News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by justin66 on Monday August 24, 2026 @08:02PM (#49427473)
> I guess if you don’t have a massive population of antisocial people who destroy the public facility, you can provide them. It’s a shame we in the west surrendered that.

What a weird way of stating the problem. There is too large a population of homeless, mentally ill, and drug addicts wandering the streets. We didn't surrender anything, at least not during the last half century in the United States. We did as little as possible to deal with homelessness and mental illness and discovered there's good money to be made incarcerating drug addicts.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by b0rtb0rt on Monday August 24, 2026 @08:45PM (#49427778)
in japan the homeless people clean up after themselves and don’t destroy everything

what’s the difference here?

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by annzabelle on Monday August 24, 2026 @11:51PM (#49428865)
Japan will lock people up for a long period of time if they show the sort of anti-social behavior that the most visible homeless people in North America are famous for.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by cortesoft on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:16AM (#49428997)
The US “locks people up” at a much higher rate, and for longer, than Japan does. About 1% of the adult population is in jail in the United States, and it’s about 0.03% of the population in Japan. The US puts people in jail at 30x the rate Japan does.

It is not because the US doesn’t lock people up enough.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by annzabelle on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:18AM (#49429018)
Japan has one of the highest numbers of psychiatric beds in the world. That's what I'm referring to. If you're experiencing psychosis in public in Japan, you will be removed from public spaces. This is not true in the US.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mikelitoris on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:43AM (#49429534)
Thank “One flew over cuckoos nest” for that.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by anon48293 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:47AM (#49429196)
Yes it is. It’s because they let them out again.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by cortesoft on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:20AM (#49435666)
That is 1% of adults being CURRENTLY locked up, not people who have ever been locked up in their life. That means the stat already factors in how long they are in for.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by OroPla on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:26AM (#49431077)
We are not talking jail, we are talking closed institution. The kind of hospital you check in but do not check out from, as many mental illnesses are incurable.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mx7zysuj4xew on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:32AM (#49432866)
Buddy, I can deprive you of several days of sleep, put you under severe emotional duress and have you experience a psychotic breakdown. Are you seriously saying you yourself should then be locked up for life?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by OroPla on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:12AM (#49434511)
Are you saying that someone experiencing a psychotic breakdown should not get psychiatric care?

Try to be charitable in your interpretation.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mx7zysuj4xew on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:21PM (#49443412)
Yeah my charitable interpretation is that it's all just a thin veneer over your main argument which is "kill the poor"
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by MarkusQ on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:28AM (#49434790)
many ≠ all; chronic ≠ acute
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Brian_K_White on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:07AM (#49428958)
The trains run on time sure enough.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mcny on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:23AM (#49429045)
I tried to find some information about how Japan manages to get away from criticisms around forced labor in prison. It seems like Japan does have very poorly paid labor, as little as usd 0.05 an hour, but the incarceration rate is low.

Once again, I don't know much about Japan but I doubt there is a large ethnic minority that is only about fifteen percent of the population but somehow accounts for almost half of all incarcerated people in Japan.

From Google:

> Low Incarceration Rates: Japan maintains one of the lowest incarceration rates in the developed world (roughly 35 to 40 prisoners per 100,000 residents, compared to over 500 per 100,000 in the US).

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by gfosco on Monday August 24, 2026 @11:41PM (#49428820)
They are Japanese.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by justin66 on Monday August 24, 2026 @09:30PM (#49428048)
My first thought is, I'm not certain their homeless are different in their behavior, but based on what little I know, I'm rather certain their non-homeless are. I'd expect disruption or damage to a public space of the kind that sparked this discussion to be dealt with swiftly as a high priority.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by TonyStr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:50AM (#49431697)
I don't know much about this, but when I visited Japan, I walked aimlessly in the outskirts of Tokyo (Sumida city) until I ended up in a homeless area. They had used old palettes and tarps to build square houses with functioning doors, and it was surprisingly clean. Their shoes were neatly lined up against the walls, they used trash bags and the ground was clean. It was quite a culture shock, because it was cleaner than non-homeless streets at home.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:56AM (#49436233)
You can't build that kind of shanty town in the US because the cops will come and steal all your shit. Otherwise it's exactly what homeless people in the US want to be able to do.

Often times, these "sweeps" just trash everything. Imagine if you were trying to put your life back together. You got an Obamaphone so you can call state assistance programs and email job prospects. You have some basic clothes, maybe some food, maybe some few possessions you have saved from your past life.

Then the cops come and take all of it and throw it away.

Gee, I wonder why it's so hard for people to escape homelessness in the US?

Imagine trying to live any life in a world that rejected your right to property?

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:22AM (#49429038)
How many of their homeless are addicted to drugs or nectary ill? It seems in the US almost all visible homeless fall into at least one of those groups.

Fentanyl and meth seems to be largely a North America issue. I previously was curious how other countries dealt with it. The only country I found that had previously had a meth issue was Estonia or Latvia (not sure anymore). It apparently was really bad for years. They fixed it by finding the single meth lab. Not a solution that's viable for us.

No idea what Japan does with its homeless but my money is that it's something like forced admission which isn't gonna fly in the US.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dspillett on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:40AM (#49430317)
> Fentanyl and meth seems to be largely a North America issue. I previously was curious how other countries dealt with it.

It isn't a particular drug: if it isn't Fentanyl or meth it will be something else, whatever is available. In the UK it is a mixed bag, but for many the problem substance is alcohol which isn't controllable the way other drugs are because of it being legal and so commonly used in a non (or at least less) problematic manner.

The problem hits from two directions: many homeless people start the path to addiction by needing an escape and that escape method spirals and takes control, and a lot (not the majority by any means, but a sizable segment) end up destitute because of spiralling substance problems to start with.

Of course many homeless do not have a substance problem, or at least not one that would be insurmountable on its own. Financial issues (that wouldn't go away if you strip the cost of the illicit substances out, accommodation is not cheap and suitable jobs are not readily available, etc) and mental illness (separating this from drug issues is complex: "self medication" is of course a major complicating matter) are probably far more common.

> curious how other countries dealt with it

Not well, for the most part. From an outsiders PoV (sat in my small but comfortable flat with the paid mortgage and no drug issues, though the mental health thing needs work) it doesn't seem to be a bad as it has been in the past (maybe in part due to efforts to make it less visible rather than fixing the issues?) but is growing again and I suspect will do so more rapidly if AI does what it promises to the job market.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:02AM (#49435391)
I was under the impression that the more recent type of meth leads to symptoms indistinguishabl from schizophrenia that last many month of abstinence. Source: https://www.econtalk.org/sam-quinones-on-meth-fentanyl-and-t...
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by laughing_man on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:31PM (#49442666)
Most Asian countries are pretty serious about keeping drugs out of their countries. In Japan's case it's a little easier since they're an island nation.

You can get a life sentence there for first offense import or manufacture of narcotics. Beyond that, your family will suffer socially.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by TurkishPoptart on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:23AM (#49429774)
[flagged]
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by tomhow on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:39AM (#49430312)
We've banned this account. We've asked you multiple times to observe the guidelines, and a comment like this, shitposting or whatever else you're trying to do here, is obviously a step too far. If you don't want to be banned, you can email us ([email protected]) to discuss ways of demonstrating your intention to participate earnestly in future.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by talon8635 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @10:46PM (#49473766)
That’s my exact point. Our culture in the west breeds isolation and antisocial chaos in a not insignificant percent of the population. Part of it os undoubtedly the vast differences between Japanese and American culture
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mvdtnz on Monday August 24, 2026 @08:49PM (#49427805)
We in the west have surrendered with weak punishments and lax enforcement for anti social behaviour. In many cases even abolishing laws or putting in place public policy that prevents the imprisonment of people who commit "low level" crimes. There's a certain segment of the population who will (largely unsuccessfully) try to shame you if you promote a tough on crime approach.

