News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:07AM (#39600257)
> Now, Euro NCAP is not insisting on everything being its own button or switch. But the organization wants to see physical controls for turn signals, hazard lights, windshield wipers, the horn, and any SOS features

This is much more reasonable than I assumed. Unlike seemingly most people here I have no problem whatsoever with fan controls or audio controls or whatever on the touchscreen, as long as it is responsive (of course the vast majority of car touchscreens are not, but some are). However, the absence of a physical speed control for the windshield wipers is the single worst design flaw of Teslas. Or at least it was, until they removed the physical turn signal controls. I'm very much in favor of requiring safety critical controls that must be used frequently or urgently to be physical.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ClikeX on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:06AM (#39601023)
Volume control is a very commonly used feature in cars. That should definitely should be a physical button. I drive a Lynk & Co (reskinned Volvo XC40) and it has a rotary knob on the center terminal for fan speed, temperature, and volume. Which are all within reach without me having to look or lean over. There's also a volume button on the steering wheel next to my thumb, which is great.

The only annoying part is that the left button pad on the wheel is the absolute worst. It's essentially a d-pad with a center press, but it's one single button cover. Which leads to a lot of wrong clicks.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:32AM (#39601183)
Is there a car without a physical volume control? Teslas have it on the steering wheel.

What really kills me is my wife's Civic has no pause button at all, physical or otherwise. And it autoplays media on your phone when you get in. Don't want your phone to play whatever random YouTube video you happened to click on hours ago? Gotta pick up your phone to pause it there. And this doesn't happen right away, oh no, it takes at least a minute into your drive for the Bluetooth to wake up.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by moogly on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:28AM (#39602457)
Most MEB cars with the VW ID style center screen have a touch strip under the center screen to adjust volume. On earlier models this isn't even illuminated at night.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by PodgieTar on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:47AM (#39601298)
A Mercedes C-Class, 2023 model, also has no way to pause the music with physical buttons. It has a volume switch, and that clicks in, but doing the Airpod double click doesn't do anything. It just mutes the music.

Instead you have to either use a weird capacitive DPad to navigate the Android Auto interface, or click the screen. It's terrible for UX.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by spicybbq on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:14AM (#39604424)
We have a newer Mazda, and I thought it had the same issue, but the mute button causes Carplay to pause the audio.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Slartie on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:53AM (#39601333)
But you are not legally required to use the volume control regularly in order to drive safely. You are not even legally required to have any kind of volume control in your car.

You are legally required to have and use the turn signals. You are legally required to have and use the windshield wipers (because you need to be able to see the road when it's raining). Same is true for the horn and hazard lights - those are safety-critical features, with their use at least partially regulated by law.

While I agree that volume control should be a physical button due to my personal taste, I would not go so far as to mandate it legally to be a physical button, with the reason being that it is not a safety-critical feature. The market can figure this out by itself. But for safety-critical features whose swift and correct use is mandated and regulated by law, I would absolutely mandate them to be provided to the user in a way that supports the swift and uninterrupting use expected from the driver, and that means: physical controls, placed reasonably reachable.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by harry8 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:59AM (#39601375)
Volume control is pretty damn safety critical when the driver takes their eyes off the road to jab at the f&^king miserable touchscreen and accidentally wipes out your family.

Sir Issac Newton wrote down the laws about piloting a couple of ton of steel some time ago. Very unlikely to be repealed.

Every control that will be used by the driver for any purpose whilst the vehicle is in motion is safety critical.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Slartie on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:04AM (#39601414)
That is true, but in that mind your kid in the back seat is safety-critical, so maybe we mandate no kids in the back? Or your wife next to you in the passenger seat, she could also make you remove your eyes from the road (happens quite a lot actually) - mandate no wifes in the passenger seat anymore?

You need to draw a line, otherwise really anything in your car can be safety-critical, you just need to imagine the right circumstances.

I would draw the line at the controls that are mandated by law. Every control mandated by law should not only be mandated to exist, but also be mandated to exist as a physical, easily reachable button.

> Every control that will be used by the driver for any purpose whilst the vehicle is in motion is safety critical.

Okay, that's at least limiting it somewhat. However, what about the setting for Bluetooth connectivity of the radio? It technically can be used while driving, and there's probably a non-zero count of people who have already used such a setting while driving to pair their phone or whatever. What about the time/date setting of the clock in your car? Same thing. Physical buttons for all of that?

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by RHSeeger on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:41AM (#39602558)
> That is true, but in that mind your kid in the back seat is safety-critical, so maybe we mandate no kids in the back? Or your wife next to you in the passenger seat, she could also make you remove your eyes from the road (happens quite a lot actually) - mandate no wifes in the passenger seat anymore?

You're being intentionally obtuse. Like everything else, this is a question of what options we have to make things safer. "Not allowing children in cars" isn't reasonable, because there isn't a simple alternative. Using controls that require less attention focus is reasonable.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ljm on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:19AM (#39601523)
They were all physical buttons before touchscreens became the norm, so the slippery slope argument you’re making doesn’t really carry much weight.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by otherme123 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:41AM (#39601687)
I think you are doing a strawman here. Nobody but you is talking about "mandates", and then you go ridiculing imaginary mandates that nobody is defending.

Case: seat belts. First introduced in 1949, three-point seat belt invented in 1955, Saab made them standard in all their cars in 1958, Volvo in 1959 after being shown studies with fatalities. The first compulsory seat belt law was in 1970 (Victoria, Australia), and only began in the US in the 1980's (with great opposition).

Case: ABS. Patented anti-locks in 1930-ish, the modern ABS in 1971, the system was slowly introduced first in high-end models, soon in every model. The US only mandates ABS in cars since 2012, Europe since 2004 (for new cars). Read: all cars were already being sold with ABS in those dates, except for the cheaper and shittiest ones.

Case: Airbags. I skip the history there, because airbags are still not mandated anywhere. They are subject to some regulations, but you can technically build and sell a car without a single airbag in it.

My conclusion: we should not wait or even hope mandates do anything. In the car market we should do our own research and trust (to a point) car brand safety records and voluntary tests like NCAP, IIHS or NHTSA. If a brand doesn't give a shit about safety unless under a government mandate, don't buy that brand, because they are decades behind safety standards.

Mandates are not the bare minimum in safety, they are well below that. Take for example one of the lowest scores in the current NCAP: Lancia Ypsilon 2015, two stars. Still, they have (not mandated): two front airbags, two side head airbag, belt pretensioner, belt load limiter, belt reminder and ESC. Fear no more, even if we find today that kids in the back raises the death rate in a collision by 20%, we won't see it mandated until 2080 if ever, way after car makers figure out a solution by themselves.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by snowpid on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:59AM (#39601835)
Which country are you talking about? Airbags are mandatory because of the UN. https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/197...

and Euro NCAP chooses the cars indepently: https://www.euroncap.com/en/about-euro-ncap/the-car-selectio...

Or is it possible that you mix up the US regulation on a thread about EURO NCAP?

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by otherme123 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:25AM (#39602013)
Your first link doesn't prove nothing, it has nothing to do with airbags being mandatory. According to this: https://autoily.com/when-did-airbags-become-mandatory/ , they are only mandatory in the US (my fault, sorry). Some countries, like India, are requiring ONE front airbag since 2019. The core of my message stands: car makers go way ahead the mandates. I don't recall any safety technology that ever banned or delayed a car model from the market, unlike for example emission regulations, that are announced with a deadline in a "by 2030 no car can emit more than X CO2 g/km, so you better comply or be banned" fashion. In Europe that kind of regulation is causing diesel cars to vanish from the market. Safety regulations are always after the fact: "it seems than 100% of the new cars already have seat belts. Lets make it mandatory", and are usually announced with "the UE would like all cars to have anti-collision alert mechanisms before 2025", signaling that maybe in 2030 they make it mandatory for the remaining 20% that still don't have it today.

About the NCAP, I don't understand your message. Maybe you understood that brands send their cars to NCAP voluntarely? What I meant was that NCAP is a voluntary non-profit organization, and they can't do much even if your car is a cofin with wheels other than giving it zero stars. It's not like they can ban your car from the market under safety motives, like a government could do if they want.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by tialaramex on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:56AM (#39604198)
What happens with these non-mandatory programmes is that a manufacturer can give the programme money to buy their standard equipment vehicle and then the programme will buy the appropriate car from a dealer. The vast majority of vehicles are purchased this way.

