News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by cipheredStones on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:29AM (#34061929)
It's pretty remarkable that this conflates:

- Well-known slurs like "Jewed"

- Outdated, now-offensive terms like "hermaphrodite"

- Touchy metaphorical language like "slave replica"

- Gendered terms that if you're being assiduous you probably want to avoid, like "manpower"

- Words that have long since lost any stigmatizing meaning by virtue of the original use being so ancient ("lame", "dumb", "stupid")

- Words that, if you look into their history, originally had something to do with some racist practice ("grandfather" something in)

- Words that never had anything to do with racism, but someone who was really on high alert might wonder if they ever did ("tarball" for "archive made with the tar tool")

- Anything that might be derogatory to anybody ("Karen": "This term is used to ridicule or demean a certain group of people based on their behaviors.")

- Terms that I genuinely have no idea how anyone could view as harmful in their actual context: "user" ("it can also negatively be associated with those who suffer from substance abuse issues"), "submit" ("Depending on the context, the term can imply allowing others to have power over you.")

Very much an "arson, murder, and jaywalking" approach.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by pclmulqdq on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:32AM (#34061945)
They just don't want to be called "Karens" for imposing a speech code on the school. It's 100% illegal in CA to do this thanks to Leonard's Law.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by photochemsyn on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:44AM (#34062023)
I can think of a few more!

"register" - might indicate that someone has to register as a second-class citizen, enemy alien, etc.

"bit" - might imply that someone is only a 'bit player', leading to feelings of inferiority.

"tool" - an obviously offensive word meaning that someone is only fit to be used by others.

"terminal" - we need to be sensitive about words that bring up the concept of death, to avoid triggering effects.

"inheritance" - individuals are not the product of their ancestry!

"class" - we don't need a class-structured society, that's a leftover from a feudal past.

"polymorphism" - too close to hermaphrodite, must be eliminated.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by erosenbe0 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:24AM (#34062322)
"Stanford" - may refer to noted racist and Asian-exclusionist Leland Stanford. Also may refer to related location formed originally as a whites-only educational enclave on indigenous lands.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kmonsen on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:43AM (#34062833)
Yeah if they want to go full political correct that is probably the best place to start.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by coffeeblack on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:01AM (#34062957)
And of course the “Master’s” degree.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by quickthrower2 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:38AM (#34063223)
Now called a Main’s degree
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by btach on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:27AM (#34063606)
I almost spit my tea out. You made me laugh.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kleene_op on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:31AM (#34063631)
That's too close to the spelling of the word Man, which would be exclusionary of the woman gender. Let's call it a Human's degree.

Or better yet, a Being's degree. Let's not be speciesists.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hef19898 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:55AM (#34064211)
Scentient, please. But let's not use the New Order's classification of species as scentient or not.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by quickthrower2 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:23AM (#34064403)
Or elementist (Silicon vs. carbon)
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jazzabeanie on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:56AM (#34065209)
Human has the word man in it, so let’s use huperson
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:15AM (#34065415)
"Terran" is an established term.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tsimionescu on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:53AM (#34065849)
That's exclusionary of beings not native to Terra.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:21AM (#34066242)
That's not going to be an issue. There are zero such beings known so far, no hard evidence they even exist, and we're not going to find or create ones any time soon - the same people who engage in language policing also currently dislike space exploration for various ideological reasons.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by skjoldr on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:46AM (#34067487)
Well the colonizers didn't know that Native Americans existed before landing in America, and look what happened. We must prevent any and all such occurrences in our interplanetary future by only using a non-specieist vocabulary.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kamma4434 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:51PM (#34070447)
It’s so obvious that if colonizers had used inclusive language, everybody would have lived in peace. Though maybe labelling them ‘colonizers’ and not ‘welcome guests’ was only the first of a set of micro aggressions that precipitated the situation.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by EdiX on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:14PM (#34069830)
> That's not going to be an issue. There are zero such beings known so far

Maybe the reason there are zero openly non-terran (or, preferrably, differently planeted) folks is attutides like yours. Think about it.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jkingsbery on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:51PM (#34070455)
> for various ideological reasons

They are opposed to colonies wherever they might be, even lunar colonies.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tosc on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:28PM (#34074377)
This is gaslighting the lived experience of those who have reported abduction by aliens.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by MrYellowP on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:34AM (#34078126)
You have no argument there. The same people who care about butchering language and destroying society are the same people who don't care about facts or what's real.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by aliswe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:26AM (#34079250)
What do you identify as, though?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by anshumankmr on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:59AM (#34127752)
I just love this thread.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by pc86 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:42AM (#34067426)
I think you missed the joke, friend.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jkingsbery on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:50PM (#34070434)
But "person" has the word "son" in it, and that's gendered.

Better go with huperchild.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by akiselev on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:58AM (#34078249)
Huperchild has the words “per child” in it, which is exclusionary to people who choose not to worsen overpopulation by not procreating.

How about huperperson?

Uh wait, that’s recursi- political correctness overflow error.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Pigalowda on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:49AM (#34067521)
Human ends in “man” and has already been regarded as offensive to “people” or “persons”. Being when referenced to an organism is only used in context of “human” (offensive) or an “alien” (offensive). Anything that is referential to an offensive word must be struck as well.

No word should ever create a mental reference to a banned word nor should a substitute word create a mental suspicion or guess of what the original offensive word was. A new vocabulary must be formed -newspeak if you will.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by agentwiggles on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:18PM (#34068959)
> Its vocabulary was so constructed as to give exact and often very subtle expression to every meaning that a Party member could properly wish to express, while excluding all other meanings and also the possibility of arriving at them by indirect methods. This was done partly by the invention of new words, but chiefly by eliminating undesirable words and by stripping such words as remained of unorthodox meanings, and so far as possible of all secondary meanings whatever.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by lo_zamoyski on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:36AM (#34068295)
You're discriminating against non-beings.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by schappim on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:55AM (#34065875)
Being brought up in multicultural Australia, I was colourblind [1] to race. I find it hard to even remember what ethnicity my peers were.

As such, I have no hate of other races but I'm filled with hate every time my "git push origin master" fails because the branch is now called "main".

[1] How was this word not on the list?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 8ytecoder on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:21AM (#34068049)
Add aliases to your gitconfig. Not gonna solve the frustration but at least it doesn’t have to be a trigger (oops). Also, I much prefer trunk over main/master anyway so I just went back to that.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by PrefixKitten on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:22PM (#34071004)
I hope you've got a big trunk, because I'm going to put my bike in it

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by schappim on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:25PM (#34073602)
Thank you! I had no idea one could alias branch names. Why be woke, when you can be aliased awake.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by lo_zamoyski on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:38AM (#34068321)
"Being brought up in multicultural Australia, I was colourblind [1] to race."

Tell that to Ibram Kendi.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by erosenbe0 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:04PM (#34069692)
He can't believe that kids in racially integrated environments are efficient thinkers largely concerned with simple priorities. Is Billy a bully? Should I pick Alice first in the game on the sandlot? Can Jose help me with this math problem?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:20AM (#34067065)
I'm not very smart and would prefer it just being called a university degree, to describe where you get it from.

I mean what the fuck is a sophomore?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:53AM (#34068576)
You're not wrong; it would probably make sense to have first/second/third level degrees instead of BSc/MSc/PhD (and their equivalents). We might even get there eventually. But the reason this would be desirable has nothing to do with etymology of "master's degree" (or "bachelor's degree"), nor with the hypocrisy of a university declaring the word "master" as offensive, while not renaming the corresponding degree.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by quickthrower2 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:16PM (#34071860)
Sophomore is an oxymoron:

> From earlier sophumer, from the obsolete sophom (“sophism or dialectical exercise”), likely influenced by Ancient Greek σοφός (sophós, “wise”) + μωρός (mōrós, “fool”). Compare oxymoron (literally “sharp-dull”), a similar contradiction.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by thequux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:17PM (#34069872)
Only in the UK. In the US, it's better known as a Line Degree.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by thinkingemote on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:29AM (#34064015)
it would be even easier to say that "Bachelors" degree is worse on multiple woke levels except perhaps race.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:06AM (#34064769)
PhD isn't any better - the Ph stands for "philosophy", which ostensibly is about "love for wisdom", but it's clear etymologically that phílos + sophía isn't exactly ungendered.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by brailsafe on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:31AM (#34063170)
Hopefully nobody from White Settlement, Tx applies
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by trilbyglens on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:09AM (#34064314)
Might explain some of the existential self-loathing embodied in this list...
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by chrisbaker98 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:15AM (#34064340)
Stanford also contains "ford", a possibly reference to the industrialist Henry Ford, a notorious anti-semite.

"Oxford" has got to go too. Not only for the reference to Henry Ford, but because of its historical origins as the name of a place where oxen could ford the River Thames. This has troubling connotations of speciesism and animal exploitation, not to mention it's exclusionary to the differently-abled, who might not be able to ford a river without some kind of additional structure being constructed. (On that note, Cambridge was ahead of its time.)

As for an alternative name, the obvious solution would be to rename these venerable institutions after a more palatable historical figure who modern undergraduates don't think did anything wrong: Stalin.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by cuteboy19 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:21AM (#34066247)
This should not be considered hyperbole. These people will write entire books which can be summarised as "Pol Pot did nothing wrong" [0]

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide_denial#Chom...

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by wholinator2 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:43AM (#34066543)
They have an email link to submit additional words. We're I not early in my academic career and worried of potential repercussions, I would be emailing these suggestions to them. Though I worry if they wouldn't just add them all to the list rather than understanding the message.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by malandrew on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:46AM (#34077462)
Funny you mention this because it reminds me of the time I pointed out that Chief Seattle owned slaves and committed a genocide against the Chimmicum people. I forgot the context in which I made this observation but the truth is that the overwhelming majority of people of historical significance would merit cancelling by today’s standards.

The road where on can’t lead anywhere but renaming anything just so a younger generation can claim superiority over older generations whom they are forcing to adopt their new vernacular at risk of cancellation.

“The basic tool for the manipulation of reality is the manipulation of words. If you can control the meaning of words, you can control the people who must use the words.” —Philip K. Dick

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by NoToP on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:36AM (#34062405)
"black Friday" - what could possibly have been on sale originally when it got this name?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by rippercushions on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:44AM (#34062839)
Clearly a reference to "white savior" Robinson Crusoe's manservant Friday, a highly offensive stereotype of a subservient BIPOC.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by JakeAl on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:02AM (#34062963)
Know your hierarchy of oppression. That's sexist. Clearly it would be code for His Girl Friday.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by denton-scratch on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:33AM (#34064053)
"Girl"? Seriously? Infantilising women is sexist.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mc32 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:58AM (#34065228)
It’s a reference to an old movie.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by highwaylights on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:11AM (#34063022)
I always assumed this was a tongue-in-cheek reference to the 1929 market crash and subsequent events.

Taken to mean “this is going to be a really stressful day”. Probably utterly not at all that though.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by IIAOPSW on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:28AM (#34064008)
The real answer is that financial ledgers used to use black ink for positive numbers and red for negative, hence the terminology "in the red"/"in the black" to mean an enterprise is in debt or profitable. Black Friday was the day of the year where every department store would have so much business that it put them "in the black", even if they had just spent the entire previous part of the year "in the red".
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by chrisbaker98 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:17AM (#34064359)
That's a good story, but according to Wikipedia this etymology was invented after the fact and isn't the real origin of the term (which is somewhat obscure.)
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by bregma on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:15AM (#34064848)
...and which pen is used in an accounting ledger at certain times of year is not obscure?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by chrisbaker98 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:55AM (#34065204)
I don't get what you're saying. It's not obscure at all that black ink denotes profits and red ink denotes losses - "in the black" and "in the red" are well-understood English phrases.

All I'm saying is that this particular meaning of black/red doesn't appear to be the origins of the name "black Friday", at least according to Wikipedia, but I really don't care about this enough to investigate any further.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Mil0dV on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:03AM (#34063423)
Origin early 17th century (as school slang, in the sense ‘Friday on which an examination is held’). The shopping sense dates from the 1960s and was originally used with reference to congestion created by shoppers; it was later explained as a day when retailers’ accounts went from being ‘in the red’ to ‘in the black’.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by evol262 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:33AM (#34062379)
How do you feel about "bad faith"?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Sebb767 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:19AM (#34062672)
Clearly insulting religion, to be avoided!
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by flyingfences on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:48AM (#34065798)
... unless that religion is Christianity, in which case, fire away!
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by vizavix on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:38AM (#34063224)
These are brilliant, I can't wait to troll my well-meaning but sanctimonious colleagues with these.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by littlestymaar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:27AM (#34063600)
> "class" - we don't need a class-structured society, that's a leftover from a feudal past.

You got this one backwards though, the notion of “social classes” is a left-winged concept, while the conservatives are usually the one pretending they don't exist.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by noufalibrahim on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:57AM (#34064224)
"Trigger warning" is now hurtful and should be replaced by "content note". That's recursively triggering.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by leoc on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:59AM (#34064238)
Ask the French about the sensitivities involved in 'bit'. Actually, they've already highlighted the issue, with typical maturity and sophistication: https://coq.inria.fr/ . (The name wasn't a coincidence, no.)
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:53AM (#34068574)
<< "polymorphism" - too close to hermaphrodite, must be eliminated.

You do not eliminate, you disintermediate.

I will admit that this may explain some of the general public's attitude towards academia and higher learning.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by PopePompus on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:40PM (#34070237)
How 'bout "gold standard", "golden rule", etc. After all, black people were forced to work in gold mines during South Africa's aparthied era. Maybe the name of the element gold needs to be changed too.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by crest on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:47PM (#34070381)
How dare you use such an offensive word as "eliminate"!?!?!? /s
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hnick on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:11AM (#34077275)
"tool" is historically and currently also slang for penis. Can't have that.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by fallingknife on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:55AM (#34062086)
I really don't understand how anybody proposing these types of rules is ever met with anything but open contempt. No one has ever been able to explain it to me.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jrmg on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:13AM (#34062220)
Oh come on. The page itself recognizes that it’s only advice.

There were a few things on the list I didn’t know the history of (e.g. ‘grandfathered’) that I’ll try to avoid now. I can understand why someone who comes from a different history than I do could be frustrated by them - indeed, I probably will be (mildly) now I’ve learned of the connotations. It costs me almost nothing to avoid them.

