News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by gwern on Friday August 05, 2022 @02:57PM (#32360386)
"The fallout of the MoFi revelation has thrown the audiophile community into something of an existential crisis. The quality of digitized music has long been criticized because of how much data was stripped out of files so MP3s could fit on mobile devices. But these days, with the right equipment, digital recordings can be so good they can fool even the best ears. Many of MoFi’s now-exposed records were on Fremer and Esposito’s own lists of the best sounding analog albums...“One of the reasons they want to excoriate MoFi is for lying,” says Howarth. “The other part that bothers them is that they’ve been listening to digital all along and they’re highly invested in believing that any digital step will destroy their experience. And they’re wrong.”...And Randy Braun, a music lover, Hoffman message board member and lawyer in New York, hopes that, in the end, the MoFi revelation will prove what he’s been saying for years, that the anti-digital crowd has been lying to itself: “These people who claim they have golden ears and can hear the difference between analog and digital, well, it turns out you couldn’t.”"

Hard to imagine a better A/A-test.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:09PM (#32360556)
That whole line of thinking just blows me away. It's possible to accurately sample and reproduce any vinyl recording in the digital realm. It's absolutely not possible to accurately record every digital recording onto vinyl. For instance, it's not hard at all to make bass so loud that it causes the needle to leap out of the track, or treble so high that the needle can't accurately track the high frequency vibrations.

In fact, part of the record player spec is the "RIAA equalization"[0] that attempts to account for the fact that vinyl isn't good at recording a wide range of frequencies well. On recording, you cut the bass and jack up the treble. On playback, you boost the bass and reduce the treble. Without that, vinyl would be even worse than it is today.

It's absolutely, 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD. I don't, but that's fine: it's purely a preference thing. But to claim that vinyl is objectively better in some way is just ludicrous.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RIAA_equalization

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by ryukoposting on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:22PM (#32361525)
I absolutely despise most of the vinyl community. Don't get me wrong, I love my records. I have hundreds of them and I play them regularly. For some reason, almost everyone I come by has this delusion that vinyl is objectively better than a good digital recording. Anyone who dissents from that narrative gets gaslit:

"oh what kind of turntable do you have? oh that's not good enough, there's your problem right there."

"what speakers do you have? what about your phono + power amps? oh that's not good enough, there's your problem right there."

"how did you place your speakers? oh, you should have them at 45 degrees, not 60."

"is it a re-pressing? from whom? oh, there's your problem right there."

The end result is a bunch of nerds ruining their credit scores because someone told them they need gold-plated hydraulic bearings in their tonearm to properly listen to their mom's copy of Led Zeppelin IV.

Does it sound different? Yes. Does it sound better? If you're really trying to get the most out of the music itself, no. Warm ⊄ good.

Vinyl is great because you aren't just listening to music. The medium demands something from you. It's tactile. The album artwork is a complete ensemble, rather than a little icon on your phone. In my case, I had to put in effort to restore the equipment I play my records on, so there's a bit of pride in it. It's a more intimate experience.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by JJMcJ on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:57PM (#32362429)
I remember when CDs were very very new the first review of them in an audiophile magazine a friend subscribed to. The reviewer was quite unhappy.

The next month he reviewed a different player. He basically retracted his opinion of CDs but said the player from the previous month was obviously terrible, at least the particular one that he did his review on, if not the entire brand.

And for audiophiles themselves, I notice many of them seem to have very poor taste in music. Like do you really need $50,000 of equipment and sand weighted speakers that weigh 700 pounds each to play 1968 bachelor pad music?

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by CamperBob2 on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:06PM (#32364433)
The next month he reviewed a different player. He basically retracted his opinion of CDs but said the player from the previous month was obviously terrible, at least the particular one that he did his review on, if not the entire brand.

He could have been right both times. Many early CDs were just plain awful. Same with the first couple of generations of CD players, even some pricy ones. The early development of MP3 and other lossy audio codecs recapitulated the history of digital audio pretty well: lots of truly crappy recordings got passed around.

Like do you really need $50,000 of equipment and sand weighted speakers that weigh 700 pounds each to play 1968 bachelor pad music?

I've never understood audiophiles. How can it make sense for me to spend more money on my equipment than the freaking recording studio spent on theirs? Do these people think studios use $10,000 power cords on their sound boards, and atomic clocks to drive their ADCs?

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by gerdesj on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:27PM (#32362701)
"I notice many of them seem to have very poor taste in music."

Great response and critique until that point. I'm old (52) enough to have seen quite a few media changes too. I recall that when you were off your tits at a party, and discussing music, you tried to find common ground. That could lead to some impressive contortions!

Can't say I ever spent much on playback hardware. I generally went second hand for speakers/amps etc. Once the Walkman was invented and then rather a lot of Chinese (and other copies were available) clones appeared then you could ruin your hearing close up with seriously decent quality sound on the move. I was still walking around with a mini cassette player with wired ear plugs in my jacket's breast pocket until around 1993ish.

I did lay out something like £200 on a pair of decent headphones for use at home. They make anything from O Fortuna to Ghost Town via say Schehehererherereherezade, Finlandia and One sound rather ... Special.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by JJMcJ on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:35PM (#32403036)
The term "audiophile" describes someone who indeed spends huge amounts on their audio setup.

It is different than someone who appreciates music, which it seems like you do.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:10PM (#32363818)
I will have you know I have great taste in total harmonic distortion and frequency response!
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by drewzero1 on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:54PM (#32364076)
I love records (78s and vinyl) for the tactile and visual experience-- and the fact that I can get something for a few bucks at the thrift store and not feel too bad about my toddler ruining it trying to put the needle on. To that end I have stuck to cheap, sturdy, school-grade equipment and mostly secondhand records.

It's so fascinating to me that an inert physical disc is engraved with sound waves that are reproduced by dragging something along to return them to sound, in the case of the 78s without the need for anything electrical in between. It's an added bonus that it has zero opportunity to inspire screen time for my kid, who absolutely doesn't need to stare at a screen while listening to music.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Animats on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:17AM (#32365436)
in the case of the 78s without the need for anything electrical in between.

For fully mechanically recorded records you have to go back to pre-1927 Edison Diamond Disks. Or the real deal, Edison cylinders.

Edison cylinders are actually rather good recordings. The mechanical playback system. with no amplifier, introduced most of the distortion. Modern playbacks, using a modern record pickup with a suitably large-sized stylus, are quite good. Here are some from cylinders made around 1900.[1] Those include Sousa's band playing Sousa's marches, led by Sousa himself.

The ultimate playback device is IRENE. This was built for the Library of Congress. It does a full 3D scan of the entire disk or cylinder surface, and a detailed 3D model of the surface is created. That's turned into audio by a program that simulates a stylus tracking through the grooves. IRENE is used on very old, fragile items. It's even possible to put broken shards back together in 3D and recover the audio.

For real authenticity, there are reproducing pianos. These are player pianos, but with a better recording system, one capable of recording key pressure while a live pianist played the piano. While the Duo-Art system had binary-coded pressure values, the Welte-Mignon system was analog. Mostly. Here's a Welte-Mignon roll being played.[2] The holes at the outer edges of the roll are encoding the key pressure. The ones in the middle indicate which keys. MIDI, from over a century ago.

If you're going to go retro, go all the way. If you just want to listen to music, it doesn't get any better than 24 bit audio. (16 bits may not be enough for really soft passages, where all the high bits are zero and you may be down to 6 bit audio.)

[1] https://www.nps.gov/edis/learn/photosmultimedia/recordings.h...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8K5Yh0aLhA

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by drewzero1 on Saturday August 13, 2022 @11:06PM (#32455986)
I do have one of those Edison diamond disks in my collection, though no playback device that can handle the vertical signal in the groove. My ~1917 Silvertone phonograph does fine for me with the more conventional 78s.

My grandpa used to tell me that they donated the clockwork out of their record player as scrap metal for the war effort, so they listened to music by spinning the records by hand and holding a fingernail in the groove. That's something you can't do with pretty much any other recorded medium, aside from print.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jgust on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:49PM (#32362367)
There is a certain ceremony involved with choosing and playing vinyl that cannot be recreated with digital media. That, to me, is the magic. In modern times a full digital setup is going to provide a more "faithful recreation" than anything analog.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by gerdesj on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:40PM (#32362794)
Been there. Browsing vinyl involves flipping fore and aft and is very tactile. Browsing tape and CDROM involves running your eyes over them but you can run a finger along them to get another sense involved.

Loading a record is quite the event: slip out of the card sleeve, then slip the dic out of the waxed paper sleeve and pop it on the spindle without scratching it. There is of course the correct way to handle them that if you are around or older than my age (52), you already know - the delicate fingers on the rim and your thumb on the centre.

I can remember my Dad going to the "biggest NAAFI in the world" (Rheindahlen) and coming back with a brand new record player in around 1978 or 79. This thing could handle something like five LPs at once and play them sequentially.

Pissing around with Spotify isn't quite the same and I do understand why people enjoy the theatrics but to be honest: I turned my CDs into FLACs and ditched the tapes a long time ago. I still prefer to buy my music by the CDROM and rip it to FLAC or mp3 or whatever - now that is me showing my age!

