News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by md224 on Sunday March 06, 2022 @09:30PM (#30583560)
The interesting thing about this is that YouTube is clearly trying to make it more difficult for non-official clients to stream video, as is evident from the required workaround described here:

https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl/issues/29326#issuecom...

The legal defense of youtube-dl is premised on the idea that there's no circumvention occurring [0]. I 100% support youtube-dl and I want YouTube to stop interfering with it, but I also think we're being a little too cute when we pretend like ytdl isn't circumventing anything... it seems obvious to me that YouTube is trying to put up roadblocks and we're trying to get around them. I would feel better if we could find a way to defend ytdl without the pretense of acting like this cat-and-mouse game isn't going on.

[0] https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2020/11/2020-11-1...

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by MereInterest on Sunday March 06, 2022 @10:03PM (#30583778)
I thought the most recent legal argument was the 2019 hiQ Labs Inc v LinkedIn Corp[0], in which the Ninth Circuit found web scraping to be legal, and forbid LinkedIn from blocking web scrapers. The exact same argument can be made for accessing YouTube via youtube-dl.

The article does indicate that the decision in hiQ v LinkedIn was vacated by SCOTUS following the 2021 Van Buren v United States [0], to be retried by the Ninth Circuit. However, I'm not seeing a way that the decision in Van Buren would change the outcome, as it concluded that the CFAA did not apply to cases where somebody is legally allowed to access a computer at all.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn

[1] https://techcrunch.com/2021/06/03/supreme-court-hacking-cfaa...

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by infogulch on Sunday March 06, 2022 @10:31PM (#30583934)
Discussed on HN before: Court: Violating a site’s terms of service isn’t criminal hacking (2020) [1] (probably other discussions as well). My comment on this one:

> ... it's the webmaster's own responsibility to "just not serve" if they don't want it to be served, and their failure to implement their own desires as software doesn't suddenly give them carte blanche to claim whatever they want was breaking the law. ... The fact that Microsoft is too lazy to implement a solution that effectively implements their desired policy isn't material to what the actually implemented policy enables.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22738180

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by bryanrasmussen on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:07AM (#30584980)
>The fact that Microsoft is too lazy to implement a solution that effectively implements their desired policy isn't material to what the actually implemented policy enables

This implies that at some point someone would be able to say, we have tried to implement a policy, we have spent this many man hours of engineers, we have had 5 different solutions that were broken through, at some point these things must become hacking.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by tedunangst on Sunday March 06, 2022 @11:00PM (#30584098)
Are youtube-dl users being charged with CFAA violations?
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by seanp2k2 on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:22AM (#30584478)
So long as the https://www.eff.org/issues/analog-hole exists, piracy cannot be stopped. The ever-escalating arms race between content and consumers will go on, but there will be no victory, only collateral damage.

If you have content people value but they aren't willing to pay for it, find out why. Maybe it's because you're charging too much, running too many ads, making it hard to cancel, or they just don't actually value it all that much. In YouTube's case, I would say that for the vast majority of content and the vast majority of users on the site, the content is worth approximately $0.00 to them, and the content is not so crucial that a few unskippable ads in a row will have most users just saying "forget it" and finding something else to do.

Yes, pointing a camera at a monitor is more work and worse quality than getting the original video with best-quality-possible [compressed] audio, but no amount of laws can prevent people from doing that if they really value the content highly.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by blibble on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:49AM (#30585904)
they can put fingerprints/watermarks into the analogue signal pretty easily if they're scared of that

plus the analogue hole is disappearing rapidly (including the 3.5mm jack)

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by armada651 on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:00AM (#30586329)
> plus the analogue hole is disappearing rapidly

As long as you can aim a camera at a monitor or put a Bluetooth speaker next to a microphone the analogue loop hole will never disappear.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by syshum on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:11AM (#30586818)
if that becomes the only avenue to rip a movie wide spread distribution of said movie with out permission will die

The idea that you would have lots of people getting up camera's and monitors to record a movie for distribution on the internet is laughable, and it would be a cam quality today so you would just end up with the early releases capture via someone setting in a theater which are generally poor quality

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by foo_barrio on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:36AM (#30588282)
I think software can create a good version of a video taken from a middle-tier camera. My 8-year-old DSLR, Nikon D750, can take 4k video at 60fps. Its sensor has more dynamic range than even high-end screens can produce. When I take a picture of my TV I can see individual pixels. That camera can capture every bit of info my screen is putting out. I bet from a 4k/60fps video from my camera you can process it to produce something closer to a 1080p/30fps BlueRay rip.

