish the browser experience even further until enough users have switched to the 'app'. The only reason is control.

It won't drive us away from a personal computer running whatever modern OS we want, but it is slowly creating a majority of people for whom computing exclusively means a managed device with a pre-approved operating system running vetted proprietary applications.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by hakfoo on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @01:14AM (#21320549)
I suspect it will just bifurcate the market eventually.

There was a brilliant moment where entertainment was all going to converge. You'd have your PC with terabytes of storage, stick a tuner card and an Ethernet cable in the back, run the sound out to your thousand-watt 20-channel amplifer, and display it all on your 70-inch flat screen. Broadcast TV, Netflix, Disney Plus, etc, would all just be desktop icons, right next to Steam and Excel. We were hurtling down that road in the mid-2000s (remember WinXP Media Centre Edition?) and suddenly it all jumped the track.

Seemed to happen pretty close to when Digital TV stumbled its way into the US market, or roughly the perfect time for it to really take hold (the classic "record a show on VHS" paradigm was suddenly killed off, and the ever-mutating subchannel lineups makes a smarter electronic program guide and recording functionality more appealing). I sort of blame the cable industry-- apparently it was virtually impossible to get a digital-cable-compatible tuner card for many years-- you had to buy from a narrow band of prebuilt PCs with the cards preinstalled, and even now the companies will scream blue murder over having to supply CableCards (if they even do anymore).

The PC is a do-anything device. Eventually, given the media industry's tastes, it will be the 'do anything except watch name-brand entertainment products' device. I don't think they can undermine general-purpose computing as a concept- there's too many other business cases that rely on being able to run random unsigned software or connect to arbitrary weird hardware.

Instead, Disney and Sony will push hard for various consumption-first or -only devices-- smart TVs, consoles, locked down phones/tablets. I'm sort of surprised they aren't already going for the subsidy model-- get a "free" PS5/Xbox 3&pi;/"smart" television if you'll sign up for years of a content subscription service to feed it.

People will end up having both and being annoyed that they can't converge things.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by shakna on Monday October 21, 2019 @01:04AM (#21309478)
> All they have to do is destroy the computing and internet freedom we all enjoy today.

That's one of those "good luck" scenarios. Building your own homebrew computer, or your own OS is a hobby for many. If you push the people behind them, and make a market for them, you'll make them popular.

The internet itself is complex, but not so complex that determined actors cannot build their own mesh networks.

And whilst governments are trying to erode encryption everywhere, it won't work in the end. They may be able to take secure encryption out of the hands of civilians, maybe. But they can't take it from the pirates.

And as for the incoming "no one would be that determined" argument, cracking chips to let consoles play pirated games have existed for a long time, and the average person did actually seek them out... And found them everywhere. If you make people build the infrastructure... They will.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by jaimex2 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:45PM (#21309198)
Even then, lets say the successfully broke all encryption and all communication - people would just go back to recording from a DVR and selling DVDs on the streets.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Supermancho on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:17PM (#21309075)
> It can be stopped.

In the context of visual/audio (re: the topic), no. Even disallowing encryption will not save companies from simple steganography.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by pmlnr on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:39AM (#21310074)
You haven't really seen the VHS age of pirating in Russia and Eastern Europe, have you?
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by viraptor on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:39AM (#21310302)
In my corner of EE that was caused by movies being crazy expensive relative to realistic income. Streaming and lower prices now definitely killed a lot of potential piracy.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by bilbo0s on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:06PM (#21307947)
>And yet 4K webrips of recent Netflix shows are readily available on torrent sites.

and:

>Piracy can be greatly reduced by distributing the content via Netflix

Aren't you guys saying different things? One is saying people already pirate on netflix, and the other is saying netflix removes the need for piracy.

If you're saying the same thing, I would interpret it to mean that piracy is greatly reduced on netflix, but not entirely eliminated. But if that be the case, would that not be evidence of netflix' anti-piracy measures working?

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Spivak on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:27PM (#21308050)
Statement 1: Piracy is inevitable in all platforms and at scale every media property will be pirated by someone.

Statement 2: If your content is available on a reasonably priced and performant streaming platform or is otherwise “low friction” the number of people who will choose to consume the pirated content instead of paying drops off dramatically.

The problem for publishers is that there’s so many different knobs that finding what brings in the most revenue is pretty much a crapshoot.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by jaimex2 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:46PM (#21309201)
Exactly what I was trying to get at, thanks.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Erudite_Genius on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:37PM (#21308108)
Content piracy has long been about the exorbitant cost of acquiring content.

If you look at the cost of downloading a full, original quality Blu-Ray rip, then burning that to a dual-layer BD-R disc, you're looking at an hour to torrent plus up to $10 for a dual-layer recordable disc. Compare that to a store-bought copy that's $7.88 and comes with both Blu-Ray and DVD copies, and it's no contest.

Make that store-bought copy $49.95 (thanks, Marvel) and it makes piracy attractive. Add terrible DRM on top and you GUARANTEE piracy, because you're being hostile to people that have actually bought your movie.