This way they can't manipulate the vehicles being tested. The easiest way for your new 4954 model to get excellent NCAP scores is to make the actual 4954's people can buy from a dealer all good enough for excellent NCAP scores, the NCAP will just buy one and test it and it should score well because it's a 4954.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by guappa on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @05:17AM (#39614346)
They might know which dealers are in the area of the testing facility?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by tialaramex on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @06:43AM (#39614873)
If only there was some way to move cars from one place to another :D

A fellow passenger on a train one day was in that line of work. Customer dispatches him to pick up a car, he gets a train to the nearest station, gets a taxi to the car, picks the car up, drives it to the desired destination, another taxi and another train ride. Pay is reasonable if you like driving and can fill your time on a train (e.g. you like to read or listen to stuff, not great if you're an outdoors person or you need to be at home looking after the kids). Obviously most customers are moving valuable cars they can't get to, classics, high end luxury or sports cars where there might only be two dealers in the country, that sort of thing, but he doesn't care if you want him to drive a mid-market hatchback bought new off the lot yesterday afternoon, pay is the same.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by amenhotep on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:26AM (#39601568)
You're looking at this from the wrong angle. We don't really want to mandate physical volume controls, because they're necessary. We want to ban touchscreen volume controls, because they're unsafe. If Tesla want to deal with this by having no volume control, that's fine! Good luck to them.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Slartie on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:54AM (#39601790)
Touchscreens are not exactly the only way to construct a control in a way that's problematic to use when driving. You can just as well place a physical control in a hideous spot in the car, which you can't reach easily, hence making you as the driver bend over and search for the control. Also, physical controls don't necessarily mean that you can recognize them safely without looking at them - buttons can be physical, but still blend into their surroundings in a way that provides no real tactile feedback to your fingers when they find the button. I've seen crazy physical controls in cars that aren't much different from touchscreens with regard to their usability when driving, but still they were technically physical controls and would thus pass your "touchscreen ban".

If you want physical controls that actually are significantly safer to use than touchscreens, you need to lay down some ground rules for them as well (reachability, size of buttons, tactile difference from surroundings,...). And that rules out a "blacklist" approach (banning some particular undesired solution) and instead requires a "whitelist" approach (requiring a solution within a defined set of guidelines that constitute what's considered an acceptable solution).

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by numpad0 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:02AM (#39604281)
Just make it like 90-second rule for aircraft escape chutes. The manufacturer has to prove the stock interface is reasonably safe.

It'll be exploited a lot, so the standards must be high enough, and implementations also must be continually scrutinized by independent neutral bodies.

And we know what comes of it; the industry consortium implementations pass the test with flying colors and it'll look like hugely unpalatable dinosaurs, while new entrants like Tesla struggle to even interpret the spec to follow. The consortium may also explicitly or implicitly ban Chromium based everything.

But at least it'll be safe.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by RHSeeger on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:39AM (#39602540)
Being able to use your phone to talk to people is not safety critical either. And yet, we make laws to lower the amount of physical interactions required with the phone while driving. Because people _do_ use them in ways that negatively impacts safety, both for themselves and other people on the road.

The question isn't whether or not the interface needs to be interacted with at times when it would be a safety issue. The question is whether or not the interface _will_ be interacted with in a way that would be a safety issue. And how much of a safety issue that is to _other_ people. And what better options there are to prevent those issues.

"People can use it responsibly" is not a viable strategy here, when the (many) bad actors injure and kill 3rd parties.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by rkangel on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @06:07AM (#39614655)
Having music in a car isn't safety-critical. But we should have unflinching acceptance of reality that a lot of people WILL have music in the car, and so if music adjustments are unsafe then the car is more unsafe.

A while ago I worked on a military vehicle intercom system (communication between different station in tanks and armored vehicles). It had a number of pragmatic requirements, learned through experience. One of them was that each station had a 3.5mm jack that mixed its signal into what the headset was hearing. They had learned that whatever you did, soldiers were going to listen to music when they got bored. If you gave them a jack then at least they'd still have their headset on, and would hear instructions (and you could override the music if necessary...). Without the jack they'd just take their headset off.

You have to accept the reality of the world you're designing for not the world you'd LIKE to be designing for.

[Another pragmatic requirements anecdote from the same system: the comms bus had to be able to cope with random disconnects. Why? Because on a tank, the comms bus went to the commander in the turret via a contact ring and when the main gun fired, sometimes that contact ring would disconnect. But then we were allowed 1.5s to reconnect. That's a surprisingly long time - how come? Because that's how long it takes the tank commander's hearing to recover after firing!]

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by iforgotpassword on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:25AM (#39600359)
But even then, how do you find the A/C or volume control on a touch screen without taking your eyes off the road, without accidentally touching something else? You just can't feel your way to the volume knob. Sure, you are a responsible driver and would only do that at a traffic light or other completely safe situation, but I don't know how many accidents touch controls in cars already caused with less responsible drivers, trying to adjust their AC while driving by an elementary school.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by oven9342 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:36AM (#39600418)
People have already died because of the screens “The ship's user interface [touch screen] was found to have contributed to the sailors' confusion.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_John_S._McCain_and_Alnic_M...

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by stby on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:28AM (#39600742)
Seems to be a US Navy thing (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_Air_Flight_655#Potential_...).

On a more serious note, there's a big difference between a vehicle like a car that is operated by one person, and a ship with a large crew with dedicated tasks.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by forgetfreeman on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:56AM (#39600954)
True. With a car there are fewer eyes monitoring the situation and frequently little or no time to correct from a mistake.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by oven9342 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:02AM (#39601394)
Each crew member should have been assigned the management and activation of a given portion of the touchscreen.

Morning briefing by the Captain: “John, you’ll supervise and operate the bottom left corner of the Touchscreen. Adam, as a left handed sailor, you’ll stand right to John and operate the bottom right corner of the Touchscreen with your left hand so there are no collisions in case of emergency”

Aye, captain

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by hef19898 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:03AM (#39601855)
The control interface you know is the touchscreen of your smartphone, isn't it?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by jkestner on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @11:56AM (#39606130)
ProPublica did excellent reporting on this: https://features.propublica.org/navy-uss-mccain-crash/navy-i...
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:40AM (#39600438)
Volume is on the steering wheel.

A/C is automatic and I don't need to touch it the vast majority of the time. While driving the most I might want to do is adjust the temperature, and since it's not safety critical I can choose a convenient time. It's at the bottom of the screen so it is easy to do by grabbing behind the bezel and only requires a quick glance to align your thumb. In practice I glance at physical A/C controls when adjusting them too, so I don't see a big difference here.

If you really need to adjust the temperature so often and can't stand the thought of using the touchscreen, you can assign that function to the left scroll wheel.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by generic92034 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:48AM (#39600893)
> While driving the most I might want to do is adjust the temperature, and since it's not safety critical I can choose a convenient time.

That is good reasoning, but are you sure a high number of drivers are also waiting with adjustments, instead of fumbling on the screen while continuing to drive?

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by otherme123 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:48AM (#39601745)
A lot of people send and read phone messages while driving. I highly doubt that same people gives a second thought before playing with the screen while driving, unless they are under a real stressing situation (pouring and twisted road at 2 AM).
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by RHSeeger on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:31AM (#39602477)
If the choice is between

1. Physical controls that you can interact with without the need to take your eyes off the road

2. Touch screen that you need to look almost every time, much of the time while actually interacting with it. But you can mitigate that by using it more responsibly, waiting until you are at a stop, our out of range of anything you might need to react to (which might not happen for 10 minutes or even longer)

Then #1 is clearly the winner. Because 2 is more dangerous for everyone on the road (not just you with your own behavior, but everyone else that might act irresponsibly and hit you). We specifically craft laws to make people interact with their phones less (hands free only, etc) because "people must act more responsibly" is not a reliable solution.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by generic92034 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:10AM (#39602333)
Exactly. That is why physical buttons you can use without looking are so much better. For the perfect driver it does not matter so much, but that is a rare species.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by franga2000 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:52AM (#39600927)
It seems like you have a more sensible car than many. I was recently in one with really dumb automatic AC that needed adjustment very often, the AC settings were in a menu behing two clicks, there was no convenient landmark to orient my hand without looking, the temperature slider was very small and dense needing high precision and the temperature text was rather small. And the steering wheel buttons are, of course, not remappable.

I drive about a dozen different modern electric cars on a regular basis (carsharing) and all of them have at least a few of the above flaws (if not for AC then for something else that needs adjusting while driving).

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by l33tman on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:14AM (#39601487)
Avoiding to get into a "which car brand is best", I'll just say that I think there is simply a difference in the "DNA" of the car brands for how they approach the driving experience. It takes many many years and iterations and care about driving a car to produce a good car UX and some brands you can just immediately conclude that the CEO or the product managers don't care about driving and probably have never driven the specific model themselves, while in some brands you really feel they are a "driver's car".

This goes for tech in general and not just cars btw :)

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by PcChip on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:13AM (#39602892)
What is carsharing, and how does it work insurance-wise?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by netsharc on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:40AM (#39603243)
Like rental, but per minute. Look up car2go, although maybe they're no longer in business in the US, i. Europe they changed their brand name.

It's like those scooters you can hire and leave (almost) anywhere, the benefit with a car is, if you park it idiotically, they can check that you were the last driver and forward the parking ticket to you.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by seltzered_ on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:08AM (#39603622)
Car2Go and Reachnow both ended in the US around 2020.

There are some other carsharing services in the US in some major cities (e.g. gig car share in sf/seattle), but I would argue overall there's less carsharing now compared to 8-9 years ago. Partly the age demographics have changed, ridesharing (uber/lyft) rose in popularity, and carsharing in the us has had its share of profitability issues.

Peak carsharing in the US to me was around 2017-2018 (car2go, reachnow, limepod, maven, ...)

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by cruffle_duffle on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:43AM (#39604858)
I think cheap uber/lyft ate their lunch originally but what sealed it was the introduction of dockless bikes & scooters.

