Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by hollerith on Sunday June 01, 2025 @12:06PM
(#44151858)
The longest-range battery-powered drones have a range of only 14 km or so (and probably cannot carry enough explosive that far to help much with an attack like yesterday's attack) thus the need for the Ukrainians to use
trucks to transport the drones used in this attack to within a km or so of the
target. It is easy for Ukrainians to pass for Russian (e.g., if stopped at a
checkpoint inside Russia) because there were 3 million Ukrainians living
inside Russia at the start of the invasion in 2022. The same cannot be said for many future
conflicts. To give an example, the German regime got almost no useful information
coming from spies in England during WWII because it proved easy for British
society to detect and capture German spies. It probably would have proved equally difficult or almost as difficult and risky for the Germans to get a truck loaded with drones, explosives, drone operators and the electronics needed to control the drones to within a km of an English military target.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by justsomehnguy on Sunday June 01, 2025 @12:26PM
(#44152000)
> It is easy for Ukrainians to pass for Russian
There is no need to do so because they did employ a civilian drivers who never knew what 'cargo' they are hauling. Just like in the previous attack on the bridge.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by hollerith on Sunday June 01, 2025 @12:32PM
(#44152046)
I was assuming that the drone operators were in the truck to make it more difficult for the Russians to jam the control signals. Do you know whether that is true?
Maybe the drones were pre-programmed for a particular destination (given to the Ukrainians by the US and its reconnaissance satellites), i.e., no drone operators needed.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by mdhb on Sunday June 01, 2025 @05:40PM
(#44153939)
The latest technique is (besides the fiber optic stuff) is running the command and control over the local phone network of the country you’re in so it just looks like regular mobile data. That’s what allegedly happened here.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by maxgashkov on Sunday June 01, 2025 @07:26PM
(#44154531)
According to videos published they still seem to be flying drones manually, so won't additional latency introduced by the cellular network & repeaters make this really hard / impossible?
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by tonyarkles on Sunday June 01, 2025 @07:36PM
(#44154587)
I don’t have a link handy but one of the videos I saw on Twitter looked like there was pretty bad latency. Once they got to the target aircraft they went into a hover and very slowly set it down on the wing before the FPV feed froze.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by tonyarkles on Monday June 02, 2025 @07:42PM
(#44164581)
In most of the videos I've seen there are failsafe warnings on the screen indicating a loss of GPS, which I'm not surprised at all about. Russia's well-known for having GPS jammers, and having them on-site at an airforce base when the enemy they've been fighting is using drones is just common sense. The video I linked to really looks to me like it's being stick flown with IMU stabilization but probably without Pos Hold.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by hollerith on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:31AM
(#44166655)
Exploding on impact is a mature tech for things like shells, but it requires building a mechanism into the shell so that it won't explode before it is fired.
If the drone will be controlled by a human operator till the end, then it might win for the drone design to avoid the complexity of a sensor to detect impacts and of the aforementioned mechanism.
Also, landing on an airplane wing is easier to train for and to test than a mission plan that involves a drone that explodes on impact.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by Teever on Sunday June 01, 2025 @07:38PM
(#44154592)
Have you checked the latency on modern cell networks lately?
I had a friend who was gaming on his phone that was tethered to his desktop about a decade ago and after he disabled some power saving stuff in the settings on android he was getting a reasonable 100ms ping that had negligible jitter.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by at0mic22 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:24PM
(#44154854)
Starting July 1st all SIM cards in Russia need to have the owner register his biometry and passport details, otherwise the number is blocked.
Ukrainians had a window to perform this operation but I doubt they'll have the same approach possible in future.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by at0mic22 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:57PM
(#44155495)
Quite easy to track though, like double sign-ins from different devices, uncommon locations, location and speed matching - like phone going 25mph in the forest.
And you don't need to permablock it, few minutes would be enough.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by at0mic22 on Monday June 02, 2025 @12:43AM
(#44155871)
Oh it’s already implemented since 2000, with SORM system. Think they are to extend it to give direct FSB access without pre-request starting from 1st of september
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by hollerith on Monday June 02, 2025 @10:13PM
(#44165577)
An LLM explains that "SORM (System for Operative-Investigative Activities) is a Russian system of lawful interception used in telecommunications. SORM is mandated by Russian law, requiring all telecommunications providers to install interception equipment".
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by tpm on Monday June 02, 2025 @03:50AM
(#44156557)
No hack needed. You just give some change to poor people and register the cards in their name. This just raises the price a bit but does not prevent anything.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by mdhb on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:16PM
(#44172315)
I think that as far as a security measure this is really up there with the form the US makes you fill out when you visit the country that asks you to tick the box if you are a terrorist.
There are countless ways around this beginning with just asking someone to buy a sim card on your behalf.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by andix on Sunday June 01, 2025 @07:26PM
(#44154532)
Someone still needs to hire the driver and set up everything. Much easier for someone that can just blend in, looks like everyone else, speaks the language and doesn’t only know the culture well, but even grew up in a similar culture.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by ponector on Monday June 02, 2025 @06:32AM
(#44157409)
>> someone that can just blend in, looks like everyone else, speaks the language and doesn’t only know the culture well, but even grew up in a similar culture.
You've described half of the Ukrainian population.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by hagbard_c on Monday June 02, 2025 @04:32AM
(#44156771)
...which can barely get off the ground due to the power consumption of that 'NVidia chip' and gives off the heat signature of a jet-powered drone once it manages to get airborne.