In my country the entire justice system has been hijacked by activist judges who are hell bent on promoting these whacky ideas and letting serious criminals go virtually unpunished.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by UncleOxidant on Monday August 24, 2026 @08:59PM (#49427871)
I'm just not sure that stronger punishment and enforcement is going to be the answer here. It seems like many of the Asian cultures have a much higher level of social cohesion even without the threat of punishment. How do we get (back) to higher social cohesion in the West? I recall seeing a film of a shanty town somewhere in the US during the Great Depression. It was very neat and tidy. What happened between then and now?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mvdtnz on Monday August 24, 2026 @09:51PM (#49428186)
Which Asian cultures are you speaking about which have high social cohesion without threat of punishment? Singapore will punish anti-social behaviour like vandalism with mandatory caning, or fine you heavily for jay walking. In Japan police will intervene much more readily in cases of public intoxication and even noise complaints.

For more serious anti social behaviour like gun crimes, violent crimes and drug trafficking there are very strong mandatory penalties up to and including corporal punishment and execution.

Conviction rates in these countries are upwards of 99%. So in cases of intervention a punishment is almost certain.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ipaddr on Monday August 24, 2026 @09:36PM (#49428092)
America has a low social cohension because of global immigration instead of targeted immigration compare to China. America use to share a culture because people came from the same places and shared the same religion and had a common history going back to the Romans.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dripdry45 on Monday August 24, 2026 @10:50PM (#49428540)
....sadly more true than anyone here would probably like to admit. I love having Indian coworkers and there’s a large Indian population where I am at, but they are just completely separated in every single way from everyone else. and they keep it that way.

my Pakistani coworkers are absolutely wonderful. Sweet, hard-working, very enjoyable to talk to, but their families and lives are just a totally different universe and they don’t share it.

The honestly very poor black community around the area? they fucking hate us white people. like actively, all the time, no what no matter what you have or haven’t done they don’t like your ass one bit. i’ve seen inside some of the homes, and they are filled with independent black power movie posters about shooting Whitey. No kidding.

I know it takes a village, but when people are so very different and forced to be near each other, it doesn’t mean that they will socialize or help each other; it’s like living on two different planets. there’s all kinds of social research showing this now, and what you get is micro segregation along income lines, rather than everyone helping each other and lifting up the community together.

I wanted for most of my life for people to get along and the world to be a better place, thinking that education and modern access to information could somehow make things better. It seems that was entirely and completely wrong. when people have any kind of discomfort at all about new culture or new person or new idea? They pretty much just run away.

The people here on hacker news are probably an exception, because we are here searching for commentary and interesting ideas and new information.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by nrr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:04AM (#49428942)
> The honestly very poor black community around the area? they fucking hate us white people. like actively, all the time, no what no matter what you have or haven’t done they don’t like your ass one bit.

Did you replace folks' smoke detector batteries for them?

The way I found to get around this prejudice was to go to church most Sundays and walk around with a sling bag full of 9V batteries and knock on doors to offer to maintain smoke detectors. (It probably didn't hurt that I was also good for bumming cigarettes off of and slowing down to have a chat.)

YMMV, but showing up and doing work was apparently what my neighbors in East St. Louis and Atlanta wanted.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by throw-the-towel on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:21AM (#49429391)
Wait, so the smoke detector thing is real? I assumed it was just a racist stereotype.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by nrr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:52AM (#49429593)
It's something of a meme that's grounded in reality, but it's honestly less grounded in race and ethnicity than it is in socioeconomic status.

That said, there's a joke that the white people version of this is the little bug in the lower right corner of the Windows desktop background that tattles on you for not having activated.

Which, like, y'know, that's fair.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by worik on Monday August 24, 2026 @10:58PM (#49428591)
What an awful society you live in.

It is not like that where I live.

The first generation of immigrants have trouble, natural enough. But are very keen that their children do better.

As for racism: Most racism here is systemic, from the state. There is casual ignorant racism, of course, but little hate.

What a mess has been made of your country. You should work to fix it.

It took us a lot of work to get here, and we have a long way to go. But I cannot imagine living in a society such as you describe.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Gud on Monday August 24, 2026 @11:46PM (#49428845)
Where I’m from, Sweden, typically it is the second and third generation immigrants who exhibit antisocial behaviour.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ipaddr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:31AM (#49429467)
Its true im many places. First generation hard working. Second generation lives in the inprint of the first generation. Third generation has no connection to the original homeland and tries to find connection or it turns to antisocial behaviour.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by vintermann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:58AM (#49430023)
Worth specifying that this also applies to the "good" immigrants such as the Poles, not just the much vilified Muslims. The kids of Polish immigrants really struggle. And if you go a generation back, the Vietnamese boat refugees had similar issues: their kids really had issues, there were Vietnamese criminal gangs in Oslo in the 90s. The ex-Yugoslav organized crime groups were maybe more notable in that they were often first generation, but they're mostly a memory too by now. Then there's the "hapas", children of Asian women who immigrated by marrying native men. Scandinavia hasn't seen much trouble with them - yet. But I think there's some danger here, online I've seen some worrying communities.

I think identity rootlessness is an underestimated factor in immigration woes. Youth of all kinds can often be exploited into adopting a destructive self-identity, but some groups are more vulnerable. One notorious Swedish gang actively recruits from the foster care system.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by modo_mario on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:34AM (#49435898)
I think less people expected those to cause generational trouble and so a common pro-migration argument 1-2 decades ago was that these people from mena regions would assimilate. After all the people from (in our case italy) mostly already did.

It's wild to see how this flipped completely around in such a short time and now some markers of integration seem to go backwards and at the same time some consider it biggoted to demand/expect assimilation.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Gud on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:57AM (#49429628)
The first generation could hardly be classified as “hard working”, the sad fact is many of them live on (generous) welfare.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by defrost on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:31AM (#49429825)
You only have to look at Trump; third generation immigrant.

His grandfather made his fortune by operating a restaurant and a brothel for miners in Whitehorse during the Gold Rush years, his father compounded that with an actual real estate 'empire' and the grandson 'earnt' money via dodgy wealth transfer schemes and sank much of it into get rich quick scams and branding deals based on fraudulent representation and money laundering, now leading the country in historic levels of open corruption.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Gud on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:39AM (#49430713)
Ok, this is very different from the situation in Sweden. Many were analphabets and live completely segregated from mainstream society with little hope(or wish) to integrate with Swedish society.

I agree with your analysis of the Trump family who have been detrimental for US society.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by defrost on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:44AM (#49430753)
Near as I can tell, Trump III is also an analphabet, living completely segregated from mainstream society with little hope(or wish) to integrate with Swedish society (or US for that matter).
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Gud on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:58AM (#49430877)
Good point.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by defrost on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:06AM (#49430938)
Questions for Sweden might be "How did the US integrate all the illiterate Irish?" (and should they do the same), "How did Australia integrate many non English speaking / writing Vietnamese 'boat people'?", etc.

Unless Sweden in majority is prepared to broom out all that they have accepted in, then this how it is, a mix of cultures having to find common directions and minimise friction over the next generation and a half.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by soco on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:16AM (#49431413)
These are valid questions the western Europe dodged for far too long. Looking the other way created the rightwing monster of today.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Natfan on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:23PM (#49436596)
or the third generation are just natives at that point, and will commit crimes at a similar rate to the native populace?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by anal_reactor on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:27AM (#49430637)
This is exactly my experience. I moved into a black neighborhood and it's real bad for me. My neighbor, a white elderly woman, organizes sort of community events, but it's 90% white people from nicest houses.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dolmen on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:25AM (#49429786)
> a common history going back to the Romans.