Of course those smart cars didn't really help either. They were great for parking and stuff but damn did it feel like driving a gocart. My foot was either at full throttle or no throttle.

...I do miss it though.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by seltzered_ on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:16PM (#39606382)
I think another kicker for carsharing at the time (~2020) was this forecasted revolution of driverless cars and robotaxis, which has sortof continued (waymo) but also collapsed (argo, cruise / tesla safety issues, etc. ) over the past couple years.

I liked carsharing from the stance that even if it didn't make me want to get rid of car ownership, it made me feel less inclined to invest as much into car ownership (i.e. keep an old used car with cheap insurance, use carsharing if my car needs maintenance or going on a trip where i dont want to worry about breaking down or if taking another mode of transit back.)

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Steltek on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:11PM (#39606333)
Zipcar is still around in Boston.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by franga2000 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:49AM (#39604121)
The kind of carsharing I use is company-run, so it's basically just rental, but billed by the minute and with parking spots scattered all over the city. I imagine they have a very expensive fleet insurance in the background.

There are also a handful of "peer-peer" carsharing systems where you let other people use your car and I have no idea how insurance would work there.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by egorfine on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:17AM (#39601509)
> grabbing behind the bezel

so, physical control.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vladvasiliu on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:40AM (#39602111)
This is presumably one of those models with the screen that's not integrated in the dashboard and looks like an afterthought. Those usually have some kind of bezel you can grab to stabilize your hand, but the actual control is still touch-based and on the screen.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vladvasiliu on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:38AM (#39602101)
It may depend on the car.

In my car, I basically never change the A/C. My dad used to have a same-vintage car for a while, but a different make, and it absolutely needed adjustment depending on whether the sun was shining on you or not, and possibly other parameters. They both had "automatic" A/C.

Now these cars are ~20 years old, maybe things have improved. I haven't ridden in my dad's ~2yo car for any long stretch during the summer to compare.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by SoftTalker on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:08AM (#39604348)
Automatic climate control is one of those things that sounds good and is nice when it works but never works properly in all situations. I much prefer manual controls.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by crote on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @01:29PM (#39607396)
The "smarter" they get, the worse they are to use. Modern cars are always blasting air into your face, at temperatures which deviate enough from the current temperature to be incredibly distracting.

I just want a gentle breeze of slightly warmer or slightly colder air, damn it!

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by litoE on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:01AM (#39604276)
My mother-in-law has had a Mercedes for four years. It has a self-parking feature. She still doesn't know how to use it and probably never will. She couldn't possibly assign a function to the left scroll wheel either. And she's Mercedes Benz's target market.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by gspencley on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:51AM (#39605019)
> While driving the most I might want to do is adjust the temperature, and since it's not safety critical I can choose a convenient time.

I'm not sure how much I agree that temperature is not safety critical. It's relative for sure, less safety critical than breaks or transmission, but it can still impact safety in certain situations. In the city when you have a lot of red lights and stop signs, it's not a big deal to wait for the next stop. But on a free-way when you've got a ways to go before you can make a stop then uncomfortable temperature can create a distracted or nervous driver situation. I suppose you could pull over on the shoulder if it were that big of a deal, but even that isn't the safest thing to do on freeways and it's recommended to only do that if you're making an emergency stop.

In my opinion this shouldn't even have to be a big deal. The only reason we're even discussing it is because car manufacturers are moving from tactile buttons to touch screens. People are accustomed to working these types of auxiliary systems without stopping and historically have been able to do so without taking their eyes off of the road. People aren't going to stop doing those things because now they have to use a touch-screen.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by dingnuts on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:36PM (#39610034)
Purely from a consumer standpoint, why on Earth would I EVER choose a vehicle that expects me to pull over to change the AC or to take my eyes off the road to control it, if there are competitors on the market that allow me to do so without doing those things?

Can you imagine actually pulling over off the interstate to change your AC? Absurd. Totally absurd and disconnected from reality. Nobody would do it, they would take their eyes off the road and then it doesn't matter AT ALL whether the function they're trying to perform has to do with safety or even operating the vehicle -- it's a distraction, and that's sufficiently bad.

Can we stop putting distractions in front of drivers, in general? Please?

I'll forgive Android Auto and Apple's thing because people won't stop looking at their phones otherwise but the driver should be able to control the vehicle and everything they might want to do in it without looking away from the road.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by WirelessGigabit on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @11:00AM (#39605235)
No. Ventilated and heated seats are something I want to control easily. And when driving in the sun I have the AC set to 64. When driving at night it's set to 72.

And it's different if I drive with the top down depending on weather. I don't need to look at the buttons to do that now.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by daniel_reetz on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @11:53AM (#39606095)
I think this is missing something fundamental. If it's too hot or cold, folks are distracted - from driving. Perhaps you are less distracted than most.

Yes, they can reassign buttons. But the core problem is distraction, which causes users to go to the touchscreen, which creates even further distraction by capturing their visual attention.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by thsksbd on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:17PM (#39606409)
The HVAC controls are a safety critical control because they are what dehumidifies your windshield screen.

And quick changes of T or RH needing the user to crank up the heat, turn on the AC and direct the air to the windshield at full speed are very possible depending on where you are.

Imagine crossing a miles long tunnel under a mountain separating two weather zones.

Hands off my HVAC controls.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ianleighton on Thursday March 07, 2024 @09:20AM (#39629374)
A sensible approach I saw in the BMW i4 was to keep the defrost buttons around, among relatively few buttons. (I forget if the climate temp controls were physical too though.)
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by maccard on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:30AM (#39601170)
> You just can't feel your way to the volume knob

Yes you can. My last three cars have had a volume knob under the left thumb. My current car has a second volume knob behind the gearstick, and the A/C is the only analog dial along the center console. I can easily adjust both without looking away.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by RHSeeger on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:33AM (#39602491)
I have volume controls and similar on my steering while, and I never use them.... because I can never remember which is where. I prefer my stereo controls to be in the stereo controls area, my climate controls to be in the climate control area, etc. Spreading them out makes it more annoying to deal with.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by SoftTalker on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:09AM (#39604359)
Yeah I really dislike controls of any kind on the steering wheel. Should not have more than a horn button in the center.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by elif on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:53AM (#39602196)
I know it will cost me karma to point it out, but in a Tesla you can use voice control to adjust your AC/radio/navigation while your eyes are on the road and your car's 10 eyes are on the road.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by alistairSH on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:42AM (#39603272)
Does it work if you have a thick (non-American or non-RP) accent? Serious question.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMS2VnDveP8

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by grndn on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:09AM (#39603627)
As one of the comments pointed out, it's even funnier if you turn on the automatic captions :)
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by alistairSH on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:49AM (#39604123)
Exactly. I have a mild accent, but my dad still has a thick brogue. Would a car understand him? Not if it's using the same algorithm as YT's captioning.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by JohnFen on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @06:36PM (#39623207)
I don't think voice control is a good replacement because I tend to play music in the car.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vel0city on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:46AM (#39602601)
I don't change the AC while I'm in motion. All my cars have auto AC so I rarely touch them even as the temperature changes outside. I probably adjust the AC a handful of times a year. I'd rather not waste a lot of dashboard space on buttons that practically never get pressed, I'd rather have my map be even bigger and easier to quickly glance at and have more space to browse my media collection while stopped.

I don't understand how so many people have come across cars with seemingly terrible auto AC systems. Even my old 2000 Honda Accord had a competent auto AC system. I haven't had manual AC on any of my cars in decades. Whenever I rent a car it's always infuriating having to constantly muck with the AC system.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by me_me_me on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:49AM (#39602629)
this is akin to it works on my PC so not an issue
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vel0city on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:28AM (#39603868)
I'm not talking about a single car, I'm talking about several different makes and models over the last couple decades.

Works on my machine implies it's something special about that one device. My experience has been auto AC has worked fine with several different car models from several different makers across the last 24 years of car manufacturing.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by me_me_me on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:46AM (#39604091)
I am talking about a use case that works for you but not others - due to preference, hardware limitations etc.

My car can only turn AC on and off. What about me then?

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vel0city on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:54AM (#39605089)
I take it your AC controls aren't behind a touchscreen then?

I'm mostly arguing having AC controls on a screen aren't that big of a deal, because chances are if they're on a touchscreen they're auto, and if they're auto you really shouldn't need to ever really mess with them while moving. The only real exception to this would be defrosters, but I do agree there should be a least a physical defrost toggle button.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by me_me_me on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @11:56AM (#39606139)
Fair enough, I wouldn't mind controls behind the screen for stuff you wouldn't need on daily basis. But I feel like we already had it with early screens and infotainment.

Functionality that might be needed when you drive (fogging up, change audio src, increase temp) should have physical interface.

So if you have auto AC it could go behind the screen.

But what I am afraid is that cars are sold with premium features as upgrades. So features that are fine behind screen would suck in cheaper models. And when looking at what BS automotive industry is pushing now (subscription services for physical features that are present), I am not hopeful this would be addressed.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vel0city on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:19PM (#39606427)
> Functionality that might be needed when you drive...should have physical interface.

I generally agree. Safety critical features need physical control options close to the driver's normal inputs.

> But I feel like we already had it with early screens and infotainment.

I have two cars. One with a big screen and few physical buttons, and one with a small screen with lots of physical buttons.