If DRM had never been invented, piracy would only be about 5% worse, and your paying customers wouldn't be cursing your existence... but the media companies are too stupid to realize that.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by pferde on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:05AM (#21309942)
> If DRM had never been invented, piracy would only be about 5% worse, and your paying customers wouldn't be cursing your existence... but the media companies are too stupid to realize that.

The media companies do not care whether their paying customers love them or hate them. What they do care about, though, is when there is 5% less of them.

Remember, big corporations do not just want money - they want all the money (and more).

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:31PM (#21308670)
Removing the reasons to infringe copyright is completely different from making it impossible to infringe someone's copyright.

Netflix is a convenient enough service that makes it easy for people to watch what they want to watch. Most people will just pay for it without thinking twice. It's easy enough that most people won't even consider infringing. Netflix's value isn't just in the content it serves, it's also in the fact it frees people from the non-trivial effort required to "pirate". Private torrent trackers have an economy of their own.

Making it impossible to infringe is extremely difficult. Movies and music are really just information. Extremely big numbers. It's trivial to make copies of this stuff and send those copies over the network. In previous centuries, you needed to be a major industry player and own big machines like printing presses in order to infringe on someone's copyright at scale. In the 21st century it's as easy as copy paste or forgetting to close the torrent client. People might not even realize they are doing it.

This is why a fragmented streaming market will push people towards copyright infringement. Instead of pooling their intellectual property and creating one single perfect streaming service with all the content, they are making it difficult and expensive for the consumer by competing with each other. At some point, people are going to wonder if there's a better way. That's when they'll find "piracy".

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by gbear605 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:18PM (#21308012)
My interpretation of the quotes is that if a show is on Netflix, its pirating rates go down drastically, but some shows on Netflix are still pirated. That’s because there is a significant population who pirates only when it is easier than streaming, and Netflix makes streaming really painless, in comparison with other streaming sites like Hulu or CBS All Access. However, some people still won’t pay for Netflix (or for any other streaming service), and they’re the ones that the first quote is talking about.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by marcosdumay on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:16PM (#21308581)
> But if that be the case, would that not be evidence of netflix' anti-piracy measures working?

No. It's evidence that just having the content available on Netflix will reduce piracy. It is a bit less effective than it could be because Netflix doesn't run on literally everything, mostly because of anti-piracy protections, but it does run on nearly everything, so it's effective.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by diamondlovesyou on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:16PM (#21308000)
Those two sides aren't mutually exclusive. Demand for content creates both.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by catalogia on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:20PM (#21308022)
DRM doesn't inconvenience pirates, but piracy inconveniences consumers.

It's inconvenient to free up 50 GB of hard disk space to torrent of a 4k netflix rip you found off some shady torrent site. It's much more convenient to just give netflix a few bucks a month. That inconvenience comes from law enforcement action against pirate sites and many users having trouble managing their hard drive space. Not from DRM.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by noodlesUK on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:28PM (#21308652)
It may be inconvenient to free up some disk space (citation needed, anyone on HN has probably got terabytes of free space somewhere), but the inconvenience of certain streaming platforms, or even the total hostility to watching anything ad-free (even paid users) will knock people into the piracy camp. There is no source where I can watch AAA movies that I buy on my laptop legally in 4K as it is illegal to break Blu-ray encryption (and I run Linux). I buy or rent movies I want to watch on my Apple TV in 4K, but what am I supposed to do if I want to watch something on a plane for instance?

Anything that is on Netflix I watch. I can’t watch amazon prime on my Apple TV because their region system is broken (yes, if an amazon employee is reading this, please fix having prime in multiple countries) so battlestar galactica and other shows in their catalogue aren’t available come from other sources.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by snagglegaggle on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:13AM (#21311317)
It's not illegal to break copy protection for a work you purchased. There was an ammendment to the DMCA for it -- likely if this had not happened more of the DMCA would have been challenged and struck.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by thejynxed on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:28PM (#21316930)
The caveat to that amendment being that you are only allowed to do so using tools you created yourself and you may not afterword share your tools, your methods, nor the decrypted material with anyone else.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by snagglegaggle on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:03PM (#21319692)
I don't see that in there anywhere. More like you can't transfer the material, even to another rights holder, but I still question that. They can't make the sharing of the tools and methods illegal as it'd be against the first amendment.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by catalogia on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:43PM (#21308714)
I'm talking about the typical consumer, not a HN user. Most people aren't running linux, have legal streaming options available to them, don't have terabytes available to them at any particular moment (maybe they have a few terabytes of portable harddrive in a closet somewhere, but not mounted and ready to roll.)

Are there scenarios where typical consumers turn to piracy? Sure, aboslutely. They generally do that when a convenient legal way isn't an option (e.g. region locks screwing them over.)

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by lowercased on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:40PM (#21308942)
> Most people aren't running linux, have legal streaming options available to them... Are there scenarios where typical consumers turn to piracy? Sure, aboslutely

my wife - a non-tech person, really - falls in to this camp. she's turned to torrenting things because the experience of streaming is just... slow. and bad. and stuttery. oh, and we still get ads on things (hulu, for one). She figured out how to find free streams for soccer matches - when we paid for "real" streams, they still had ads taking up 20% of the screen. And still somewhat jittery/stuttery (but - those 2 minute car ads at the start of the stream were never jittery).

yeah, the 'free' stuff experience isn't always great, but when the paid experiences are still kinda crappy, what's the point of paying?