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by throwaway81523 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @12:05AM (#32364730)
I used to just look at the titles on the spines of my records (back when I had them) to decide what to play. I'd look at one and listen to the music in my head for a few minutes before deciding whether to actually put the record on, or else look at the spine of another record and do the same thing. I could spend hours doing that, and by that time I had to go do something else. I got a whole concert with no equipment at all. That's when I decided I wasn't an audiophile.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jamiek88 on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:15PM (#32363021)
I did the same as you but iTunes Match for $25 per year is my ‘vault’.

It’s very convenient especially now that lossless is an option.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by macintux on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:32AM (#32365131)
I have a few songs ripped from CDs over the years that I’ll be very unhappy to lose if iTunes Match ever goes away, since I’ve lost the CDs and as far as I know they simply aren’t online. Such a great service.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jamiek88 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @11:23AM (#32368901)
Same. A couple of the cds ‘rusted’ and no longer play. Others lost in moves etc.

I hope we get plenty of warning before they axe it. Imagine that being a google service?!

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by sneak on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:17PM (#32369855)
If your Apple ID gets accidentally suspended because of a false positive from the "can't turn it off" clientside CP local file scanning that Apple is planning to roll out to all of our devices, you won't get any warning.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by macintux on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:12PM (#32370310)
Can we not flog this dead horse?
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jamiek88 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:54PM (#32370177)
You mean the hash search.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by JJMcJ on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:53PM (#32362393)
There is also some with CDs, but vinyl's the real deal. The record cleaner brush. Inspect the needle for dust. Be sure the record is properly seated. Sit back and enjoy.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jgust on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:53PM (#32362403)
Just watching the record spin is so incredibly satisfying.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by JJMcJ on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:11PM (#32362554)
Yes, a connection to the physical world.

Sometimes especially on Zoom I look at my cabling and think it's amazing that images of other people and their voices are going through that cable.

Only on Zoom and similar video conferencing. For all other uses I don't even think about it.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by crooked-v on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:02PM (#32363778)
You may find VR social environments interesting.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by throwaway81523 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @12:07AM (#32364745)
I'm not going to say the date but my birthday is exactly 4 months before a certain holiday. So some years back (too many, alas), on this holiday and 4 months after I turned 33, my friends put on a party to celebrate both the holiday and my 33 1/3'rd birthday. Naturally, LP records were played.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by boring_twenties on Saturday August 06, 2022 @12:18AM (#32364800)
Hopefully the night ended with a screening of the third Naked Gun movie?

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0110622/

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by throwaway81523 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:16AM (#32365033)
Damn, we didn't think of that.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kevinmchugh on Saturday August 06, 2022 @11:55PM (#32373768)
You're better off for it
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by adrian_b on Saturday August 06, 2022 @05:11AM (#32366371)
Watching the reels spinning at different rates and the tape moving on an intricate path, in a high-end open-reel tape recorder with multiple motors and multiple heads, e.g. a Revox, was even more satisfying.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by noduerme on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:28PM (#32363562)
>> The end result is a bunch of nerds ruining their credit scores

Hilarious and well put! Speaking as an erstwhile musician, this has been my theory about Guitar Center's business model since the 90s.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by hbn on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:54PM (#32362409)
I recently got a record player and have been amassing a small collection of my favourite albums. Including the reasons you gave, my excuse for buying/listening to records is I like having a physical representation of albums I like, and something that won't disappear because a contract expired with a streaming service.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by ryukoposting on Sunday August 07, 2022 @06:57PM (#32380757)
Stick with it. I discovered some great music buying random stuff from the <$5 section. You'll meet fun people at the right record stores (if you're in Minneapolis, I have some suggestions). Every once in a while one of your LPs will turn into a nice investment piece. If you haven't tried repairing/restoring your own turntable, I recommend it. The engineering inside all the little mechanisms in an old turntable are fun to tinker with.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by dekhn on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:41PM (#32362293)
There definitely was a short period in college where I needed to spend money I barely had to upgrade my system. This was when CDs first came out. I could tell, when listening through my stereo (as compared to plugging my headphones into the CD player) that there was a ton of extra noise/distortion and most importantly, a very high noise level (audible hiss). Ended up having to go to Salvation Army to buy a $25 used receiver and the speaker store to buy a pair of $200 speakers before I got decent results. Even after that, I had no end of problems with the analog cable. it took a long time to switch to digital.

Nowadays I can get excellent audio quality watching good Youtube videos or streaming from my preferred music site (I only listen through headphones now).

I'm super glad I was able to get to the quality level I liked for fairly cheap.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by xbar on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:24PM (#32362151)
Is this not the experience in every human community?

For the record, I like your approach to music enjoyment.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by iforgotpassword on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:28PM (#32360833)
That's the main reason I really like vinyl. Physics prevents the mastering engineers from going overly crazy. Vinyl often sounds more carefully mastered, even though nothing would technically prevent you from releasing the same thing in digital form.

The other thing I like is that it really takes more effort to put on a record than start a track on Spotify. I really only do it when I can take the time to do so. Pick a record from the shelf, carefully take it out of the sleeve, carefully put it down on the turntable, and then really listen to a full record while sitting or lying on the couch doing nothing else. Again nothing you couldn't do with Spotify or YouTube music, but somehow you (well, at least I) never do.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by defterGoose on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:43PM (#32361019)
It's still true that it takes a skillful ear/hand to do that mastering. I've heard terribly mastered older (not abused) records and modern releases that are excellent. A good original copy of Rumours is about as good as it gets IME.

Vinyl _does_ also provide a nice soft upper limit to the loudness wars.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by FullyFunctional on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:58PM (#32362897)
Couldn't we characterize vinyl limitations and capture that as a digital filter? And if so would you be able to tell the difference between the vinyl and filtered digital?
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by iforgotpassword on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:07AM (#32365369)
It wouldn't work with albums where the mastering is different, especially if the digital release is compressed more. You cannot undo squashed dynamic range really. A famous example from a while ago is the album stadium arcadium by the red hot chili peppers. Comparing the two versions of a song should sound notably different even to a casual listener. And you can really see the difference just looking at the wave forms.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by toast0 on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:26PM (#32364238)
The premise in this part of the thread is that the mastering engineers will not make a record that exceeds the limits of the medium, and what fits on the medium sounds nice.

Assuming this is correct, and that the digital mix intended for cds or streaming/downloads outside vinyl's range, you might be able to filter the digital mix to fit in vinyl's range and that might approximate the vinyl mix, but maybe the mastering engineer would make different choices (of course, maybe they just use a filter). It'd be interesting to explore with actual data.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:32PM (#32360873)
I listened to "Disintegration" last week exactly like that, but with Apple Music. It was the first time I'd listened to an album start-to-finish in years, and I highly recommend it.

I like not having to flip the record halfway through, or being able to listen to "The Wall" without 3 flips.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by wk_end on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:56PM (#32361880)
The structure that side/disc limitations impose is part of the listening experience, to me - I like having to take a moment to consider the sub-narrative of the side as a whole before moving on. Even when streaming I’ll often look up the vinyl track listings to get a sense of the artist’s intended schema.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by hbn on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:57PM (#32362436)
> I like having to take a moment to consider the sub-narrative of the side as a whole before moving on.

That's a great way of putting it! And something I hadn't considered before I bought a record player and started listening to it. There's that point in time where you realize the A-side is done, you get up to go and flip it, and you have a half-minute or so of reflection on the first half. Then the B-side starts and it's like the second act of a play is starting after intermission.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:01PM (#32361937)
I get it. I still like having the option to skip it if I'm being lazy.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by conradfr on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:30PM (#32361628)
That's why I like to download vinyl rips.

But some vinyls actually come from a digital master anyway.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by aeyes on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:50PM (#32361822)
Even if the master wasn't digital, how many vinyl mastering engineers used a digital reverse RIAA?

I have a ton of vinyl records myself, never understood why anyone would say they sound better. Vinyl is a compressed format, even if the compression is analog. There is significant loss of signal in the whole signal chain. You need to do reverse RIAA (compression), then you fabricate a master, then you press vinyl from this master which is only good for a few thousand presses, then you have the pickup and at last the RIAA preamp (decompression)...

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:02PM (#32361953)
Don't forget that playback progressively damages the medium. A true audiophool keeps a stockpile of virgin vinyl so they can playback once and throw it away.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jrajav on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:21PM (#32360721)
Most of the time people will argue that vinyl has "warmth" and this makes it subjectively better. This is true, but it's actually because of the pleasing distortion record players add to the music. Being distortion, even if it improves your listening experience (and this depends on genre, though it generally does), it is certainly objectively worse in terms of accurate reproduction.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bambax on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:01PM (#32361940)
YES! The article says this:

> But a few specialty houses (...) have long advocated for the warmth of analog. “Not that you can’t make good records with digital, but it just isn’t as natural as when you use the original tape,” says Bernie Grundman

which is absurd. "Warmth" is a kind of distortion, and if a signal is distorted then it's less accurate or "natural"!

They can't claim "fidelity" and "warmth" at the same time. It's one or the other.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by AnimalMuppet on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:20PM (#32362102)
But if analog is what you knew, that wasn't "distortion". That was "natural", because it was what you grew up with. That was the way things were supposed to be.

So "fidelity" means "fidelity to the way I remember" (and like).

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by yencabulator on Sunday August 07, 2022 @07:04PM (#32380801)
Not "natural", "familiar".

