News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by WheatMillington on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:51PM (#33255655)
I don't think I'm necessarily having the same experience as you.... my advice to people who aren't sure if they want kids, is DON'T. It's bloody hard, you sacrifice A LOT. Don't have kids unless you're very sure it's what you want.

I have 2 kids under 6 and I feel like I just don't have any time for any of my hobbies any more. I leave for work first thing, come home in the afternoon, and haven't had any time for myself until the kids are down at 7.30, and I'm utterly wasted. Weekends are just chaos, yeah we can divide and conquer but that only goes so far.

As for enjoying hanging around with kids.... I don't know what age that starts, but I'm 5 years and counting.

Honestly I'm exhausted, and I'm not gonna lie, I have some regret about having kids when I see the child free people around me, and how they're spending their 30s.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by arcticfox on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:30PM (#33255938)
On the other hand, I wasn't sure if I wanted kids, and the borderline decision to go ahead was the best decision of my life. YMMV.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by tacoman on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:00PM (#33255727)
Yes, spending time with little kids can be really boring, be present when it counts though. This period of life doesn't last forever so take care of your health and maintain your important relationships with whatever energy you can muster.

Every time I look at pictures of my kids when they were younger I feel a tinge of regret for not being more in the moment.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Aeolun on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:37PM (#33255986)
> I feel a tinge of regret for not being more in the moment.

That’s not really something you control. In that moment you probably just wanted to escape for 5 minutes of blessed peace.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ip26 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:39PM (#33256858)
The weird part is the lag. You want to escape for 5 minutes. But you only want that now because you couldn't escape for years before. If you stopped to think about it, maybe you don't really want those five minutes. If only you stop and really think.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by nostrademons on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:50PM (#33257398)
That requires stopping to think for five minutes, which you didn't have in the moment.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by warner25 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:09PM (#33255782)
I feel the same as WheatMillington most of the time, but also feel the same as you when I look at pictures of my kids from the past few years. It's so conflicting.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by klipt on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:50PM (#33256057)
"The days are long, but the years are short"
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by spockz on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:27AM (#33257659)
100% this. Be in the moment. Enjoy. Play.

You can rest later. (When the kids are bigger and can do chores themselves. ;-))

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ojl on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:26AM (#33258095)
I feel the same, but also got lucky that my oldest son and I both like climbing. So even if he, as a typical teenager, wants to spend time with friends or simply wants to be left alone in his room we spend 2-3 evenings per week together at the climbing gym.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by andyferris on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:19PM (#33255849)
Hang in there another couple of years. Now my youngest is 7 I find life a lot more liberating then when they were under 6. And its fun doing "older" activities with the kids. But yeah it's hard for more than "the first few months/years"!

> when I see the child free people around me, and how they're spending their 30s

On the flip side, I wonder if you might enjoy your 70's and 80's a lot more with kids (and possibly grandkids).

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by agilo on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:24PM (#33255896)
With the way things are going, they might be living with me in a basement and sharing my old age security for sustenance.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Aeolun on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:38PM (#33255995)
Then you won’t need to worry about 75% of your time with them being before they are 12 ;)
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Aeolun on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:34PM (#33255961)
> until the kids are down at 7.30

Yours sleep at 7:30?! How do you not consider that to be literally oceans of free time?

That said, yeah, you give up the whole evenings spent trying to solve some problem, but honestly, I don’t think that, on my deathbed, I’ll ever regret that I didn’t get to solve problem x 30 years ago.

What I’m almost positive I’ll look back on very fondly though is every evening spent going in the bath with my kid, then taking him to bed, watching some youtube and reading books.

My biggest regret is that (barring a miracle) I won’t have any more than one (for his sake as much as mine).

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by muzani on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:57PM (#33256100)
Having 3 kids, I put them to sleep by 9.30. There's a loop that they can't fall asleep when they're tired and they're tired because they don't get enough sleep, so we even make sure they have excess sleep if possible. Otherwise they get cranky and it's a bad day/week/month for everyone.

I realise I could just wake up earlier to do stuff, and if I wake up early, I'm also less likely to waste it on pointless things.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by flurdy on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:51AM (#33259357)
Ditto, mine are not all down until 9.30, or worse. Then I am too knackered and shell-shocked to actually get anything done, yet wont actually do the sensible thing and go to bed early as too guilty with the chores still to do...
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by spockz on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:35AM (#33257716)
The kids being down at 730/19:30 doesn’t mean everything is done:

Laundry, cleaning after dinner, tidying up, ordering groceries/making shopping lists, actually doing groceries, fixing something in/at house/car/garden, taking out trash(diapers), paper/plastic, researching which child seat to buy when they get bigger, parent/teacher sessions. This when you are lucky. Maybe even preparation for work or study is needed still. Etcetera.

Just to point out that free time and therefore a moment for yourself doesn’t automatically start the moment kids are at bed.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Aeolun on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:08AM (#33257975)
It’s not that I disagree, but all those things need doing just as much if your kids are in bed at 9:30 at the earliest.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by nlitened on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:34AM (#33258157)
Have you tried outsourcing all the chores? Get a nanny, a gardener, a personal assistant, hire handymen, don’t cook at home.

Sorry for being analytical about it, I am personally interested in having kids—and so far it seems to me that you’re overburdening yourself with too much stuff that you don’t have to do at all.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by spockz on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:44AM (#33258209)
I can outsource and I do, I also readily buy any tool or appliance that saves me time. But not everyone is as well of that they can afford to do that.

Also, I have found that there is significant benefit in doing chores yourself. At least it gives me a sense of accomplishment and a chance to do something with my hands instead of thinking a lot and then wiggle some fingers to type or draw PowerPoint.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by withinboredom on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:41AM (#33258192)
My wife is a morning person. I am not. She does all the morning stuff, and gets the kiddo to school before I even wake up. I put our kid to bed, do the dishes, and game/hobby stuff until midnight to 2am. My wife enjoys her quiet mornings before I wake up and the kiddo is in school, I enjoy my quiet evenings when everyone is in bed.

I can’t imagine how couples that are both morning or night people can function. It must be so different.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by jcul on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:53AM (#33271918)
I feel like it's a trade-off between having a little extra time in the evening or a little more sleep in the morning.

Mine go to sleep about 7:30pm, but are generally awake at 5:30 to 6:00am, so you yourself need to go to sleep not long after, or you will have a sleep deficit.

So, it's not a huge amount of time, especially once you do all the jobs than need to be done once they are asleep.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by treeman79 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:11PM (#33255799)
I gave up all my hobbies. 1-8 was brutal with 2 of em. A few years later I’m picking them back up again.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by notch656a on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:55PM (#33255691)
I feel it. Whether the statistics are true or not, the idea of being 75% done with the time by 12 sounds extremely liberating. I put in the time and effort for the sake of the children, but the truth is I want them independent as soon as possible. The older they get and the less they need (and the less time I have to spend with them), the more joy I get out of life. The first year was a black hole of lots of work which obviously the child has no capacity to really express gratefulness for (not that it is owed).

There's nothing that can really prepare you to know what parenthood will be like with you're particular children, and by the time you know what it's like to regret it it's too late -- at the very least you're in it for child support. I recommend anyone who enjoys their life as it as and don't see it as a "must have" to fulfill their sense of purpose to strongly STRONGLY consider before they have kids.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by maxsilver on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:58PM (#33256108)
My partner and I have 5 kids under 7yrs old -- four of whom are adopted and two of whom are struggling with severe developmental delays (and likely autism, still waiting on formal diagnosis).

