Here's the thing, though: most Europeans seem to be suffering some pretty serious misconceptions.
First, Americans build out of wood because we have wood, lots of it. Europeans don't skip wood because brick or stone is superior -- it's because Europe is largely deforested. Europe doesn't have wood for people to use at the same scale.
Second, wooden houses last a plenty long time. "80-150+ years", as you put it, is entirely expected for a well-constructed wooden house. Neighborhoods that date from, say, 1850, e.g. in New England, have plenty of old wooden homes that people adore because of their character.
Third, wood construction has a ton of advantages. Not only is it less expensive to build, but it's tremendously more energy-efficient when filled with insulation. Brick and stone homes are absolute energy guzzlers both in hot summers and cold winters. And remember, e.g. in New York State you're dealing with 100°F (38°C) summers and -10°F (-23°C) winters. Insulation matters.
The idea that American homes are somehow lower quality or shorter-lasting because they're built out of wood is a myth through and through. To the contrary, they're built out of wood because that's the best construction for local climate and availability.
1) New houses in the UK are very well insulated indeed. Walls are commonly of cavity construction with 'lightweight' thermal blocks or timber on the inside skin, and insulation in the cavity. We also indsulate the floors and roofs. Our building code is pretty strict about insulation and I believe that is also true in Germany for instance.
2) We use brick on the outside because the UK climate makes external wood rot very quickly in normal circumstances. Cedar cladding can work if left to 'silver', but you have little chance of keeping paint on anything. Exterior woodwork also has to be treated with fire retardant if used as cladding. Roof coverings are normally clay tiles or slate.
There are buildings in my town that are 600+ years old, built out of oak framing with wattle and daub infills...but this is a very expensive way to build.
Source: my family in Norway owns several wooden houses that are a couple of hundred years old, and as a kid/teenager I spent a lot of time having to treat these houses :)
There's also the fact that when the ground is frozen, the microbes in the soil that cause rot and decay are less active. The constant dampness of UK soil means any wood that touches the ground is rotted through in a couple of years unless you take significant precautions, while in Iceland, the ground being frozen or dry a large part of the year makes this less of a problem.
I also live here in the PNW and I know what you mean by the ugly boxes, but that is what people want.
Cedar shake looks very nice, but perhaps it is a bad idea when there is a non-zero chance of a neighbourhood fire blowing embers onto your roof. Here in western Canada, the Fire Smart guides are great. e.g., https://firesmartbc.ca/
There are some brick buildings, and there are some things you can do to reinforce them in preparation for an earthquake. But in general, wood is better.
114 days vs 170 days. UK has more frequent rain.
Was just curious so looked it up and shared. Not drawing any conclusions. I actually find it hilarious that so many of the comments here are trying to distil such a complex and nuanced cultural difference down to stats and logic :)
I realize I use different sources, and that maybe all forests are not equally good for lumber production. But Europe has as much forests as the US. Yes, a lot of it is concentrated in Scandinavia and Eastern Europe, so traditionally, that would have been less accessible to most central and western European countries. Also, traditionally, there was far more farm land. But nowadays, Europeans could access lumber as easily as Americans.
1:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forests_of_the_United_States#:.... 2:https://www.forestresearch.gov.uk/tools-and-resources/statis...
EU: 161,000,000 ha
ha = ac / 2.4711
818,814,000 / 2.4711 = 331,356,076
Ok, the US has roughly double the forested surface area.
EU pop is 448m compared to US' 328m. So with 30% more population and half the forested surface area wood does seem scarser in the EU.
https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL?locations=E...
Then again, including Canada would probably as well.
In any region, there are going to be specific factors of soil, climate, infrastructure, etc. that all affect how you would build homes. Transporting materials is expensive, so the availability of local materials is also a factor, though less of a factor than it used to be.
Builders and skilled tradesman in any region are going to have knowledge and practical experience with these local factors, and with the techniques and materials that address those factors. And to some degree, you're better off with the type of house that they're really good at building than the type of house that they're less experienced with.
