I presume that this falls under the same consideration as direct links to science papers in articles that are covering those releases. Far as I can tell, the central tactic for lowering bounce rate and increasing 'engagement' is to link out sparsely, and, ideally, not at all.
I write articles on new research papers, and always provide a direct link to the PDF,; but nearly all major sites fail to do this, even when the paper turns out to be at Arxiv, or otherwise directly available (instead of having been an exclusive preview offered to the publication by the researchers, as often happens at more prominent publications such as Ars and The Register).
In regard to the few publishers that do provide legal PDFs in articles, the solution I see most often is that the publication hosts the PDF itself, keeping the reader in their ecosystem. However, since external PDFs can get revised and taken down, this could also be a countermeasure against that.
We need an AI driven extension that will insert the links. This would be a nice addition to Kagi as they could be trusted to not play SEO shenanigans.
Agree on the extension idea, except I’m not sure I want to see the original sensationalized content anyway. Might as well have the bot rewrite the piece in a dry style.
That’s painting with an overly broad brush. Nevertheless, the news was relying on ads long before most people knew the word “Internet”, but there were far fewer channels to place ads back then, so in some respects news and media organizations had a captive audience in advertisers.
Mass adoption of television was effectively made possible because of advertising money.
People come to your site because it is useful. They are perfectly capable of leaving by themselves. They don't need a link to do so. Having links to relavent information that attracts readers back is well worth the cost of people following links out of your site.
It's not the only reason their traffic is declining, but it seems like a big one.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:List_of_citogenesis_...
Google shifted views that used to go to Wikipedia first to their in-house knowledge graph (high percentages of which are just Wikipedia content), then to the AI produced snippets.
All to say, yes...Wikipedia's generosity with outbound links is part of the popularity. But they still get hit by this "engagement" mentality from their traffic sources.
In terms of a single search, I don't think Google really benefits from preventing a click-through - the journey is over once the user has their information. If anything, making them click through to an ad-infested page would probably get a few fractions of a cent extra given how deeply Google is embedded in the ads ecosystem.
But giving the user the result faster means they're more likely to come back when they need the next piece of information, and give them more time to search for the next information. That benefits Google, but only because it benefits the user.
This doesn't happen nearly as often on smaller sci/tech news outlets. When it does a quick email usually gets the link put in the article within a few hours.
https://www.404media.co/this-stunning-image-of-the-sun-could...
Journalists don't make it easy for you to access primary sources because of a mentality and culture issue. They see themselves as gatekeepers of information and convince themselves that readers can't handle the raw material. From their perspective, making it easy to read primary sources is pure downside:
• Most readers don't care/have time.
• Of the tiny number who do, the chances of them finding a mistake in your reporting or in the primary source is high.
• It makes it easier to mis-represent the source to bolster the story.
Eliminating links to sources is pure win: people care a lot about mistakes but not about finding them, so raising the bar for the few who do is ideal.
And there's also the idea that you should be able to at least somewhat trust the people reporting the news so they don't have to provide all of their references. --You can certainly argue that not all reporters can or should be trusted anymore, but convincing all journalists to change how they work because of bad ones is always going to be hard.
Reputable news organizations are more robust against such pressures, but plenty of people get their news from (in some cases self-described) entertainment sites masquerading as news sites.
So they rarely are forced to do anything but state the name of who they interviewed, and that's it. And puts them in the habit of not acknowledging what they read, as a source?
I have to assume the journalist writing such an article knows that they are misrepresenting the research to make a broader point they want to make.
Once users leave your page, they become exponentially less likely to load more ad-ridden pages from your website.
Ironically this is also why there is so much existential fear about AI in the media. LLMs will do to them what they do to primary sources (and more likely just cut them out of the loop). This Google story will get a lot of clicks. But it is easy to see a near future where an AI agent just retrieves and summarizes the case for you. And does a much better job too.
I am significantly less confident that an LLM is going to be any good at putting a raw source like a court ruling PDF into context and adequately explain to readers why - and what details - of the decision matter, and what impact they will have. They can probably do an OK job summarizing the document, but not much more.
