News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by allturtles on Friday March 24, 2023 @08:52PM (#35297840)
A lot of people in these comments still seem confused about what has happened here.

This ruling is not about the emergency library at all. It's a ruling that controlled digital lending (one physical copy backing each digital copy lent out) is illegal.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by warent on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:27PM (#35298135)
That seems horrendous. Don't many community/government libraries do this? Seems like a huge blow to freedom of information and sharing.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dmix on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:36PM (#35298211)
Is this just ebook lending? Is that popular among local libraries?

I thought Kindle/Nook/Apple books/etc completely dominated that market. Reading PDFs on computers/tablets for long form stuff never made much sense to me. I'm curious if local libraries get much traction from their digital libraries.

I could see audiobooks getting locked down being a big hit though. Audible has a monopoly on that harder than ebooks ever experienced.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by jhbadger on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:38PM (#35298230)
It's very popular among local libraries (at least in the US and UK) -- Libby/Overdrive being the main player, followed by Hoopla.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Mindwipe on Saturday March 25, 2023 @06:05AM (#35301160)
It is worth noting that Libraries in the UK have to pay authors/publishers to loan out books on a royalty basis with the Public Lending Right payment of course. Even physical books.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by cratermoon on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:59PM (#35298362)
My library lends epubs through OverDrive, which puts Adobe's DRM on them. It works quite well with my Kobo Libra H2O. Checkouts of ebooks spiked during the pandemic, with 3 million in 2019, for a county with a total population of ~800K
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by boomboomsubban on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:26PM (#35298569)
>Checkouts of ebooks spiked during the pandemic, with 3 million in 2019, for a county with a total population of ~800K

Did you mean 2020? Or did they spike before the pandemic really started?

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by cratermoon on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:54AM (#35299886)
Sorry, those were two different thoughts. I only have numbers for 2019. I haven't been able to find anything for pandemic years other than general reports that ebook borrowing spiked.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dunham on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:38PM (#35298666)
My ten year old uses "Libby" a lot to borrow books from the local library - at one point they started rate limiting him. He also typically has a dozen physical books checked out at any given time.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dmix on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:26PM (#35298998)
Just curious: What kind of books do they read? On an ipad or something?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by piceas on Saturday March 25, 2023 @04:14AM (#35300540)
For my five year old, we have been rate limited on overdrive reading Pete the Cat and Franklin books. Partly because the selection is woeful (about 20 English books) compared to IA's thousands in that category.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by efreak on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:12PM (#35413430)
If a book exists in overdrive, they allow you to request that your library add it to their collection. My first two requests were added to my library within days, several others came a few months later, and now about 4(?) years later I'm still getting an occasional notification about it, though at this point I've read them already...
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dunham on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:17PM (#35310444)
Yeah, on an iPad. He reads a variety of stuff, but he tells me it's been pokemon themed manga recently. We limit screen time, so he mostly reads print books, but he'll get an hour of bonus libby time in the mornings on school holidays. His fun screen time, 30 min weekdays, 1.5 weekends is typically minecraft or pokemon games.

I also occasionally let him have a little bit of Libby or scratch time (which I deem "educational") before going to school or before bed. (Everything is contingent on behavior.)

Aside from minecraft/pokemon stuff, he typically reads a mix of kids graphic novels and books. Including Tristan Strong, Artimis Fowl, Wings of Fire, Dogman. He's also read Harry Potter, some Terry Pratchett, and Tolkien. He first read the Lord of the Rings in the summer between first and second grade, which blew my mind (it was middle or high school or me). So I don't really worry about stuff like the ratio of graphic novels to textual books.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by bdowling on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:44PM (#35298263)
> Don't many community/government libraries do this?

Those books are licensed to the libraries by the publishers. The introduction of the opinion here explains how it works:

> This dispute concerns the way libraries lend ebooks. Public and academic libraries in the United States spend billions of dollars each year obtaining print books and ebooks for their patrons to borrow for free. Pls.’ 56.1 ¶ 113. Libraries usually buy their print books from publishers or wholesalers. Id. ¶ 114. Copies of ebooks, however, are typically not bought but licensed to libraries from publishers through distributors called “aggregators.” Id. ¶ 117. The Publishers task aggregators with ensuring that a library lends its ebooks only to the library’s members. Id. ¶¶ 123, 125. The Publishers also require aggregators to employ approved “digital rights management” (“DRM”) software and other security measures to prevent unauthorized copying or distribution of ebook files. Id. ¶ 126.

https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.53..., page 3 (emphasis added).

