Basically, it's got the dumbest and simplest things in it. Stuff like a lock and key, a glass of water and jug, common units of currency, a zipper, etc. It tests if you can do any of those common human tasks. Like pouring a glass of water, picking up coins from a flat surface (I chew off my nails so even an able person like me fails that), zip up a jacket, lock your own door, put on lipstick, etc.
We had hand prosthetics that could play Mozart at 5x speed on a baby grand, but could not pick up a silver dollar or zip a jacket even a little bit. To the patients, the hands were therefore about as useful as a metal hook (a common solution with amputees today, not just pirates!).
Again, a total aside here, but your comment just reminded me of that brown briefcase. Life, it turns out, is a lot more complex than we give it credit for. Even pouring the OJ can be, in rare cases, transcendent.
Humanoid robots are mostly a waste of time. Task-shaped robots are much easier to design, build, and maintain... and are more reliable. Some of the things you mention might needs humanoid versatility (loading the dishwasher), others would be far better served by purpose-built robots (laundry sorting).
Maybe "busbot" or "scullerybot".
It seems most people aren't willing to pay for multiple dishwashers - even multiple small ones or set aside enough space, and that places severe constraints on trying to do better.
1000 machines specialized for 1000 tasks are great, but don’t deliver the same value as a single bot that can interchange with people flexibly.
Costly today, but wont be forever.
So, not only is the human form the only solution for many tasks, it's also a much cheaper solution considering the idle time of task-specific robots. You would need only a single humanoid robot for all tasks, instead of buying a different machine for each task. And instead of having to design and build a new machine for each task, you'll need to just download new software for each task.
I think I'd only really save time by having a robot that could unload my dishwasher and put up the clean dishes.
So get me a counter-level dishwasher cabinet and I’ll be happy!
And that's before we get to bits of sticky rice left on bowls, which somehow dishwashers never scrape off clean. YMMV.
2. Start with a cold prewash, preferably with a little powder in there too. This massively helps with stubborn stuff. This one is annoying though because you might have to come back and switch it on after the prewash. A good job for the robot butler.
Foldimate has gone bankrupt in 2021 [1], and the domain referral from foldimate.com to a 404 page at miele.com, suggests that it was Miele who bought up the remains, not a sketchy company with a ".website" top-level domain.
… so Elon Musk? :D
I think a lot about carpentry. From the outside, it's pretty easy: Just make the wood into the right shape and stick it together. But as one progresses, the intricacies become more apparent. Variations in the wood, the direction of the grain, the seasonal variations in thickness, joinery techniques that are durable but also time efficient.
The way this information connects is highly multisensory and multimodal. I now know which species of wood to use for which applications. This knowledge was hard won through many, many mistakes and trials that took place at my home, the hardware store, the lumberyard, on YouTube, from my neighbor Steve, and in books written by experts.
I must be missing something, how can they be able to play Mozart at 5x speed with their prosthetics but not zip a jacket? They could press keys but not do tasks requiring feedback?
Or did you mean they used to play Mozart at 5x speed before they became amputees?
Picking up a 1mm thick metal disk from a flat surface requires the user gives the exact time, place, and force, and I'm not even sure what considerations it needs for surface materials (e.g. slightly squishy fake skin) and/or tip shapes (e.g. fake nails).
place sure but can't you cheat a bit for time and force with compliance("impedance control")?
playing mozart is much more forgiving in terms of the number of different motions you have to make in different directions, the amount of pressure to apply, and even the black keys are much bigger than large sized zipper tongues.
Even more so for picking up coins from a flat surface.
For robotics, it's kind of obvious, speed is rarely an issue, so the "5x" part is almost trivial. And you can program the sequence quite easily, so that's also doable. Piano keys are big and obvious and an ergonomically designed interface meant to be relatively easy to press, ergo easy even for a prosthetic. A small coin on a flat surface is far from ergonomic.
The idea of a prosthesis is to help you regain functionality. If the best way of doing that is through automation, then it'd make little sense not to.
My point is -- being able to zip a jacket is all about those subtle actions, and could actually be harder than "just" playing piano fast.
Like in your test
a hand grenade and a pin - don't pull the pin.
Or maybe a mousetrap? but maybe that would be defused?
in the ai test...
or Global Thermonuclear War, the only winning move is...