I do agree that given current trends there is going to be significant impact to journalism, and I don’t like that future at all. Particularly because we won’t just have less good reporting, but we won’t have any investigative journalism, which is funded by the ads from relatively cheap “reporting only” stories. There’s a reason we call the press the fourth estate, and we will be much poorer without them.
There’s an argument to be made that the press has recently put themselves into this position and hasn’t done a great job, but I still think it’s going to be a rather great loss.
It is, in my view, a decent bit of reporting generated very very quickly and with a high level of readability, though. I'd be keen to hear what you think.
---
Me: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...
Review this court ruling: summarise and reflect on its implications, and explain in brief the rationale given.
---
Claude (Sonnet): I'll review this court ruling for you. Let me fetch the document first.
Fetched: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...
This is a significant court ruling in the Google antitrust case. Let me continue reading to get the complete picture of the remedies ordered.
Fetched: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...
## Summary
This is a landmark court ruling on remedies in the Google search monopoly case from September 2, 2025. The court previously found that Google violated Section 2 of the Sherman Act by maintaining monopolies in general search services and search text advertising through exclusive distribution agreements.
## Key Remedies Ordered
*What Google MUST do:* - Be barred from entering or maintaining any exclusive contract relating to the distribution of Google Search, Chrome, Google Assistant, and the Gemini app [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) - Make available to Qualified Competitors certain search index and user-interaction data, though not ads data [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) - Offer Qualified Competitors search and search text ads syndication services to enable those firms to deliver high-quality search results and ads [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) - Publicly disclose material changes it makes to its ad auctions to promote greater transparency in search text ads pricing [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...)
*What Google will NOT be required to do:* - Divest Chrome or Android [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) - Stop making payments to distribution partners [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) - Present users with choice screens [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) - Share granular, query-level data with advertisers [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) - Fund a nationwide public education campaign [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...)
## Court's Rationale
The court emphasized judicial humility, noting it "has no expertise in the business of GSEs, the buying and selling of search text ads, or the engineering of GenAI technologies" [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) and that "courts must approach the task of crafting remedies with a healthy dose of humility" [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) .
The judge rejected the most aggressive remedies (Chrome divestiture, payment bans) because "Plaintiffs overreached in seeking forced divesture of these key assets, which Google did not use to effect any illegal restraints" [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) and because cutting off payments would "impose substantial—in some cases, crippling—downstream harms to distribution partners, related markets, and consumers" [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) .
## AI and Future Competition Focus
A major theme is how generative AI (GenAI) is changing the competitive landscape. The emergence of GenAI changed the course of this case [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) , with the proceedings being "as much about promoting competition among GSEs as ensuring that Google's dominance in search does not carry over into the GenAI space" [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) .
The court found that the GenAI space is highly competitive [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) with companies like OpenAI (ChatGPT), Anthropic (Claude), and others rapidly gaining users, though GenAI products have not eliminated the need for GSEs [courtlistener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...) .
## Implications
This represents a middle-ground approach that avoids the most disruptive structural remedies while still imposing meaningful constraints on Google's anti-competitive behavior. The 6-year term and focus on data sharing and syndication requirements suggest the court is trying to foster competition without breaking up Google's core assets. The heavy emphasis on AI competition indicates the court sees this emerging technology as the most viable path to challenging Google's search dominance going forward.
The ruling reflects a careful balance between punishing past violations and avoiding over-regulation of a rapidly evolving tech landscape, particularly around AI development.
Citations: - [https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.223...)
Im concerned about bootstraping.
Edit: also, the primary point is that if everyone uses LLMs for reporting, the loss of revenue will cause the disappearance of the investigative journalism that funds, which LLMs sure as fuck aren’t going to do.
Content that can't be easily made by an LLM will still be worth something. But go to most news sites and their content is mostly summarization of someone else's content. LLMs may make that a hard sell.