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by encryptluks2 on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:50PM (#35298310)
So then IA just needs to have a free membership and implement the most basic DRM.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by teraflop on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:52PM (#35298327)
Libraries' ebook lending programs are not legal because they require membership and use DRM. They're legal because they're authorized by the copyright owners, and those are the terms the copyright owners choose to impose (along with licensing fees).
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by drdaeman on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:56PM (#35298340)
But if I purchase the paper book, there is - thankfully - no shrink-wrap licensing anywhere that tells me that I can or cannot lend it to anyone, yet I sure hope I can. Why IA can't?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by sparky_z on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:02PM (#35298386)
They can lend the book, they just can't make a copy of it and lend the copy instead.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by eyelidlessness on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:28PM (#35298589)
Which might be legally sound (so says this court, we will presumably hear from others), but it’s logically balderdash. The copyright applies to the “intellectual property” content of the book, not its paper and binding. (I’m sure there are some esoteric exceptions to this because artists gonna art, but I feel confident that I’m representing the vast general case correctly.)

If I rightly own a copy of a book, I don’t think any court within the bounds of absurdity would say I can’t make a digital copy for myself because that’s how I prefer to consume it. Being allowed to lend one finite form but not another equivalent one is definitely something law or license might specify, but that doesn’t mean it makes any kind of sense.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by leeoniya on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:06PM (#35298873)
> a digital copy for myself

"myself" being the operative word here.

you can make 100 copies for yourself. what you can't do is make a copy that you give to someone else while simultaneously retaining access to the original (or another copy).

the way libraries work is by relinquishing posession, which replication would circumvent.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by eyelidlessness on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:11AM (#35299278)
> what you can't do is make a copy that you give to someone else while simultaneously retaining access to the original (or another copy).

I’m pretty sure I can do that.

> the way libraries work is by relinquishing posession

I almost included that I could shred my copy, keeping only the digital equivalent, and still retain the same rights to the work and lending it.

Any individual in IA’s position could do this without fear of legal scrutiny. An organization doing it is under scrutiny not because there’s actual, meaningful copyright violation happening but because they systemized a thing no reasonable person would object to individuals doing.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by tsimionescu on Saturday March 25, 2023 @03:07AM (#35300239)
> I’m pretty sure I can do that.

Not legally.

> I almost included that I could shred my copy, keeping only the digital equivalent, and still retain the same rights to the work and lending it.

This is the part that is not true. For example, you are free to transcribe a book onto a parchement and read it that way, and store the parchment separately from the book for archival purposes, and keep the parchement even if the original book gets destroyed.

However, this is a limited exception to copyright. You are not in fact allowed, at any point before or after the original copy is destroyed, to lend or re-sell the parchment you created. That parchment will forever be an unauthorized copy, but one that you are allowed to use in certain limited ways.

The only wrinkle is that, at least in the EU, when you acquire an authorized digital copy of a work, you are allowed to lend or sell that copy as long as you don't retain access to it during the lending/after the sale. This is allowed even though technically you are technically creating a new copy of the digital work and destroying your own afterwards, but this is an exception specific to digital realms, it can't be extended to digital copies you make of a phyisical work.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by PinkRidingHood on Saturday March 25, 2023 @05:21AM (#35300935)
Does that mean I can take the book, copy it, then resell it, keeping the copy?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Mindwipe on Saturday March 25, 2023 @06:04AM (#35301153)
Obviously there are lots of jurisdictions and you have to hit a broad brush with answers, but generally, no. Your reproduction is only considered to be reasonable by law while you retain the original.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Mezzie on Saturday March 25, 2023 @10:00AM (#35302699)
Now I'm wondering how this would apply in situations where the person doesn't know if they have the original or not.

Inspired by the fact that my emulation of Link's Awakening to play on a screen I could see is technically legal since we had a cartridge stuffed away in a drawer. But for 10-15 years that cartridge lived in a limbo land of 'we used to have that, it might still be around somewhere...'

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by tsimionescu on Saturday March 25, 2023 @02:58AM (#35300194)
I believe this court ruling suggests that, while you are free to make a copy for yourself of a work you legally acquired, and you are free to lend or re-sell the original work you acquired, you are not free to lend or re-sell the copy you made, even if the original doesn't exist anymore.

Basically, the only thing you are legally allowed to sell is the exact copy you bought of a physical representation of a work, assuming it was created by an authorized entity. You do not legally own an abstract copy of the idealized work, you own a physical object which happens to represent a copy of that work.