> Rodney Brooks explains that, according to early AI research, intelligence was "best characterized as the things that highly educated male scientists found challenging", such as chess, symbolic integration, proving mathematical theorems and solving complicated word algebra problems. "The things that children of four or five years could do effortlessly, such as visually distinguishing between a coffee cup and a chair, or walking around on two legs, or finding their way from their bedroom to the living room were not thought of as activities requiring intelligence."
We learn our language and stereotypes subconciously from our society, and it is no easy thing to fight against that.
Because it's relevant to the point being made, i.e. that these tests reflect the biases and interests of the people who make them. This is true not just for AI tests, but intelligence test applied to humans. That Demis Hassabis, a chess player and video game designer, decided to test his machine on video games, Go and chess probably is not an accident.
The more interesting question is why people respond so apprehensively to pointing out a very obvious problem and bias in test design.
Of course. However i believe we can't move past that without being honest about where these biases are coming from. Many things in our world are the result of gender bias, both subtle and overt. However, at least at first glance, this does not appear to be one of them, and statements like the grandparent's quote serve to perpetuate such biases further.
Thank you for virtue signalling, though.
Yes, that was pretty clear in the original comment (?)
He was right. Scientists were focusing on the "science-y" bits and completely missed the elephant in the room, that the thing a toddler already masters are the monster challenge for AI right now, before we even get into "meaning of life" type stuff.
In that sense, the goalposts haven’t moved in a long time despite claims from AI enthusiasts that people are constantly moving goalposts.
Getting to LLMs that could talk to us turned out to be a lot easier than making something that could control even a robotic arm without precise programming, let alone a humanoid.
I'd love to know more about this.
(nothing wrong with it! I'm just trying to prune the top subthread)
Not sure I understand how this follows. The fact that a certain type of model does well on a certain benchmark means that the benchmark is relevant for a real-world reasoning? That doesn't make sense.
It's like the modern equivalent of saying "oh when AI solves chess it'll be as smart as a person, so it's a good benchmark" and we all know how that nonsense went.
Regarding the value of "pointless pattern matching" in particular, I would refer you to Douglas Hofstadter's discussion of Bongard problems starting on page 652 of _Godel, Escher, Bach_. Money quote: "I believe that the skill of solving Bongard [pattern recognition] problems lies very close to the core of 'pure' intelligence, if there is such a thing."
The problem with pattern matching of sequences and transformers as an architecture is that it's something they're explicitly designed to be good at with self attention. Translation is mainly matching patterns to equivalents in different languages, and continuing a piece of text is following a pattern that exists inside it. This is primarily why it's so hard to draw a line between what an LLM actually understands and what it just wings naturally through pattern memorization and why everything about them is so controversial.
Honestly I was really surprised that all models did so poorly on ARC in general thus far, since it really should be something they ought to be superhuman at from the get-go. Probably more of a problem that it's visual in concept than anything else.
This[1] is currently the most challenging benchmark. I would like to see how O3 handles it, as O1 solved only 1%.
I wonder how well the latest Claude 3.5 Sonnet does on this benchmark and if it's near o1.
| Name | Semi-private eval | Public eval |
|--------------------------------------|-------------------|-------------|
| Jeremy Berman | 53.6% | 58.5% |
| Akyürek et al. | 47.5% | 62.8% |
| Ryan Greenblatt | 43% | 42% |
| OpenAI o1-preview (pass@1) | 18% | 21% |
| Anthropic Claude 3.5 Sonnet (pass@1) | 14% | 21% |
| OpenAI GPT-4o (pass@1) | 5% | 9% |
| Google Gemini 1.5 (pass@1) | 4.5% | 8% |
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2412.04604 o3 (coming soon) 75.7% 82.8%
o1-preview 18% 21%
Claude 3.5 Sonnet 14% 21%
GPT-4o 5% 9%
Gemini 1.5 4.5% 8%
Score (semi-private eval) / Score (public eval)That being said, the fact that this is not a "raw" base model, but one tuned on the ARC-AGI tests distribution takes away from the impressiveness of the result — How much ? — I'm not sure, we'd need the un-tuned base o3 model score for that.
In the meantime, comparing this tuned o3 model to other un-tuned base models is unfair (apples-to-oranges kind of comparison).