Nah, you don't need an 'NVidia chip' for this purpose, a reasonably modern mobile phone will do and has all the sensors you want. Just add a battery, 4 motors with propellers and something (other than the battery) which goes boom and voilà, an autonomous drone. Some [1] mobile [2] phones [3] even have their own thing-that-goes-boom [4] built in from the factory to make this project even easier to accomplish.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by ClumsyPilot on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:06PM
(#44154758)
> It is easy for Ukrainians to pass for Russian
It would not be necessary, as you pointed out, plenty of Ukrainians still live in Russia and they are free to drive trucks. Best of my knowledge, there is nothing like interment of Japanese that happened in US during WW2.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by wltr on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @04:42AM
(#44167807)
As far as I’m aware, the USSR (read: Russia) forced everyone to know Russian, and not just know, but know only Russian and forget their own languages and culture. So, most of the populations once occupied by Russia, they can pretend they’re Russians quite easily, especially when they look European. Including former Polish territories. They had plenty of Russian occupation too.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by drysine on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @07:19AM
(#44168745)
You are mistaken. I don't blame you - it's a common narrative of Russophobic propaganda.
I'd suggest reading "The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939" by Terry Martin [0]
"The Soviet Union was the first of Europe's multiethnic states to confront the rising tide of nationalism by systematically promoting the national consciousness of its ethnic minorities and establishing for them many of the institutional forms characteristic of the modern nation-state. In the 1920s, the Bolshevik government, seeking to defuse nationalist sentiment, created tens of thousands of national territories. It trained new national leaders, established national languages, and financed the production of national-language cultural products.This was a massive and fascinating historical experiment in governing a multiethnic state."
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by wltr on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @08:20AM
(#44169180)
Am I? I was born under Russian occupation, before my parents migrated. I know all this very well, and much better than I’d want to. As much as I can fluently understand and speak Russian. As much as I can blend in, even despite the fact I haven’t been there for a very long time. Their culture didn’t change much for generations.
Everyone else reading this nonsense, go read Timothy Snyder’s Bloodlands, where he writes exactly that very time frame. You’d learn a lot of new things about the USSR and its attitude towards minorities.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by drysine on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @02:07PM
(#44172852)
I love how you have just ignored the reference to the book that contradicts your comment.
I've read and watched enough of Timothy Snyder to know that he's quite biased when talking about modern affairs, so no, I don't have Gell-Mann amnesia and don't feel like trusting him when he writes about history.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by wltr on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @02:20PM
(#44172995)
I mean. Are you seriously telling me I’m wrong and continue forcing this weird book upon me? Like yeah, my personal life experience as well as millions others make no sense, there’s a non forced upon me by some presumably not biased westplainer.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by wltr on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @05:57AM
(#44179012)
Half of Ukraine — the one closer to Russia — does not speak Ukrainian, mostly Russian. All of Belarus knows only Russian, mostly not knowing Belarusian. Latvia and Estonia have huge parts of their population who don’t speak local national languages, but speak only Russian.
I’m telling you to back off, I don’t like you and your attempts to diminish me and westplain me something you don’t know personally, basically spreading Russian propaganda how wonderful it was under Russian occupation during the Holodomor timeline. I wish you to get blocked on here sooner than later.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by drysine on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @09:03AM
(#44180320)
>Half of Ukraine — the one closer to Russia — does not speak Ukrainian, mostly Russian
This half?
"The name Novorossiya, which means "New Russia", entered official usage in 1764, after the Russian Empire conquered the Crimean Khanate, and annexed its territories, when Novorossiya Governorate (or Province) was founded. Official usage of the name ceased after 1917, when the entire area (minus Crimea) was annexed by the Ukrainian People's Republic, precursor of the Ukrainian SSR." [0]
Maybe because it used to be a part of Russia and was gifted to the Ukraine by Lenin, the evil bolshevik? Hmm...
>Latvia and Estonia have huge parts of their population who don’t speak local national languages, but speak only Russian.
Because they are children and grandchildren of Russians who migrated there after the WW2 and now are subjected to discrimination by local nationalistic government.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by workfromspace on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @10:49AM
(#44181289)
> who migrated there
Not "migrated", but ordered population transfer by Stalin [0]
> now are subjected to discrimination by local nationalistic government.
Please elaborate. As a resident I am not aware of any discrimination. (Unless you're talking about some of these Russians refusing to move back to Russia, refusing to learn the local, official language of their country and still wanting to have the citizenship of the country they are living in)
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by drysine on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @11:12AM
(#44181566)
>Russians refusing to move back to Russia
Back? Those Russians were born in that country and you suggest they must move to Russia because they are ethnic Russians? It's called ethnic cleansing.
>refusing to learn the local, official language
Do you realize that you are writing this in the thread where another commenter condemns the USSR for forcing everybody to learn Russian language?
>still wanting to have the citizenship of the country they are living in
That's how it works in the civilized countries - citizenship is gained by the birth right, not by the ethnicity of their parents.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by SergeAx on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @11:34PM
(#44176991)
I also was born in USSR, and can assure you that there were and are distinct accents in speech coming from European ex-Soviet republics, including Baltic states, Ukraine and Belarus. For native speakers it will sound different enough.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by wltr on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @03:21AM
(#44178033)
That depends individually. I can speak Russian accent both with Russian and English that nobody ever would recognise. Normally I have American accent, but I’m having ‘you think this is bad neighbourhood’ kinds of hires with friends very well made Russian accent.
I know many people like that either. I personally spent some time in Moscow, nobody ever knew I’m not a local. Same goes for a friend, we both were laughing at them being unable to recognise we’re not locals.
I believe this might be truer for small distant regions, where people might have their own local accent there. Plus not too many people to blend in that easily. But in general, even if one speaks differently, it might not take too long to adapt to speak like everyone else.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by wisty on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:09PM
(#44154780)
In WWII, a joint Australian / British force carried out an attack, posing as Japanese fishing boat, and sailed right into Singapore harbour to place explosives on the vessels there. They flew a Japanese ensign, wore sarongs and wore tan makeup. Operation Jaywick was not a huge strategic success (and the local population was subject to reprisals since the Japanese thought it was their fault) but it did raise morale a lot in allied forces, as it was an early blow against Japan (which had seemed invincible at the time).
Even in the extreme example of white Australians trying to pass as Malaysians, special forces have pulled of plenty of raids without the need for native language speakers.
