Whether a copy of a work is fair use turns on, amongst other things, the effect of the copy on the potential market for the original. The article acknowledges this.
Controlled Digital Lending competes directly with the licensing scheme publishers have for library ebooks. The fair use argument was always doomed to fail.
The article then completely ignores the copyright argument and tries to equate CDL with libraries loaning out their physical copies. This is completely absurd, since libraries do not distribute copies of their physical books and so do not even enter the realm of copyright.
If libraries were systematically distributing copies of their existing books they would be sued for copyright infringement. And no, section 108 does not allow them to do so (see 17 U.S. Code § 108(g)(2), which is why IA did not raise that argument in court).
I don't see the argument that this is "distribution" any more than regular (obnoxious) ebook lending is.
The courts have gone back and forth on this issue, and I would expect this ruling to be appealed by either side if they had lost.
Nothing. Which is why losing was inevitable.
Then truly they would be lending only a copy, which was never legal to begin with.
I thought the IA was in a bad place before, but they got very shown up in court.
I'm not convinced fair use is the strongest argument in IA's case. But the idea that lending ebook copies can't be fair use simply because it competes with publishers' ebook licensing schemes seems like a misreading of how fair use is typically applied.
Of course other fair use considerations factor in, but the market impact for a specific format isn't a death blow against reproductions of a work, generally speaking.
It's not impossible for a case to win when competing against a licensing scheme, but it is very, very, very hard.
There may be a question of definition here. Do you mean that they have to lend it, but they cannot give it away?
They intend to say "libraries do not distribute duplicates of purchased books; they distribute the originals".
Unfortunately the word "copy" could also mean "the books purchased by the library". Of course the library distributes purchased books. They just don't scan the books, print fascimiles of those books on new paper, and then distribute those prints they made themselves.
Wow, so they're arguing that the destruction of the sold good is implicit in the sale, and that preventing that is therefore illegal.
Broadly speaking, physical books last much longer than ebooks have been proven to. With preservation measures, you can get 100s of years out of a single book copy, but even without most books will last for decades unless something catastrophic happens or someone destroys them on purpose. I have several books from the 1800s that weren't cared for at all (picked up at an estate sale) and they're perfectly serviceable and would be fine if I rebound them.
So I have books from the 1860s that are still usable. Given how the digital world has developed, the odds of someone's Kindle or ePub file being viable in 2180 is exceptionally low. In the same way that playing old video games can be a hassle, I'd be shocked if we're still using the same files and formats in 160 years. (Outside of us weirdo archivists of course).
>Every part of that has been deemed legal. Copyright law already has first sale rights, written directly into the law and allow for the lending or reselling of copyright-covered works without a license or permission. Similarly libraries are given explicit rights to make copies, so long as those collections are made available to the public. On top of that, courts have determined, multiple times, that book scanning itself is fair use for libraries.
>So, literally each separate component of what is happening with Controlled Digital Lending has already been deemed to be legal and exactly what we expect libraries to do.
>To counter this, publishers (and their supporters, which unfortunately include some authors) argue that (1) this interferes with the market for licensed ebooks, and (2) that there is a real difference in lending out the digital scans: that they don’t deteriorate the way that physical books do.