This was not the case with handy-cam theater rips. Those things were at best 480p and could never capture the picture projected on a screen even in the best conditions.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by easrng on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:22PM (#30591373)
Yeah, with a known resolution (1920x1080) and a stable camera it shouldn't be to hard to get a near-perfect rip.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by ziml77 on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:44AM (#30588387)
Then people will make a complex device that hooks in where the LED/LCD grid does and converts the signals intended to drive the panel into a video feed for recording. And making a device that directly takes the output of a Bluetooth device's DAC (or even grabbing the digital output directly) should be even trivial.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by Qub3d on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:10PM (#30596008)
Absolutely!

It wouldn't be easy, and would need some adjustments for colorspace etc but this is a method I have seen discussed online before.

The speaker part is much easier. At some point in almost all modern audio systems, there will be a PCM signal as part of the DAC step. Hook in here, pipe that signal to a computer's audio in / microphone port, and you've got a pretty clean audio stream.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by toyg on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:17AM (#30588066)
Poor quality but they still exist. If all digital versions were made unfeasible, you can bet good money that camripping would become more popular - and probably result in better-quality approaches at some point.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by blibble on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:24AM (#30589701)
fingerprinting can survive both of those
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by fluoridation on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:07PM (#30590335)
While someone is busy tracing that fingerprint, everyone has already copied and watched the video.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by blibble on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:47PM (#30590960)
the fingerprint disables the camera (or puts it into some sort of crappy mode)

if you want a real world example of this in practice: search for the EURIon constellation

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by fluoridation on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:00PM (#30591113)
Use an old camera.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by blibble on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:08PM (#30591214)
then when you try ingesting the footage into the machine/cpu/hard drive/router/cloud storage/...

it's not really something you can win as an individual on an infinite timescale

(unless you plan to keep your VHS around for the next few hundred years)

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by 14 on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:30AM (#30585109)
You gave me an idea if someone was to design a small display attached to a camera paired specifically to capture high quality video not just someone propping up a camera but where external light was blocked and the image size and camera are perfectly matched with an audio input as well they may have a market.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by dento on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:11AM (#30585352)
Why not skip the display completely and just go with a capture card? They are cheap and have none of the issues with lights and timings.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by adhesive_wombat on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:23AM (#30586914)
In theory, HDCP is supposed to prevent such use, by cryptographically verifying that the video isn't going to a device able to copy the media. Keys can be revoked by, say inserting a disc with a new set of revocations on it (alongside the media).

If you want to play such media, you have to license keys from Intel and show that your design is hostile to copying.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by account42 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @08:07AM (#30599436)
In theory, yes.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by 14 on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:36AM (#30585475)
I was just thinking with vendors making hardware more hostile and if they made that not a possibility where an external camera defeats that. If a capture card works then that seems even easier and if youtubedl is under attack maybe that is how people will do it but one thing is for sure, people will do it.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by diavolodeejay on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:02AM (#30587230)
You may be on something: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinescope

So yeah, it's possibile to do it, but nowadays isn't done because there are more pratical ways to record video

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by eashman on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @06:10PM (#30608617)
This is similar to how they would broadcast film on television in the early days - using a Kinescope.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinescope

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by alamortsubite on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:11AM (#30588688)
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by feanaro on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:32AM (#30586146)
We're not being a little too cute. If you are supposed to be able to access YouTube from Firefox or Chrome, then you are also supposed to be able to access it via youtube-dl, given all of those are HTTP clients. Saying otherwise would be setting a dangerous precedent of trying to legislate which HTTP clients are allowed and which are disallowed.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by lelandfe on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:21AM (#30586895)
Surely things like Widevine show that that precedent has already been set? There are many online things that cannot be consumed by unblessed clients.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by feanaro on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:24PM (#30591399)
Surely the fact that a single blemish exists does not imply that we should just curl up in a hole and admit defeat. The fact that Widevine exists does little to damage the core of the above argument.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by lelandfe on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:24PM (#30592208)
My point is that this is fundamentally not a viable argument anymore:

> If you are supposed to be able to access YouTube from Firefox or Chrome, then you are also supposed to be able to access it via youtube-dl

Were this an axiom, services like Netflix simply could not exist. We're defeated whether we admit it or not – browser DRM is not being yanked from browsers anytime soon. That's not even talking about its forebears, like Silverlight, Flash, Applets, etc.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by feanaro on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:12PM (#30594593)
The difference is DRM is a technical-only measure in most countries. The services employing DRM are scumbags, but they're welcome to try it.

That doesn't mean that ridiculous positions such as trying to legally forbid access to a website other than through a handful of sanctioned browsers is going to fly.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by paulcole on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:13AM (#30587319)
I can go to an all you can eat restaurant with my empty stomach. I can’t go to an all you can eat restaurant with an empty garbage bag to fill up with food for later.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by feanaro on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:37PM (#30591566)
It's a cute analogy, except it fails to explain why youtube-dl is the garbage bag in this instance.

If we step away from analogies for a bit, are you actually arguing that we shouldn't have the ability to modify the markup and the code before we display it on our computers?