When kids get older, they get a lot more "fun" and a lot less immediate work. I can take my eldest two out pretty much anywhere without a ton of effort, they are fun to hang out with, they can be trusted to be kind and respectful in adult spaces, and they'll invite me into kids spaces, etc.

But also, anything can happen. Anything can happen. Your kids could be born with lifelong conditions or issues. They could be healthy at young ages, but develop special conditions as they hit early childhood or late adolescence. They could struggle with lifestyle issues (violence, drugs, alcohol, crime, etc). You may just end up not liking them very much (you may end up wishing they were more like you, when they aren't), they may have hobbies that differ from you, they may choose careers you'd prefer not, they may choose religious views you disagree with, they may end up being LGBTQIA+ even if you aren't, and so on. We have one child who is at high risk of never developing cognitively enough to safely live on their own as an adult -- anything can happen.

Having a child is a literal forever commitment -- even more so than any marriage is -- to love and care for a person that might not even exist yet, no matter who they end up being. Be absolutely ready to make a literal lifetime commitment to love and care for this child as a fellow human, before deciding to have one.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with opting out of all of that, and spending your 20's, 30's or lifetime doing something else -- having a child is a huge responsibility, and not something anyone should ever get pressured into, or jump into capriciously.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by shanewwarren on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:06PM (#33256581)
I've heard stories of how difficult the process of adopting kids can be. So, kudos to you, that sounds like a lot to manage.

Regarding opting out, I get it, but I don't agree personally. Not having kids, can enable some pretty great lifestyles. But I do feel like you don't get a chance to understand what being a parent is all about. No amount of being a great aunt / uncle / whatever, gives you that feeling of needing to nurture or protect your child.

It forces you to change, maintain a good relationship w/ your partner, be a good role model, etc.

If I was do it again, I'd try to do it earlier.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by brokenbyclouds on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:31PM (#33256794)
It absolutely does not force you to change at all, nor does it force you to maintain a good relationship with your partner. Divorce rates are high, there are lots of bad parents. Having kids may have pushed you to be better, and that's great, but there are a lot of people out there for whom it makes no positive difference at all.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by shanewwarren on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:59PM (#33257009)
I don't disagree with you. Divorce rates are high, and for many it doesn't make a positive difference. I imagine most folks on HN are pretty conscious about striving to be better, so for this small subset I think my opinion is reasonable. And I know plenty of people who if they had kids (but abstain) would absolutely rock at it, and it *could* be a positive forcing function, such that they get to experience different aspects to life.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by lazyasciiart on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:18AM (#33257599)
People who are having kids because they "want to be better" can go ahead and just be better by helping take care of the kids already here who need it.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:11AM (#33259484)
In my experience, people who are having kids because they want to be better have something broken in their lives that they ought to to work on fixing before having kids, and the consequences if they don’t can be…quite bad.

Get a therapist for therapy, not a child.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by volkl48 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:48PM (#33256929)
Life is a series of choices, and it's impossible to explore every path you could take.

> But I do feel like you don't get a chance to understand what being a parent is all about.

That's 100% accurate.

There's a pretty much infinite number of possible life experiences I'm not going to get to experience personally and will not have the time/money/ability to fit into my lifespan. The wishlist of things I'd love to do or experience someday continually grows longer - no matter how much I try to fit more of them into my life.

Taking on what amounts to a lifetime commitment and a massive investment of time and money for an experience that I have zero interest in and think I would actively dislike, seems like a terrible use of my finite resources.

> It forces you to change, maintain a good relationship w/ your partner, be a good role model, etc.

Perhaps it inspired you to do that. But the divorce rate and number of parents out there are terrible role models, suggest that it's not exactly the case for everyone.

I'll also suggest that people who don't have much interest in becoming parents are probably a whole lot more likely to wind up on the negative side of those possibilities should they wind up having children anyway.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by EamonnMR on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:59PM (#33257465)
> Taking on what amounts to a lifetime commitment and a massive investment of time and money for an experience that I have zero interest in and think I would actively dislike, seems like a terrible use of my finite resources.

If you consider maximizing your experience the best use of your resources, I suppose not.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by xyzzy_plugh on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:04AM (#33259433)
> Taking on what amounts to a lifetime commitment and a massive investment of time and money for an experience that I have zero interest in and think I would actively dislike, seems like a terrible use of my finite resources.

This is a naive way to think about it. In the grand scheme of things, as TFA hints at, kids don't take up a significant portion of your life. If you're goal is to focus on striking off entries on a wishlist, there are many, many things that can be sacrificed to make room that don't involve children.

It's not as bad as you make it seem.

Lastly, I don't really care about experiences the way I did when I was younger. Going on a trip to an exotic locale doesn't really excite me as much as, say, taking a good picture of a friend or family member and sharing it. Or hearing a good story or joke.

Kids expand to fill the space in your life you make for them. I have more fun with my kids than possibly anyone else. I want to share experiences with them, not for myself.

Have you ever been excited when telling a friend about a cool spot they've never been to, and subsequently taking them there? Kids are like a revolving door of those opportunities. They start from scratch.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by eyelidlessness on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:09PM (#33257098)
I would have been a shit parent to a human child. I would still be a shit parent to a human child. I don’t want one, if I accidentally had one they would eventually not want me too. I’ve been a half decent parent to my youngest sibling, because what you say about life forcing you to change has some truth.

I’ve experienced what you described with my pup, but that’s because she is exactly the bond and the responsibility that fits my life. It revolves around her, every day, all the time. No amount of parenting a human would ever change that.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:08AM (#33259460)
> It forces you to change, maintain a good relationship w/ your partner, be a good role model, etc.

No, it doesn’t actually, as any kind of even approximately universal effect, force any of that, and even a casual look around at society would demonstrate that pretty clearly. It may or may not have motivated that in you – but plenty of people who would describe themselves as having those traits in their own relationships / parenting objectively don’t, so self-assessment is pretty clearly not a reliable gauge here. I would agree that there are people whose combination of innate personality, life experiences, etc., will lead them to actually be nudged in those directions by having children, but there are plenty who won’t be. And there are plenty of people who will be nudged in much more negative directions by the experience.

As a parent myself, it amazes me how many people who are parents are drawn into a bizarre evangelization of parenting as some kind of universally ideal vocation, with stories about the effect it will have that are trivially refutable by looking outside of one’s own internal narrative of their own experience with their own kids at the rest of the world around them.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by alpinemeadow on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:14PM (#33256661)
I always say I only found unconditional love once I became a parent. (From me toward my child)

As you say, the commitment is forever, whether we are present or not. For the movie Interstellar, one of the themes Nolan developed was that at some point we become our children’s memories. It probably happens around the 12 year old mark.

For all parents out there, be present, however you can.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by chasil on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:32PM (#33256797)
This is not always so.

For me, unconditional love was a youthful thing.

My parents are much less admirable now, as I have grown older.

My reasons are legion.

I don't wish them harm, but they are nothing like me.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by mlyle on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:07PM (#33257084)
From the comment you replied to:

>(From me toward my child)

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ChainOfFools on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:38PM (#33256849)
> Be absolutely ready to make a literal lifetime commitment to love and care for this child as a fellow human, before deciding to have one.

Unfortunately, if you decide after all of this reflection that you don't want to have kids there is no need to worry, at least, about perpetuating the human race... because for every couple who conscientiously decides not to have kids it's, there are a half dozen more who don't give any thought to any of this whatsoever and proceed to have (often multiple) kids anyway.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ransom1538 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:52PM (#33257410)
"there are a half dozen more who don't give any thought to any of this whatsoever and proceed to have (often multiple) kids anyway."