Native Americans are not related to Romans.

Slaves brought by force from Africa neither.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Eueudhsbsj32 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:17AM (#49431980)
Neither of those two groups were citizens of America historically.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:24AM (#49429046)
Is the problem social cohesion or mental illness and meth and fentanyl addiction?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by joshuat on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:32AM (#49429092)
Stronger punishments? Probably not, but better enforcement? I believe so.

It has repeatedly been shown that the severity of punishment does not sway crime nearly as much as the certainty of punishment does [1]. This all feels like a byproduct of the hyper-individualism we have in the West and the US, especially.

[1] https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/670398

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by podocarp on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:02AM (#49429289)
Indeed. Wasn't there a study where a policeman stationed on a street corner decreased crime or something even if he was just standing there doing nothing? Like a scarecrow effect.

Of course people will come out and scream Gestapo! And talk about their freedoms, but are the only two choices in life complete anarchy and a police state? Can't we live somewhere in the middle like a reasonable society? It's really just slippery slope fallacies all the time like either we don't police at all or do north korea style surveillance.

Also the demonization of police, the need is to have better police, not no police! It's just absurd what people come up with, it's so unreasonable yet these ideas gain such a large following.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by deadfoxygrandpa on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:57AM (#49430009)
there are police booths on many street corners in urban areas of china. they're very common, and people don't act afraid of them. the most common interaction you see is people asking them for directions
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by podocarp on Saturday August 29, 2026 @02:03AM (#49487325)
Sorry I don't understand your reply. Are you agreeing with me? The police booth is not to make you afraid. The idea is that it would deter pickpockets and other petty crime just by being there, regardless of whether the booth was meant to do so or not. Yes it could just be a almost retired security guard inside giving out directions but that would still work better than nothing at all.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by cortesoft on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:19AM (#49429019)
The United States is certainly part of the west, and we incarcerate people at a higher rate than any other advanced nation, BY FAR.

The idea that we are soft on crime is insane.

Harsher punishments do not lead to lower crime.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by gottorf on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:04AM (#49429656)
> we incarcerate people at a higher rate than any other advanced nation, BY FAR

Crime is committed at a higher rate than in any other advanced nation, though some of the others are catching up.

> The idea that we are soft on crime is insane

Not even a little bit insane. There are a million criminal laws on the books that do not get enforced at all. For example, I live in a state that is stereotypically conservative and "tough on crime" and any marijuana-related products are strictly illegal, most often at the felony level; yet I constantly smell it while driving on the road, no less! People are smoking while driving all the time. This cannot be described as anything but soft on crime.

The US system was overall built by and for people who are largely self-governing. This philosophy gets in the way of a true hard-on-crime pivot.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by cortesoft on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:40AM (#49433918)
And yet your prisons are full of people in jail for marijuana related crimes.

Because putting people in prison for weed does not stop people smoking weed.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by laughing_man on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:38PM (#49442732)
You don't go to jail for possession of weed in most US states. You won't even go to jail for dealing unless you've been busted multiple times or you're moving heavy weight.

When you see statistics about people incarcerated on marijuana charges, what they normally obscure is either that's not the only charge or they pled down from something more serious.

There isn't a single person in federal custody there for marijuana possession and only that.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by giardini on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:33AM (#49429097)
cortesoft says "Harsher punishments do not lead to lower crime."

Nonsense! Increase the punishment and it does. At the extreme, death for every crime, harsher punishments would totally eliminate criminal recidivism.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by SamoyedFurFluff on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:55AM (#49429246)
Do you have evidence that harsher punishments have a causal effect on crime rates?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by cortesoft on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:42AM (#49429167)
It would not stop crimes committed by the people in charge of enforcing the draconian punishments.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by andrepd on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:51AM (#49430399)
People _2000 years_ ago were writing books about why this is not true, but in the year 2026 there's still people saying "just give them the death penalty bro"....
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:29AM (#49429074)
As others have pointed out the US has a massive prison population.

Our problem isn't insufficiently harsh punishment. Our problem is unlikely punishment. The US spends more on incarceration and less on policing and the justice system. You are less likely to get caught and punished in the US but if you get punished it's harsher. Yet studies have shown that a milder punishment that happens more swiftly and with higher certainty is much better for preventing crime.

Not sure that helps with mentally ill homeless but it's at least an improvement we could aim for

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by SchemaLoad on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:27AM (#49429434)
This is what China has done. Aside from drug crimes it doesn't seem like they punish any harsher than the rest of the world, they just have an incredibly good ability to follow up. If you smash the window of a store, they will find you and you'll have to pay for it. Just the knowledge that there is an almost 100% chance of having to pay to restore anything you break seems all that's needed to stop the destruction of public spaces.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:45AM (#49429548)
On the less extreme end, Europe also has much higher rates of catching criminals and punishes then less. I understand the US is really the outlier.

I read an interesting article that laid out how that's ultimately rooted in what level of government pays for what. It's easier for local politicians to call for harsher punishment because prisons are run by state or federal but police is funded locally.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by vintermann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:42AM (#49429901)
I don't think the police is underfunded in the US though?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by zhivota on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:56AM (#49430002)
It simultaneously is and isn't. It's overfunded on things that don't matter for the problem at hand - traffic enforcement using full fledged officers in expensive vehicles, militarized SWAT teams, regulations requiring huge officer presence at all events, etc. But it's underfunded on what would change things for the better - foot patrols, investigation, etc.

This is why you can get pulled over for a broken taillight in the US and have 3 police cars behind you complete with a K9 unit, but if that same car gets stolen, you'll probably get asked to make a report and never hear a peep from the police again.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by OroPla on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:34AM (#49431127)
Reminds me of a story I read recently where they deployed a SWAT team to deliver a letter. I thought it must have been fake, but maybe not..

(It was news because the old building's stairs couldn't support the weight of the SWAT team and collapsed, injuring many of them.)

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:39AM (#49433889)
Look at officers per 100k: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependen... France has 422, Germany 349, Italy 456, US 242. There are countries that are super safe like Japan and Singapore with only 255 and 174 but I think it's safe to say that the US probably is better compared to France here. China also has only 258 but I think they make up for it through surveillance which isn't welcome in the US.

The US also doesn't train police officers well compared to most European countries. In the US it takes just a few months to become a police officer. In Germany it takes years.

Very good conversation on the general topic: https://youtu.be/6gMwh3jkWy0?is=MiTI5N1wdEpd_izP

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by zhivota on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:52AM (#49429971)
The thing there that the West has not been able to accept to achieve this is the surveillance state. Just look at Flock.

I'm not sure anyone has really cracked how to get it done without that part, though certainly tweaking the spending from prisons to police would help a lot. The trouble in the US at least is people (rightly) don't trust police, and don't want to give them more power, so it also needs to be paired with reform on that front for the population to accept it.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Shog9 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:11AM (#49433428)
Because cameras alone do nothing useful, and there's precious little evidence these are being used to help address petty vandalism.