If you insist on making a cute physical analogy, a more apt one would be of a tyrant buying out all the stores and allowing free entry on the condition that people's eyelids are forcibly taped open before they enter. After some reasonable people start removing the tape from their eyelids, the tyrant throws a tantrum and attempts to legislate away removing eyelid tape.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by paulcole on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:28PM (#30592243)
> it fails to explain why youtube-dl is the garbage bag in this instance

No it doesn't.

The buffet lets me eat as much as I want while I'm in their restaurant following their house rules. The garbage bag lets me take food out of the restaurant and consume a much larger amount of food however/whenever/wherever I choose – something the restaurant has forbid me to do according to their rules.

This feels very much like what Youtube DL allows me to do.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by feanaro on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:15PM (#30594615)
> something the restaurant has forbid me to do according to their rules.

Except they're not their rules. My computer, my rules.

I really wish you'd chosen to respond to my technical question instead, though.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by paulcole on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:33PM (#30595489)
> are you actually arguing that we shouldn't have the ability to modify the markup and the code before we display it on our computers?

I’m not arguing you shouldn’t have that ability.

Morally, I feel I’m bound to play by the rules of the service if I want to use that service. If they’re showing ads I find distasteful, then I don’t use that service. I don’t find some technical workaround that allows me to do something that I believe is fundamentally immoral.

The same as I wouldn’t take a garbage bag to a buffet, I won’t block ads on YouTube (or anywhere for that matter). In fact, I love that YouTube lets me pay $10 a month to not view ads. Are they still tracking me? Probably. Do I care? Not at all.

If you have different morals, awesome!

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by feanaro on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @10:04AM (#30600641)
Thanks for answering, I really appreciate it because it helps me to better understand your position.

I do feel the same general impetus not to be an ass to people. Not bringing a trash bag to steal all food from a buffet for myself is a part of my rule set too.

However, I feel strongly that websites are not very much alike to a physical place in which I have to observe the rules of the host. In fact, I cannot bring myself to view the website's code as rules.

To consider a web where I am merely a passive consumer of content served to me by an active publisher goes counter to the very nature of the open web with which I have grown up. The opposite view makes much more sense to me: I am an active participant and the website is the passive information vessel.

A malicious website enforcing its will on me feels like a decidedly perverted concept. My best attempt to explain why would be to liken it to an evil magic book which, upon being brought into my home, attempts controlling and limiting my behaviour. It is the book that is the guest inside my house and not the other way around!

I also do care about tracking quite a lot. I do not want to be tracked. To track me against my will feels like an act of aggression, or at least rude and distasteful, quite similar in tone to the actions of the rude garbage-carrying patron in your example.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by leothecool on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:51AM (#30589193)
As a garbage bag manufacturer, can you advertise that your garbage bags are for that purpose?
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by paulcole on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:27PM (#30592907)
No. But there are many great, moral, and legal uses for garbage bags which can be advertised.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by roastedpeacock on Sunday March 06, 2022 @10:30PM (#30583927)
> The interesting thing about this is that YouTube is clearly trying to make it more difficult for non-official clients to stream video, as is evident from the required workaround described here:

Can not reply with the entire situation but I would not be surprised if Google does not care enough to stop the project through other means but tries to reduce mindless zombie-bots from sucking up bandwidth all day long. If you have access to a fast connection you may notice even the web player is throttled sometimes.

Irrespective of that, the complaining party is the RIAA and not Google or YouTube in name.

> I 100% support youtube-dl and I want YouTube to stop interfering with it, but I also think we're being a little too cute when we pretend like ytdl isn't circumventing anything

I think the optics are a little different when it's a third party internet service as the medium, but 'we' are still arguing what constitutes fair-use of DRM protected physical media. :-(

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by icelancer on Sunday March 06, 2022 @11:25PM (#30584216)
>> If you have access to a fast connection you may notice even the web player is throttled sometimes.

This has been happening more and more recently - seriously slow playback when my Internet access is still ~1gbps on all other sites including fast.com/netflix, or Google Drive.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by seszett on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:43AM (#30584564)
> If you have access to a fast connection you may notice even the web player is throttled sometimes.

I'm not sure if that's still the case today, but in my case it used to be because of a dispute between Google and Free/Proxad (a French operator) which led to limited peering for years.

I'm pretty sure in your case it's also just anemic peering capacity between your ISP and Google, rather than Google as a whole lacking bandwidth. I haven't noticed anything at all here for example.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by agilob on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:55AM (#30585604)
>The interesting thing about this is that YouTube is clearly trying to make it more difficult for non-official clients to stream video

My Android One phone has camera app which has "stream to YouTube" functionality that stopped working in late 2020

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by gizmo686 on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:43AM (#30584562)
As I read that post, the circumvention applies only to a throttling control, not an overall access control. Since it should have been just as easy (if no easier) to simply block unofficial clients instead of throttling them, it seems like a clear argument that Google does not intend to block 3rd party Downloader, but merely give preferential treatment to first party ones.

