Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues
by lelandfe on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:21AM
(#30586895)
Surely things like Widevine show that that precedent has already been set? There are many online things that cannot be consumed by unblessed clients.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues
by feanaro on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:24PM
(#30591399)
Surely the fact that a single blemish exists does not imply that we should just curl up in a hole and admit defeat. The fact that Widevine exists does little to damage the core of the above argument.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues
by lelandfe on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:24PM
(#30592208)
My point is that this is fundamentally not a viable argument anymore:
> If you are supposed to be able to access YouTube from Firefox or Chrome, then you are also supposed to be able to access it via youtube-dl
Were this an axiom, services like Netflix simply could not exist. We're defeated whether we admit it or not – browser DRM is not being yanked from browsers anytime soon. That's not even talking about its forebears, like Silverlight, Flash, Applets, etc.
Re:The campaign to shut down YouTube-dl continues
by feanaro on Monday March 07, 2022 @06:12PM
(#30594593)
The difference is DRM is a technical-only measure in most countries. The services employing DRM are scumbags, but they're welcome to try it.
That doesn't mean that ridiculous positions such as trying to legally forbid access to a website other than through a handful of sanctioned browsers is going to fly.