Even if you need someone highly fluent who can pass as a native, most of the time there's a nearby country where they have some kind of grudge against the belligerent. Which potential theatre do you have in mind where finding an enemy of a belligerent who can pass as a "native" would be difficult? North / South Korea? China / Taiwan? The Middle East?
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by jacquesm on Monday June 02, 2025 @08:38PM
(#44164981)
> The longest-range battery-powered drones have a range of only 14 km or so (and probably cannot carry enough explosive that far to help much with an attack like yesterday's attack)
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by zzzeek on Sunday June 01, 2025 @03:14PM
(#44153105)
That was my intended joke to say the least
Interesting that they claim the attack was shared with the Trump admin ahead of time. That seems very unnecessarily risky as well considering where Trump's loyalties lie
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by rasz on Sunday June 01, 2025 @04:35PM
(#44153590)
I read Ukraine leaked attack details ahead of time, except it was supposed to be 2000 mile range heavy slow drones striking in the middle of the night. Russians "somehow" got this info and prepared waiting ready until the morning with all bombers fueled up ready to take off. Drones never showed up, morning came, national aviation holiday, pilots went to celebrate, 12:00pm drones take off from trailers.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by JumpCrisscross on Sunday June 01, 2025 @01:31PM
(#44152461)
> curious how they managed to control the drones from such a distance
The targets weren’t moving. As long as you have a cell connection in the trailer and up-to-date satellite imagery, you could send the coördinates and even flight path to the drones ahead of time and then have them deal with minor obstacles on their own.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by danogentili on Sunday June 01, 2025 @03:00PM
(#44153021)
Apparently they're using a simple 4g/3g/2g modem with Russian SIM, which is the reason why all russian ISPs completely turn off mobile internet (& voice) when drone launches are detected (clearly hasn't helped here as the drones were launched from trucks super close to the targets).
These launches specifically seem to have also used on-board AI targeting models trained on photos of the plane models to hit, I assume as a fallback in case mobile connection isn't available inside the bases (and photos on some Telegram channels seem to show usage of the FOSS autopilot system ArduPilot (https://ardupilot.org))
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by berndi on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:52PM
(#44155231)
Someone claimed they used fiber optic drones [1]. So perhaps the drones were connected to the trucks via optical fibers and the trucks carried the modems. That way, jamming over the airbases would have had no effect.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by MountainMan1312 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @11:39AM
(#44151674)
Weird, it only shows one drone coming out. Do they come out one at a time? When I think launching a drone swarm deep inside a country, I imagine the top blowing off and thousands of drones swarming out at once like insects.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by Zanfa on Sunday June 01, 2025 @01:06PM
(#44152289)
There’s at least one other video where you can see the drones flying out one after the other, with like 10 second delay. Launching one at a time needs fewer pilots and has no risk of collisions that might set off a chain reaction. They’re clearly not in a hurry since who’s going to go near a truck full of high explosive drones anyway.
its after the attack and drones gone. Those idiots were lucky, there is another video from a truck that malfunctioned and caught fire on side of the road. russian forces the door, enters and boom. Appeared booby trapped.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by stevenwoo on Sunday June 01, 2025 @02:35PM
(#44152853)
Anywhere, not just conflict zones. There was a decades long terror campaign against planned parenthood and other clinics in the USA and white supremacist nut jobs keep trying to start a race war every five to ten years with bombing and shooting sprees, the weekly school shooting in the USA, and there’s the using a vehicle worldwide for killing civilians by incels/fundamentalists of all stripes. This opens up a new venue for those inclined to act.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by afroboy on Sunday June 01, 2025 @04:19PM
(#44153505)
US is doing a lots of shit in Middle east right now and the new kids will grow to revenge, it will be interesting times since the drones doesn't costs much.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by suzzer99 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @07:45PM
(#44154642)
I'm not convinced that what the US does or doesn't do now will have any impact on Muslim extremists' desire for revenge against Israel, the US, and the West. That ship sailed a long time ago. They seem to be in permanent revenge mode.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by nothercastle on Sunday June 01, 2025 @04:35PM
(#44153586)
This is going to get nasty really fast until defensive technology catches up a lot of really expensive targets are very vulnerable.
That being said all you really need to do is install defensive netting at bases. You don’t even need hangers so relatively inexpensive retrofit.
That will probably cause drones to shift to dropped minions but at least those are less accurate.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by cosmicgadget on Sunday June 01, 2025 @03:01PM
(#44153027)
Absolutely, not trying to dump cold water on this remarkable feat of covert action. I just imagine there are a few support aircraft, fighters, non-op planes, helicopters, etc.
At the very end, you can even see how the bombers were hit: a drone strikes the right wing of a Tu-95, causing the internal fuel tanks to catch fire and spill burning fuel. The wing then breaks off and collapses.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by hshdhdhj4444 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:14PM
(#44154804)
Russia has been using these planes to bomb Ukrainian cities.
They also have a pattern of engaging in massive attacks right before major diplomatic events.
Russia and Ukraine have peace discussions scheduled for June 2 so Ukraine probably (and apparently correctly) anticipated Russia would be loading up for a bombing campaign the night before.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by morkalork on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:08PM
(#44154775)
Maintain a high level of readiness? At one point during the cold war, the US had B-52s not only fueled and ready to go but also airborne 24/7 (operation chrome dome).
Could also just be fuel vapors in the tanks going off too. Do bears have rigid tanks? In WW2 there was a big difference in survival between planes that did vs ones with bladders that collapsed as fuel was consumed.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by robocat on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:25PM
(#44154857)
If they were nuclear bombers, then an attack on nuclear deterrent infrastructure should really put the shits up the US (what if Russia mistook who was attacking?).
From another article (although maybe journalist is making shit up):
The attacks that went after the heart of Russia's strategic [bomber] capabilities and one arm of its nuclear deterrent should serve as a global wake-up call.
Also if they are part of Russia's strategic military assets, then wouldn't Russia wonder if the US was a secret puppetmaster?