Just like people buying yellow lightbulbs because that's how incandescent bulbs used to always be -- actual natural sunlight isn't that yellow. Good LEDs are more "natural", but less "familiar" to people.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by tomc1985 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:29AM (#32365107)
On a high quality record with a high quality setup, you can have both. It's because the distortion is really subtle, and hits all the right harmonics. On bass-heavy music it makes the bass sound really nice. The other parts of "warmth" aren't really in my wheelhouse, but it makes the bass in bass music better
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:24PM (#32360765)
Exactly. If you like that warmth, awesome. There's not a thing wrong with that. It's when people confuse "warm" for "better" that the problems start.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by taylorportman on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:58PM (#32361227)
An instrument amplified by vacuum tubes does have a distinct sound, "vinyl" also has its own signature.. magnetic tape is pretty analog too. All of these signature sounds can be digitized/discretized at sampling rates that preserve the vinyl crackle or tube warmth or combinations. To me it seems like marketing and the consumers justification of their susceptibility.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bigiain on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:56PM (#32364092)
> An instrument amplified by vacuum tubes does have a distinct sound

Only if it’s pushed into distortion.

Guitar players (generally) like tube Amos because of the way they distort compared to transistor amps.

If you are not pushing the amps into distortion, they will only sound different if they’re badly designed.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bobbylarrybobby on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:58PM (#32364395)
Not necessarily (well I guess it depends what you mean by "pushed"), but I think tube amps naturally boost the even-numbered harmonics at all volume levels. This sounds good but is distortion.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bigiain on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:57AM (#32365656)
That’d show up in the Total Harmonic Distortion figure for the amp, and for any halfway hifi quality oriented amp it’ll be well below 0.1%. Perhaps “golden ears” can hear that? I’m not convinced. Most hifi audio amps typically run at well down into the single digit percentage of their rated output at ordinary listening levels in most systems, so they’re an order of magnitude or two away from clipping. If the feedback circuit and the output devices (transistors or tubes) can’t keep the response perfectly linear the thd down under 0.1% across the entire audio frequency band in that power range, it’s just badly designed.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by mod on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:33PM (#32360880)
Can't the warmth just be reproduced in a digital player anyway?
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by mrandish on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:18PM (#32361497)
You can also bake analog sounding warmth into your hi-res digital master and it's done all the time. There are a wide variety of different digital mastering plug-ins which do remarkably sophisticated analog modeling.

Ultimately, this boils down to signal which vibrates speakers. As a thought experiment, if you use some kind of theoretically perfect surface-sampling laser to capture every movement of the speaker surface at sufficient frequency and fidelity to reproduce all of the information in the original signal and speaker surface vibrations (ala Shannon->Nyquist), then a digital playback of that signal which vibrates the same speaker surface identically will sound exactly the same.

Individuals can prefer different sonic characteristics encoded in an output but that's an aesthetic choice. The entire signal chain creating that output is the result of creative and technical choices. It goes from guitar string to studio acoustics to microphone to mixing board to outboard processing gear to recording medium to duplication to distribution to playback to amplifier to speakers to room acoustics to human ear. Most of those elements significantly color the sound. Yes, mistakes can be made in the downstream signal chain which diverge from the creative intent. However, those mistakes are exceptions, and not inevitable. Done correctly, there's no reason a digital step in the chain shouldn't be completely undetectable.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by KennyBlanken on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:46PM (#32362339)
> Individuals can prefer different sonic characteristics encoded in an output but that's an aesthetic choice.

I find that listening to one of three different sources (earbuds, gaming headset which is EQ'd via open source software, and inexpensive-but-fancy headphones) causes me to adjust to that particular set of headphones' sound. It seems to be like the equivalent of our brain continuously auto-white-balancing our vision.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by mrandish on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:12PM (#32363000)
Absolutely, personal sonic character preferences can vary per content, listening context and the play back device (plus play back signal chain like DACs, pre-amps etc). And it's not just personal taste, most human's bio-based input 'hardware' varies enough to matter, especially for those of us who are out of warranty (ie >40 yrs old). There are even interactive apps which will give you a quick hearing self-test and build an EQ profile based on your individual response curves. I use one bundled into Android and it definitely improves my listening experience.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by com2kid on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:42PM (#32360988)
Yes, the "warmth" generated by from literally any possible analog circuit can be reproduced digitally.

Physics doesn't care about people's beliefs, but sadly many people also don't care about physics.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by 323 on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:12PM (#32361425)
In theory.

In practice, if I give you a random analog box, transforming it into an accurate DSP algorithm it's an extremely difficult problem.

Which is why people instead of doing that, they recreate the "idea" (reverb, delay, ...) digitally, but it's not a copy.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by nyanpasu64 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @04:23AM (#32366133)
I've heard the recent Kemper Profiler uses advanced analysis to generate fairly convincing simulations of analog equipment, given its response to specially designed test signals. I haven't tested it myself though.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by conradfr on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:33PM (#32361657)
Although for some reasons 2021 was a great year for distortion/saturation plugins.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by smnc on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:32PM (#32362217)
Any recommendations?
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by conradfr on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:53PM (#32362400)
The hotly debated P42 https://www.pulsarmodular.com/product/p42-climax-line-amp/

The popular Kelvin Tone Shaper https://www.toneprojects.com/kelvin-tone-shaper.html

Maybe you want tape? London Acoustics Tapei https://www.londonacoustics.com/product/taipei-studio-tape-r...

As for freeware, the comeback of Variety of Sound with https://varietyofsound.wordpress.com/2021/11/30/tesslase-mki... or the less subtle https://kitplugins.com/pages/burier-free

This is just a part of (good) saturation plugins from 2021...

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by peapicker on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:53PM (#32364371)
Not from 2021, but in May 2020 Fabfilter’s update to Saturn 2 is great, and the original was already a fantastic Saturation plugin I’ve used a lot.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by lucas_membrane on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:48PM (#32363292)
The finding some years back was that the harmonic distortion in tube circuits was even harmonics and in solid state was odd harmonics (or maybe vice versa). This could cause tube electronics to sound better than equally good (by measure of thd %) solid state electronics.

This says nothing about the difference between analog and digital recording media unless you think that disc lovers shun solid state electronics or something like that. Do they?

There wasn't much digital sound around when McLuhan said that "The medium is the message." I think that's the substance of this whole brouhaha. What's wrong with rejecting digital media when one deplores the inundating tide of changes in society's tempo, cultural content, aesthetics, and forms of dis-function that have been carried so far and wide by digital media? Isn't change always impugned?

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by analog31 on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:58PM (#32362451)
My son told me that some hip-hop recordings incorporate digitally generated tics and scratches to simulate vinyl.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bl0b on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:46PM (#32364635)
That reminds me of a thread here from a few weeks ago about how somebody was training an ML model to add noise to video, so that the noise-free version of the video can be compressed better but then the noise can be added at playback to maintain the authentic feel of old video.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by masklinn on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:41PM (#32360981)
Well yes but that's not actually what the intent was.

Though I would expect it'd be more of an eq profile thing.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by EL_Loco on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:43PM (#32363256)
Sure you can, but then you can't call it 'analog' anymore. But you can reproduce the distort...I mean, the "warmth" with digital filters or whatever and it will pass any blind test.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:40PM (#32360970)
Yup. Boost the mids on your EQ and you're halfway there.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by djbusby on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:52PM (#32361126)
What's the other half? Magic in the amp-circuit?
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by cool_dude85 on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:08PM (#32361362)
Thousand dollar rocks and crystals to place around your room.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by iamacyborg on Saturday August 06, 2022 @06:49AM (#32366876)
Crystals? I only use wooden resonators, personally.

https://www.analogueseduction.net/record-clamps/SHUNMOOKprod...

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by pessimizer on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:08PM (#32362005)
I still think that "warmth" is a way to describe not actually hearing the separate digital samples subconsciously, and just hearing the sounds gliss into each other. I also think it's an anachronism that comes from way back when the digital sample rate was often a lot lower (and people would insist that their live digital effects sounded as good as analog, when you could sometimes even consciously hear the samples jumping into each other.) Other than that, it seems like something that people project onto music with bassy reverb.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Wolfenstein98k on Saturday August 06, 2022 @04:15AM (#32366080)
You cannot hear samples, or the "steps" between them. This is a silly idea that comes from people seeing pictures of the waveform as it is digitally captured and imagining they can hear it.

You cannot, it is impossible.

Even with an unrealistically low sample rate (say 500Hz instead of 44.1kH), this will not sound like 500 beats per second as the "steps" occur, but rather will just sound extraordinarily dull, as the Nyquist frequency has dropped to 1kHz, a fairly low tone, and all info above that has been lowpassed away.

When the signal is changed to analog by the DAC in order to come out of a speaker, the "steps" become smooth curves like any analog waveform. You cannot hear "digital steps" because they cannot be audible - sound is vibration, and it cannot be made into steps in the analog realm.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by palimpsests on Saturday August 06, 2022 @12:11PM (#32369290)
as the other poster noted, it’s not possible to hear each sample individually.

what is bassy reverb?

