These things are not actually useful. They hyper optimzed it for coding usecase but it still sucks balls at it.
cost isn't the limiting factor in this though. 'even larger' models arn't 'more capable' . where did you get that from?
The US has been so used to being number one that not being number one equates to “collapse”.
No the US Will NOT collapse. They just won’t be number one in economic/military/technological might. Similar to how many countries like the UK, Japan, and more have not existed as the number one economic super power.
Give it another generation and if China will not walk off the ledge with either government or societal issues (which, granted, is where they are slowly going IMO) they will own the UX and design as well. My 2c.
Given that the US has been number one for a really long time now it doesn’t sit well with a lot of the patriotic identity people have about the US. People either can’t accept reality or the make up some excuse about unfair economic practices.
The last thing they want to admit is that China is more competent or more superior.
Previously I always thought democracy was a slow but eventually correct system of producing wisdom. And to a degree there’s been truth to this. However the missing ingredient has been what do we do with that success once we’ve had it.
The west would never have the guts to delete a billion dollar industry even if they realized it was a net negative. We simply don’t know how to guard against our passions, pleasures, and handle success in a responsible way. I think cccp has many flaws but taking bold action against this kind of problem isn’t one of them.
I do hope that I’m wrong about this though and that a democratic system can see its way out of a local maximum built upon an unsustainable way of doing things. I think the belief in the market as some kind of oracle that knows value and price is its language has a lot to do with this track we’re on.
But let's not pretend China is perfect. The purge had much more to do with a) eliminating a potential competing power to the CCCP, and b) Xi's boomer-era gut instinct that new media forms are bad.
Eliminating businesses competing with state power sounds like something that we too should have done when we still could.
It's not a better grasp on philosophy. It's a logistical issue. A centralized government can wipe this out because control is centralized. In a democracy the control is spread out among people who understand, people who don't understand and among people who have business interest in said topic.
Think about it this way. The very people responsible for the unicorn social media companies in a democracy have a say in whether or not there own companies can be wiped out. If they're rich they can influence the game even more with advertising and propaganda. They influence the outcome and thus self interest actually pollutes the decision making process in a democracy.
It's not about guts. It's literally that in a democracy even the conflicting business interests can stop the right thing from happening because of they are self interested in the bad thing to happen. It is a logistical issue. When business interests influence government then government decisions favor business interests. It's that simple. And right now since businesses are more centralized and have more power then individuals then the government actually favors big corporations. That's the eventual outcome of most capitalist societies.
In a dictatorship, the dictator is usually well removed from such things and thus can make decisions very impartially and with no resistance. But like an evil dictator can do stuff like behead your entire family if you talk shit about him. Good sides and bad sides. The problem is you live in a democracy so everyone talks about how shitty the alternative is because of bias. The reality is democracy and dictatorship are simply two sides of a coin.
Organically, sure. If a company has an opportunity to build higher value components profitably it would likely take it. But that is slow.
What I mean is state pouring massive amounts of money, every year for many years, into as-is unprofitable areas to build not just the products but education, infrastructure and support needed for the local companies to become competitive.
WSJ had a good article in the last few days on China's containership building which AFACR said the government poured over 10 billion at the time to become the world's shipbuilder. This is the time of effort I am talking about and, as far as I know, it is fairly new.
You can’t buy back entire supply chains and a workforce, it takes generations.
So really nothing will change, Americans will keep thinking they're number one and life will go on as usual.
Google. Facebook.
Global reach.
Oh yeah Mac OS. Global reach. iOS global reach. Android global reach.
Minecraft global reach. I know Minecraft was from Sweden but since Microsoft bought it Europe can’t take credit for it.
Time to start learning Chinese.
So to compete on software West might encounter unexpected difficulties. You need good platform docs to develop good software.
Probably not a problem for big companies.
在中文和任何拉丁-德语语言之间进行转换是机器翻译仍然难以完成的任务;我不知道为什么,但它比英语-西班牙语或英语-C 等语言的转换要困难得多。
I come here because I value what people here think and want to read their thoughts and share mine.
Pasting AI output like this devalues the conversation and is uninteresting.
I bet the Chinese AI will tell you the "chinese point of view" just like the one from USA tells the US one.
Also who knows what was censored or added there.
Is censorship a thing for models? Of course. Does it matter? Probably not, unless you either specifically have chats on those specific topics, or if you are trying to create a meme.
The concern of censorship is way overblown by some people. Most users only care about "does it work?", then some "is the answer correct?", and at the bottom is "is the answer censored, and according to what ideology?". Seriously, think about these models/products like a normal person.
- WIPO copyright exemption
- Anti-China protectionist measures
- Hard-line hardware export control
- Multi-billion dollar government contracts
Require open source / open weights of any company that used data to it doesn't own to train its models. If chinese companies do not comply, their copyright becomes void in the US, and these models are very easy to copy. Treat advances in architecture as a utility, and let the utilization of those architectures be the market for companies to compete in.