Because of all the physical buttons, the screen had to be a lot smaller. The vast majority of those buttons relate to actions I really shouldn't be messing with when driving or are connected to the auto AC system which as mentioned doesn't really get used. So it is a ton of wasted space on the center console.

On the other car, the screen is very large. There's still important physical controls related to driving and defogging and adjusting media and what not, but they're all immediately around the driver's area not the center console. This allows for the maps for navigation to be very large and easier to glance at. The interface for changing media a lot easier to use when stopped and wanting to actually look at what choices I have or have my passenger make changes.

At least to me, I'd much rather have the center console be filled with the map and actually used input surface rather than just have it filled with tons of buttons which generally still shouldn't be used when driving.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Toutouxc on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:19AM (#39604478)
> I don't understand how so many people have come across cars with seemingly terrible auto AC systems.

> Whenever I rent a car it's always infuriating having to constantly muck with the AC system.

Am I missing something or do these not make sense together?

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vel0city on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:44AM (#39604876)
I guess I should have phrased it as "chosen to own cars with seemingly terrible AC systems". Theromostatic controls are pretty cheap to implement, its not like you'd need some high-end extreme luxury car to have that feature be normal.

If the AC controls are on a touchscreen, chances are they're auto. If they're auto, you probably shouldn't have to mess with them at all while moving.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by dzikimarian on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:41PM (#39606740)
You need at least sun direction, temperature and humidity sensors and reasonable software behind them to have good automatic AC.

Basic thermostat is somewhere in center console, which doesn't help much if your chest is blasted with sun. Also temperature you feel is different depending on humidity.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vel0city on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:53PM (#39606884)
I live in North Texas. I guarantee you we get a lot of days with intense radiant heat.

Both of my cars have glass roofs. Previously they had sunroofs. Lots of sunlight in the cabin.

I haven't had issues with automatic AC in decades in cars that aren't exactly luxury cars. It is a solved problem for at least every brand of car I've owned.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by fastasucan on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @01:49PM (#39607656)
This explains why you are content with automatic AC. When you live with fost and snow many months a year you get a need to adjust the AC while you drive.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vel0city on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:22PM (#39608030)
It snows in Texas. I wake up with many mornings of frosted windows and several week stretches below freezing. I still don't need to adjust my AC other than pressing "defrost" at the start and pressing it again later when its all melted. I'm 100% for a physical defrost button as things related to visibility should absolutely be physical, but that's not really a part of regular AC settings.

I'm still not adjusting the overall temp or vent activation or compressor on or off, I'm just setting it to max defrost and turning that off when it's done. Even when I drive to places where its below freezing every day, I'm still just leaving it on auto AC other than defrosting. Why would I need to adjust the AC while I drive when its snowing outside of defrosting? The AC can automatically adjust itself.

People say auto AC can't possibly work when its hot and sunny. People say auto AC can't possibly work when its cold out. And yet every car I've had for over 20 years of model years with auto AC has worked perfectly fine at 0F and at 110F.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by NovemberWhiskey on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:52AM (#39604152)
My car has no physical climate controls etc. I just use the voice controls.

“Hey Google, set the driver’s side heated seat to one”

“Hey Google, turn off the steering wheel heater”

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by guappa on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:15AM (#39604430)
Judging from how google subtitles my videos on youtube, this would look like a comic gag for most people.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by NovemberWhiskey on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @11:33AM (#39605791)
In my other car, which adheres to the “buttons for nearly everything” philosophy, the steering wheel heater (for example) is down by the driver’s left knee, even using it via the touchscreen is probably safer.

Experiences with this sort of thing are subjective, but I’ve never had any problems with Google Assistant in the car.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by crote on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @01:32PM (#39607448)
"I'm sorry, I didn't quite catch that"

"I'm sorry, could you please repeat your query?"

"I'm sorry, I did not understand that request"

"You said 'Heated Seat', calling closest contact 'Holly Smith'..."

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by antifa on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:37PM (#39608234)
In my experience it'll probably work out a little more like:

"Hey Google, lower the volume"

"Calling $NAME_OF_DECEASED_PERSON_OR_RANDOM_RESTAURANT"

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by guappa on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @05:12AM (#39614308)
An immigrant taxi driver wanted me to say the street where I wanted to go, for google maps.

It would have been ~20x faster to just let me type it.

At least I had told him the general area, so we were getting there even while I kept repeating the address and maps was getting it wrong.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Kuinox on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:15AM (#39601069)
> I have no problem whatsoever with fan controls

Fan controls are important to remove fog on the windows. I should be able to enable it without looking away the road.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:21AM (#39601115)
If you live in a place where this is frequently required, in a Tesla you can put the defrost button on the shortcut bar at the bottom of the screen, where it only requires a quick glance to align your thumb to activate it. Which is actually easier than many cars with physical controls that may require multiple button presses and/or knob turns to configure all of the correct climate settings for defrosting in the current conditions.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Kuinox on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:52AM (#39601771)
My electric car, a Zoé, have real buttons to toggle the defrost. I know what the buttons are like, so I can jut move my hand until I feel I'm on the right button. I don't need a "quick glance".
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by arethuza on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:25AM (#39601143)
Much easier to have a single physical button.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:36AM (#39601215)
Overstated. It's at best marginally easier to hit a random physical button on the center console than to hit a single button on the bottom bar of a Tesla screen, where it is very easy to grab by design. I generally don't hit those physical buttons without at least a glance, and that's all it takes for the Tesla bottom bar buttons too.

This doesn't save the wiper situation, though, because that requires navigating menus. Clearly far worse than a physical control in that case.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by arethuza on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:47AM (#39601297)
Well, I'm the customer and I want physical buttons!

Edit: I had a car that used a touch screen feature to activate the heated windscreen - it was perfectly responsive, easy to find but I still hated it. Current car has a single physical button to turn on all relevant features with one press and I love it.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by klausa on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:53AM (#39601334)
> It's at best marginally easier to hit a random physical button on the center console than to hit a single button on the bottom bar of a Tesla screen

You presumably typed this out on a keyboard of some sort.

Which one can you do more confidently and reliably without looking:

— hitting the "u" key on a physical keyboard without looking — hitting the "u" key on a touchscreen keyboard on your most used mobile device?

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:00AM (#39601380)
I can touch type and hit 'u' without looking, sure. But only if my hands start on the home row. This has no relevance for the situation under discussion. I cannot hit the 'u' key on a physical keyboard confidently and reliably without looking if it is mounted on the center console of a car and I am driving with my hands starting on the steering wheel. I always look to position my hand to hit those buttons. Meanwhile, the Tesla bottom bar buttons are far easier to hit than any key on my phone keyboard because they are much larger and mounted in a fixed position relative to me with a built in place to rest and align my hand. These situations are completely incomparable.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by klausa on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:34AM (#39602503)
>I can touch type and hit 'u' without looking, sure. But only if my hands start on the home row.

The keys have bumps to let you know when your hands are in the right place.

Similar affordances exist in many cars. Even where they don't; the much smaller amount of them makes remembering things like "the third button from the left mutes the audio" and finding it by touch entirely possible.

Look, I'm not trying to argue that touchscreens are useless or whatever — if you like your touchscreen, fine, whatever, your problem.

But claiming that they're _as easy_ to use without looking as button is just not believable.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Omin on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:37AM (#39601647)
There are knobs on the f and j key so you can find the home row without looking. Similarly, physical buttons in a car can be shaped in such a way that they allow for feeling your position.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by nottorp on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:09AM (#39601452)
> But only if my hands start on the home row.

But but... in a car your hands always start on the wheel...

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:12AM (#39601472)
...which is nowhere near the center console, very much unlike the 'u' key's convenient position millimeters from the home row...
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by otherme123 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:58AM (#39601817)
Be honest: when you reach for a physical button you might glance for 0.5 seconds or even less. Usually you'll try to reach it without looking, and only glance if for some reason you can't do it. You glance, reposition your hand, and operate the knob without looking.

When you try to use a touch screen, you look at it all the time. I've just tested: to unlock my phone I have to push a physical button on the right side, swipe up and then make an easy pattern. I can grab the mobile, orient it correctly and push the side button without looking or even thinking. But just to make the up swipe I look at the screen (I can force my self to not do it, with effort). But I'm unable to make the pattern without looking all the time I trace it. It's like the brain don't want or can create muscle memory for touch screens.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by hot_cereal on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @02:01PM (#39619781)
thinking about it, I actually like this comparison. You make a good point, in that the physical keyboard is a more accurate tool. But that doesn't mean it doesn't have drawbacks.

The advantage of the digital screen is the customizability and adaptability. If I never use the web browser or music on my iPhone, i can just move those apps off the home row. If my keyboard has a numpad, but I don't need it, I'm stuck with a numpad until i buy a new keyboard.

In my old Land Cruiser, the pull knob to open the vents is right next to the pull knob to open the choke which is right next to the pull knob to activate the hazard lights which is right next to the pull knob to activate the fan. None of them are lit, they all look the same in the dark. We've come a long way since 1981, but the point is that the improved reliability of a physical button means nothing if the ergonomics of the interface as a whole are bad. And it's a lot easier to improve the ergonomics of the system (or adapt them to the user's needs) if the controls are on a touch screen.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by hermitdev on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:55AM (#39605112)
Why touch screens should be an absolute no-go for anything safety adjacent: gloves. The overwhelming majority of touch screens just do _not_ work with the user wearing gloves.