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by christkv on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:42PM (#32362301)
Reminds me of the tube vs transistor amplifiers discussions where tube amplifiers are supposed to have a warmer sound.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by cammikebrown on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:32PM (#32360875)
What’s really funny about this is that although CDs objectively can present a greater dynamic range, the loudness wars have created a lot of highly compressed CDs that do sound worse than a lot of vinyl, where it often seems that more cars is taken with mastering because of the limitations of the medium. Additionally, a lot of early 80s albums sound better on vinyl because digital mastering wasn’t as good then. It is an absolutely night and day difference between my vinyl copy of Unknown Pleasures and my CD.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Nav_Panel on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:07PM (#32361358)
Yep. This is why I like buying original 80s CDs where they just chucked the master tape onto a digital disk, rather than post-2000 reissues where they slap a limiter on the master and jack it up +8 dB.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by btown on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:38PM (#32361712)
> it often seems that more cars is taken with mastering

I know this was a typo, but tools like https://shop.audified.com/products/mixchecker (with a literal "sedan" button) and articles like https://ask.audio/articles/the-final-mix-using-your-car are sadly indicative of the emphasis in modern mastering on sounding good on car speakers - which is the entire problem in a nutshell.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by palimpsests on Saturday August 06, 2022 @12:20PM (#32369381)
modern mastering does not optimize fidelity in a car at the expense of other modes of listening, and these articles do not indicate as such.

modern mastering does take into account a highly popular listening environment, to ensure that the mix sounds good there as well.

the second article you posted is talking about using a car as one of several environments in which to test a mix. because it’s a “known” reference in a real-world environment (your ears are used to listening to mastered music on a car stereo).

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bigiain on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:47PM (#32364038)
> It's absolutely, 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD.

I love listening to vinyl. But I’m not gonna lie to myself and say “it sounds better”. The engineer/scientist in me knows it doesn’t, and the pragmatist/experimentalist in me knows that even if I can reliably detect differences between a good digital recording and a good vinyl copy of a song (which I’m not convinced I really can) there is nit nearly enough difference ever to say one is better than the other.

I like the ceremony of playing vinyl. It adds to my enjoyment, but in the kind of way that a Japanese tea ceremony “improves the taste” of tea.

Also, a long time back I realised that listening to hifi _gear_ leads only to criticism and unhappiness, while listening to great music leads to joy. So I mostly have given up critically listening to “gear”. A great song or album can be a thing of joy coming out of your laptop speakers. Coltrane or Ellen Allien or Polyphia are no less amazingly talented in shitty phone earbuds compared to my thousands of dollars of living room hifi. I’m too old to want to argue about “clarity of soundstage” or “time alignment in the tweeter crossover”, I just want to rock out or dance or groove along to great tunes. I can do that with a 100% analog signal path in my lounge room, or in cheap Bluetooth earbuds inside my motorcycle helmet with a 97db noise floor…

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by FullyFunctional on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:52PM (#32362867)
Flat earth, Scientology, dowsing rods, ... willful ignorance is hard to fight.

Anyone with basic understanding of A/D conversion and sampling theory will understand that you can always exceed analog with digital, given enough bits (and 2*16 @ 44.1 kHz is already pretty darn good).

In the early days of MPEG Audio, Level 2 (not mp3) I spent a lot of time listening to samples and I was taken aback when I finally traced flaws back to the CD itself (Cranberries, Zombie, 1994). Many of the early CDs really weren't that great, but that wasn't due to being "digital", just a sloppy production.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by mrandish on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:52PM (#32363314)
Agreed. So much of the early negativity around "digital" and "compression" was due to avoidable mistakes made when mastering some particular pieces of media back in the early days.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by analog31 on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:41PM (#32362296)
There's no a priori reason why any recording medium needs to have a flat response curve, so long as the curve is known so it can be reversed. The reason for the RIAA curve is that most sound has an inverse relationship between amplitude and frequency. The RIAA recording curve limits the overall amplitude of the groove, allowing for better management of dynamic range and distortion in the cutting and playback processes. The slight lumps in the curve are a concession to practical filter technology of the 1950s.

Other analog broadcast and recording media have similar curves, called pre- and de-emphasis.

Digital doesn't need it because it has effectively zero distortion, and dynamic range to spare.

An advantage of vinyl is that there's a physical deliverable, making it possible to monetize it. I think that's why a lot of indie bands use vinyl.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:34PM (#32363612)
More people own CD players than record players. Indie bands would be better off selling CDs if that were really the main intention.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by analog31 on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:32PM (#32364273)
Indeed, that's true. The vinyl thing is probably more about the vinyl trend.

I go to a lot of "indie" performances, and have the musicians directly: How do I buy your stuff, so you make the most money? The answer is always the same: Buy the CD right here.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by cratermoon on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:45PM (#32361043)
> it's not hard at all to make bass so loud that it causes the needle to leap out of the track

Reminds me of the LP my band teacher in high school had. It was the 1812 overture, and the groves for the cannon shots at the end were easily distinguishable with just a casual examination. Based on what you're saying, I suspect that recording was pushing the limits of vinyl.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:11PM (#32362033)
Yes! That exact song is perhaps the canonical demonstration of the limitations of vinyl! Here are some pics of the grooves on that LP: https://imgur.com/a/veVB0
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by cratermoon on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:09PM (#32362970)
Oh, very nice. That's exactly I as I remember it.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by cwillu on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:24PM (#32361550)
I'm imagining a recording of a nuclear blast with sufficiently deep grooves to accurately reproduce the shock wave.

With the satisfying full warm tone vinyl is known for.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by wrycoder on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:31PM (#32364267)
Fermi just dropped small pieces of paper :)
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by cwillu on Saturday August 06, 2022 @04:49PM (#32371483)
Was going more for: “Rabbit hands Duck a phonograph of a nuclear detonation. Duck carefully places the needle on the record. Duck sits quietly in front of the phonograph's horn. Blastwave from nuclear detonation is emitted from the horn while Rabbit looks at the viewer smugly.”
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by brigandish on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:35PM (#32364580)
> For instance, it's not hard at all to make bass so loud that it causes the needle to leap out of the track

I was a drum and bass dj when it was all still vinyl. Even in a club with huge speakers, I've never seen the needle jump due to the bass (although some places used to tape a penny to the top of the headshelf). The weighting on the tone arms can be adjusted so if you've got a needle dancing around it's due to your set up, not the bass, or Jungle music wouldn't have lasted too long.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by crtasm on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:58PM (#32370632)
They're not referring to amplified sound. If you press a record with too much bass on it the 'wobble' of the groove itself can end up so extreme it'll make the needle jump out - no speakers required.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by brigandish on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @04:27AM (#32493760)
There's an awful lot of bass on drum and bass records and yet I've never seen a needle jumping because of it.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:09AM (#32365389)
See my other comment here about the 1812 Overture.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by iamacyborg on Saturday August 06, 2022 @06:52AM (#32366899)
Same deal with dubstep records.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by wrycoder on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:19PM (#32360698)
The thing I miss with the Apple audio chain is a user-controlled equalizer. With my hearing issues, I really need to boost treble, and I prefer to boost bass. I haven't yet discovered a way to do that. Apple thinks that flat is best, and so should you, apparently.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by egypturnash on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:36PM (#32360916)
On OSX Music, window>equalizer. You can also grab Rogue Amoeba’s “SoundSource” to have volume controls for every noise-generating app on the computer, and apply effects chains to them, including EQ.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:53PM (#32361151)
I love SoundSource so much. I bought it so I could use the volume keys on my keyboard to adjust the system volume on my HDMI monitor. I was blown away when I found out I could plug my collection of VSTs into the output pipeline.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by egypturnash on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:55PM (#32362421)
Yeah, adjusting the volume on my monitor was really the reason I bought it, too. All the other stuff's a nice bonus.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by wrycoder on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:55PM (#32364083)
Great, thanks very much. All their products look useful.

I've tried Sound Source and not only do the eq's work, but I can boost the volume so I'm listening at 6/10, where before I was at 9/10 and had no headroom.

I knew I'd get an answer by saying something wrong on the internet.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bitcurious on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:22PM (#32360732)
On iOS, settings>music>EQ has some presets you could try. Not quite the same as custom eq but might be better than flat.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by ultrarunner on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:52PM (#32361127)
And it's insane that this hasn't changed for at least a decade! Apple's own PowerBeats Pro sound like garbage without bumping up the low frequencies, but with an equalizer they sound great. Or maybe this is just subjective and you can file it under "accessibility".

I was jailbroken on iOS 14 for the longest time solely for a system-wide equalizer for Apple Music. With a new phone it's a major step back, and I've switched to Spotify for their (worse) equalizer and somewhat worse overall experience (Spotify doesn't even have an equalizer on desktop!)

It's really unfortunate that such a straightforward feature is so limited on Apple platforms, and for no discernible reason.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by ben7799 on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:07PM (#32361995)
There are hearing accommodations in iOS that can even use your audiogram.

Settings -> Accessibility -> Audio/Visual -> Headphone accommodations

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by wrycoder on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:15PM (#32364173)
Yes, I've used a couple of those iOS apps, but the end result is not boosted enough in the higher frequencies. My $500/pair of MDhearingaid Airs work a lot better, but they don't connect to my Apple devices.

I also have the latest AirPod Pros. With Apple Music, they are not too bad, but Apple is preventing me from having enough volume. I switched to Tidal - the sound is better, and their overall audio out level is higher than Apple. (Tidal also has notes on the music and the bands like the liner notes in the old days.) I tried Idagio, but their output level is even lower than Apple's Music. Basically, I couldn't hear the music well enough to bother with them.

If I play music on my sound system at a comfortable level, and ask people, "Is it too loud for you?", they say, no, it's fine.