Note that this is in fact very much how most people would think of copyright. If I buy a book and someone steals it from me, or it is there in my house and it burns down, I don't have some right to now obtain another physical representation of that novel free of charge, or to obtain a copy made by a friend with a xerox. My sole right was to that one physical copy I bought, and that no longer exists.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by HDThoreaun on Monday March 27, 2023 @11:11AM (#35327722)
Can they just buy an ebook instead of a physical copy?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by grey413 on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:54PM (#35298793)
It's worth emphasizing that part of the reason why publishers are happy to work with providing libraries with ebooks is that libraries are extremely good customers. There's something like 100,000 libraries in the US alone. A single organization like the Internet Archive just simply doesn't have the purchasing power to make publishers willing to give up any ground.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by superkuh on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:36PM (#35298213)
https://www.techdirt.com/2023/03/22/book-publishers-wont-sto... is a good overview (from a day or two before the judgement).

>Every part of that has been deemed legal. Copyright law already has first sale rights, written directly into the law and allow for the lending or reselling of copyright-covered works without a license or permission. Similarly libraries are given explicit rights to make copies, so long as those collections are made available to the public. On top of that, courts have determined, multiple times, that book scanning itself is fair use for libraries.

>So, literally each separate component of what is happening with Controlled Digital Lending has already been deemed to be legal and exactly what we expect libraries to do.

>To counter this, publishers (and their supporters, which unfortunately include some authors) argue that (1) this interferes with the market for licensed ebooks, and (2) that there is a real difference in lending out the digital scans: that they don’t deteriorate the way that physical books do.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by granzymes on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:44PM (#35298271)
The article doesn't seem to understand the issue.

Whether a copy of a work is fair use turns on, amongst other things, the effect of the copy on the potential market for the original. The article acknowledges this.

Controlled Digital Lending competes directly with the licensing scheme publishers have for library ebooks. The fair use argument was always doomed to fail.

The article then completely ignores the copyright argument and tries to equate CDL with libraries loaning out their physical copies. This is completely absurd, since libraries do not distribute copies of their physical books and so do not even enter the realm of copyright.

If libraries were systematically distributing copies of their existing books they would be sued for copyright infringement. And no, section 108 does not allow them to do so (see 17 U.S. Code § 108(g)(2), which is why IA did not raise that argument in court).

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by musicale on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:27PM (#35298582)
What IA is doing is removing the physical copy from circulation, making a digital copy, and lending out the digital copy.

I don't see the argument that this is "distribution" any more than regular (obnoxious) ebook lending is.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by refulgentis on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:44PM (#35298726)
Laws a bit more open to interpretation and chaining rarely works, it’s humanist, and it’s at its face unreasonable that one physical copy => right to lend out digital cooy.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by grey413 on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:45PM (#35298730)
If the IA is creating their own digital copies of physical books, it could be argued that that the IA is creating and distributing derivative works. I'm not certain, but my impression is that derivative works have little in the way of legal protection.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by ac29 on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:14PM (#35298924)
The court order discusses this, and says while the first sale doctrine means IA could resell or lend their physical books, that right does not extend to unauthorized reproductions (such as making an ebook by scanning in a print book).
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Retric on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:50PM (#35299138)
They very much do in cases of backups and even VCR/DVR recordings of live TV.

The courts have gone back and forth on this issue, and I would expect this ruling to be appealed by either side if they had lost.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dahart on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:20AM (#35303523)
Changing formats without changing content is not a derivative work; it’s just a copyright violation. A derivative work must “add new original copyrightable authorship to that work.” https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ14.pdf
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by endisneigh on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:03PM (#35298855)
What’s stopping IA from using the physical book while it is simultaneously lending out a copy?

Nothing. Which is why losing was inevitable.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by gcanyon on Saturday March 25, 2023 @02:33AM (#35300075)
Isn't this answerable by destroying the physical copy? (not saying that IA took this action, just saying that it removes the complaint of dual use)
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by endisneigh on Saturday March 25, 2023 @06:23AM (#35301248)
No, because if they destroyed the original then they would have no way of saying they have the original and that’s what’s being lent.

Then truly they would be lending only a copy, which was never legal to begin with.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by yencabulator on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:08PM (#35304036)
In the industry the title page is often considered to be proof of ownership. E.g. when a book doesn't sell, and book stores want it off the shelves, they may be asked to destroy the books except return the title pages to the publisher, as proof.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by gcanyon on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:13PM (#35304093)
Yep, waaaay back when I worked part time in a book store. I've stripped paperbacks.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by gcanyon on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:14PM (#35304099)
It would be trivial to document the ownership/destruction of the original. Video the process?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by toast0 on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:46PM (#35299114)
Regular (obnoxious) ebook lending is done under license of the publisher, presumably with the approval of the rightsholders. It may or may not be distribution, but it's approved, so it's ok.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Mindwipe on Saturday March 25, 2023 @05:57AM (#35301119)
One of the reasons the IA has lost (at least so far) here is that the judge noted they do not really do that, and have no mechanisms in place for doing that.