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by noodlesUK on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:08PM (#21308832)
You’re probably right, but I know plenty of people who are happy to use putlocker etc who aren’t technically competent at all (and yeah, they sure get malware...)
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:45PM (#21308723)
"Piracy" is inconvenient. It takes knowledge, effort, time and money as well as computing power, storage and network bandwidth to participate in the ratio economies of private torrent trackers. It gets to the point it looks like an enthusiast operation run by people who want the best possible version of everything.

What's truly sad is how so many people find this preferable to paying for the official services. It speaks volumes to the quality of their streaming services. A huge number of people don't even have the choice to pay for the content to begin with: many of the of companies that complain about copyright infringement don't even offer their services outside of the United States. They ignore entire markets and complain when people find a way via unofficial means. It's really hard to feel any sympathy for the copyright industry.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by catalogia on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:55PM (#21308781)
There are some users, such as myself, who find the legal streaming sites intolerable for technical reasons if not ethical reasons. But I think the vast majority of users prefer the legal options when they're available, which is the part the media industry keeps on fucking up.

If they were better at their jobs, better at delivering to consumers what consumers want, they wouldn't have to worry about DRM, piracy, control of consumer behavior or any of this nonsense.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:42PM (#21308947)
Completely agree with you. If their services were good enough, I doubt they would even need copyright protection to make money. The fact they can't match the quality of a bunch of underground sites despite being a multi-billion dollar industry is a sign the industry is relying on artificial scarcity to have any chance of competing in the marketplace.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by realusername on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:59PM (#21309252)
> What's truly sad is how so many people find this preferable to paying for the official services. It speaks volumes to the quality of their streaming services.

I was even pirating shows I had access for free on Amazon prime... that just tells you how bad the platforms are, it's not about money.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by geofft on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:26PM (#21308048)
It's been decades and literally everyone in multiple industries is still refusing to admit they're throwing money after a lost cause? I won't say that's impossible, but the entire idea behind capitalism is that this happens rarely. Eventually someone will realize they can make more profit by not paying for anti-piracy, right?
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by neltnerb on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:06PM (#21308226)
They cannot possibly actually think DRM stops anything. Maybe they don't get that it's convenience that drives sales rather than the content itself.

I just rented Spiderman on Amazon streaming for like $6, about the same as I remember video rental used to be. I'm certain I could have pirated it if Amazon streaming had not worked on Linux. It was slightly easier and slightly more ethical feeling to rent it from Amazon, so I did.

I have seen a bit of a pattern where content distributors start out by cranking the DRM to 11 and then year over year get less and less worried about it. I guess they realize over time that the DRM isn't stopping anything, who knows, maybe they're using it to provide a PR argument that they're trying their best to push some other agenda.

But I think they know that it's the distribution method rather than the encryption that influences buying decisions unless they magically stop all casual piracy. Be at least as easy as casual piracy?

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by tjalfi on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:47PM (#21308432)
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Freak_NL on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:03AM (#21309937)
Baen Books is one publisher who gets it, and makes a profit doing so.

Some of their back-catalogue is available for free on-line, such as David Weber's Empire from the Ashes. Complete trilogy:

http://www.baencd.freedoors.org/Books/Empire%20From%20the%20...

(hard sci-fi)

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by mdpopescu on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:50AM (#21310120)
When companies are inefficient for a long time, it's usually because they managed to prevent competition. In this case, they successfully managed to bully the whole world, using the US government, into adopting rules created by US companies. (The idea that a sovereign country - say India - is forced to police 1.5 billion people to make sure they don't use Mickey Mouse in ways that would upset a company in a foreign country is insane. We don't normally care if people in Nigeria cook their leftovers in ways that upset a famous Italian pizzeria.)

---

Every time you find a problem with capitalism, stop and look again: you will find state intervention in the market, which is the opposite of capitalism. (Free trade between the involved parties, without the intervention of others.)

In this case, the problem starts at the root: copyright is by definition a state intervention in the market. It cannot exist in a free market, because it mandates that someone prevents you from using your own resources as you see fit (namely, copying a DVD you own on a computer you own, using electricity you're paying for).

Kinsella's "Against Intellectual Property" is probably the best resource point out the contradiction between Imaginary Property and the free market.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by geofft on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:44PM (#21314348)
How do you prevent state intervention in a free market? What prevents the capital-possessing incumbents in a market from saying, "We need a government and an armed police force to enforce intellectual property laws"?
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by mdpopescu on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:49PM (#21314403)
Competition. You hire a different police force to protect your property.

Of course, if one entity has a monopoly over the legitimate use of force in an area, you're in trouble.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Nasrudith on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:16PM (#21317473)
That sounds a lot like warring oligarchical or dictatorial nation states with extra steps in practice.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by mdpopescu on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @05:31AM (#21321717)
If they manage to get monopolies over geographic areas then yes, you get exactly what we have today.