You might have to update this [1]. People do care. People have an iphone now. People can read. The "tons of kids poppin" arguments don't hold. We will see a global wide population decrease soon.

https://econofact.org/the-mystery-of-the-declining-u-s-birth...

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ChainOfFools on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:04AM (#33257946)
spend a couple months in and out of your local NICU, as I have, seeing firsthand the depressingly common spectacle of premature neonates being left alone for days, sometimes over a week, by parents (or parent) who can't make the time to visit their own clinging-to-life offspring.

Because their lives are already overburdoned by the several other - somehow always toddler-age - children in tow with them. Lives frequently complicated by various degrees of substance abuse, leading to the NICU births. You would not be as comfortable googling some factoid response here.

Whatever the macro trend may be in terms of total birthrate, its the constitution of those births, in terms of quality of life, my post was referring to.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by nostrademons on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:39AM (#33258512)
Pretty heavy selection bias in that sample. All the people who chose not to have kids obviously are not going to be in the NICU. Among the people who do choose to have kids, those with good prenatal care and healthy habits are going to be very underrepresented in the NICU, particularly if you're in a community where you see a lot of substance abuse. So what's left is what you've observed.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by xyzzy_plugh on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:56AM (#33259387)
This seems awfully America-centric. I understand what you're saying but in my experience it is a local phenomena, not global. Most parents (or at least a parent) spend a lot of time with their kids at the start of their life.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by collegeburner on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:57PM (#33256996)
i'm too young to be having kids rn anyway but i thought about it a little and this is one of the big things that makes me hesitate. i don't think i could handle raising a kid who ended up special needs and required lifelong care. seems like having a kid who ended up an alcoholic/junkie/mentally retarded/deeply at odds with my values would really remove most of the positives, so it would be a serious gamble.

of course, i also have it easier since men can just remarry at 50 and still have kids. i have time. but it really makes me wonder if i ever want children. my parents think it's a great thing and i shouldn't be quite so worried but they have quite the case of survivorship bias, all their kids turned out well and so it is easy from their perspective on the other side.

the annoying part is all the girls i meet either know they want kids or know they don't. nobody my age should be quite that certain yet in either direction. makes dating a bitch beyond casual relationships ngl.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by frontman1988 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:57AM (#33258611)
Even I am young and lean childfree. My reasoning is that non-existence is better than existence. More and more I see the world, more and more I agree with Buddhism's first noble truth that there is suffering in life. There are some moments of joy, but is all of it worth it afterall? It's just a tough question. I don't want to bring any more suffering to this world. There is already so much suffering and I can't do anything about it. So many innocents throughout history have suffered so much. Millions of innocents died in holocaust or nuclear bombs or famines in the last 100 years ago alone. Recently teenagers are getting killed mercilessly in Iran. Life can be so unfair sometimes that it feels like a bad gamble to produce more of it. A child can give great joy to their parents for sure, but they can also cause great suffering. Like there is hardly anything more hurtful in life than the bereavement of your own child. People forget that something that can give you great joy can also give you great pain. And for me, it's not just about me and the happiness I derive from parenting my kid, but also the child who will one day grow into an adult and have to deal with this cruel world and the sheer pain of conscious existence itself. For these reasons I am leaning childfree for now.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by meheleventyone on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:53AM (#33258988)
The answer to all this is to stop considering it so abstractly and talk to some parents who have been in these situations and actually look at the incident rates. Anything could happen but not all outcomes are as likely. There’s loads of mundane activities we do that have serious life changing events that could happen. A kid is a commitment but also one that is profoundly human that people have been doing successfully for millennia.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by scotty79 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:46AM (#33259327)
> But also, anything can happen. Anything can happen. Your kids could be born with lifelong conditions or issues. They could be healthy at young ages, but develop special conditions as they hit early childhood or late adolescence. They could struggle with lifestyle issues (violence, drugs, alcohol, crime, etc).

I could never understand how people are so easy to punish someone with life. Especially someone who they'll love unconditionally. I didn't like my life from the start despite it being fairly decent in objective terms.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by nickd2001 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:10AM (#33259933)
Much respect to you for adopting 4 kids, especially those with additional needs! :) To this "We have one child who is at high risk of never developing cognitively enough to safely live on their own as an adult.", I'd argue, society in general needs to look after people like this much better. Everyone, particularly the rich, should be paying their fare share of taxes to cover decent quality care for those unable to look after themselves due to disability. That includes respecting the people who work in that field properly as doing a vital job, and paying them well enough. When parents feel that this lifetime responsibility falls on them alone, I feel that something is severely broken. What about people with learning disability who do not have family to look out for them? They need a system to look after them. I think some of the comments on this discussion reflect that there's a lack of general support for families, especially in the USA with its insufficient social programmes.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by addingadimensio on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:23PM (#33256282)
This is short sided the first five years are tough the next are great and the following are even better
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ekanes on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:35PM (#33256342)
I don’t know that the GP comment disagrees - I think you’re just actually still in the hardest phase. imho it gets much better and more interesting soon! And then they’re teens you can have amazing conversations with them. And while we aren’t there yet, I gather from everyone that being a grandparent is bliss. Sending you positive vibes!
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by smesla on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:35PM (#33256345)
Thank you. With soon to be 8 billion people on the planet, the norm really should be to not reproduce. If people are dying for kids that's fine I guess, but only after like three mandatory abortions, minimum.

/hotTake

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by andsoitis on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:36PM (#33256356)
> norm really should be to not reproduce

Humans, just like other organisms, can't help themselves.

More seriously, we are expressions of replicating organic matter, the vessels for this process to continue to unfold. Humans are a phase in a long progression of evolution by natural selection. One day, just like long ago, "we" will no longer be around. And that's OK.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by smesla on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:39PM (#33256368)
I...beg to differ.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by hattar on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:52PM (#33256944)
This might be one of those MiB things:

> A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky, dangerous animals and you know it.

Many individuals can help themselves, but on the whole the species cannot.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by a_e_k on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:45PM (#33256413)
I have four kids. YMMV, but I've found with mine that six years old seems to be the magic threshold. Developmentally, it seems like at that age a switch suddenly turns on and they start really showing distinct interests, talking fluently, thinking more abstractly, making solid friendships with a few peers, and wanting a bit more independence. I find the 6yo age to be a blast.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by baryphonic on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:23PM (#33257196)
I'd echo this. My youngest is 5, and though we went through the terrible 2s through the f**ing 4s, it seems we've turned a corner at age 5. There's this sweet little kid who can start to control his emotions and frequently makes us laugh. In place of fits and tantrums we had for basically the past three years, we have someone who can take a breather and accept "no" for an answer.

The best part is all of the hugs, the I-love-you-Daddy-s, the endless curiosity (tonight's: "if you use Apple Pay, are they taking [cash] dollars out of your phone?") and a newfound recognition that other people with their own dignity and needs exist.

It is still a lot of work, but I love spending time with my kids and seeing them learn and grow into civilized people.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by TedDoesntTalk on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:42PM (#33257335)
Read “Setting Limits” by Robert Mackenzie if you still have problems with “no” and tantrums. I’ve read 10 parenting books and this is hands-down the best.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by dotnet00 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:35AM (#33257717)
I agree, although I'm not a parent, I babysat my niece a lot throughout. She's turning 6 in a few weeks and it's pretty great how much more "interactive" she can be now.