I thought the IA was in a bad place before, but they got very shown up in court.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by unopened on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:05PM (#35298417)
The market considerations for fair use concern the market for the work of authorship as a whole, not a specific format of it.

I'm not convinced fair use is the strongest argument in IA's case. But the idea that lending ebook copies can't be fair use simply because it competes with publishers' ebook licensing schemes seems like a misreading of how fair use is typically applied.

Of course other fair use considerations factor in, but the market impact for a specific format isn't a death blow against reproductions of a work, generally speaking.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Mindwipe on Saturday March 25, 2023 @06:00AM (#35301133)
It's only one of the tests, but in legal terms and precident it is a very strong one that HN frequently underestimates.

It's not impossible for a case to win when competing against a licensing scheme, but it is very, very, very hard.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:02PM (#35298384)
<< If libraries were distributing copies of their existing books they would be sued for copyright infringement.

There may be a question of definition here. Do you mean that they have to lend it, but they cannot give it away?

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Borealid on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:26PM (#35298576)
The parent post makes the unwise choice of using the word "copy" to mean "duplicate".

They intend to say "libraries do not distribute duplicates of purchased books; they distribute the originals".

Unfortunately the word "copy" could also mean "the books purchased by the library". Of course the library distributes purchased books. They just don't scan the books, print fascimiles of those books on new paper, and then distribute those prints they made themselves.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by granzymes on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:26PM (#35299000)
Ah, thank you. Replaced "copies" with "duplicates" in my post
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by zuminator on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:31PM (#35298607)
I think what GP is saying is that when lending (or for that matter giving away) print books, libraries don't copy anything, they just distribute purchased works, which they have a fundamental right to do (in the US). That's different from the IA first making a digital copy and then distributing that copy, which there is no fundamental right to do.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by granzymes on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:27PM (#35299008)
Yes, exactly.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by blincoln on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:44AM (#35299505)
Do you believe that libraries should be barred from archiving material to microfiche? How is that significantly different from format-shifting a book to electronic form, as long as they use DRM to limiy concurrent viewing?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by jhanschoo on Saturday March 25, 2023 @04:37AM (#35300684)
I suppose the difference is that publishers aren't suing such libraries and such archival isn't accessible enough to harm publishers' markets.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by granzymes on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:12PM (#35304081)
The second point is crucial. The microfiche copies of e.g. newspapers do not compete with the originals.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by leoc on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:58PM (#35305216)
IANAL but I think I recall seeing that the US libraries’ initiative to reprint some older books on non-acid-based paper was supported by an explicit carve-out in US copyright law.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by yencabulator on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:10PM (#35304063)
Honest question: Are libraries special cased in US law? (They are in many other places, and have rights beyond consumers or businesses.)
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by mmanfrin on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:54PM (#35298328)
> that they don’t deteriorate the way that physical books do

Wow, so they're arguing that the destruction of the sold good is implicit in the sale, and that preventing that is therefore illegal.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by whatshisface on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:24PM (#35298551)
So much for right to repair, eh?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Mezzie on Saturday March 25, 2023 @09:56AM (#35302661)
It's more pernicious than that because it's a lie.

Broadly speaking, physical books last much longer than ebooks have been proven to. With preservation measures, you can get 100s of years out of a single book copy, but even without most books will last for decades unless something catastrophic happens or someone destroys them on purpose. I have several books from the 1800s that weren't cared for at all (picked up at an estate sale) and they're perfectly serviceable and would be fine if I rebound them.

So I have books from the 1860s that are still usable. Given how the digital world has developed, the odds of someone's Kindle or ePub file being viable in 2180 is exceptionally low. In the same way that playing old video games can be a hassle, I'd be shocked if we're still using the same files and formats in 160 years. (Outside of us weirdo archivists of course).

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by hedora on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:17PM (#35298498)
That’s a terrible ruling. The first sale doctrine says the copy of the book you bought is yours. Lending the book is clearly not copying it.

So, I guess you just don’t own anything you buy anymore? Like what if I want to lend a tool to someone, and the tool manufacturer wants to rent their tools out? Is that also illegal?

What if the tool contains software?

What if reasonable use of the tool requires accessing a print manual? A pdf manual?

Edit: Reading the ruling, IA should have argued they are simply format shifting a single copy that they own. I wonder if they did make this argument, and then the judge conveniently ignored it (then lied in the summary ruling, when they say IA made no other arguments in their defense), or if IA’s lawyers screwed up.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by jkdufair on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:38PM (#35298660)
I don’t disagree with the ruling. IA is not lending their copy that they purchased. They are lending a copy of their copy. While that copy is lent out, they are still free to, I.e. read the copy in their possession.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by benatkin on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:57PM (#35298807)
Unsurprising that not all of HN is pro-fair use.