However, for a couple of years after 1990 we actually had quite a lot of security companies that were competing peacefully in the same areas (Romanian police being absolutely irrelevant at a local level, with the reorganization of the state that was taking place). Of course, once the state got re-established "properly" that was quickly ended.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by arvinsim on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:56PM (#21308174)
I think some companies are just looking for the appearance of fighting and succeeding against piracy.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by chillfox on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:52PM (#21308454)
The entire theory of capitalism is that everyone always acts rationally and in their own interest. In reality, humans are frequently irrational and acts against their own interests.

Basically the foundations upon which capitalism stands are cracked and have always been craked. Regulation is what usually fills out those cracks to prevent the entire thing from crumbling.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by barney54 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:23PM (#21308616)
This view misses much of what has happened in economics since 1980. https://reason.com/2019/10/20/the-third-lesson-of-economics/
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by dredmorbius on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:51PM (#21314419)
Reason (FEE / Atlas Group / Mont Pelerin Society / Koch Network) are feeding their own interest here and are hardly indifferent.

Or correct.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by alvah on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:26PM (#21308637)
The theory of capitalism is that the means of production are privately owned (as opposed to government owned). What you're talking about is part of economic theory, not the same as capitalism at all.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:09PM (#21308547)
They just refuse to license their intellectual property to streaming companies that haven't developed "adequate" protection against "piracy". It's all about making a billion dollar investment look less risky in the eyes of executives. I seriously doubt it's helping them make more money.

Any victory against copyright infringement will come from competing directly against it. The copyright holders are too busy competing with each other and fragmenting the market instead of building something that's actually equal to or better than "piracy". It's pretty sad how a bunch of "pirates" manage to provide a better product than corporations valued at tens of billions of dollars.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by yuushi on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:50PM (#21308754)
I remember this being in the context of video games, and from some time ago (so things may have changed with Steam sales and the like), but it said that something like 85% of sales occur in the first two weeks. Thus the DRM was there to (hopefully) hold out for as much of that initial time as possible.

Anyway, anecdotal story, take with (many) grains of salt.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by sushid on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:24PM (#21308310)
It could also be an attempt to sway the public and their views on piracy.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Silhouette on Monday October 21, 2019 @02:03AM (#21309688)
How correct are they - are these mechanisms effective at stopping some amount of casual piracy and converting that into purchases?

Yes. Contrary to popular opinion among the geek crowd who tend to be very hostile to DRM, the people using it are not in fact completely ignorant and stupid. I write this as someone who used to believe similar things myself in my younger days, but who has now seen both sides of the coin and has moderated some of those views in light of that experience.

One thing that a lot of people don't seem to realise is that piracy often isn't about the price, but rather the convenience. If it's easier to find a ripped copy of something online, for example because it's not available in a certain region from legal sources, then people who want that content will go looking and they'll find the illegal sources. If it is available from legal sources, then to some extent DRM doesn't have to stop someone from being able to find a pirate copy, it just has to make it more inconvenient than finding a legitimate one. Given that any pirate content found online comes with a certain degree of risk, from malicious payloads pretending to be something else, poor quality or incomplete content that frustrates the person who gets it, and in some cases from honey traps that can result in legal action, this isn't entirely unrealistic.

One specific but very important instance of this, briefly mentioned already elsewhere in this discussion, is that if DRM can delay the widespread availability of some popular new work via pirate channels for a few weeks or even just a few days, that can make a huge difference to profitability. There have been AAA games where the DRM has been cracked but not for several months, and that might have saved the developers and legitimate distributors many millions of dollars.

At the other end of the spectrum, there is lots of content that is going to be many orders of magnitude less profitable even with a good run, simply because it's aimed at relatively small markets: niche music genres, software for running some specific type of shop or leisure facility, a documentary programme about an obscure interest, and so on. There is much less desire from the kinds of people who would be able to crack substantial DRM schemes to spend time on these things, so even simple measures can be quite effective in preventing that content from being trivially findable online, thus preserving the limited market for these kinds of products.

And finally, there is the simple but still relevant issue that some people genuinely don't realise piracy isn't legal or that what they're doing is piracy. "If it's on the Internet, it's free, right?" Even the most basic DRM schemes mean people probably have to do something that is clearly not the intended way of getting hold of the content, and that itself can be a useful deterrent for the "unwillfully ignorant" crowd.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by ehsankia on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:02PM (#21308810)
> DRM punishes paying customers and does nothing to stop piracy.

That's not necessarily true. I agree with the DVD example, but for example, I've almost never had any issues with Netflix's DRM. I can even pre-load videos on phone/tablet, and for the most part it works as expected. Same thing with Steam, it's fairly transparent to the user.

Yes there are bad DRMs out there, but there can be a balance when done right where it doesn't hurt the customer and provides more value than pirating (like Steam).

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by AlexDragusin on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:27PM (#21308332)
The info is there not to stop piracy but as a legal matter in case the customer says "I didn't knew, I wasn't informed".
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by omegabravo on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:45AM (#21310779)
I'm not sure the "you wouldn't download a car" is legally binding
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Izkata on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:13AM (#21311318)
That one was just confusing anyway, the general response was "if it existed, yeah I would".
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by throw0101a on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:54AM (#21311181)
> It reminds me of those "you wouldn't kill" segments at the start of DVD's that you couldn't skip ...