There are also a few things I find questionable - but on the whole this list is basically just ‘try to be kind to others’. It’s disappointing to see it so badly received.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by fallingknife on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:17AM (#34062247)
But it's only ever people who come from the same history as I do (white upper-middle class) that are offended by them.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jrmg on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:20AM (#34062272)
I really don’t think that’s true of the entire list.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tsimionescu on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:16AM (#34063067)
There are exceptions, such as the handful of obvious slurs that they added (tar baby, hermaphrodite, etc) but the vast majority of the list is exactly like this.

Probably even things like policeman, man-in-the-middle etc are not offensive or patriarchal to the vast majority of women (especially since many such words are probably older than the current use of "man" to mean male person, and refer to the older sense of person, as in the US constitution).

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kelnos on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:51AM (#34063328)
> especially since many such words are probably older than the current use of "man" to mean male person, and refer to the older sense of person, as in the US constitution

I feel like that use is... complicated. Why, exactly, did "man" mean "person"? Why not "woman", then? It feels like using "man" to mean "person" -- including and especially in historic usage -- is itself patriarchal. Given the time period you reference -- the writing of the US Constitution -- I think it's even more stark, as it was written by men who were not inclined to allow women any sort of participation in the government (and I expect many of them did not feel that women were as entitled to many of the rights they were enumerating).

But really, the semantics aren't the primary issue. If a lot of women feel excluded by "man"-terms, then that's a problem. To be fair, though, I have never asked a female police officer or firefighter if she felt that "policeman" or "fireman" made her feel excluded, so I don't really know.

I think "excluded" is a better term than "offended" in some cases. "Offended" is a very squishy, subjective, imprecise, emotional term. What matters is why someone might feel offended by a particular term, and I could certainly sympathize with a woman who felt like "policeman" was implicitly telling her that she wasn't fit for the job, that women should be excluded from consideration for that job, or that women should intentionally exclude themselves from considering wanting that job.

As much as I disagree with a lot of the things on Stanford's list, I think calling words "harmful" is better and more descriptive than calling them "offensive".

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mogrim on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:53AM (#34063799)
It's amusing to try turning it round, makes you realise just quite how sexist it actually is:

"No, of course I'm not offended by being called a firewoman, why would I be? It's clearly referring to both women and men" - Jake Miller, Firewoman, Springfield Fire Department

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tsimionescu on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:50AM (#34064621)
The words woman/women refer explicitly to a group where every single member is a woman (female).

The words man/men, at least historically, can refer either to a group of unknown composition OR to a group where every member is a man (male). Basically it is a homonym with two separate meanings, just like mouse (animal or input device) or chair (object or leader of a committee).

Point being, policeman being ambiguous doesn't mean that we would expect policewoman to be considered ambiguous as well, since woman is not a homonym.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by saberience on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:17AM (#34064870)
You would probably feel differently if you had learned the term man and mankind also refer to all human beings and that usage had been normal and active for your entire life.

Of course saying womankind sounds funny now because we haven’t heard it used for our whole lives. The term mankind derives from Sanskrit meaning children of Manu (a god). It’s not a sexist term and we’ve gone 2000 years without people finding it offensive, it’s only one that people with no other issues in their life need something to be offended about and decide to make a war on words.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tsimionescu on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:32AM (#34064035)
Etymologically, in Old English, man used to mean person, and there were explicit terms for a (male) man and a woman - wer and wif. Wer fell out of use[0], and the generic "man" started referring both to all people, and to men (males) in particular.

This conflation found in early modern English uses of "man" started being seen as problematic in the early 20th century, and style guides started preferring other words to refer to people in general, thus relegating "man" to mean only male person somewhat artificially.

[0] the only remaining usage is in werewolf - though few would assume a werewolf has to be male.

[1] note that I am using "male person" only to make it clearer when I'm using the generic or specific meaning of "man". I'm not trying to conflate sex with gender or any other kind of subtle transphobia.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sethherr on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:52AM (#34062501)
I think this could be rewritten as “only white upper-middle class people complain about these things” which doesn’t mean they’re the only ones offended or upset
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by imiric on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:47AM (#34062856)
They're not even offended by this language.

They just want to appear progressive and sympathetic. It's virtue signalling.

Allowing these people to police language is mass insanity.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by vineyardmike on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:05AM (#34063442)
Genuine question, because I hear this sentiment a lot.

Are they the only ones who tell you, a fellow white man, or are they the only ones who are offended? I strongly suspect (this is not meant to be insulting) that you may not have a relationship with the people who this language impacts. It takes an emotional toll to confide with someone that something is upsetting to hear, even with coworkers or casual friends, especially if you don't think they'd understand.

Also, language has the opportunity to shape and influence how we structure society, even unintentionally. Thats why there's a lot of emphasis on teaching children about what words are appropriate. Even if naming your git branch "master" won't realistically impact racism and the history of slavery, describing some bad event in your day a word that has an origin in describing people can lead to negative associations.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by fallingknife on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:23AM (#34067107)
Tons of black people where I come from, and I've talked to a lot. The idea that somehow that black people are afraid to tell white people what pisses them off is racist and incorrect. Again, comes only from upper class white people who don't actually talk to anyone other than other upper class white people. Here's a tip for you. Don't spout woke shit to minorities you meet IRL (as in outside of SV). It's cringe AF, and will make people dislike you. Just talk to them like normal people, which they are.

I mean, you do realize that 99% of black people have no idea where "grandfathered in" comes from, right? You do realize that going into etymology to find offense is something only snobby linguistics cunts that you would find at elite universities would do, right?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:37PM (#34075111)
> I strongly suspect that you may not have a relationship with the people who this language impacts.

In society we have come to a collective understanding that “I’m not racist; some of my best friends are black” is an invalid dismissal of a person’s potential for racism.

Somehow, however, we have also decided that if someone does not have a sufficient quantity nor quality of relationships with black people, then that is a strong signal of racism.

Damned if you do. Damned if you don’t.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by d0100 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:22AM (#34092961)
Brazil has started to try importing this US "harmful words" shenanigans, and most of the words they target are common vernacular among the supposedly harmed people

Labeling a word as harmful actually harms more, since most new generations are so removed from the word's origin that it carries none of the supposed harm

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tsimionescu on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:10AM (#34063018)
A good long part of the list is dedicated to avoiding black/white words as if the negative connotations of the color black, and the positive connotations of the color white, have anything to do with their use in racial contexts. I find this deeply disturbing and absurd.

A blacklist, a black-hat hacker etc have nothing to do with racialized use of these terms. The color black is deeply associated with death in European cultures, and as such it has clear negative usages. Trying to make it seem like this somehow reflects negatively on black people is simply wrong, ahistorical, and encourages a kind of extreme thinking that really does seem like a slippery slope.

The logic used to even suggest these words are harmful to black people directly leads to the conclusion that dressing in black at a funeral or representing Death as a figure hooded in black should be avoided, as they perpetuate this association.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mdiesel on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:06AM (#34063457)
Language absolutely affects how we think, the brain makes links subconsciously and learns all the time from all inputs, so I don't think it's sensible to dismiss the idea of language making small differences to how we think.

The most likely cause of death for me on the next 20 years, as a white man in his 20s, is suicide. A major part of the reasoning for that is men typically struggle to reach out and talk about issues. A contributing factor I think is growing up around phrases like "man up" or "stop being a girl". Obviously anyone who says them isn't saying "bottle up serious issues until it becomes too much" but that repeated learning does stick and despite times changing and there being far less pressure now to be an alpha head of family type guy, the issues continue to affect us.

I don't see any reason that same repeated learning from a young age wouldn't also apply to black/white language if there's an overwhelming imbalance.

Muhammad Ali famously gave a speech on exactly this, though he also covered cultural references as well which is a broader scope: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-us-canada-52988605

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tsimionescu on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:59AM (#34064241)
The link between the color black and negative feelings exists beyond language, and it has 0% to do with anyone's race. Furthermore, the negative association is with the deep black color of funeral clothes, not with the brown color of most black people's skin.

Even more, the color black itself has many different connotations, and not all are negative. It is for example a color of formal prestige (black belt, black ribbon). It is high-contrast (the situation is black and white). It is the color of things which don't emit light (black body radiation, black hole). It is also the color of many bronze statues, and also of ebony - both often used to depict saints and Jesus himself all in black since medieval times.

Humans are perfectly capable of keeping context in mind, and connotations from one context don't actually bleed into other contexts all that much.

The missing representation of black people in European and American art is a different problem, and it is a real problem that won't be addressed by replacing black box with opaque box.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mdiesel on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:11AM (#34064810)
Not bleeding across "all that much" might well be true, though I disagree since it's kinda the whole strength of the human brain applying learning from one area to another, that's why we're more intelligent than animals and have been more adaptable to new problems. You're also thinking about this in terms of conscious decision making when in our day to day lives we rarely sit down with an open mind and properly think about things.

But even if it is not all that much, it's still there. A million people having a 1% shift in their views due to language adds up. That's why we're seeing groups of individuals who aren't racist/sexist somehow reach answers that statistically do appear to be.

The specifics of which uses are neutral or not is the next debate. Step 1 is acknowledging that language is something that feeds into the "nurture" side of how we think, especially since language is such a large part of our learning during early brain development. With that in mind, it's something that should be debated and selection of words should be considered.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tsimionescu on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:11AM (#34065365)
If there actually was even a 1% universal association of the color black with evil (instead of the more specific associations that happen in certain contexts), do you really think anyone in medieval times would have created representations of Jesus, Mary and other highly revered figures in black wood or metal?

It is up to anyone claiming such an effect exists to go and prove it with solid data, enough data to overturn hundreds of years of language use. And if such a link actually exists, and someone actually believes in it, then I would like to see them insist people don't wear black (or red, yellow, brown or whatever other color they think is racialized) to funerals.

Edit: I also want to comment on the idea that the brain's ability to generalize would apply to meaning bleeding between separate contexts that use the same words. I think this is a misunderstanding of how the brain works. Concepts used in our thought later get translated into (spoken/written) language, or back again when listening/reading. But, the concepts are not the words that they are represented by. The black of a funeral is not the same concept as the black used to refer to a black person, even though they use the same word or symbol. Just like I'm not applying anything I know about mice scurrying through my house to the mouse I'm holding in my hand while playing (even though the origin of the word is exactly that animal), there is no reason to think there is any transfer whatsoever between the various meanings of black, even if they are related.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mdiesel on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:22AM (#34068061)
If you're waiting for someone to find a case of someone joining the KKK because they once heard about a blacklist, of course that is never going to happen. This is about one facet of learning that happens over 20 years of someones childhood, and then trying to link it to statistical issues that emerge over large groups. If it were even possible to isolate all the different factors to just look at language, it would take generations to test.

This is where we're coming at it from different sides. I think changing language is a relatively cheap and easy thing to do, that might help fix an issue in some small way, and there's really not much reason not to. The cause and effect is plausible, if not provable on any reasonable timescale.

Metaphor, simile, pathetic fallacy are all powerful tools that really do change the way we interpret the substance of what we read. Colours too, it's not a coincidence the major tech brands have gone with various blues, those blues are deliberately designed to nudge people towards a particular emotional response that is completely unrelated to the brand itself. If word selection really did nothing to change the impression of what we read, then writers and poets would be out of a job.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by PrefixKitten on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:36PM (#34071262)
In NASCAR the color black is legendary for reasons I truly hope don't need to be explained
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dTal on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:05PM (#34083301)
>The link between the color black and negative feelings exists beyond language

We should probably just stop calling people "black" then.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by cataphract on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:15AM (#34064338)
> Language absolutely affects how we think, the brain makes links subconsciously and learns all the time from all inputs, so I don't think it's sensible to dismiss the idea of language making small differences to how we think.

This is true enough, the problem is going from the conclusion that these negative associations will have any real-world impact. Recent reviews of implicit association tests (IAT) suggest that they correlate with nothing but brain activity.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ohgodplsno on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:57AM (#34065901)
This is the strong Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, and it has been disproved many times. Language certainly affects how you think in the way you turn sentences (a french speaker speaking in english will definitely word and think of things relative to how french behaves), but the theory that using words that could eventually have had a racial history in the very specific context of the United States would affect you on a deep level is utter bullshit.

The issue with "man up" or "stop being a girl" isn't language, it's patriarchal habits having ingrained in many of us that men don't cry, men don't talk, men are strong. It's not the words used that kill you, it's the social construct.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tosc on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:38PM (#34074503)
> It's not the words used that kill you, it's the social construct

How does the social construct get perpetuated except through words?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ohgodplsno on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:44AM (#34077804)
By every single sense and aspect of you.

Hearing those words is a thing, yes. Men wearing floral perfumes will be shamed for it (patriarchy sees this as feminine). Men will receive less gentle physical touches, caresses, care, either in an expectation that it makes them weaker, or that they don't need it. Men are expected to dress a certain way.

Men don't commit suicide _just_ because they're told to man up and deal with it. They do it because of a socially enforced dreadful lack of emotional comfort. A hug doesn't need words to comfort someone, not being judged or looked at wrongly for going away from the mold doesn't need words to comfort someone. That's why it's a social construct, not a verbal construct. It permeates everything around you.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tosc on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:57AM (#34083174)
No. It’s not that simple. Yes there is a legacy of cultural practices to contend with, but it isn’t this all encompassing reality you imagine.

Consider that levels of affection afforded to men (or harshness they are expected to endure) vary significantly across cultures and very much between subcultures in a modern nation like the US. It’s trivial to find groups of people who are very positive about affection vs people who are very traditional within a few miles of each other.

These groups speak very differently about their ideas of masculinity (since you introduced that example) and will make different arguments about what is right. Those arguments absolutely do inform group members and newcomers alike about what is considered acceptable.

Language is of course not everything - people do learn through mimicry, but you might be surprised how easy it is to use language to get someone to try something they didn’t think was for them. Advertisers do this all the time.

I don’t really see how someone can sit there with a straight face and say language doesn’t matter because of patriarchy.

Also patriarchy doesn’t ‘see’ anything because patriarchy isn’t a person and doesn’t have eyes. Patriarchy is an academic term for a set of ideas, not a mystical being.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tsimionescu on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:56AM (#34077868)
The point is that they get perpetuated through any words. "Ban" a word and a phrase will take its place.

This is very visible in the words used for those with mental disabilities. They used to be called "idiots" by doctors. Then, as idiot became a common insult, doctors moved on to "<people with a> mental retard". When that became a common insult, they moved on to "mentally challenged" and so on. This will be a never-ending arms-race though: as long as people insist on insulting others by comparing them to those that have a mental disability, they will always pick up the current medical terminology for them and use it as an insult.

