News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by marcus_holmes on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:36PM (#37865892)
I am coming to the opinion that Windows XP was the maximum usable interface, and we should have stopped there [0]. But then, I might just be old and telling the kids to get off my lawn.

[0] this is definitely true for Windows. All subsequent versions of Windows have had worse UX.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by jchw on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:00PM (#37866075)
I absolutely agree. For at least 10 years now, my dream has been to essentially recreate the Windows 2000/XP UX as a Linux desktop environment.

That said, doing so would basically require creating everything from the ground up, because merely theming some existing toolkit and window manager to look like XP is not at all the point. And frankly, there HAVE been SOME useful UI/UX improvements in the past couple decades, like, FTA, minimaps. But can you imagine a much more conservative desktop, with highly integrated apps, based on the "good old days" of desktop design with just a touch of modern elements when they improve on things?

... Truth told, the closest thing in existence is probably SerenityOS... but it really would be more practical if there was a Linux desktop for this. Every so often I fantasize about how I might start such a project. It's been like that forever now.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by jwrallie on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:29PM (#37866253)
I believe the biggest obstacle is dealing with different toolkits, since gtk3 and later are constantly breaking theme compatibility with new versions, and nobody have the time to maintain good alternative themes in these conditions.

XFCE with Chicago95 already exists (and so does Q4OS with XPQ4) as proof of concept that the window manager and toolbar side can be replicated.

The problem is that important pieces of software are not relying on any toolkit directly, but implementing their own version, so even if you support qt, gtk2 and gtk3+ applications with 3 different themes, there will be software running under electron or implementing their own client side decorations and breaking all the rules.

I think the easiest way to start would be to simply collect and maintain existing themes with a unified look and make a distro based on Ubuntu LTS or even RHEL to avoid breaking changes at maximum. This distro would have pre-selected software that behaves well with the selected themes, and need to have at absolute minimum a working browser with extensions following that theme.

If implementing from the bottom up, then something similar to helloSystem could also be a way, but I do not see it working in practice due to the time it would take.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bluGill on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:37AM (#37870457)
You can find well maintained applications for almost everything in either qt or gtk3. So you can select one toolkit to support. KDE might even accept your theme if you did enough work on it to make it work - and this is something that is feasible for one person. The hard part is those few exceptions, if you need one GTK3 app because KDE doesn't have a good alternative (or one qt app because GTK3 doesn't) then you have twice as much work and it is probably beyond what one person can do. Making that missing app for qt/gtk3 probably needs a large team and a few years and so is beyond you (unless you are rich and can afford to hire someone to fulfill your vision) - and there are many missing applications, not to mention existing ones which are just barely acceptable
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:11PM (#37876609)
Most maintained GTK 3 apps replaced menu bars with hamburger menus.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by cwillu on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:03PM (#37866094)
If you haven't already, look at xfce.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by jchw on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:22PM (#37866211)
I did like XFCE at one point, but it never really did quite nail the UX for me. A lot of the problem is more on GTK+2 than it was anything else. (Obligatory mention of no thumbnails in file dialog; I used to patch GTK by hand for this!) Now with newer versions of GTK, this problem has unfortunately gotten worse for me, and I don't really prefer XFCE very much. Worseyet, I've gotten used to wlroots giving me good support for things that never really worked well in X11, and XFCE's plan regarding X11 and Wayland going into the future is still somewhat unclear.

I also tried LXDE and LXQt as well. I actually thought LXQt might be the one for me, but it was a bit buggy and lacked a lot of much-needed maintenance.

Also, although I'm glad Linux developers don't always make a habit of just simply throwing out ideas and code that works fine, it does bother me how antiquated some things have gotten. DBus is the best desktop IPC option on Linux, and that's not really a great thing in my opinion. Likewise, it sucks that most file archivers still work by popening some command and parsing its output, occasionally breaking on edge cases, usually having limited support for the kinds of advanced functionality you'd get in Windows archive tools. I do understand that making actually-good applications takes time, but over the course of the past couple decades it doesn't feel like much progress has been made here. I mean hell, speaking of archive tools... FreeBSD has been working on libarchive for ages and it'll likely be integrated with fucking Windows before it's integrated with common Linux desktops, which will probably mostly farm out to CLI tools like unar and zip directly. This is the same approach, with the same exact problems, that I remember being used as far back as when I started using Linux, in programs like Xfe.