If I get into a car and it's -20F out, last thing I want to be doing is removing my gloves to operate a fucking touch screen to turn on heater/defroster/defogger/wipers, etc. And I absolutely, definitely, without a doubt, do not want to have to be removing/putting gloves back on while actually driving to adjust anything.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by vel0city on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:37AM (#39603989)
Properly defrosting/defogging the windows would be more than just a fan control. Ideally you want to ensure the AC compressor and heat are both running and you need to change the vent settings.

Far better to have a dedicated defrost button next to the driver's normal controls that does it all as a single toggle rather than have the driver make multiple adjustments. Which is what I have on both of my cars, one of which people complain about how it's just a giant touchscreen.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by sundvor on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:37AM (#39600425)
Tesla wiper? Just push the wiper button on the left stalk and you can cycle through the speed settings with the left funky switch (multi function button) in addition to the on screen display options that then pop up. Very easy to do.

Also this: https://youtube.com/shorts/3eKcDOHVZWc?si=-jL4o4Bhu-2y0ibj

Doesn't cover the left multi function button feature after short pressing the wiper button.

(Model 3, 2022, Australia).

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:51AM (#39600509)
> Just push the wiper button on the left stalk and you can cycle through the speed settings with the left funky switch

Yes, they added this relatively recently. For the first few years I owned the car this was not possible. Also, guess what, it still sucks! More steps than a physical control, fiddly because of the short timeout, and still requires an extra step of looking at the touchscreen because you can't know which way to push the wheel without finding out the current setting. Is it on "Auto" or "Off"? They're at opposite ends of the menu. Acceptable for something less important like setting the A/C temperature; definitively not acceptable for something safety critical like wipers.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Dunati on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:53AM (#39600929)
I have a 2018 model x with a traditional wiper dial stalk and it almost never works. It has markings for 5 settings and most of the time it just ignores the setting you have it on. The auto setting doesn't seem to change the behaviour at all. My model 3 was annoying with the wipers on the touchscreen (mostly) but at least they worked consistently.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by darkwater on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:14AM (#39600635)
I had cars in which for the life of me I could not ever remember which part of which stalk controlled the wipers and which part controlled the lights. Ah, and then there are Volkswagen and Opel which had the light control as a wheel outside the wheel-drive, on the bottom left, and you had to take a hand off to modify it.

My point: just having physical controls doesn't mean it is easy or safe to use, if the layout sucks.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by sensanaty on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:35AM (#39601205)
I haven't driven that many different cars in my life, but isn't it usually the stick on the same side as the driver's seat? Aka if the driver's seat is on the right, then the blinkers are on the right, and the other way around in left-seated cars?

I switch between Indonesia and EU fairly often and most cars I've driven followed that pattern as far as I can remember (maybe I just never noticed though)

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by darkwater on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:00AM (#39601383)
Yeah but there might be 2 stalks on that side. Also in some car you need to pull the stalk down X positions, in others you have to rotate a crown, so it really depends.

The safest solution is to have properly working automatic wipers (UNLIKE current Tesla, where wipers are complete dogshit) so you just don't care. The same for lights.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by frumper on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:58PM (#39606945)
My wife's car has a stalk that you can turn the end, turn the inside. It has a slide that moves up and down inside of the inside rotating part. The stalk can go up, or down, or double up. You can also pull the stalk towards you. It's bonkers.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by rvba on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:15AM (#39601490)
Controls should be standardized across cars.

Imagine that someone rents a car and is tired + every manufacturer has their own konami code, or secret button to start the wipers. That's how accidents happen.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by paganel on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:02AM (#39602265)
That's just lame, sorry to say it. I'll start with the end by saying that most probably voice command won't work in a downpour, for the simple reason that downpours are usually associated with lots of noise that will cancel out your voice commands. And all the other "options" involve taking your eyes off the road and looking at a big screen in order to adjust wiper speed, all this while there's a potential downpour happening. That is a very big no from me. And, no, "automatic" wipers never do their job perfectly when it comes do downpours, you always have to adjust them in one way or another.

Granted, that guy that posted it was from Australia so that they probably don't have that sort of downpour problem over there (the same goes for places in the US like California or Texas).

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by tmikaeld on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:17AM (#39600316)
> …Teslas. Or at least it was, until they removed the physical turn signal controls.

The turn signals wasn’t removed, they moved them to the steering wheel as physical buttons. Which ofc isn’t optimal, because you turn it…

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:45AM (#39600464)
I would call them virtual buttons rather than true physical buttons, as they are capacitive touch buttons that don't depress and are missing a defined physical boundary. Granted, they are fixed in place and don't move. Except that, as you point out, they do move...
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by mgoetzke on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:24AM (#39601553)
the new model 3 highland buttons feel and behave exactly like physical buttons.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by AlexandrB on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:13AM (#39602891)
"Designed for California" nonsense. It's pretty common to wear gloves while driving in the winter in Canada. Now you have to make sure your gloves are compatible with your car.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by LeoPanthera on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:34AM (#39601203)
They're not physical buttons. They're touch sensors. They don't move or click.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by maccard on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:31AM (#39601180)
> Which ofc isn’t optimal, because you turn it…

You're supposed to indicate before you turn, to be fair.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Biganon on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:07PM (#39606287)
Not if you want to indicate that you're exiting a roundabout, in which you'll be constantly turning
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by nehal3m on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:35AM (#39600405)
You’re supposed to signal before you turn the wheel.

Way too often I see people signaling as they turn, not because they are trying to communicate with other road users but because it’s the law. Indicate your intent first and then take the indicated action.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by the_gipsy on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:09AM (#39600605)
You might already be turning, but completely unrelated to an upcoming maneuver that you must signal.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by martin8412 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:36AM (#39600416)
Roundabouts..
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by gambiting on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:46AM (#39600472)
Correct. But then maybe OP lives somewhere where roundabouts aren't very common so they never ran into that usecase.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ben_w on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:45AM (#39601283)
In the UK, which has loads of roundabouts, this issue is still common enough to notice, and derided.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by hawski on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:02AM (#39601396)
In my country there are a lot of roundabouts, but also crossroads do happen on a quite tight curve especially in smaller cities.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by nehal3m on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:03AM (#39601861)
I do, but I’m also an idiot. Worse, I’m an idiot that does not even own a Tesla. Maybe my temper in traffic got the better of me in that comment.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by nottorp on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:13AM (#39601481)
> Roundabouts..

And crossroads that aren't at 90 degrees. Like, you know, old cities that weren't built on a grid.

The one time i test drove a Tesla I abandoned a left turn because all the roads involved were curvy enough I couldn't get the turn signal to stay on ;)

Mind, it was just a test drive. I guess that if I practiced for years I could master the wisdom of Tesla controls.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by faiD9Eet on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @04:55PM (#39622159)
Some countries, e.g. Poland, require you to turn on your left indicator as soon as you enter a roundabout and as long as you stay in the roundabout. If you intend to exit, you have to switch from left indicator light to right indicator light. Switching happens while steering left. Poland has multi lane roundabouts where you are expected to stay on the innermost lane possible and only move to an outer lane when your exit is close.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by usrusr on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:13AM (#39601479)
Yeah, that might actually be an advantage of that new Tesla layout (never seen a Tesla from the inside): small fiddly sensor surfaces on the wheel are best operated while going straight, whereas the stalk keeps tempting the driver to leave operation to the hand movement that happens anyways when starting the turn. Guilty as charged, deeply sorry about that (I don't think it's a regular habit of mine, but we've all seen cars driven like that)

But, as a sibling comment already mentioned: roundabouts! One of the most important indicator engagements is made crazy awkward for people who keep "walking" their hands to neutral position while the wheel is turned instead of wrestling it like some animal.

Which does make me wonder: has any carmaker started engaging turn signals from navigation? I'd imagine that this could be an amazingly subtle user interface for following a route: just don't press the veto button when the car decides to engage indicators and steer as if the indicator decision had been your own. No more following robot voice orders. An established pattern I don't know about? Tried, but turned out to be terrible? Legal uncertainty (or legal negative certainty)?

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by rightbyte on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:22AM (#39601998)
> Yeah, that might actually be an advantage of that new Tesla layout

Seems annoying if you want to do a turn when in a turn?

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by usrusr on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:57AM (#39602225)
Absolutely, that's the roundabout scenario. Downsides do outweigh the advantages.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by williamcotton on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:20AM (#39600332)
So that’s why everyone who drives a Tesla never uses their turn signal?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by concordDance on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:27AM (#39601151)
I've seen hundreds of Teslas driving in the UK and they're just as likely to use a turn signal as anyone else (~99%).