If you by that argument. Then bypassing the protection might be illegal, but would not be a copyright issue, and Google would be the only one with standing to sue.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by foo_barrio on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:57AM (#30588514)
The throttling is so severe it is effectively blocking. The throttling goes down to 50KiB/s on my PC trying to download a basic youtube video. That around 0.4mbps which puts you barely around the bandwidth needed to stream a very low quality 360p/480p video. For reference, this video is about 2 minutes long and that's how long it took me to download it via the last version of youtube-dl:

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nVRInek075g

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by Nextgrid on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:44AM (#30586232)
Maybe it's a compromise because they still have their own legacy versions of the client that can't support the new scheme and yet need to remain at least semi-functional?
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by blowski on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:52AM (#30587151)
I'm sceptical there is a long-term solution for people to have all the content available on YouTube (and similar services) accessible by the freedoms we experienced in 1995-2005. You choose either the range of content, or the freedom of choice in how you access it.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by charcircuit on Sunday March 06, 2022 @09:35PM (#30583599)
btw that cipher is only on a subset of videos (usually music videos)
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by stuu99 on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:23AM (#30584485)
>I 100% support youtube-dl and I want YouTube to stop interfering with it

Well if you've bought any client-server app over the last 23 years its a bit too late for computing freedom. They are locking down IO with trusted computing, there's been a 23+ year initiative to move to encrypted computing to take input/output control away from the user, this required the co-operation of hardware manufacturers. Windows 10 and windows 11 are the beginning of you not being able to run or play files or exe's over the next 20 years as youtube, netflix, the game industry update their software to use TPM.

This was from 2001:

https://www.theregister.com/2001/12/13/the_microsoft_secure_...

Here is a paper explaining what the future of files/broadcasts will be like:

https://web2.qatar.cmu.edu/cs/15349/dl/DRM-TC.pdf

Basically they are building a parallel mainframe inside our PC's that only youtube, netflix, the game industry and other software companies will control. They are removing ownership of our devices and they needed microsofts help to do that.

We've seen mirosoft trial bricking cracked exe's via update. Many UWP games only work on certain versions of windows.

See here (ctrf-f then select the UWP link)

https://old.reddit.com/r/CrackWatch/comments/p9ak4n/crack_wa...

They are bringing console lockdown to the PC that is why windows 10 had forced updates. That is why windows 11 was also pushing forced internet connection hard for home users.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by TheRealDunkirk on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:17AM (#30586858)
Kind of insane that we’re turning our glorious revolution of cheap, general purpose computers back into TV’s in the name of protecting Big Copyright from a niggling amount of infringement.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by pydry on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:24AM (#30587412)
It's part of a wider war over who owns and controls general purpose computing which we're losing.

It's as much about downloading pirated copies of Finding Nemo as all encompassing network surveillance is about finding pedophiles.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by irrational on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:40AM (#30584553)
So, if I don’t use Windows then I’m fine?
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by heavyset_go on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:56AM (#30584919)
You'll be locked out of using your hardware's full potential, same goes for the software and media you use, too. Look at how Nvidia already locks nouveau developers out of using their GPUs' full power with cryptography.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by Iolaum on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:10AM (#30586811)
There are already non mainstream OEMs you can buy hardware from that won't have this problem. System76, entroware, Purism (laptops+smartphones), Frame.Work (not only Linux laptops) and other Linux manufacturers are there to serve you. On the mobile space there is Purism, Pine64 and FairPhone. In our dystopian future, if you want ownership of a computing device you 'll need buy a nieche one.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by arepublicadoceu on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:46AM (#30587100)
And good luck buying any of these devices if you’re outside of the blessed distribution centers.

Try buying any of those in Brazil or non US/UK/EU countries and you’re going to have tons of fun with import taxes and shipping.

Suddenly, a cheap device costs more than a flagship iPhone or android with none of their benefits except the intangible freedom.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by supercheetah on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:56AM (#30587792)
Slimbook in Spain is like the EU version of System 76.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by mardifoufs on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:23PM (#30592855)
Isn't system 76 european already?
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by Iolaum on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:07AM (#30589431)
Unfortunately that is so. In that case I 'd recommend (used or older) laptops compatible with linux and (older) phones known to be compatible with LineageOS (or postmarketOS if you are adventurous). This "solution" may not work everywhere in the world but hopefully it will cover a not insignificant part of non EU/US/UK.

One of the best purchases I ever made was a le eco le pro 3 phone once the company went bankrupt for half the retail price 5 years ago. Bought it because it already had LineageOS support. Today it runs Lineage OS 18.1 (android 11) like a champ, it can be make to run bank apps (passing safetynet) if I want to. Still lineage OS is not a silver bullet you either need to get lucky and pick a phone with a big enough following that volunteer devs will support or scout XDA threads in order to identify those phones before purchasing.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by heavyset_go on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:41PM (#30594339)
As far as I'm aware, all of those OEMs will ship Nvidia's proprietary drivers and not nouveau.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by mschuster91 on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:53AM (#30585935)
> Look at how Nvidia already locks nouveau developers out of using their GPUs' full power with cryptography.