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by myk9001 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:53PM
(#44155236)
They didn't mistake anything and aren't wondering about anything.
Here's a primer on how these things work in Russia.
You can be as careful as you want, if they decide they want confrontation with the US, they'll make up a reason.
If they don't feel confrontation is in their best interest, you can hit Moscow with a Tomahawk and, magically, no one will notice anything but a clapping sound.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by morkalork on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:14PM
(#44155061)
Tu-95 bears are indeed Russia's equivalent of a B-52 long range strategic bomber. You can see four of them burning in one video alone. A nuclear state losing one third of a leg in their nuclear triad in one morning to asymmetric warfare should put a fire under everyone's ass.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by pmfgpmfg on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:30PM
(#44155129)
Of course they will. russia, and russians disparage Ukrainians as a default. A success such as this will absolutely be blamed on “Western puppentmasters” rather than absolute mastery by Ukrainians. After all, the alcoholic descendants of a subservient Mongol enforcers couldn’t possibly have had their ass handed to them by Ukrainians. This is standard russian racism, beaten into them throughout the generations.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by rsynnott on Monday June 02, 2025 @09:12AM
(#44158493)
The “what if Putin’s delicate feelings are bruised” style of Russian propaganda is just increasingly absurd at this point, honestly. Ukraine cannot be expected to put up with these bombers hitting their cities on a rather flimsy theory that damaging the precious bombers might result in more Russian aggression.
In practice, Ukraine has significantly reduced Russia’s _capacity_ for such aggression with this move. Russia only has a limited number of working bombers, and they’re irreplaceable.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by at0mic22 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:19PM
(#44154831)
I find it more interesting seeing tires on the wings.
Would assume that drones do not drop cumulative ammo, but the shrapnel ones. Those tires in theory should have protected from smaller pieces flying around causing a mess of a damage.
Russian media reports of 2-4 planes being destroyed while others are damaged. Think this dumb cheap hack actually helped a lot in minimizing the effectiveness of the strike.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by dieortin on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:39PM
(#44154931)
They didn’t drop any ammo, the drones themselves exploded on top of the wings, making the plane catch fire. So if there were tires (I didn’t see any) they didn’t do much to protect the planes.
Also, I don’t know why you would consider the reports in russian media. There’s more than 4 planes being destroyed on video.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by at0mic22 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:50PM
(#44154974)
It does not really matter, as long as it is not cumulative, its spreading smaller particles around.
The proven historical rule of thumb is take ukrainian reports, take russian reports, and the truth is in the middle. You'd have to question your own sanity to trust numbers from either side blindfoldingly
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by rcxdude on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:14PM
(#44155322)
In the generous interpretation of 'middle'. Ukrainian reports tend to be a lot closer to the truth than Russian reports, but they do still have some bias (as in it's rare that things are better then Ukraine is making out).
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by at0mic22 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:25PM
(#44155376)
Ukraine is damn good at media war, although it has nothing to do with real life.
The real marker is immediate numbers. I bet even Russians yet to find out how many aircrafts have they irrecoverably lost, however we get numbers reported as if they are confirmed.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 02, 2025 @09:59AM
(#44158941)
> In the generous interpretation of 'middle'. Ukrainian reports tend to be a lot closer to the truth than Russian reports, but they do still have some bias
Sure. But the solution isn't to interpolate Russian and Ukraininan claims, as the former have been proven time and again to be complete fabrications. Instead, a good M.O. is to take Ukraininan claims with a grain of salt until corroborated by either open-source or third-party analysis.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by wltr on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @04:33AM
(#44167757)
More likely they cite some local city madmen who were spilling ‘Russia will fall within weeks’ narrative. Which is pretty harmful for Ukraine and their allies. However, when Russia will fall, it would be a quick and sudden, as with the USSR. They fake and fabricate everything, and huge chance they themselves might be unaware how bad things really are.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by wltr on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @03:34AM
(#44178122)
I rather meant real weirdos, mostly YouTube experts et al. But well, if the official had it said …
However, there’s this one weirdo who held official position (if I’m not mistaken) yet he was spilling similar nonsense for … well, he may still do that, I’m not aware. He’s this infamous Mr Arestovych, all I’m aware is him pushing Russian narratives these days and not holding any official position these days. I’ve heard him being even sanctioned for treason-like something, but I’m really not following him much to tell more.
That’s who came to my head first, as he’s quite infamous for this ‘Russia will fall within 2…3 weeks.’
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by at0mic22 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @07:00PM
(#44196447)
Yep, this guy also delivered this nonsense when working as a president advisor. Since then I am genuinely surprised when someone brings ukrainian official statements on the table. Like, really guys?
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by DonHopkins on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:07PM
(#44155296)
Russian reports are so reliably untrustworthy that your pathetic "both sides" argument is nothing but spectacularly insincere Russian shilling, 100% bullshit, not even a half truth.
Ukraine doesn't have to fabricate about how Russia is killing its innocent civilians, or how Russia drove a Buk surface-to-air missile across their border and shot down a plane full of innocent civilians, which Russia 100% flat out denied. There is no "truth in the middle" there.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by drysine on Monday June 02, 2025 @03:30AM
(#44156471)
As opposed to Ukrainian reports like this?
"Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky denied on Wednesday that his government had been involved in the explosion on the Crimean Bridge separating the Crimean Peninsula, which Russia invaded and annexed in 2014, from mainland Russia.