The other problem I have with the AirPod Pros is their transparent mode doesn't provide any gain or much EQ for external sounds (even with the audiogram), so I can't hear people nearly as well as I can with my cheap hearing aids. I still have to remove the AirPods and put my hearing aids on, if I want to talk with people in anything but a silent room.

What I need more than anything else is compression. I can hear loud sounds fine - in fact, they bother me. What I can't hear any more is quiet sounds. That's what I need amplified, along with treble boost to compensate for my aging ears.

Apple is really missing a market here for OTC hearing assist. They have all the tech needed, even already built into existing hardware - AirPod Pros are an engineering marvel. They are holding back for some reason, probably some contractural arrangement we're not aware of.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by amelius on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:39PM (#32360956)
> On recording, you cut the bass and jack up the treble. On playback, you boost the bass and reduce the treble.

Sounds like if you combine the two steps you end up with the identity operator :)

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by mturmon on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:48PM (#32361074)
It is the identity for the signal, but RIAA equalization cuts the high-frequency noise that's characteristic of needles in grooves.

  signal -> [HF boost] -> [needle adds HF noise] -> [HF cut] -> same signal, less HF noise
As for the low end, cutting the bass helps to control the size/excursions of the grooves, which are rather close together (https://groverlab.org/hnbfpr/2019-08-06-stereo-records.html).

Dolby B for cassette tapes is the same idea (but only for the highs).

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by colejohnson66 on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:44PM (#32361027)
That’s the idea, in theory. But because analog components such as the resistors, capacitors, and transistors will not be identical[0] between the master and player, it’s not perfect.

[0]: you can get very low tolerance resistors and capacitors, but they’ll cost you

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:45PM (#32361031)
To a point, but remember that you're dealing with low-bit floating point math. That boosting stage creates information that wasn't originally there. That's not so bad in the treble case where original * boost / filter is pretty close to the original. But in the bass case, original / filter * boost might be significantly different than the original. That's usually not a huge problem because the low bass frequencies are pretty forgiving, but it's something to consider.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Jaxan on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:43PM (#32361018)
That’s the point!
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by amelius on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:23PM (#32362129)
Parent was trying to show that

> It's absolutely not possible to accurately record every digital recording onto vinyl.

Outlining an idempotent process of recording and playback does not help there.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:41PM (#32362289)
If they were idempotent, yes. But they're not. Analog processing can't be perfect, and amplification is an inherently noisy process. The RIAA curve first cuts the signal on the bass end of the spectrum, throwing away information in the process (because vinyl doesn't have infinite resolution). Then it amplifies that degraded signal.

You can simulate this pretty well with computer speakers. Turn down your audio outputs so that it's barely audible, then turn up the speakers as load as they'll go. Noisy, isn't it? In theory that should be the same as turning the outputs to their maximum clean level and turning your speakers way down, but in practice it's absolutely not. Well, every vinyl record made does exactly that to the bass.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bigbillheck on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:43PM (#32362311)
> It's absolutely, 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD.

There's a lot of weirdos out there, but these ones aren't hurting anybody.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by staticautomatic on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:31PM (#32363935)
I’ve heard stories about things like the cannon sounds in the Telarc vinyl of the 1812 Overture blowing out unfiltered speakers. Are they myths?
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:25PM (#32360785)
> 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD

It's not intellectually fine, only fine in the sense that it's well within the bounds of free speech.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by NovemberWhiskey on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:39PM (#32360957)
No; it's really fine - same with tube amps etc. It's OK to have a subjective preference for some kinds of distortion. It's not OK to say it's "truer to the original sound", which is where this usually comes off the rails.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:55PM (#32361190)
Sure, if the artifact you prefer actually exists and you can confirm it in a double blind test.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by wolrah on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:37PM (#32362264)
You're not wrong in the general "audiophile" world where fools and their money are parted over snake oil magical cables claiming benefits only those with the most golden of ears can enjoy.

Where you're getting pushback is that this thread is talking about vinyl records and tube amps, things where the noise and distortions introduced by their operation are well known, well documented, audible to anyone with normally functional ears, and regularly utilized artistically. These are not the inventions of grifters with a product to sell, it's just an older technology that is less precise in a certain predictable way which some people find pleasant.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Dylan16807 on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:24PM (#32363081)
It's relevant to the article, where a digital source made from a tape should sound the same as the tape.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by wolrah on Monday August 08, 2022 @04:05PM (#32390375)
Right, but this subthread is about it being fine for people to prefer the sound of less accurate systems, just not to claim those systems are objectively superior.

The poster I'm replying to is then acting like it's some weird audiophile belief that records sound different from other media.

On the topic of the overall article, of course the people who believe a digital processing step makes things inherently worse are absolutely off their rockers.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Saturday August 06, 2022 @08:49PM (#32372885)
A quality tube amp for audio reproduction (not guitar playing) has very low distortion.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by cwillu on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:25PM (#32361570)
“I prefer bit of oregano on my pasta.”

“Not without a double-blind test you don't!”

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by pessimizer on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:11PM (#32362028)
"The pasta you just said was the best pasta you ever had didn't have any oregano on it."
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by cwillu on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:49PM (#32362364)
There was no cilantro in the dish you just said was delicious: we substituted dove-brand soap shavings.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Edman274 on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:55PM (#32361194)
A digital recording has to be mastered with the understanding that it could end up getting played on a car stereo, on a bluetooth boombox, on cell phone speakers, in bluetooth earbuds, at a dance party with a DJ or on a hi-fi stereo setup that looks like the one from the old Maxell "blown away" ad. A recording on a vinyl record doesn't. The person mastering a record doesn't need to care about bluetooth earbuds, car stereos, cell phone speakers, boomboxes, and only marginally about DJs at dance parties. They can tune their mixing and mastering decisions to just the case of a hi-fi stereo setup with an enthusiast listening. They have to make fewer compromises because there are fewer cases to handle. The format enforces those constraints. You can't just ignore that.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by mrandish on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:45PM (#32361778)
> They can tune their mixing and mastering decisions to just the case of a hi-fi stereo setup with an enthusiast listening.

This is what audio purists should be asking for. Let's pay the creative production team to create and release a high-fidelity digital mix optimized for us. No concerns about radio play, boomboxes or loudness wars. Just their original creative intent.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Syonyk on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:21PM (#32364502)
If there's a "high bitrate" (24-bit, 96kHz FLAC or something like that) master, often enough that will be the case. You can reasonably assume that someone who's buying that version of the track has something capable of playing it back sanely. Same with the "high def audio" formats (SACD, there was another one...) - they often did, in fact, sound better. Not because of the high resolution, so much as because they were mastered to be listened to on a competent system, not on the subway on earbuds.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jamiek88 on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:25PM (#32363092)
If tidal offered that it would be good value and a real differentiator.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:04PM (#32363783)
Nobody who is mastering records gives a damn about bluetooth boomboxes or phone speakers; and there is no way to optimize for a phone speaker and the "Maxell blown away" stereo setup.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:48PM (#32361083)
I subjectively prefer to add sriracha to my burrito. That's intellectually fine. It doesn't make it an objectively better burrito.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:59PM (#32361241)
Yes, because the sriracha can be confirmed to exist.

If you say that waving your hand over the shriracha while murmuring a magic incantation makes it taste better, then that may not be so intellectually fine any more.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by nerfbatplz on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:30PM (#32360857)
Not only can you not tell the difference between analogue and digital, you also cannot tell the difference between lossless and properly transcoded MP3.

Most audiophile mania is poorly informed at best and astrology at worst.

http://abx.digitalfeed.net/

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Maursault on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:46PM (#32361046)
> you also cannot tell the difference between lossless and properly transcoded MP3

I'm not sure what you mean by "properly transcoded," as though there's a scourge of bad encoders out there and everyone has nutty encoding practices, but I really, really bet you can. Listen to an mp3 of a rock/pop track. Try to focus on the cymbals. See if you can isolate them aurally from the rest of the music. Can you hear how mp3 encoding completely munges high frequencies to sound like digital glass breaking? Then you shall finally understand why mp3 encoding has always sucked, and Napster really, really should have won.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kimixa on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:41PM (#32362292)
Many mp3 encoders cut off really high frequency stuff - somewhere between 16khz and 20khz depending on the encoder. Often this isn't changed by any of the quality settings, e.g. on lame it's still enabled on the "insane" preset without manually disabling it.

While that's on the very top-end of human hearing - most by middle age can't detect anything above 14-16khz, but it's certainly possible (especially for those younger) to have frequencies all the way up to 20khz as audible.

So it is possible for some people to hear a difference with some mp3 encoders, no matter the bitrate or quality settings.

And the psychoacoustic model is going to focus on the "average" listener, so it's perfectly possible that an lower bitrate encoding is transparent (IE: Completely indistinguishable) to one person, while another may be able to notice higher frequencies that have been cut off to provide more quality in the more noticeable parts of the spectrum. Or even the same person at different ages. This is completely physical difference, and no amount of training or harder listening would be able to bridge the gap.

And I find many of the higher frequencies that are hit by such things are often not particularly noticeable unless you're actively looking for them, being able to tell there's a difference and knowing what to specifically look far isn't the same as saying the recording is somehow less enjoyable due to quality differences.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Nav_Panel on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:10PM (#32361394)
^ yeah exactly. Also, you really do need a pretty good sound system to hear it. I was with the poster above you for a long time, but then I did blind A/B testing on my buddy's $10k monitors, and the difference was clear.