The problem is not cryptography, the problem is copyright.

Nouveau could in theory upload the signed firmware blob from a legitimate driver to the GPU and build an interface to communicate with it. The problem is, the legitimate driver package prohibits any kind of modification outside the intended purpose, which means it's questionable if building and redistributing a tool to extract the firmware blob out of a driver package is legal, and it's certainly not legal to redistribute that extracted blob.

Here in Europe, at least the building and distribution of the tool as well as the act of the user to download the legitimate driver package, extract and use the blob should be legal, but that doesn't help if the developers of the project are outside of the EU :(

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:55AM (#30585944)
Maybe "full potential" could have multiple meanings. For example, one user might focus on hardware performance^1 while another might focus on hardware flexibility. Freedom, doing whatever it is they wish with the hardware they have purchased.

1. Only applicable to an "approved use" of the hardware.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by irrational on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:21AM (#30588107)
Well, I haven’t used Windows since 2002. I’ve been fine with my hardware speeds so far.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by jhanschoo on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:32AM (#30584786)
If you don't use Windows you may not be able to access the content. See: platforms on which Netflix 4K streaming is supported.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by RealStickman_ on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:57AM (#30585614)
This is clearly a service problem that justifies sailing the high seas.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by avhception on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:31AM (#30585802)
As long as you are able to purchase sufficiently fast hardware that lets you run other OSes and don't want to play games or watch videos on that hardware I guess.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by malka on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:45AM (#30585873)
I agree for games. They can be made extremely difficult to crack.

Videos are easy to though.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by faeyanpiraat on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:39AM (#30586198)
Just wait till they figure out how to emit light from the TVs which you can see but cameras cannot. :D
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by CrazyPyroLinux on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:35PM (#30593611)
That's where Nerualink comes in...
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by CraneWorm on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:46AM (#30586245)
as long as you pirate stuff you should be golden
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by conradev on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:52AM (#30585226)
Or macOS/iOS – both can enforce HDCP at the kernel level, for example
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by TrapLord_Rhodo on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:15AM (#30588737)
Creator revolt is the only way it seems to force the issue. If everyone started using a open-source medium of storing data and simply extended that to the other platforms, it would take away their control of the medium with which it is presented.

Filecoin might be a good usecase here.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by cuteboy19 on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:00AM (#30589348)
Except for the fact that filecoin advertises the ability to use DRM to protect NFTs ... or something. I have no idea what this post says except for a lot of buzzwords and something related to DRM

https://filecoin.io/blog/posts/filecoin-news-37/

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by r3muxd on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:31AM (#30584505)
I just wish something could be done about it all.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by hughrr on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:19AM (#30585390)
HDCP strippers and torrent sites are a thing.

I prefer my media from an ethical source, which means mkv on a usb stick. Even if I paid for the streaming service already.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by CactusOnFire on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:39AM (#30584544)
Use linux?

My next PC I am making the switch.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by mftb on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:33AM (#30585135)
I did. If you're a developer, for a personal machine it's both easy and straightforward (I have work provided machines that use other OS's but that's outside the scope of this post). Do a little research on HW that works well with Linux (I went all AMD). Purchase, wipe, install distro of your choice (I went with Manjaro, because of Arch, doesn't really matter). It's been about 2 years and I haven't had a single serious issue (serious as defined here is, can't boot or non-functional HW). I'm running most of the latest stuff, Sway on Wayland, pipewire, etc...
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by alias_neo on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:37AM (#30589002)
Better yet. Buy from a company that won't charge you for the Windows licence you don't want.

I'm a developer. I am also exclusively a nix/BSD user for about the past decade; my machines, servers, my wife's laptop, my work laptop etc, all nix/bsd.

When I bought my personal XPS 13 I contacted DELL customer support to buy a "Developer" version, it took 3 weeks to ship because they had to build it, rather than provide an off-the-shelf box with Windows pre-installed, but I saved something like £43.

It's not about the money, but I would rather have it in my pocket than give it to Microsoft for some software I _really_ don't want (or need).

Side note, I'm planning on buying a Framework next.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by mftb on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:24AM (#30589694)
Nice and yea, I would definitely consider going this route in the future.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by Gareth321 on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:33AM (#30585462)
Not a good alternative for the big middle distribution of computer skills of the computer user base. Web browser only? Great. Highly skilled? Great. Everyone else? It can be a nightmare. Linus' Linux Challenge videos (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0506yDSgU7M) provide excellent insight into the typical user experience for anyone beyond web browser only requirements and beneath administrator level. If you find yourself saying "what an idiot, how did he not know that "do as I say" would mangle his OS," you're definitively in the highly skilled camp.