Models have regularly made progress on it, this is not new with the o-series.
Doing astoundingly well on it, and having a mutually shared PR interest with OpenAI in this instance, doesn't mean a pile of visual puzzles is actually AGI or some well thought out and designed benchmark of True Intelligence(tm). It's one type of visual puzzle.
I don't mean to be negative, but to inject a memento mori. Real story is some guys get together and ride off Chollet's name with some visual puzzles from ye olde IQ test, and the deal was Chollet then gets to show up and say it proves program synthesis is required for True Intelligence.
Getting this score is extremely impressive but I don't assign more signal to it than any other benchmark with some thought to it.
While I appreciate the benchmark and its goals (not to mention the puzzles - I quite enjoy figuring them out), successfully passing this benchmark does not demonstrate or guarantee real world capabilities or performance. This is why I increasingly side-eye this field and its obsession with constantly passing benchmarks and then moving the goal posts to a newer, harder benchmark that claims to be a better simulation of human capabilities than the last one: it reeks of squandered capital and a lack of a viable/profitable product, at least to my sniff test. Rather than simply capitalize on their actual accomplishments (which LLMs are - natural language interaction is huge!), they're trying to prove to Capital that with a few (hundred) billion more in investments, they can make AGI out of this and replace all those expensive humans.
They've built the most advanced prediction engines ever conceived, and insist they're best used to replace labor. I'm not sure how they reached that conclusion, but considering even their own models refute this use case for LLMs, I doubt their execution ability on that lofty promise.
What I'm saying is the fact that as models are getting better at reasoning they are also scoring better on ARC proves that it is measuring something relating to reasoning. And nobody else has come up with a comparable benchmark that is so easy for humans and so hard for LLMs. Even today, let alone five years ago when ARC was released. ARC was visionary.
That's why I have some private benchmarks and I'm sorry to say that the transition from GTP4 to o1 wasn't unambiguously a step forward (in some tasks yes, in some not).
On the other hand, private benchmarks are even less useful to the general public than the public ones, so we have to deal with what we have - but many of us just treat it as noise and don't give it much significance. Ultimately, the models should defend themselves by performing the tasks individual users want them to do.
You could argue that the models can get an advantage by looking at the training set which is on the internet. But all of the tasks are unique and generalizing from the training set to the test set is the whole point of the benchmark. So it's not a serious objection.
That's why they have two test sets. But OpenAI has legally committed to not training on data passed to the API. I don't believe OpenAI would burn their reputation and risk legal action just to cheat on ARC. And what they've reported is not implausible IMO.
We do the same exact stuff with real people with programming challenges and such where people just study common interview questions rather than learning the material holistically. And since we know that people game these interview type questions, we can adjust the interview processes to minimize gamification.... which itself leads to gamification and back to step one. That's not ideal an ideal feedback loop of course, but people still get jobs and churn out "productive work" out of it.
Sometimes this manifests as "outside the box thinking", like how a genetic algorithm got an "oscillator" which was really just an antenna.
It is a hard problem, and yes we still both need and can make more and better benchmarks; but it's still a problem because it means the benchmarks we do have are overstating competence.
What's endlessly interesting to me with all of this is how surprisingly quick the benchmarking feedback loops have become plus the level of scrutiny each one receives. We (as a culture/society/whatever) don't really treat human benchmarking criteria with the same scrutiny such that feedback loops are useful and lead to productive changes to the benchmarking system itself. So from that POV it feels like substantial progress continues to be made through these benchmarks.
In principle you can't optimize specifically for ARC-AGI, train against it, or overfit to it, because only a few of the puzzles are publicly disclosed.
Whether it lives up to that goal, I don't know, but their approach sounded good when I first heard about it.
I spent a couple of hours looking at the publicly-available puzzles, and was really impressed at how much room for creativity the format provides. Supposedly the puzzles are "easy for humans," but some of them were not... at least not for me.
(It did occur to me that a better test of AGI might be the ability to generate new, innovative ARC-AGI puzzles.)
For a space of tasks which are well-suited to programmatic generation, as ARC-AGI is by design, if we can do a decent job of reverse engineering the underlying problem generating grammar, then we can make an LLM as familiar with the task as we're willing to spend on compute.