When they're much younger you constantly have to fret over them, but now she's learning to write, asks fun questions and overall the "spark" of being her own person is really visible.

While I used to enjoy babysitting earlier too, back then I still used to be glad to be done so I could rest and catch up on some hobbies while nowadays I usually feel pretty guilty having to leave.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by svnt on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:26AM (#33258431)
This is a pretty consistent finding in early childhood development —- typically around 5-6 years old they go from just absorbing everything to being more like a person as we think of it. There is another shift often around 8-10 where they become more fully integrated.

Then that integrated little soul gets thrown into major hormonal shifts…

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by treespace8 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @10:14PM (#33256662)
I felt exactly the same way. Very, very hard until the kids are in school full time. But still hard until they are teenagers.

I'm finding the teenage years to be much more pleasant. Getting some payback for all the time invested. I know it's still a long way away for you.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by dionidium on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:23AM (#33257630)
If it makes you feel any better I delayed having kids and spent my 30s dating and hanging out and going to bars -- and it was terrible. I was never more depressed. I got tired of dating. I got tired of bars. I was lonely. My life had no meaning or direction. I had a nice career and could go anywhere and do anything I wanted, but it turns out none of that made me even a little bit happy.

I remember one summer making plans to go camping with three different groups of friends three weekends in a row and realizing at the end of it that all three weekends were exactly the same. Nothing new happens. You're not missing anything if you just stay home.

Happiness is extremely overrated. I had a lot of laughs in my 30s, but my life was a disaster. Now I'm tired and busy and I don't go out and do "fun" stuff very often, but I'm much more satisfied. My biggest regret is that I waited so long to start my life. Brunch isn't life.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Panzer04 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:39AM (#33257738)
This feels a lot like a more extreme version of what I'm doing now (especially the camping thing), and I'm a lot younger..

Thanks for the perspective.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by dalyons on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:05AM (#33257957)
Just don’t take it as a rule though - I had a kid late also and I don’t regret the camping, brunches, career and travel at all. Some are memories I’ll keep forever and all those experiences make me feel like I’ve had a fullish life already, which can make it easier to deal with the no-life of having kids :)
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by dionidium on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:11AM (#33257994)
For sure. Maybe these anecdotes are useful; maybe not. I don't know. Everybody has to figure it out on their own, in the end.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by nmcfarl on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:33AM (#33261877)
There’s 1000 places in this conversation to say this, but I thought here would work. I too had a kid late and do not regret the camping, but wanted to say the no-life is time limited^, or can be if you are lucky.

My kid is now 9, and while a fancy brunch is beyond him, he can do a sit down sushi dinner. We've done a couple of international trips with him, and we've settled into a friend group with similar interests so we are constantly doing camping, backcountry backpacking, and in the winter skiing - all with him and his friends. It is pretty good, and certainly not a no-life.

---

^ And we knew what we wanted, so even though many of the early trips where miserable, the kid can say he’s been backpacking and xc-skiing every year of his life.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by cossatot on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:39AM (#33258183)
Camping is also a great activity with kids, for what it’s worth. Backpacking 20 miles into the wilderness is not going to be an option at least until they are older, but car camping can still be pretty fun even when they are itty bitty especially if there is some fun and accessible terrain to explore—water to throw rocks into, mossy rocks and tree trunks to check out and stumble over, etc.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by stickfigure on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:32AM (#33263675)
Kids make camping even MORE fun.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by natnatenathan on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:15AM (#33258026)
This is exactly my experience, probably from age 28 until I met my wife at ~34. My friends and I would go to all these bars, clubs, rock climbing trips. While I loved my friends and generally enjoyed doing those things, I felt this long-term malaise of meaningless. The loss of freedom getting married and then greater loss when having kids was unexpected and a jarring change. But it has made me such a better person. And even though it sucks going through the same chores every day or when my 4 and 6 year olds are in maximum procrastination mode. I wouldn't trade my worst day with them for my best day of freedom when I was younger. I've never been more happy.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by RamblingCTO on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:39AM (#33258513)
Thank you and also the parent for the perspective. That's also what I experience. Not sure kids will fix that, but it always feels better knowing you're not alone.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by kanahanin on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:55AM (#33260254)
You've just described my life. Thanks for the perspective, That empty feeling was very confusing for me. I've something to look forward too!
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Defitio on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:23AM (#33260496)
In my opinion you just use kids as an escape goat for meaning of life.

My question would be why you value your kids time more than bouldern?

Because you made them? Because they consume so much time with them?

Or because you are just better in being a parent and biological getting satisfaction out of it?

Unfortunately for me I'm not sure if I would end like you or the other poster who regrets it sometimes.

Also I'm not sure if I want to force another/new human through my experiences like going to school etc.

In dune the king new/realized that he can't do what is necessary but has to prepare his son to do so.

I have the opposite though: perhaps I need to not to have kids to stop the cycle of creating meaning through procreation.

Yes I overthink stuff and one way or the other I still think becoming a parent would be a life changing experience but besides all of the normal thoughts climate change comes on top of it.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by skinnymuch on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:31AM (#33260594)
If you can edit this. Edit out the “you” to “people”. It doesn’t look like an attack then. I see your comment is greying out so it’s getting downvotes.

Having diff perspectives is cool so it would be unfortunate for yours to get flagged because it seems too aggressive.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by neweroldguy on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:25AM (#33261101)
I think your concern (will I be one who is fulfilled, or one who regrets?) is reasonable, but in fact for many people the answer is “yes”. You’ll often feel fulfilled. Occasionally you’ll regret.

Also, “escape goat”, while an amazing phrase, should be “scapegoat”.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by skinnymuch on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:00AM (#33263225)
Escape goat is such a better term haha. I wish it was a legit synonym
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by lee on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:59AM (#33261480)
> Or because you are just better in being a parent and biological getting satisfaction out of it?

It is totally this. We are biological creatures and we cannot escape that.

Love, sex, friendships, relationships, parenting, happiness, and so forth are all aspects of our biology. We are not automatons living a purely rational life. Satisfaction in life depends on those biological mechanisms and shouldn't be seen through a purely rational lens.

Kids aren't a scapegoat for a meaningful life. They do absolutely make life meaningful. Much in the same way eating a delicious meal brings pleasure. We depend on our biological wiring to feel such things.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by skyhvr on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:11PM (#33265074)
Thank you for this poignant reminder.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Defitio on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:58PM (#33265705)
Yes but is it fair to the new human?

Oversimplified: would you be okay to create a new human if you know they have only 100 days to life? 5 years? 20? Suffering in school, sleep problems etc etc?

Just because it's evolutionary pre programmed?

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by amag on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:54PM (#33266376)
Not everyone who struggles in life would rather not live. I think it's quite arrogant to contemplate whether living is worth it for another human being.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Defitio on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:33PM (#33267588)
When I'm the maker of another human it's definitely worth considering before if it will be worth to do so
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by amag on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:56PM (#33267827)
Even so, that person will not be you. Even if they will go through exactly the same things you've been through they may not have the same experience. You cannot know if it was worth it for them.

I think it's fine if people don't have kids, I just find the reasoning "what if they suffer, etc" a cop-out. You cannot know that beforehand and even if they suffer, they may still find meaning in life.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by logical_ferry on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:43AM (#33271873)
Last several replies you gave are such high quality. I hate it when people overintellectualize such obvious things like having a kid. I would have flipped out at the other poster, but you stuck in there and gave some really good points. Awesome.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Defitio on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:54AM (#33271921)
Having kids is everything but obvious.