That's how you digitally send a copy of a book.

You're saying something similar to "you wouldn't download a car".

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by endisneigh on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:02PM (#35298845)
I don’t see how you’re refuting their point
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by benatkin on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:20PM (#35298954)
> You're saying something similar to "you wouldn't download a car".

It's applying without considering it.

The digital book isn't being kept at the old location because there is no digital book in the physical book.

It's the only way to transfer a single copy of a book without destroying the physical copy.

Judges should consider stuff like this and it's a disappointing ruling.

But go on...

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by endisneigh on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:23PM (#35298979)
Exactly. And there lies the issue. Internet archive has the book and lends the book simultaneously. Hence why they lost.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by hackernewds on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:49PM (#35299131)
This makes logical sense. Pay for one, lend one.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by jrmg on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:48AM (#35299532)
The ruling discusses this (at length!) and concludes that even a buy-one-physical-lend-one-digital scheme would not be acceptable under current law.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by criddell on Saturday March 25, 2023 @06:44AM (#35301348)
Do you think it would have made a difference if they bought three copies of the book and then shredded two of them? That way they would have the original they scanned, their digital version they copy to lend, and the loaned digital copy.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by endisneigh on Saturday March 25, 2023 @07:39AM (#35301665)
No, because they still wouldn’t be lending out what was bought.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dahart on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:15AM (#35303474)
No, that’s not why they lost. The reason is because they effectively lend it to many people simultaneously, and implement no controls on getting it “returned” (deleted) by the people they lent it to, while even being aware that some of them don’t “return” it.

The technicality that they keep a copy of the book while it’s being lent isn’t really at issue here at all. It’s not because there are two copies, it’s because there are three or more copies, given to two or more parties at the same time. It has become “distribution” in the eyes of copyright law, beyond the lending analogy.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by endisneigh on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:31AM (#35303642)
Even if they did what you described they would still lose. There would be no way to implement a control to prevent an additional simultaneous copy. It's not a technical issue, it's simple impossible inherently.

I don't know why companies keep trying this. MP3.com, Aereo, etc. The precedent is clear.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dahart on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:36AM (#35303702)
The question isn’t whether it’s technically possible, the question is whether they even tried, and one of the reasons they lost is not just because they didn’t try at all, and instead looked the other way when they knew the borrowers didn’t “return” the book.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by endisneigh on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:42AM (#35303783)
my point is that even if they did try, the outcome would've been the same and CDL was doomed from the beginning. their inane emergency CDL plan simply accelerated this outcome
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dahart on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:42PM (#35305043)
Maybe, but that’s speculation, and others have won fair use claims. The decision in this case explicitly cited the defendant’s lack of effort to control their loaned copies while being aware of infringement.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by endisneigh on Saturday March 25, 2023 @04:02PM (#35306669)
who is doing anything even remotely similar that won fair use claims?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dahart on Saturday March 25, 2023 @05:11PM (#35307399)
I didn’t claim similar, and it seems like we’re losing the point here. Mine is that your claim at the top, that the problem had to do with having two copies, actually has nothing to do with why they lost. The problem, as the judge described, is that they didn’t put the “C” in CDL, and looked the other way when then knew it was missing, and then tried to claim fair use for something that clearly isn’t fair use. They didn’t lose because the judge is being pedantic about how many copies there are, they lost because they’re actually squarely violating existing copyright law.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by xuto3 on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:05PM (#35331694)
Again, speaking about the wider CDL initiative (one digital copy lent for each physical copy) and not their National Emergency Library, the Internet Archive do implement a DRM on that digital copy, so for the reader to make additional copies of it is not trivial. Regardless, from where do you get a requirement to prevent (with 100% certainty) the reader from making additional copies? When a person borrows a physical book from a library, they could photocopy the entire thing, then return the book they borrowed to the library and still have an additional copy that they made. Does that make library lending illegal? How is that something that can be blamed on the library in the first place?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by hker999 on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:07PM (#35298880)
Yet, we should proscute GPL violations when the original GPL code is untouched.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by benatkin on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:23PM (#35298973)
You're comparing apples and oranges.

In the case of a physical object needing to temporarily go digital, it needs to be sent digitally and the records kept, and of course the physical copy has to be kept.

In the case of the GPL there's no physical copy and thus there's no need to consider how to move from one form to the other.

To require that a physical object never be used digitally is bad for society.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by yencabulator on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:48AM (#35303842)
People rarely buy copies GPL'ed source code, they obtain a license to the software. Buying something is very different from licensing it.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by denton-scratch on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:31AM (#35302021)
> Unsurprising that not all of HN is pro-fair use.