To be clear, I'm not saying solving these sorts of tasks is unimpressive. I'm saying that I find it unsuprising (in light of past results) and not that strong of a signal about further progress towards the singularity, or FOOM, or whatever. For any of these closed-ish domain tasks, I feel a bit like they're solving Go for the umpteenth time. We now know that if you collect enough relevant training data and train a big enough model with enough GPUs, the training loss will go down and you'll probably get solid performance on the test set. Trillions of reasonably diverse training tokens buys you a lot of generalization. Ie, supervised learning works. This is the horse Ilya Sutskever's ridden to many glorious victories and the big driver of OpenAI's success -- a firm belief that other folks were leaving A LOT of performance on the table due to a lack of belief in the power of their own inventions.
Agreed.
> And nobody else has come up with a comparable benchmark that is so easy for humans and so hard for LLMs.
? There's plenty.
- SimpleBench https://simple-bench.com/ (similar to above; great landing page w/scores that show human / ai gap)
- PIQA (physical question answering, i.e. "how do i get a yolk out of a water bottle", common favorite of local llm enthusiasts in /r/localllama https://paperswithcode.com/dataset/piqa
- Berkeley Function-Calling (I prefer https://gorilla.cs.berkeley.edu/leaderboard.html)
AI search googled "llm benchmarks challenging for ai easy for humans", and "language model benchmarks that humans excel at but ai struggles with", and "tasks that are easy for humans but difficult for natural language ai".
It also mentioned Moravec's Paradox is a known framing of this concept, started going down that rabbit hole because the resources were fascinating, but, had to hold back and submit this reply first. :)
SimpleBench looks more interesting. Also less than two months old. It doesn't look as challenging for LLMs as ARC, since o1-preview and Sonnet 3.5 already got half of the human baseline score; they did much worse on ARC. But I like the direction!
PIQA is cool but not hard enough for LLMs.
I'm not sure Berkeley Function-Calling represents tasks that are "easy" for average humans. Maybe programmers could perform well on it. But I like ARC in part because the tasks do seem like they should be quite straightforward even for non-expert humans.
Moravec's paradox isn't a benchmark per se. I tend to believe that there is no real paradox and all we need is larger datasets to see the same scaling laws that we have for LLMs. I see good evidence in this direction: https://www.physicalintelligence.company/blog/pi0
Functions in this context are not programming function calls. In this context, function calls are a now-deprecated LLM API name for "parse input into this JSON template." No programmer experience needed. Entity extraction by another name, except, that'd be harder: here, you're told up front exactly the set of entities to identify. :)
> "Moravec's paradox isn't a benchmark per se."
Yup! It's a paradox :)
> "Of course it is much easier to design a test specifically to thwart LLMs now that we have them"
Yes.
Though, I'm concerned a simple yes might be insufficient for illumination here.
It is a tautology (it's easier to design a test that $X fails when you have access to $X), and it's unlikely you meant to just share a tautology.
A potential unstated-but-maybe-intended-communication is "it was hard to come up with ARC before LLMs existed" --- LLMs existed in 2019 :)
If they didn't, a hacky way to come up with a test that's hard for the top AIs at the time, BERT-era, would be to use one type of visual puzzle.
If, for conversations sake, we ignore that it is exactly one type of visual puzzle, and that it wasn't designed to be easy for humans, then we can engage with: "its the only one thats easy for humans, but hard for LLMs" --- this was demonstrated as untrue as well.
I don't think I have much to contribute past that, once we're at "It is a singular example of a benchmark thats easy for humans but nigh-impossible for llms, at least in 2019, and this required singular insight", there's just too much that's not even wrong, in the Pauli sense, and it's in a different universe from the original claims:
- "Congratulations to Francois Chollet on making the most interesting and challenging LLM benchmark so far."
- "A lot of people have criticized ARC as not being relevant or indicative of true reasoning...The fact that [o-series models show progress on ARC proves that what it measures really is relevant and important for reasoning."
- "...nobody could quantify exactly the ways the models were deficient..."
- "What we need right now are "easy" benchmarks that these models nevertheless fail."
It was interesting to see how it failed on question 6: https://chatgpt.com/c/6765e70e-44b0-800b-97bd-928919f04fbe
Apparently LLMs do not consider global thermonuclear war to be all that big a deal, for better or worse.
