SP2 was fantastic. For me personally, Windows XP means XP SP2. Anything before that wasn’t worth using.
That is because Microsoft had its own versioning system:
- RC was alpha quality.
- Releases were betas.
and then starting with SP2 one can talk about a released product. NT had 6 SPs, 2000 had 4, XP had 2. Even in Windows 11 they fixed things (taskbar) after release.
This really tells a not so nice story about engineering and quality at Microsoft.
I use XFCE btw
No offense, but I cannot possibly trust your judgement when you use a DE that, by default, is the classic example of no window borders for the mouse to grab onto.
Also I use i3 so my windows are tiled most of the time.
Anything else is a work around poor UX.
The fact that decades later it is still an issue is really disappointing.
I don't "agree to disagree", they offer a function that's unusable.
It would be the equivalent of MacOS breaking the ability to double click on an app.
But it's okay because you could use Spotlight.
That's great and all, but if everything else allows double clicking and MacOS allowed double clicking but only on the absolute centre pixel, we would all consider it broken.
On newer bikes if the starter fails or the battery dies you need to unceremoniously push the bike to speed, jump on and put it on first.
AFAIK quite a lot of 21st-century motorbikes still have that. (Some of them probably still only have that.)
Like Windows, from at least 3.1 (ca 1987?) to at least mid-life of Windows 7 (ca 2012-14?). The item under discussion, window border width, used to be settable from 0 up to... Pretty much all of your screen. (But from some update somewhere halfway through W7, it defaulted to at least one pixel however hard you tried to set it to zero.)
In a world without borders, there would be no problem of Gates.
I do not remember how I have configured it, perhaps the window border width is determined by the window theme (I use Chicago95), but I have also been using XFCE for many years and I have decent-sized window borders on my 4k monitors and my mouse theme (Hackneyed 48x48) has extremely obvious mouse cursor shape changes whenever you touch the window borders, so they are easy to grab.
The default theme that XFCE ships with has a 1px grabbing area set. So it's not that the cursor doesn't change, it's just you have to be very precise.
There are "fixes" where people hack the theme to increase the size of some transparent images to force a larger grabble area or telling people that they are holding it wrong.
That’s more of a truth universally acknowledged. XP was goofy then, it’s goofy now, and it was goofy at every instant between.
It's what the general public needs that us nerds can least relate to.
The best-looking Windows UI, IMO, was Vista.
Well, are you sure which of those groups you belong to? At least as far as Windows is concerned? Because:
> It would have been much better if they had had selectable themes.
It did. One click in the right place in the Control Panel and it looked like W95/NT4/W2K. (So did Windows 7, and therefore I must assume Vista, too. [Skipped that one myself.])
But, hey, brand-new users and children couldn't be expected to find that, right?
Plus, W2K was ugly too, just in a different way.
Then why spend time commenting -- ERRONEOUSLY -- on them now?
> Plus, W2K was ugly too, just in a different way.
Über den Geschmack streiten sich selbst die Götter vergebens.
Anyway, point stands:
> > It would have been much better if they had had selectable themes.
> It did.
Only if you didn't/don't know how to use it. Like, for instance, where to click to make it look like W95/NT4/W2K.
You are describing tiling window manager users.
Yeah, most people apparently never noticed the Control Panel setting in XP where you could with one click activate the W95/NT4/W2K interface in stead of the "Fisher-Price" one. Worked in Vista and Windows 7 too, but there they started to remove ever more of the detailed UI customisation settings from the Control Panel. (For a while, you could change them by editing the Registry, but towards the end of W7's lifetime, at least some of those didn't take effect any more.)
Windows 7, which was Vista's equivalent to SP2 also has some fans. Heck, I'd even personally argue that Windows ME has some niceties not seen in subsequent releases, particularly when combined with Active Desktop (which I'm pretty sure did not survive the transition to XP).
I wonder if/when some subset of users will prefer a more controlled window layout engine, one which always opens windows into their own "space" on the screen. To that end, I don't actually mind how iPad does its window layout, I just wish iPad had all the features and openness of macOS to install your own drivers, background apps and virtual devices/mixing. A simpler UI can actually be a good thing, but you shouldn't lose functionality when making things simpler. A simpler UI doesn't necessarily mean less complex operating system...