Isn't "fair use" restricted to (a) short portions of a work, (b) used for specific purposes, such as education or criticism?

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by derkades on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:13AM (#35312262)
The entire article is about fair use and how what IA is doing is not fair use. I would like the IA to exist, but I agree with the ruling that their fair use argument is nonsense. It's not a derivative work.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by nighthawk454 on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:07PM (#35298879)
That’s technically true. But frankly it seems like such people have a giant stick up their ass. The digital version would be infinitely more accessible, while still maintaining effectively 1-1 access restrictions. I’m not even sure if they’re _is_ a physical IA library one could go to. For all I know they’re in a vault somewhere. Even the USD isn’t backed 1-1 with physical tokens. It seems patently ridiculous that books be held to this standard in this day and age.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by benatkin on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:38PM (#35299060)
It's based on refusing to adapt to a society with digital objects.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by IshKebab on Saturday March 25, 2023 @03:38AM (#35300388)
And also it's a lot easier to copy a digitally borrowed book than it is to copy a physically borrowed book.

There are practical differences between the two, which mean that the law probably should treat them differently. I expect a lot of HN have difficulty dealing with that because they think "but they both contain the same information".

It reminds me of people trying to encode books into prime numbers or the digits or pi or whatnot to "get around" copyright. Fundamentally missing the point.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by yencabulator on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:45AM (#35303821)
You cannot even read an ebook without copying it from storage to RAM, to CPU cache, to video RAM, and so on; by your thinking, all owners of ebooks commit multiple instances of copyright infringement every time they read an ebook.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by jkdufair on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:07PM (#35308994)
Making a copy in RAM, cache etc does not involve distributing it to other people.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by yencabulator on Saturday March 25, 2023 @09:12PM (#35309546)
You cannot lend someone a digital instance of the item without copying it. The problem is the sharing of supposedly-one-instance, not the copying.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by jrmg on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:48PM (#35298748)
Replying to your edit: The format shifting argument and first sale doctrine are discussed in the ruling. Notably in the section headed ‘3’ starting on page 28 - but also in other places.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by bradrn on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:13AM (#35299297)
This is interesting, from that section:

    Nor does IA’s promise not to lend simultaneously its
    lawfully acquired print copies and its unauthorized reproductions
    help its case. As an initial matter, IA has not kept its promise.
    Although the Open Library’s print copies of the Works in Suit are
    non-circulating, IA concedes that it has no way of verifying
    whether Partner Libraries remove their physical copies from
    circulation after partnering with IA. Pls.’ 56.1 ¶¶ 495-496. To
    the contrary, IA knows that some Partner Libraries do not remove
    the physical books from their shelves, and even if a Partner
    Library puts a physical book into a non-circulating reference
    collection, it could be read in the library while the ebook
    equivalent is checked out. Id. ¶¶ 494, 497. IA also does not
    inform Partner Libraries when an ebook in its collection is
    checked out, and Partner Libraries do not tell IA when their
    physical copies are circulating. Id. ¶ 498. IA admits it has
    never taken action against a Partner Library that did not
    suppress circulation properly. Id. ¶ 499.
I do want IA to win, but this certainly doesn’t help their case, to say the least…
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by klabb3 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:48AM (#35299852)
This is such an “ackchully” argument from the ruling. It’s not the spirit of the law and the principles behind the idea of free access to information. Instead it’s narrowing in on the specifics of physical lending of books, grasping for analogies to the 20th century, in a world which has transformed and moved on decades ago.

But even if all those things weren’t true, or important, it’s profound that there’s enough collective incentive to go after IA, instead of say corporations violating GPL, or the hedgies who created “temporary” artificial supply of stocks (which shares a similar “overprovisioning” aspect, except they’re fraudulent at massive scale).

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by alwayslikethis on Saturday March 25, 2023 @02:06AM (#35299950)
Make no mistake, the law is specific made to limit free access to information. Originally this was a reasonable concession to encourage creative work, but as the length extended and copyright starts to be controlled by massive corporations, they gradually became a way to protect profits.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by nmeagent on Saturday March 25, 2023 @04:00AM (#35300490)
Right. IMO copyright in general seriously conflicts with the very concepts of free expression and ownership. As corporations eat the world and are able to push to maximize copyright to protect their profits, our rights of expression and ownership are diminished. Fair use and the first sale doctrine will ultimately be meaninglessly minimized curiosities if we don't fight, tooth and nail, corporate IP holders and the bought state entities that protect them.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by GolfPopper on Saturday March 25, 2023 @09:47AM (#35302576)
This.

