News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by cheschire on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:52AM (#43378289)
Hardware tech, to be specific. Plenty of room left in software services still. The east can compete on price but user experience is incomparable.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ptero on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:15AM (#43378419)
So far. China has been focused on becoming a world's factory for 30 years. They started moving up the food chain fairly recently.

Give it another generation and if China will not walk off the ledge with either government or societal issues (which, granted, is where they are slowly going IMO) they will own the UX and design as well. My 2c.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ninetyninenine on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:19AM (#43378435)
They’ve been moving up the food chain for 30 years. The only difference is recently that upward movement has begun to surpass the US.

Given that the US has been number one for a really long time now it doesn’t sit well with a lot of the patriotic identity people have about the US. People either can’t accept reality or the make up some excuse about unfair economic practices.

The last thing they want to admit is that China is more competent or more superior.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by asimpletune on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:47AM (#43378608)
The moment I realized this was going to be the truth was when the Chinese government essentially purged a bunch of unicorn social media companies overnight, erasing billions of wealth on paper. It seemed like the motive was to value and encourage actual economic value over worshipping whatever makes the line go up. When I saw they had the guts and wisdom to do that I realized that they may have a better grasp on philosophy.

Previously I always thought democracy was a slow but eventually correct system of producing wisdom. And to a degree there’s been truth to this. However the missing ingredient has been what do we do with that success once we’ve had it.

The west would never have the guts to delete a billion dollar industry even if they realized it was a net negative. We simply don’t know how to guard against our passions, pleasures, and handle success in a responsible way. I think cccp has many flaws but taking bold action against this kind of problem isn’t one of them.

I do hope that I’m wrong about this though and that a democratic system can see its way out of a local maximum built upon an unsustainable way of doing things. I think the belief in the market as some kind of oracle that knows value and price is its language has a lot to do with this track we’re on.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ProjectArcturis on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:31AM (#43379810)
I agree with your comments about the West. The fact that we continue to expand legal gambling is evidence enough that we don't care about the negative consequences of an industry.

But let's not pretend China is perfect. The purge had much more to do with a) eliminating a potential competing power to the CCCP, and b) Xi's boomer-era gut instinct that new media forms are bad.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by jampekka on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:53AM (#43379983)
> a) eliminating a potential competing power to the CCCP

Eliminating businesses competing with state power sounds like something that we too should have done when we still could.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by asimpletune on Sunday March 16, 2025 @12:19PM (#43380162)
Yeah, good points. Definitely not my intention to say China's perfect, and I'm probably reading too much into the wisdom of this vs. good ol' preservation of power.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by viraptor on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:57AM (#43378672)
Which social media companies have been removed? They still have large clear leaders at the moment.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by selimthegrim on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:32AM (#43378940)
Jack Ma’s
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ninetyninenine on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:08PM (#43384189)
>When I saw they had the guts and wisdom to do that I realized that they may have a better grasp on philosophy.

It's not a better grasp on philosophy. It's a logistical issue. A centralized government can wipe this out because control is centralized. In a democracy the control is spread out among people who understand, people who don't understand and among people who have business interest in said topic.

Think about it this way. The very people responsible for the unicorn social media companies in a democracy have a say in whether or not there own companies can be wiped out. If they're rich they can influence the game even more with advertising and propaganda. They influence the outcome and thus self interest actually pollutes the decision making process in a democracy.

It's not about guts. It's literally that in a democracy even the conflicting business interests can stop the right thing from happening because of they are self interested in the bad thing to happen. It is a logistical issue. When business interests influence government then government decisions favor business interests. It's that simple. And right now since businesses are more centralized and have more power then individuals then the government actually favors big corporations. That's the eventual outcome of most capitalist societies.

In a dictatorship, the dictator is usually well removed from such things and thus can make decisions very impartially and with no resistance. But like an evil dictator can do stuff like behead your entire family if you talk shit about him. Good sides and bad sides. The problem is you live in a democracy so everyone talks about how shitty the alternative is because of bias. The reality is democracy and dictatorship are simply two sides of a coin.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ptero on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:30AM (#43378501)
> They’ve been moving up the food chain for 30 years.

Organically, sure. If a company has an opportunity to build higher value components profitably it would likely take it. But that is slow.

What I mean is state pouring massive amounts of money, every year for many years, into as-is unprofitable areas to build not just the products but education, infrastructure and support needed for the local companies to become competitive.