Working around how?
Edit: Facebook torrented 81.7TB of books.
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2025/02/meta-torrented-o...
[1] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/openai-whistleblower-who...
Why should people involved in some hyped company deserve all this "socialism for the rich" from the state?
/s ... but... maybe not?
Wherever you sit on the political spectrum the fact that this idea will almost certainly be seriously discussed in the coming months should be concerning to you.
Even if casual usage happens with employees which is questionable already, the real money would be from corporate adoption which is highly unlikely even from a European country, the risks are too high for data leaks.
This is the paradox in those who are championing barring Chinese students from the US to prevent them from stealing IP, they don't see that at least 50% of this IP is generated by students from China, in a way they will be handing the CCP a gift by incentivising those students to remain in China.
Source? I noticed your post leaves out various other countries that have high representation in US universities.
All AI models are built on the back of massive amounts of "IP stealing". Either we consider IP to be valid and then all western companies in this space are just as bad, or we go with the direction the western companies are claiming and then China is not doing anything wrong.
except that they are not
“he brought British textile technology to the United States, modifying it for American use. He memorized the textile factory machinery designs as an apprentice to a pioneer in the British industry before migrating to the U.S. at the age of 21.”
the European themselves bringing this industry to the US
I believe that is what is being referenced.
Not sure that matters anymore in the new world order.
Frontier tokens are largely fungible now. The details of how they came about doesn't make them any less useful.
Dismissing Chinese tech is foolish. They are tech leaders in many areas and moving to new ones every day. Solar, Nuclear, Batteries, EVs, Drones, Robotics etc. They have no one to copy in those fields because they have left the rest of the world behind.
First of all, it’s really sad to see people saying it doesn’t matter the journey of how one achieves success, and all that matters is your current state.
Brushing the CCPs countless acts of IP theft under the rug is like saying it doesn’t matter that the Trump family committed financial fraud for decades. All that matters is that they’ve managed to become billionaires today. Would the Trump family be anywhere near as wealthy if they hadn’t cheated for so long? Would China be much further behind than they are now if the CCP hadn’t stolen so much IP? I see multiple people here implying those questions are irrelevant, which I absolutely disagree with. Ignoring all that history is a huge injustice to everyone else who didn’t resort to that kind of behavior.
I also want to be clear I’m not trying to make some ridiculous claim that Chinese individuals have been working independently to hack and steal IP. It’s their government and that same government is to blame for the many people like me who really look down on them despite what they’ve ultimately been able to achieve. They undoubtedly have huge numbers of brilliant citizens. When I make comments about China’s shameful history of tech IP theft, I’m talking about their government.
I know there's some about of corporate espionage where trade secrets got exfilled, but what makes you so certain the majority of Chinese success is from stolen IP, as if electrical engineering grad students can't figure out how to make solar panels from first principals?
something something software patents
Is economy a zero sum game now? Isn't economic development supposed to be a good thing? Can the West only exist in a world of poverty and underdevelopment?
It's not just the Chinese who are lacking the acknowledgment of these contributions.
It is strange and inappropriate to call that observation racist.
We can discuss the reasons why they might or might not open source things, or we can agree not to because someone might call us racist for discussing corporate and wcenomic motivations.
The West mostly has not shared their knowledge. Most software is not open source.
I am simply assuming that China follows the same principle - try to wring maximum advantage out of their industrial might and commoditize their complement wherever possible. Because of China's unique single party system, their strategies are very top-down coming straight from the CCP in key areas like AI and robotics. It is not racism, simply realpolitik.
Generally, I’ve found that almost no founders or friends I speak with have any vision for the future anymore. They care only about making money and do not care how. It’s a spectacular collapse of vision and purpose—these people have always existed but it feels incredibly pervasive now.
With that, I realize your comment is much broader than AI so below is too domain specific but…
VC has been investing in AI as-if it were a winner takes all market, but it has been obvious that isn’t the case.
Not only that, but the massive amount of cash thrown to anyone with even marginal credentials has undermined the constraints that often lead to innovation.
There is 0 reason that Safe Superintelligence should be raising for the second time at a 30 B valuation with no product.
I really don't see how this was supposed to go, and I've never heard an explanation.
I don't see any kind of coherent vision from any of these types.
Most normal folks (i.e not SV/HN types that seem to desire to replace their marketable programming skills with LLM output) really don't "want" LLMs in any real sense.
Sure, people use them like a search engine, kids cheat on homework with them etc, but there's not this overwhelming universal desire for them like there was for, say iPhones.
I never once have heard any sort of proposed roadmap for how LLMs were supposed to work as a product.
They were just going to get, uh "really good" and take everyone's office job or something?*
Normal F500 organizations that are obviously a target for LLM use (via hyperscaler sales) are still yet to see a clear path to "revolutionizing" their workforce or whatever via LLMs-it's just not there. Costs are too high, there's no obvious use case, "hallucinations" are a real impediment etc.