I'm not sure I've seen a less substantive comment on hacker news that wasn't flagged.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by williamcotton on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:44AM (#39603305)
People in the UK actually use their turn signals. Try driving around Central Texas. The joke, as another commenter pointed out, used to be BMW drivers. There is some kind of linear relationship between the luxury of a car and the lack of conscientiousness amongst many American drivers.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by snowfield on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:35AM (#39600408)
They used to own BMWs
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by faiD9Eet on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @04:57PM (#39622177)
:D
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by resolutebat on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:36AM (#39600417)
That's a weird assertion, because if you're driving a Tesla and using autopilot/TACS you have to use turn signals to change lanes.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by snowfield on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:34AM (#39600404)
To be fair, the new EVs have pretty good adaptive wipers. I have not found the bed to actually overwrite this yet.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by modeless on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:40AM (#39600442)
Not Teslas, unfortunately. The auto wipers are trash and always will be because Tesla refuses to add a dedicated sensor. It's a double whammy: handicapped auto mode and awful manual controls.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ahahahahah on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:42AM (#39600448)
Cars for 15-20 years have had good automatic wipers, they're just becoming more widely available now (and evs are generally in the price range where it's expected). Well... except for Tesla. They decided that a person can tell when wipers are needed just by using their eyes, so certainly they could save a buck or so and do it using just a camera.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by usrusr on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:43AM (#39601706)
Cars had it, because an ICE drive train is so cheap that in the price range you are talking about it's almost negligible. All the cost is in nice to have things like extra sensors for every tiny niche use case. Fast forward to BEV and suddenly the drive train eats such a large part of your cost budget that you are hard pressed to cut much of the fat of the ICE era.

Carmakers haven't stopped doing electric variants of ICE models because it's oh so difficult to put batteries where an engine, tank and gearbox used to be (it's not), they switched to dedicated BEV designs to have an opportunity to do a "cost reset" about their approach to all those little nice to have things they introduced in the late ICE era to maximise the price buyers were willing to pay for a given vehicle class. The BEV-specific base architecture certainly helps, but it's as much about the expectations reset. This certainly does not mean that they switch their rain sensor to the Tesla approach, they might actually end up cheaper cost-optimizing what they have and know, but BEV does mean looking at costs in a very different way than in the ICE era.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by sensanaty on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:32AM (#39601191)
Teslas don't have physical blinker switches?? That is pure lunacy, are you telling me they're touchscreen activated now?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ainiriand on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:22AM (#39603006)
It is even worse, because the buttons are placed on top of the steering wheel so when you turn they also turn in place and it is confusing.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by OvbiousError on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:37AM (#39601218)
From the article:

> Tesla is probably at greatest risk here, having recently ditched physical stalks that instead move the turn signal functions to haptic buttons on the steering wheel.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by sensanaty on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:38AM (#39601228)
That's legitimately insane to me. Plus you don't even get that satisfying clunk of turning the blinkers on.

God the future is turning out so lame...

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by nottorp on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:12AM (#39601471)
The main problem is you have no tactile confirmation of the blinker status.

They may have left some blinking icon on on the screen, but you're watching the road and don't see it.

They may have left that confirmation 'click' sound on, but you can't hear it because you can't adjust the music volume :)

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by yurishimo on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:03AM (#39601399)
Some parts of the future are always lame! But luckily, they can get better if at least one person cares enough to make facilitate the change :)
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by mgoetzke on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:23AM (#39601550)
those 'haptic' buttons are real buttons. with a click feel and everything. they are great (tested in highland model 3)
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by close04 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:50AM (#39601758)
What people call "real buttons" usually require a certain force and travel to activate. Capacitive buttons require little to no force or feedback, sometimes not even solid contact.

I think the easiest way to understand the difference is to ask 2 questions: "can I put my finger on that button and not immediately trigger it" and "can I can physically tell that I am triggering it (ideally some physical travel)?" If the answers are "yes", then it's probably the kind of button people look for when talking about wanting "real buttons".

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ricardobeat on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:39AM (#39603231)
The parent commenter was making the point that the particular buttons on the latest Model 3 (Highland) actually feel almost like physical buttons. They require pressure and won’t activate just by being brushed against.

Still, as blinker controls they don’t have tactile markings and a stalk would be much better.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by close04 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:10AM (#39603647)
> feel almost like physical buttons

You're correct. But I was addressing GP's wording (emphasis mine):

> those 'haptic' buttons are real buttons

I was making the point that it's not a "real button" if, as you also say, it just "almost like" a real button. Knowing the M3 buttons, that "almost" is doing a lot of heavy lifting. Press a classic hazard lights button, and a Tesla signal button and see if they really feel similar. No need to go to the vastly different stalk.

For any normal person a button involves not only the application of pressure but also the consistent feedback of travel. Things like Apple's taptic engine and similar techniques simulate already bad buttons with microscopic travel.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by mythhabit on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:47AM (#39602162)
Apple has actually combined the two with their touchpads. When you press on them you get the "click" feedback. But its not actually a physical travel that activates, it's what they call "the haptic engine" that vibrates in a way that makes it feel like you've clicked a physical button. It works really well.

However, I think that such buttons are far more expensive than a physically activated button, even if the latter is engineered to last a lifetime of heavy use.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by close04 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:35AM (#39603183)
> But its not actually a physical travel that activates

This was the little (to no) feedback of a press I was mentioning. Simulating the absolute bare minimum of travel. With the pressure sensors and the piezoelectric actuators it becomes a super-expensive, overengineered button simulator that works almost as well as the real thing.

Even Apple dropped the fancier 3D touch completely, and the less fancy Force touch is just for trackpads. Everything else is the cheaper Haptic touch doing away with pressure sensors entirely. It was fine for my iPhone 8 home button and old watch.

But a car is different. A hazard light button has ~5mm of travel. Blinker or wiper stalks have centimeters of travel. Same for rotary knobs. They're also well spaced from each other with hard to confuse actuation methods. In noisy and vibration prone environments, with time sensitive requirements, you want to have very clear and distinct ways to act and receive feedback that actions were performed, especially if critical for safety.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by mythhabit on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @05:28AM (#39614423)
I do not disagree with you. I was pointing our that there is a certain class of physical buttons we can replace with an "emulation" that works just as well. That is not to say we should.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by yreg on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:41AM (#39602124)
It depends. The solid state button under the MacBook trackpad is indistinguishable from the previous physical button.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by close04 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:41AM (#39603257)
I wrote more in the comment above but just to add that the old trackpad is not the best point reference. This is just Apple chasing thinness by making any button barely have any travel. Signal or wiper stalks have 2 orders of magnitude more travel.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Yizahi on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:00AM (#39602246)
Tesla planned that everything in the car would be automated, including driving. In such case people don't need a thought out UI and responsive controls and all that can be cut down to either save money or to focus on media entertainment for the passengers. That's why they replaced steering wheel with a yoke, buttons with screens etc. Unfortunately they forgot that car need to be fully automated first, and then redesigned later. Not the other way around.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by LeoPanthera on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:34AM (#39601199)
They are touch areas on the steering wheel. It's not on the screen, but they're not buttons. They don't click.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by mgoetzke on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:17AM (#39602374)
They do in the new models like the 3 refresh
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by lm2s on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:25AM (#39601567)
On recent models they removed the stalks and put blinker buttons in the steering wheel.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by CorrectHorseBat on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:41AM (#39601247)
>However, the absence of a physical speed control for the windshield wipers is the single worst design flaw of Teslas.

The fog lights are much worse

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ojosilva on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:29AM (#39601596)
How about the voice commands for these? ("Wipers 1-slash-4"). I just got my first Tesla, MYLR, and even though it's annoying not having the stalks given the rain sensor is absolute junk the voice command seems to work 98% of the time. The voice command is activated from a button on the steering wheel - it may require a network connection though. I haven't tried the fog lights, it may not have a command, but there's apparently a shortcut with the left stalk where you pull or push and a quick light menu comes up - 2 clicks instead of 1 but seems reasonable - I could never find my fog lights quickly enough on most of my previous cars anyway.

My only concern with the wipers would be for an emergency, ie the street washers drive by and suddenly I have no visibility, but for those situations I have the button on the left stalk that fires the wipers on demand.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Hamuko on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:51AM (#39601766)
Voice commands are absolutely crap and are never ever a substitute for actual controls. The device can't either hear you, mishears you, doesn't speak your language, doesn't understand your accent, doesn't understand your dialect, doesn't like the tone of your voice or just doesn't like your particular combination of words.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by eldaisfish on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:34AM (#39603956)
why are so many people in the tech world obsessed with voice controls? Seriously, this is imperfect at best and definitely a downgrade from a physical button.

What is with this obsession?

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ojosilva on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:27PM (#39610411)
Well, the OP says:

> almost every vehicle-maker moving key controls onto central touchscreens, obliging drivers to take their eyes off the road and raising the risk of distraction crashes

The concept of a physical button is the mother of all distractions. The touchscreen is just the physical button problem moved somewhere else.

Maybe today voice commands are not state of the art, or maybe, holy ball and chain batman, not even close to being the solution either, but I hope in the future nobody remembers there used to be cars with 113 physical buttons:

https://rennlist.com/forums/panamera/976009-too-many-buttons...

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by CorrectHorseBat on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:54PM (#39609058)
I hate the voice commands.

Half of the time it says it doesn't understand me, or it does something completely different "turn or rear window defrost" -> turn heat to high!. Fog lights it does understand, but it's "not yet implemented", whatever that means.

> pull or push and a quick light menu comes up - 2 clicks

Yeah, so I have to flash someone in front of me to turn on my fog lights, great. And don't forget to turn off automatic lights because it will turn off the fog together with the other lights but not turn them back on.