I wouldn't call it "night and day", but I had no trouble distinguishing even 320 MP3 from FLAC on his system by focusing on the very high frequencies (3/3, small N I know I know, but I felt like I could've gone on indefinitely). The MP3s lost some clarity in the highs which led to less dimensionality/sense of space ("soundstage"), because our spatial hearing is very attuned to minute transient differences in high frequencies in particular. But you need to be listening on a system that is adequately equipped to reproduce very high frequency transients accurately, which most people don't have access to.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by conradfr on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:39PM (#32361726)
The encoders of today create really good mp3 even at 192kbps (at 128kbps not so much which is a shame as a lot of internet radios use that).

Do you have a favorite rock track we can do an ABX test with?

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by user_7832 on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:55PM (#32361872)
Not the person you replied to, but Hotel California’s Hell Freezes Over version is generally very well regarded in mastering.

If I’m not mistaken one of those A/B/X test websites also tested that, and while I was using a very simple pair of headphones, the difference was noticeable.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by conradfr on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:30PM (#32362205)
Why not.

https://abx.funkybits.fr/test/the-eagles-hell-freezes-over-h...

(obviously there's a bug on the tracks display after round 1)

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by conradfr on Saturday August 06, 2022 @04:39AM (#32366201)
(fixed)
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by user_7832 on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:11PM (#32391064)
Thanks, I’ll try and take the test asap. (I need to find my earphones and usb c to 3.5mm adapter first). Is there any way I can contact you after taking the test, perhaps email?
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Maursault on Saturday August 06, 2022 @04:43AM (#32366218)
> Hotel California’s Hell Freezes Over version is generally very well regarded in mastering.

Never heard this, but I know the original track is used for reference in studios from LA to NY, and is generally regarded as among the best mixes ever engineered.

Another commenter suggested high end audio equipment and $10K monitors... not necessary. With any off the shelf hifi, $100 worth of equipment, one can easily hear mp3 high frequency problems. Focusing on the cymbals just makes it obvious.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bayindirh on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:09PM (#32361380)
As a former orchestra player I can say that, with a good hi-fi system, the difference is audible, in terms of soundstage size/depth, not in details.

I have a couple systems, one is a proper hi-fi system. If the album is mastered without brick-wall normalization, the difference is easier to hear.

When I listen the same album via my DAC, from MP4, I enjoy it. When I listen the same album, from a CD, I sit in front of the system like a rabbit blinded by lights.

The DAC is the same. It’s a Yamaha CD-S300 with a proper iPod interface, which carries the signal digitally till DAC.

This ABX test is the same. You need a high fidelity chain to enjoy it. I have a nice sound card, but the speakers connected to it can’t handle the resolution put out by it.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Night_Thastus on Saturday August 06, 2022 @12:27AM (#32364831)
Those are two completely different situations.

I'm not a fan of analog, but a high-end analog system will sound far different than a similarly priced digital one. It's a very different type of sound.

Whether someone likes it or not is personal preference. But it does sound night-and-day different to listen to a vinyl from a turntable and using a DAC.

As for MP3 vs lossless, that's mostly true assuming a modern variable bit rate MP3 on OK hardware. The better the audio, the better the equipment, the more noticeable it gets. But yes, for 95%, it's basically not significant.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by MivLives on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:40PM (#32360967)
Badly transcoded mp3s are the worst. For most artists I couldn't tell the difference between a v2 and a flac. There were a few who you could but they're mostly not what people are listening to (intentionally very noisy artists). Realistically if I just heard them blind I don't think I would have cared.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by havblue on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:46PM (#32361784)
As an anecdote I've noticed that while driving, the bass line in YouTube music jazz can be incredibly hard to hear despite my shelling out for the premium Bose sound system that can shake the vehicle. So I wonder whether this is the encoding or whether it's really supposed to be that quiet.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by brigandish on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:39PM (#32364605)
There's definitely some difference in quality with some music. For instance, the reverb will be slightly better with lossless, in my opinion. Some might say it's not much to bother with but it's definitely there.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Tao3300 on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:53PM (#32364071)
Cymbals always sound like bubbling shit in mp3.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Night_Thastus on Saturday August 06, 2022 @12:22AM (#32364812)
MP3 is not monolithic, and has changed drastically since it was released.

You're going to get a pretty terrible experience with MP3 128kbps, whereas modern variable bit rate schemes can actually be quite decent. Personally I prefer to always go lossless, but for most people on most systems, the difference isn't noticeable. (Moreso the better the system gets, ofc)

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by iggldiggl on Sunday August 07, 2022 @05:16PM (#32379987)
> MP3 is not monolithic, and has changed drastically since it was released.

To some extent certainly, though I think that e.g. the handling of short sharp transient remains somewhat of a fundamental problem of MP3 no matter how much bitrate and encoding brain power you throw at it, and was only really improved upon in the subsequent generation of codecs, i.e. like AAC, Vorbis or Opus.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Night_Thastus on Sunday August 07, 2022 @05:24PM (#32380060)
True, though I think variable bit rate MP3 is fine enough for most.

But the main reason is that it's so ubiquitous. If you're buying music, it's almost always MP3 unless you go to a source like Qobuz which serves FLAC. Same with devices - basically everything supports MP3. Vorbis and Opus support is far patchier.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by iggldiggl on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:30AM (#32383694)
> unless you go to a source like Qobuz which serves FLAC.

Apple is another odd one out there by only selling music as AAC, and Bandcamp gives you a comprehensive choice of all sorts of formats.

> Same with devices - basically everything supports MP3. Vorbis and Opus support is far patchier.

True that, though AAC support might also be somewhat reasonably common-ish these days. (Though I've found that apart from also having a relatively low folder count limit in general, my car radio also has some difficulties with reading the metadata in some files, and as far as I can tell I think the affected files are all MPEG-4 files. It's only some MPEG-4 files that are affected, though, but I haven't yet bothered to find out what exactly else they might have in common.)

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Night_Thastus on Monday August 08, 2022 @02:27PM (#32389138)
I wish everyone was on Bandcamp. It's such a great service. It's so flexible. And unlike Qobuz, it's website is actually decent.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Tao3300 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @03:03AM (#32365694)
> Personally I prefer to always go lossless

Oh? Why's that?

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Night_Thastus on Saturday August 06, 2022 @10:16AM (#32368291)
While I likely wouldn't notice the difference, digital space is so cheap now that it costs me very little to store everything I want as lossless copies. Even if the difference is negligible, there's little reason not to get the best quality I can.

The main reasons why not would be streaming (currently Qobuz is the only one I know of that does it properly, and services like Roon + Qobuz can get pricey) and bluetooth (which doesn't support lossless at all).

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by apohn on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:57PM (#32361216)
>The fallout of the MoFi revelation has thrown the audiophile community into something of an existential crisis.

Don't worry, the crisis will not last long. Audiophiles will find a way to get over it and buy some better cables that would have revealed they were using a Digital source all along.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by floren on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:39PM (#32362790)
Cables are all well and good, but the quest for perfect audio will continue until somebody invents a gadget which makes you 15 years old again, hanging out in your friend's basement, having just tried pot for the first time and hearing Led Zeppelin III on a cheap Sears record player. I don't know exactly what this gadget will look like, but it's the only thing that will get audiophiles the sound they've been chasing.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jamiek88 on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:29PM (#32363140)
Yes, there’s deffo something to that.

Hence the cassette revival for those of us of a certain vintage.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by toast0 on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:46PM (#32364330)
I think I'm in the right vintage for that, but did cassettes ever sound good? I could get nostalgic for the sound (especially fast forward/reverse, which is lovely), and I probably never had good equipment, but tapes were always kind of warbly for me. I had access to older records too, which could sound good when there wasn't too much hissing and popping and they weren't skipping. Some records were maybe off balance? and wouldn't play at consistent speed either. Again, I didn't have great equipment.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by apohn on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:02PM (#32369725)
>I think I'm in the right vintage for that, but did cassettes ever sound good?

Compared to CDs? Definitely not! Not to mention how many people listened to homemade mixtapes and copies, which made the audio quality even worse.

Did they sound good enough that you could dance, relax, have a good time, be consoled when you were unhappy, or whatever people did with music? Absolutely.

Even when CDs did eventually come out, I far preferred a WalkMan to a Discman. I could put a Walkman in one pocket and a cassette in the other. That wasn't easy with CDs.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jamiek88 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:53PM (#32370168)
Yep plus early ‘discman’ didn’t have anti skip and battery life was terrible.

Cassettes we’re easy to remix, record, share.

The physical mixtape was a cultural touchstone of romance and friendship for a while there.

So yeah, I guess ‘good enough’.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by apohn on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:49PM (#32370566)
>Yep plus early ‘discman’ didn’t have anti skip and battery life was terrible.

I had completely forgotten about the development of anti-skip. And now that you've made me remember it, I suddenly feel old.

I knew somebody (with very rich parents) who basically had a shoulder bag (read: man purse) so he could carry around his Discman (early Sony version, no anti-skip), an extra CD case or two, and an extra set of batteries. It was awful.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by user_7832 on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:57PM (#32361900)
> Don't worry, the crisis will not last long. Audiophiles will find a way to get over it and buy some better cables that would have revealed they were using a Digital source all along.