The UK already went down this road years ago - cameras everywhere, public restrooms nowhere, prompt and automatic ticketing for parking violations but precious little in the way of assistance from humans should you need it. The shut-in dotage of a former empire too afraid to leave its house.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by crote on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:36AM (#49429853)
So how come the weak-on-crime Western European countries are not drowning in homeless drug addicts?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by soco on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:13AM (#49431391)
It's probably the difference you can also notice between Switzerland and Germany for example. Take rough sleeping: in Germany it's there (no, not LA-style but still noticeable). In Switzerland they get immediately rounded up and taken to a shelter, no "muh freedom" discussion just housed. Add warm meals and a community and the light at the end of the tunnel starts to be be noticed. Of course mentally ill will come out again, so at some point they will have to be institutionalized. Nobody belongs on the streets, no matter what the gop is telling.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by modo_mario on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:20AM (#49435680)
There's a growing amount of visible homlessness near here in Brussels and the other big cities in Belgium and a lot of other western european cities

Influences related to migration have overwhelmed whatever support systems there are to tackle this.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by socalgal2 on Monday August 24, 2026 @10:08PM (#49428292)
> We did as little as possible to deal with homelessness and mental illness

SF would beg to differ. They have a budget of $100k per homeless person. They can't solve the problem because the problem is not money

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:18AM (#49429012)
What do you suggest the solution is?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by olmo23 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:56AM (#49430004)
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by selfmodruntime on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:32AM (#49430265)
Insane Asylums.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by giardini on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:26AM (#49429057)
Soylent Green.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:43AM (#49429171)
So mass murder?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by anon48293 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:44AM (#49429175)
Life sentences in prison for any drug crime.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:03AM (#49429299)
So anyone who has LSD on them gets life in prison? Sounds expensive. Is that how other countries have avoided having this many visible homeless?

Any concerns about police placing drugs on someone if punishment is this harsh?

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by SchemaLoad on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:20AM (#49429386)
It is pretty much how China has handled it. It seems like it does actually work if your goal is to fully eliminate drug issues, but it's unacceptably harsh for most countries to palate.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by vintermann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:37AM (#49429861)
A quick check suggests the penalty for possession is 3 years in prison, not life. No idea if that is a maximum sentence.

From what I can find, it looks like China does a lot of what the US does, including DARE style education, and that there is still (by Chinese accounts) quite a lot of illegal drug use.

I would think that since China is very nationalist and still fairly collectivist/anti-individualist, and has a grim history of drugs being used as a tool of foreign imperialism (the opium wars), drug use is much further out of the social "Overton window". I think that's a better explanation for apparently lower drug use than harsh punishments, because other states also have those (notably the US!)

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by anon48293 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:28AM (#49429441)
Why is it expensive? Forced labor and for profit prisons exist.

And if there is a life sentence on hard drugs who would possibly have them on them?

You could also make it the 3rd offense or something, not that difficult.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by kakacik on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:12AM (#49430541)
Dealers can deal with that easily, this is often how they operate now, they don't carry big bags of stuff in their pockets usually they have nothing if police will do quick search. With that approach you will mostly catch users.

If I would be getting these naive suggestions of yours in this thread from my 6 year old son, I could respect them. But adults in 2026 should definitely know better and know a bit of history to reflect on.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:50AM (#49430804)
So essentially a return to the failed drug policies of the last 50 years.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by gambiting on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:32AM (#49432860)
>>And if there is a life sentence on hard drugs who would possibly have them on them?

Well by that logic there's no thieves in countries that cut your arm off for stealing. It doesn't work this way.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by s1artibartfast on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:17AM (#49429365)
Yeah, that is actually how a lot of countries in Asia have handled the problem
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by crote on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:28AM (#49429803)
So how come incarceration in Asia is orders of magnitude lower than in the US?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by s1artibartfast on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:08AM (#49430515)
The laws are enforced harshly and consistently, so people follow them. As a result, you have low crime and low incarceration
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by account42 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:05AM (#49433330)
Be careful comparing such statistics between countries as the defintions of what counts at every step will be different and there are always contributing factors that skew the statistics.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by s1artibartfast on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:46AM (#49434014)
I think I took appropriate caution. Do you have a specific concern?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by codedokode on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:36AM (#49433832)
Could it be because Japan is populated mostly (98%) by people who have lived there for multiple generations under strict rules? Also, it's probably a cultural thing where crime is shamed.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mx7zysuj4xew on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:30AM (#49432836)
They haven't "handled" the problem. Drugs are still as plentiful and cheap as ever there
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dgoldstein0 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:28AM (#49429442)
Prison isn't the right idea. But getting them into some sort of treatment would make sense. And that could be court mandated for repeat offenders for some crimes.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by pelagicAustral on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:23AM (#49429776)
I kind of read the suggestion as a deterrent for dealers and people engaged in drug trafficking, which could lead to less addicts... Not as "jail the junkies!"
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by crote on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:27AM (#49429797)
The biggest drug dealers are legitimate doctors. You can't solve the problem without first adressing the pipeline to addiction.

Want to get rid of drug addicts? Start by banning all pharma ads and stopping over-prescription.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mschuster91 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:17AM (#49430577)
> Want to get rid of drug addicts? Start by banning all pharma ads and stopping over-prescription.

People don't go to their doctor and complain about pain for no reason.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by account42 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:08AM (#49433373)
And? Doctors are not supposed to be a pharma dispensary. Depending on motivational factors a doctor may either tell someone to suck it up, quickly fill out a standard subscription to cover up the symptoms or spends some time to diagnose and fix the root cause and then prescribe medication by taking into account but the patients immediate needs and the long-term health impacts.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by kakacik on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:07AM (#49430501)
Ah, the age old 'if we jail all the dealers drugs will go away' fantasy. If we ban all the alcohol all the issues stemming from it will go away. If...

Fools that don't learn from their own mistakes are bound to never-ending cycle of repetition. Individuals or whole societies, doesn't matter.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajmurmann on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:59AM (#49435348)
That was what was supposed to happen in Oregon when they decriminalized drugs. However, building the treatment centers, shelters, etc took forever, in part due to communities pushing back against these facilities being built in their neighborhoods, and you still need a well-staffed justice system with sufficient judges and public defenders to actually process offenders in a timely fashion or at all. Lack of public defenders, judges and jail capacity is why Portland has so much catch and release, not due to unwillingness to enforce the law.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by crote on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:24AM (#49429785)
Can we start with the drug-using tech billionaires?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Natfan on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:13PM (#49436463)
okay, so byebye elon?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by tomhow on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:39PM (#49457907)
Please don't post like this on HN. Multiple guidelines ask us to avoid this kind of thing, in particular:

Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

Eschew flamebait.

Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by phrotoma on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:17AM (#49431021)
Repeal all prohibition. It enriches cartels and incites corruption. Take all the money pissed up the wall fighting drug crime and spend it on treatment and rehab. Let corporations sell pharmaceutical grade drugs like heroin (junkies don't actually want fentanyl, it wears off too fast while heroin lasts for hours) and pay some fucking tax.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by justin66 on Monday August 24, 2026 @10:59PM (#49428600)
Spending money is necessary but not sufficient to fix this sort (or literally any sort?) of big problem.

I hope you don't think San Francisco having spent a lot of money on the problem (the $100k per person figure in isolation is deceptive, but let's not dwell on that) means we've expended more than a really minimal amount of effort as a nation on the problem. Consider how little the problem of homelessness was discussed during the last presidential cycle, or how often it's discussed in congress, and I think you'll see what I mean. (consider the words used when debating it and you'll really understand what I mean)

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by cortesoft on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:08AM (#49428965)
Just because you can spend money poorly doesn’t mean money isn’t needed to fix an issue.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ericd on Monday August 24, 2026 @10:50PM (#49428538)
Something to keep in mind is that that figure includes homeless people who have been homed and are being supported, it's not just the ones currently on the streets.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by sroussey on Monday August 24, 2026 @10:44PM (#49428509)
And still once I was ina small restaurant that let a homeless guy use the toilet and they forced the door open after hearing crashing sounds, and he had painted the walls with his poop and jumped up and down on the sink until it broke off.

Days later I saw a sign in their window saying the bathroom was for customers only.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by vkou on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:01AM (#49428917)
I assure you, if they stopped spending that money tomorrow, things would get dramatically worse, as all the people that money keeps off the streets would be on them.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by CamperBob2 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:40AM (#49429147)
Do they spend $100,000 per homeless person in Europe and Asia? If not, why don't they have similar problems?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dolmen on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:19AM (#49429740)
EU:

The social net prevents homelessness.