Linux UX convention relies on the terminal as a matter of course. Almost everything not in the package manager requires use of the terminal. Even many of the package managed applications require tweaks and configuration via terminal. It's an open secret that package managers are largely inferior to the terminal anyway, in every distribution. The almost universal response to "I am having an issue with the package manager" is "use terminal." Bottom line: terminal is far less user friendly than an object oriented environment, and is often much slower. Until a flavour of Linux exists which never ever, for any reason ever, requires the use of the terminal, Linux will remain in the low single digits in terms of consumer market share. I don't think this will change, because if you ask the average Linux developer what they think of the terminal convention, they love it, and they think users just need to stop sucking so much.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by DoingIsLearning on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:30AM (#30586137)
Whenever people mentioned Linux UX and computer knowledge I always feel like I should evangelize that Zorin OS is alive and well, now at Zorin Core 16.

I use it for my parents, after they got fed up with Windows warnings and pop-ups for Windows 10 upgrade.

I am not sure they full understand they are using Linux, they just assume it is a 'free' windows version.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by Gareth321 on Monday March 07, 2022 @08:05AM (#30587259)
Thanks for the suggestion. I've never used it so I'll boot up a VM and give it a go.

I will be honest with you: I don't expect Zorin to have solved the CLI problem. For example, Radarr is an extremely popular tool for managing movies. It connects to usenet and torrent clients, as well as indexers and movie databases. It makes maintaining a home movie collection seamless.

Radarr is not in major package managers, and requires the CLI for install (https://wiki.servarr.com/radarr/installation#linux). In Windows, I double click an .exe. On Zorin (I assume) I will have to follow a reasonably complicated and time consuming installation process, full of opportunities to misconfigure the install.

This is just one example of many. Radarr isn't a super hardcore 1337 program. It's a very common application aimed at everyone who runs Plex. Until Zorin has a .exe equivalent for all applications like this, it's just not going to be a competitor to Windows, for users who need more than just a web browser, and those who are not IT administrators.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by tartoran on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:03AM (#30586342)
Can you compare Zorin to Ubuntu?
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by DoingIsLearning on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:46AM (#30586643)
Zorin 16 is based on Ubuntu 20.04.3, so everything you are used to is still there. The only difference is in the UI, with 'Windowish' looking widgets and a focus on usability for non-technical folks.

There are some more extra bells and whistles, as well as service support, in the pro version but I haven't used those in my family computers so I can't comment on that.

I don't want to be dismissive, Zorin is a massive effort but it is mostly a DE change, but it's a DE where they actually thought of the typical non-technical user and cater brilliantly to that.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by pcdoodle on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:35AM (#30587016)
Zorin looks pretty cool! just spent some time looking through their site.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by JeremyNT on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:35PM (#30590774)
This doesn't actually solve the problem, though. What's going on is that more systems are becoming reliant on "secure computing" to work properly, so (e.g.) Netflix won't stream full quality to your Linux PC.

On its own that may not seem like much, but the screws are being turned (albeit slowly). We'll reach a point where the only way to access any proprietary content on the web will also require running proprietary operating systems on DRM enabled hardware using secure boot. Banking sites won't work, video playback won't work, even access to textual content will eventually be restricted. This is because the browser vendors, the OS vendors, and the content distribution platforms are all colluding to create this future.

Linux on the desktop doesn't have enough users to push back in a meaningful way against this trend at this point (and I say that as a Linux user). 10 years ago, maybe, but now it's simply too late. Sure you'll still be able to run open source software on your Linux PC, and write your own code and run it, but you'll be prevented from accessing huge chunks of the Internet.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by adhesive_wombat on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:54AM (#30584909)
Dual boot on your current PC, no time like the present.

Bonus: you add years to the useful life of the machine, because most Linuxes fly even when Windows chugs.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by jimbob45 on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:01AM (#30584946)
Fifteen minutes to get up and running with Ubuntu or Mint if you stay focused. A lot of people don’t realize that LibreOffice, Steam, and Discord are all fully usable on Linux these days.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by Loughla on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:43AM (#30590007)
Switched my family to Mint a while ago. It is genuinely seamless. They didn't notice, other than the background changed (and I slowed my haranguing them about virus safety).

Not all Steam games are available, but enough are to keep you busy.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by hutzlibu on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:51AM (#30585922)
Have you watched the video, this guy linked? It basically tries this, from the perspective of a linux beginner switching from windows.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30585462

It is 15 minutes, if nothing goes wrong and you know what you are doing. If something goes wrong and you are not native with the terminal - good luck.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by adhesive_wombat on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:25AM (#30586114)
The point was not that Linux is grandma-friendly as an OS, the point was that you do not necessarily have to delay installing it until you get a new computer, and may even negate the need for a new computer (certainly it's added years to various laptops in my orbit).
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by hutzlibu on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:52AM (#30586294)
"Fifteen minutes to get up and running with Ubuntu or Mint if you stay focused."