“We definitely did not order that, as far as I know,” Zelensky said during an interview with Canada’s CTV television network. " [0]
>how Russia is killing its innocent civilians
What does Kiev regime says about how Ukraine is killing innocent Russian civilians? Like blowing a bridge exactly when a passenger train was passing under it leading to deaths of civilians including children? [1]
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by tim333 on Monday June 02, 2025 @04:32AM
(#44156763)
Yeah but if Russia invades a peaceful country killing thousands for no good reason apart from extending their empire and the then the the country tries to defend itself by hitting Russian bridges with the odd casualty those things are not really equivalent.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by drysine on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @07:49AM
(#44168950)
Bryansk oblast is not the war zone. And even in the war zone intentional murder of civilians is a war crime. Unless it's done by Kiev regime, of course.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by wltr on Monday June 02, 2025 @12:46PM
(#44160696)
It always amuses me that some people truly believe Russian reports and then they are like ‘shrug, I don’t know, Russia said none of the planes were damaged, so we cannot trust Ukraine on reporting they destroyed at least 40,’ even when there are literally high quality videos of the planes being destroyed. I myself saw a weird DW video this morning, where some woman were spilling similar nonsense with the Russian accent she tried to cover.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by andrewflnr on Sunday June 01, 2025 @11:28PM
(#44155611)
Last I heard the tires are there to break up the visual signature of the planes, to throw off autonomous visual targeting. It doesn't seem to work great.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by comrade1234 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:19PM
(#44155078)
Imagine this scenario... Ukraine tells USA that they're launching long-range drone attacks on Russian strategic bomber bases. USA tells Russia through back-channels. Russia preps bombers to fly if the long-range attacks are launched. Ukraine launches short-range attacks too fast for the bombers to escape.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by 3eb7988a1663 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:41PM
(#44155440)
You mean when there were hostile drones in the sky? Fire suppression takes a back seat when risking your life for some aircraft is going to do nothing to change the immediate engagement.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by 3eb7988a1663 on Monday June 02, 2025 @08:07PM
(#44164772)
Who said anything about hiding? When enemy forces are attacking, first priority is repelling the attack. Stopping the active drones and/or defending against potential follow-up infantry crews.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by SkyPuncher on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:14PM
(#44155323)
My understanding is the bases targeted are far away from the front lines. They keep the large, strategic aircraft here because (1) they out of range of conventional missile/drone attacks (2) they still have the range to make the trip to the front and back (3) these aircraft are largely launching missiles that fly hundreds of miles (so they don't actually need to be too close to the front). The smaller aircraft tend to be closer to the front.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by dragonwriter on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:15PM
(#44155327)
> Would it be reasonable to assume some of the damaged aircraft are not bombers?
Probably not many if any, they weren't attacked with area munitions but with FPV drones they were attacking bomber bases, specifically aiming to reduce offensive capability, there's not a lot of reason to target non-bomber other aircraft.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by PedroBatista on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:47PM
(#44155462)
It would, but these were FPVs and their targets can be precisely chosen at the very moment of the strike.
Also, these are remote airbases where all the strategic bombers are stationed. Fighter jets would not be there in significant numbers if any since they are needed in other bases closer to the front-lines and also some at the borders.
In in of the videos you could see a Mi-8 which was ignored because of it's insignificance compared to the primary targets.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by thrill on Sunday June 01, 2025 @08:27PM
(#44154874)
It may have been even more effective than that if the intel supported specific target selection. Russia is likely already having a difficult time keeping their fleet operational, and if Ukraine was able to select aircraft that had recently flown then it's likely to have left mostly the non-flyable aircraft, causing Russia that much more difficulty to employ them.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by Sammi on Monday June 02, 2025 @06:43PM
(#44164033)
Ukrainian intel have said that they were seeing Russia prepare for a large aviation bombing attack. So all the best bombers were out on the tarmac getting fueled when they attacked. Maximum pain. Russia didn't just loose a third of their strategic bombers, they lost their best third. The other lesser two thirds will now have to handle the wear and tear going forward. And these planes are already old and torn and require a lot of upkeep.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by gloosx on Monday June 02, 2025 @02:05AM
(#44156159)
The planes were relocated and loaded with fuel and munitions for a massive raid which would've have happen that morning. They were able to hit fuel tanks specifically as they had few museum pieces to train on for the whole year.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by gloosx on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @03:55AM
(#44167535)
You also probably don't know that Putin really likes cool dates. 1st of June is not a random date, it is a Military Aviation Day in Russia, and they wanted to celebrate by bringing their heaviest bombers to a massive WWII Dresden-style raid before the "peace talks" to show their power and leverage. It was a pretty obvious move and on the 3rd year of ongoing war they got so careless they just exposed 30% of their strategic bombers fully loaded, standing still in the open and visible on every sat imagery for the sake of showing off.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by MilnerRoute on Sunday June 01, 2025 @02:37PM
(#44152862)
CNN says the drones "were targeting aircraft that bomb Ukrainian cities every night, the Ukrainian Security Service said – estimating the damage caused to the Russian side at more than $2 billion."
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by nradov on Sunday June 01, 2025 @07:19PM
(#44154497)
Sure, there are radars that effective for picking up small targets at short range. The C-RAM point defense system has detected and destroyed incoming mortar rounds. It's very expensive.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by jandrewrogers on Sunday June 01, 2025 @07:54PM
(#44154709)
This already exists as relatively mature military technology in vehicle active protection systems. Trophy[0] is a well-known example. The latency from detection to reaction is measured in milliseconds.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by greedo on Sunday June 01, 2025 @11:52PM
(#44155712)
It already exists on the ground for armored vehicles, but is useless for protecting aircraft on the ground. The last thing you want around thin-skinned aircraft is something that explodes!
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by andrewflnr on Sunday June 01, 2025 @11:56PM
(#44155730)
To be clear, around the perimeter of the base. But also, you do realize these planes are members of a large class that exist entirely to be near things that explode?
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by greedo on Monday June 02, 2025 @12:15AM
(#44155791)
Ummm, bombers have no desire to be around things that explode. They want to drop their bombs/missiles, and then get out of Dodge as quick as possible. The munitions on the ground are (at least on Western air bases) housed in very well protected vaults.
Airplanes are so relatively fragile, that it's common for airbases and aircraft carriers to conduct FOD walks to make sure their runways are free of small pieces of metal debris that could be ingested by their engines. It doesn't take a lot to put an airplane out of commission.