Obligatory IT Crowd reference:

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALZZx1xmAzg

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by unlinked_dll on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:01PM (#21307915)
>DRM punishes paying customers and does nothing to stop piracy.

Media companies aren't stupid. They know exactly how much DRM and piracy impact their bottom line. That's why DRM-free distribution is a non-starter for virtually every media company, because it saves them money.

Like all things dealing with bad actors, DRM isn't about stopping behavior. It's about slowing it down and making it more cumbersome

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by catalogia on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:07PM (#21307951)
They may not be stupid, but that doesn't mean they're totally rational either (that would be inhuman and I can assure you they're just as human as the rest of us.) Most of these media companies have never even tried no-DRM so a fully rational appraisal of the value of DRM simply isn't possible for them.

The music industry largely went no-DRM (and streaming) and they were totally unscathed. A good quality mp3 or flac file is what, tens of megabytes at most? Really easy to pirate. A good quality 4k rip is going to be tens of gigabytes. Pirating something that large is a hassle for me but inconceivable for some of my friends or family members. Pirating movies and TV shows has always been more niche than pirating music. And the formats easiest to pirate (720p, low bitrate, etc) are the formats being given the lightest DRM.

I wager there are some very human emotions involved in the decision making, namely pride and possessiveness. "We made this so we get to control it." The effectiveness of the DRM takes a backseat.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by jowsie on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:19PM (#21308595)
A good quality (for your average media consumer) 4k rip can be as low as 8gb. Sure it's not blu-ray quality but neither is Netflix, and no one cares. At least where I live, you're looking at 5-15 minutes to download a 4k rip on the average home connection. This is also completely ignoring pirate streaming sites, that while not as popular as they used to be, still exist and are lower friction than Netflix half the time.

I'd wager I know more people pirating films/tv than I do music.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by catalogia on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:48PM (#21308738)
Those pirate streaming sites are such a nightmare of ads and malware, I find it hard to believe many consumers prefer it to legal streaming. The reason somebody would use that is because they can't afford the legal streaming service, or legal streaming isn't an option at all. This has nothing to do with DRM.

And why do they use those shady pirate streaming sites, instead of pirate torrents of higher quality? It's because many of them struggle to find even 8GB of free space. I know some users who view deleting files to free up space to save new files as part of their daily routine. It doesn't need to be this way, but that's the way it currently seems to be.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by xzel on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:52PM (#21308457)
Early streaming services didn't own their own content but DRM is/was a requirement for most content contracts. I don't totally buy this argument and I think everyone knows its doesn't do much to stop piracy but its just a part of the process now.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by SifJar on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:48AM (#21310334)
> That's why DRM-free distribution is a non-starter for virtually every media company, because it saves them money.

Why is it saving them money a bad thing?

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by everyone on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:05PM (#21307941)
"Media companies aren't stupid. They know exactly how much DRM and piracy impact their bottom line."

Citation needed.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by lifthrasiir on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:07PM (#21307952)
> DRM punishes paying customers and does nothing to stop piracy.

There is a plot twist here: DRM does help stopping piracy, but only for smaller businesses producing the contents that appeals enough to be copied but not enough to be paid for. I'm pretty fine with Steam DRM for that reason, without that indie games will have much harder time. For Disney+, I cannot understand their reasoning at all.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by hannasanarion on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:14PM (#21307987)
Most games on Steam don't have DRM. Valve's DRM product is called Custom Executable Generation (CEG) and it costs extra for developers to add to their games. Most steam games work fine even if you uninstall Steam and have no internet.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by lifthrasiir on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:37PM (#21308101)
How exactly many games do (EDIT: typo) have DRM? AFAIK the answer is "many enough", I'm unable to give a concrete number but I do recall many games in my library that doesn't appear in a list of DRM-free games. I don't agree to your premise.

(To be clear, I do think DRM---so-called---is very bad in general. I accept DRMs for indie games only because DRMs have been already existed for games.)

[1] https://steam.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_DRM-free_games

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by earenndil on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:37PM (#21308387)
That list is community-maintained and almost certainly contains many omissions.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by nikanj on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:20PM (#21307648)
Device manufacturers. Play nice, or we won't grant you the magic pixie dust to play our content in glorious 4k.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by tshaddox on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:37PM (#21307774)
To clarify, this isn’t just a cynical comment. It’s actually why digital content producers use DRM. Generally speaking, they’re not idiots, they know it will have little effect on determined pirates and will cause some hassle for some legitimate customers. The point really is so that the digital content producers can maintain control over the providers of computer hardware and distribution channels.

Here’s an old article claiming to be a big revelation, but it’s pretty much common sense and has been fairly well recognized for much longer than that:

https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-engineer-drm-has-nothin...

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by sideeffffect on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:31PM (#21308351)
Ian Hickson's insightful short essay about DRM was on Google+. But now it's gone...