When IP laws existed to make sure authors could be compensated people broadly supported them. The perception has changed (for many reasons), to where people broadly see IP laws as an enabler for corporate greed more than being about fair compensation for authors. (See Disney not paying owed royalties, for example.)

We can either have "good copyright" that the public sees as reasonable, or we can have rampant piracy and the consequences thereof. The villains of the piece are those who deliberately perpetuate an unsustainable system out of greed (and I am not talking about authors and publishers trying to get paid for the work they've done).

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dahart on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:09AM (#35303400)
> they gradually became a way to protect profits.

It was always from the very beginning a way to protect profits, that was the primary intent of copyright law, to give the creator of a work the exclusive right to make the money from the work before others are allowed to take the content and sell it for their own profit. Yes the length has become crazy long, and yes the law limits free (as in beer) access to information, but that hasn’t changed the reason for it’s being at all. It’s not really a “concession” either, more like it was intentionally balanced to provide enough time for people to make profits (which is what economically encourages creative work), while being short enough to allow works to reach the public over time.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by gcanyon on Saturday March 25, 2023 @02:44AM (#35300120)
Strange that this isn't easily dealt with by:

1. IA actually buying a physical copy (or as many copies as they plan on simultaneously making available to borrowers) of the book. 2. After scanning the physical copy, destroying it, and documenting same.

Then as long as they guarantee that they only loan out as many copies as they physically had (before destroying them) there's no question of simultaneous usage.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by malborodog on Saturday March 25, 2023 @09:34AM (#35302469)
Why isn't it easily dealt with by doing that??
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by cowsandmilk on Saturday March 25, 2023 @09:39AM (#35302512)
The Internet Archive freely admitted in the case that the physical copies owned by partner libraries were not destroyed.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by gcanyon on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:16PM (#35304117)
Yeah, I get that they may not have done this -- that's why I suggested it could be "easily dealt with" by doing this.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by harshreality on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:32AM (#35311676)
IA doesn't want to destroy its own books, because it warehouses them in climate-controlled spaces so that it can re-scan them with improved technology in the future. That should hardly preclude (controlled) lending of scans of its own physical books that nobody is using, even under current draconian copyright law.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by hedora on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:10AM (#35303416)
Oh, then this case was found on the facts. (They are doing a thing that pretty clearly violates fair use.)

I like the IA, but I’m happy this was the screw up. It should greatly weaken the precedent this ruling creates.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by bradrn on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:14AM (#35312860)
If this were the only argument, I would agree with you. However, there’s other arguments, many of which are quite general in nature.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by alwayslikethis on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:16AM (#35299308)
Now that I think about it, not being able to own anything is a good reason to start stealing. Think about it, why is stealing bad? Usually, this is an application of the Golden Rule. If you don't want people to steal the stuff you own, you shouldn't steal their stuff either. However, if you are no longer allowed to own anything (just like under communism), then the argument falls apart. Realistically, information wants to be free, and spreading it is much easier than controlling its spread. I expect the current copyright wars will come into an end in a decade or two, ending in the loss of the copyright mafia as society reconsiders the concession that is the copyright system.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by 0x72 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @04:59AM (#35300804)
Come on, this was explained like milion times: you cannot own private property (factory, land, buildings, means of production), but you can own your personal property just fine. Why do leftist use such confusing terminology? I don't know. We should ask Free Software Foundation.

Most importantly here, information falls under "means of production", so under communism it should be free.

Freedom of information under capitalism is (as everything) a discussion about money.

I admire your optimism, regarding the copyrights future. Fingers crossed.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by detrites on Saturday March 25, 2023 @03:48AM (#35300428)
"Alpaca III, can you write an accurate page-by-page summary of every page of Book-I-Want-To-Read, where each summary's one page long and as faithful to the original pages content and length as possible, fully quoting each page permitted?"

My point being: as technology marches on the ageing concept of "owning" entirely fungible digital material becomes less and less valid. It is already at a stage meaninglessness is flirting with it in a new way daily and that will continue.

Really, we need to let it go.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by jkdufair on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:14PM (#35309054)
Whether or not someone is allowed to distribute creative works without the permission of the author, the point of copyright, is and will contribute to be independent of the technology used to do the distribution.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by sacnoradhq on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:46PM (#35298737)
This sets back archival and human knowledge back 100 years. If you embargo a physical copy, an electronic copy should be lendable.

I would start a webtorrent+ipfs+i2p site in Iceland just to get around this insane perpetual monopoly on difficult-to-find, old shit that doesn't have a market but publishers keep locked away.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Zetice on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:53PM (#35298788)
100 years? Seems hyperbolic.