Note that I'm not saying we should be calling children with Down syndrome "idiots" or "retards". Even though the "fight" will probably be endless, it's worth it not to use known derogatory terms for your pacients. Similarly, even though racists and other bigots can express their bigotry even with perfectly neutral language, it doesn't mean we should accept the use of slurs.

But it's also important not to get a false impression that just because Richard Spencer isn't using the n-word to refer to black people (in public), it means he's not being racist. You can always use language to teach others to hate BIPOC and ask for them to be thrown out of the country, along with LGBTQIA+ people if you're at it.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dTal on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:02PM (#34083249)
If anything, it's possible that the powerful connotations of "white" and "black" influenced their application in a racial context in the first place.

I see this backwards sort of thinking elsewhere in the list. Someone once used "yellow" as a racial pejorative, but instead of simply condemning the slur they attempt to preserve it, by forbidding other, non-racialized uses of the word "yellow".

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kelnos on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:39AM (#34063233)
I was surprised to learn about "grandfathered" here, too. But, frankly, I am skeptical of their explanation, after reading their incredibly specious reasoning for avoiding "tarball". Not to mention my skepticism over whether any serious numbers of black people would actually be offended by "grandfathered". But hey, I'm a white guy, so I could easily be wrong about that. (It's just that I feel like the majority of people who might jump down my throat for believing "grandfathered" isn't a big deal are more often than not likely to also be white people who don't actually know if the word is truly offensive, either.)

> but on the whole this list is basically just ‘try to be kind to others’. It’s disappointing to see it so badly received.

I think it's being so poorly received specifically because it doesn't come off as a "try to be kind to others" list. I do agree with quite a few of the things on their list, but many of the items are so out there and tenuous that it makes it seem like a list put together by some severely out-of-touch people who get off controlling others. Which, unfortunately, I suspect is actually the case. And I think overall it undermines the efforts of people who are trying to get others to stop using some of the legitimately harmful words on the list.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hoseja on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:06AM (#34063462)
You should probably stop using language whatsoever, it was made by people who lived human lives.

Switch to something like Lobjan.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jkingsbery on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:59AM (#34068660)
That might be the intent, but in a lot of ways it expresses the opposite. For at least half of the terms flagged by this page, one would have to construe the meaning uncharitably for it to be a problem. If I call someone a paraplegic, I only imply that the person cannot walk, not that the person cannot accomplish other great things. If you try to tell me that I meant that that person isn't a person at all, then you are the one being unkind, not me. It is not the case that "masters enslaved people" - some masters did, but some masters also served as teachers to an apprentice, and if you tell me that I meant the kind that enslaved people when I clearly meant the kind that taught apprentices, then you are the unkind one, not me.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by vineyardmike on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:47AM (#34063296)
Some people recognize that language has impact on others, despite the intentions of the speaker. Those people may chose to adapt their language to be more accommodating, or ignore it.

Its like requiring all new buildings be handicap accessible. No one is mandating that everyone use a wheelchair, but instead we're building new things in a way to (try to) minimize the impact on the handicap. By telling architects that stairs are hard to use, and ramps are easier, you're telling people how to build for everyone.

Similarly, by telling people what words may have negative meanings, you're empowering them to minimize their impact on others. This is a suggested language update, not a forced way of speaking, so its even weaker than the handicap accessible requirement. If you meet this list with open contempt but you don't show the same contempt for a handicap ramp... then maybe approach the list with a different perspective.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by djray on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:39AM (#34064090)
Strong disagree. You present a very poor strawman (sorry, straw-person). Don't attempt to equate physical disabilities with what is effectively learned behaviour.

Academic institutions are increasingly places which attempt to police language (and consequently thought). It's a nigh-on puritanical drive to molly-coddle the overly sensitive and limit debate. And it's even more frustrating considering the fact that an academic institution is the place where young people should be exploring all viewpoints, not just what has been deemed acceptable by the elite or those in power. Also see: de-platforming.

It's telling that some of these are terms which have been used without issue for far longer than half a century. It's only recently that they've ever been deemed to be "harmful". I don't know, it's almost as if...the same word can have different meanings depending on its context!

You may say that this is optional and just a suggestion, but it's a short path from compiling a list of these terms to real honest-to-goodness compelled speech.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ModernMech on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:50AM (#34065137)
> It's a nigh-on puritanical drive to molly-coddle the overly sensitive and limit debate.

When have you last spent any significant time at a university? Debate and diversity of thought are ever present. I can’t think of a single viewpoint that is missing from my institution.

Sometimes people don’t like what you have to say and cause a stink, but that’s what tenure is for. Unless you’re consuming a steady right wing news diet, I don’t see how you could come to your conclusion.

> You may say that this is optional and just a suggestion

So what do you propose, we ban letting people make lists of words? This is just an exercise in marketing, not the slope to which your speech will be controlled. Feel free to do and say whatever you want, offend whomever you want. No one is obliging you to pay attention to the the guidelines Stanford is making for themselves behind their school login; this list is not only optional for you, it’s not even meant to be read by you.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by bentley on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:32AM (#34067264)
> So what do you propose, we ban letting people make lists of words?

Amazingly, the strawmen keep coming. You think this is a bad list because it has bad entries in it? You must be against the very concept of lists!

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mensetmanusman on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:04PM (#34070684)
“I can’t think of a single viewpoint that is missing from my institution.“

You know when you are a bubble when…

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dumpsterdiver on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:50PM (#34076425)
> So what do you propose, we ban letting people make lists of words?

I'm not a huge fan of watching baseball. Would you also assume that I want baseball to be banned just because I'm not that into it?

There are ways to gracefully respond to someone you disagree with, but suggesting that someone wants to "ban letting people make lists of words" because they disagree with the content of a single list isn't one of them. If you're going to be disingenuous at least put a little effort into it.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ModernMech on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:05AM (#34080194)
I’m not being disingenuous. If you haven’t noticed, the range of opinions here starts at “meh” and ends at “I’m serious that we need to literally ban these people who wrote this list from decent society.”

That someone here might believe we need to ban the making of lists like this (because they believe them to be the first step to controlled speech) is not far fetched to me, especially when they are so worked up about a list that has no conceivable power over them and their life. It’s just a list of words. If you see a problem with a list of words, what is the proposal to fix that, exactly? Short of banning lists entirely, what fixes are even possible?

Anyway, can you think of ways to engage with someone without calling them disingenuous? Why wade into this discussion if you’re just going to attack my motives? You felt like I needed to be chided even though all of the discussion in this story has died?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by AustinDev on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:45AM (#34064134)
‘Handicap’ is offensive consider using ‘differently-abled’
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by TexanFeller on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:43AM (#34065736)
Elsewhere in the comments jojobas informed us that "differently abled" is also offensive now: https://www.betterup.com/blog/differently-abled
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by AustinDev on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:54AM (#34065860)
Haha now that’s hilarious.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by fallingknife on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:46AM (#34067484)
And fair enough. If I were disabled, and you called me "differently abled," or any of these other awful bureaucratic terms, I would probably want to punch you in the face. It's just dripping with condescension.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by YurgenJurgensen on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:23AM (#34064404)
'Perspective' is a visual phenomenon, and therefore its use is offensive to the blind.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by scarmig on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:29PM (#34074393)
> No one is mandating

Humandating, please. Etymology aside, this is suggestive of men forcing people to do things, which is insensitive of ~~survivors of rape~~ people who have survived rape.

> architects

People who engage in architecture. Just as people who engage in sex work do not want to be reduced to sex workers, people who architect do not want to be reduced to their occupation. Architect also has white supremacist undertones, as it's derived from a Greek word and implies the ability of white men to impose order on physical reality.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by horns4lyfe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:28AM (#34079786)
You should let people in a wheelchair know that providing wheelchair ramps is on the same level of importance as removing words like “tarball” from use. Sounds very important.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sinity on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:58AM (#34081505)
> Some people recognize that language has impact on others, despite the intentions of the speaker.

Fine; can we ban "nail polish remover"? I'm a Pole, and this reminds me of Nazis killing millions of poles. When will someone do something about this horrific phrase?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by akiselev on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:56AM (#34062093)
> "submit" ("Depending on the context, the term can imply allowing others to have power over you.")

And they’re simultaneously kink shaming!

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by throwawaylinux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:56AM (#34062099)
The absolute state of the left.

They obviously inflame and pursue this kind of garbage to 1. distract from the absolute failures in almost all their prior such initiatives, and 2. to perpetuate their positions and status as experts and leaders at combating discrimination.

The glaring lack of objective evidence for almost all of these idiotic efforts really takes the cake. And if you dare to ask for any, you'll get bullied by throngs of sycophants if not the "experts" and institutions themselves -- "Why is it so hard for you to just change a few words? Are you really so racist that you would rather keep using bigoted language?"

The craziest thing is that places this drivel comes from are typically hives of institutional discrimination and racism. Actual discrimination, I mean.

They don't want you using the word "American" to refer to people from USA, because "This term often refers to people from the United States only, thereby insinuating that the US is the most important country in the Americas (which is actually made up of 42 countries)." Utter claptrap.

It's high time these charlatans are forced to cough up actual evidence for their claims and demonstrate the efficacy of all their prior work, and run out of town if they are incapable of delivering, which they will not be. People should just collectively laugh in their faces and tell them they're full of it. Bullies quickly lose their power when people start to stand up to them.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kashunstva on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:14AM (#34062648)
> The absolute state of the left.

The left is not a monolithic block of automatons. There is some large number of persons who support most progressive positions but decry this sort of top-down control of language along with the way it’s used to enforce an orthodoxy of opinion. Labelling this as an “absolute state” of the left is a mischaracterization of the positions of most progressives I know.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by throwawaylinux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:19AM (#34062671)
Sorry, this is what the mainstream left is. It's an accurate characterization. I don't need to do an exhaustive poll of every single person who calls themselves leftists to paint a broad but accurate stroke, which is clearly what this is. Just like you can criticize "conservatives" for some common or mainstream stance without first ensuring that they are a monolithic block of automatons on that issue.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by TylerE on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:50AM (#34062879)
Then the right is a bunch of bigoted, science hating Hitler worshipers! See how easy and fun it is?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by throwawaylinux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:09AM (#34063483)
Were you under the impression that the right does not receive generalized criticism on the internet or this web site? Or that your comment is a rebuttal to what I wrote?

By all means feel free to criticize conservatives / right wing. They certainly do make it easy, you're right about that if nothing else.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kelnos on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:11AM (#34063026)
> Sorry, this is what the mainstream left is.

Sorry, you have no idea what you're talking about.

See, I can make blanket, unsupported statements, too, and pretend they're facts!

(Also love the sibling's comment about the right. If you're gonna paint the left with the brush you've chosen, gotta do the same with the right.)

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by throwawaylinux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:14AM (#34063518)
> Sorry, you have no idea what you're talking about.

> See, I can make blanket, unsupported statements, too, and pretend they're facts!

This isn't an argument.

> (Also love the sibling's comment about the right. If you're gonna paint the left with the brush you've chosen, gotta do the same with the right.)

I don't gotta do anything. Obviously the right can be and is criticized in a generalized way like I'm doing with the left now, but I'm not talking about the right here.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by andrekandre on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:16AM (#34062659)

  > The absolute state of the left.
not to play semantics too much, but is it "the left" or elite liberals that are pushing this kind of stuff?

it seems (anecdotally) to me that this kind of language policing is mostly pushed from the top down... maybe im wrong tho...

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by rjbwork on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:53AM (#34062905)
We should play semantics here. Elite liberals control the institutions, not some imagined socialist, communist, or anarchist boogiemen. Stanford is one of the most elite of elite institutions, and I don't see ANYONE there or any high profile graduates attempting to wrest the means of production from their alumni funders.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by erosenbe0 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:32AM (#34063176)
Insitutional elites are not liberals anymore, just opportunists. Those Alumni funders are largely possible because ultra-wealthy elite institutions have tax-exempt status. Plus, they are allowed to admit whoever they want despite taking in lots of federal funding. So the offspring of oil-barons and politicians comingle with the top 0.1% of academic talent, creating the next generation of crony capitalists.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by throwawaylinux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:18AM (#34063543)
But they are the mainstream left's thought-leaders and popular politicians, and they get broad support and little criticism.

How many significant leftist politicians, journalists, news corporations, academics, or other commentators criticize this kind of rubbish coming from Stanford? How many polls of left leaning people would disagree with it? Very few I suspect.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by SturgeonsLaw on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:35AM (#34065003)
There are no leftist politicians in the United States. I think you're mixing up liberals and leftists.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mbg721 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:38AM (#34065025)
No one knows what to call the Democrats' political philosophy. It's not really leftist, although it sometimes claims to want to be, and it certainly isn't liberal in this age of woke authoritarians.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by throwawaylinux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:07AM (#34065321)
I'm not. Clearly they've long since abandoned any pretense of being an actual labor movement, but this is what the left is now and everybody knows what is meant. The majority of self identified left-leaning people will vote for and support democrat party politicians.

It's just as unhelpful to try to claim there are no right wing politicians in the United States because none of them actually support free markets or small government. Technically true by at least some of the multitude of definitions, but it's just being contrary.

I get that a lot of leftists are probably deeply embarrassed and upset by what their movement has become. I was too. But language evolves and so do political movements, and it's more correct to say that the leftist movement in the United States (and largely the western world) are no longer of and for the worker.

They certainly aren't traditional liberals either, defined by support for liberty, individual rights, equality, ad tolerance.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by andrekandre on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:20PM (#34074266)

  > a lot of leftists are probably deeply embarrassed and upset by what their movement has become.
then what should they call themselves... they don't agree with "the left" yet they are part of the left? orthodox leftists?

  > They certainly aren't traditional liberals either, defined by support for liberty, individual rights, equality, ad tolerance.
they sound like... conservatives?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kelnos on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:24AM (#34063115)
I'm downvoting you not because you're entirely wrong, but because you've chosen to be somewhat right in an irritating, unproductive, flamebaity manner.

No, this is not "the absolute state of the left". This is the state of some loud people who think they have the final word on ethics and morals. Unfortunately, many others have allowed them to flourish, rather than shutting them down.

I agree with some of the items on Stanford's list, though most of the words I think are pretty harmless, or at least should be. That doesn't mean that some people wouldn't feel harmed by them, but it's just my personal opinion that the harm is minimal, or that yes, some people do need to learn that not everything is about them, and that language has moved on, and no one actually associates the word they're using with the thing they feel offended about. (Like, if I were to say something was "lame", I would not expect a person who couldn't walk to be offended by that, as that's just not what "lame" means anymore. Ditto for words like "dumb".)