Not entirely, actually, thanks to the Internet Archive!!!

https://web.archive.org/web/20190119000840/https://plus.goog...

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by narrator on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:12PM (#21307978)
So the purpose of DRM is to thwart the first sale doctrine?
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by c256 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:19PM (#21308597)
It is absolutely one prime motivation. “The purpose” is essentially non-verifiable.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by catalogia on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:45PM (#21308141)
Reading that article, it seems to me that the arguments don't fit the conclusions. Media companies may be strong-arming software and device manufacturers, but they're doing so as a means to an end, not an end unto itself. Their motive for strong arming software and hardware manufacturers is their desire to control consumer behavior. That may be slightly more general than "piracy" specifically, but not that different.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by baddox on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:08PM (#21308237)
Sure, of course they ideally want end to end control. The point, though, is that the argument “pirates will still be able to pirate and legitimate users will be inconvenienced,” while true, is not a great argument for why content producers should stop using DRM, because DRM still works quite well for establishing control over hardware and distribution providers.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Igelau on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:37PM (#21308098)
I'm not a lawyer, but if we look at the DMCA,

17 USC §1201 (A)(1)(a): "No person shall circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title."

No one is interested in perfect because the actual DRM is only a tiny sliver of the protection. The bulk of it is the threat of having to pay a huge settlement because you don't want to get the piss beaten out of you in court.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by gruez on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:51PM (#21308159)
>No one is interested in perfect because the actual DRM is only a tiny sliver of the protection. The bulk of it is the threat of having to pay a huge settlement because you don't want to get the piss beaten out of you in court.

I don't find that argument convincing. I can't think of any famous cases of copyright holders or law enforcement going after rippers/encoders (the people who break the DRM and make it available for others to copy), but plenty of cases of them going after people who downloaded the content.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by giancarlostoro on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:05PM (#21308222)
And worse... You could have crappy DRM and if someone circumvents it. Its cheaper to produce and you can still prosecute the rippers.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by P_I_Staker on Monday October 21, 2019 @01:52PM (#21315159)
That doesn't explain the cat an mouse game. DRM schemes are constantly updated to fix issues so that previous hacks no longer work. Occasionally, the industry invests big money into sweeping changes.

If what you're saying is true, you'd expect the minimum reasonable measures to suffice. No need to invest in new methods. Yet they do. I'm sure lots of people would be interested in "perfect", if you had that product to give them; you could be a millionaire, the problem is that it's impossible, as far as we know.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by noonespecial on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:12PM (#21307977)
When a bad outcome is assured (piracy from their perspective) the only rational course of action is that which will prevent the blame from falling on you:

"Yes it was pirated, but we spent maximum cash on the very best DRM... what else could we have done?"

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by foota on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:37PM (#21307781)
I imagine you'd see a lot more casual piracy if it were trivial to copy, i.e., people just sending the videos to their friends.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Sendotsh on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:17PM (#21308005)
For every person torrenting there’s multiple getting movies off friends on USB sticks and stuff.

One member of my family does the torrenting for a dozen others in my family, and I know plenty of others that work like that.

I personally do a mix of paying for content and pirating. I’m 100% happy to pay for content if I can, but with geoblocking and platform restrictions and all the other bullshittery, it’s legitimately impossible for me to legally buy half (or more) of the content I’m actually interested in, so I pirate it, and I don’t feel bad for doing so in the slightest.

I also regularly have to pirate things I already own thanks to DRM that doesn’t work on my devices, missing subtitles, etc.

The entire industry is broken and it’s their own fault.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by giancarlostoro on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:07PM (#21308231)
Not sure if applicable to your region but have you given movieseverywhere a shot?
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Sendotsh on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:57PM (#21308482)
Do you mean Disney Movies Anywhere? That’s a US exclusive, like just about all content these days.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by giancarlostoro on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:03AM (#21311240)
https://moviesanywhere.com/

This website, it's not Disney specific, but that sucks. It would mostly be the convenient solution to this problem. If you have a movie on iTunes or Play, it unlocks in the other, and vice-versa.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Freak_NL on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:18AM (#21309993)
Mostly so.

With some interesting exceptions, luckily. You can watch Star Trek: Discovery on Netflix in 32 countries, including most of Europe, but not in the US (there it's an exclusive on CBS or something like that).

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by AlfeG on Monday October 21, 2019 @01:19AM (#21309522)
Pirating is already casual. But situation is much worse.

I can have russian voiceover from 4-5 studios on the next day after popular TV series aired. They even go this far, as to put full time commercials of not so legal online casino web sites. I dont even need to torrent, to watch any tv show next day after air. There is android apps that will allow to watch any show via http or torrent. There is pirate websites with payed and free access. And as I said earlier fulltime commercials of online casinos, that sponsor pirate translations.

This situation is very bad for any commercial tv show services in ex USSR territory. No low regional prices can battle 0 price.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:15PM (#21308266)
The argument above was that the lowest level of Widevine is sufficient to prevent casual piracy (through that channel), and I agree: It's a lot easier to just torrent a clean version than to dump an encrypted Netflix stream, run some side-channel attack on Widevine (for which the PoC code doesn't seem to be public), then decrypt the dump.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by dwild on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:07AM (#21312392)
> I imagine you'd see a lot more casual piracy if it were trivial to copy, i.e., people just sending the videos to their friends.