Apart from that I really like the car, just put a few more functions on the stalks and it would be a great car.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Hamuko on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:23AM (#39601548)
Highly doubt it considering that fog lights have very limited use compared to the windshield wiper.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by trompetenaccoun on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:26AM (#39601572)
Depends very much on where you live. Some people need them every other day, some may never use them at all. Certainly not "limited use" when you're in a mountainous region with regular fog.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by nottorp on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @04:57AM (#39601355)
> with fan controls

I want at the least a physical recirculate/bring air from outside button.

The use case is coming up behind a vintage truck that was made before they even thought of pollution standards on a winding mountain road where you can't overtake and you need to pay attention to the road. And you also need to set the a/c to recirculate before you suffocate.

For audio... with radio dying or dead I guess you can just run Spotify the whole trip. I'd still like volume and mute buttons.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by jwr on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:22AM (#39601540)
I have a VW (ID.4) and they took the touch craziness to another level. There are things that don't look like buttons, but are touch-sensitive, and there are also buttons, that apart from being pressure-sensitive, are also touch sensitive. Like volume buttons on the steering wheel, where if you try to feel for them without looking, you end up accidentally "swiping" and turning your volume up to the max.

The whole touch cluster on the left of the steering wheel, just below the vent, is a disaster, too. If I want to check the temperature of the air that's blowing into the cabin, I end up accidentally turning off the lights, turning on rear antifog lights, and turning on defroster heating for the windshield. The next minute or so is spent trying to get everything back to normal.

The rule should be that everything in the car needs to be a physically actuated button, and touching those buttons without pressing them should only ever light them up or show help messages, never perform any action.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Vespasian on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:35AM (#39601627)
I ultimately decided against an MEB based model because the (steering wheel) UX felt almost unusable during my test drive. I partcularily struggeled with the cruise control swipe-click and hilariously the window switch.

The car i ultimately settled on has worse overall infotainment software but physical controls which can be operated blindely and reliably.

No wonder VW is already in the process of correcting this disastrous, budget driven, decision.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by hef19898 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:37AM (#39601645)
VW went so far into left field with their controls on the ID-series, it is embarassing. Good to hear that they correct.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Vespasian on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:54AM (#39601788)
Just my own thought but I believe they were under immense pressure to achieve similar (or even some) margins with their very first broad market BEV, as they are getting with comparable ICE models.

As a car the MEB siblings are not bad at all and by now the software is fine I hear, but they cut just to many ergonomic corners instead of accepting the costs of getting started in a slightly different market segment.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by hef19898 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:59AM (#39601826)
Funny thing is, Skoda is doing better (no real news so), despite using the same platform.

What definitely didn't help, was putting a self-declared Tesla fanboy in the CEO seat. Only Tesla is Tesla, no other brand can get away with Tesla stuff. Should have been clear for VW, as they lived of marketing to sell overpriced cars for decades.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by foobarian on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:40AM (#39604026)
I think you're right, this is not a financial decision but cargo culting at its best. Just look at what happened to phones after iPhone 1 came out.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by moogly on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:24AM (#39602432)
Doesn't Skoda have pretty sensible steering wheels still?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by arethuza on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:53AM (#39602675)
They do but I would say the design of the two scroll/click wheels has got worse in the last couple of years.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Vespasian on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:28AM (#39602456)
Yes I should have limited my comment to VW, Cupra and Seat(?)
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ack on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:45AM (#39603312)
The Skoda I just rented in Portugal has real controls but they were really horrible. Even once I got used to their locations, I regularly made something happened than I wanted. Rear windows open instead of front, etc. There's even a control for the digital dashpanel enticing one to play with the display while driving.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by a_gnostic on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:32AM (#39604660)
Had an old Chevy with similar problems. Ended up taking a Dremel to the rear window controls, a bit of roughness is all it took.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by moogly on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:20AM (#39603764)
I really wonder how much money you can save by removing the individual rear window buttons and instead adding a modal touch "rear" button, like VAG has started doing.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Maakuth on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:53AM (#39601784)
And how much cheaper can this stuff really be than real buttons?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by heavyset_go on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:14AM (#39601932)
Can the buttons show you ads and upsell you on features?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Maakuth on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:08AM (#39602310)
That's just it - these are no more customizable than real buttons! They come with preprinted symbols for their function, so no cost advantage of customization.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by hef19898 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:00AM (#39601838)
Enough. Also, these design changes were advocated for by the CEO at the time.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Bluestrike2 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:02AM (#39604279)
We're talking a few dollars per unit for the various capacitive buttons, if that. Steering wheel controls already connect over CAN bus so it's not like you're saving a great length of wire, for example. They still connect to controllers, etc. Even tiny savings add up, but the cost of non-capacitive buttons is something they could recoup with almost zero effort.

Instead, it's almost certainly a design choice: they're easier to design around and 'feel' futuristic. Or that's what the designers and marketers think, anyhow.

The bigger cost-savings are in the touchscreen infotainment systems, where they get to eliminate the physical cost of a ton of buttons while simplifying manufacturing and parts inventory (no having to deal with a bunch of different trim parts to accommodate buttons for various options, etc.). That's probably the biggest reason why consumer pushback against touchscreens has taken so damn long to barely start having an effect.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by kevincox on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:08AM (#39601899)
> The machine was rather difficult to operate. For years radios had been operated by means of pressing buttons and turning dials; then as the technology became more sophisticated the controls were made touch-sensitive--you merely had to brush the panels with your fingers; now all you had to do was wave your hand in the general direction of the components and hope. It saved a lot of muscular expenditure, of course, but meant that you had to sit infuriatingly still if you wanted to keep listening to the same program.

By Douglas Adams in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ndsipa_pomu on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:43AM (#39602573)
Can people please stop implementing ideas that were intended as satire?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by drewzero1 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:48AM (#39603365)
Or as social criticism! A lot of tech giants seem to be trying to bring about the techno-future of scifi and completely missing the point that a lot of it is a dystopian hellscape serving as a thin veil over commentary on contemporary society.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ChainOfFools on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:14AM (#39604420)
The sense that you're being asked, or coerced, to participate in realizing someone's shallow, misunderstood, but aggressively peddled reading of a dystopian social commentary fantasy scenario is very near to the heart of what makes tech bro culture so obnoxious for everyone else.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by MR4D on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:36AM (#39604737)
No. That's the only way we know we're in a simulation. Reality could never be this stupid.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by Silasdev on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:56AM (#39604203)
Did Douglas Adams travel in time.... this is scarily accurate!!! My BMW keeps turning off the volume if I wave at anything in the direction of the touchscreen. There is a little infrared camera near the roof that can sense hand-gestures and turn volume up or down ... and lots of other things.

Douglas Adams so spot on I want to cry!

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by papichulo4 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:19AM (#39604482)
Um, hello friend. Turn gesture controls off. It's in the settings.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by graphe on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:48AM (#39604948)
You did buy a car without a dipstick, what do you expect? BMWs are fun to drive and are horrible too maintain. I remember helping someone because the radiator melted a reservoir tank, such a terrible design I never looked at another one!!

They should need forced to make dipsticks but the EU doesn't care when it's a European company. The EU is more anti American companies than actually caring.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by maxerickson on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:01AM (#39602256)
I bet you get bad controls even with a rigid prescription.

And then your rigid rule would prevent something like having a touch menu for a setup function that you would never have good reason to adjust while driving. Likely making it worse.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by parchley on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:53AM (#39603425)
I took and ID3 for a test drive, an accidentally activated the speed limiter on the highway. That got quite scary, and it took ages to realize I had to swipe on one of the fake buttons to disable it.

Compared to ID4, ID3 has another epic cost saving measure: They removed the two switches for the rear windows from the driver door, and replaced it with a toggle switch that decides whether the switches for the front windows really control the front windows, or the rear ones. So in total they saved one physical switch, but made the user experience much worse.

I also skipped the entire ID-family due to that. At least the Enyaq (Skoda's ID4) has a much better setup with physical buttons on the steering wheel, and more physical buttons for the console.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by matsemann on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:33AM (#39603945)
Same. Rented an ID3 for a weekend. Will never drive one again. Almost lethal design decisions on that car.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by btown on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:02AM (#39603529)
An ability to turn volume up to the max, unintentionally, is a safety issue, IMO. And more generally, I wonder how many “took my eye off the road for the radio” accident reports are actually a result of bad physical UX.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by jval43 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:43AM (#39604856)
I was in the market for a car, and initially really wanted a Tesla or VW / ID, but with no buttons, no dials, and on the Tesla additionally no parking sensors, wonky rain sensors combined with missing stalks and no straight-on speedometer, it quickly became clear to me these were all potential usability and safety issues.

I found a nice Toyota instead with a button for every function, and everything just works.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by helij on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @11:36AM (#39605847)
May I ask which Toyota. Did you go with their EV model?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by andix on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:52AM (#39605045)
I think it’s really hard to get good UX by setting up some simple rules. In the end we need good UX, however this is done.

For things like lights or wipers the solutions from the past are quite good I would say.