But "master"/"slave"? Sure, those words suck. "Tranny"? Sure, 90% of the people using it are using it as a slur, and I don't want to be associated with shitty people like that. "Black-" prefixes meaning things that are bad, and "white-" prefixes meaning things that are good? Yeah, screw that, that's bullshit.

But then we get to... "Tarball"? Associated with "tarbaby"? What, are you kidding me? "Brown bag"? I'd never heard of the association with "brown paper bag test"; I always thought of it as "brown bag lunch", as in the kind of paper bag I'd always use to bring my lunch with me to school when I was a kid. Is the negative association actually a thing, or is this just Stanford's hand-wringing over nothing?

I'm also really annoyed by the "person-first" stuff. Not only is "person who has immigrated" a mouthful, but I don't know any actual immigrants who would consider being called an "immigrant" offensive. Worse, I think trying to put a stigma on words like "immigrant" ends up putting a stigma on the entire idea of being "a person who has immigrated", which is a shitty thing to do.

I've gone to the effort to write all this out to attempt to demonstrate to you that not everyone on the left -- or even a "majority of mainstream" or whatever you think -- would come up with or agree with the entirety (or even a majority) of a boneheaded list like this. My perspective is absolutely not unique in this, either.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by throwawaylinux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:05AM (#34063455)
Hopefully it helps you feel better to shoot the messenger, and eventually helps you get the courage to stand up against it. Would be really great if the left actually focused on important issues instead of this unscientific divisive bullcrap. I'd better add the disclaimer here that I also hope the right does too, because I seem to have twisted a lot of panties and enraged some valiant "nazi" hunters falling over themselves to bully me for daring to laugh at this pathetic clownery.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by patcon on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:20AM (#34062270)
> - Words that have long since lost any stigmatizing meaning by virtue of the original use being so ancient ("lame", "dumb", "stupid")

If you've known someone with mobility issues (e.g., a limp from birth) long enough for them to be honest with you, then the term "lame" (as a slang term meaning "something shitty") that might still be a sore spot.

EDIT: you don't have to do anything. But it does mean something to some ppl, and some of these ppl do notice it being said or avoided. And after hearing that from someone you care about, if might make you want to notice more (once the surprise of realizing it's an actual concern fades away)

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kergonath on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:18AM (#34067041)
> But it does mean something to some ppl, and some of these ppl do notice it being said or avoided

Yes, but that is very context-dependent. The rule of thumb is “don’t be stupid” and “don’t be a dick” (yes, offensive to eunuchs and people who think this excludes women; in which case replace with “twat”). The words you need to avoid to that effect depend on who you’re talking to and in which circumstances. Blanket bans based on lists of words someone is crusading against are counter-productive.

> And after hearing that from someone you care about

The first time can just be a mistake; people you care about do not have the exact same mindset you have. In that case, a short explanation should suffice, without implying malice. If it is a pattern, then the people you care about don’t care as much about you.

OTOH, it is unreasonable to expect a random stranger on the Internet to be aware of your sensitivities.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jrmg on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:24AM (#34062316)
It’s very obviously not intended to imply that all the terms are equally offensive or inaccurate.

Why _wouldn’t_ I want to avoid using any but your last category?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by cipheredStones on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:33AM (#34062382)
One would hope it isn't intended to imply that, but if not, it's doing an extremely poor job at it.

Here's two almost-adjacent entries:

> hip-hip hurray, hip hip hooray > This term was used by German citizens during the Holocaust as a rallying cry when they would hunt down Jewish citizens living in segregated neighborhoods.

> Jewed > This term is based on a stereotype that people of Jewish descent are cheap and/or hoard money.

The latter is, as I said, a well-known slur that any Jew would find offensive. The former is an extremely commonplace expression which is allegedly offensive due to a history that I've never in my life heard of before, and which seems on a quick search to be quite dubiously evidenced.

Without knowing the actual context of these, one might very well be persuaded by this list that "hip, hip, hooray" was more offensive than "Jewed" - after all, a rallying cry for a genocide sounds more harmful than a mere ethnic stereotype!

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jrmg on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:40AM (#34062426)
It says, at the top of the page:

The purpose of this website is to educate people about the possible impact of the words we use. Language affects different people in different ways. We are not attempting to assign levels of harm to the terms on this site. We also are not attempting to address all informal uses of language.

This website focuses on potentially harmful terms used in the United States, starting with a list of everyday language and terminology. Our "suggested alternatives" are in line with those used by peer institutions and within the technology community.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by cipheredStones on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:51AM (#34062496)
I don't actually see how this is an argument against my point at all.

They say "we are not attempting to assign levels of harm to the terms on this site", and then proceed to list a huge number of terms, some of which are almost universally viewed as discriminatory or harmful and some of which are almost universally viewed as _not_ discriminatory or harmful. They may not be explicitly claiming that these terms have equivalent negative impact, but the presentation does nothing to suggest otherwise, and in many cases neither do the explanations.

As I said in my original comment, it's an "arson, murder, and jaywalking" approach - as if someone had just given you a list saying "these things are illegal, don't do them" without noting that one of them can be punished by life in prison and another is so widely disregarded that it'll be viewed as odd if you never do it.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jrmg on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:57AM (#34062544)
I think “We are not attempting to assign levels of harm to the terms on this site.” is quite pain in its meaning. Do you just object to the existence of the list? Or am I misunderstanding and you’re just saying it’s weird to list them all together, and not attempting to ascribe value (or lack thereof) to the list?

I still think my original question stands - why wouldn’t I want to avoid most of these terms? Isn’t the list useful if I would?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by cipheredStones on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:23AM (#34062713)
> Do you just object to the existence of the list?

I object to the existence of this particular list because I think it's extremely poorly done - to the point of being actively harmful to efforts to reduce offensive language - and would be incredibly confusing to anyone who didn't already have the fairly deep linguistic and cultural competence required to know which parts to take seriously and which parts to ignore.

I don't object to the general existence of lists of this type, but I do think they're often subject to the same pathologies this one is.

> I still think my original question stands - why wouldn’t I want to avoid most of these terms? Isn’t the list useful if I would?

I think a huge section of this list is not helpful to anybody. "Red team", "yellow team", and "black box" have nothing to do with race whatsoever, for example, nor would a reasonable person think they did; eliminating them from your vocabulary would do no more to address racial injustice than eliminating "armadillo" would. And I do think there are costs to urging people to monitor their speech to greater and greater degrees for rapidly decreasing - and in many cases zero - benefit.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jrmg on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:07PM (#34071747)
Thanks. I understand your position better now, and agree with more of it than I first thought. I don’t think our positions are so divergent as to be problematic in real life - though I suspect I will continue to monitor my speech a little more than I you think is advisable.

I wish online forums encouraged civil discussion like this more than they seem to. So much knee-jerk even here.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jamincan on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:49AM (#34067533)
I see a list like this potentially being more harmful than helpful in a few respects:

1. By saying certain phrases could be understood to be harmful, even when they aren't commonly understood to be and explicitly don't have racist or sexist etymologies, the list is actually reinforcing the threads of harmful stereotypes in our language. Black box is not a racist term; adding it to a list like this just associates black=bad, which is not something we should want at all.

2. Lists like this encourage black-and-white thinking about language that ignores context. It's the same sort of thinking that leads to your white uncle complaining that rappers use the n word, so why can't he? Words don't hurt; how words are used hurt.

3. Lists like this are ripe for abuse. While I have heard interesting discussions about how certain language can be harmful (The Allusionist podcast recently had an interesting discussion over terms like neuro-divergent, neuro-typical, autism and so on), it is often used in a bullying way to dismiss and discredit someone who is trying to engage in good faith rather than to educate. Consider "rule of thumb". The etymology presented is wrong, but wide spread. Maybe the fact that many people believe this is enough to avoid it, but the list doesn't present this nuance and instead perpetuates the myth.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Xelynega on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:40PM (#34071334)
I see it quite opposite.

"We are not attempting to assign levels of harm to the terms on this site" means literally nothing but "we shouldn't be held accountable for intermingling actual racial slurs with misinterpreted Wikipedia articles".

I don't see how trying to cover your ass at the start of an article somehow invalidates the content of the article.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hbrn on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:01AM (#34062574)
> term was used by German citizens during the Holocaust as a rallying cry when they would hunt down Jewish citizens living in segregated neighborhoods.

Hmm, I bet they also drank water after hunting down Jews. Drinking water literally makes you a Nazi!

Seriously though, where does this stop? Don't they see the absurdity? It almost feels like absurdity is the goal.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by YurgenJurgensen on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:16AM (#34064355)
It stops when they reach the end of the euphemism treadmill. There is no goal here, only the desire to be seen to be doing something. When you reward people for catching rats, they don't kill all the rats, as then there won't be any rats to catch next season.

Except that 'treadmills' were used as punishment devices in prisons, so the preferred alternative is 'euphemism exercise machine'. Except that "exercise" is ableist and so the real preferred alternative is...

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by schoen on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:01AM (#34062576)
It seems that the etymology is actually mistaken.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hep-Hep_riots

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/hip_hip_hooray

I've heard the earlier theory (that it was an acronym for "Hierosolyma est perdita" which was supposed to have been a Crusader slogan), but Wiktionary thinks this is a false etymology.

I'm Ashkenazi Jewish and have never heard any Jewish or non-Jewish person claim to have personally associated the "hip hip hooray" cheer with antisemitism. Perhaps that association, even if it's etymologically incorrect, would have been top-of-mind for many Europeans in the 1820s, but I don't think that's so today.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by animuchan on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:43AM (#34062832)
Moreover, the same "hip-hip hooray" rally cry was used by the Red Army, who (while not specifically siding with Jewish people) liberated quite a number of people from the death camps.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by azangru on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:06AM (#34063456)
> the same "hip-hip hooray" rally cry was used by the Red Army

Which Red Army? Unless it's the Chinese Red Army (which I have no knowledge about), but rather the Russian (Soviet) Red Army, then, firstly, the battle cry of its soldiers was not "hip-hip hooray", but rather "ura" (cognate of the English "hurrah"); and, secondly, this battle cry is much older than the Red Army. It's an old word; almost certainly a borrowing into Russian; but in which century (seventeenth? sixteenth? older?), and from which language, I do not know.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hef19898 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:07AM (#34064304)
Well, this is the first time I hear "Hipp, hipp, Hurra" (the proper German version, since hurray is definetly not German) being linked to the Nazis and anti-semitism... And us Germans are rather sensitive about that
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by shever73 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:05AM (#34064285)
Yes, the use of "hip hip hip hoorah" (with three "hips") in English predates the Hep Hep riots.

Most etymologies attributed to acronyms for words pre-20th century are usually false.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by scarygliders on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:19AM (#34063085)
> The latter is, as I said, a well-known slur that any Jew would find offensive.

You'd be incorrect, as I happen to know a Jew who some might consider "based" and knowingly says things like "...so I Jewed it..." and so on. Like, he literally just comes out and says these things in casual conversation and humour.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hoten on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:22AM (#34063565)
Not sure what you're meaning here. Slurs aren't slurs without the context of hatred or disdain, and an obvious example of self deprecating humor doesn't mean that your friend would enjoy a stranger directing that word towards him.

Pretty much no one would claim the n-word is not a slur just because some black people use it amongst each other.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Xelynega on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:44PM (#34071390)
As we know, music created by artists who identify as "black" has never had racial slurs against that same group included.

"Finding something offensive" is not mutually exclusive with "doing that thing yourself".

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by azangru on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:53AM (#34063345)
> Why _wouldn’t_ I want to avoid using any but your last category?

Thing is, _you_ are free to avoid anything you want for whatever reason you want. It is when someone else (e.g. myself) who doesn't want to have his language policed is faced with a prospect of being told to change his language, that he may become upset. After all, if you recognise that language is part of a person's identity, and that identity is important (as those who champion such linguistic changes almost invariably tend to do), it is really inconsistent to then be demanding that people change the way they talk.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ModernMech on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:24AM (#34064924)
> it is really inconsistent then to be demanding that people change the way they talk.

Okay, but Stanford is not demanding that; this site is about words they don’t want used on their own websites and marketing materials. This isn’t a list of words they don’t want you to use, it’s a list of words they don’t want to use. The obvious solution if you don’t want to be policed by this word list is to not work at Stanford.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by azangru on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:43AM (#34065732)
> Okay, but Stanford is not demanding that; this site is about words they don’t want used on their own websites and marketing materials. This isn’t a list of words they don’t want you to use, it’s a list of words they don’t want to use. The obvious solution if you don’t want to be policed by this word list is to not work at Stanford.

I'm a little confused by the transition that happened within this paragraph. You start with a language used on websites and in marketing materials, and end by saying not to work at Stanford (which I don't :-) ). But there is a long range of cases that fall in between marketing materials and total strangers. Will professors, who are neither websites nor marketing materials, be obliged (or "advised") to abide by the code? Will the students? If someone working/studying at Stanford thinks that this is stupid, is he free to ignore the advice? Or does he have to leave? If someone associated with Stanford writes a book or a paper, will he need to have the language of his manuscript checked? What about a master's or a phd thesis? What about a talk? Lots of uncertainty there.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jack_codes on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:45AM (#34066576)
> is he free to ignore the advice? Or does he have to leave?

are they free to ignore the advice? Or do they have to leave?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by azangru on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:59AM (#34066751)
That's exactly what I am talking about :-) In my idiolect, it's a he; in your idiolect, it's a they; our idiolects are perfectly understandable to both of us; and yet, instead of simply recognising a variation in my speech, you feel an urge to change my language.

Remarkably, it's exactly the opposite of the public attitude towards regional dialects. Where previously it was common to correct speakers of non-prestigious dialects, it is now required to be accepting and tolerant.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jrmg on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:59AM (#34067689)
I take issue with “perfectly understandable”.