Needless to say... my feelings are complicated.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by marcus_holmes on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:27PM (#37866239)
using KDE Plasma, which isn't bad, and is configurable enough :)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by gnyman on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:00AM (#37866881)
Have you looked at Q4OS with the windows theme pack? https://q4os.org/ and https://xpq4.sourceforge.io/

It's does not seem well known but it looks and works very closely to old Windows.

I have a side project plan to take this, combine it with a decent laptop, pre install libreoffice and a browser and sell it as "Stable OS" with a long term "no-change" policy to anyone who just needs a basic computer where not everything changes at the whim of someone looking for a item on their resume.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by MenhirMike on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:09PM (#37866128)
Windows 2000 was the last truly great Windows for me. It was the last Windows version that had a working "Find in File Contents" feature without having to install grepwin.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by l0b0 on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:20AM (#37866621)
Recursive agree to all the above, purely in terms of UI/UX.

Firefox currently has about 20x20 pixels next to the tabs to grab and move the window, and "always show scrollbars" is off by default. This would be reasonable on a phone, but not on any kind of machine with a mouse.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bonton89 on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:08PM (#37872896)
Can you not right click and enable menu bar to get the traditional menu (plus a title bar of sorts) back for this?

I'm not really defending firefox UI to strongly here, I use it every day as my browser of choice and I find the defaults wonky but at least customizable.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hulitu on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:42PM (#37873993)
Firefox is also highjacking the title bar.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:06PM (#37876582)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:41AM (#37897156)
> Can you not right click and enable menu bar to get the traditional menu

FF has a great compromise setting, keeps the menu bar hidden by default but it appears when you press (the CUA standard keys) [Alt] or [F10]. (At least on Windows, that is.)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by worik on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:38AM (#37866749)
Windows 3.1 for me
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by codetrotter on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:56AM (#37866861)
Well. Someone had to say it :p
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Fatnino on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:24AM (#37867013)
If you double click in the top left corner of most windows they will close. Leftover behavior from 3.1
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Narishma on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:02AM (#37869636)
No, it worked like that since the very first Windows version.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Fatnino on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:30PM (#37876730)
Fair, but after win3.1 there wasn't a menu up in that corner anymore.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @05:11AM (#37897364)
> Fair, but after win3.1 there wasn't a menu up in that corner anymore.

WTF are you on about?!? There still is!

Source: Just clicked on the top-left icons on a few programs in Windows 10. Not guideline-defying shit like Microsoft Office / Outlook / Edge / Teams, of course, but programs that follow the Windows developer guidelines display the standard menu just like they've always done: Restore, Move, Size, Minimize, Maximize, Close (usually also displaying the shortcut key, [Alt-F4]). Notepad++ does, WinSCP does, 7-Zip does, PuTTY does, SAS client software does, Teradata client software does... Seems most built-in Windows utilities do, too: File Explorer does, Task Manager does, Command Prompt does, Notepad does, Paint does, Snipping Tool does...

Seems you have to go out of your way to build a Windows app that doesn't have a system menu up in the top-left corner. (Start building a Windows application in most IDEs I've used, and unless you change the default settings it sure gets one automatically.) So why do you spout such drivel, when you obviously have no idea what you're talking about?

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Fatnino on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:12AM (#37926402)
Because I haven't used windows in over 5 years. I apparently conflated the space bar icon being absent with the idea of the entire menu being gone.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Thursday October 19, 2023 @06:17AM (#37940810)
Still quite a bit of time between "after win3.1" and "over 5 years". Like, almost thirty years now where that exact icon has, OK, "been absent" -- but replaced with other icons in the exact same spot. Did you never, even by mistake, click on one of those in all those over twenty years? Wow, you must be a lot better than I at mouse control. And / or a lot less curious.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Fatnino on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:50PM (#37952200)
I'm certainly better at something control...
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by xtracto on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:56AM (#37867210)
I never understood the switch between win3 groups and windows based view to the START menu and sub sub sub menus view. I preferred the former.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hulitu on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:17AM (#37867337)
From an usability perspective Windows 3.1 is better than Windows 10. You have scrollbars, titlebars, window menu and a window border.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Mikhail_Edoshin on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:23AM (#37867371)
Especially with the Dashboard shell [1]. Was very convenient: compact, always at your fingertips, with extended virtual desktop, fully configurable and stable: you lay out things some way, they stay this way.