These aren't A-10s with titanium bathtubs protecting their pilots. They're large, slow, aluminum skinned craft that have limited maneuverability, and are the quintessential "bomb trucks" for Russia.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by greedo on Monday June 02, 2025 @09:50AM
(#44158848)
My argument is that countering this threat is non-trivial, there are no existing systems in the US that address this threat, and that simplistic solutions should be evaluated on their merits. It's far too easy to hand wave away the complexities of the drone threat.
For example, say we deploy an Arena/Trophy type system around an airbase? What are the ROE for its use? Do we keep it operating 24/7 or only when the threat level seems high enough? Most airbases in the US have small security detachments, and they have ROE that tell them not to blow up semi trucks that might have stalled on a road near the fence. So how do they counter an attack like Ukraine just pulled off?
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by jandrewrogers on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:11PM
(#44155306)
Irrelevant to the question, which was if military radar existed that could detect and track small objects at relatively short-range. The technology is modular and in fact fast enough to detect and engage supersonic threats. The military could wire up any response they wish to a detected threat (and they have). It doesn’t literally have to be the Trophy system. That serves as an existence proof and is a well-known example of such tech.
The engineers that design these things seem to have more imagination than their critics.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by greedo on Sunday June 01, 2025 @11:57PM
(#44155737)
APS systems like Trophy aren't anything special. And radar already exists that can track and target drones down to FPV size. Most AD radars are tuned to ignore birds and small objects that aren't moving in a consistent speed and direction. So it's not a matter of solving a detection/tracking problem, but instead a matter of enough effectors to take down a swarm.
Covering an airbase will be expensive, and there's the problem of false positives; say you deploy 4 Skynex systems around an air base. Drones attack, you down them but the fratricide ends up damaging aircraft anyways. C-RAM has been around protecting bases in the Middle East for years, and those 30mm rounds have to land somewhere...
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by jandrewrogers on Monday June 02, 2025 @02:23AM
(#44156217)
Again, you are missing the point. The technical capability exists, you are arguing the details. Obsessing over APS isn’t materially contributing to your argument. The technology isn’t constrained by your examples. We are not talking about traditional AD radars. Trying to make it about AD radars is disingenuous.
You are pretending that things that have proven solutions don’t actually have solutions.
I’m not saying the current set of solutions implementations is perfect but you are not making a credible argument that they don’t exist. Local battle-space sensing is very fast and very effective as a matter of record, at least in the US arsenal. That tech may not exist in the Ukraine/Russia theater but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by greedo on Monday June 02, 2025 @09:45AM
(#44158796)
Pretty sure that I'm not the one who brought up Trophy systems?
Yes the technology exists to mitigate some of the risk. It's not deployed currently, and is very expensive. There are significant limitations to these systems, and most haven't seen combat.
You're trivializing a complex problem by pointing out that it's technically feasible, when it's more than just "we have the technology."
Show me a "proven system" in the US arsenal that can protect a large airbase from this type of attack. Not similar technology that the DoD has talked about converting to address this threat, but purchased, deployed systems.
Re:Ukraine destroys more than 40 military aircraft in drone ...
by mrguyorama on Monday June 02, 2025 @04:11PM
(#44162541)
>C-RAM has been around protecting bases in the Middle East for years, and those 30mm rounds have to land somewhere...
Actually no, the CRAM based Phalanx systems use self-detonating ammo. They explode after their tracer runs out. The Naval versions use kinetic penetration rounds with tungsten cores and do not self detonate.
There is no need to do so because they did employ a civilian drivers who never knew what 'cargo' they are hauling. Just like in the previous attack on the bridge.
Maybe the drones were pre-programmed for a particular destination (given to the Ukrainians by the US and its reconnaissance satellites), i.e., no drone operators needed.
They either used the trucks as a relay for the operators far away or the drones themselves were automated.
If the drone will be controlled by a human operator till the end, then it might win for the drone design to avoid the complexity of a sensor to detect impacts and of the aforementioned mechanism.
Also, landing on an airplane wing is easier to train for and to test than a mission plan that involves a drone that explodes on impact.
...and more importantly it is also easier to automate, i.e. autoland on wing spar, detonate, mission complete.
I had a friend who was gaming on his phone that was tethered to his desktop about a decade ago and after he disabled some power saving stuff in the settings on android he was getting a reasonable 100ms ping that had negligible jitter.
And you don't need to permablock it, few minutes would be enough.
It does not help a lot with end-to-end encryption though
There are countless ways around this beginning with just asking someone to buy a sim card on your behalf.
You've described half of the Ukrainian population.
Nah, you don't need an 'NVidia chip' for this purpose, a reasonably modern mobile phone will do and has all the sensors you want. Just add a battery, 4 motors with propellers and something (other than the battery) which goes boom and voilà, an autonomous drone. Some [1] mobile [2] phones [3] even have their own thing-that-goes-boom [4] built in from the factory to make this project even easier to accomplish.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XcoU2mXJJ3k
[2] https://discussions.apple.com/thread/252212685
[3] https://www.thesun.co.uk/tech/6281000/iphone-explosion-video...
[4] https://discussions.apple.com/thread/250125537
It would not be necessary, as you pointed out, plenty of Ukrainians still live in Russia and they are free to drive trucks. Best of my knowledge, there is nothing like interment of Japanese that happened in US during WW2.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_America...
I'd suggest reading "The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939" by Terry Martin [0]
"The Soviet Union was the first of Europe's multiethnic states to confront the rising tide of nationalism by systematically promoting the national consciousness of its ethnic minorities and establishing for them many of the institutional forms characteristic of the modern nation-state. In the 1920s, the Bolshevik government, seeking to defuse nationalist sentiment, created tens of thousands of national territories. It trained new national leaders, established national languages, and financed the production of national-language cultural products.This was a massive and fascinating historical experiment in governing a multiethnic state."
[0] https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.7591/97815017...