If you're comparing the US and EU though, I think you also need to account for culture and language barriers. Construction techniques and materials across the US are more similar because builders and tradesmen from Oregon, Arizona, Texas, and Florida can all communicate more easily than builders and tradesman from across Europe.
I'm pretty sure Scandinavian houses do tend to use wood. Likewise, less forested parts of the US, like Arizona, tend to have fewer wooden houses.
I'm an American and I look at the things we do and they seem to be a combination of stupidity and greed.
You can look at strongtowns.org and many other places for a summary of the illogical, unsustainable and short-term-greed fueled quality of American urbanism.
With modern buiding techniques - building an air tight home and then ventilating with mechanical ventilation, and taking into account thermal bridging - that's no longer true. If anything the extra thermal mass, compared to a wooden framed house, helps to keep it more comfortable and reduce energy consumption during day-night temperature swings. Some bricks, e.g. clay blocks with air pockets inside [0], are both structural and somewhat insulating - you could use them for something like a garage without any other insulation. If you are cheap you don't even need a facade :D
A lot of Central Europe has similar climates to NY - my area had -25C in the winter and 36C just this week. We usually don't even turn on the heating until it gets below 0C outside, as our home is more than comfortable enough (above 21C / 70F) inside until then.
Not gonna argue with the expensive part (there's a reason why people don't build 5000sqft homes here), however it is worth mentioning in most desirable places to build, it is often the land that is the most expensive part.
[0] https://www.wienerberger.com/en/brands-and-products/wall.htm...
Not that I would expect Americans to just copy what we do, but the outright refusal to acknowledge that someone else is doing things that seem impossible is at times hilarious.
All that with the obvious exception, everything military.
Edit: American houses are lower build quality because of lower build quality. Not because they are build out of wood. They are also considerably cheaper.
We’re not asking you to believe in some “American Dream,” just notice that we also have hundreds of millions of people who make highly varied decisions that conform to natural environments and resources, historical contexts, cultural preferences and financial limits.
The US is in the stone age when it comes to wall construction (for longevity and energy savings), vapor control, doors and windows.
I have a small project and I am having to order my windows, house wrap/wrb and tape from European suppliers.
This does not encourage a culture of energy savings. Relevant experience just is not as deeply ingrained. Yet, if I may hope so.
Some examples, just concerning windows, unfortunately without references:
- One can still buy and legally install single pane windows in most of the US.
- A significant share of new windows in the US apparently still are double pane.
- New windows in the US are still often filled with air instead of specialised gases.
- Multi-chambered pvc windows are still being marketed as a tech innovation in some places in the US, while these are bog standard bottom line products even in the Baltic states.
- Try and ask your average window installer about air tightness seals and blower door tests.
[0] https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_pri_sum_a_EPG0_PRS_DMcf_m.htm
[1] https://www.milieucentraal.nl/energie-besparen/inzicht-in-je...
Most of NZ gets cold enough to need (at least) double paned windows, and all of NZ needs low-emissivity glass to reduce heat gain in summer. I believe the same is true of Australia.
NZ's current building standards are state of the art for the 1970s.
As gp said, specifying ordinary modern designs, materials and and fittings (by European standards) gets you looked at as though you're from outer space.
NZ's housing stock is cold, damp, and mouldy inside for the most part. Not coincidentally NZ has one of the highest rates of asthma in the world.
According to my calculations, the return on investment on reduced electricity costs will come in about 100-200 years, if not more.
In the meantime, if my house will end up in the market, it would hardly sell for any premium over any other house of similar footage in that area, so it's unlikely I would ever recover these costs.
Secondly, NZ, OK, maybe it won't need even double glazing. But aren't AU summers super hot?
I agree that it "should". The added costs don't justify it, that's why it usually doesn't. In my region, ROI on triple glazing is in hundreds of years.
I worked in a wood barn in my youth that was built in 1680 in upstate NY, and will remain standing as long as the roof is maintained. My current home is a circa 1910 wood frame house that is in great shape and should be for years to come. There’s nothing wrong with wood.