It is interesting that modern UIs keep removing agency from the user. There is very little space in the system that feels mine because I am the sole owner of it. On Windows 3.1 I managed everything in the program groups. It was not too convenient (compared to that Dashboard shell or Mac), but still, if the system added a group now and then, I could always take it apart and rearrange to my liking.

Now the Start menu is completely taken over. The ability to manually arrange things in a folder is taken away. The folders that should be rightfully mine (such as Documents) are constantly invaded by every program that feels entitled to put things there. As a result “we do not go there anymore.” The only places that are left for me to manage are: the area to the right of the start menu and the desktop. But I do not like the start menu and do not like cluttering the desktop, so the only place I still govern is a tiny custom toolbar I added to the taskbar.

[1] https://winworldpc.com/product/dashboard/30

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by WarOnPrivacy on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:07AM (#37871482)
> Now the Start menu is completely taken over.

Which brings this conversation full circle.

The Windows 10 Start Menu scrollbar is unclickably skinny.

It is supposed to expand when you stop your workflow to undertake the Hover-Your-Pointer-Tip-Over-The-Miniscule-Scrollbar Ordeal. If you win, the scrollbar will typically expand to something less difficult. But expansion doesn't happen so reliably that it has your full trust.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by eastern on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:35AM (#37869049)
At least till XP, and maybe 7 too, you had progman.exe and fileman.exe in the Win folder.

All you had to was set shell=progman.exe in (I think) win.ini. Or maybe in the other .ini but it was possible.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by supportengineer on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:53AM (#37866839)
After a few small tweaks, Windows 7 Professional was a cat. Purring in my lap cause it loves me.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by happymellon on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:46AM (#37867134)
> After a few small tweaks

Hence why it was worse.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:56AM (#37872021)
But at least you could tweak it to make it reasonable.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Sohcahtoa82 on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:49PM (#37872666)
Windows 7 with the Classic theme was peak UI/UX, IMO. It's been downhill ever since.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:43AM (#37897174)
> Windows 7 with the Classic theme was peak UI/UX, IMO.

Yup. Until some point midway through its lifetime, when they started disabling (at least some) detailed UI settings even via the Registry.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Varriount on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:48AM (#37867148)
This is something that's always puzzled me - why is searching in Windows always so gosh darn slow? You'd think with an entire background service dedicated to file indexing, I'd be able to quickly find files in a directory tree with the word "foo" in their file name or contents, but even with a modern SSD it still takes at least a minute on any remotely populated directory.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by xtracto on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:53AM (#37867200)
File search in graphical Linux is terrible as well.

Just the other day i was trying to do sone simple file search in Mint and oh god the GUI search function is completely useless. I had to jump around installing 3 "file search" programs, none of them really worked and at the end I settled with some console bash magic. ... its 2023 people.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by anthk on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:51AM (#37868351)
With Linux the best option it's to use recoll to create a database and a GUI to search into your documents.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hulitu on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:36PM (#37873939)
Locate works great.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Jenda_ on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:41PM (#37875394)
Locate is for file names, not file contents.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by deepspace on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:36PM (#37876359)
ripgrep for contents
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:37PM (#37876764)
ripgrep is fast for what it is. But indexes are faster.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Jenda_ on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:47PM (#37876819)
Additionally, I would expect indexing to extract text contents from non-plain-text formats. (such as Recoll does)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by xtracto on Saturday October 14, 2023 @02:23AM (#37878505)
How's its GUI? you know, because I was talking about GUI based file searching.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by dzonga on Monday October 16, 2023 @10:31AM (#37900365)
yep on linux have to use catfish file search
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by AuryGlenz on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:51AM (#37867541)
It blows my mind that third party applications are better at search than the freaking OS.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:54AM (#37872003)
And that it's not only been that way for a lot of years, but it's getting worse with time. It's utterly baffling to me.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by SturgeonsLaw on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:03AM (#37870109)
Microsoft should just buy Everything off Voidtools because they have perfected Windows search and it boggles my mind that Microsoft can't recreate that.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by velox_neb on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:32PM (#37875287)
> Microsoft should just buy Everything off Voidtools

