News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by hombre_fatal on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:27PM (#21308647)
> DRM punishes paying customers and does nothing to stop piracy.

I would think DRM stops trivial tools like a Chrome extension that adds a "Download" button on anything you're watching on Netflix.com.

Which is good enough. Because piracy is confusing to most people. Piracy sites are scummy and require tech-savyness just to navigate them and download the right thing.

For example, my girlfriend knows "The Pirate Bay" by name though a torrent client is still confusing to her. First google result for that is https://thepiratebays3.com.

It has a scary and scummy banner at the top: "Official The Pirate Bay Warning. Do NOT download torrent files without hiding your IP! With a VPN you can Hide your IP & stay anonymous, avoid fines and lawsuits, especially in USA. <Link to NordVPN affiliate link>". And searching anything doesn't work for me.

So, I think the war against piracy is more or less won due to how relegated it is to a tiny part of the population that's capable of navigating it.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by kuon on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:57PM (#21308790)
I know some not very technical people that bought some HDMI network restreamer on ebay, it's basically an HDMI splitter with an ethernet port that will act as a (I think rtmp) server. I didn't check the technicals details, and he uses VLC on his desktop computer to record movies he wants to keep. He does it at night with TV luminosity and volume at near 0.

Of course you have to play the movie/serie in mirror on the TV, but he can record HD (not sure about 4k) movies of whatever plays on the TV. The cherry on top is that he bought 3 IR mirrors (well, it was just aluminum sheets) that he placed strategically to be able to control the IR stuff of the TV from his bedroom.

He was a but uneasy when he showed that to me, but I didn't mock him, I was genuinely fascinated by that setup. For someone who has near zero technical knowledge, this was very good.

I don't really have a point, I just thought of it when you mentioned your girlfriend fear of the pirate bay.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by P_I_Staker on Monday October 21, 2019 @01:35PM (#21314955)
It's not even really about stopping your friend, although I'm sure they'd like to do that too. They want to prevent there from being a zero effort "download button". That's the only advantage of DRM (same with DVD/digital delivery). Even the act of having to insert a DVD, or hit play and manually record is enough to stop people.

If they went entirely DRMless, you'd just be able to copy the content to a thumb drive, and share with friends. Instead, you have to mess around with other software (or in your friends case hardware), that does sometimes "breaks", or is otherwise inconvenient.

It's the same as DRMless games; people absolutely go crazy making copies (even back in floppy disk days). As much as the pirate community likes to pretend they're in it for moral reasons, some of the DRMless games by smaller developers became the most pirated games out there.

It is a very minor deterrent, for people that are too lazy. That's one area where streaming has prevailed over pirating. People can be extremely lazy, and having a convient streaming platform with decent content, is enough for some people not to bother.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by Lammy on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:38PM (#21318793)
Get your friend an HDMI dummy plug and he should be able to turn off the TV. No affiliation with this particular item but just sorted Amazon by lowest price to find an example: https://www.amazon.com/Emulator-Headless-Display-3840x2160-G...
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by stiray on Monday October 21, 2019 @02:07AM (#21309701)
You are right to some extent. Which is good for the copyrighted works but it is also sad. People, with all this beautiful technology are uncapable to understand or use it. Everything today goes down to "simplify usage even if you remove some features as people wont be able to use it".

I still remember days when I was kid, smuggling c64 under car seat into Slovenia (former Yugoslavian republic). All the sofware was sold on flee markets by known pirats. No internet, no manual. But still we were more than capable to grasp software usage, learn to develop in basic, even asm (after getting some book from Austria, german and translated line by line with help of dictionary - I was 12).

It comes down that resourcefullness is coming from lack of something. But today everything is available and no one tries to be resourceful. Probably the decadent part of human evolution.

Anyway, piratebay is part of known torrent scene, but there is also less known part, at least to the public: https://wiki.installgentoo.com/index.php/Private_trackers#Wh...

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by wolco on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:44AM (#21309411)
You don't need a torrent client to watch movies on piratebay.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by oblio on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:02AM (#21309925)
You don't?
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by rinchik on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:42AM (#21312792)
latest uTorrent is just a webapp that streams torrents, there are also a bunch of others.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by sli on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:55AM (#21313703)
That's contributing to the death of torrent ecosystems in the same way as Popcorn Time: all leeching, zero seeding.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by rinchik on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:03PM (#21318968)
Yep. 100%. At the same time, torrent ecosystem is a lot larger than piracy and movies/TVshows and actively used to share big data among researches and individual "archivists".

r/datahoarder lives in torrent ecosystem (there are a lot more things there besides linux ISOs)

internet archive is also big with torrent files that have nothing to do with streaming.

Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM by gsich on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:04AM (#21309938)
why not?