> Brick and stone homes are absolute energy guzzlers both in hot summers and cold winters.
That is not my experience, but a difference is maybe in how we heat things. This article about local heating explains my philosophy pretty well: https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2015/03/local-heating.html When it's cold, I tend to stay in the room where my computer is and wear a jacket. I do think that it's possible due to how Europe and especially France has a more temperate climate than the US though.
> wood construction has a ton of advantages. Not only is it less expensive to build
The comparaison doesn't really hold as in Europe it's easier to leverage old houses, due to the history of Europe. I don't think any new houses are made of stone.
It's really nice to have people like you point out misconceptions that Europeans can have, but please remember than you can have misconceptions too, and that Europe as a whole (like the US) is very large and has different climates. Not everything you said will hold in France, Spain, Ukraine, Greece, Norway.
All the other differences (ie isolation) can be achieved (or messed up) with either form of construction.
Chopping down Brazilian rainforest for rare woods or cow grazing is environmentally unfriendly. Using commercial softwoods is supporting carbon sequestration and is probably more sustainable than most agriculture.
I hope empress trees become usable in construction, they grow insanely fast.
2) I spent a year working in D.C. and watched 4-5 houses come up in the neighborhood during that time. The amount of insulation used was _laughable_. Watching builders on YouTube I get the same impression. In Sweden 99% of houses are wood, but all have at the very least the double amount of insulation, often more.
Aerated concrete doesn't have that issue, because the concrete cells are closed and don't draft. If you end up with a poorly fitted window or 50+ mph winds, it doesn't let air through.
OTOH, totally agree about wood. Cheap(er), plentiful, and most importantly, everyone already knows how to work it and has the tools to do so.
Masonry work is physically harder, requires a sounder foundation that won't settle at all due to the increased weight, and there are fewer people willing to do the work. Getting anyone to do foam or aircrete is impossible- you have to watch a bunch of YouTube videos and DIY it yourself.
You're not wrong, but IMHO the two should be handled separately. The fact that airtightness has been less stringent in the US is mostly an accident of history, which is being improved with recent building codes. It's just that in the past it was easy for people to simply buy some fluffy stuff and stuff it into the walls: doing blower door tests is a lot more complicated.
Building science has also progressed quite rapidly in the last 2-3 decades, and we now 'know better' in many areas than in the past.
> Aerated concrete doesn't have that issue, because the concrete cells are closed and don't draft. If you end up with a poorly fitted window or 50+ mph winds, it doesn't let air through.
First: what's the carbon footprint of concrete? What is footprint of wood framing?
Not letting air through (in or out) is actually what you want. The structures of buildings should not pass any air at all ideally, and all air exchanges should be done primarily via mechanical means:
Such is, my point was that foam boards and concrete are compared to blown / rolled fiberglass, even though the fiberglass has more failure modes for insulating. A poorly fitted window will seriously compromise the R value of the surrounding fiberglass.
As for the carbon footprint of cement, solid is pretty high, foam not so much. I don't know about commercial stuff, but most DIY'ers seem to use a little under 100 lbs portland cement to make a 55 gallon barrel's worth once the foam is mixed in. Rough math puts a 55 gallon barrel of concrete at about 1000 pounds.
Edit: I just realized that 10% seems low, so what I saw may have used a 55 gallon barrel but not completely filled it. In any case, depending on the structural integrity that you need, the weight reduction (and therefore carbon footprint from curing) is significantly reduced.
Having said that, your point about footprint holds and building with wood is coming 'back' here especially because of that, using cross laminated timber from sustainable forests.
Carbon footprint of wood framing is terrible, because its mostly made of engineered wood with a lot of oil in it.
[citation needed]
Certainly LVL and LSL products are more processed, as is OSB, but those have the advantage of using 'off cuts' so they can use up some of raw materials that might otherwise be thrown out.
Even with all that processing I find it hard to believe that it would be worse than concrete, given the amount of (fossil fuel?) energy needed for cement kilns and other things.
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_concre...