Don't give them ideas, they'd find some way to ruin it.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by MenhirMike on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:55PM (#37875524)
Azure Voidtools, powered by Cortana AI. Microsoft Account required for use.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by rob74 on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:45AM (#37867514)
I was a fan of Google Desktop Search - that was actually able to find relevant content in my files, and it was fast. But Google killed it as soon as they decided to drive everyone into the cloud. Supposedly all major OSes have such a search functionality integrated nowadays, but for some reason it doesn't really work, and I'm never motivated enough to find out how to fix it...
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by anthk on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:51AM (#37868355)
Recoll it's close to Google Desktop Search.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by marczellm on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:23AM (#37868570)
I still have the installer lying around somewhere, do you need it? :)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by albert_e on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:44AM (#37868702)
May be they are so busy figuring out how to upload our data to their servers and sneak in clauses in their terms and conditions to cover it ... that they forgot to build the actual functionality of showing search results to user.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by fuzztester on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:41PM (#37876398)
Same with Google Talk (as in, was good, then killed by Google). This is their text chat and voice chat app before crapware like Hangouts. Not tried Duo or Meet.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by mort96 on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:51AM (#37870001)
I won't argue against Windows 2000's usability. But I will say that to me, as someone who first started using computers in the XP era, any Windows earlier than Windows 7 looks so god damn ugly to me, and Windows 2000 even more so than XP.

Interestingly though, I don't have the same impression when looking at the old Apple OSes. To me, Mac OS 9 looks old, but not ugly.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bluGill on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:25AM (#37870324)
Pretty/ugly and usable are very different things. Sometimes they are in conflict, but mostly they are unrelated.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by MenhirMike on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:12AM (#37871537)
To me, XP and Vista looked like a terrible attempt at replicating Mac OS X when that all wow'ed us - it's hard to imagine these days just how big of a deal the iMac and later on OS X were in terms of moving away from grey boxes everywhere (though sometimes too far, since Windows 7 really toned down and refined XP/Vista's UI).

For me, I grew up on Amiga Workbench 2.0 and MS-DOS, so Windows NT/2000 felt like a good evolution from it's User Interface. Very functional, for sure.

100% agree on Classic MacOS. As outdated as the tech was, it was beautiful because it was elegant without being distracting.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by deepspace on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:38PM (#37876376)
To the contrary, XP and Vista' soft, round buttons and edges always made me think of a Douglas-Adamsian dystopia. Win2000 was bare bones, square and functional.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by lstamour on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:09PM (#37866136)
Everything old is new again? I remember when people were deriding Windows XP for being "Fisher-Price" in appearance and preferring to run Windows 2000 because it was more stable (until roughly SP2 came out, which basically was an entirely new OS released as a service pack).

Windows 7, which was Vista's equivalent to SP2 also has some fans. Heck, I'd even personally argue that Windows ME has some niceties not seen in subsequent releases, particularly when combined with Active Desktop (which I'm pretty sure did not survive the transition to XP).

I wonder if/when some subset of users will prefer a more controlled window layout engine, one which always opens windows into their own "space" on the screen. To that end, I don't actually mind how iPad does its window layout, I just wish iPad had all the features and openness of macOS to install your own drivers, background apps and virtual devices/mixing. A simpler UI can actually be a good thing, but you shouldn't lose functionality when making things simpler. A simpler UI doesn't necessarily mean less complex operating system...

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by addicted on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:11PM (#37866150)
> until roughly SP2 came out, which basically was an entirely new OS released as a service pack

SP2 was fantastic. For me personally, Windows XP means XP SP2. Anything before that wasn’t worth using.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by marcus_holmes on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:27PM (#37866243)
Yes. XP == SP2 :)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hulitu on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:25AM (#37867384)
> For me personally, Windows XP means XP SP2. Anything before that wasn’t worth using.

That is because Microsoft had its own versioning system:

- RC was alpha quality.

- Releases were betas.

and then starting with SP2 one can talk about a released product. NT had 6 SPs, 2000 had 4, XP had 2. Even in Windows 11 they fixed things (taskbar) after release.

This really tells a not so nice story about engineering and quality at Microsoft.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by tonyedgecombe on Saturday October 14, 2023 @06:28AM (#37879424)
SP2 was largely about security issues. Before then XP was riddled with vulnerabilities.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by nar001 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @08:36AM (#37879999)
XP had 3 service packs not 2!
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by mildred593 on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:35PM (#37874605)
The only thing I remember is that I would never install SP2 because of EULA. I don't remember the specifics though. Around that time I started mostly using Linux anyway.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by inferiorhuman on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:33AM (#37866708)
Ya know one of the first things I do on an XP install is to go in and disable as much of UI faffing about as I can. It takes a couple of clicks, but once you disable themes in XP you get something that looks quite a lot like Windows 2000.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by arcanemachiner on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:52AM (#37866829)
I did it because my computer was a POS. But then it turns out I have a minimalism kink, so I've been doing that ever since.