Don't dismiss critical thinking with an attack on you just because it feels obvious to you.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Defitio on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:51AM (#33271908)
Regret emotions etc. are only possible when you are alive.

Missery etc also can only be felt when you are alive.

You clearly don't take any responsibility at all otherwise I'm lost on how easy you just dismiss concerns.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by amag on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:38AM (#33273158)
So is joy, happiness and pleasure. I feel sorry for you if your life is only filled with regret and misery. For most people there are ways out of misery but it all starts with the realization that it's not a necessity. When you're depressed it's difficult to imagine ever being able to feel anything else again but knowing that it is possible can put you on the right track.

Maybe your need to pass judgement on my character based on two posts should tell you something about yourself. It really takes an inflated ego to, as a non-parent, talk about responsibility with a parent. Paraphrasing: "Responsibility as a parent is heavy as a mountain, deciding not to have children is light as a feather".

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by juniperplant on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:08AM (#33271687)
I find it arrogant to force a human being to life, especially at this time. I question everyday the fact that somebody else decided for me that life is somewhat worth living.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by dmbche on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:13AM (#33272639)
Well, if you believe that life is worth being experienced as it's pretty unique as far as experiences goes, it's normal to expect to be okay with giving that to your child isn't it? I think most people think of life as a net positive.

There's a song where I'm from with a funny line about that - Life is short, but it's long in small stretches.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ciphol on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:15AM (#33261669)
When I was a teenager I thought kids were a pyramid scheme. If your life isn't worthwhile, then what point is there in creating another life whose worth will be equally questionable? This sounds like your "scapegoat for meaning of life" idea.

What I eventually gradually realized was that the kid might just be another person, but you're not just creating a person, you're also creating a relationship with that person. And it's a unique kind of relationship, in some ways more intimate than any relationship you can have with anyone else including your romantic partner. (Which adult runs with beaming face to hug you whenever they see you come home from work and you know it's all totally genuine?) I'm not an expert on what has objective meaning in life, but I'm pretty sure that deep relationships like this are one of the stronger candidates.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by HideousKojima on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:17AM (#33261684)
>I have the opposite though: perhaps I need to not to have kids to stop the cycle of creating meaning through procreation.

You won't stop the cycle though, others who do actually have kids will simply continue it, and the single biggest way in which you could have had and influence on the future of the world and the human race will have been eliminated.

And that's before you get into any religious implications of having and raising children.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by skinnymuch on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:02AM (#33263253)
Being wealthy or powerful probably has more influence on the world and humans than having kids.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by HideousKojima on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:43AM (#33263847)
Nonsense, on a long enough timescale your descendents will intermarry with other people, and the wealthy and powerful of future generations will be your descendents. Dave Thomas may have had a major influence on the US with his restaurants and charitable foundations, but if he had never been born in the first place he wouldn't have been able to accomplish any of that. I chose Thomas as an example because he's a literal orphan and his adoptive family wasn't particularly wealthy either as far as I can tell.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by skinnymuch on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:39PM (#33264662)
I agree maybe that’ll happen. Maybe it won’t. OTOH, as society is now, being rich and/or powerful can definitely influence things and almost all influences of society happen by the rich and powerful.

In my pov, saying having kids is the most important way to influence the world unfortunately provides an excuse to prop up the status quo of incredibly imbalanced power and wealth structures.

It also seems a bit mean to posit having children is the way to most influence society. Not every one can responsibly and properly raise children. Or have the financial foundation

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Defitio on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:59PM (#33265718)
At least I would stop it for my gen pool.

I'm not responsible for potential suffering of others.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by saiya-jin on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:50AM (#33260758)
Well, I was into that rock climbing, and, alpinism, ski touring, diving, paragliding, various expeditions and god knows what else.

It can fill up your life, and if you have good close friends it may be enough to feel long term OK and have amazing moments, which I kinda was. In fact, I've spent all my 30s like that, and backpacking around the world. I needed that, I felt I needed that back then, and when looking in retrospect it was right emotion, it made me a more complete human being (and later better parent too). Some can get there without, I couldn't, didn't have the right environment for it when growing up. This worked very well even when married, my wife complements me well in this (we met on a climbing session so that part was covered).

And then kids came, one just before covid and one during. I clinged to that climbing (with buddy) a bit, that was my escape for few hours a week into easy good times that were. Then I had this year injury of wrist, and then broken foot (all in civil setting, ie falling down the stairs in kindergarten) and I lost it all, and I blamed kids internally. I was depressed a bit. My sleep for past year was never, ever uninterrupted, good 8 hours (those damned teeth, how could evolution fucked up so badly? any animal with this trait would simply die out over few generations). That normal sleep is just gone, and I am mentally at maybe 70% at better days, more irritable, less patient.

But the thing is, kids bring up the hardest moments just as much as the best moments of your life. And we humans generally are OK with suffering quite a bit for those few nice moments. Kids bring tons of those. Even when walking relative valley of the shadow now with small kids (diapers, various naps during day that block anything bigger, teeth and lack of sleep), without cheaping out and outsourcing many troubles to nanny (or grandparents), they are amazing to watch, to experience. They love you back, unconditionally (for now), and it just feels natural to continue what all generations since ever did. It had been a rough year, few folks died in close family, and when my grandpa died 2 days ago, hugging my kids made it much much much more bearable.

I am pretty darn sure that skipping kids would be by far the biggest regret of my life later, met quite a few older folks like that. No need to always do the mistake to realize others were right again. But - if one has some serious mental issue which make them unable to be a stable partner and caretaker, then it should definitely be avoided. Too many sad stories out there already.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ChaitanyaSai on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:16AM (#33258035)
"Brunch is not life." This phrase is going to stick with me.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by obruchez on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:08AM (#33259085)
I don't know what it's supposed to mean, though. I like brunches. My son likes them as well.

I mean: any part of life is not life. Kids are not life.

Or am I missing something?

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ChaitanyaSai on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:37AM (#33259276)
I take brunch and life to be stand-ins for two notions. Brunch as the ability and desire to wish for a lazy day spent as one wishes, desultory consumption of something nice and/or new while in control of our time. Life is the sum-total of all meaning we accrue along the way, including our experiences from events we are thrust into.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by McBeige on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:34AM (#33260106)
It's lightness and weight, as in Kundera's 'Unbearable Lightness of Being'.

Lightness is nice, it's comfortable, but vertigo inducing. So we also long for weight sometimes.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by watwut on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:26AM (#33258430)
> realizing at the end of it that all three weekends were exactly the same. Nothing new happens. You're not missing anything if you just stay home.

To be honest, I felt exactly like that when kids were small, especially when being at home with them. Every day same as one before, with only minor variation. Going for vacations meant doing exactly same things as at home, except in harder setup. Nothing ever ever happens either. And plus, you are isolated from other adults, falling into depression and loosing ability to socialize.

Genuinely, I am glad I have kids. But I am so glad that period ended.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by novok on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:16AM (#33259153)
IMO that adult isolation is a bit of a choice. What I've seen happen is other parents socialize with other parents with kids of a similar age. Two moms who both have babies visit each other and hang out, etc.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by watwut on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:24AM (#33260503)
> What I've seen happen is other parents socialize with other parents with kids of a similar age. Two moms who both have babies visit each other and hang out, etc.