WSJ had a good article in the last few days on China's containership building which AFACR said the government poured over 10 billion at the time to become the world's shipbuilder. This is the time of effort I am talking about and, as far as I know, it is fairly new.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ricardobeat on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:39AM (#43378558)
$10B is a drop in the ocean. If all it took was a bit of money the US could have stayed ahead. For perspective, they’ve earmarked $800B for clean energy subsidies, that AI fund is $500B.

You can’t buy back entire supply chains and a workforce, it takes generations.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ptero on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:03AM (#43379167)
It was 10B 20 years ago when China was significantly poorer. And it is not just money. It is planning, oversight and various care and feeding activities (china-style, including executing officials for corruption) for almost 10 years before that part of the system became mature and economically self-supporting.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by otabdeveloper4 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:19AM (#43378839)
The USA hasn't been number one in anything for decades.

So really nothing will change, Americans will keep thinking they're number one and life will go on as usual.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by pupppet on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:07AM (#43379189)
USA is number one in believing they are number one.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ninetyninenine on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:15PM (#43384234)
The US is still number one I making software and space. Though I doubt we have much longer to hold onto this.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by otabdeveloper4 on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:53AM (#43388016)
The only US-made software with global reach is Microsoft Windows, and I doubt that thing can be considered "number one".
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ninetyninenine on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:06AM (#43389349)
Software nowadays is cloud based.

Google. Facebook.

Global reach.

Oh yeah Mac OS. Global reach. iOS global reach. Android global reach.

Minecraft global reach. I know Minecraft was from Sweden but since Microsoft bought it Europe can’t take credit for it.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by WiSaGaN on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:02AM (#43378338)
What user experience are you talking about? Chatbot? Or software in general? Cause Tiktok beats Facebook out of water. Chatbot for English communities sure, I also prefer Claude over Deepseek in terms of project support and UI. But this is because they are focusing on Chinese communities, Doubao has much better features that is used by Chinese. It's not really comparable even if all US chatbots were accessible in China. Once LLM tech slows, I am sure Chinese chatbots would beat the American ones in terms of user experience.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by jampekka on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:56AM (#43378307)
A lot of consumer tech with very competitive UX is coming out of China. They are also getting very strongly into e.g. web frontend tech. I see no reason why the west would have any special advantage in this.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by csomar on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:01AM (#43378331)
They are ahead of Europe (at least in car UX) but quite behind of the US. This is the last stronghold that the US has but given the recent layoffs and transition toward "AI everything", I am not sure if the US tech industry will survive this too.

Time to start learning Chinese.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by uhhhhhhh on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:07AM (#43378369)
I would rate Europe over US by far for car UX. My north American vehicles universally have the worst interfaces. My European Cars typically the best and Japanese/others in between.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by Hikikomori on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:10AM (#43378385)
What US car UX is ahead of Europe?
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by numpad0 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:02AM (#43378710)
I assume you have Tesla center screen and CarPlay/Android Auto in mind, but those aren't that highly regarded outside the US...
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ninetyninenine on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:16AM (#43378425)
Software is more trivial than hardware. That’s why you see bootcamps for software but not for hardware. China can easily eclipse the US on the software front. And they have.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by vbezhenar on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:01AM (#43378334)
Chinese hardware docs are very scarce if you don't know mandarin and don't have Chinese connections.

So to compete on software West might encounter unexpected difficulties. You need good platform docs to develop good software.

Probably not a problem for big companies.

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by yoz-y on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:32AM (#43378516)
That feels like something AI could solve.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ben_w on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:05AM (#43378729)
Last time I did this, someone who knew the language described the attemped Chinese in dispagaging terms:

在中文和任何拉丁-德语语言之间进行转换是机器翻译仍然难以完成的任务;我不知道为什么,但它比英语-西班牙语或英语-C 等语言的转换要困难得多。

Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by selimthegrim on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:33AM (#43378954)
What are C languages?
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ben_w on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:04AM (#43379172)
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by makeitshine on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:18AM (#43379251)
In the above Chinese this doesn't really make sense.
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by ben_w on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:39AM (#43379863)
Thus demonstrating the point I was making with (and demonstrated by) the "attemped Chinese": machine translation isn't good enough yet. (This Chinese is from Google Translate).
Re:GPT 4.5 level for 1% of the price by makeitshine on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:17AM (#43379248)
It's shorthand for something or it's a typo. It doesn't make sense otherwise.