We don't get broke because of medical bills.

Labor laws prevent being fired without prévenance.

Being fired grants you employment benefits.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Auracle on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:58AM (#49430030)
The vast majority of the homeless you see on the streets in the US are there no because of money trouble, but because of mental health or drug issues (or both).

People with money issues can almost always lean on friends or family. It’s the people that no longer have any friends or family willing to put up with them that end up on the streets.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by panta on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:19AM (#49430170)
Then the question becomes why US has such a huge problem with mental health and drugs that most other countries don't have with this scale. Maybe it's easier to develop mental health and/or drug issues when there are no societal safety nets, like accessible healthcare, decent affordable housing, unemployment benefits, ...
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:24AM (#49430210)
We really should go with a harsh Chinese solution. If you do drugs in China, you hope your dad is Jackie Chan or you are going to have a really hard life. And being caught homeless in a big city gets you a free escorted bus ticket back to the poor rural area your hukou is in, where you couldnt make it either.

The more western solutions are compassionate containment like in Finland.

America cant make up its mind if it wants to be like China or Finland.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Auracle on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:13PM (#49438213)
I don't know why people seem to think the US has "no societal safety nets."

We have medicaid, unemployment benefits, how expensive our housing is completely depends on location just like other places (rural-ish areas are probably cheaper than almost all of Europe), etc.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ido on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:32AM (#49430662)
I live in Berlin and there's a ton of homeless people on the streets. As bad as most major US cities (SF is worse, or at least was - I haven't visited in a few years).
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by fragmede on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:54AM (#49429606)
If they're spending money on, say, school lunches for poor kids and on substance abuse programs, they're not technically spending money on homeless people, but it's hard to see that the money that isn't being spent on the unhoused doesn't help people not become unhoused in the first place.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mikelitoris on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:40AM (#49429520)
Closer familial ties + extremely harsh laws for drug sale and use. Asians realized how opium fucked China for a century and made sure none of that shit flies.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by codedokode on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:38AM (#49433883)
As I remember, in Finland everyone is guaranteered an apartment, even if the person has no money.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Natfan on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:18PM (#49436520)
google medical bankruptcy, zero (0) other first world countries deal with this concept
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by db48x on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:30AM (#49429455)
Spending less money more efficiently would not make the problem worse.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by vkou on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:35AM (#49429848)
But currently housed people becoming street homeless would.

Unless you mean to say that you don't care either way if they do.

(If your value system places zero value on that, then my value system places positive value on spending your money on things you very explicitly don't value.)

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by db48x on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:36PM (#49439474)
This argument is so dumb. SF spends so profligately that a well–run system could spend less money and be just as effective, if not more effective. Nobody would be turned out onto the street just because less money was being spent. Half of that money is probably going to fraudsters who are bilking the government. A lot of it is probably being spent in useless ways that ensure that more money will be spent on the problem in the future, to keep the cash spigot running to the NGOs that profit from the homeless.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by geysersam on Monday August 24, 2026 @10:39PM (#49428472)
The problem is money, but for preventing homelessness and mental illness in the first place.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dgoldstein0 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:35AM (#49429493)
SF - and probably much of the US homeless problem elsewhere - is largely cost of housing; rent and home prices are ridiculous enough that if you don't make big bucks, you are likely barely scraping by. Rents here are rising way faster than inflation, and it makes everything more expensive and means a lot more people are living that much closer to not being able to pay their rent. Way easier to end up homeless after losing your job when paying 3k/month in rent than 1k/month, as at the cheaper rent saving money is actually possible.

We've consistently built a tiny fraction of the new residential units needed for projected population growth for decades now. Supply has been barely growing while demand surged; what else should we expect?

Other parts of the country have not been as extreme, but this has played out in other cities too. We've had terrible housing policy, and increased homelessness is a direct consequence.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by slg on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:15AM (#49429717)
What you say is completely true, but part of the problem is that people have very different ideas of what they are talking about when they talk about homeless people.

People who tend to complain about the homeless are generally only complaining about the visibly homeless (i.e., the people living on the street). Meanwhile the people who advocate for helping the homeless are more likely to also care about the invisible homeless who tend to make up the majority of all homeless people. These are the folks who might have jobs, live in their car, have a gym membership to shower, etc. You could spend a lot of time with many of these people and have no idea they were homeless and as a result they aren't included in many people's perception of the problem of homelessness. Therefore, it's hard for people to believe that something as simple as lowering rent prices could actually solve homelessness for a majority of homeless people.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mrngld on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:31AM (#49432133)
I think the burden of proof is on your position. When activists in my area pick a fight with local government, it's never over that invisible group. Indeed, as far as I can tell, they don't give a rip about the veterans living in the forest over by the VA hospital. I've never seen them over there. They're too busy picking fights defending the ones pooping at the downtown parks (and not in the public toilet) or trying to get city funding and approval for safe drug use, etc.

Now, you're right that there are people that do care and put tremendous effort into that more invisible group. Churches and church-backed organizations do a lot of that. Difference is, except for fund-raising from like-minded folks (and a lot of them hate even asking for money), they go about their work quietly, without seeking attention or reward.

There'd be the possibility of joining forces, but not with the DSA-types that jump in the limelight and scream the loudest and advocate for free needles. The people doing the bulk of the hard work don't want to make a statement on Palestine, they just want volunteers for the hard-to-staff weekday shower-cleaning shift. They need men willing to be mentors, etc. They care about the actual people they're serving, not trying to bring about glorious revolution. The two groups aren't compatible at the moment.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by adwn on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:22AM (#49432734)
> they just want volunteers for the hard-to-staff weekday shower-cleaning shift

This may sound like a loaded question, but I assure you, that's not my intention. If you want to provide for those "invisible" homeless, who aren't drug addicts or mentally ill, shouldn't the primary volunteer pool consist of exactly those invisible homeless people? Or in other words, once you have organizers, why do you need external volunteers for cleaning the showers?

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by miriam_catira on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:22AM (#49434673)
Point in case - my 75-yr-old retired parents staff one of those church showers in one of the most affluent towns south of SF. They have time, because they're retired. The people using those showers can't volunteer, they have jobs they have to get to.

That's the point here, the invisible homeless are people who are _fully employed_ but they're still too poor to have homes to live in.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by hackable_sand on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:09AM (#49435502)
HN comments always seem to be driving in the right direction and then yank the steering wheel at the last moment.

Gotta be some kind of weather vane for you guys.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by adwn on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:32AM (#49435882)
Please elaborate. Where does my comment leave the "right direction"?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Natfan on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:16PM (#49436499)
how can a volunteer group only consist of one group of people?

surely then they aren't volunteering, but rather being volunteered

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ashf023 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:15PM (#49439147)
Being volunteered to help clean the facilities they depend on and otherwise get for free?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by xp84 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:53AM (#49436200)
Thank you for being one of the few to draw a distinction there! The thing is, that second group are arguably already being helped by the many, many taxpayer-funded services we already have. They use the resources as intended to get back on their feet. I know it's not a fun time to be in that boat, but as long as it's a temporary boat and not a permanent predicament, it's not a societal emergency. To be clear, I'd support any reasonable policy specifically targeted and proven to help people who are in this situation.