* Strayed from reality
* Strayed from the document and is freely admixing with other information from its training data without saying so. Done properly, this is a powerful tool for synthesis, and LLMs theoretically are great at it, but done improperly it just muddles things
* Has some kind of bias baked in-ironic mdash-"in summary, this ruling is an example of judicial overreach by activist judges against a tech company which should morally be allowed to do what they want". Not such a problem now, but I think we may see more of this once AI is firmly embedded into every information flow. Currently the AI company game is training people to trust the machine. Once they do, what a resource those people become!
Now, none of those points are unique to LLMs: inaccuracy, misunderstanding, wrong or confused synthesis and especially bias are all common in human journalism. Gell-Mann amnesia and institutional bias and all that.
Perhaps the problem is that I'm not sufficiently mistrustful of the status quo, even though I am already quite suspicious of journalistic analysis. Or maybe it's because AI, though my brain screams "don't trust it, check everything, find the source", remains in the toolbox even when I find problems, whereas for a journalist I'd roll my eyes, call them a hack and leave the website.
Not that it's directly relevant to the immediate utility of AI today, but once AI is everything, or almost everything, then my next worry is what happens when you functionally only have published primary material and AI output to train on. Even without model collapse, what happens when AI journobots inherently don't "pick up the phone", so to speak, to dig up details? For the first year, the media runs almost for free. For the second year, there's no higher level synthesis for the past year to lean on and it all regresses to summarising press releases. Again, there are already many human publications that just repackage PRs, but when that's all there is? This problem isn't limited to journalism, but it's a good example.
Distribution Agreements
A central component of the remedies focuses on Google's distribution agreements to ensure they are not shutting out competitors:
No Exclusive Contracts Google is barred from entering into or maintaining exclusive contracts for the distribution of Google Search, Chrome, Google Assistant, and the Gemini app.
No Tying Arrangements Google cannot condition the licensing of the Play Store or any other Google application on the preloading or placement of its other products like Search or Chrome.
Revenue Sharing Conditions The company is prohibited from conditioning revenue-sharing payments on the exclusive placement of its applications.
Partner Freedom Distribution partners are now free to simultaneously distribute competing general search engines (GSEs), browsers, or generative AI products.
Contract Duration Agreements with browser developers, OEMs, and wireless carriers for default placement of Google products are limited to a one-year term.
Data Sharing and Syndication
To address the competitive advantages Google gained through its exclusionary conduct, the court has ordered the following:
Search Data Access Google must provide "Qualified Competitors" with access to certain search index and user-interaction data to help them improve their services. This does not, however, include advertising data.
Syndication Services Google is required to offer search and search text ad syndication services to qualified competitors on ordinary commercial terms. This will enable smaller firms to provide high-quality search results and ads while they build out their own capabilities.
Advertising Transparency
To promote greater transparency in the search advertising market, the court has mandated that:
Public Disclosure Google must publicly disclose significant changes to its ad auction processes. This is intended to prevent Google from secretly adjusting its ad auctions to increase prices.
What Google is NOT Required to Do
The court also specified several remedies it would not impose:
No Divestiture Google is not required to sell off its Chrome browser or the Android operating system.
No Payment Ban Google can continue to make payments to distribution partners for the preloading or placement of its products. The court reasoned that a ban could harm these partners and consumers.
No Choice Screens The court will not force Google to present users with choice screens on its products or on Android devices, citing a desire to avoid dictating product design.
No Sharing of Granular Ad Data Google is not required to share detailed, query-level advertising data with advertisers.
A "Technical Committee" will be established to assist in implementing and enforcing the final judgment, which will be in effect for six years."
Frankly I don't think that's bad at all. This is from Gemini 2.5 pro
You should play with LLMs this week.
This is true for first party applications, as well as for custom integrations, where I can explicitly check that the context should be grounding them with all of the relevant facts. It doesn’t matter, that isn’t enough, you can tell me I’m holding it wrong, but we’ve consulted with experts from anthropic and from OpenAI and who have done major AI integrations at some of the most prominent AI consuming companies. I’m not holding it wrong. It’s just a horribly flawed piece of technology that must be used with extreme thoughtfulness if you want to do anything non-trivial without massive risks.