I use XFCE btw

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by inferiorhuman on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:36AM (#37867075)
Yep I got into the habit of doing that because I run XP in a virtual machine for legacy junk. I actually had opportunity to run classic MacOS recently and realize that I largely prefer the 10.x UI especially once they started toning down the decorations. Classic MacOS got a lot of things right that are missing in current operating systems, but man is it ugly.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by happymellon on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:49AM (#37867161)
> I use XFCE btw

No offense, but I cannot possibly trust your judgement when you use a DE that, by default, is the classic example of no window borders for the mouse to grab onto.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by arcanemachiner on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:48AM (#37867939)
Alt + click-and-drag solves that problem.

Also I use i3 so my windows are tiled most of the time.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by happymellon on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:58AM (#37868017)
Having boarders that are bigger than 1px would solve that problem.

Anything else is a work around poor UX.

The fact that decades later it is still an issue is really disappointing.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by arcanemachiner on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:40AM (#37868281)
Agree to disagree I guess. I don't need a window border when I can drag/resize the window from anywhere in that window.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:00PM (#37872058)
I do need window borders. A good interface would allow enough configuration that we both could have what we want.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by happymellon on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:49PM (#37874779)
Agreed.

I don't "agree to disagree", they offer a function that's unusable.

It would be the equivalent of MacOS breaking the ability to double click on an app.

But it's okay because you could use Spotlight.

That's great and all, but if everything else allows double clicking and MacOS allowed double clicking but only on the absolute centre pixel, we would all consider it broken.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by arcanemachiner on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:41PM (#37877681)
For me it's more like being disappointed that there's no way to crank start the engine in my car instead of using the key.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by nickserv on Sunday October 15, 2023 @05:19AM (#37888253)
Some older (pre 21st century ) motorcycles have a kick starter in addition to the electric one, and it does actually come in handy.

On newer bikes if the starter fails or the battery dies you need to unceremoniously push the bike to speed, jump on and put it on first.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:37AM (#37897131)
> Some older (pre 21st century ) motorcycles have a kick starter in addition to the electric one, and it does actually come in handy.

AFAIK quite a lot of 21st-century motorbikes still have that. (Some of them probably still only have that.)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:35AM (#37897116)
> A good interface would allow enough configuration that we both could have what we want.

Like Windows, from at least 3.1 (ca 1987?) to at least mid-life of Windows 7 (ca 2012-14?). The item under discussion, window border width, used to be settable from 0 up to... Pretty much all of your screen. (But from some update somewhere halfway through W7, it defaulted to at least one pixel however hard you tried to set it to zero.)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by fuzztester on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:49PM (#37876456)
>Having boarders that are bigger than 1px would solve that problem.

In a world without borders, there would be no problem of Gates.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by adrian_b on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:25AM (#37868199)
This must depend on how you configure it.

I do not remember how I have configured it, perhaps the window border width is determined by the window theme (I use Chicago95), but I have also been using XFCE for many years and I have decent-sized window borders on my 4k monitors and my mouse theme (Hackneyed 48x48) has extremely obvious mouse cursor shape changes whenever you touch the window borders, so they are easy to grab.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by happymellon on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:42AM (#37871169)
It is defined by the theme.

The default theme that XFCE ships with has a 1px grabbing area set. So it's not that the cursor doesn't change, it's just you have to be very precise.

There are "fixes" where people hack the theme to increase the size of some transparent images to force a larger grabble area or telling people that they are holding it wrong.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by stolsvik on Sunday October 15, 2023 @04:21PM (#37893065)
On many Linux DEs you have “Alt-drag” and “Alt-resize”. It is absolutely amazing, and luckily there are hacks to get that on Windows too.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by masklinn on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:01AM (#37866890)
> Everything old is new again? I remember when people were deriding Windows XP for being "Fisher-Price" in appearance and preferring to run Windows 2000 because it was more stable

That’s more of a truth universally acknowledged. XP was goofy then, it’s goofy now, and it was goofy at every instant between.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by nerdponx on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:27AM (#37867029)
Yes but hindsight endearingly so. And the UX itself was still really good. The start menu in particular was an actual improvement over the old one, as were the clickable login screen icons.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by shiroiuma on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:46AM (#37867921)
The usability was very good. The appearance was goofy and Fisher-Price-like. The two things are mostly orthogonal.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Fluorescence on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:39AM (#37868663)
I wouldn't say orthogonal. Making something inviting, approachable and feel like a safe place to experiment/explore for a novice is a critical and overlooked part of usability. The childlike choices of "bright primary colours" and "no sharp edges" is one way to attempt that.