I think many (most?) people hearing or reading that would make an assumption from your use of ‘he’ that you expect that professors and students are usually male. Perhaps that you believe they _should_ be male. If you really mean them to be gender-neutral, you are not communicating clearly. I would argue that this has always been true - but even if I’m wrong about that, it’s true for modern English usage.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by azangru on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:26AM (#34068136)
The hypothetical "someone" in my sentence (a professor or a student) is indeed probably male if I look at him closely. I pass no comment on whether professors or students _should_ generally be male; but at the same time, have no qualms with imagining them as such. I understand that many think differently, and have seen plenty of texts where an imaginary character of unspecified sex is introduced as a she (a random example: "For a Product Owner to properly adapt a product, she needs some empirical evidence, something to inspect", from "The Professional Product Owner" by Don McGreal and Ralph Jocham). My argument is that if should be perfectly fine for a writer to use the default gender that he is most comfortable with.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hbrn on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:25AM (#34062325)
Basically anything that can make anybody[1] offended. If a term doesn't seem offensive right away, see if you can make it offensive through mental gymnastics.

[1] This, of course, excludes people like me, who are offended by the very existence of such lists.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by josephg on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:25AM (#34063123)
Uh oh! “mental gymnastics” sounds like it implies able bodied people who can do gymnastics are better than people with disabilities! Burn the heretic!

I find a lot of the cultural appropriation items on this list deeply ironic because they imply English is allowed to take words from French (“beef”, “rendezvous”) and German (“welcome”, “hound”, …). But terms from non-white cultures aren’t allowed to become part of english? (“Guru”, “bury the hatchet”, and so on in this list.)

Is it just me or is that policy remarkably racist?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by wasabi991011 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:55AM (#34063816)
The negative forms of cultural appropriation they want to remove is when a religious/ceremonial/"important" term from another culture (gury, bury the hatchet) is used in inappropriate context, not just any word from another language (beef, rendezvous, welcome, hound).

If you want a better example (though convoluted and still imperfect) of what that could look like for English, it would be like if a different language/culture started using the word "PhD" for anyone with some expertise. Now maybe you don't mind, but you've got to recognize that a fair amount of people would feel like it cheapens the work and expertise that goes into becoming a doctor.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dfadsadsf on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:16AM (#34063923)
You do not need to come up with convoluted example like PhD, just call code monkey an engineer and see chartered engineer come out of woodwork to complain that to be called engineer you need to do some random formal stuff and without that you break law in one province or another.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by vlovich123 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:42AM (#34065069)
And as someone who went to an accredited engineering program, I’d agree they’re silly. Doctor’s and lawyers have specific value in being restricted because the harm is so high. Chartered engineers can’t be confused because the business hiring them should be doing a backend check with the licensing board to confirm their license anyway (regardless of the title they put on a resume). I used to think it’s a good thing but I’ve come around to recognizing it as unnecessary protectionism / wanting to feel special.

Also doctors raise similar complaints when PhDs call themselves doctors.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 908B64B197 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:49PM (#34073139)
> Also doctors raise similar complaints when PhDs call themselves doctors.

... what do they think the "D" in PhD stands for?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by vlovich123 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:49AM (#34077473)
Doesn’t matter. The powers a licensed medical doctor have are very different and when someone says they’re a doctor in the middle of giving medical advice, they can’t play the “but I have a PhD card” or “free speech” because the recipient of that message would reasonably assume due to common colloquial understanding that that person is a licensed medical doctor (unless the PhD somehow clarified this in a reasonable way).

The main distinction that lawyers and medical doctors have in terms of the title is that these professions talk to lay people outside their profession regularly and there needs to be a distinction between them and other people offering advice that’s not governed by the rules of the medical community and codified in law. The risk and consequence of harm would be elevated and the ability for recourse would be limited. For example, if you get bad legal advice from random Joe Schmoe, you can’t claim ineffective council (heck you can’t even do that if it’s a licensed lawyer who told you something if that isn’t your lawyer. This doesn’t happen with engineers.

Now I’m not defending or espousing any specific position here. I’m just trying to illuminate the differences and the claims. The counterpoint is that these licensing requirements don’t actually change anything, they’re over broad, they raise prices on services far more than they should, they unfairly exclude people from prestigious jobs that maybe they could do anyway even without schooling (eg an experienced paralegal for 15 years maybe doesn’t need a “lawyer’s education” for certain kinds of legal work) and they go against the principle of free speech. On the other hand, trademarks exist and inhibit free speech in similar ways. On the other hand, trademarks can’t be regular words. On the other hand the government is responsible for writing the rules of trademarks.

On the other hand, this post brought to you by Tevya the Milkman and his fiddle.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 908B64B197 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:38PM (#34083766)
That's a fairly long response not to answer a very simple question.

> when someone says they’re a doctor in the middle of giving medical advice, they can’t play the “but I have a PhD card” or “free speech” because the recipient of that message would reasonably assume due to common colloquial understanding that that person is a licensed medical doctor (unless the PhD somehow clarified this in a reasonable way).

I don't see why in this scenario the burden would be on the PhD to offer clarification. Again, the meaning of the "D" in PhD hasn't changed in the west since the Middle Ages.

Medical Doctor can simply state his affiliation to his licensing board; to me some organization claiming ownership of a term in common usage singe the Middle Ages screams first amendment violation.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by afiori on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:36PM (#34096742)
Doctor is culturally a trademark
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 908B64B197 on Friday December 23, 2022 @12:43PM (#34108552)
That's not a thing.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by afiori on Saturday December 24, 2022 @08:36AM (#34116660)
Not in law
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sinity on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:04AM (#34080849)
> Doctor’s and lawyers have specific value in being restricted because the harm is so high.

Nah. Quoting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional

> The notion of a professional can be traced to medieval European guilds, most of which died off by the middle of the nineteenth century, the exception being the scholars guild, or university.

> With most guilds formally abolished outside of the realm of academia, establishing exclusivity and standards in a trade had to be achieved via other means such as licensing practices, of which might begin as an informal process established by voluntary professional associations, but then eventually become law due to lobbying efforts.

> (...) a significant motivation in the development of the AMA was to gain authority over unlicensed practitioners so as to minimize competition among medical practitioners, thereby enhancing the earning power and prestige of medical professionals. The licensing process Starr argues, was unnecessarily prolonged and the costs were artificially enhanced with the specific aim of deterring potential practitioners from entering the field.*

> (...) while defenders of guilds have argued that they allowed markets to function by ensuring quality standards, Sheliah Olgelvic has instead argued that markets of the Middle Ages flourished when guilds were abolished and that there is much evidence to support the notion that individuals prefer a wide variety of products of varying quality and price to being granted protections which they did not ask for, and which artificially constrain consumer options.

* on that note, https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/06/06/against-tulip-subsidie...

> In America, aspiring doctors do four years of undergrad in whatever area they want (I did Philosophy), then four more years of medical school, for a total of eight years post-high school education. In Ireland, aspiring doctors go straight from high school to medical school and finish after five years.

> Americans take eight years to become doctors. Irishmen can do it in four, and achieve the same result. Each year of higher education at a good school – let’s say an Ivy, doctors don’t study at Podunk Community College – costs about $50,000. So American medical students are paying an extra $200,000 for…what?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by TexanFeller on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:27AM (#34065546)
> code monkey

Please don't use that term as it summons the Ghost of Racism Past.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by FactoryReboot on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:24AM (#34064414)
Doctor’s borrowed the title from academics. They didn’t even have it first.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jkingsbery on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:58PM (#34070575)
But that's what the word in Latin doctus means: being learned or skilled in something: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/doctus.

And in any case, when a word is incorporated from another language, it's meaning is misunderstood all the time. Why is this case somehow morally offensive?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:38AM (#34065023)
England didn't take words from French, the French inserted them by force. The French conquered them and they had to learn some French to understand their lords and masters who spoke a different language.

That's why they as peasants looked after the cows, but the aristocrats from France ate the beef. (Sheep/mutton, pig/pork)

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mbg721 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:41AM (#34065052)
Your comment reminded me of a line I heard from a 90s comedian: "Oh, the royals are a sort of middle-class German family really,"
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:56AM (#34068609)
> England didn't take words from French, the French inserted them by force.

Is "reverse cultural appropriation" a thing then, or do we have a better phrase for when it's no longer appropriate for a population to use words that were inserted into their language by force?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:17PM (#34068949)
They fight back by pronouncing it horribly:

“L'anglais n'est que du français mal prononcé”

“English is little more than badly pronounced French”

-- D'Artagnan in Vingt ans après

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 082349872349872 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:22AM (#34081790)
murky buckup poor lead !
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by fsckboy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:43PM (#34076743)
England didn't take words from French, the French inserted them by force. The French conquered them and they had to learn some French to understand their lords and masters who spoke a different language.

False, it was not the French but the Normans, Vikings who had learned to speak French, who conquered England.

An England made up of Brittanic Celts who had been conquered, ruled over, and had mixed with and learned to speak the Germanic languages of the Angles, the Saxons and then the invading Danes.

French, the language of France, is derived from the Latin language of the Romans who had conquered that Gaulic Celtic place before they were in turn conquered by the Germanic Franks who switched from their lingua franca to Latin. Then the Normans settled in Normandy, just north of Brittany, still occupied by the Celts.

So there is nothing French about the Germanic Franks, nor anything Gaulic or Frankish about the language French, a language the Romans brought to Gaul and the Germanic Normans brought to Great Britain.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by gorwell on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:09PM (#34068804)
Yes, that's right. It's racist to the core but presented as "anti-racist", which is a remarkably effective phrase.

It was the same thing with food packaging. Land 'o Lakes literally removed the Native American woman but they kept the land!

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by thomasahle on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:38AM (#34062412)
> Indian summer | late summer | This term infers that Indigenous people are chronically late. While it may be innocently used to describe a beautiful time of year, it could have an unintended negative impact on those who hear it.

This one was surprising to me. I always assumed Indian summer was about summer in India lasting longer.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by devmunchies on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:52AM (#34062503)
Speaking of Indigenous Americans... the list has Brave (noun), with the reasoning: "This term perpetuates the stereotype of the "noble courageous savage," equating the Indigenous male as being less than a man."

I actually think Brave ("the Braves") would have been a good name to refer to Native Americans. I don't feel like "noble, courageous" is much of a slur. It's pretty honorable in fact. I don't see how calling someone brave equates them with less than a man.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by thomasahle on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:11AM (#34062627)
I've never heard brave used as a noun. Can you give me an example?

I guess I can see it used in an infantalising way.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by WalterBright on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:41AM (#34062817)
The dictionary sez: "a North American Indian warrior"
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ancapsfascists on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:44AM (#34062837)
It's often used in a wild west sorta way, "we were surrounded by braves". It's super outdated, for sure, as are most words that mean "my enemy's warriors".
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by devmunchies on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:54AM (#34062908)
The Atlanta Braves is a Major League Baseball team.

Used like you would use “warrior”.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by robarr on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:54AM (#34062911)
It was very common on old ‘cowboys and Indians’ movies’, at least on the old Spanish language translated reruns I watched as a kid: Some scout returned to some army fort and reported the presence of ‘500 braves’ coming from the north o hidden beyond some mountain or something like that.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by rsj_hn on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:27AM (#34063603)
example: "We came across a camp with twenty braves."

It's an unusual usage. Fun Fact: "brave" when referring to male warriors is assumed to come from Spanish bravo which means "courageous, untamed, savage".

The association of courage and savagery comes from Spanish Renaissance culture and both meanings are meant simultaneously - that is, savages - those prone to violence -- were associated with courage and vice versa. Because English didn't have such an association, the word was repurposed to have two meanings and the second meaning fell into disuse after the 19th Century.

Now in the 21st century, unless you are reading a book written in the 1800s, when you hear "brave" you can pretty much assume it's an adjective with the primary usage.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by thomasahle on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:23AM (#34063976)
> that is, savages - those prone to violence -- were associated with courage and vice versa. Because English didn't have such an association

The association of "savages" with honor and courage seems pretty universal. Like the vikings are often depicted with a strong sense of honor. Or the celtics by the romans, or the huns and mongols. Basically any tribal culture I can think of. While those living in cities / bigger civilizations are associated with corruption, deceit etc.

I suppose it's better to accept that both honor and deceit exist in all human beings, irrespective of group.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by rsj_hn on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:24PM (#34069994)
Yes, that's a good point. I wouldn't be surprised if this goes back to the original Latin
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by bregma on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:23AM (#34064911)
When I was growing up (many years ago now) we were taught that the indigenous people of North America were not men and women, but braves and squaws. Like stallions and mares, bucks and does, roosters and hens.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by agentwiggles on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:21PM (#34069006)
> A little Indian brave who before he was ten

> Played war games in the woods with his Indian friends

> And he built a dream that when he grew up

> He would be a fearless warrior, Indian Chief

> Many moons passed, and more the dream grew strong

> Until tomorrow he would sing his first war song

> And fight his first battle

> But something went wrong

> Surprise attack killed him in his sleep that night

> And so castles made of sand > Melts into the sea eventually

From Jimi Hendrix's Castles Made of Sand, one of his better and more underrated tunes.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by SanjayMehta on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:02AM (#34063419)
Brave Browser? Banned?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by vintermann on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:23AM (#34064412)
Well, I've wondered about that. Isn't it odd that black Americans have a comparatively low suicide rate, whereas native Americans have a sky-high one?

I have wondered if maybe at least some suicides are about a disconnect between what you're actually able to do, and what people expect of you.

It's obviously bad if people hate you and expect no good to come of you. But there's an additional horror when you're given an impossible task, and people expect you to do it - indeed, when they're actually genuinely disappointed in you when you can't. It's like in Kafka's "The transformation": the real horror isn't that Samsa wakes up and finds that he's turned into a giant cockroach. It's his family's reaction: how could you do this to us? How could you put us in this situation?

I'm thinking maybe that stereotypical image of the noble, brave Indian with his great wisdom, connection to nature, unbreakable spirit - something you'd want to live up to, who wouldn't? - is especially cruel in the face of the material realities of first nation communities.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by prepend on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:18AM (#34066207)
This stuck out to me as well. Also because you’re not supposed to use the word in any form so saying”devmunchies is brave” is bad.

I can understand a complaint like the Atlanta Braves offending someone because it’s a caricature, but still don’t think it should be changed.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dmitriid on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:53AM (#34062509)
In Russian this is called "women's summer"
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by trilbyglens on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:29AM (#34064453)
And in czech, "Babi Leto: or "granny summer", like the summer has gotten old, but still bakes you cookies.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by lo_zamoyski on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:43AM (#34068404)
Unsurprisingly, given the linguistic similarity, it's same in Polish ("babie lato"). But that's sexist and ageist, of course.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dmitriid on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:17PM (#34068952)
Yeah, same in Russian but I was too lazy to type it out on a mobile :D
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Lazare on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:35AM (#34065005)
They got the etymology wrong. There is no negative connotation.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by fleddr on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:38AM (#34068328)
Same for "burry the hatchet". That's actually a beautiful and creative expression to resolve a situation into peace.