One more thing:

> something as simple as lowering rent prices

Suppose you solve that (by market means, constructing an incredible amount of homes, or by communist means, by draconian rent-control cutting all rents by 70%). A 2-bedroom apartment in SF is now $1,200 and there are 50,000 of them vacant. Would these apartments not be immediately rented by 50,000 households from elsewhere who have always wanted to live there but haven't been able to afford it? Either the rents would shoot right back up if we're letting markets function, or the apartments would be insta-filled by a few very lucky people, with a years-long waiting list for any housing that ever opens up. There will always be one more person who will be happy to move to a great climate, top-tier city, unless the rents are obnoxiously high.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dgoldstein0 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @05:05AM (#49496979)
Rent control won't really solve the problem as it can only help people who already live in the city but makes rents even higher for new residents - there have been studies that essentially find that rent control essentially just transfers money from newer residents to ones who have lived here a long time. And worse, it a removes incentives for improving existing buildings and for current tenants to move, thereby reducing liquidity in the market - eg if you would like to upsize or downsize for whatever reason, being locked into a good rent controlled price is a strong disincentive.

The better solution is definitely "build an incredible amount of homes" though $1200 probably is not be obtainable even at extreme ends of possibility. We also should consider it a region wide problem and not just an SF problem - the whole bay area needs to build more, as rents in Oakland, Daly City, San Mateo, etc are related to SF prices as well. If the region is going to add jobs we better add housing at the same rate, and we've massively failed at that.

But anyway if the market actually starts functioning as new supply appears any tent decrease would incrementally attract some new tenants from elsewhere. Rents only shoot back up if the supply increase isn't sustained addition, or we somehow artificially lower rents for a short period. In a functioning market we should find an equilibrium price and when demand spikes faster than units can be built, be development would spring up that in a few years would push prices back towards normal (as jobs / the economy clearly moves faster than new housing can be constructed). But even in the booms when construction should be seeing the influx of people with high salaries and trying to develop new housing to keep up... Well, the volume of new housing just didn't keep up.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by phyzix5761 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:51AM (#49429966)
They offered the homeless in California free homes, free drugs, and a monthly stipend if they got off the streets. Most didn't take it because they didn't want to surrender their "freedom".
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by EduardoBautista on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:36AM (#49430292)
Many of the homeless don’t have jobs. They wouldn’t be able to afford rent in Bangladesh.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by simiones on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:21AM (#49431454)
Becoming and then staying homeless for a significant time is often almost irreversible. The key is to prevent people from ever getting there, as much as you can - and that is the point the poster above was making. The fall from house + job > house > no house makes it very hard to ever get another job that actually pays enough to go back to having a house.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mx7zysuj4xew on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:27AM (#49432788)
In Bangladesh someone can put up a plywood shack somewhere and call it their home

Anyone living in a tent city would most likely not only survive but thrive there

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by xp84 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:56AM (#49436236)
The tent city people here are all on meth and fent, sadly. That's why they're there. They can't thrive anywhere.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by 59percentmore on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:08AM (#49433370)
Semi-related anecdotes:

After the Civil War, when many plantation properties became economically unsustainable, occasionally the main house would be abandoned by the owners, and the remaining sharecroppers would take up residence; one house that used to be for one extravagantly wealthy family, now occupied by a handful.

In Newport, RI, after the income tax made maintaining grand Gilded Age domiciles untenable, many were subdivided into multiple units. Again, a house for one family (and there servants) turned out to be decent housing for multiple.

People keep saying that America has a building deficit, and to some extent, we do. But we also have a lot of physically massive houses that house one family, because those families can currently afford it. Historically, that has not been a permanent state.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by xp84 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:43AM (#49436044)
> SF - problem... is largely cost of housing

Are you talking about the homeless who are actually causing any problems (the chronic homeless)? Or the meaningless statistical group of "Everyone who doesn't have their own/rented home today"?

> Way easier to end up homeless after losing your job when paying 3k/month in rent than 1k/month

Any person without serious mental and/or substance problems can handle losing their job without sleeping in the streets. By virtue of not being mentally ill and addicted, everyone else has "friends" and "family" somewhere who would say "Oh, gee Fred, sorry you lost your job. Sleep on my couch for a few weeks while you're looking for work."

The only people who don't are those who have burned every bridge by repeatedly betraying the trust of those who love them (theft, bringing drugs into their home, sexual abuse, etc).

A lot of people also sleep in their cars and shower at the gym while putting their lives together. Now, those people DO count as homeless in the official counts, but they aren't the ones causing any problems, and they also consume only a tiny fraction of the public resources that "The Homeless" we see on the streets do.

So, while lower rents would help with the official numbers, you would see little improvement on the streets because that's not why they're there.

(All that said, I'm sure there's a small pipeline from the 'temp homeless' to the 'chronic homeless,' which is probably 99.9% made up of people who are in the "living in the car" or "couch surfing" phase who make the poor choices to take up an addiction to drown their sorrows.)

Separately, the other problem with the "just build more housing" plan is: These cities aren't surrounded by 50-foot walls. They're not closed systems. Say we build so much that the $3000 rent drops to $1000. Now, people from elsewhere, seeing that SF is now as cheap as Fresno, will decide to move there, as the weather is way better, and there are tons of cool things about living in a world-class city by the sea. The low prices pull people from elsewhere just as reliably as low air pressure causes wind to blow towards it. (This is also why these temperate coastal cities can't fix things with money: The more comfortable you make it to be homeless in your city, the more tweakers from the hinterland will gravitate to the city.)

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by samus on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:19PM (#49437427)
> Any person without serious mental and/or substance problems can handle losing their job without sleeping in the streets.

This statement is very load-bearing in your whole argument though. Losing a job can completely derail a person's daily habits and cause their issues to worsen, either by the additional stress or by forgetting to keep their meds. It's downhill from there.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by piltdownman on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:13PM (#49436462)
From about 2010 onwards we have had the phenomenon of the High-Income White Collar Itinerate - the Silicon Valley worker living in a converted van, or the remote coder working from a LOC country with low barriers to entry regarding Visas and Taxation. These being the 'privileged' demographic.

The less fortunate simply deal with shrinkflation of the bottom tiers of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs. Only 12% of married Americans under 30 own a home in 2026. In 1960 it was 52%.

https://wealthvieu.com/homeownership-rate-by-demographics/

The pandemic-heightened desire for more spacious and independent living, as well as “excess” savings accumulated early in the lockdown stages of the pandemic, propelled headship rates of young adults by two percentage point to 43.1%, the highest level since 2010. This still didn't meet parity with the historic norms of 1990-2000s.

https://eyeonhousing.org/2023/01/how-pandemic-changed-living...

In other news, U.S. Home Prices Are up 29 Percent Since 2019.

https://www.jpmorgan.com/insights/global-research/real-estat...

tl;dr Americans will vote for an Economy over a Society, so long as Social policies continue to be villainized in political discourse.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dyauspitr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:49AM (#49429573)
The problem is you can’t get people off the street if they don’t want to get off the street unless you do it forcibly. You can end the homeless problem overnight but SF is too empathetic. I’m not even saying this is a fault, I’d rather they fail on the side of empathy than succeed violently.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by crote on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:23AM (#49429775)
Very few people want to be homeless. The alternatives offered to them just somehow manage to be even worse than homelessness.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dyauspitr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:04PM (#49441338)
They don’t want to be homeless but they don’t want to put up with free housing drug free rules so they prefer to stay on the streets where they can keep using.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by laughing_man on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:46PM (#49442789)
The problem is one of the alternatives they consider worse than homelessness is a life without opioids.

I had cousin who was homeless in San Diego. Over the years she came into money a couple times, either from family members or through inheritance. Instead of getting a place to live she figured drugs were a better use for that money. We tried everything to get her off the street, and nothing worked. She wouldn't even stay at a shelter. Because she had no intention of giving up the drugs.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by panta on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:26AM (#49430217)
The problem is money, but at a different level. When you deal with the homeless it's too late. That money must be spent before someone becomes homeless, on welfare: unemployment benefits, accessible healthcare and housing. A minor cut taken care of immediately is nothing, but let it turn into gangrene and you won't be able to fix it at all.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by hgomersall on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:57AM (#49430861)
Even benefits etc are too late. The money should be spent on providing hope for people. It's 45 years of neoliberalism that we are reaping.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by latexr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:17AM (#49431026)
> The money should be spent on providing hope for people.