It's what the general public needs that us nerds can least relate to.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by shiroiuma on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:31PM (#37895036)
It might have been good for brand-new users and children, but not all computer users are like that. It would have been much better if they had had selectable themes.

The best-looking Windows UI, IMO, was Vista.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:24AM (#37897062)
> It might have been good for brand-new users and children, but not all computer users are like that.

Well, are you sure which of those groups you belong to? At least as far as Windows is concerned? Because:

> It would have been much better if they had had selectable themes.

It did. One click in the right place in the Control Panel and it looked like W95/NT4/W2K. (So did Windows 7, and therefore I must assume Vista, too. [Skipped that one myself.])

But, hey, brand-new users and children couldn't be expected to find that, right?

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by shiroiuma on Monday October 16, 2023 @05:36AM (#37897514)
I was a Linux user back then (and still am). I didn't spend enough time with XP to bother learning intricacies like that.

Plus, W2K was ugly too, just in a different way.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @06:38AM (#37897905)
> I was a Linux user back then (and still am). I didn't spend enough time with XP to bother learning intricacies like that.

Then why spend time commenting -- ERRONEOUSLY -- on them now?

> Plus, W2K was ugly too, just in a different way.

Über den Geschmack streiten sich selbst die Götter vergebens.

Anyway, point stands:

> > It would have been much better if they had had selectable themes.

> It did.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by eastern on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:33AM (#37869038)
You could switch the theme (at least in SP2) to look basically like 2000, which is what I always did. You could actually do that in 7 too.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:58AM (#37872034)
It may have looked goofy, but it was usable. I'll take ugly/goofy and usable over pretty and hard-to-use every single time.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by tonyedgecombe on Saturday October 14, 2023 @06:30AM (#37879431)
You shouldn't need to make that trade off though. There is no rule that says a usable interface has to be ugly.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:25AM (#37897071)
You didn't need to. Select the W95/NT4/W2K theme in the "Appearance" Control Panel, and done.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:20AM (#37897045)
> XP was goofy then, it’s goofy now, and it was goofy at every instant between.

Only if you didn't/don't know how to use it. Like, for instance, where to click to make it look like W95/NT4/W2K.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by atahanacar on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:51AM (#37867172)
>I wonder if/when some subset of users will prefer a more controlled window layout engine, one which always opens windows into their own "space" on the screen.

You are describing tiling window manager users.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:18AM (#37897028)
> I remember when people were deriding Windows XP for being "Fisher-Price" in appearance and preferring to run Windows 2000 because it was more stable

Yeah, most people apparently never noticed the Control Panel setting in XP where you could with one click activate the W95/NT4/W2K interface in stead of the "Fisher-Price" one. Worked in Vista and Windows 7 too, but there they started to remove ever more of the detailed UI customisation settings from the Control Panel. (For a while, you could change them by editing the Registry, but towards the end of W7's lifetime, at least some of those didn't take effect any more.)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by addicted on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:10PM (#37866141)
I thought Windows 7 was pretty good.

Vista eliminated the Fisher Priceness of XP but added a whole bunch of glowing and reflective stuff, which Windows 7 toned down dramatically.

I don’t remember if Win 7 still allowed you to have the classic start menu, but I do believe I was ok with what it did have.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by fsckboy on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:55PM (#37866445)
there's a great add-on called... ClassicShell http://classicshell.net/

I stopped using windows after Using Win10 for a short time, but ClassicShell was always maintained and worked flawlessly... oh, dev stopped in 2017. oh well.

the source was released and there is a fork that has recent changes https://github.com/Open-Shell/Open-Shell-Menu

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by BlueTemplar on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:26AM (#37867792)
There are more things than graphics : the ability to search the start menu was a huge improvement in Win7 (or was that Vista ?)