Cultural appropriation is such a fucking dumb concept. It is a positive. It enriches all of us.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by goatlover on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:40PM (#34072210)
All of human history involves "cultural appropriation", since cultures are shared and shaped as different groups interact over time. Very few human groups remain so isolated that they're not influenced or don't influence other cultures.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by fleddr on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:38PM (#34073774)
Exactly. We can now eat the best foods from all over the world, enjoy music, stories, art, all of it.

How very cynical and destructive does one have to be to police that? This movement is miserable.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by fleddr on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:36AM (#34068293)
The Dutch term for Indian Summer is "Old wives summer". Referring to old wives knitting clothes at that time of the year in preparation for winter, in correlation to another phenomenon in late summer: an explosion of spiders making cobwebs.

Ableist, sexist, biologal-essentialism, so many red flags. Wait, red is a cultural appropriation as its differently used in different cultures.

Anyway, Indian Summer referring to people being late is completely made-up.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by naravara on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:42PM (#34070275)
This list doesn't really seem all that concerned with historical or etymological facts to be honest. Take a look at the entry for brownbag, for example.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jjslocum3 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:15PM (#34083419)
Actually, the way I learned it in probably the '80s was that during the colonial era in the Northeast US, the indigenous peoples (Indians) would resume attacks against frontier colonists during late-autumn thaws (cold weather typically preempted organized war parties).
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by basch on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:45AM (#34062453)
User is a prime example of one I appreciate being on this list. Lists like this do a good job of making people think, and causing discussion. Some of that discussion might be posts like yours.

So to discuss user. User is quite often used in a slightly pejorative way, by power user, sys admin, programmer, support crowds. You can almost always replace it with the word person or someone. I take it more as a challenge, when I am about to say it, to try and find a better way to say what I was going to say. Most often than not, I can avoid the word user.

The same goes for lame. I just try not to use it, because I do use it, and I take it as a challenge to erase it from my vocabulary and use better words.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by cipheredStones on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:06AM (#34062601)
Well, first, their explanation for why "user" might be problematic has nothing to do with that pejorative use. It's

> While often associated with one who uses (software, systems, services), it can also negatively be associated with those who suffer from substance abuse issues or those who exploit others for their own gain.

which seems to bizarrely ignore the fact that common words have many different meanings that are distinguished by context.

Second, I would actually argue that the techie pejorative usage of "user" is a good example of the shortcomings of this "words to watch out for" approach. "User" has an extremely common neutral meaning, and also some people who design or operate systems use it contemptuously - without even really changing what it means, just with the implication that most users aren't very smart! The problem there is not with the word at all, it's the attitude with which it's used.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by basch on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:41PM (#34069325)
I know this crowd leans anti censorship and anti pc, but all I'm saying is that I appreciate being made to think by opposing viewpoints, hence I find value in lists like this.

I personally have made effort to not use the word user. I decided I don't like it. For me. I'm not lecturing other people not to use it.

In my experience, user has become a fill in word, when better words exist. And its pejorative use is, in my opinion, closer to the substance abuse meaning than it appears at first glance. Both basically describe someone who uses and takes advantage of something, without either mastery or self control.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Xelynega on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:55PM (#34072399)
Well yea, but this is an "opposing viewpoints that makes you think" in the same way asking an 8 year old their opinion on geopolitics is "an opposing viewpoints that makes you think".

I think your attitude around the word "user" is putting the cart before the horse, which is what the user above was getting at. The problem isn't that we use language that infantilizes users, the problem is that infantilizing users is how you get the largest market share. Google isn't going to shift their design philosophy away from "ease-of-use" because of language use, the language use would shift with the design philosophy.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by chrisandchris on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:27AM (#34062736)
By your logic, no computer can be a user of your service. Then you'll use consumer, but the user also consumes...
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by antonvs on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:18AM (#34062665)
How does it “conflate” them?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 3np on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:35AM (#34062777)
Some further examples that stood out to me as being too far-fetched, fashion, and/or excessive to be part of any reasonable "Elimination of harmful language initiative" (explanations verbatim qouted from TFA):

> abusive relationship (The relationship doesn't commit abuse. A person does, so it is important to make that fact clear.)

> rule of thumb (Although no written record exists today, this phrase is attributed to an old British law that allowed men to beat their wives with sticks no wider than their thumb.)

> trigger warning (The phrase can cause stress about what's to follow. Additionally, one can never know what may or may not trigger a particular person.)

> no can do (Originated from stereotypes that mocked non-native English speakers.)

> yellow team ("Yellow" is often used disparagingly against people of Asian descent.) Also not really a fan of forcing ethnical identity by insstitutionalizing "Black" or denying individuals to own their sexual identity as a choice ("")

> survivor (Using person-first language helps to not define people by just one of their experiences. If the person identifies with the term, then use it.)

> preferred pronouns (The word "preferred" suggests that non-binary gender identity is a choice and a preference.)

> spirit animal

> calling a spade a spade (Although the term has its origins in Greek literature, the subsequent negative connotations with the word "spade" means that the phrase should be used with caution or not at all.)

Some of these terms were even popularized by the same movement with similar motivations and reasoning in the past few years. How many of the "Consider using" suggestions will be considered "harmful language to be eradicated" in another few years? Feels like we're getting to a place where even a person who is honestly and carefully choosing their words to be non-offensive will be chastised because they missed the memo this year. While many of the entries make perfect sense and should be avoided for the sakes of inclusiveness, respect, and compassion, the conflation and strong wording makes this have the exact opposite effect of the communicated intention...

> Our "suggested alternatives" are in line with those used by peer institutions and within the technology community

Yeah, no, they did not do their homework on the tarball I think.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by cipheredStones on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:03AM (#34062971)
> Some of these terms were even popularized by the same movement with similar motivations and reasoning in the past few years. How many of the "Consider using" suggestions will be considered "harmful language to be eradicated" in another few years? Feels like we're getting to a place where even a person who is honestly and carefully choosing their words to be non-offensive will be chastised because they missed the memo this year.

Yeah, many of these feel extremely "fashionable" to me, in the sense that there was already a term intended to be thoughtful and compassionate, and the latest "preferred alternative" is driven by the latest academic framework to achieve popularity rather than any change in values or the preferences of the people being addressed.

In addition to "survivor", as you highlighted, I know and know of people who would certainly prefer "sex worker" to "prostitute" but would roll their eyes at "person who engages in sex work" - and point out that it actually carries more of an assumption of stigma, since nobody would say "person who engages in office work".

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by nicolas_t on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:17AM (#34063926)
In a much less extreme way, this sometimes reminds me of the cultural revolution where what was fully accepted as being non-bourgeois and non-capitalistic would then be banned the next year for being ignorant of class struggle. The reasoning seems to me to be the same, it's signalling of a subgroup's belief running amok where people end up competing as to who can be the more culturally sensitive person by denigrating terms that were previously seen as culturally sensitive.

At first, the initiative can easily be seen as good, after all who wouldn't want to give more consideration to disenfranchised people by making such a small effort to alter one's language but pushing this to extreme is more than a little problematic.

It's fascinating to see but it's very sad that an institution of higher learning is pushing this and ignoring logic, common sense and restraint.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jamincan on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:05AM (#34066835)
In another world, I feel that being thoughtful about how we use language in this way could be a good thing. I might say something, and my counterpart could point out the history of the word and why it might be hurtful to someone, and I would walk away more aware and be more considerate in the future.

Sadly, the reality seems to be that the bleeding edge of sensitive language is more often wielded combatively to try to discredit someone.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by physicles on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:42PM (#34069337)
What amazes me about this whole thing is how anyone can fail to see to the parallels with the cultural revolution, right on down to the ritualistic self-criticism you're required to perform when you sin against the orthodoxy.

Will it really take 10 years before everyone wakes up in a collective stupor and says, "well, that really went off the rails. How about we move on?"

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by MrYellowP on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:54AM (#34078227)
> Will it really take 10 years

That's not going to happen, because these fascist nutjobs are teaching our children to think the way they do.

Democracy and freedom will die in a thunderous applause.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sinity on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:51AM (#34081404)
> That's not going to happen, because these fascist nutjobs are teaching our children to think the way they do.

Eh, that'd cause children to be innoculated to these if anything.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kodah on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:32AM (#34063180)
> rule of thumb (Although no written record exists today, this phrase is attributed to an old British law that allowed men to beat their wives with sticks no wider than their thumb.)

This is a myth: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_thumb

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by chrisbaker98 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:19AM (#34064372)
Don't let the truth get in the way of a good story.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Nursie on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:47AM (#34063298)
> How many of the "Consider using" suggestions will be considered "harmful language to be eradicated" in another few years?

It's been interesting to watch The Guardian tie itself in knots over the acronym BAME (and later to some extent BIPOC), which was meant to be the new, inclusive, non-offensive to the minorities it sought to describe, term for non-white (particularly in the UK), which the newspaper was much in favour of but then seemed to decide was probably bad and might even be racist. And then keep using it all over the place.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/may/22/black-...

In the mean time, outside of that particular bubble, I think most people either looked on with bemusement or had no idea of the existence of the term anyway.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by AustinDev on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:39AM (#34064086)
What always made me giggle about BIPOC and it’s usage by the guardian is it made no sense. The white British are by definition indigenous to the island and more over everyone is indigenous to somewhere by the terms very definition.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hef19898 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:03AM (#34064269)
Curious question, what would be negative about spade? It's either a form of shovel or a card color? Fairly certain I am missing something here.

Edit: Because it is really fun, in a strange way, to go through the list: Isn't chief also used to address, e.g., a chief petty officer?

Edit 2: The list is just, well, strange. Ghetto for example, in the list it is mentioned as a non-white neighborhood. Historically, it was a jewish one. Let alone to speak about the Ghettos the Nazi's put in place. Karen, bad because it insults (?) people for their behaviour, this just stands out against all the other terms on list because of negative perception around what people are. Pretty lazy list, especially for an instituation like Stanford from which I would have expected better understanding of cultural and historic context...

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by chrisbaker98 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:21AM (#34064392)
"Spade" can mean "black person". Although I'm not sure whether it's considered offensive and I've never heard anyone use it to mean "black person" in real life... was it more common in the past?

Edit: I just remembered one place I've heard it: in the lyrics to the song "Everyone has AIDS" from the movie Team America. "The gays and the straights and the whites and the spades / everyone has AIDS!"

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:24AM (#34064419)
https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/spade

Meaning 3: "A black person"

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by tremon on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:24PM (#34074328)
This could have been good but this is executed poorly enough to be completely counterproductive

I'm curious, how could this ever have been good? Haven't we read enough books about wrongthink, doublespeak and thought crime to know where this will inevitably lead?

This is supposed to be a university, for crying out loud, an institution intended to nurture higher-level thinking. Not to coddle immature minds.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 3np on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:45PM (#34074582)
Changing the title to "guidelines for inclusive language on official Stanford communication" or similar would be a good start. You know, to make it less harmful language itself.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ancapsfascists on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:41AM (#34062823)
I don't read it as conflating, they just say these are all harmful, not that they are equally harmful. A hangnail is harmful and a car crash is harmful, I try to avoid both. I'm less put out by a hangnail and I go to great lengths to avoid a car crash.

Any list like this should be read as: "you are causing harm somewhere between a paper cut and a gunshot wound, you may not realize it. Be advised you might be causing that harm, in case knowing that would cause you to take a different course of action"

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by handoflixue on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:28AM (#34063145)
Surely it matters the extent of the harm, though? If I'm doing home wiring, it is not at all helpful to know "this could result in a slight tingle or kill you and burn your house down."

Ambiguity means I can wave off your complaints because clearly what you're complaining about is a hangnail. Ambiguity means I can punish you brutally, because how dare you not take my car crash seriously.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by vineyardmike on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:54AM (#34063354)
Stairs are really hard for people in a wheelchair, signage is really hard for someone blind, and fire alarms are really hard for someone deaf. Missing any of those ADA adaptions is more harmful to one group than another.

Harm can vary based on the person, so doing something "harmful" is person dependent. The goal is to recognize the harmful history of language when choosing words, because, thankfully all spoken words are newly spoken, so you can pick fresh each time.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by lolinder on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:17AM (#34067022)
In a huge portion of these cases the only harmful history is in the imagination of the author. "Tarball"? "Red team"? "Submit"? "White paper"?

All of these have very clear etymologies that don't have any offensive history whatsoever. The idea that we should avoid any term that uses the words "white", "black", "red", or "yellow" on the grounds that they once were used in some contexts to referred to people is absurd.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by chrsjxn on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:10AM (#34063017)
If you were trying to help people be more inclusive with their language, categorizing them like this seems counter to your goals

Your own list seems to say that exclusionary language about someone's medical condition (lame) is more acceptable than other exclusionary language, because that stigma has a different history? Or because that language is more common?

Those words can still do real harm to real people, even if they're lower down in your ranking of these words

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kortilla on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:13AM (#34063046)
Yes, the author is being a real tarball about the whole thing by compressing these things all together.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by donkeyd on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:59AM (#34063837)
> Those words can still do real harm to real people

Pretty much anything you can say that has any form of content can do harm to someone. If we want to never ever accidentally hurt someone's feelings, we need to stop talking about:

- Having kids. It's quite painful to those who can't.

- Parents. It's painful to those who don't have any, or have abusive ones.

- War. It's painful to veterans or people who fled war.

- Anything medical. It might hurt someone who's dealing with a medical issue in one way or another.

- Pets. It might be a sensitive subject to someone who just lost a pet.

- Stop asking people how they're doing. It's a sensitive subject to people dealing with burn-out or depression.

Where do we draw the line?

I've been personally affected, many times, by multiple things in my examples above, so please don't say I'm exaggerating with those examples. However, I really don't want to live in a world where we need to watch every word because it might make someone feel bad.

If anything, this type of thinking might even affect people negatively, because it pushes the idea that feelings should be repressed, in stead of dealt with.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jamincan on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:01AM (#34067728)
This is why we almost universally resort to talking about the weather when speaking with relative strangers. It's hard to be offended by overcast weather.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by donkeyd on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:29AM (#34068185)
I can see a future where we can't do that anymore either, because climate change will displace many people and weather will also become a topic that might hurt some people's feelings.

While typing this, I realized we're there already. During summer, when talking about the temperature, people already feel the need to add their opinion about climate change to the discussion, which then becomes political.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:05PM (#34068773)
> While typing this, I realized we're there already.

