We're just amused that the dude thinks he is a genius, but is unable to think a step or two ahead.
The solution it seems to me is in the name : moderation.
Instead of unfiltered thoughts, we moderate so we can more clearly communicate. In that sense the word censorship loses all meaning : because meaning should be conveyed carefully, especially when topics are sensitive. And so often online people aren’t sensitive at all, for many reasons that seem evident.
Source : moderated several chatrooms for many years.
https://www.reddit.com/r/TalesFromYourServer/comments/hsiisw...
That was the case before acquisition. Just the lowest common denominator biased towards whatever political views twitter mods held
How unfortunate that we're left to imagine this, rather than having the new ownership articulate a content moderation policy that reflects their curation decisions.
For example, I had set my region to Germany because Twitter would automatically block more content for German users (due to Nazi content being illegal in Germany).
So, is your imaginary conclusion that Elon has changed Twitter's policy from: "speech is restricted for users in a locale according to the local laws" to "speech is restricted platform wide according based on the most restrictive laws that exist in the world"?
It would seem very anti-free speech to me if this new system allows China to determine which content is available on Twitter, or we impose the UK's onerous libel laws on all American users.
The picture Ye posted is not illegal in the United States and so therefore it appears he no longer supports free speech.
Instead his "free speech absolutism" is a brand, it's there to signal what kind of person he is, it's not a set of principles and therefore cannot stand up to scrutiny.
When Trump said on Jan 6th he wants his supporters to "fight" to "stop the steal" a lot of people took that as endorsing violence to storm the capitol. I think that's less clear-cut than Nazi endorsement, but other people disagree.
Main thing I care about is "covid misinformation" is no longer banned. So Twitter won't ban an epidemiologist who posts a clinical study saying mRNA vaccines lower sperm counts anymore. https://legalinsurrection.com/2022/06/im-an-md-suspended-by-... Bans like that were just absurd.
My understanding is that Twitter did not specify what exactly (i.e. which set of tweets) Kanye is banned for.
Someone was proposing incitement to violence has a threahold etc. This to me is clearly incitement to violence.
Some have claimed he didn't know what "death con" (defcon) means to which I say what could he have possibly meant. It's <something negative> on Jewish People.
Personally, I think he probably meant something else that very likely could have been closer to an incitement of violence, but he doesn't have the vocabulary and we can't convict someone for what you think might be in their head.
Possibly due to very limited imagination?
The technical definition of a word is not as important as the real world usage of the word.
And pretty sure most people would consider using Defcon in that way to be hostile.
but i was thinking, does this tweet "I’m a bit sleepy tonight but when I wake up I’m going death con 3 On JEWISH PEOPLE," incite violence? I don't think it does.
Now if he said "when i wake up i want to read on the news how all of you went death con 3 on JEWISH PEOPLE" that would be inciting violence to me. btw, i'm thankful Taylor Swift is mostly benign, her fans are fanatical to the point of acting like a brain washed cult. Anything she tells them to do is done.
Can't understand how you can be racing to explain and apologize that.
Nailed it
When you combine that with him using "death con" instead of "defcon" and the tenor of his comments both before and since (posting a swastika?) it is a little hard to imagine he meant he was preparing to defend himself from an attack rather than going on attack. "I'm a little sleepy, but after I wake up I'm going to prepare for an attach By JEWISH PEOPLE." Is this seriously what you think he was saying?
The "going deathcon one on the Jews", which led to the pre-Musk ban, is arguably a more explict violent threat than the symbol.
wikipedia.org/wiki/Swastika
So when kayne used it, of course he referred to the Nazi symbol and just wanted attention and strongly hint at his antisemitism.
But other people can mean something very different:
"In several major Indo-European religions, the swastika symbolises lightning bolts, representing the thunder god and the king of the gods, such as Indra in Vedic Hinduism, Zeus in the ancient Greek religion, Jupiter in the ancient Roman religion, and Thor in the ancient Germanic religion."
Then why make this generalised statement?
" I can't see what other meaning today it could have?"
Because I know people who are into germanic livestyle and they are NOT nazis, but they would like to use that old symbol freely. So that is one counterexample. There are people today who use the swastika who explicitley do not refer to the nazis.
But like I said, when people like kayne use the swastika, their meaning is very clear and different.
If an individual book owner decides to have a backyard barbecue of all their pro-Nazi propaganda or an individual theater owner doesn't feel comfortable running Jojo Rabbit, that's up to them.
Most people would interpret the phrase "I’m a bit sleepy tonight but when I wake up I’m going (def) con 3 On JEWISH PEOPLE" to mean preparing to go to war or enter into conflict against, not preparing to defend against an attack from, jewish people.