And you don’t need to do anything at all; all of these books have been freely available on IRC for years.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by nvader on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:57PM (#35298813)
Sherlock Holmes' emotions would like a word. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/oct/07/the-curious-ca...
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Zetice on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:33PM (#35299033)
Are you aware of how that case resolved?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by nvader on Saturday March 25, 2023 @03:46AM (#35300418)
My recollection was that they reached a settlement, but I don't know for how much. https://abbasmedialaw.com/posts/copyright-netflix-reaches-se...

I found this chart interesting, and unexpectedly complicated: https://www.belmont.edu/legal/pdf/Public-Domain-Chart.pdf

Based on that I think a heuristic of 100 years is broadly correct.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Zetice on Saturday March 25, 2023 @05:33AM (#35301006)
No, it’s not broadly correct, because “when does copyright expire” has no relevance to “setting back the concept of human knowledge”.

Human knowledge remains entirely unaffected by this ruling.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by katbyte on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:15AM (#35299675)
are you not aware of how long copyright lasts now?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Zetice on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:16AM (#35299687)
Yes, are you not aware of how pirating works?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Xelynega on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:31PM (#35309200)
> I would start a webtorrent+ipfs+i2p site

Libgen?

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Zetice on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:54PM (#35298795)
So what does this mean for my extensive library in Plex of DVDs I own?
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by tsimionescu on Saturday March 25, 2023 @03:08AM (#35300248)
It means you are not legally allowed to lend them or sell them, even if you lose the original DVD and even though you did have the right to lend or sell the original DVD.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Zetice on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:20PM (#35304837)
It seems like I might not have legally been allowed to make a copy of the DVD in the first place too...
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dmonitor on Saturday March 25, 2023 @04:54PM (#35307230)
you can make a personal backup, but once you hand it to someone else it is no longer personal
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by Zetice on Saturday March 25, 2023 @05:05PM (#35307343)
Can you? The ruling seems to rake issue with the digitalization itself.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by jasomill on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:39PM (#35309260)
IANAL, but even if we assume the act of backing up a DVD to a hard drive is legal, it's not clear to me how one could legally use a hard drive copy of a DVD without somehow circumventing CSS.

And with only narrow exceptions that probably don't apply here, this act of circumvention violates 17 U.S.C. 1201(a)(1)(A)[1].

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by gamblor956 on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:39PM (#35299068)
This is basically the same way that courts have always ruled on this point.

Redbox tried this theory several years ago when they were trying to launch their film streaming service, and failed for the same reasons.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by ssalka on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:14AM (#35299300)
If a judge thinks THAT's illegal, wait till they hear about fractional reserve banking.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by GolfPopper on Saturday March 25, 2023 @09:53AM (#35302632)
Pretty sure fractional reserve banking passes the "do rich people make money from this" test, and is therefore fine.
Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by dahart on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:39AM (#35303751)
> It’s a ruling that controlled digital lending is illegal.

That’s not really true. One issue described explicitly in the decision is that the lending is mostly uncontrolled, and worse there’s evidence of it the defendant was aware of. The second issue is that the defendant isn’t using the first sale doctrine, their defense is fair use. Presumably the whole reason they decided to argue fair use is because they knew they weren’t adhering to the lending analogy, because they were aware they were effectively distributing copies, not just lending them.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive by lucb1e on Saturday March 25, 2023 @02:17PM (#35305403)
> This ruling is not about the emergency library at all. It's a ruling that [...] one physical copy backing each digital copy lent out) is illegal.

That's not what I read in the linked article, specifically:

Regarding "IA’s promise not to lend simultaneously": "IA has not kept its promise. Although the Open Library’s print copies of the Works in Suit are non-circulating, IA concedes that it has no way of verifying whether Partner Libraries remove their physical copies from circulation after partnering with IA…. To the contrary, IA knows that some Partner Libraries do not remove the physical books from their shelves"

As I understand it, this case exists because the IA was not keeping its promise anymore and made an error of judgement by breaking the 1:1 ratio without any legal argumentation or even a logical reason for it. It was said at the time already, but the obviousness, whether something as important as the wayback machine's owner should compete with the pirate bay for market share on illegal ebooks, and the use of (my/our) donated money on the ensuing legal nonsense, is a different discussion...

If these underlying facts and circumstances were different, such as if someone tries this concept again but keeps their promise and implements it correctly, the same ruling cannot be passed because it's not the same situation. It would have to be tried again and it might (or might not) swing the other way, at least that is my general understanding of legal systems around the world.

Perhaps it would also be different in another country whence ExampleBooks Ltd could operate legally, that will depend in part on whether the copyright alliance pact (I forgot the name) has provisions letting signatories (afaik that's every nation you might want to live in) make exceptions for things like this.