Standard Assessment Producedure (which is used for household energy ratings) incorporates both this and some fudge factors for draftiness and local wind speed.
You misunderstand building construction. American insulation is, indeed, rated by R value, its resistance to the conductive flow of heat. *Any* draft will bypass insulation of any material. A leaky window will leak air, regardless of the construction material of the wall. American wooden buildings are sealed with sheet plastic, Tyvek, etc. to prevent drafts; all part of the insulation.
Tyvek: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/TyvekAs for the wall material stopping drafts in a window frame, that makes no sense at all.
I've never had a draft through a fibercement/wood/fiberglass/drywall wall, in any case.
Cracking is why single family homes generally avoid concrete walls in the permafrost.
Hi there, I'm a civil engineer from the EU who specialized in building structures and was trained in masonry and timber structures.
None of the concerns you mentioned feature as a design constraint. There is no shortage of building materials in Europe, and is indeed cheaper than the classical building materials. We do use a lot of concrete, masonry, and steel, none of which grows on trees.
The main factor is population density, and the ultimate and serviceability state that buildings need to comply with in order to be assuredly safe to be habitable by people.
It's fine if you wish to build a single-family home with a timber structure from top to bottom, provided that you do all the work to ensure that expected win loads are not able to blow out your home. There are homes being built like that around here. But those are indeed rare, because of cultural differences. The everyday joe around here looks at modern timber homes and, when compared with masonry, concrete, and even steel structures, immediately perceives it as low-quality work. Think McMansion. Prefabricated homes in general suffer from that prejudice, including light steel frame homes. That in turn leads to a market where most offerings target the low-end.
On higher density residential buildings things are quite different. most residential buildings have 4 or 5 stories and thus structural soundness starts to be harder to ensure. You no longer are able to meet safety requirements by having a low-skilled carpenter randomly nailing together two boards. Moreover, the loads are more demanding, both dead loads and live loads such as wind Here the problem lies in the need to put together building structures that is verifiably safe involving cases where the minimum prescribed values in building standards don't cut it anymore. More importantly, you start to need to design specialized structural elements that can easily need to span over 6 meters. This is engineered timber territory, and one which can involve designing specialized structural elements. To add to the complexity, this technology introduces problems in complying with serviceability limit states that don't pose as big of a challenge with other technologies such as vibration limits and sagging.
Consequently, we do see engineered lumber structures in long span structures and even foot bridges, but in general it's more cost effective, simpler, durable, lower-mainrenance and higher-quality to just build with other building technologies.
Wood frame houses don't have that.
We don't have that in most of America. Having a high thermal mass in New England just means your heater has to work harder in the winter to heat your thermally massive house. Ditto for Arizona during most of the year.
Owning a concrete block house feels like all my money is going through the walls. Even if you have the AC on in the summer, you can touch the walls from the inside and they feel warm. I’m definitely going to need to look at insulation going forward.
Wood framed houses can have thermal mass to keep a stable temperature. This is more common with homes with exposed wood framing, and SIP on the outside.
That's a lot of industrial processing with a lot of oil-based glues and so on. By weight, the houses are almost more oil than wood.
Here's an enlightening chapter of "Well there's your problem" podcast about this with actual civil engineers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVodkE47aLw
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete_masonry_unit
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foam_concrete
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expanded_polystyrene_concrete
In fact, if you google "uk new builds" almost every image that comes up is a red brick house.
For black metal, it's the most obvious method — welding.
For sheet metal, it's clinching, snaps, or, more rarely, threaded fasteners.
I agree about European deforestation. Wood from the Russian Taiga and the Amazon are illegally imported as a result, that’s so embarrassing and wrong.
I did list specially treated wood in the list of building materials btw, you might have overlooked that. I agree that wood can be a great material for building modern houses, when combined with other materials. Homes purely made of wood would be too unsafe for me personally (fire hazard, termites in the US, high susceptibility to outside forces).
1: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ninety-percent-of-u...
2: https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/use-of-energy/homes.php
"Ninety Percent of U.S. Homes Are Under Insulated"
Yes, because Ninety Percent of U.S. Homes Were Built With Old(er) Building Codes.