We definitely are there already. I can't comfortably talk about weather anymore, because after either side mentions anything interesting - such as it being surprisingly cold, or hot, or snowy, or windy - I feel tempted to say something about climate change. Being risk averse, I stop myself and say nothing, but this creates an awkward pause and ends the conversation.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by goatlover on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:49AM (#34068504)
What does "real harm" even mean in this context? Someone will be offended? Their feelings will be hurt? Is that something we need to avoid at all cost in society?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by alchemst on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:02AM (#34092508)
And isn't there in implicit insult in that? That an entire group is so fragile, that seeing a mere word on paper, in a completely different context, will somehow reduce them to emotional rubble?

Aren't many of these making things worse, e.g. "calling a spade a spade" or "blackbox" by implying that any distant possible connection to 'black' makes something so horrible that its use must be suppressed? What does that imply about that color?

These lists are actively harmful, not to mention wasteful, but I guess they are good at creating demand for DEI officers and giving them work to do.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by veltas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:59AM (#34063392)
It's my opinion that the best policy is no policy. If you make rules people will break them. And when the rules are so strict it means nobody bothers. If the rules aren't strict some will push it as far as they can. Everything has context. But in general I think people are far too easily offended today, and considering offense a valid issue to fight on has turned out to be a real rabbit hole. Unfortunately, there's no way an institution is going to push back; instead we get this cowardly policy that always caters to the most neurotic minority of social policers (and is probably partly written by said policers). This is policy by mob, and lowest common denominator decision making.

This is the reason why individuals should defend others, even if they disagree with them or think what they said was unnecessary or even malicious. Because there isn't enough time in the day to worry about language this much, and because it's Orwellian... without the literal thought police.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by wazoox on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:40AM (#34067394)
> It's my opinion that the best policy is no policy. If you make rules people will break them.

That's precisely the point of such obscure, arbitrary ruleset. Keep everyone obediently in line. Keep everyone on the edge, afraid of "failing" and being subjected to a Maoist style trial that they can't win. That's a tool of power and oppression, under the smart disguise of forbidding relationships of power and oppression.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Beltalowda on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:13PM (#34076541)
> I think people are far too easily offended today

One has to wonder who was ever offended by the usage of the term "whitespace". Yes, that is actually on the list under "Institutionalized Racism" because it "assigns value connotations based on color (white = good), an act which is subconsciously racialized."

I am skeptical of the entire "subconsciously racialized" idea in the first place; to the best of my knowledge there is no evidence for it. But even if we accept it for the sake of the argument, does "whitespace" assign any value connotation at all? [Insert tabs vs. spaces joke here]

I don't really have a problem with with a policy on this as such, but the issue tends to be that once you start drafting a policy you will get a committee or the like and they will search for words that that could possible maybe perhaps be considered problematic by someone, somewhere, sometimes. That's kind of the reverse of how it should work: policy should reflect real concrete problems that were encountered. "I'm black and find the usage of 'slave' problematic" is, I think, more than reasonable, and a concrete situation. But grepping the dictionary for (white|black) ... a bit less so.

Once you start looking for something you will find it. This is why studies are double blind etc.

I have a lot of issues with this list. Does "more than one way to skin a cat" really "normalize violence against animals"? Cruelty against animals – especially pets – seems one of the very few topics where everyone from the most hard-core "Stalin did nothing wrong" communist to the most hardcore "Hitler did nothing wrong" neo-Nazi can find common ground. Does a phrase like that change it? I don't see how it does. I can go on and on, but clearly this is a "dictionary grep" list and not a "let's solve concrete problems" list.

So, are people "far too easily offended today"? I'm not so sure if they are.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sinity on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:39AM (#34080549)
> "I'm black and find the usage of 'slave' problematic" is, I think, more than reasonable, and a concrete situation.

I don't think so. If it is, then so is being offended about 'kill' command.

Why is using a concept as a metaphor bad? Also, I really don't like the implication that slavery is somehow racialized. The internet is global; it seems that Americans don't even acknowledge it.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Beltalowda on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:10AM (#34082526)
If someone was trying to be cute and name some anti-virus quarantine code "Auschwitz" then I'd object.

Of course there are limits to what is or isn't reasonable, as I mentioned in my previous post, but I can see how people might find "master/slave" inappropriate, like I would consider "Auschwitz" inappropriate.

At the end of the day, I don't really mind adjusting a few terms here or there if people really object to it, even if I don't fully understand it, or even agree with it, just as a matter of being nice to people. I'm neither Black nor American, so who am I to judge what they can or can't find offensive? The problem with lists like this is that I don't think anyone genuinely objects to half of the items on it, if not more.

> Also, I really don't like the implication that slavery is somehow racialized. The internet is global; it seems that Americans don't even acknowledge it.

Considering the history of the country it's not really a huge surprise. Also worth remembering it's the 3rd largest country on the planet, and the largest Western country by quite a substantial margin (Germany comes second with ~85M, vs the US ~330M).

And sure, I've been annoyed by American self-centred attitudes as well; not everything is about the US, but we also can't just always dismiss it either.

It's also not an uniquely American issue, in my own country in Europe there have been similar discussions as well.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sinity on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:33AM (#34080492)
> Unfortunately, there's no way an institution is going to push back

If everyone pushed back harder, perhaps things would be different.

From what I remember, HN reacted mostly positively to someone's speculation that 'master' branch or 'blacklist' might offend black people (they weren't black themselves). Tons of comments arguing that changing it is not an issue, so we should do it.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by cm2187 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:51AM (#34063787)
We should also ban the word logic which is insensitive to woke humanities student who are incapable of.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Aeolun on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:55AM (#34068598)
Incapable of what?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:14PM (#34074892)
This is one of the most amusing joke formats I have seen on this website.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by malandrew on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:14AM (#34077604)
Thinking, which is a word we should also ban because it is a list. Instead you should use the word “feel”

Unless of course that is ableist against us autists.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by alchemst on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:41AM (#34092383)
It is, but don't worry, they don't care about that group.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mananaysiempre on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:19AM (#34064375)
> Outdated, now-offensive terms like "hermaphrodite"

Is there anything outdated if you talk about e.g. a hermaphroditic tree? I thought this was still the standard term in biology for species which practice sexual reproduction and normally or frequently have individuals with both kinds of reproductive organs, either simultaneously or alternately.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by Nasrudith on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:08AM (#34078744)
Intersex is the current preferred term for non-binary biological sex but it is one meant for people.

Although if you had say, a cat with ambiguous genitalia it wouldn't be offense to reference them as intersex.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by rmak on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:45AM (#34064592)
Totally ok to use "incel" but not Karen.

Notice how they are fine with using words like "gunman", "conman" but not the positive masculine words like man-made, mankind ...

Also no issues with "motherboard" or "mother nature".

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kennend3 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:44AM (#34065750)
Notice it is also missing many other "offensive" terms like :

"Settler" - It actually uses this word a lot in its definitions as to why words are bad, but "Settler" itself is an offensive term used by First Nations against "whites".

"White privilege" is also missing? Again another harmful word thrown around which many consider offensive. Words which include "Everyone" are generally not good because within "white people" there is a wide range of thoughts/beliefs. I'm sure that very poor white people don't feel they have "white privilege"?

When asked to define "white privilege" the SJW's fail miserably.

At the end of the day, given Stanford is in the US and has "first amendment rights" this list itself is utter nonsense.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by GendingMachine on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:08PM (#34075390)
This is an inane and deliberately obtuse response to this policy.

There is a vast difference between terms used by marginalised groups to refer to dominant ones, and terms used by dominant groups to refer to marginalised ones.

Whether or not this policy itself is effective or well-considered, the broader mission to identify ways in which historic injustice is ingrained and perpetuated through our language and try to amend it is a noble one.

There are many words throughout history that have been common place but carried so much cultural baggage that they became damaging and were thus abandoned - most terms we now consider slurs were once defended with arguments of similar merits to your own.

The process of improving our language is never going to be an easy one, no doubt many found it challenging to fully excise many of our abandoned terms from their vocabulary, but it's been done before, and will likely be done indefinitely into the future unless we ever reach a point of such equality that our language can no longer cause harm.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by joshlemer on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:21PM (#34076259)
Sure there's a difference, but not for the purpose of this discussion. The term 'settler' is basically a slur used to marginalize people who pass as white in North America. So it should receive the same treatment as these other offensive terms.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by MrYellowP on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:50AM (#34078204)
> The process of improving our language

Political Correctness is not improving language, it's forcing people to be afraid of what they're saying, thus thinking.

> that our language can no longer cause harm.

Language does not cause harm. Emotionally immature people do.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by horns4lyfe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:18AM (#34079679)
The policy itself is inane and deliberately obtuse, why would the response be any different?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by goatlover on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:11AM (#34090700)
What you've described is essentially Newspeak. I won't be part of any effort to purge language, and I don't believe that doing so will socially engineer a better society, nor do I believe in such attempts to social engineer. I also don't believe words are harmful unless they're used in a harmful manner, and a majority of the words on Stanford's list not used in such a manner, being just part of every day language.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by necovek on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:13PM (#34075882)
Well, I am not sure they understand those words the same way I do: eg. a "man-made lake" should be a "lake made by hand"? ;)
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sinity on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:11AM (#34080930)
Suggesting that women are less likely to want to be plumbers? (Nothing)

Suggesting that women are less likely to want to be programmers? Get fired, and yelled at by the media.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jojobas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:48AM (#34064609)
All these categories have something in common - their use can be seen as rude in a particular setting, the rest is bullshit. You can be rude using the most refined vocabulary.

You won't exterminate rudeness by banning a set of words, nor should you be trying to.

By giving people an option to be rude you can see people that choose not to. And then I'll rather choose a rude vulgar teacher who knows his stuff than a milquetoast who doesn't.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by xkcd1963 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:30AM (#34068204)
Yes, it is a common misconception nowadays that there is a causal link between language and society. For example, in languages such as Spanish and German, feminists are seeking to introduce gender-neutral words in an attempt to facilitate equality. However, this is not the correct way around – language is shaped by society, with gender roles and stereotypes influencing the language rather than the other way round. Therefore, making changes to language is not only ineffective but rather counterproductive.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by himinlomax on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:19AM (#34065450)
> - Touchy metaphorical language like "slave replica"

> "submit" ("Depending on the context, the term can imply allowing others to have power over you.")

In both those cases, the problem is when it applies to a person, because enslaving someone or having someone submit by force is obviously bad, but there's equally no problem with enslaving a computer or submitting a form, even if you have to force it into a jammed letterbox.

The obvious next step is banning cut, kill, brand or maim, because that's what bad people did to innocent victims; never mind that you can cut paper, kill viruses, brand a product or describe an industrial accident.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by gpderetta on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:27PM (#34071111)
Kill considered harmful. Kill -9 doubly so.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by curiousllama on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:00AM (#34065957)
It's also intresting that some of these terms were, initially at least, meant to be anti-racist.

"Survivor" is on the list (as in, survivor of SA). So is "Karen" (which, IIRC, was popularized through videos of white people harassing black folks minding their own business).

I can't imagine this list should be used as anything more than an MLA style-guide type list of "these are outdated terms for formal writing"

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by fnordpiglet on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:43AM (#34066534)
Surely “American” is the most absurd. Literally no one is offended that people in the United States of America are referred to as American, even if there are 42 other countries in the Americas. The technical fact is it’s correct - anyone in the americas could be called an American correctly. But only one has “America” in the country name. But by including this it sparks a patriotic and nationalist response in most Americans and makes the whole “wokeism is against us” meme have teeth. It’s the political football that speaks to many people, especially immigrants who are proud to be called an American and not merely a U.S. citizen - which frankly has more nativist connotations and is used to separate natural born citizens from naturalized.

They also focus on age being the problem with “grey beard” rather than the implication that all senior engineers are men. I’ve always been turned off by the term not because it singles out age as a proxy for experience, because they’re literally proxies for each other. You don’t have 30 years of experience without aging 20 years. But not everyone with 30 years of experience can grow a beard or has a penis. Given the gender issues in technology, which are so obvious in the statistics over time, I genuinely think language like this calcifies the gender divide.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by diehunde on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:06AM (#34066842)
You are wrong. I'm from South America, and the "American" thing is an issue for many people. In Spanish, we don't even call Americans "Americanos" but "Estado Unidenses". Many people joke when Americans say they are Americans by answering, "yeah, me too." I couldn't care less especially because I know the difference between America and "The Americas" but many people don't
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by xkcd1963 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:21AM (#34068040)
If you feel offended by referring to the two landmasses as "America", then rest assured there is no malice intended. Northern and Southern America are connected landmasses .. why not simply use the term "America" to refer to both areas? Remember, just because someone are not "sophisticated" enough to come to the conclusion that Americans can also be South Americans does not mean they are seeking to offend you.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jamincan on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:04PM (#34069694)
And just to show that nothing is straightforward, if you were to refer to a Canadian as an American, they will definitely make a point to correct you.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by whb07 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:35PM (#34076347)
This isn’t an issue for anyone but for people like yourself.

Like you said there are a couple words used for Americans in Spanish:

Gringo, Americano, Estadounidense.

That set of words does not intersect with any words used to describe anyone from South America. This applies to slang or official sources.

Please show me an example where a Paisa from Colombia or Argentino would like to be referenced as “American”.

In fact, especially with the World Cup win, any warm blooded Argentinian would fight if called “American”.

Plus it’d be an easy fight as someone who’s pushing for “words are violence” has clearly never experienced real violence.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by diehunde on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:35PM (#34076698)
If by "people like me" you mean people from South America then yes that's what I said. By the way I said I personally don't care. I was just correcting OP when he said that "literally no one is offended" when I know for a fact many are. Also I never said they wanted to be called Americans. And no idea what your point is with your violence blabber.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by whb07 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:23AM (#34081064)
Lol “violence blabber”. Call a spade a spade.

I too am from South America, never have I seen anyone down there assume they are “American”.

This is just a ban list, or better yet a black list to bring a 1984 dystopia.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jean_tta on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:03AM (#34078705)
If your point is that it offends "no one", except "people like [the other commenter]", i.e. people that are offended, then I guess this would apply to any word about any group.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by malandrew on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:07AM (#34077565)
I’m also from South America and my observation is that it’s not an issue for almost all people. The only people that I’ve ever seen make it an “issue” do so to try and be pompous to some gringo. They don’t really care. It’s meaningless flexing.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by mananaysiempre on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:42PM (#34069336)
I wouldn’t be so sure. I (a European) have occasionally used “American” in that sense when speaking English in a group of foreign students in Europe that included one from Latin America, and he somewhat pointedly substituted “from the States” etc. in his replies. He never went as far as correcting me, and I never explicitly asked if that phrasing annoyed him, but it seemed like it did.