That does not make isolation choice. That makes some people finding friends despite suddenly seriously limited pool of options. You are starting from zero, not knowing anyone and loosing both actual existing friends and actual related hobbies. The only thing you have in common with most of those people is the similar age kid.

You need to be seriously extroverted to be able to create friendship out of nothing after you have seen each other twice on playground while also supervising the toddler. People here complain about loneliness while having incredibly easy situation compared to that, seriously.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by BeFlatXIII on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:42AM (#33260685)
My parents tried that and were fairly lonely during the early childhood years. They hated trading inane poop stories with other parents and longed to return to real adult conversations. If they wanted to discuss the specifics of child-rearing, they’d talk to each other or ask their own parents for advice.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by novok on Thursday October 20, 2022 @12:30AM (#33270830)
You don't just have to talk about the kids, you can talk about other things? One thing I've noticed from the other side is my friends that got kids, it's hard to just visit, hang out and have some lunch even, even if we get it delivered.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by bluecalm on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:07AM (#33258681)
If you try to build your life around brunch (or bars or camping trips) then it's not a surprise getting some structure and something to care about makes you happier. Many people find happiness having kids but there is no denying other life pursuits will suffer.

There is less time and less energy no matter how you cut it. The priorities will change as well as they should - why have kids if they are not very important part of your life.

Someone with less time, less energy and different things to prioritize will never get as far in creative pursuits, business, sports, scientific research. It's fine but it's a trade-off. Don't pretend the child free option is just a bar night or brunch with friends. If it is, you really haven't even started figuring it out.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Ayesh on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:27AM (#33258811)
I turned 30 last month, and I gotta say I can totally see how easy it is to fall into the state you mentioned.

I can already see through getting wasted on weekends with friends, hikes, trips, etc that seem to "normalize" as I age.

Though, I don't see kids as the only "fix"; far from it. Perhaps it's just that we get saturated from experiences, and how much new things we can experience is limited by where we live, expendable income, physical fitness, etc. So it's natural to not have the same level of novelty in experiences.

In the same vein, my uneducated and inexperienced guess is that raising the third or fourth kid wouldn't feel as much as mentally rewarding as the first kid or two.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by poisonarena on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:09AM (#33259478)
37, almost 38 and no kids, doing what you are describing right now all over the world, and it is absolutely amazing. I think your depression and feeling of everything being overrated is a you thing, and not everyone feels that way. This has been the best decade of my life and I have been poor the whole time, just hustling and making things work how i can with jobs and money and exploring the world and the people
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by saiya-jin on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:00AM (#33260858)
Been there, done that (and tons of adrenaline/extreme sports on top of that), it feels amazing when you discover it and few more years, but novelty wears off a bit eventually. Had kids, and those years brought some nice memories and personal growth, but otherwise they were shallow.

There is no more depth in life than raising kids properly, the good and bad combined. If you are up to it.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Shocka1 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:24AM (#33263575)
I'd agree with you. As a sidenote, I held an American professional Superbike racing license through most of my 20s and did a whole bunch of crazy stuff I won't mention here on top of it. Watched several people die and get maimed in one of the many races I competed in. Before that I spent some time in the Marines, including time in a warzone. I have a few regrets from a couple bad decisions I made, but I enjoyed every moment of that absolutely crazy life and never felt more alive looking back at it. It seems like an old dream I had at this point - In my 30s I slowed down, got married and had children. It's much different than my previous life, but it's been a wonderful and powerful experience as well. I feel like I've had my cake and ate it too, and you bet ya I feel blessed every single day to be here taking my share of fresh air.

It would be interesting to see my thoughts if I had never had kids, but I feel as though it would be positive either way because I choose it to be.

That being said, I do feel personally like there is more to life than living for yourself. Whether that transfers to having kids or volunteering somewhere to help others, etc., I'll leave that decision to the reader.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:22AM (#33259567)
> If it makes you feel any better I delayed having kids and spent my 30s dating and hanging out and going to bars – and it was terrible.

I didn’t have kids until my 40s – didn’t delay, it just worked out that way – after getting married in my late 20s, spending…very little time dating or hanging out in bars, and it was wonderful. So was having kids. And once I had them, I certainly wouldn’t have minded having more of the energy of youth with them, but I also don’t mind the life experience that I had first.

> I had a nice career and could go anywhere and do anything I wanted, but it turns out none of that made me even a little bit happy. […] Happiness is extremely overrated.

Happiness isn’t overrated; as you yourself explicitly note, you didn’t find it and were miserable because of that.

> Now I’m tired and busy and I don’t go out and do “fun” stuff very often, but I’m much more satisfied. My biggest regret is that I waited so long to start my life. Brunch isn’t life.

Brunch (both literally and, as I understand the use, metaphorically) very much is life (not all of life, but, in its slice, as much “life” as anything else), for many people.

So can kids be, for many people.

So is anything you have a passion for, whether its the activity, or the companions, or the mission motivating the activity. (Bonus if it is a combination of all of those.)

Doing things merely because you’ve got the idea that it is socially expected that they will provide happiness, though, usually isn’t going to be it.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by hhmc on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:27AM (#33259604)
> Happiness is extremely overrated

This seems like a strange conclusion to draw, it doesn’t sound like you were happy

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by fossuser on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:57AM (#33260278)
Somewhat disputing definitions - he’s talking about the low stakes idle hedonistic “happiness” from commonly thought of as pleasurable things (brunch, camping, food/drinks with friends, etc.) vs. the type of more difficult stuff that while maybe less pleasant in the day to day moment is often more fulfilling over longer time horizons. Not worth arguing about the word meaning rather than just taking the underlying argument for what it is (imo).

One take away I had from Tim Kreider’s “I Wrote This Book Because I Love You” was that everyone he met who was older and unmarried had a certain aloofness about them or continued search for meaning. This largely wasn’t present in those that had families. We have a strongly selected source of fulfillment baked in as part of the human experience, it may not be for everyone but it’s probably not something that should be dismissed lightly.

Looking at old people and what they regret (and what they value) at the end of their life can be a way to help make fulfilling life decisions, or at least try to steer things in that direction.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by hhmc on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:58PM (#33264918)
> he’s talking about the low stakes idle hedonistic “happiness” from commonly thought of as pleasurable things (brunch, camping, food/drinks with friends, etc.)

But it doesn't sound like they were happy even by this definition..

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by dionidium on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:02PM (#33265743)
This is a mistake in my original comment above. My first use of "happy" should have been replaced with "satisfied" or "fulfilled." My sloppiness confused the message a bit.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by erfgh on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:30AM (#33260578)
I don't really believe happiness exists without kids. Happiness can exist when you are a kid and it can exist when you have kids. It cannot exist otherwise. You can be satisfied at any point of your life, with or without kids, but you can never be happy.

I remember being happy --- I was a kid. I remember when it stopped --- gradually when I became a teenager and completely when I became an adult. I had a career, I had money, more than I could spend. I had a loving wife, better wife than I ever expected to have. I lived in a free country. I was passionately interested in a myriad of subjects: Films, books, sports, programming, science, I had a lot of hobbies, never stopped being busy. All those hobbies I had since I was a kid. But I realized that I don't see them the same way I saw them when I was a kid.

Sports, I hated long-distance running as a kid, found it tedious and grueling. As an adult, I would run and run and run, run through pain, through exhaustion, became sick with over-training, developed anemia, had multiple injuries, had pain almost every day, ran through injuries because I didn't want to lose fitness, reached almost 20 BMI, was frail and weak. What for? Nobody cared, not even me. It was just an obsession, looking for something that wasn't there.