Also being a republican (politican) is a choice and therefore valid to be a target of hatred. People aren't born Republican , however bring Jewish is considered both an ethnic group and religion. This is the key to why it's acceptable to attack a political group verus an ethnic group.
Jews have different views, they don't act as one group, they don't have a hierarchy like republicans, nor don't put out group statements.
Afaik, nobody at twitter2.0 has made a clear statement as to what tweet caused the permanent suspension. Just commenting "that is not" is not at all the same as saying "and this will get you banned".
[1]: https://www.politico.com/news/2022/10/10/kanye-wests-twitter...
The real reason is that Kayne was booted is that he toxic waste and having him on Twitter would have damaged the Twitter brand and cost Elon money.
An incoherent person? What do you mean?
I wish more people would understand this. For people like Musk, his personal brand is extremely important and they spend a lot of effort portraying and selling a specific image. It is an important part of his success as a businessman. FTX’s Sam Bankman-Fried is another example. His disheveled, messy geek look was calculated, and in an interview after FTX’s collapse he basically admitted that some of his opinions and philosophies that he espoused before were BS to push a specific narrative.
Musk has repeated “free speech” enough times that it’s become part of his brand. And people will associate that with him regardless of what he actually does. In his view Twitter is free speech. An attack on Twitter (as he alleged Apple was doing) is an attack on free speech. Twitter dying means the death of free speech. To claim that a company is the embodiment of free speech is ridiculous yet so many people buy into it.
Weird theory, but it points to Elon not being quite as foolish as the left would believe.
Let's not pretend the site wasn't an absolute disaster before the acquisition though. If I clicked on even a single trending topic about a game or news item I'd often be presented with unfiltered hardcore porn. Then there would be topics of innocent things like landscapes that get filtered. It was a complete joke and harmful place to visit.
No, you wouldn't. Either you don't know what hardcore porn actually is, or you're exaggerating.
Could be related?
Another data point: Been using Twitter daily within the past two years and I’ve never encountered anything remotely close to the filtering blunder you describe.
Also instead of a company struggling to be consistently profitable it was actually a complete dumpster fire that was doomed to fail in the near future if not for the timely intervention
Well, it never had a ban on porn as such, did it? Although I'd venture "full of porn" is an exaggeration. Do you have numbers?
> and especially child porn which previous leaders didn't care about.
Got a source for that? As best I know, they weren't considered a problem by the authorities. Unlike now where they have one (1) moderator (thanks to Musk's firings) for the entirety of Asia (tens of millions of users.)
> it was actually a complete dumpster fire that was doomed to fail in the near future
Their 2020 figures show that, apart from an unfortunately timed $800Mi settlement, they'd have made $580Mi profit. Now that's not a great profit on $5Bi revenue but it's definitely not "a complete dumpster fire that was doomed to fail", is it?
> if not for the timely intervention
Which has added $1Bi a year debt payments. Now that is "a complete dumpster fire that was doomed to fail"...
Settings | Privacy and Safety | Display media that may contain sensitive content
Did you enable that maybe?But it was a managed absolute disaster that was trying to be better.
And so regulators such as EU, FTC were okay to let it continue to operate.
That is clearly changing since Musk took over.
> Musk has repeated “free speech” enough times that it’s become part of his brand. And people will associate that with him regardless of what he actually does.
The models here are the guru/savior/grifter, which encompasses and goes beyond just "brand".
Why don't the followers see the contradictions in what the guru says and does? Some of them are truly deluded, but a whole lot of them understand it just fine and just want to see if they can get in on the action.
It accomplishes absolutely nothing - people are perfectly willing to put their real name and reputation behind their harrassing and toxic behavior. It does, however, make it easier to extend harassment campaigns to people's homes, businesses, families, etc.
Just like people are happy to have signs on the gardens or stickers on their truck they are more than willing to tell people their views online. Especially because they don't work for some multi-national that cares what their political views are. And so there are no consequences for whatever they say or do.
Wasn't Elon talking about the US anyway? Political speech itself is banned in many countries, so surely that wasn't his measure.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ra%C3%ABlism#/media/File:Raeli...
The rapper said: “I see good things about Hitler … Every human being has something of value that they brought to the table, especially Hitler.”
Jones replied: “The Nazis were thugs.”
“But they did good things too,” Ye said. “We gotta stop dissing the Nazis all the time.”
“Oh my goodness … just because you don’t like one group doesn’t mean –” Jones said, clearly uncomfortable. Ye interrupted: “I love Jewish people. But I also love Nazis.”