I remain convinced that the people who can’t see the massive flaws in current LLM systems must be negligently incompetent in how they perform their jobs. I use LLM’s every day in my work and they are a great help to my productivity, but learning to use them effectively is all about understanding the countless ways in which they fail and thinks that they cannot be relied on for and understanding where they actually provide value.
They do provide value for me in legal research, because sometimes they point me in the direction of caselaw or legal considerations that hadn’t occurred to me. But the majority of the time, the vast majority, their summaries are incorrect, and their arguments are invalid.
LLMs are not capable of reasoning which requires non-obvious jumps of logic which are more than one small step removed from the example that they’ve seen in their training. If you attempt to use them to reason about a legal situation, you will immediately see themselves tie themselves in not because they are not capable of that kind of reasoning, on top of their inability to actually understand in summarize case documents and statutes accurately.
Where do you think LLMs learned this behavior from? Go spend time in the academic literature outside of computer science and you will find an endless sea of material with BS citations that don't substantiate the claim being made, entirely made up claims with no evidence, citations of retracted papers, nonsensical numbers etc. And that's when papers take months to write and have numerous coauthors, peer reviewers and editors involved (theoretically).
Now read some newspapers or magazines and it's the same except the citations are gone.
If an LLM can meet that same level of performance in a few seconds, it's objectively impressive unless you compare to a theoretical ideal.
But I do pay for quality journalism / news websites!
ie it's no longer a "source of truth"
Sometimes it's so ridiculous that a news site will report about some company and will not have a single link to the company page or will have a link that just points to another previous article about that company.
How fuxking insecure are you ??
On PC, it'll be Steam, GOG, maybe Humble. Then on consoles you have Xbox, Playstation and Nintendo. If you wanna put affiliate link, go for it. It's better than no link at all.
These articles already bait my click for ads by never putting the name of the game in the title anyways. At least let me get to the game and buy it.
A much better job for who? For you, or the firm running it?
A future where humans turn over all their thinking to machines, and, by proxy, to the people who own those machines is not one to celebrate.
Maybe.. not. LLMs may just flow where the money goes. Open AI has a deal with the FT, etc.
The AI platforms haven't touched any UI devolution at all because they're a hot commodity.
If they actually link to other websites and their sources - it's worth my time. If they don't - it's a honeypot.
I have the same peeve, but to give credit where it is due, I've happily noticed that Politico has lately been doing a good job of linking the actual decisions. I just checked for this story, and indeed the document you suggest is linked from the second paragraph: https://www.politico.com/news/2025/09/02/google-dodges-a-2-5...
Usually I would agree with you, however, the link is in the article hyperlinked under "Amit Mehta" in the 3rd paragraph. Now could the reporter have made that clearer...yes, but it's still there.
I’m only angry about this because I’ve been on ars since 2002, as a paid subscriber for most of that time, but I cancelled last year due to how much enshittification has begun to creep in. These popups remove any doubt about the decision at least.
(I cancelled because I bought a product they gave a positive review for, only to find out they had flat-out lied about its features, and it was painfully obvious in retrospect that the company paid Ars for a positive review. Or they’re so bad at their jobs they let clearly wrong information into their review… I’m not sure which is worse.)
It basically means I don’t use the web very much, but it’s probably better for me in the long run anyway, at least that’s how I see it.
I assume they and all the other big publications have SEO editors who’ve decided that they need to do it for the sake of their metrics. They understand that if they link to the PDF, everyone will just click the link and leave their site. They’re right about that. But it is annoying.
About a year ago when the NYTimes wrote an article called liked "Who really gets to declare if there is famine in Gaza?", the conclusions of the article were that "well boy it sure is complicated but Gaza is not officially in famine". I found the conclusion and wording suspect.