This sounds to me like it is all easy and if it takes longer than 15 minutes, it is my fault for not being focused.

Well, as a matter of fact, I did install linux on various devices, dozen of times. And with my own customized manjaro install usb stick even in less than 15 minutes, with all my needed software up and running.

But I would never, ever tell anyone that he can expect a flawless install in 15 minutes. This is not realistic. It may happen, if you are lucky - but there are too many buggy drivers and compatibility issues and even official mainstream distros getting shipped with major open bugs, that this advise is just receipt for disapointement.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by acomjean on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:46AM (#30587099)
And zoom. I know Linux but I’m not a sys admin by any stretch. I’ve been using Linux as my personal laptop for 3 years now. It updates itself and has required hardly any manual intervention (just once I had to command line for an upgrade. Generally it’s justed worked.

The upgrader/installers are not perfect but it’s hardly so difficult that software developer would find it daunting.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by godmode2019 on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:00AM (#30585637)
You can just put linux on a USB and boot it from the USB on each startup.

Makes it easy to try before you commit to dual booting.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by stuu99 on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:34AM (#30584526)
Unfortunately there is no freedom under capitalism mon capitan, it's part and part of private ownership. American copyright law grants companies state like powers to remove your rights and freedoms.

The only way would be to either 1) revolt against capitalism or 2) try to reform copyright law.

But as we all know the US is the most worshipful of capitalist ideology.

Software coming under copyright allows companies to remove out rights because we never got any property rights for software and games. That allows them to encrypt binaries and make computers that obey them and not us.

So you could call the FTC and launch an anti-trust complaint. https://www.ftc.gov/

Because DRM is vendor lockin when you get down to it.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by bnjms on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:09AM (#30584989)
Anti-capitalism isn’t enough for you to sell as an alternative. We really don’t have a serviceable alternative ideology given the tendency for communism to fall under control of a few men same as capitalism. The Reddit subs can point out some of the problems with Capitalism but not alternatives.

At some point the only option will be to use something like an rPi with a Linux and only interact with the culture made from the next punk movement. Or, targeted violence somewhere. But where.

I think both 1 and 2 are ripe for action. The right person can explain that the assumptions we’ve been sold about capitalism no longer resemble truth and we need to change the rules so they do.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by stuu99 on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:16AM (#30585028)
The real issue is company ownership is anti-democratic so we can't stop EA or activision from making games in fraudulent ways, so we'd need to have some ownership share over the company because it effects us politically.

There's no other way then private power being co-owned with the rest of society, aka there are certain things private individuals and companies can't engage in. That is the only explanation because corporations have state like powers at scale which all effect us. So capitalist ideology is still the root cause, there is no other alternative. AKA bobby kotick can say to his employee's "make games with drm" and the employee's must obey or be fired, that is the fundamnetal problem with capitalism in a nutshell. If someone who owns a powerful business is a giant dick there's no way to push back unless you give up the idea of owernship being in the hands of one or a small group of owners that can simply compel our obedience to their rules.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by mikem170 on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:07AM (#30588634)
Maybe part of the problem is that the limited liability companies enjoy is no longer descendant on them performing a public good [1].

I'd add that we also enshrined money as equivalent to speech, effectively allowing corporations and the rich to run much of our politics [2].

[1] https://ptolemy3.medium.com/but-corporations-are-private-com...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_united

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by scarygliders on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:47AM (#30585196)
> The real issue is company ownership is anti-democratic

Wrong. Company ownership is perfectly democratic.

> need to have some ownership share over the company because it effects us politically

This happens now with share ownership.

> AKA bobby kotick can say to his employee's "make games with drm" and the employee's must obey or be fired, that is the fundamnetal problem with capitalism in a nutshell.

Every single time communism has been tried, it inevitably ends up that ultimate power rests in the hands of a few. It turns out way, way worse than capitalism, and belief that scrapping capitalism in favour of socialism (which Lenin stated is the path to communism) or jumping straight to communism, is always - always! - from either young idealistic but naive people, or believed by older people who never grew out of their earlier naive disgruntlement.

Besides which, I still believe now in my early 50's that what we have now isn't capitalism at all; it's more akin to corporatism. It's certainly not lassez-faire capitalism.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by heavyset_go on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:03AM (#30585296)
> This happens now with share ownership.

No it doesn't, you can not own shares in a company and still have it affect you. You can also own shares and have no voting rights, either.

Share ownership is, as it stands, undemocratic in the sense that there is no democratic decision making by all of those who are affected by a company. And a model where wealth decides how many votes you get isn't very democratic, either.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by bigfudge on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:06AM (#30586774)
This is written from a position of ignorance on European companies. There are successful midpoints between US style capitalism and communism. In Germany, for example, company boards (for large firms) have worker representation: https://www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Rela...