> Yes, European homes are also underinsulated, but bricks provide better insulation per default.
A lot of Europe is a lot more temperate than the US and Canada, so it didn't make much of a difference. I'm in Toronto, Canada, and we regularly get -15C winter weather as well as >30C (>80% RH) summer days too. To stay comfortable you really need heating and cooling. Many buildings in the EU don't have cooling (which has caused all sorts of problems during heat waves).
The US has eight climate zones (AK not shown):
* https://www.ecohome.net/guides/3521/climate-zones-map-usa-ca...
And while a lot of the construction techniques would be the same regardless of location (e.g., air tightness), other things would not (insulation, HVAC equipment).
Most public housing projects in Vienna, Austria, were retrofitted with modern insulation in the timespan of 10-20 years ago. Public funding exists in various EU countries for home owners to do the same.
> A lot of Europe is a lot more temperate than the US and Canada, so it didn't make much of a difference.
The number of households in Sweden, Finland, and Norway combined is comparable to Canada. Temps seem to be similar there. In Austria we get -10 and sometimes -15 degrees Celcius in winter, and up to 35 degrees in summer. Same in Germany, where 18% of EU inhabitants live. Bricks are a staple in energy conservation in big parts of Europe.
They, like Canada, have a convenient source of wood in the boreal forests.
Multi-story buildings in cities are typically prefabricated concrete modules, sometimes clad in brick, sometimes just painted.
It also matters how one determines under-insulated. Energy here is cheap; we use big trucks as commuter cars. Using half our electricity for heating and cooling didn't matter until CO² usage became important; now it's huge.
Sure, 50 years ago. Modern code calls for a lot of insulation.
Also, while there is more wood in North America, it’s not like there are no forests in Europe. Take a look at Romania or Bosnia if you want to see big wild ones.
Site note: can't stand the amount of noise(!) going throw the house as opposed to concrete.
Having grown up in the United States and lived over a decade in various parts of Europe, I find U.S. construction quality and expectations (esp. modern) absolutely dismal. It’s truly in the space of relative deprivation. In no way are most of the property structures worth their market prices (pre-bubble).
I spoke to a Swiss colleague who lives part time in the States recently about this. He attempted to have a house built to modern Swiss design spec. where he was living (climatically similar to the Schweizer Mittelland) and gave up due to infeasibility. Money was not the problem; knowledge, at-grade quality inputs, etc. are all lacking in the United States. And I’d believe it being in CH now and today. I’ve kept an eye open for quality execution on all of my return trips (various parts of the country), and I just don’t see anything that can hold a candle to modern construction in DACH.
Simple quality of life improvement for many buildings Stateside would be retrofitting these onto more doors: https://planet.ag/produkte/produkteuebersicht/. Folks deserve noise, smell, and climatic isolation. You don’t know what you are missing. I’d easily spend $50 a night more for hotels that’d use these. I don’t want to be able to hear a mouse fart from a room down the hall unattenuated at perfect fidelity.
You say "Money was not the problem". I take that to mean your friend was reasonably not willing to pay as much as an order of magnitude more in the US than average (say a range of $300-1K psf for just the improvement and not including the dirt). Generally, if he went to high-end commercial builders, opened a checkbook, and said, "use these materials and parts, build to these specs and tolerances", he'll get whatever he wants in the US.
Compare average US tract residential SFH construction build quality to what you find in private venture companies that builds and operate their own MFH's. While the interiors are similar, the private venture companies are staffed by people who know what will and will not work in the bones of the structure over the investment payoff timeline. They won't care about insulation for the tenants' benefit, but they will make very certain for example that the walls, roof and foundation stand for as long as they project to hold the investment.
The US aggressively min-maxes for the wealthy capital-holding class. It is no accident that if you want something done right and will last, you will avail yourself of the same kinds of resources that class will use themselves.
I've lived in wood houses all my life, all of them built between 1920 and 1950.