Then just put enough of DRM for that not to happens. The fact that it's working through an app is more than enough. Most people have trouble even getting videos out of Youtube and doesn't know you can find apps to do that.

People share password much more than they share video files too.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by s3cur3 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:40PM (#21308397)
My experience with small content producers is that their decisions surrounding stopping piracy have almost nothing to do with the economics of it; it’s an emotional decision. I’ve seen people spend 25%+ of their content’s revenue on DRM.

Now, why the major players also pour money into this stuff is just baffling.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by aaron695 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:23PM (#21308036)
> And yet 4K webrips of recent Netflix shows are readily available on torrent sites.

WEBRIP (capture) are worse quality than WEB/WEB-DL (hacked DRM)

So actually you prove their point, they are winning.

The scene can do some WEB, they keep it secret, they even have servers for crew member to use without telling them how.

WEB is probably using old TV software with weaker DRM, hence why 4k is rare.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by deogeo on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:52PM (#21308978)
> I don't understand who these higher levels of DRM are trying to target.

They target device manufacturers. If you want to sell a computer/tablet/phone/TV that will play Disney+/Netflix/etc, then you must submit to their demands, pay their licensing fees, and hope you don't anger them. They want to be the gatekeepers to who can make a commercially-viable product.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by vbezhenar on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:49PM (#21307852)
How those webrips are performed? Are there leaked DRM keys or something like that? I thought that DRM encrypts stream all the way from website to display, so it's quite hard to intercept it.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by bscphil on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:37PM (#21308388)
Pirates cracked Widevine (and possibly other schemes). They have a drop-in replacement DLL (which they keep secret) that dumps the original content of the stream (not a screen / HDMI capture, like the other two comments said). This is called a WEB-DL, while capturing and encoding the stream is usually called a WEBrip.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by tbodt on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:00PM (#21308500)
This doesn't work for Widevine L1, as L1 is handled in hardware. Windows has some interface to the Intel Management Engine used for this, Android OEMs write drivers and ship devices with keys, other platforms are out of luck.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by mrb on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:03AM (#21309932)
Widevine L1 has been cracked. Pirates gain code execution in the ARM TrustZone¹ and peek into the decryption keys of the widevine module. That's how 4k WEB-DL Netflix content gets pirated.

¹ For example: http://bits-please.blogspot.com/2016/04/exploring-qualcomms-...

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by bscphil on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:25PM (#21308629)
That's correct. Anything actually protected by Widevine L1 (meaning no workaround to get L3 instead) would require a different approach than just cracking the library.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by baybal2 on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:25AM (#21310022)
If 4k netflix is what protected by their best hardware DRM, then... somebody managed to either exfiltrate the key, or drill the chip and get it extracted physically.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by ikeboy on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:04PM (#21308215)
It's not clear. The tools are kept secret to avoid patching. But presumably they reverse engineered it and have a way to capture the raw stream.

I know at one point they were using Roku TVs or Fire TVs which allowed an older DRM standard. Now apparently there's a crack for Windows that's kept underground in the scene groups doing releases.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by swebs on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:03PM (#21307924)
HDCP has had its master key leaked in 2010. You can also buy hardware over the internet that bypasses HDCP.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by gruez on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:56PM (#21308181)
Basically this. HDCP 2.2 is "secure", but the previous versions aren't. A company signed the HDCP agreement and got the decryption keys, and made a device that could downgrade HDCP. Apparently this was allowed by the HDCP licensing agreement so it's all legal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-bandwidth_Digital_Content...

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by aaronax on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:24PM (#21308624)
Ok but that will be lower quality. The original compressed file will be decoded and sent to the monitor at full resolution and frame rate, and then the pirates will be able to capture that. Then the pirates will need to encode/compress that for distribution. This new file will be lower quality, I believe.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by huffmsa on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:13PM (#21307982)
If you have a good internet connection and graphics card you can just capture the screen and intercept the audio separately. It's got a few artifacts here and there, but nothing that makes it unwatchable
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by unfocused on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:48PM (#21309208)
No key involved, but a long time ago, circa 2008, I used to record my TV shows in my Rogers (Canada) PVR. It so happened it had a firewire port, and all you had to do was load the firewire SDK on your macbook, and when you play back your show on the PVR, you could capture the raw .ts (transport stream) which contained the MPEG2 video.

I think that's why most players now have no extra ports besides the HDMI as it was easy to bypass the HDMI protection...if you can call it that.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by aidenn0 on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:26AM (#21309345)
Aside from this comment[1], DRM prevents casual piracy. There was a point where a lot of my music was cassette tapes with the album written on it with a sharpie. DRM definitely prevents this.

HDCP up to 2.2 is completely broken, so even perfect software DRM has a huge gaping hardware hole, but most people don't have the tools needed to circumvent this.

One person breaking the DRM can make a torrent for all torrenters, but if say 1/4 the population can break the DRM, then people will copy things for friends.