How do you suggest that would work? Obviously you can’t just buy hope, so could you provide some specific ideas?

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by hgomersall on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:30AM (#49444833)
Yes, develop an economy that is not run for rent seekers. Provide a job guarantee so everyone can work at a wage floor. Build housing stock that is actually affordable and desirable for anyone on a normal wage. Make sure healthcare is affordable and available universally. Provide schools that are good regardless of where you live or what you can afford. Those things would be a start.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ricardobayes on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:26AM (#49434757)
AFAIK also SF was long known as "hobo capital", meaning many homeless or drifting people just ended up there. So it's much more complex than that, since many of the homeless are not even locals.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by idiotsecant on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:55AM (#49432379)
Because they're forced to burn dollars to solve a problem that was created upstream for the want of pennies.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by detourdog on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:40AM (#49432995)
I think around 1986 Reagan cut the federal funding to the facilities that would house the mentally ill. This created the homeless situation in the USA. I remember the term homeless as newly formed at that time and remember the population exploding as I went through college in center city Philadelphia.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by xp84 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:03PM (#49436322)
Some good source material:

https://factually.co/fact-checks/politics/did-ronald-reagan-...

The homeless situation as we know it had multiple causes in the 80s and prior. Part of it was Reagan-era policies wanting to save money, but the other half (which in my view would have probably still "achieved" the same end result) was activists who argued that involuntary institutionalization violated the rights of those who were committed. "The Left" and "The Right" were full partners in dismantling what we had. In my opinion, both were too stupid to realize the consequences of just deleting what existed without having a realistic plan for how to deal with those people. It's like if you realized your water heater was consuming $30 worth of electricity every month so you just turn the breaker off and say "We saved $30 and improved our climate footprint" but now everyone has to take cold showers forever and the dishes don't get properly cleaned.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by aninteger on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:01AM (#49433297)
We've had homeless people forever (although less). I think we used "hobo", or "tramp" back in the 1960s.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by detourdog on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:14AM (#49433474)
There was always a population that preferred living on the margins of society. Hobo’s and tramps are different than the mentally ill and they were called hobos and tramps. My grandmother used to trade food for labor of these people as they passed through.

The homeless were people that could not care for themselves or be of use in some way. The grey area might be junkies.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dessimus on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:20AM (#49433562)
SF is one of the highest cost of living cities in the US. I'm guessing housing and utilities is going to chew up the majority of that $100K, before you even consider medical and mental health visits and transportation to and from those visits, and there is likely tons of resistance from surrounding localities to allowing the City to relocate those they are helping to suburbs where they might find cheaper and/or more accessible housing, food costs, improved access to healthcare, etc.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by remarkEon on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:51AM (#49429225)
Anti-social people as a group is a larger population than just the homeless, mentally ill, and drug addicts, though these subsets are obviously a significant portion. The superset includes people who are genuinely anti-social in their nature, may be nominally employed, have a mailing address, and a place to sleep at night. These are the people we actually surrendered to when we changed enforcement priorities in major US cities to, ostensibly, have some grace and compassion toward the subset of homeless, mentally ill, and drug addicts. This is a demonstrably true statement. For me, and many like me, I know it's true because I can do something like "walk around in a neighborhood from my youth" or "visit a downtown corridor I used to frequent as a young adult" and simply observe the difference between the then and now. It's not always about the homeless, and the oft tiring debate around what to do about them. In many US cities, larceny is de facto legal as long as you are stealing goods valued under a certain amount. This is what people are talking about when they use the word "surrender".
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by CalRobert on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:01AM (#49429644)
I dunno, this could be it but living in rural Ireland showed how many obnoxious teenagers will completely destroy a playground just for kicks. I'm sure a public toilet would fall prey to the same impulse.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by fallingbananna on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:20AM (#49429749)
It's not just homeless, mentally ill or drug addicts.

In Europe it's frequently teenagers (even those whom parents provide good lives), football fans, drunk people, etc.

Some people are antisocial and destroy public stuff just for laughs, not because they feel resentment towards society.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by 59percentmore on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:58AM (#49433262)
And sometimes it's not even active destruction, just neglect. Public use amenities are subject to large amounts of wear-and-tear. Sometimes a thing just breaks, from someone being careless or not knowing how to operate it. You have to have the wherewithal for follow-through with upkeep.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Libcat99 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:28AM (#49433692)
One day a bridge collapsed, and no one came to fix it.

This is how an empire dies. One toilet/park/swing at a time.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by grehbies on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:14AM (#49434541)

  About a half a dozen who were nearby when the bridge collapsed, and, of those, only two actually missed seeing it happen. *Everyone* heard it, though: a great roaring waterfall of concrete and steel that echoed across the derelict plains for minutes and miles. The local folk would have told you that it was the river flooding a month earlier what had done it; that, and the heat of that summer havign roasted the old tarmac to pieces. But that wouldn't have been the truth; not entirely. Their hindsight failed to reach past a few preceding seasons, the road's slow degradation after years of use and somewhat fewer years of maintenance as far beyond the horizon as the sea. The columns that supported the span, plunging deep into the river below it, had had great, sweeping cracks for as long as the youth who periodically swam out to tag them could remember. The chain link fence that ran along the bridge's sides had rusted through to a twisted ragged heap even before then.

  The river the bridge had spanned was the _____, and the bridge itself - part of an interstate, from back when there had been states - had linked the northern and southern portions of Jefferson County (which still existed). Thankfully, no one was on it when it finally gave up the ghost. (For a few days, the Hughes of just south of the old rails were worried for their son, Kurt, who had failed to return home that evening; but he eventually turned up a week later, having spent the time with his girlfriend.)

  The loss of the ancient connector meant 50 miles extra travel for anyone who wanted to get from Dodge to Shelley, already a 70-mile trek. With gas so hard to come by, that was no small thing. Rebuilding it would have been ideal, but the fact was that there was no one around who could possibly manage such a project; most of that expertise was locked up in Atlanta, New York-Jersey, Charlotte, and St. Louis, and not one of the territories so mentioned was on good terms with small, flyover, Sep-sympathizing Jefferson County. Besides that, there were scant funds for construction equipment and materials anyway; the curse of Jefferson's self-sufficiency knocking unwelcome on the doors of Jeffersonian hearts more often than any stranger. The bridge would not be rebuilt. So, after the commotion of the actual collapse had died down, and the locals had ceased stopping by to gaze at the ruins and shake their heads and scowl, the structure, half-submerged stone monolith, lay placid and abandoned.

  None of this is really important, except for the part about the 50-mile detour. That... that is actually very important.
---

  The Biker learned of the bridge's collapse well before reaching Jefferson County. For all that had broken down from neglect or sabotage or accident in this land over the years, it seemed that the grapevine was as resilient as ever. The proprietor of a public house - the one he'd stopped in at when it came time to transfer some of his precious fuel from an emergency tank to the hot rod proper - was the bearer of the bad news. He'd thanked her, pulled out the Handspring loaded with a bootleg map app, and started searching for a new route. This one wouldn't do, it was likely to be more of a still-glowing crater than a road; and that one, that one ran right through hardcore Sep territory. And this one... No, he'd definitely run out of fuel. ...Maybe the second, again? If he could be quick, go at the right time of day... Too risky, his common sense told him. Nonsense, said the impulsive part that had gotten him out of (and, admittedly, into) many a hairy situation. T could outrun any trouble he might find. And he wouldn't find any, because he would be very, very careful. 'You don't got a choice, bub. Gas isn't cheap OR plentiful.' 