It's Windows 8 that wrecked things, by making the two-way correspondence between the start menu and a folder of icons basically void.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:02PM (#37872079)
Of all the versions of the Windows UI, Win 7 was -- for me -- the best by far. Nothing else even comes close, and everything from Win 8 on has been substantially worse.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by jeffparsons on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:10PM (#37866142)
I might be getting old, too. (Born 1987.) I have also come to regard Windows XP as the pinnacle of personal computing UI. Almost everything that followed, regardless of vendor, feels like a step in the wrong direction.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by tetris11 on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:26AM (#37867393)
Same, and same. It was pretty optimal too, where i remember getting the number of BG tasks down to 15 and I knew what each every one did. I haven't been able to make that claim for an OS for many many years now.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @07:39AM (#37898334)
> I might be getting old, too. (Born 1987.)

Muahaha... Heh. Please don't say stuff stuff like that, kid.

Because if you are "old", then... What are many of the rest of us, antique?

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by TerrifiedMouse on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:15PM (#37866168)
Win95 default was peak Windows UI for me. It had proper shading so you can see the window edges. Min/max/close buttons were high contrast and easy to see, and were big enough to easily click. Window titles were high contrast and clear. The UI was light and snappy unlike XP’s.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:27PM (#37866237)
What was worse in Windows 98? Or Windows 2000?
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by forgotmypw17 on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:20AM (#37866628)
Active Desktop and IE Windows Explorer, for one thing.

But also, generally, the difference is that Windows 95 still feels like a "workstation" computer, designed for maximum readability and clarity, while staying in the background and not drawing any attention to itself.

With Windows 98, the OS begins trying to look pretty, which means having more elements and style choices which take attention away from the work.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:39AM (#37866759)
You could turn off Active Desktop and IE Windows Explorer? And what in Windows 98 or Windows 2000 took attention away from the work?
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by forgotmypw17 on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:03AM (#37868049)
It can be turned off, but it can't be turned off. It's still there, lurking just around the corner, and still showing up in some dialogs.

And I think this is exactly what many people's complaints are in this thread: an interface that is faulty out of the box that needs to be "tuned" in order to change it from an entertainer back into a workstation.

I haven't played with Windows 98 and Windows 2000 in a while, but I remember all sorts of "improvements" over Windows 95, such as sliding menus, "shiny" icons that draw attention to themselves, "shiny" gradient title bars, and so on.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:35PM (#37877065)
Lurking how? What dialogs?

The article complained about things which were not configurable or not easily configurable. So did many comments.

Judicious animation has well studied benefits. I do not see how Windows 98's icons were more attention grabbing. Gradient title bars help locate the buttons in my experience.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by forgotmypw17 on Thursday October 19, 2023 @02:50PM (#37946964)
> Lurking how? What dialogs?

I do not use Windows 98 as my daily driver, and I can't give you precise examples.

But I know that many areas of the OS, such as parts of the Control Panel, like the Display control panel require, load into memory, and include IE modules.

> I do not see how Windows 98's icons were more attention grabbing. Gradient title bars help locate the buttons in my experience.

I hope you are aware that these are subjective.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by somat on Sunday October 15, 2023 @03:06AM (#37887584)
If I remember correctly turning off active desktop on 98 was almost a requirement if you wanted a ... I was going to say stable system but lets be real this was 98 the best you could hope for was a sort of stable system.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by TerrifiedMouse on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:54AM (#37866847)
> What was worse in Windows 98? Or Windows 2000?

Nothing. Those are just touch ups of the Win95 UI. Smoother color gradients from using more colors and smoother animation.

XP was the next big change. Never liked it. Felt like I was dragging around bitmaps. It’s “heavily” for no reason - no usability improvement nor does it even look that good.

Edit: Oh right I forgot about Active Desktop and MS’s attempt to turn Windows Explorer into Internet Explorer. Not a fan of it but at least it didn’t impair usability that much. Visually it still use the same “language”.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by einr on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:24AM (#37868571)
https://gekk.info/articles/images/explorer/98_explorer.png

All this crap to the left in Explorer windows that takes up space for no good reason. Active Desktop. Uglier icons that are inconsistent with the many older Win 95-style icons that remain everywhere in the OS. It's not that bad on the whole, and you can reverse most of it, but it's a bloating and bastardization of the (unironically) finely honed aesthetic of Win95.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:44PM (#37877113)
The left area was used for information like file size, disk usage, and image preview. There have been better implementations. But Windows 98 could suit either preference.

Windows 98's icons look very similar to Windows 95's. Windows 2000's look better and more consistent to me.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Clamchop on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:18PM (#37866185)
I'd tack a few more features onto it, like multiple desktops, and give it a small face-lift to make it just a wee less ugly.