“I don’t think Hitler was a good guy,” Jones stated later. Ye replied: “There’s a lot of things that I love about Hitler. A lot of things.”
That is the same exact boilerplate response we get over here by extreme right wingers (assuming non extreme right wingers do exist, which over here is not the case) when talking about the atrocities committed by the Mussolini regime: "he did good things too". Yeah sure, like conscience is something that can be recharged like a cellphone battery: "Ok, I've helped 99 old ladies to cross the road, so now I'm entitled to beat and robber the next one!". Those people are full of shit, period.
So no, whatever you think of utilitarianism, this is not its problem.
https://nitter.net/dappergander/status/1598497428340088834#m
[edit: corrected the nitter URL]
https://www.abdpost.com/elon-musk-finally-sanctions-kanye-we...
Weirdly enough near-every site censored it, I had to go to duckduckgo to actually find that
I expect that the whole account was banned worldwide, more because it made headline news (in the bad way) around the world. And so not banning Kanye's horrible, mentally ill and rather sad antics, would scare off the advertisers who pay the bills. I mean, the remaining advertisers.
> Elon isn't following policies, he is following his whim.
Agreed.
> The problem with that is all the previous moderation statements he made did not align with this banning
It's almost like it wasn't thought through.
It doesn't.
Which is really really odd because quite a lot of his previous PR stunts — the Easter eggs in the Teslas, the “ring of fire” SpaceX video, the trans-Martian Roadster, the announcement of the Cybertruck — are things I regard as pretty effective brand building.
But this? This is weirder than trying to build a civil engineering brand by labelling weed-removal-torches as "flamethrowers".
He's been pretty clear that hated by ~50% and fine with the other 50% of the population is the old line, not the new one.
Where that puts the threshold is still an open question, and unfortunately one that will likely be answered somewhat capriciously. Then again, that's not really different from before.
More like 20% for both of those numbers [1]. Most choices are non-binary ... most Americans just don't care about Elon.
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1304563/us-adults-impres...
Neither position necessarily implies approval of the person or content.
"The Babylon Bee, was suspended by Twitter, after it had mockingly awarded transgender government official Rachel Levine the title 'Man of the Year.'"
This is the type of speech that Elon believes should be allowed, and I agree. He has repeatedly said freedom of speech absolutism is still subject to laws, and inciting violence past that line, but clearly not transgender satire.
No one complained about banning a dude posting swastikas unironically in 2005. The Overton Window has radically changed since then and not for the better.
And yet when the same satire it directed at Musk, he blows a gasket. Jeph Jacques[1] changed his profile picture and name to Musk's and tweeted (paraphrasing) "I like drinking my own piss first thing in the morning" and got permabanned for it. It was clearly satire to me, and broke no laws AFAICT.
1. Author of Questionable Content webcomic
> Level Three: “We’re the free speech platform! But no CSAM and no infringement!”
> Power to the people. Freedom is great!
> “Right, boss, apparently because you keep talking about freedom, a large group of people are taking it to mean they have ‘freedom’ to harass people with slurs and all sorts of abuse. People are leaving the site because of it, and advertisers are pulling ads.”
> That seems bad. Quick, have someone write up some rules against hate speech.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_book_burnings#The_burning...
Do you think that nobody knew Rachel Levine was a trans woman until the Bee pointed it out and that simply knowing this will drive violence towards them? If so, the Whitehouse is who you should blame. They already honored Rachel Levine as being a trans woman, which means male, so the secret was out.
Or is it that they're being allowed to say that a man presenting as a woman isn't exactly the same thing as a woman, hence "trans woman" and thus shouldn't be eligible for the same awards? That sounds like a reasonable opinion that a father might have, or a taxpayer paying for those awards.
What was provoking imminent lawlessness?
Not only that, the murder rate for women is higher than the rate for transwomen. And higher for men then transmen.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homicide_statistics_by_gender
Worldwide, men constitute 78.7% of homicide victims, making cis men the largest group of homicide victims.
Same goes for deliberately mis-labelling a person. Ironically, the Nazis started their hateful propaganda in the very same way.
Over 2000 years ago, Ovid said "Principiis obsta. Sero medicina parata, cum mala per longas convaluere moras." - stop it at the beginning; a cure is attempted too late when, through long delay, the illness has gained strength.
As an example, SNL had a lady play Rudy Giuliani to make fun of him: https://popculture.com/tv-shows/news/snl-cecily-strongs-mich...
Why is one acceptable and the other not, other than one's own perceived bias about which 'side' has the moral upper hand?
Deliberately misgendering someone is not the same as making fun of them. The Babylon Bee's entire punchline is just that they're using a hateful slur.