I'll add many of the public usecases for this (i.e those a hyperscaler would blog about as a sales promo) are seriously weak ("we reduced onboarding time by 20% with $MODEL")
I would really like to hear a proposal for how this is all supposed to come together. Does anyone have a concrete plan for the future for all this stuff?
*I'll note, this is NOT the way to sell a product to the masses, either.
Addendum: I'm not an "LLM hater" by any means. I pay for GH Copilot, and have been running local LLMs since it's been a thing (granted with limited hardware, and limited quality)--I intend to wait a bit and buy better hardware with one motivating factor being running local LLMs in a year or so when the open-source offerings stabilize"
This is one of the most finest and most accurate things that I have read in a long time.
This really could be a blog post which I encourage you to make! (I would prefer github pages but if you really want , I have a domain name on cloudflare and I am more than willing to host the static page of such blog on my own domain name for absolutely free (lets go , cloudflare!)
Its just facts. Pure facts. "" Generally, I’ve found that almost no founders or friends I speak with have any vision for the future anymore. They care only about making money and do not care how. It’s a spectacular collapse of vision and purpose—these people have always existed but it feels incredibly pervasive now. ""
Why did I read it in a monotonous way as if a student from the future understands the current scenario. I felt as if it was the same level of sadness in my heart as that when you listen to some video which has raining background and he reads the dark comedy (something like burialgoods oats shitposting but this time more serious and real!)
Currently saving this on wayback machine just for this comment. Internet needs to preserve this comment , no matter what.
May archive never go down!
There’s a lot of opportunity to make low cost software that out competes big tech just because it doesn’t demand 10000x returns on every if statement.
I’d encourage Europeans to start replacing American software vendors with small teams today. You won’t become the next American oligarch but you’ll be able to clean up millions from the incompetent Americans.
I think in general there is a feeling that the time to get your bag is rapidly shrinking.
Once everything is built by these things there will be no reason to create anything as the platform owners (big tech) will be able to take everything for themselves and no longer have to share 70% with those pesky creators/small business/startups etc.
Now I feel like everything is more top-down. The tech sector feels less like market capitalism and more like something being centrally planned: we all must chase trends that come from various industry thought-leaders. And it all must be done a very specific way (this in particular is why Chinese companies are likely going to disrupt the AI market: they’re free from this burden)
I think you're witnessing it rather getting back in touch with reality than collapsing. Multi-trillion out of jsx generator was too much from the beginning. You folks just don't know what to do with too much money you have.
Sometimes reality acts more weird than fiction itself. I have just now decided to call this "fictional reality"
Like yesterday when I realized that nuclear bombs weren't that far away from the creation of chemical resonance & they happened after world war I and I think , just really 5-6 years before nuclear bombs but still!
It actually gave me a lot of hope because I felt that a lot of people were focusing on AI , so I can use AI (sometimes , if I want) to focus on a passion project that I want , to maybe earn some money.
I have also thought of creating AI projects but that too for fun. I don't know two shits but I just want to know what the hype is about from a theoretical standpoint.
You're witnessing the USA tech scene getting in back to reality. Software engineers in other western countries looked at the salaries the Tech scene was paying in the USA, and scratched their heads.
They have massive amounts of low cost labor and, unfortunately, the US has pretty large walls up preventing mass in-migration of white collar workers.
H1B is capped and also more of a lottery than a points based system.
If the US allowed mass white collar immigration, wages would decline materially which would make our industries more competitive for the next generation of software.
Right now the system is geared around protectionism (intended or not) and wage inflation for US local workers.
The current market wages in software are far far above what a global equilibrium would be. Though myself and I'm sure most others here have benefited from it in the short term.
To be clear, established companies with an existing market are fine for now and can do well with high wages.
But the next generation of companies that are chasing smaller markets and margins, ones that require more elbow grease to out-compete are underserved.
e.g. the entire DeepSeek team was paid less than a few Meta engineers (with 7 figure comp each)
"The firm offers 14-month pay for various positions and the highest offer is for deep learning researchers for artificial general intelligence (AGI), with a monthly salary between 80,000 yuan ($10,983) and 110,000 yuan, which could mean an annual income of up to 1.54 million yuan, the report said."
This is just like everything in China. They will find ways to drive down cost to below anyone previously imagined, subsidised or not. And even just competing among themselves with DeepSeek vs ERNIE and Open sourcing them meant there is very little to no space for most.
Both DRAM and NAND industry for Samsung / Micron may soon be gone, I thought this was going to happen sooner but it seems finally happening. GPU and CPU Designs are already in the pipelines with RISC-V, IMG and ARM-China. OLED is catching up, LCD is already taken over. Batteries we know. The only thing left is foundries.
Huawei may release its own Open Source PC OS soon. We are slowly but surely witnessing the collapse of Western Tech scene.