The closest current day equivalent is probably many people sharing a Netflix password.

1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21307648

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by vkaku on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:34PM (#21307755)
This ^

DRM is only to create the illusion of security, to deter the average person, not the determined pirate or developer. Once you've sent the content to the client, you've lost all practical ways to avoid these torrents.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by LaundroMat on Monday October 21, 2019 @01:40AM (#21309589)
It's all about (pretending to be) protecting intellectual property. After all, a large part of media companies' assets are intangible IP. To make sure the value of that asset is not eroded, companies such as Disney must invest in technologies that claim help protect it.

(Edit: to be more precise, they must invest in tech that maximizes the extraction of (future) value from that IP).

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by paulddraper on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:29PM (#21308913)
> many Android devices only support level 1

Isn't Android the biggest OS on the planet by # of users?

Wouldn't the impact be huge?

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Nasrudith on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:01PM (#21317307)
They aren't for the consumer or even product security despite what they say. They certainly pay enough to afford people to tell them the truth - instead they pay extra to get ones who tell them what they want to hear.

As far as I can tell they are a very expensive security blanket for those too tech illiterate to realize that trying to circumvent the analog hole for serial formats is barking madness or as an ass-cover.

It brings to mind the use of polygraphs as similar outright instituional superstitions whose true function is blame deflection.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by untog on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:11PM (#21308561)
They're available on torrent sites, but how are you going to watch that video on your Roku, Apple TV, smart TV or whatever? The key here is hardware control. The big players have it.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by jowsie on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:23PM (#21308614)
Plex and similar software are pretty popular. Not to mention most phones can 'cast' to all those devices. Both my smart tv's even have USB ports.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by untog on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:25PM (#21308630)
It's kind of funny the number of people responding with Plex. I've used it for years, and it's an effective piece of software but it requires running a server in your house, managing storage, etc. etc... there's no way the average user is interested in doing that.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by joecot on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:52PM (#21308765)
> it requires running a server in your house, managing storage, etc. etc... there's no way the average user is interested in doing that

Which is why my family, my girlfriend's family, and all our friends just use my Plex server

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by tbyehl on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:06PM (#21309026)
Plex is just an application. My start, back when it was still Mac-only, was to run it on my Macbook Pro. When the drive got full, I deleted content that I'd already watched.

For a decade now, Plex runs on any Windows / Mac / Linux device. It'll run on a Raspberry Pi. NVIDIA Shield. Western Digital's My Cloud NAS products (from $139 w/ 2TB). QNAP. Synology.

The main obstacle for "average" people is just knowing that Plex exists.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by untog on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:47AM (#21311632)
It isn’t just an application, it’s an application that runs on your always-on computer. Which most people don’t have. Nor do they have a Raspberry Pi, QNAP or Synology NAS.

Knowing that Plex exists is certainly one thing. But you still need to run it somewhere.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by tbyehl on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:41AM (#21312788)
What's the argument here, that average people are too dumb to know that their computer needs to be on to access something running on it? That they're too dumb and poor to find and buy another device to run their Plex server if they don't want to use their PC?

I think you underestimate people a bit too much.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by untog on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:37AM (#21313486)
"Too dumb" feels overly emotive. But yes, I'm saying there is a significant gulf between the average user's current setup (a Roku, Apple TV, whatever) and a server that costs several hundred dollars (if you want anything approaching plug and play) and has to be on all the time, both financial and tech knowledge wise. It's not that users are "too dumb" to do it, it's that it is an inconvenience people are more than willing to pay to avoid.

"You use your remote to choose the show you want to watch, and you watch it" is worth $10-15 a month to people when it's compared to "You buy a server, plug it in and leave it on all the time, maybe be responsible for software updates on a regular basis, and also set up some kind of torrenting system to request the shows you want in advance".

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by tbyehl on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @11:39PM (#21330841)
My experience around average income non-tech-enthusiast parents is they have a binder stuffed with $2 pirated DVDs and a USB drive full of stuff they've torrented / exchanged with friends.

Running Plex with whatever computer they've got isn't a stretch.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by 29083011397778 on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:02PM (#21315961)
A Plex server will reach out even if you don't open the port it wants. It doesn't require you manage storage, just have a bit of space on a HDD. Same with a server; it needs a desktop, which only needs to be on when you want to watch something.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by jsjohnst on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:23PM (#21308618)
> how are you going to watch that video on your Roku, Apple TV, smart TV or whatever?

Plex ;)

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by TrueDuality on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:22PM (#21308612)
Plex.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by lousken on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:16PM (#21307604)
Obviously, the point is to screw up the customers - every DRM can and will be broken at some point
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by beerandt on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:10PM (#21313931)
I think at this point it's just an excuse for sub-par distribution networks. Or an excuse for poor playback compatibly. Or maybe even a way to save on bandwidth.

It gets them out of any contractual or common law minimum level-of-service complaints.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by stevetodd on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:20PM (#21308018)
It’s designed to reinforce the idea that piracy is morally wrong.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by gok on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:53PM (#21308167)
It gives content producers leverage with device manufacturers.