Balloon construction has, generally speaking, been great. The frames are strong and light, easy to run cabling/utilities, easy to modify/remove/renovate (You know what else I've done in every house I've owned? Moved at least one wall - in my current house we just completely modified the layout of the upstairs. Moving the walls cost on the order of a few hundred dollars each, since they weren't structural supports, and it's just wood and drywall)
Basically - They're cheaper, better for the environment, and when cared for last a LONG time. Do they have some specific downsides? Sure. But overall they work fantastically well.
Also - if you think concrete is sturdier than wood frames... in most cases I suspect you're wrong for residential homes. I live in a temperate rain forest (Atlanta, GA) the pine trees are HUGE, and they fall constantly - they hit houses a lot. Most take damage, but it's usually easy to repair, and honestly, the wood frame alone usually keeps people inside safe. Hundreds of houses a year take tree hits, and having someone die is rare enough it usually makes the news. Wood is tough. I've seen a 100ft pine literally bounce off a house.
FWIW, if you are concerned about fire, you should be aware that it's really the contents of the house that pose the greatest risk. You can get to flashover temperatures in a matter of minutes before any of the wood structure is burning.
All in all, correctly built wooden houses are pretty much as safe and sturdy as anything else.
The things that do burn are furniture, paint, drapes etc and are present in any house.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/idahonews.com/amp/news/local/ho...
Because wood is a renewable resource, not a source of carbon emissions (like concrete), and is absolutely strong enough for single family homes.
Termites are a constant battle for my parents there in their concrete home. I can't imagine the carnage with a wood frame home.
I lost a piece of furniture there living in a condo, downtown in the city. The termites are industrious.
Time to bring the Latvian video back up again: https://youtu.be/G-J86Ka9MkQ
My point is that building of brick/concrete doesn't guarantee you're rid of flammable infrastructure.
I'll take a typical drywall panels on a wooden frame over wooden walls.
I always thought that the reason that winter air is dry is because warm air can hold more moisture than cold air, so as you heat it, relative humidity decreases. So, for example, if it's 5C outside with 50% relative humidity, if you heat that air to 22C, then it will have only 17% relative humidity.
But modern houses (even wood ones) are so well sealed that even in winter you could end up with too much humidity inside just from normal activities (cooking, bathing, breathing).
There was a tornado just a few days ago in the Czech Republic (not far from where I live), and as far as I can see, houses did lose their roofs, or the shingles at least, but the structures remained mostly intact. Many houses have basements in which people could hide in relative safety. Five people died unfortunately, not sure how many of those were in their homes at the time. But I think those rather sturdy houses made of bricks did infact save a lot of lives, and prevented many more from totally losing their home.
To me it feels deeply illogical to build a house basically made of light wood frames when I know a hurricane can blow it away while I‘m inside of it. I‘m not sure about earthquakes, we have them of course, but they are less severe than in other areas in the world.
A log cabin would not have survived the worst areas of it I don't believe.
There's a saying: It's not THAT the wind is blowing,it's WHAT the wind is blowing.
EF4 or EF5 tornadoes are around 2% of those in the US (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tornadoes_in_the_United_States), which means any state with more than 34 or so a year can expect to see at least one. That accounts for 14 states with a combined population of about 106 million people. That's approximately 32% of the total US population.
8%-ish of tornadoes rate EF3. At which point any state with seven or more a year should expect at least one in the EF3-5 range (yay, birthday paradox!). That's 32 states totaling 270 million people - 82% of the US.
Looking at this image (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Improved_Average_Annual_T...) from the wikipedia article you linked shows this, with New Orleans, Atlanta and Miami being outside their state's main tornado zone and Houston and Chicago right at the border of high-tornados and medium-tornados.
I think the overall point is sound, though. A huge chunk of the US population is in territory regularly subject to strong tornadoes.
Also, I would beg to differ that this map puts Chicago at the edge of a high-tornado zone. It's solidly in one, as is Kansas City.
But your larger point stands.
Hurricanes are far more destructive and many spawn tornadoes. About 44% of Americans live in a Hurricane zone.
