Re:Judge Decides Against Internet Archive
by Mindwipe on Saturday March 25, 2023 @06:00AM
(#35301133)
It's only one of the tests, but in legal terms and precident it is a very strong one that HN frequently underestimates.
It's not impossible for a case to win when competing against a licensing scheme, but it is very, very, very hard.
I'm not convinced fair use is the strongest argument in IA's case. But the idea that lending ebook copies can't be fair use simply because it competes with publishers' ebook licensing schemes seems like a misreading of how fair use is typically applied.
Of course other fair use considerations factor in, but the market impact for a specific format isn't a death blow against reproductions of a work, generally speaking.