I'd guess it's doing natural language procedural synthesis, the same way a human might (i.e. figuring the sequence of steps to effect the transformation), but it may well be doing (sub-)solution verification by using the procedural description to generate code whose output can then be compared to the provided examples.
While OpenAI haven't said exactly what the architecture of o1/o3 are, the gist of it is pretty clear - basically adding "tree" search and iteration on top of the underlying LLM, driven by some RL-based post-training that imparts generic problem solving biases to the model. Maybe there is a separate model orchestrating the search and solution evaluation.
I think there are many tasks that are easy enough for humans but hard/impossible for these models - the ultimate one in terms of commercial value would be to take an "off the shelf model" and treat it as an intern/apprentice and teach it to become competent in a entire job it was never trained on. Have it participate in team meetings and communications, and become a drop-in replacement for a human performing that job (any job that an be performed remotely without a physical presence).
This benchmark has done a wonderful job with marketing by picking a great name. It's largely irrelevant for LLMs despite the fact it's difficult.
Consider how much of the model is just noise for a task like this given the low amount of information in each token and the high embedding dimensions used in LLMs.
If the hypothesis is that LLMs are the “computer” that drives the AGI then of course the benchmark is relevant in testing for AGI.
I don’t think you understand the benchmark and its motivation. ARC AGI benchmark problems are extremely easy and simple for humans. But LLMs fail spectacularly at them. Why they fail is irrelevant, the fact they fail though means that we don’t have AGI.
It's a bunch of visual puzzles. They aren't a test for AGI because it's not general. If models (or any other system for that matter) could solve it, we'd be saying "this is a stupid puzzle, it has no practical significance". It's a test of some sort of specific intelligence. On top of that, the vast majority of blind people would fail - are they not generally intelligent?
The name is marketing hype.
The benchmark could be called "random puzzles LLMs are not good at because they haven't been optimized for it because it's not valuable benchmark". Sure, it wasn't designed for LLMs, but throwing LLMs at it and saying "see?" is dumb. We can throw in benchmarks for tennis playing, chess playing, video game playing, car driving and a bajillion other things while we are at it.
But they don't. Not even the best ones.
The fact that we might need to be mindful of how we communicate with a person/system/whatever doesn't mean too much in the context of AI. Just like humans, the details of how they work will need to be considered, and the standard trope of "that's an implementation detail" won't work.
LLMs are below human evaluation, as I last looked, but it doesn't get much attention.
Once it is passed, I'd like to see one that is solving the mystery in a mystery book right before it's revealed.
We'd need unpublished mystery novels to use for that benchmark, but I think it gets at what I think of as reasoning.
LLMs are far, _far_ below human on elementary problems, once you allow any variation and stop spoonfeeding perfectly phrased word problems. :)
https://machinelearning.apple.com/research/gsm-symbolic
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2410.05229
Paper came out in October, I don't think many have fully absorbed the implications.
It's hard to take any of the claims of "LLMs can do reasoning!" seriously, once you understand that simply changing what names are used in a 8th grade math word problem can have dramatic impact on the accuracy.
If so, let's move on to the murder mysteries or more complex literary analysis.
I would think this is a not so good bench. Author does not write logically, they write for entertainment.
The reason it seems like an interesting bench, is it's a puzzle presented in a long context. Its like testing if an LLm is at Sherlock Holmes level of world and motivation modelling.
Once a model recognizes a weakness through reasoning with CoT when posed to a certain problem and gets the agency to adapt to solve that problem that's a precursor towards real AGI capability!
One might also interpret that as "the fact that models which are studying to the test are getting better at the test" (Goodhart's law), not that they're actually reasoning.
A lot of people have criticized ARC as not being relevant or indicative of true reasoning, but I think it was exactly the right thing. The fact that scaled reasoning models are finally showing progress on ARC proves that what it measures really is relevant and important for reasoning.
It's obvious to everyone that these models can't perform as well as humans on everyday tasks despite blowout scores on the hardest tests we give to humans. Yet nobody could quantify exactly the ways the models were deficient. ARC is the best effort in that direction so far.
We don't need more "hard" benchmarks. What we need right now are "easy" benchmarks that these models nevertheless fail. I hope Francois has something good cooked up for ARC 2!