You don’t need to attack any person or community - especially given that rich people buying expensive stuff is hardly hurting others directly. Please make good faith arguments.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bambax on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:06PM (#32361979)
> especially given that rich people buying expensive stuff is hardly hurting others directly

Superstition is always bad.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by user_7832 on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:17PM (#32362603)
If superstition is always bad, I take it you're also annoyed/angry at Wayne Gretzky or Serena Williams? Or any athlete engaging in superstition?

(https://thevarsity.ca/2022/03/20/athletes-superstition/)

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bambax on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:35PM (#32362760)
I have never heard of Wayne Gretzky; Google tells me he's a hockey player. I don't think I have ever seen a match of hockey in my entire life. I'm not annoyed by what I don't know.

But the "superstitions" that the linked article mentions, are rituals, lucky charms. They're much less dangerous than going around pretending that something exists, that provably isn't there.

Audiophiles are moon-landing deniers. Some might think it's funny or harmless. I think it's terrifying.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by user_7832 on Monday August 08, 2022 @05:06PM (#32391010)
> Audiophiles are moon-landing deniers.

Sorry, but I do not follow how you came to this conclusion, could you explain it?

> They're much less dangerous than going around pretending that something exists, that provably isn't there.

By your definition is every person in the world who believes in god therefore dangerous?

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Sporktacular on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:35PM (#32362763)
If they just bought it and shut up about it maybe.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by throwawaycities on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:10PM (#32362025)
> Hard to imagine a better A/A-test.

In part it goes to prove Mark Twain’s quote that it’s easier to fool people that to convince them they have been fooled. So many people build their identity around being something like an audiophile and something like this demonstrates the are mostly frauds…not all of it is a bad-faith fraud either which makes it so much more difficult for those people who believed they had a genuine passion and talent to accept.

On the other hand there are people who really don’t give a shit and just shill themselves in a given industry to make money as self-proclaimed experts. It’s part of a sickness social media pushes on people where they think they are brands…as opposed to actual humans. These people have no allegiance and will readily move on the the next money making opportunity so long as they can…probably high priced wines.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by allears on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:03PM (#32360480)
That's a little simplistic. You can certainly tell the difference between a good analog recording played on a high quality system vs. an MP3. But once you throw enough samples and bit depth at it (more than are on a standard CD), you get quality that's equivalent to, or better than, most analog media.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by jrajav on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:18PM (#32360693)
44100hz sample rate is enough to reproduce well above the highest frequency even young humans can hear, and 16 bits of depth is enough for 96db of dynamic range, enough to make the noise floor of any consumer system totally inaudible.

Standard CDs might not be good enough for archival and further production work (where you also need wiggle room for further processing or format changes), but they have plenty of headroom to reproduce any kind of sound for playback purposes. Any more is just placebo.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by doix on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:33PM (#32360885)
So it's been many years since I looked at this stuff, but the reason for higher sample rate isn't to do with humans being able to hear over 20khz. If you sample at 44khz you need a high pass filter at 22khz to avoid aliasing. Since that's pretty close to 20khz, it needs a pretty sharp drop off. Having a filter with a sharp drop off can introduce artifacts.

With 96khz sampling rate, you don't need as a sharp drop off in your filter.

The above is mostly accurate, hopefully someone else will comment and tell me how I'm wrong and correct the inaccuracies.

Edit: to anyone reading this, read the replies if you want the correct explanation. To everyone that replied, thank you :).

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:40PM (#32360961)
You are correct; with a 96 kHz sampling rate, you don't need such a brick wall filter. But then you dohn't have to actually keep the data at 96 kHz; it can be reduced to 44, this time using a digital filter.

A sharply cutting off analog filter is expensive to produce. It has multiple stages to create the multiple poles. High precision resistors and capacitors have to be used to get all those circuit stages to line up. The filter will have phase distortion.

That's the basis of "supersampling": sampling at a higher rate with a simpler filter with less of a cutoff, then completing the job with a digital filter to get to the target sample rate.

This can be done in reverse, in reproducion. Take, say, a 48 KHz signal, and digitally interpolate it to a higher sample rate like 96 KHz. That is fed to the DAC. The filter after the DAC then doesn't need such a steep cutoff after 20 KHz. A greater bit depth can be used; like 16 bit samples interpolated to 24 bit at a higher rate, fed to a 24 bit DAC.

The digital filter or interpolator doesn't care about accurate resistors, capacitors or drift in component values over time or due to heat; it does the same thing with the same data every time.

Digital filters can look at future values also. The state of an analog filter is determined by only the current and past values of the signal; but digital signal processing can delay the signal a little bit and look at a "box" around the current value. I think that is key to preserving phase relationships.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:53PM (#32361154)
> with a 96 kHz sampling rate, you don't need such a brick wall filter.

This is incorrect. See my comment above/below.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by masklinn on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:47PM (#32361054)
Anything above 44 is problematic because lots of systems have non-linear responses and will create audible intermodulations of the ultraharmonics.

Monty (of xiph) has an article on the subject (well on 24/192 but it applies all the same) which goes into the gory details: https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by pnut on Saturday August 06, 2022 @04:51AM (#32366273)
Interesting video on sample rate effects during digital music production https://youtu.be/-jCwIsT0X8M
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by ajross on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:48PM (#32361073)
That's the "further processing" notion the grandparent comment talked about. A correctly processed signal at 44.1kHz is more than sufficient to reproduce all audio. But if you're going to do something with the sample series (like low-pass it for aliasing protection in your example, or to resample it for conversion, or for any effects or mixing step really) it's good to have extra data in there to prevent headaches. Likewise sampling at 24+ bits prevents accumulated error in repeated processing, etc...

There's a space in the audio world for more bits of data. But the final output format isn't where it belongs.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:53PM (#32361148)
[ EDIT: contents of this post were factually incorrect. What Kazinator wrote in response is correct, and I don't want to leave incorrect ideas floating around. ]
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:27PM (#32361580)
If the goal is audio capture and reproduction, the filter used when sampling at 96 kHz still starts rolling off at around 20 kHz. The wrap-around aliasing artifacts do not begin until around half of 96 kHz, or around 48 kHz. So the filter only has to be steep enough to hit a large attenuation at 48 kHz: full signal to virtually nothing over the space of 28 kHz.

If you're sampling at 48 kHz, the signal has to be severely attenuated already; it has to go from 20 kHz to deep cutoff in just the space of a few kHz.

At 96 kHz can achieve the effect as if you were sampling at 48 kHz, with a steep filter. You sample at 96 kHz with a milder filter, and then purely in the digital realm, you down-sample to 48 kHz. There is an overall filter consisting of the original analog one plus the digital processing.

That is cheaper and more reliable than doing it all in analog.

An analog filter with a steep cut off will be challenging in mass production because of the strict component tolerances.

Sure, you could use a steep filter with 96 kHz also. Say, a steep filter that starts cutting off at 30 kHz. It would still be a less demanding filtering application because of the margin that you have in the frequency domain. The multiple poles of the filter don't have to be lined up as well. E.g. if the first pole starts rolling off at around 30 kHz, and then next ones at 31, and the third one at 28, ... it doesn't matter because you're still hitting the absolute target of there being next to nothing at 48 kHz, and nearly the full signal at 20 kHz.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:19PM (#32362097)
You're right, and I'm wrong.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Sporktacular on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:47PM (#32362841)
Sure, but going to disagree about the numbers there. I have a DAW interface which is exceedingly linear (+/- <0.15 dB) up to 35 kHz. Don't need to start filtering so low to hit those results.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by mturmon on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:04PM (#32361299)
This explanation loses me at "infinity per dB" ... and I'm an EE. I think you're trying to cover too much ground here, it's really confusing to try to understand what you mean.

I believe the comment you're responding to is talking about the analog filter that is needed to avoid aliasing -- as the first words of your comment correctly note/explain.

And in particular, the original comment seems to be noting the phase distortion (in frequencies near the cutoff) that analog brick-wall filters will cause. This has been a design contention for decades, really, ever since the CD format was introduced.

It's a big design space, with options for gentler analog filters, followed by very fast digital sampling, and further tricks with filtering in the digital domain, where you don't have to worry about getting great capacitors, etc.

It may be out-of-scope to lay all that out in one paragraph!

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:10PM (#32361390)
That's why I had some blank lines in there :)

You're right that its a big design space. The key takeaway is that "yes, higher sample rates can actually make a difference, but almost entirely down to the filter design, not because Nyquist moves ... and you probably cannot hear the difference."

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by TylerE on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:45PM (#32361034)
Yes, i hate when people talk about Nyquist as if its some Panacea.

Its vwry “spherical cow”. It assumes all your filters, DACs, are perfect, and that time is infinite.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:55PM (#32361196)
Nyquist isn't about such assumptions at all. It is an information theoretic value, based on the provable claim that there is zero information present in the original analog waveform that is not represented in the digital version.

Yes, your filters, DAC and speaker wire could still create a less than ideal listening situation, but the fundamental aspect of the Nyquist frequency is not concerned with any of that.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:12PM (#32361433)
There is zero information present in a waveform that is not contained in the digital version, if that original waveform is confined below the Nyquist limit. Either it is that way already, or else is derived from an original-original waveform that isn't, by low-pass filtering.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:27PM (#32361585)
That's an excellent coda/qualification of what I said. Put into a more listener centric context: there's no audible information in a waveform that is not captured by sampling it at 44.1khz.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by masklinn on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:51PM (#32361108)
The exact same spherical cow issue applies, with worse effects, when you increase your sampling rate unnecessarily.

