News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

unopened

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:05PM (#35298417)
The market considerations for fair use concern the market for the work of authorship as a whole, not a specific format of it.

I'm not convinced fair use is the strongest argument in IA's case. But the idea that lending ebook copies can't be fair use simply because it competes with publishers' ebook licensing schemes seems like a misreading of how fair use is typically applied.

Of course other fair use considerations factor in, but the market impact for a specific format isn't a death blow against reproductions of a work, generally speaking.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:37PM (#35298223)
The concept of "owning" a book digitally is already on shaky ground, since most large publishers only sell licenses for accessing ebooks. You're not actually purchasing a copy in perpetuity like a physical book. Naturally these licenses are entirely on the publishers' terms.

In practice this means publishers can revoke access licenses for all sorts of arbitrary reasons, alter the content of ebooks already purchased, or plenty of other shady practices, with little recourse available to the reader.

Plus it means they can force libraries to keep paying repeated, marked-up fees for the privilege of lending out ebooks. Much better deal for the publishers than the physical library lending model!

I don't blame IA for trying to find a way to liberate library lending from that racket.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive on Friday March 24, 2023 @08:28PM (#35297613)
If anything, their "first sale doctrine" route seems like a stronger argument than fair use here. When you purchase a copy of a work, you have the right to lend, sell, or share that copy without any additional payment or permission required to the creator. This is how libraries have operated for centuries.

I think what IA was doing, making sure they only lend out as many copies as they physically own, was clearly within the spirit of that doctrine. But in the digital era, lending anything over the web necessarily means making a copy of it somewhere along the way, which laws haven't adequately adapted to yet.

Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive on Friday March 24, 2023 @08:11PM (#35297449)
Aaron Swartz founding the Open Library in collaboration with Internet Archive was a shining moment in web history. Sad to see giant corporations stomping on his vision of a web that offers free access to information for all.