Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM
by sideeffffect on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:31PM
(#21308351)
Ian Hickson's insightful short essay about DRM was on Google+. But now it's gone...
Not entirely, actually, thanks to the Internet Archive!!!
https://web.archive.org/web/20190119000840/https://plus.goog...
So the purpose of DRM is to thwart the first sale doctrine?
It is absolutely one prime motivation. “The purpose” is essentially non-verifiable.
Re:Disney+ streaming uses draconian DRM
by catalogia on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:45PM
(#21308141)
Reading that article, it seems to me that the arguments don't fit the conclusions. Media companies may be strong-arming software and device manufacturers, but they're doing so as a means to an end, not an end unto itself. Their motive for strong arming software and hardware manufacturers is their desire to control consumer behavior. That may be slightly more general than "piracy" specifically, but not that different.
Sure, of course they ideally want end to end control. The point, though, is that the argument “pirates will still be able to pirate and legitimate users will be inconvenienced,” while true, is not a great argument for why content producers should stop using DRM, because DRM still works quite well for establishing control over hardware and distribution providers.
Here’s an old article claiming to be a big revelation, but it’s pretty much common sense and has been fairly well recognized for much longer than that:
https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-engineer-drm-has-nothin...