The message underlying this is: if men who, as the Bee put it, "dress like a western cultural stereotype of a woman" are now eligible for women's awards, then what does that leave for actual women to be honoured as women?
You see how that sounds? How do you think the Nazis treated trans people? You think it turned out any better for them than for the Jews?
The history of social media platforms shows that not moderating away, well, "hateful speech" tends to lead to it drowning out all the other voices.
That hypothesis only functions if users are trapped in one conversational space. What happens instead is that users choose not to volunteer their time and labor to speak around or over those calling for their non-existence (or for the non-existence of their friends and loved ones) and go elsewhere... Taking their money and attention with them.
As those promulgating the hate speech tend to be a much smaller group than those who leave, it is in the selfish interest of most forums to police that kind of signal jamming to maximize their possible user-base. Otherwise, you end up with a forum full mostly of those dabbling in hate speech, which is (a) not particularly advertiser friendly, (b) hostile to further growth, and (c) not something most people who get into this gig find themselves proud of.
In this particular context it's rather about commerce.
Kanye posted some really super antisemetic things. At one point, he posted a picture of a swastika overtop of a star of David.
Then he posted an unflattering picture of Elon Musk- and was banned within minutes.
When Elon Musk says "free speech" he means "free speech for me, not for thee". You can say anything you like, as long as Elon likes it too.
"Just clarifying that his account is being suspended for incitement to violence, not an unflattering pic of me being hosed by Ari.
Frankly, I found those pics to be helpful motivation to lose weight!" https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1598546057138524160
Oh, that's probably the reason - Ol' Muskie is really quick on the suspension button for people who mock him.
https://twitter.com/EliErlick/status/1598011331658948609?s=2...
Seems like there’s multiple levels of trolling going on there… the “clarification” was added by readers, and the “link that contains an example of a Twitter suspension email“ links to the New York Post.
Just that Twitter didn't exactly consistently enforce it.
So sure the bans were just sad rich man being offended but they were still technically breaking TOS
The idea that Elon HAD to ban those people because of the TOS created by the previous ownership is absolutely hilarious.
No, like the broader right, his whole “free speech thing” is nothing more than “speech I like should be more favored by private parties than it currently is”.
Free speech absolutism is illegal. There are laws you must follow or the FBI will come knocking on your door.
Whether free speech is appropriate on a platform like Twitter I don't know or care really. But surely Twitter can't promote itself as a free speech platform while banning Kanye for legal speech.
I view the boundaries of acceptable speech as a resource. And like other resources in which we need to allocate in society, we use the power of markets to come to the “fairest” allocation that we can.
I believe Elon could implement a “free speech market” on Twitter where Twitter creates an asset which gives the owner the right to ban or allow a particular controversial user. This asset is then auctioned off (providing revenue for Twitter) and then the users get the ultimate control over who is or isn’t allowed on the platform.
This also has the benefit of taking the decision making out of the hands of Elon and those at Twitter and giving power directly to the people.
Also, the People have money too. They can organize. I just want to give them a chance to organize and have a seat at the table.
1. It sort of is that insofar as advertisers (the actual customers) are free to stop buying ads, but when they do so Musk throws a conniption fit and says not giving him money is a step away from tyranny
2. If there's a tradable 'right to offend' asset then it will either be bought up by wealthy people who are assholes or assholes who raise money from other assholes on the promise that they will be bigger assholes (see also politics, US)
I mean, why not have a market for murder, and just limit the number of permits to 10% less than the current homicide totals? The government makes tax revenue and homicide falls by 10%, (almost) everybody wins! Vote for me in '24!
do not vote for me
2. If there’s one thing I know about wealthy people, it’s that there’s wealthy people on both sides of any given politcal/social issue. So for every one that wants to allow certain speech there will be one that wants to ban it. Also people can organize from the grassroots to form large pools of capital and have their voice heard if the issue is important enough.
3. Although your hypothetical is a bit sensationalist and off topic, I’ll entertain it. If the outcome of such a scheme really did lower the homicide total by 10%, then it’d be hard to argue against it vs. the status quo as it is an objectively better outcome.
Absolute free speech is an illusion that has never existed and never will. Our problem in society is that that we censor the wrong kinds of speech and tolerate the wrong kinds of speech. Overton windows aren't bad. Ours has just been corrupted. Musk explicitly said he wants to essentially broaden and fix the tolerance window, not abolish it.
He was openly crowing over being able to hoax/troll the media on Twitter as of just a few days ago. The off-the-wall idea that what he says represents what he believes is constantly promoted even by the people who supposedly are frothing with hatred for him.