I went looking to see if they would like to the actual UN and World Food Program reports. The official conclusions were that significant portions of Gaza were already officially in famine, but that not all of Gaza was. The rest of Gaza was just one or two levels below famine, but those levels are called like "Food Emergency" or whatever.
Essentially those lower levels were what any lay person would probably call a famine, but the Times did not mention the other levels or that parts were in the famine level - just that "Gaza is not in famine".
To get to the actual report took 5 or 6 hard-to-find backlinks through other NYTimes articles. Each article loaded with further NYTimes links making it unlikely you'd ever find the real one.
The data sharing remedy and other remedies were not the judge's proposals. They were proposed by the parties.
The judge doesn't propose, he rules on what the parties propose, and that can be an iterative process in complex cases. E.g.. in this case, he has set some parameters in this ruling, and set a date by which the parties need to meet on the details within those parameters.
This is an editorial decision and not something individual reporters get to decide. Headlines are the same.
External links are bad for user retention/addiction.
This also has a side effect of back linking no longer being a measure of a 'good' website, so good quality content from inconsistently trafficked sites gets buried on search results.
Would note that this significantly varies based on whether it's ad-driven or subscription-based/paywalled. The former has no incentive to let you leave. The latter is trying to retain your business.
There is a link right there in 3rd paragraph: "U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta", though strangely under the name...
> I would rather be able to see the probably dozens of pages ruling with the full details rather than hear it secondhand from a reporter at this point.
There is no way you'd have time for that (and more importantly, your average reader), but if you do, the extra time it'd take you to find the link is ~0.0% of the total extra time needed to read the decision directly, so that's fine?
> with the full details
You don't have them in those dozens of pages, for example, the very basics of judge's ideological biases are not included.
Bafflingly, I’ve found this practice to continue even in places like University PR articles describing new papers. Linking to the paper itself is an obvious thing to do, yet many of them won’t even do that.
In addition to playing games to avoid outbound links, I think this practice comes from old journalistic ideals that the journalist is the communicator of the information and therefore including the source directly is not necessary. They want to be the center of the communication and want you to get the information through them.
That said, reporters have most probably nothing to do with what you’re decrying. Linking policies are not the reporter’s business. There are probably multiple layers of SEO “experts” and upper management deciding what goes on page and what not. Funnily enough, they might be super anal about what the story links, and then let Taboola link the worst shit on the Internet under each piece… So please, when you start your sentence with “reporters” please know that you’re criticizing something they have no power to change.
If anything, you should be helping to cut through the BS layers and insisting that the original source link (or, even just the full name of the court case) be included with your reporting.
Oh you sweet Summer child :-)
The worst is with criminal cases where they can't even be burdened to write what the actual charges are. It's just some vague 'crime' and the charges aren't even summarized - they're just ignored.
And the reporter would rather you hear it second hand from them :)
I agree, online "journalists" are absolutely terrible at linking to sources. You'll have articles which literally just cover a video (a filmed press conference, a YouTube video, whatever) that's freely available online and then fail to link to said video.
I don't know what they're teaching at journalistic ethics courses these days. "Provide sources where possible" sounds like it should be like rule 1, yet it never happens.
It seems such a simple step (they must have been using the ruling PDF to write the story) yet why is it always such a hassle for them to feel that they should link the original content? I would rather be able to see the probably dozens of pages ruling with the full details rather than hear it secondhand from a reporter at this point. It feels like they want to be the gatekeepers of information, and poor ones at that.
I think it should be adopted as standard journalistic practice in fact -- reporting on court rulings must come with the PDF.
Aside from that, it will be interesting to see on what grounds the judge decided that this particular data sharing remedy was the solution. Can anyone now simply claim they're a competitor and get access to Google's tons of data?
I am not too familiar with antitrust precedent, but to what extent does the judge rule on how specific the data sharing need to be (what types of data, for what time span, how anonymized, etc. etc.) or appoint a special master? Why is that up to the judge versus the FTC or whoever to propose?