  "Shit."

  He hit the Handspring's power button and gingerly slid it back into his leather side saddle, and delayed his oncoming foolishness by taking the moment to glance around like he was looking for someone who was looking for him. Other than the pub, a converted vinyl-sided colonial, there was nothing but the coiled curves of cracked suburban roads and sidewalks; the mounded plots that lay along them, where the foundations of dozens of long-dismantled domiciles had once stood; and each building's replacements, bunches of grass and scrub, waving occasionally in the odd and rare breeze, which were staking out their own homesteads.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by sgirard on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:12AM (#49435540)
What book is this from? I would like to read it.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by grehbies on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:59PM (#49441837)
The one that might get written if I ever figure out what it's about. (I truly appreciate the inadvertent encouragement.)

I can pass along some of the inspiration, at least:

https://playlists.at/youtube/embed/?playlist=FdW1CjbCNxw%2CS...

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by sgirard on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @11:32AM (#49450931)
You have a talent for engaging writing. Keep it up.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Libcat99 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @06:24PM (#49456754)
I wanted to add I searched online for the text to see where I could find/read the rest :) So yes, keep it up.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by gambiting on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:06AM (#49432502)
Over here where I live(UK) it's neither the homeless nor mentally ill people, it's groups of teenagers who have literally nothing else to do and they will destroy every single piece of public infrastructure that isn't solid metal and welded down. Even keep them out of children play parks is a challenge the local police can't manage effectively, I love finding that every single swing and seesaw has been ruined because of bored teenagers.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by devilbunny on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:54AM (#49434177)
Whatever other issues they may have, they are overwhelmingly mentally ill, largely schizophrenic, and the surrender in the US happened just outside your fifty-year window when the Supreme Court decided that it should be much harder to institutionalize someone against their will. The timing was similar in the UK, from what I have read. Don’t know about the EU.

The problem with severe schizophrenics is that they don’t like and won’t take their meds if left to their own devices [EDIT: regardless of how much social support you provide, even though we certainly didn’t provide enough]. Institutions are in no way perfect, but One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest is not a documentary.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:24AM (#49435744)
The causation arrow isn't unidirectional, though. Mental illness causes some homelessness, particularly often because in the US healthcare system medications are expensive and can lead to bankruptcy. (And it is certainly not the only path to bankruptcy in the US either.) But more and more studies are showing that the biggest problem with homelessness in the US is that it causes mental illness. (Same thing is being found with drug addictions: some cause bankruptcy and then homelessness, but to cope with homelessness many find new addictions after becoming homeless.)

Most homeless shelters are run by religious charities. The majority of them treat homelessness as a sin, either by intentional policy or accidents of attitude. These "charities" often require a lot of work to keep being allowed to use their housing at their shelter from regular job hunting to regularly attending worship sessions to "zero tolerance" policies on everything from curse words to keeping private possessions to having pets to sometimes taking/keeping necessary medication. It's hard to keep your mental health in good shape when the groups that are housing you in the worst weather are berating you for being terrible sinners and treating you like prisoners.

Outside of shelters the most common interactions between homeless people and the cities around them are interactions with cops, who very rarely have mental health training or social work experience, and treat homeless people like criminals because their job is sometimes to treat everybody as would be criminals.

You ever really talk to a homeless person? The ones that really survive become very organized. They have a list of shelters memorized, which months they prefer to be at each one, what things they need to fake about themselves they need to do to survive in that shelter for a few weeks, how much "rent" they need to raise before they get there (some shelters often cost pennies per day just to show that the homeless person is "working" somehow; some homeless panhandle just to afford shelters), and exactly how long they can stay before they inevitably get kicked out (most shelters are "short term", intentionally). Just listening to all the rules and regulations and requirements makes me think I would go schizophrenic dealing with that world. It sounds like being stuck in a middle school that never ends, if that middle school's "classrooms" were all in entirely different parts of a city and all had deeply different rules. I can easily see why homelessness often causes mental illness in the US.

Institutions are close to the right answer, but for an entirely different reason than you assert. We do need better secular institutions (in the endowed place of learning sense, not the mental hospital sense) with mental health as one goal among several such as long-term support in charge of dealing with the homeless. The numbers keep showing that the greatest fix we've found for homelessness is making sure that everyone has a home where they feel safe and private and don't have to do anything to "earn" much less keep that home.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by devilbunny on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:55PM (#49441230)
Right, so, what do you do about the guy who smears feces on the walls and won't take his meds? Because that guy is the one who makes public spaces unlivable. Including places like SRO hotels that actually could provide people with affordable living spaces.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by gambiting on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:16PM (#49441434)
That's the guy who should be institutionalised, obviously?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by devilbunny on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:14PM (#49441983)
Yeah, except that because the Warren Court was so incredibly arrogant, it's almost impossible to institutionalize anyone against their will in the US unless you go through all the process of setting up guardianship.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:50PM (#49444017)
This (straw) man scenario feels like a proximate cause versus root cause situation to me. You've managed to establish a relatively strong proximate cause (or so it seems) as "won't take his meds". Where did he get the meds he was supposed to take? How is he paying for them? Was he given the meds in a place of safety and security enough to have reason to trust the meds might help?

If you were given strange meds that you don't understand anything about by someone who wasn't your personal doctor in a situation that feels like a prison out of your control, would you take them?

That's equally a straw man question, but a useful one to maybe establish empathy for the situation that homeless "guy" might have found himself in.

That's also assuming that is the correct proximate cause. As far as I know science has not yet found exactly a "don't use excrement as spray paint" drug. There are people that will do that which don't need meds and there are people that will do that even on most anti-psychotic meds.

But let's talk about some of the root cause of it all: If you find yourself in a world that you cannot control, that won't let you use any bathroom without buying a coffee/being a customer, that doesn't want you to exist, that says you are only as valuable as the property that you own but then won't allow you any longer to own any property due to some bad luck or misfortune, at that point "the only spray paint I have to send a message about how much this world sucks" might seem pretty clear.

I find it easy to have sympathy with that sort of (straw) man, because there is a logic to it. It's not necessarily a psychotic break. At least, not necessarily at first a psychotic break.

What would I personally do to prevent that? I'd try to prevent people from being homeless in the first place. I'd try to get people mental health resources sooner ahead of crises rather than trying it do it in the middle of a different one (bankruptcy/homelessness). Which is the same as I suggested statistically seems to be the only thing that works: give people private houses with locks and keys and help them feel safe and secure in them, with a sense of ownership and privacy, and with no need to "earn" it or "rent" to keep it. Maybe it doesn't stop the person from covering "their own" walls in feces until they feel safe and secure enough (and that's still a public health problem in the meantime) to try an antipsychotic med that they need to take. But as far as I'm aware no one wants to take or trust an antipsychotic medication if they don't at first feel like they live in a safe enough or secure enough place.

Which again also circles back to "institutions are almost the correct approach, but for the wrong reasons" I mentioned before. A place with mental health resources seems to be an important part of that, still, but I don't think you can address mental health problems in a prison, especially in a society that values private property and private spaces, without first addressing the problems around homeless not having access to private property and private spaces.

But yeah, that's mostly just my opinion on the subject based on statistics and studies that I've read. You don't have to take my word on it. One archived secondary source (with additional links): https://academicweb.nd.edu/~rwilliam/ndonly/readings/SocProb...

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by SubmarineClub on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:03PM (#49441324)
lol suuure it does. I totally believe that becoming homeless causes people to stand on sidewalks jabbering obscenities and smearing shit all over the place.

Why the fuck are we so soft on these gutter trash in this country.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by devilbunny on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:51PM (#49442824)
They are humans and American citizens. They deserve our compassion.

They just don’t deserve to destroy our public places.