Of course, there’s a substantial difference between annoying and offending, but it seems like there are, in fact, reasonable people who object to that usage.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by commandlinefan on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:53PM (#34069521)
> Literally no one is offended that people in the United States of America are referred to as American

Actually, no - my Mexican wife is genuinely offended when I refer to US citizens as Americans, or when I refer to the United States as America.

So I do it as often as I can.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by runarberg on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:37PM (#34071273)
In addition to my sibling posts, I do wonder about “Americans” who are not from the North American continent, e.g. people that live in Hawaii, American Samoa, Guam etc. or even Puerto Rico to an extent (or especially Puerto Rico since “Americano” in Spanish usually means from the two continents and the Caribbean).

This demonym is really unfortunate.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by MrYellowP on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:52AM (#34078219)
I've had Canadians thank me for always specifically calling USAmericans "USAmericans", instead of just "Americans", because they didn't want to be put into the same bucket.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by wazoox on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:34AM (#34067294)
> Outdated, now-offensive terms like "hermaphrodite"

As far as I know, it describes a real state of things; for instance snails are hermaphrodite, and I don't think anyone ought to feel insulted by this banal fact.

The dumbest series of the list are those words containing "white" or "black" (from "blackballed" and "black hat" to "white-space") which supposedly now carry racial undertones (hint: they don't, and never did).

It looks almost like a plot by rich, progressive people to build a culture war with rich, right-wing people to prevent any serious debate on environmental collapse, class exploitation, plutocracy, etc. You could nearly believe that all those supposedly warring high-ranking people play a clever game together to actually keep the power structure as is, and make minuscule problems obfuscate real ones. Almost.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by lo_zamoyski on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:49AM (#34068499)
> - Well-known slurs like "Jewed"

Homophones are next. "Hey Jude".

> - Touchy metaphorical language like "slave replica"

Slave comes from "slav"[0]. So speaking of "slaves" or "slavery" is racist.

[0] https://www.etymonline.com/word/slave#etymonline_v_23653

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by lolinder on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:16PM (#34069856)
Homophones aren't even next, they're already in the list. They recommend against "tarball" on the grounds that it might sound like "tarbaby" which is apparently a racial slur (I'm only familiar with the Brer Rabbit story).
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by rufus_foreman on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:30PM (#34075996)
>> Homophones are next. "Hey Jude".

Rob : You're a total paranoid.

Alvy Singer : Well, how am I a para-? I pick up on those kind of things. You know, I was having lunch with some guys from NBC, so I said, uh, "Did you eat yet or what?" and Tom Christie said, "No, didjew?" Not, "did you", "didjew eat?" Jew? No, not "did you eat", but "Jew eat"? Jew. You get it? Jew eat?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by matt-attack on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:15PM (#34068910)
> "This term is used to ridicule or demean a certain group of people based on their behaviors."

Isn’t that precisely when it’s ok to ridicule someone? Not based on properties they cannot change (race, height, sex, etc) but indeed based on behavior they choose to engage in (religion, politics, social behavior, life choices, etc.).

If ridiculing people for their behavior is now off limits then what the hell is left? Do we just talk about the weather?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by aussieshibe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:19AM (#34078394)
Reading this comment, all I can picture is a Sims character with a full red Social bar and only three interaction bubbles:

Ridicule (trait), Ridicule (behaviour), Discuss Weather

Firby nurbs!

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by diebeforei485 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:16PM (#34070917)
There is no one-word replacement for something being "grandfathered". It's important to consider practicalities here.

Moving away from "slave" was reasonable (Buildbot got rid of it many years ago!), but led us down a very slippery slope.

I'll stick my head out and say "master" is fine actually.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dahfizz on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:40PM (#34071339)
> There is no one-word replacement for something being "grandfathered". It's important to consider practicalities here.

In fact, much of this list replaces a single-word term with a longer phrase.

"Bob survived the accident but is now a paraplegic" becomes

"Bob is a person who was impacted by an accident, and he is now a person with a spinal cord injury".

Less precise and much wordier.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sinity on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:38AM (#34081250)
> Moving away from "slave" was reasonable

It wasn't, because it didn't make any sense. Using 'slave' as a metaphor doesn't imply slavery is good.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by jiggawatts on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:31PM (#34072079)
One school district I worked for a long time ago used to label backup tapes with color codes. This is a bad idea in general, but the real issue was the official complaints:

Lemon — suggests that the system is of poor quality, or substandard.

Black — racist.

Brown — also racist.

Pink — too girlie for straight male staff.

And so on.

Eventually they had to change the system because this went all the way up to the minister of education.

”They’re just colors of the rainbow Karen! No, not the gay one!”

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by aussieshibe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:30AM (#34078470)
I've been told I wasn't allowed to color code anything in a UI I worked on because "someone might be living with color vision deficiency".

Not that we have to also provide an alternative for people who can't use the color coding, but we can't use color coding at all.

The world is full of people with good intentions and bad ideas.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sinity on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:16AM (#34080979)
> I've been told I wasn't allowed to color code anything in a UI I worked on because "someone might be living with color vision deficiency".

Refuse to do GUI at all - surely terminal is better for blind people.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dTal on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:37AM (#34082915)
Refuse to write the program entirely. It's ableist against people too unintelligent to use computers.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 908B64B197 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:01PM (#34073313)
I can't help but to think this is intentional. It's a thinly veiled attempt at shifting the Overton Window [0].

Nobody would use "Tranny" or "Jewed" in professional conversation. It's a non-issue. But a non-controversial term like "Tribal Knowledge"?

It really reminds me of the main vs master default branch controversy where some activists really pushed a racial connotation on a term which had none [1] [2]. Of course, someone would have to be technical to be able to find the source while whining on social media is available to anyone!

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window

[1] https://twitter.com/xpasky/status/1272280760280637441

[2] https://repo.or.cz/cogito.git/commit/3c4347c8b64fb516bc097ab...

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ModernMech on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:40PM (#34073791)
> some activists really pushed a racial connotation on a term which had none

This isn’t quite right. The term “master recording” itself refers to the master/slave dichotomy and has been used in the music industry with the explicit knowledge of that. Master recordings have also been used by the music industry as tools to assert control over artists. This practice was recently exposed in popular culture by Pharrell Williams.

If “master branch” is to derive from “master recording”, it carries the same racial baggage.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:41PM (#34075147)
> it carries the same racial baggage.

Which race? You mean white people, right?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 908B64B197 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:29PM (#34083620)
> The term "master recording" itself refers to the master/slave dichotomy and has been used in the music industry with the explicit knowledge of that.

It doesn't. Audio or video mastering means to create a reference recording that's then down sampled and used as a reference when manufacturing records [0]. It has nothing to do with race. "Remastering" something means to re-release it with a higher audio quality (typically in a different medium) by using the uncompressed source material (the master) and newer sound processing technologies. It's the reason you can watch old movies in HD on Netflix.

The idea here is that the "master" would be what would be sent to manufacturing when producing a release. It's also why many SaaS use "master" to mean the exact version of the software that's in production, because it's assumed to be the one sent for distribution. It has nothing to do with race or the idea of owning human beings.

> Master recordings have also been used by the music industry as tools to assert control over artists. This practice was recently exposed in popular culture by Pharrell Williams.

There's nothing to expose. When signing up with a producer or recording label, it's common practice to exchange a portion of the rights to the master produced in exchange for (advance) payment and promotion from the label. It's just like founders exchanging equity during fundraising. I'm surprised the practice is unknown or even controversial on a board centered around VC and startups. Black owned record labels [1][2] use the exact same deals when signing up artists.

Now, Pharrell Williams is notorious on his own. Does he need promotion from a label or an advance check for his music? Probably not. That's why he was able to re-negotiate his contracts to keep ownership of his masters. Same way a bootstrapped founder won't sell part of his equity for funding. It has nothing to do with race (but maybe Pharrell, having a large audience, tried making it about race to get leverage when negotiating...).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastering_(audio)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_Row_Records

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roc-A-Fella_Records

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ModernMech on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:25PM (#34084393)
> It doesn't.

That's now what I've found in my research, which makes very explicit references to a master/slave dichotomy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26497027

If what you say is true, that master recording has no relationship to a master/slave dichotomy, then why is there such a thing as a slave reel? Why do industry insiders refer to the dichotomy with a wink and nudge, as if it's a pun ("get it")? They explicitly talk about the master as representing "control" and not "quality".

> There's nothing to expose.

I said expose to popular culture. Many people did not know about this practice, and find it objectionable.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 908B64B197 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:10PM (#34085762)
You seem to enjoy quoting yourself.

>They explicitly talk about the master as representing "control" and not "quality".

You seem to misunderstand there's a technical term (a recording master, the highest quality and original recording made in a studio) and a legal term (owning the rights to the master) in which said performance can be sold.

>Many people did not know about this practice, and find it objectionable.

I guess they object to owning stocks and shares too?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ModernMech on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:18PM (#34085860)
I’m not quoting myself I’m pointing you to links, which is exactly what you did for me. I just didn’t want to repaste them here.

> You seem to misunderstand

Had you read the link I provided, you’d have seen I quote a source that says exactly what you’re saying. So no, I am aware there are two usages. However, both refer to the master/slave dichotomy in the recording industry:

> there's a technical term (a recording master, the highest quality and original recording made in a studio)

Right, and this is the one from which “slave reels” are made. So the “master/slave” dichotomy exists there. If the name we’re about quality they wouldn’t call the derivatives “slaves”.

> a legal term (owning the rights to the master) in which said performance can be sold.

Which is also part of a master/slave dichotomy because it is about control. The book I link to explicitly refers to the master/slave dichotomy in that particular context.

> I guess they object to owning stocks and shares too?

They are against the exploitive aspects surrounding the practice. I’m not sure how owning stocks and shares could be considered exploitation.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by 908B64B197 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:45PM (#34086175)
> If the name we’re about quality they wouldn’t call the derivatives “slaves”.

I've never heard the term "slave reels" and git doesn't have the concept nor the term slave anywhere in the codebase afaik.

The term is very much about quality; in the analog days it was way harder and sometimes even impossible to make a perfect copy. Hence the importance of the master being the highest quality (and often recorded on a different, much more expensive medium).

> They are against the exploitive aspects surrounding the practice. I’m not sure how owning stocks and shares could be considered exploitation.

As explained, it's the same model as raising funds for a startup. The record label claims a percentage, or the whole master in exchange for advance payment and promotion. This isn't a race thing.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ModernMech on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:19PM (#34087686)
> I've never heard the term "slave reels"

Well now you have, and I've shown you plenty of evidence that the term has been used even in "the analog days". You may keep insisting that the term is very much about quality, but the sources I've linked suggest the opposite. If you can provide some sources aside from the wiki on "Mastering (audio)" I'm willing to look at them and integrate them into my perspective. Otherwise it's your insistence against the references I've already found.

> and git doesn't have the concept nor the term slave anywhere in the codebase afaik.

That's the whole point of this thread. The original contention was that a "master" branch is a reference to a master/slave dichotomy. The retort is that "no, it actually derives from the term "master recording" in the audio industry, which has nothing to do with a master/slave dichotomy." I've show references that in fact, the "master" in "master recording" is an explicit reference to the master/slave dichotomy.

> As explained, it's the same model as raising funds for a startup.

VC funding is also a pretty dubious imo. But that's neither here nor there.

> This isn't a race thing.

I hear you saying that, but I've also heard others who've shown me evidence that it is. We'll have to agree to disagree. I'm willing to split the difference and accept it can be a little of both, but you can't hide from the term "slave reels". Even if you want to say it's very much about quality, it's clear there is a race component, and maybe you can admit that too? Either way I'll still be defaulting my repos to "main" and teaching my students that way.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by yakshaving_jgt on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:44AM (#34091181)
You conveniently ignored my question.

When you say "it's clear there is a race component", which race are you referring to?

I am white, and my white great-grandfather died as a slave in a concentration camp at the hands of white Nazi masters as a consequence of white-on-white ethnic persecution.

So do I understand correctly that when you say "it's clear there is a race component", you are referring to white people?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by ModernMech on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:35AM (#34093633)
I ignored your comment because it didn't make sense to me. And since I'm flagged in this thread for having a contrary opinion to the groupthink in this thread, I'm rate limited to reply. I can only reply to like 3 posts before HN tells me to take a break, so I only responded to comments that made sense.

I'm sorry for your grandfather, mine died as well at the hands of Nazis.

By "race component" I'm making reference to racial relations in America, which to a large extent, revolve around the fallout from hundreds of years of chattel slavery of Black people. This country was built on the backs of black slaves, and that still has repercussions in society today. This conflict has deep roots, and many aspects of American life that may seem benign have a context in that history. If you don't know the history then you may not feel one way or another about it. If you do know the history, then it colors things differently (depending on who you are).

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by HelloNurse on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:07AM (#34078736)
I noticed major failures to put language in context. For example, "whitespace" isn't racist: there are fundamental physical reasons for paper, vellum, papyrus etc. to be approximately white, and there's no reason to think it refers to people.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dTal on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:44AM (#34082999)
If so many words assign connotations to "white" and "black", indicating a deeply embedded metaphor, perhaps the solution is simply to stop using such loaded and inaccurate word to refer to skin color? They are trying to boil the ocean to preserve a silly convention that was probably racist to begin with.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by dumpsterdiver on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:38AM (#34078946)
Yeah, once you get to "user" and "submit" it starts to appear as if these folks take offense to those words ever being defined in the first place.

"John isn't addicted to crack cocaine, and in fact I find the word 'addicted' to be offensive. He's just really dedicated to crack cocaine. He's an unsung hero, really."

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by horns4lyfe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:33AM (#34079837)
It’s make-work. Stanford has nearly as many administrators as students, and they have to justify their paychecks somehow. This is just a resume padding exercise for some unscrupulous ladder climber.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sinity on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:27AM (#34080427)
> Touchy metaphorical language like "slave replica"

Why is that touchy? It doesn't make any value judgements about slavery. It's just referencing the concept. If referencing the concept is bad, then I guess schools shouldn't teach it anymore? Let's all pretend there never was any slavery!

I wonder when someone will find a problem with 'kill' command.