Heck - even functioning trade unions (not crippled as they are in the UK and US) provide a form of democratic check on individual companies.

The mistake is to paint this as a black or white choice, which tendency in the US is driven by hysteria media reporting of any policy which doesn't suit the needs of big business and rich elites.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by thereddaikon on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:11AM (#30588699)
What Marx calls socialism and what Western Europeans style as socialism aren't the same thing. Western European nations practice social democracy which developed before and independently of Marx.

When discussed without stupid names and branding, most people are open to discussing some of the ideas you are presenting. But the moment you call it socialism you are going to lose people, especially Americans. Because a lot of people have been murdered in the name of socialism.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by heavyset_go on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:50PM (#30594408)
> Western European nations practice social democracy which developed before and independently of Marx.

When we look at Germany and their universal healthcare system, it was developed in the 1880's under Otto von Bismarck and their monarchy in a direct response to the fears of a Marx-inspired socialist uprising.

A lot of what developed in Europe was inspired by Marx and socialist organizing and developments on the continent.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by mschuster91 on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:01AM (#30585979)
> Wrong. Company ownership is perfectly democratic.

It's not because a lot of shares end up owned by one of the few large ETF/pension plan administrators: in 88% of the S&P 500 companies [1], Vanguard/BlackRock/State Street together own the majority of the shares, and at least the passive ETF-held parts usually do not participate in voting which means that tiny "activist" investors now have a lot more vote percentage than they should.

Not to mention corporates with different share classes where the ones with voting rights are to a large degree privately held and the ones traded publicly do not have vote rights, such as Tesla [2].

> Every single time communism has been tried, it inevitably ends up that ultimate power rests in the hands of a few.

So where's the difference to the current situation, where those with the "ultimate powers" in society are effectively under control of their party donors? At least in communism, everyone had a right to a home to live in and to a decent employment matching his skill (see e.g. Art 24 sec. 1 of the Constitution of the former GDR [3]).

[1]: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/business-and-politic...

[2]: https://www.thestreet.com/investing/stocks/how-elon-musk-con...

[3]: https://www.kas.de/c/document_library/get_file?uuid=9c5c691c...

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by falcolas on Monday March 07, 2022 @09:53AM (#30588471)
Plus, I ask when did democracy get defined as “those who can pay get a say”?

Also, non-public companies exist.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by zirobi on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:50AM (#30585569)
Interestingly, this belief is never shared by people from Europe who've actually experienced communism.

The issue in many cases is _corruption_ which will exist whatever you do (there's always a snake in the garden) so the trick is to implement the right legislation to control it and ensure freedom...

...which admittedly is easier said than done!

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by brigandish on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:14AM (#30585021)
> The only way would be to either 1) revolt against capitalism or 2) try to reform copyright law.

Since (2) precludes the need for (1) and, hence, shows (1) is irrelevant to the discussion, and to do (1) would be an immense act of self harm akin to sticking one's fingers in one's eyes, repeatedly, for all time, I'll take (2), thanks.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by stuu99 on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:18AM (#30585040)
You can go ahead but the history of the last 200 years suggest reformism doesn't work.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Term_Extension_Act#/...

Corporations got their way every time over the last 200 years. There has never been a time where copyright was pared back in the public interest.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by pbhjpbhj on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:44AM (#30585181)
In the UK we got format shifting rights for a year or so, that was a minor, temporary paring back!
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by brigandish on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:12AM (#30596960)
Until the alternative given is not dump capitalism then reformism is the only option I'll be backing, as the least worst of a sorry bunch.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by ehvatum on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:46AM (#30586247)
> Unfortunately there is no freedom under capitalism mon capitan

If only the government prevented you and I from exchanging goods and services, all our problems would be solved, says the Communist.

Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by dukeofdoom on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:03AM (#30585985)
We might end up in a situation in the near future where China provides the more open solutions. Russia will now use Chinese UnionPay to get around MasterCard and Visa banning Russian clients. I have gen2 ipod touch that the hardware is perfectly fine, but no way to update the software that I know.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by xionon on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:32AM (#30588927)
You think that China, famous for it's nationwide firewall, will provide open solutions?
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by dukeofdoom on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:45AM (#30589107)
What's possible is that China will have one policy for its own citizens, but another for the rest of the World. They have proven to be very flexible on ideology if it makes them rich.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by 1234letshaveatw on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:59AM (#30589340)
Just ask Jack Ma
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by crtasm on Monday March 07, 2022 @04:39PM (#30593650)
How many UWP games are there? That page lists six and the stickied post from last April say MS no longer makes UWP exclusive games.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues by reshie on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:34AM (#30584802)
it is practically a wget for web videos and can be forwarded to like mpv. you should look at the supported sites it is quite extensive and youtube being a humble beginning.