But yeah.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:26PM (#37866232)
Windows XP couldn't search the start menu.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by marcus_holmes on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:30PM (#37866272)
I didn't say it was perfect ;) Just better than everything that came after it
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:02AM (#37866499)
You said we should have stopped there.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by marcus_holmes on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:44AM (#37866779)
Yes. Because XP with no ability to search the start menu is better than everything that came after it.

That doesn't mean that XP was perfect. There are still faults with it.

But if fixing those faults means iterating on it more, then I'm happy with not.

Things can be imperfect and still better than everything else.

Does that make sense?

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by AlexandrB on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:04AM (#37866514)
That's why Launchy exists: http://www.launchy.net/

Incidentally, I still use it in Windows 10. Probably more out of habit than anything else.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by t_mahmood on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:37AM (#37867472)
Oh! Blast from the past! I loved this app, when I was a Windows user. The workflow is still with me, in a gnome extension.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by johnnyworker on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:48PM (#37872647)
https://open-shell.github.io/Open-Shell-Menu/

I use it because it rocks more than anything else :)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bandrami on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:30PM (#37866263)
Same time frame: GNUStep/Windowmaker on the Linux side of things, also something of a high water mark. It's really weird to me how much interfaces have degraded in the past two decades.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by robomartin on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:16AM (#37866595)
I thought Silicon Graphics Irix was pretty nice back in the day. I used to work with Onyx and Onyx 2 machines. Amazing hardware at the time.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chankstein38 on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:41AM (#37870498)
I swear they actually are actively trying to make the "Control Panel" / system settings experience worse with each iteration for sure. 90% of 10 and 11's system settings feel like they just took the original Control Panel screen and hid it, exposed 2-3 of the least valuable options, and displayed them in a weird solid-colored screen. To me the only way to adjust most windows settings is to find the "Advanced settings" link in the solid-colored window that will bring up the original control panels.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @06:50AM (#37897973)
Put a shortcut to

    C:\Windows\System32\control.exe
or

    C:\Windows\SysWOW64\control.exe
into your Start menu. HTH!
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by zamadatix on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:38PM (#37872506)
I'd love the windows 2000 style classic theme with the overall customizability improvements in XP with the UI feature sets of newer versions.

E.g. booting up 2000 by itself it absolutely sucks. I mean, it looks great... but you can't tile windows, you can't resize the command prompt dynamically, you don't have DPI support, a lot of the little victories like pinning and grouping aren't there, the way it draws often causes ghost trails, virtual desktops aren't a thing, a surprising number of things were modal when they didn't need to be. It has great parts but the problem isn't newer versions threw them all away with no improvement it's that not every change was an improvement.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by quantified on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:06PM (#37876136)
I'd go with Win 7.

Mac is all secret handshakes, nothing discoverable, terrible af keyboard-primary work. Windows was very good at letting you stay on the keyboard.

In the spirit of scroll bar discussion, the standard of Ctrl-Home, Crtl-End, Shift-Ctrl-Home and Shift-Ctrl-End are so good. No such "begin of doc" and "end of doc" on a Mac except if an app wills it.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by cmiller1 on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:52PM (#37876843)
Cmd up or down arrow
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by quantified on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:32AM (#37878742)
Ok, except for default intellij key bindings, that works. Thank you.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by GuB-42 on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:12PM (#37876183)
I'd go up to Windows 7.

From Windows 95 to Windows 7, the UI fundamentally stayed the same, with a few details here and there, including, scroll bars, window title bars and borders.

Essentially, what changed is just cosmetic and mostly as a result of better hardware. Earlier versions of Windows were designed for 256 color displays, Windows XP fully embraced 24-bit color, and Windows 7 was designed with GPUs in mind. That's how we got from pixel art to shading to semi-transparency.

And I must admit I liked Windows 7 because it was both functional and pretty. A nice, modern for the time skin on top of tried and tested UI core concepts.

Windows 8 broke everything as an attempt to unify the desktop and mobile experience, and we haven't recovered since then. In fact, I think mobile killed desktop usability. We are in a conundrum that we didn't find a way to resolve: desktop and mobile are fundamentally different platforms, so they would need different UI paradigms, but there is an overlap functionality as many apps are present on both platforms, so it would be nice to provide the same experience on both.

To that, add the fact that the web is often third or a fourth option (mobile and desktop web), and the ability to use native controls in web browsers is rather poor, so people make their own, but then, you want the website to look like the desktop app. Same kind of problem.