Science, it was no longer the wonderful curiosity-satisfying endeavor that it was when I was a kid. It had become stressful research, anxiety to learn as much as possible, guilt and feeling of worthlessness when I couldn't really understand something after studying it for a period of time.

Films, I would watch 100-150 per year. Had a film-club subscription and watched pretty much everything they put on. Went to film festivals and watched 30+ films in a week. Watched something at home regularly. When you watch so many films they become tedious and you hate 90% of what you watch but I had to keep doing it because, what else would I do with all the free time I had?

I realized that there's nothing wrong with all those activities, what's wrong is what I expected from them. I wanted too much from them. I wanted them to give meaning to my life which was at a point when no meaning could be extracted by such activities.

And then I had kids. It was stressful, yes, it was tiring, yes, but oh boy --- no doubt about it, I was happy. I wanted to run out on the streets screaming from my happiness. I could not get angry any more. Everything that happened to me I just smiled and went on. And 6 years later I miss every time I awoke at night, every time I held them screaming. I am absolutely and positively sure that there can be no greater happiness in this world than the one I felt back then. I realize that I can have another kid now but it won't be the same.

And it all feels like it was one second ago. It all passed me by in an instant. Now my kids are old enough to do almost everything by themselves. Soon they will know how to read. I now do all the activities I mentioned above. But no obsession. I run enough to stay fit. I started weight-training which made me feel and look better than ever. I study science with a smile and with an understanding that I will never understand everything.

Everything has meaning now.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by parthianshotgun on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:57PM (#33267212)
I think you are trying to fit the narrative to your own bias and experience. Tolstoy thought the opposite, to offer a countervailing outlook. > I cannot now help seeing day and night going round and bringing me to death. That is all I see, for that alone is true. All else is false. The two drops of honey which diverted my eyes from the cruel truth longer than the rest: my love of family, and of writing -- art as I called it -- were no longer sweet to me. Tolstoy

Now, as to how he dealt with this angst, that's a story for another time

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by fn1 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:00AM (#33257913)
> Weekends are just chaos...

It is normal that kids take up all your time, but "just chaos" doesn't sound right.

Without knowing your situation, maybe this helps: As you probably know first there was authoritarian parenting (rule the kids), then permissive parenting (let them do whatever they want), both of which create problems for the children.

The parenting-style agreed upon today by psychologists is "authoritative parenting", which basically means telling the kids what you want them to do, but giving them a lenient timeframe and freedom to chose how and when they do it. It raises their self-esteem and encourages them to work together with you.

https://www.healthline.com/health/parenting/types-of-parenti...

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by riffraff on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:02AM (#33257931)
> As for enjoying hanging around with kids.... I don't know what age that starts, but I'm 5 years and counting.

My kids are 6 and 8 and I have enjoyed spending time with them since they were little. I do get tired and want to be alone after a while tho.

I think we should just accept the fact that some people enjoy children and some don't.

It makes sense, some people like ballet some outdoor activities some videogames, there's no reason to expect kids would be different.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by lhball on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:19AM (#33258051)
> I just don't have any time for any of my hobbies any more

Exactly this. I have 2 under six, and outside the odd night were my wife bathes both kids, from 6am to 9pm I’m either working or hanging out with my kids. Maybe 2-3 times a month I’ll get 4 hours to myself to go watch a baseball/hockey game.

At the end of the day though, I look back and I’m grateful. I tell myself “where did my hobbies go” but deep down I know I probably would have spent that time watching a 3 hour super smash brothers documentary or re-reading LOTR or something stupid like that.

Kids have made me more focused. Their unconditional needs force me to weed out the time wasting, unimportant things in my life. I honestly sometimes wonder how it ever felt like I was busy before.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by mingusrude on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:22AM (#33258414)
When we had kids I realized that I had to get new hobbies because I wouldn't be able to keep doing the old ones. I pretty much decided that cooking and looking after house plants were going to be be my new hobbies since I knew that I would actually have time for it because of necessity (well maybe not the plants). It worked out OK, I still enjoy cooking a lot.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Xixi on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:02AM (#33258319)
Parent wrote "The sleepless nights and diaper changes are a mere blip on the scale of a lifetime with kids." You still pretty much in the middle of that blip. It is exhausting. When your kids are getting closer to 10, you will have a very different perspective. And you will have as much time as you want to enjoy hobbies, going out, etc.

Source: I have a 12yo at home.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by radicalbyte on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:01AM (#33258641)
> haven't had any time for myself until the kids are down at 7.30

I have three kids (3, 6, 9) and we don't get to sit down without kids until around 22:00 on average. Sometimes it's quiet at 20:00 (the youngest two asleep), sometimes at 00:30.

We have no life outside of work and kids. It should eventually get better though, as soon as the youngest two start being able to sleep themselves.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ssss11 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:25AM (#33258799)
I’m kind of in the same boat as you, but I don’t think it’ll last forever. We’ll get some personal time back, but in the meantime hang in there.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by TomK32 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:42AM (#33258928)
Sounds like you are the breadwinner, have you thought about the financial feasibility of taking an afternoon off, at least until the kids are at school and a lot more independent?

One hobby I picked up when my kid was about three was crochet (men can do it just fine), so we spent afternoons at the playground, she playing with other children while I did crochet e.g. a hobby horse.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ckdarby on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:12AM (#33259493)
Have you had your blood checked in the last year? You could very well have a vitamin D deficiency which will explain the exhaustion.

It's hard to have empathy, because my weeks are 70-80 hours every week and I honestly still feel like I have plenty of down time.

In terms of time you have the time based on your profile. Plenty of time spent on HN. You're also gaining the equivalent of work+commute every Saturday & Sunday.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by flurdy on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:23AM (#33259570)
>> 3) You actually like hanging out with your own kids.

> I don't know what age that starts, but I'm 5 years and counting.

I hope it kicks in soon. I love spending time with my kids. They are 8 & 11 now. Sure they can be annoying and nag each other. And as they get older more viscous arguing...

But still I look forward to go for walks with them or have a little minecraft session together, or just some simple lego. Or just fixing/building things together around the house, inside or out. Sometimes not or just for short periods. But I look forward to the next time.

I have taken a lot of time off on purpose (weeks and sometimes months between contracts) to spend as much time with them as possible whilst they are young. And worked a lot from home (before we all had to) so that I could do school runs and see them during the day.

Still they get super excited to spend time with me on anything. But my oldest is now 11 and I can feel she soon will prefer hanging out with her friends and not her embarrassing dad.

But I agree, weekdays when I am working full time it is still knackering. I dream of them all being in bed at 7.30. And spending time with and looking after my kids means I have no time for friends or most of my hobbies at weekends.

Though as the older one may soon want to spend less time with her dad that also means she require less of my supervision as she goes to clubs and sports after school, and organises her time herself more independently.