For things like the Tesla turn signal buttons I would actually prefer to have both buttons and the traditional stalk. Depending on the situation one is superior of the other.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by marginalien on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @11:27AM (#39605688)
I have been driving an ID.4 for almost three years by now. I consider much of what others criticize here in terms of UI, touch-sensitive buttons etc. to be „not great“ either but it did work for me. I didn’t really care to be honest.

What did not work for me was the re-charging experience on longer trips. I do not want to „subscribe“ to anything just to recharge my car in a reasonable amount of time. But even with a hypercharger it still takes way too long and without the „right“ subscription you feel like they steal your money from you. This is the worst from my POV when it comes to EVs, this is where they felt like inferior technology and business model to me as a consumer. Guess what, even though I was always a fan of EVs and hybrids (even drove three different models of Toyota Prius prior to my ID.4) my next car will be a traditional one (Hyundai Tucson to be precise).

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by dang on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @11:45AM (#39605983)
(We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39600257)
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by anilakar on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @05:42AM (#39601691)
I'm going one step further and arguing that if a function has no physical control, it's not essential but just a distraction and should be done away with.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by jajko on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:03AM (#39601858)
Even if I wouldn't be hating Musk for his position re actual freedom and his apparent respect for murderous dictators, these moves would solidly cement Tesla as a company I wouldn't buy a car from.

Stupid, arrogant moves nobody asked for pushed down the throats of unsuspecting users. A colleague's model 3 died during rain (apparently its such a solidly built car that a bit more than normal amount of rain can kill it for good, got replaced without questions which indicates this is a well known issue). Newer version didn't have physical turn signals. He was almost crying, an early adopter with a lot of love for the company that evaporated in an instance. Its not every day that car manufacturer actively tries to increase chances of people getting killed and acts like all is fine.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by elif on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:51AM (#39602182)
What's the difference between "physical turn signal controls" and "physical buttons with haptic feedback"?
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by kanapala on Friday March 08, 2024 @10:46AM (#39642132)
A physical control changes position and stays in that position so you can feel it to know if your turn signal is on for example.

Real button changes position when you press it. Haptic button is flat surface with vibrating motor inside that buzzes so it "feels" like a click. Like in a smartphone.

The ones I have seen have a lag, so you don't immediately know if your button press was registered or not.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by andrepd on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:09AM (#39602323)
>I have no problem whatsoever with fan controls or audio controls or whatever on the touchscreen

Why? What's the difference? You fiddle with these as well while you're driving, and they're also dangerous and distracting.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by kwhitefoot on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:10AM (#39602332)
> However, the absence of a physical speed control for the windshield wipers is the single worst design flaw of Teslas.

My 2015 Model S has a stalk with a rotary switch for wiper control that includes several automatic and manual modes and speeds.

But I was loaned a Model 3 when my Model S was being repaired and I hated it because most of the stalks had been removed making things like cruise control and the radio much more awkward to use.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by MyFirstSass on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:31AM (#39603127)
No just make buttons. Screens can hickup, scroll weird, etc. also you don't get any tactile feedback.

I don't wan't a touchscreen keyboard on my laptop, and the travel is already small enough - i say bring back tactility! The dead cold glass orb has destroyed so much.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by mavhc on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:48AM (#39603356)
Let's check all those items with the Tesla Model 3 2024 manual

To engage a turn signal, press the corresponding arrow button on the left side of the steering wheel. (The buttons move on the Highland steering wheel)

Turn signals: To turn on the hazard warning flashers, press the button on the drive mode selector located on the overhead center. All turn signals flash. Press again to turn off.

Hazard lights: Overhead console drive mode selector with arrow pointing to hazard warning light button in the middle.

If a severe crash is detected by your vehicle, the hazard warning flashers will automatically turn on and flash quickly to increase visibility. Pressing the hazard warning flashers once will return the lights to their normal cadence. Pressing a second time turns all hazard warning flashers off.

To sound the horn, press and hold the center pad on the steering wheel.

You can access wiper settings by touching the wiper button on the steering wheel

Press the wiper button on the steering wheel to wipe the windshield.

Press and hold the wiper button to spray washer fluid onto the windshield. After releasing the button, the wipers perform two additional wipes then, depending on vehicle and environmental conditions, a third wipe a few seconds later. You can also press and hold the wiper button for a continuous spray of washer fluid—the wipers perform the wipes after you release.

Whenever you press the wiper button on the steering wheel, the touchscreen displays the wiper menu, allowing you to adjust wiper settings. Press the left scroll button on the steering wheel left or right to choose your desired setting.

Off/Auto/Intermittent slow/fast/Continuous slow/fast

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by trogdor on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:26AM (#39603841)
I can’t believe that Tesla still ships cars without a center-press horn button.

I own a Model S Plaid, and the horn button’s location on the yoke can generally only be reached by the driver’s right hand. Even more dangerous, its position in space changes dramatically any time you are in the middle of a turn. The horn button is not easy to press in an emergency.

Same story with the turn signals.

If you are in the middle of a turn and you have rotated the yoke 180-degrees, your turn signal buttons are now upside-down, and on the other side of the yoke. I have owned my car for a year and a half, and there are still times when I have to look at the yoke mid-turn to figure out which turn signal button is which.

So stupid.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by archon810 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:20PM (#39610358)
100000% this. It's mind boggling that they managed to ship a car without the center horn, and it's even more mind-boggling that the NHTSA let and is still letting them.

I got used to the turn signals and the wipers because I use them a lot. But I still haven't gotten used to the horn and the lights because these functionalities are used very infrequently, so there is no muscle memory for them at all. I've had this car for over a year now.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by ambichook on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:05PM (#39610678)
my current car (tk barina) has two horn buttons just to the left and right of where you expect a centre horn to be and it drives me insane. i dont typically feel the need to use the horn but whenever i do i have to make the conscious decision to press my thumb in on one of those specific spots because theyre also small enough that using the heel of your palm to do it feels wrong
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by roeles on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @03:24AM (#39613605)
Given that you are most likely to use the horn to prevent an collision, and that during collisions the airbag deploys.. I would say that the center of the wheel is just about the worst place to put the horn button. Slapping yourself in the face somehow seems worse than the airbag deploying properly.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by FireBeyond on Saturday March 09, 2024 @01:51PM (#39653855)
As someone who has had an airbag go off 'in my hand' (resulting in, among other things, a hyperflex of my wrist... trust me, the 'slap in your face' is the least of your concerns. The airbag will be doing that too.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by flatline on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:36AM (#39603981)
My Jeep Wrangler has a physical volume knob that may or may not elicit a change in volume when turned within the first 30 seconds of starting the car. Which can be literally deafening if you had on e.g. a podcast at 75% volume when you turned the car off and it turned back on to the radio. Some of these things need a dedicated circuit.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by stronglikedan on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:50AM (#39604128)
The 2022 Acura MDX has that too, but it's not a "may or may not", it just doesn't. Thankfully they fixed it in the 2023 model, but I still don't understand why it's not fixed in the 2022 model since it's obviously software and both get OTA updates.
Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by sandworm101 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @11:16AM (#39605529)
>> I have no problem whatsoever with fan controls or audio controls or whatever on the touchscreen, as long as it is responsive (of course the vast majority of car touchscreens are not, but some are).

It was -27f/-33c this morning when I started my car. At those temperatures ALL touchscreens generally become slow and unresponsive, especially when wearing mittens. I want the defrost/fan/temperature controls on a physical switch. I also don't want a screen that isn't happy unless it is getting a full 12v/14v. Not all car batteries will give that when cold. Frankly, I'd be happy with a series of valves ... anything other than a touchscreen.

Fyi, automatic wipers are a nightmare in winter. It is very easy for them to break if caked in snow. Standard procedure being to start the car first and let it warm up as you remove the snow and ice. So you need them to be on a physical switch to ensure they are off prior to turning the car on.

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by NoobSaibot135 on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @07:46AM (#39615335)
> the touchscreen, as long as it is responsive (of course the vast majority of car touchscreens are not, but some are)

Normal refresh cycle period for tablets(iPads) is ~5 years.

Normal life of a car is 10 years (2x).

That means that by year 7 or so, multi-touch performance in autos starts to seriously lag consumer tablet market.

Perhaps we need to have a replaceable/swappable infotainment console now

Re:European crash tester says carmakers must bring back phys... by hot_cereal on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:08PM (#39618883)
I don't hate that Tesla tried to do something different with indicators. I think there are some issues with how stalks work, and thinking about how to make cars better and safer is good. Complicated stalks that make adjusting your wipers feel like playing a game of Bop-It? Total pain in the ass. And assuming something is well designed because that's how it's been done for decades is obviously silly.

But that doesn't make it wrong to do the research, go through the design process, and come to the conclusion that, in the end, putting blinkers on a stalk is still better than the alternatives proposed. It reeks of change for the sake of being different, rather than an actual innovation.

My biggest issue with the choice is that, on a wheel, indicator buttons are constantly moving. And when the buttons are right next to each other, it makes it significantly easier to indicate the wrong direction. Or have to take your eyes off the road to find the indicator when your wheel isn't straight (suppose you're trying to exit a roundabout)

And then with the lack of dashboard on some teslas, there's the knock on problem of having to look away from the road to see which way you're indicating if you think you've indicated incorrectly, rather than the indicator arrow clearly flashing at the bottom of your field of vision.