Everyone else reading this nonsense, go read Timothy Snyder’s Bloodlands, where he writes exactly that very time frame. You’d learn a lot of new things about the USSR and its attitude towards minorities.
I've read and watched enough of Timothy Snyder to know that he's quite biased when talking about modern affairs, so no, I don't have Gell-Mann amnesia and don't feel like trusting him when he writes about history.
I’m telling you to back off, I don’t like you and your attempts to diminish me and westplain me something you don’t know personally, basically spreading Russian propaganda how wonderful it was under Russian occupation during the Holodomor timeline. I wish you to get blocked on here sooner than later.
This half?
"The name Novorossiya, which means "New Russia", entered official usage in 1764, after the Russian Empire conquered the Crimean Khanate, and annexed its territories, when Novorossiya Governorate (or Province) was founded. Official usage of the name ceased after 1917, when the entire area (minus Crimea) was annexed by the Ukrainian People's Republic, precursor of the Ukrainian SSR." [0]
Maybe because it used to be a part of Russia and was gifted to the Ukraine by Lenin, the evil bolshevik? Hmm...
>Latvia and Estonia have huge parts of their population who don’t speak local national languages, but speak only Russian.
Because they are children and grandchildren of Russians who migrated there after the WW2 and now are subjected to discrimination by local nationalistic government.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novorossiya
Not "migrated", but ordered population transfer by Stalin [0]
> now are subjected to discrimination by local nationalistic government.
Please elaborate. As a resident I am not aware of any discrimination. (Unless you're talking about some of these Russians refusing to move back to Russia, refusing to learn the local, official language of their country and still wanting to have the citizenship of the country they are living in)
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_transfer_in_the_Sov...
I sus you are another putin-troll.
Back? Those Russians were born in that country and you suggest they must move to Russia because they are ethnic Russians? It's called ethnic cleansing.
>refusing to learn the local, official language
Do you realize that you are writing this in the thread where another commenter condemns the USSR for forcing everybody to learn Russian language?
>still wanting to have the citizenship of the country they are living in
That's how it works in the civilized countries - citizenship is gained by the birth right, not by the ethnicity of their parents.
I don't have to respond further to obvious propagandists.
You, on the other hand, are justifying ethnic cleansing when it is committed in the 21st century by supposedly liberal democratic government.
I know many people like that either. I personally spent some time in Moscow, nobody ever knew I’m not a local. Same goes for a friend, we both were laughing at them being unable to recognise we’re not locals.
I believe this might be truer for small distant regions, where people might have their own local accent there. Plus not too many people to blend in that easily. But in general, even if one speaks differently, it might not take too long to adapt to speak like everyone else.
Even in the extreme example of white Australians trying to pass as Malaysians, special forces have pulled of plenty of raids without the need for native language speakers.
Even if you need someone highly fluent who can pass as a native, most of the time there's a nearby country where they have some kind of grudge against the belligerent. Which potential theatre do you have in mind where finding an enemy of a belligerent who can pass as a "native" would be difficult? North / South Korea? China / Taiwan? The Middle East?
As a Ukrainian soldier – ha ha ha
You are completely, utterly clueless.
I'll bet Russia is curious too.
Starlink is a joke here but "satellites" in general are not
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starshield
Interesting that they claim the attack was shared with the Trump admin ahead of time. That seems very unnecessarily risky as well considering where Trump's loyalties lie
The targets weren’t moving. As long as you have a cell connection in the trailer and up-to-date satellite imagery, you could send the coördinates and even flight path to the drones ahead of time and then have them deal with minor obstacles on their own.
Camera locking on to a parked plane, should be fairly easy to do the job.
These launches specifically seem to have also used on-board AI targeting models trained on photos of the plane models to hit, I assume as a fallback in case mobile connection isn't available inside the bases (and photos on some Telegram channels seem to show usage of the FOSS autopilot system ArduPilot (https://ardupilot.org))
[1] https://nitter.net/bayraktar_1love/status/192915556386414634...
https://x.com/ChrisO_wiki/status/1929166249348476968
video of the self-destruct: https://bsky.app/profile/militarynewsua.bsky.social/post/3lq...
https://nitter.poast.org/Osinttechnical/status/1929149970566...
its after the attack and drones gone. Those idiots were lucky, there is another video from a truck that malfunctioned and caught fire on side of the road. russian forces the door, enters and boom. Appeared booby trapped.
well current actions certainly aren't helping
That being said all you really need to do is install defensive netting at bases. You don’t even need hangers so relatively inexpensive retrofit. That will probably cause drones to shift to dropped minions but at least those are less accurate.
[1] https://www.wdmma.org/russian-air-force.php
At the very end, you can even see how the bombers were hit: a drone strikes the right wing of a Tu-95, causing the internal fuel tanks to catch fire and spill burning fuel. The wing then breaks off and collapses.
Why were they loaded with fuel?
They also have a pattern of engaging in massive attacks right before major diplomatic events.
Russia and Ukraine have peace discussions scheduled for June 2 so Ukraine probably (and apparently correctly) anticipated Russia would be loading up for a bombing campaign the night before.
Could also just be fuel vapors in the tanks going off too. Do bears have rigid tanks? In WW2 there was a big difference in survival between planes that did vs ones with bladders that collapsed as fuel was consumed.
From another article (although maybe journalist is making shit up):
Also if they are part of Russia's strategic military assets, then wouldn't Russia wonder if the US was a secret puppetmaster?Here's a primer on how these things work in Russia.
You can be as careful as you want, if they decide they want confrontation with the US, they'll make up a reason.
If they don't feel confrontation is in their best interest, you can hit Moscow with a Tomahawk and, magically, no one will notice anything but a clapping sound.
That is true, but they also perceive interests that can result in confrontations, for very real reasons.
No, it's almost as if Ukraine has a good reason to blow up the planes that airstrike them.
They were nuclear-capable bombers that have regularly been used to attack Ukraine with conventional weapons (mostly cruise missiles.)