And you can use oversampling to correct for the filtering issues. That's pretty standard in modern DACs and ADCs.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Dylan16807 on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:30PM (#32363149)
You only need so much margin, though.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by NovemberWhiskey on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:49PM (#32361090)
That's fine - but, to the extent that's true, it's true only about the recording and mastering process. CD, as a delivery mechanism, is totally fine and perceptually flawless.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by tzs on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:51PM (#32363311)
> 44100hz sample rate is enough to reproduce well above the highest frequency even young humans can hear

It's enough to reproduce well above what we can hear by the normal mechanism that we use for most of our hearing (sound vibrates the eardrum, which vibrates some tiny bones in the middle ear, which cause fluid in the cochlea to ripple which disturb sensory hairs which we perceive as sound).

Ultrasonic sounds can be conducted to the cochlea via the surrounding bone bypassing the eardrum and middle ear. Those bone conducted ultrasonics can be perceived. See [1].

This is probably not important in music except in maybe a few rare cases.

I'd still like to see better frequency handling though, so that our music wouldn't sound terrible to the dogs and cats that are forced to listen with their owners. We can't normally hear much past 20 KHz (more like 12 KHz for many of us), but they can.

There are several musical instruments that have significant ultrasonic output. It would be an interesting experiment to see if dogs and cats like those instruments live better than they do recorded (or dislike live less than they dislike recorded). Then compare to the same experiment but with instruments that don't have ultrasonic output.

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23384569/

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kazinator on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:37PM (#32360933)
Not only that, but what you hear at those upper frequencies isn't tone anyway. the highest harmonics of tonal sounds live in that region, plus aperiodic signals (the hiss from sibilants, cymbals crashing, and so on).

The content can be faked, and this is used in low-bandwidth codecs and such.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bandwidth_extension

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bayindirh on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:44PM (#32363270)
> Any more is just placebo.

This is a very simplistic view of things, on many fronts, but I'll try to be as concise as possible.

In a classical wind/bow orchestra, there are more harmonics at play than the 20Hz-20KHz band, and these harmonics affects our perception of the sound and soundstage. However, recreation of this is very hard, because you need both recording and playback chains which can handle these harmonics as well.

To faithfully reproduce such orchestra, you need a speaker for every instrument, ideally with the exact air movement capacity of the instrument you're mirroring. This is not practical. Instead we mic all of them, mix all of them, and add room echo to the mix to capture harmonics as best as we can.

However, this can't replicate some instruments anywhere around its real sound.

Examples are Turkish qanun [0] and Chinese guzheng [1]. These instruments sound bland, flat and shallow on all recordings, but listening them live, directly with your ears is a goose pimlples inducing experience. Higher end stringed instruments have a similar vibe to them.

So, a 16bit/44KHz signal at 20Hz-20KHz band cannot reproduce these instruments with any faith.

Standard CDs, high quality vinyls, lossless files carry a lot of information, but not all information we can process with our ears. Like how even the best digital cameras cannot reproduce the colors we can see with our eyes.

Reaching these resolution levels are neither cheap, nor practical, hence we use what's practical.

As a result, your master-pressed-vinyl possibly can't carry this information either, because the recording chain was not able to capture that amount of information, even if you went all the way to install your own power pole to feed clean power to your impossibly expensive audio equipment with all that capacity to reproduce that sound.

IOW, you can't extract the sound which is not there to begin with.

Your friendly ex-orchestra player reported from its AKAI-AM2850.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qanun_(instrument)

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guzheng

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by tzs on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:02PM (#32363385)
> To faithfully reproduce such orchestra [...]

It has never been clear to me what the goal of home playback is supposed to be.

Let's simplify from a full orchestra to just a solo piano. Is the goal

1. to sound like it would if that piano was being played in my living room, or

2. to sound like what I'd have heard if I was there in the concert hall sitting in a good seat when the recording was made, or

3. to sound like what it would sound like if a replica of my living room was built inside the concert hall but with walls that do not transmit sound, with my speakers replaced by speaker-sized holes in the wall behind where the speakers normally sit, and I was sitting in that replica living room during the concert?

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bayindirh on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:10PM (#32363442)
Normally, it’s “2”. Music is mastered to transfer you to the place where it’s recorded. Mastering is just tuning the sound to fit into your music system limits, while keeping the atmosphere as much as possible.

ABBA’s sound is mastered to fit into AM radio and jukeboxes for example. To make the music broadly listenable, for example.

Today everything is so blurry, because there’s no studio per se. It’s just sequenced, vocal is added, mastered, compressed and released (today’s pop). Rock and other stuff is still track recorded, tho.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by hemogloben on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:57PM (#32364093)
I worked in guitar audio effects for a while (the exact opposite of this discussion), but I started playing with stereo guitar rigs and then thought about three speaker setups and beyond.

At a certain point the speakers really start to interfere with each other and you have to worry about the stability of the image at each point in the room...

It occurred to me at that point that you're really starting to approach 3. You're trying to recreate the sound pressure patterns within the room.

That's about the point I moved on to something simpler. Granted my explorations were super simple, but it was a VERY weird thought that got me thinking about the question you've asked.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by TylerE on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:16PM (#32360666)
I suspect the real reason is that vinyl largely escaped the ravages of the loudness war, because physics.

(And also much of the digital gear in the 80s when the first wave of CD releases was pretty crappy)

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bayindirh on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:20PM (#32360710)
And the standard equalizer you need to apply during record/playback of the medium.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by aaaaaaaaaaab on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:08PM (#32360552)
>(more than are on a standard CD)

Sorry, but CD (16bit PCM) has better dynamic range than vinyl. The best vinyl systems can have dynamic range of around 80dB. 16bit PCM is 96dB.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bayindirh on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:16PM (#32360655)
Unless it’s brick-wall normalized during mastering.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by kstrauser on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:22PM (#32360743)
That's a real thing, to be sure. The Loudness Wars have completely ruined any number of otherwise decent recordings. The worst I ever heard was Dropkick Murphys's "The Meanest of Times" which had the dynamic range of an air conditioner in Phoenix.

Still, you can always take a great analog recording, pipe it into a good ADC, and listen to that sample forever without degradation. I think almost everything can play FLACs now.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Tsiklon on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:31PM (#32363580)
Metallica's Death Magnetic was another truly dreadful example of the loudness war - Thankfully a better mastered release came out in 2015. I've just got my hands on this release and comparing it against my original copy it is a night and day improvement - especially on "All Nightmare Long".
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bayindirh on Saturday August 06, 2022 @03:05AM (#32365705)
Yeah, the first release was pure clipping, no music. I remember listening to it and saying? “Did all we wait for this? C’mon”.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by nikau on Saturday August 06, 2022 @11:57PM (#32373772)
Hah I had the same experience, I thought some idiot had recorded it via their soundcard line in or something.

Eventually got the better mastered version which was leaked from guitar hero or something.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by masklinn on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:22PM (#32360736)
Sure but that's got nothing to do with the CD itself. Except in that you would not be able to brick-wall a vynil at all so you don't.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by vosper on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:23PM (#32360754)
Which is not an issue with the digital format, but with the mastering.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bayindirh on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:34PM (#32361665)
However, you can’t change the mastering of the album you have bought. When the CD version of the album you have bought has subpar audio quality, the abilities of the medium has no value and importance.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Sporktacular on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:52PM (#32362869)
"When the CD version of the album you have bought has subpar audio quality"

Yes, but these mastering choices could apply to the vinyl version too. In other words, your response had nothing to do with a comparison of the two media.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bayindirh on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:30PM (#32363151)
Nope, you can't apply the same mastering to the vinyl, esp. the latest stonewalling compression/normalization techniques because of RIAA equalization [0].

Without RIAA equalization, it's not possible to keep the needle in the groove with that amount of bass and low end. You can't keep the needle on the track with stonewalling even with RIAA equalization.

As a result, you are limited by the medium itself, hence you have to make milder choices.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RIAA_equalization

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Sporktacular on Monday August 08, 2022 @06:37PM (#32391998)
Obviously the mastering differs. So your point is that the mandatory mastering limitations specific to each medium should be factored into comparisons between media?

Perhaps, but what about optional mastering choices like brick-wall limiting with normalization (which is what I think you meant)? Maybe I'm misunderstanding your point.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by netr0ute on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:17PM (#32363040)
> could apply to the vinyl version too

They can't, because these choices create enough volume for the needle to go haywire, so mastering always has a better dynamic range.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by Sporktacular on Monday August 08, 2022 @06:42PM (#32392047)
Again, mastering choices differ between distribution media, that's obvious.

When you say 'mastering always has a better dynamic range', did you mean CD quality PCM has a better dynamic range?

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by NovemberWhiskey on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:03PM (#32364422)
The highest-of-high end analog tape with Dolby SR and the works is still objectively inferior to vanilla 44.1 kHz / 16 bit PCM.
Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by bayindirh on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:15PM (#32360637)
Telling this out loud upsets a lot of people, but I’m on the same boat with you.

A good lossless album, regardless of the medium played through shows a significant difference in soundstage given the system can handle the resolution thrown at it when compared with a MP3/M4A file.

Re:A Phoenix record store owner set the audiophile world on ... by masklinn on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:23PM (#32360752)
> Telling this out loud upsets a lot of people, but I’m on the same boat with you.

It "upsets a lot of people" in the same sense and for the same reason as telling them drinking alkaline water cures cancer.