So I may soon have time for hobbies again. Mid-life crisis here I come.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by nickd2001 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:54AM (#33259792)
Are you exhausted from the kids, or because your job exhausts you too much to have energy left for them? In which case change jobs? Sure kids are tiring, temperamental, they go completely hyper, argue incessantly about stuff, don't get ready to go out when asked, don't go to sleep then are tired and fractious next day, change their mind about what they want to do when you made a big effort for them, fight with each other (as well as being very nice and caring to each other next minute) etc etc. But they're delightful, and funny, and super companions at the same time. As for hobbies, as others have said, finding hobbies you can do with your kids is good. The great outdoors and music making can be shared at a young age, if they're into that. I found even reading them stories, as they get older the books get more interesting, many kids books are actually fascinating for adults.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by icare_1er on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:08AM (#33259913)
Kind of makes me anxious about having kids but I have also heard, on the other end, senior people expressing how gloomy it feels to not have kids. And unlike the tiredness of having kids, that anxiety only grows forever till the day you die and all you leave behind is a nice car.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by p2detar on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:26AM (#33260035)
My algorithmic approach has always been:

1. You’re 100% sure you don’t want kids? Then don’t.

2. In all other cases, have a child. Even when in doubt.

Years will pass and doubt may perish, but with it also the ability to have children.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by texasbigdata on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:08AM (#33260372)
This seems like the most inhumane way to make the decision discussed, even if you're not necessarily wrong for taking this approach. I can't imagine what it'd be like being a small child in a household where your parents "had doubt" and turns out they didn't really want you after all. You can't fake it well enough for 18 years where they wouldn't notice. Just sad imho
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by cliftonk on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:41AM (#33260149)
I have two kids under two. It's tough, but i dont personally know any parents that don't have a ton of fun with their kids. I love spending time with my 2 year-old. We have tons of fun together (like many 2 year olds, outside activities are a must). I'd rather be with him than any of my friends or other family and wouldn't trade it for the world.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by danielrpa on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:43AM (#33260165)
The best phase is about to begin, and the worst of child raising is behind you. It will never be easy, but IMHO older kids are a lot more fun, clever and interactive.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ybalkind on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:01AM (#33260313)
My experience of having kids is very similar to yours. But I will say that I'm starting to see light at the end of the tunnel. My kids are now 8 and 4, no more diapers or waking up at night. My wife and I are getting better at managing parenting responsibilities and lifts. My life is getting more balanced again. And I'm feeling a shift closer to what the comment above yours describes, although I'm not entirely there yet. To be fair though we have 4 grandparents to help plus a nannie so not representative of most people.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by sgt101 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:52AM (#33260776)
The big change for me was year 6.. so hang in there friend.

When they are 6 they become much more self contained, they don't need constant entertaining. They will leave you alone, without being asked, for hours at a time to do what they want to.

You have 2 so you will have a bit of a longer spell, but after 6 you enter into the high summer of their childhood. They are small enough not to have any real problems (apart from, god forbid, medical ones) but they are big enough to give you time and space to breath.

I hear your pain. But it will be worth it, and it will improve.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by trident5000 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:08AM (#33260937)
Dont have kids if you're poor.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by ttcbj on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:25AM (#33261103)
It is exhausting. My kids are 9 and 11. It’s different, but still all consuming.

Still, I think it is very hard for anyone to predict what some one else’s experience will be having kids. It depends on the kids temperament, yours, your spouses, how your relationship works, What the expectations are in your community, and so much more.

The older I get, especially now that I see my parents really aging, the more I see life is just complicated. Kids or not, you have to find happiness where you can, and accept that sometimes things are imperfect.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by the_other on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:31AM (#33261167)
> I don't think I'm necessarily having the same experience as you.... my advice to people who aren't sure if they want kids, is DON'T. It's bloody hard, you sacrifice A LOT. Don't have kids unless you're very sure it's what you want.

That's one perspective. I wasn't ready for kids but had one anyway. It's worked out fairly well. My kid rocks and we have a lot of fun.

> have 2 kids under 6 and I feel like I just don't have any time for any of my hobbies any more. I leave for work first thing, come home in the afternoon, and haven't had any time for myself until the kids are down at 7.30, and I'm utterly wasted.

I have one and I started to get back into hobbies around their age 7. So I would imagine having two slows that process down a bit. I'm pretty sure you'll get some time back, but you might need to stick it out a couple more years. If you can, tweak your hobbies to include them a bit (obviously it depends on the hobby) - mine really liked synths for a couple of years: that was great fun :-D.

Something that hit me hard recently was that when I do my hobbies & socialising, I do them away from my family. This now looks like a mistake. I think I should have worked harder to have kid-compatible friends and hobbies over the last couple of years. I'm aiming to do more more activity stuff (camping, surfing etc) with mine over the next couple of years. Deeper into their teens, they wont want to hang out with me much so I need to get it done now.

> As for enjoying hanging around with kids

It's really hard. You've got to get into undirected play yourself. I didn't do this enough.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by _jss on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:39AM (#33261240)
I didn't genuinely enjoy parenting until my kids were all above 6, and it was gradual. My kids are 16 and 14 now, and at the start of their summer break I left a job I really liked to spend as much time as I could with them. Their problems were more thought provoking and time intensive, navigating tough tradeoffs. I love helping them through these moments, teaching critical thinking, and we still have fun doing things.

When they were younger, I tried to find some longer focal point and figure out what my role and goals were as a parent. I found that, and it helped relieve some of the repetitive stress of parenting young kids.

I don't know the source for the "75% of the time we spent with our kids happens before age 12" but I hope it isn't true. Kids are inexperienced people, and experience cultivates interesting people. I also believe an hour spent with a glassy eyed baby barely counts compared to a thoughtful, focused 15 minute discussion with a teenager.

I hope you find your groove. It took me a while.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by stormdennis on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:51AM (#33261377)
To cap it all you'll feel guilty for feeling this way in later years when they're gone.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by mherdeg on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:01AM (#33261503)
Do you think your own parents felt this way?
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by lee on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:02AM (#33261520)
My kids are older now (10 and 13) and I really enjoy these years than when they were younger whereas my wife really enjoyed them more in the earlier years.

That period of enjoyment really varies between individuals, and I think in the aggregate men tend to enjoy hanging out with older kids compared to women. There was also a moment when I shifted my own personal attitude towards spending time with them that made it more enjoyable. Instead of seeing time with them as a time-suck where I could be doing something else, I saw it as fleeting moments that I could never get back when they're older. I became more grateful for the time I had with them.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by Shocka1 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @10:54AM (#33263125)
I would agree mostly, but this comment a little on the extreme side IMO. You sound miserable.

I can relate as this is exactly how I felt the first 6 months of the first child we had - they are between 4 and 7 now. I was and still am a pretty selfish person with lots of hobbies, but most of them had to go to the backburner for the time being. Once I was able to get over myself things started going a lot smoother.

Of course there are times I wish I could be mountain biking, fishing, etc., instead of one of the many tasks that involve children, but I find myself looking forward to spending time with them these days. They are getting to the age where I'm starting to take them with me to enjoy the things I love as well. I imagine this will get higher in frequency as they get older.

From one selfish person to another, hang in there.

Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by imetatroll on Thursday October 20, 2022 @09:50AM (#33274672)
Life was pretty vapid in a deeper sense until I had children so I have to disagree with you. It is a challenge but is the only challenge that I have experienced in my life that truly feels worthwhile.
Re:75% of the time we spend with our kids in our lifetime wi... by joshuahedlund on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:58AM (#33317551)
> I have 2 kids under 6 and I feel like I just don't have any time for any of my hobbies any more

I remember feeling like this when I had 2 kids under 6. Now they are both slightly past 6 and I feel everything the parent comment said about how brief that time was - they are in school most of the day, when they are home they spend at least some time playing Legos, watching shows, playing Minecraft, reading books. I have more time for hobbies than I've had in years. They are even starting to be old enough to accompany me on some of my hobbies. The reversal is so stark it's hard for me to comprehend how long it felt at the time and how short it looks now.