"If there be time to expose through discussion the falsehood and fallacies, to avert the evil by the process of education, the remedy to be applied is more speech, not enforced silence."[0]
Louis Brandeis did believe that context and specifics are important, so I think the technology of the online platform is significant especially with respect to the first part of that quote.
[0] https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep...
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/274/357/
> "Whitney was one of the founders of the Communist Labor Party, which was a radical wing of the Socialist Party that split from the rest of the Party after a convention in 1919. When she attended a convention to organize a California wing of the Labor Party, Whitney exhorted workers to vote for its candidates in elections and advocated for taking political action in a resolution. The Party eventually adopted a more extreme program than what Whitney advocated in her resolution, and she protested to no avail. Whitney was charged with violating the California Criminal Syndicalism Act on the basis that she had helped to organize a group that sought to effect economic and political change through the unlawful use of violence.
She argued that she had not intended the organization to act in this way and did not plan to aid it in those objectives, so she should not be charged merely for attending the convention. Whitney claimed that the California law violated the First Amendment."
As usual, lots of nice things may have been said about free speech, but in the end she was convicted and jailed for organising a political party.
Also he wrote this before social media. He wrote that before fascism swept in on the back of free speech and public persuasion in the 1930s. We're in a new paradigm now and worldviews need to be updated to fit new information and new evidence than what was available during his time.
It is. Mid 2000s 4chan and more recently 8kun found it immediately.
When you remove limiters people slap the rail immediately. What value does it add? No one is learning anything when posting anonymously without moderation, they're just lulling themselves into an easily manipulated state.
https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19/green-blackboa...
My favorite memory is playing carnival music through my mic while spinning a grabbed merc around. That and everything about aquarium.
West tweeted an image of a swastika in a star of David - technically an obsolete symbol of the Raelian UFO cult, in practice it suggested Nazis vs Jews to any casual observer. In the context of West's long-simmering beef with Jewish people and current manic episode of shouting about his enthusiasm for Hitler from inside a ski mask, it was certainly meant to taunt and would fit most people's standard for hate speech.
But incitement to violence? Not exactly, and that's why I say Musk doesn't seem to know what he's doing. There is an indirect kind of incitement, in that it inciting people to behave like Nazis is synonymous with violence; neo-Nazis might deny the holocaust but are just as likely to follow up with the suggestion that it would be a good idea, and in conversation among themselves are a lot blunter about their desire to do violence, preferably on a grand scale. This is why Nazis complaining about free speech is a bad joke, since their gameplan for pretty much any speech they dislike is to simply kill the speakers.
But legally speaking, incitement to violence has a much narrower threshold; it has to be be specific and produce imminent lawless action. For a long time this meant internet speech didn't cunt at all, as jurists figured there couldn't be an imminent risk if the speaker and the recipient were in different places, and that electronic communication was too attenuated to inflame the passions of its receivers. Legislators and courts have somewhat caught up to the realities of the internet age and so things like SWATting or issuing threats by voicemail or online are taken much more seriously than they used to be (to a fault in some jurisdictions like the UK, whose legislators have a Canute-like fondness for prescriptivism).
In this sense, West's tweet absolutely is not incitement to violence, because while it endorses Nazism and Jew-hatred in a trollish way, it lacks the specificity (in action, time, or place) to merit a legal charge. It's not impossible that West might end up suing Twitter or Musk personally for defamation, given his wealth, mania, and apparent ability to hold a grudge.
Free speech advocates have long wrestled with the ramifications of declaring some speech to be 'hate speech' - I think myself that hate crimes are a legislative punt by making a new and scary-sounding law that doesn't mean very much, rather than clarifying existing law and letting juries weigh the significance of hatred as a possible motivation in the trials of violent crimes. Free speech absolutists, in whose company Musk previously placed himself, generally insist on the narrow legal standard of criminality as the only acceptable reason to inflict bans, and argue that all other speech should proceed unchecked. This argument generally arrives clad in the purple robes of Platonic idealism, though in practice totally un-moderated environments soon resemble an orgy of cynics behaving as obnoxiously as possible to maximize their sense of freedom.
So if Musk is just making it up as he goes along, then he's in the situation of alienating everyone to his left and right simultaneously. I don't know how closely he's supervising content moderation decisions, (probably not very) but the reappearance on Twitter of super far right figures like Brett Stephens and Andrew Anglin (currently evading a federal arrest warrant) suggests the 'public square' is going to see regular brawls for a while.
I find the unlimited free speech arguments to be disingenuous and lazy most of the time. There's always a limit to speech, and it's not easy to find. That doesn't mean we should explore the space to find it.