> Also if they are part of Russia's strategic military assets, then wouldn't Russia wonder if the US was a secret puppetmaster?
Increasing distrust between Putin and the Trump Administration would also be a coup for Ukraine, but, no, I don't think that's a real threat here.
Sounds racist to me. Are you banderovets[0]?
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banderite
In practice, Ukraine has significantly reduced Russia’s _capacity_ for such aggression with this move. Russia only has a limited number of working bombers, and they’re irreplaceable.
Would assume that drones do not drop cumulative ammo, but the shrapnel ones. Those tires in theory should have protected from smaller pieces flying around causing a mess of a damage.
Russian media reports of 2-4 planes being destroyed while others are damaged. Think this dumb cheap hack actually helped a lot in minimizing the effectiveness of the strike.
Also, I don’t know why you would consider the reports in russian media. There’s more than 4 planes being destroyed on video.
The proven historical rule of thumb is take ukrainian reports, take russian reports, and the truth is in the middle. You'd have to question your own sanity to trust numbers from either side blindfoldingly
No it isn't. Russia's reports are complete fabrications.
The real marker is immediate numbers. I bet even Russians yet to find out how many aircrafts have they irrecoverably lost, however we get numbers reported as if they are confirmed.
Cheap
Sure. But the solution isn't to interpolate Russian and Ukraininan claims, as the former have been proven time and again to be complete fabrications. Instead, a good M.O. is to take Ukraininan claims with a grain of salt until corroborated by either open-source or third-party analysis.
Source? (Kyiv was agitating for Western aid in 2022. It would be odd for them to be downplaying the threat.)
[1] https://www-pravda-com-ua.translate.goog/articles/2022/12/19...
However, there’s this one weirdo who held official position (if I’m not mistaken) yet he was spilling similar nonsense for … well, he may still do that, I’m not aware. He’s this infamous Mr Arestovych, all I’m aware is him pushing Russian narratives these days and not holding any official position these days. I’ve heard him being even sanctioned for treason-like something, but I’m really not following him much to tell more.
That’s who came to my head first, as he’s quite infamous for this ‘Russia will fall within 2…3 weeks.’
Ukraine doesn't have to fabricate about how Russia is killing its innocent civilians, or how Russia drove a Buk surface-to-air missile across their border and shot down a plane full of innocent civilians, which Russia 100% flat out denied. There is no "truth in the middle" there.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_17
"Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky denied on Wednesday that his government had been involved in the explosion on the Crimean Bridge separating the Crimean Peninsula, which Russia invaded and annexed in 2014, from mainland Russia.
“We definitely did not order that, as far as I know,” Zelensky said during an interview with Canada’s CTV television network. " [0]
>how Russia is killing its innocent civilians
What does Kiev regime says about how Ukraine is killing innocent Russian civilians? Like blowing a bridge exactly when a passenger train was passing under it leading to deaths of civilians including children? [1]
[0] https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/why-did-zelensky-deny...
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/jun/01/deaths-as-russ...
Arrogance. My Diamond Star stays fuelled. But I’m not committing imbecilic war crimes.
I suspect the definition of front line has changed with drones.
kinda risky to be anywhere around them due to secondary explosion risk
Probably not many if any, they weren't attacked with area munitions but with FPV drones they were attacking bomber bases, specifically aiming to reduce offensive capability, there's not a lot of reason to target non-bomber other aircraft.
Also, these are remote airbases where all the strategic bombers are stationed. Fighter jets would not be there in significant numbers if any since they are needed in other bases closer to the front-lines and also some at the borders.
In in of the videos you could see a Mi-8 which was ignored because of it's insignificance compared to the primary targets.
https://www.cnn.com/2025/06/01/europe/ukraine-drones-russia-...
Or is conventional radar so noisy / limited that close range and object size is a real problem?
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trophy_(countermeasure)
Airplanes are so relatively fragile, that it's common for airbases and aircraft carriers to conduct FOD walks to make sure their runways are free of small pieces of metal debris that could be ingested by their engines. It doesn't take a lot to put an airplane out of commission.
These aren't A-10s with titanium bathtubs protecting their pilots. They're large, slow, aluminum skinned craft that have limited maneuverability, and are the quintessential "bomb trucks" for Russia.
For example, say we deploy an Arena/Trophy type system around an airbase? What are the ROE for its use? Do we keep it operating 24/7 or only when the threat level seems high enough? Most airbases in the US have small security detachments, and they have ROE that tell them not to blow up semi trucks that might have stalled on a road near the fence. So how do they counter an attack like Ukraine just pulled off?
The engineers that design these things seem to have more imagination than their critics.
Covering an airbase will be expensive, and there's the problem of false positives; say you deploy 4 Skynex systems around an air base. Drones attack, you down them but the fratricide ends up damaging aircraft anyways. C-RAM has been around protecting bases in the Middle East for years, and those 30mm rounds have to land somewhere...
You are pretending that things that have proven solutions don’t actually have solutions.
I’m not saying the current set of solutions implementations is perfect but you are not making a credible argument that they don’t exist. Local battle-space sensing is very fast and very effective as a matter of record, at least in the US arsenal. That tech may not exist in the Ukraine/Russia theater but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist.
Yes the technology exists to mitigate some of the risk. It's not deployed currently, and is very expensive. There are significant limitations to these systems, and most haven't seen combat.
You're trivializing a complex problem by pointing out that it's technically feasible, when it's more than just "we have the technology."
Show me a "proven system" in the US arsenal that can protect a large airbase from this type of attack. Not similar technology that the DoD has talked about converting to address this threat, but purchased, deployed systems.
Actually no, the CRAM based Phalanx systems use self-detonating ammo. They explode after their tracer runs out. The Naval versions use kinetic penetration rounds with tungsten cores and do not self detonate.
Also they are 20mm
Ukraine destroys small plane drones and loitering munition with drones with the help of radar guidance.
Also I’ve heard about the case when training on an FPV drone and accidentally leaving designated area in the city triggered an air raid alert.