Add earthquakes and fires maybe 60~70% of Americans live in a place with reoccurring natural disasters.
But, tornadoes here follow similar paths over a fifty year period. When I bought my house I found a hole in the fifty year tornado map and I’ve never had one come near me. Every couple decades the patterns may shift to other patterns, but generally speaking both the new patterns and old patterns have all happened in the last fifty years.
https://www.icfmag.com/2012/09/tornado-resistant-concrete-ho...
For a few decades the Swiss required building concrete nuclear fallout bunkers for every resident. This was relaxed only recently, but presumably it was doable for five decades. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-swiss-bunker/swiss-relax-...
It seems a concrete dome would also work if digging a bunker is too expensive. Yes it’s not pretty, but not being afraid of dying during the next hurricane season must be worth something. A small dome can’t cost much.
What was your source for this information?
> Plus many areas are subject to tornados and hurricanes when it is rather pointless to build anything that lasts 100 years. On that time scale the house will be destroyed or badly damaged in any case.
Tornadoes yes, hurricanes, no. Build strong and heavy, with durable steel shutters for all windows and very secure doors, and there's no reason your home can't survive hurricanes with minimal damage. Flooding is another matter, entirely.
1,000 sq mi is about 640,000 acres, so that's .0000015 tornadoes per year per acre. If I've got my math right, that's about a 99.9% chance that your 1 acre plot will not be hit by a tornado in 1000 years, if you live in the Atlanta area, which is only a middling high-probability area. (https://weather.com/storms/tornado/news/tornado-odds-of-bein...)
Hurricanes are generally only a coastal problem, although flooding is a fairly large issue everywhere. (Don't get a house in a low lying area. Please.)
Earthquakes are mostly a West Coast thing, modulo New Madrid (pronounced "mad-rid") and various oil drilling operations. But then there's fires and termites and everything else.
There are plenty of hundred-year-old houses all over the US, as well as plenty of newer ones that could last more than a century with proper maintenance.
Few houses today are built to last that long, though, because it's more expensive but doesn't add anything to the purchase price like granite countertops. Stick frame on slab construction is pretty close to mini-maxing housing construction as the article describes (even in areas where slab foundations are geologically idiotic).
Anyway, when you get down to the second-to-last section of the article, remember that, past a certain point, efficiency is the enemy of resiliency.
I appreciate your attempt to come up with realistic numbers, but you are making the assumption that each tornado only affects a single acre. As discussed in the article you linked, if a tornado touches down, it frequently causes destruction for a path of several miles, making this a faulty assumption.
They have earthquakes in e.g. Italy and Turkey too, you know.
There are certainly earthquake (and hurricane) areas but the majority of the US population does not live in those. I'd need some risk/benefit analysis and actual data before believing they are even a factor in the equation for most people and areas. I can think of 100 other possible reasons (eg historically people moved frequently, or it was simply cheaper to rebuild than maintain as building standards/expectations change frequently, or in the cities you anyway expect someone to come in and buy up old building stock and rip it all down to put something bigger in, or ... ).
See ASCE 7-16 Minimum Design Loads and Associated Criteria for Buildings and Other Structures, For wind: Chapters 26-31 for 144 pages of wind load design criteria. (California Building Code and International Building Codes recognize and point to that standard)
Of particular note, is a concept called "Basic Wind Speed" which is derived from mapped values. What you'll find is that its intimately correlated with hurricane landing. Most people live on the coast in the US where the wind speed is highest. Depending on the risk category of the building, a typical value on the West coast is ~105 mph. On the east coast, it vaires by latitude from ~115-200 mph, increasing in all the areas that get hit by hurricanes. To address your skepticism, I assure you things like hurricanes are undeed a significant design concern.
The seismic load is similar.
Both loads are fundamentally designed to give a defined risk of failure from storms and earthquakes with particular recurrence intervals ranging from 50-100 years. (Offhand, I believe this value is ~1% for total collapse with a much higher risk of damage.). It is indeed carefully weighted and considered balance between risk reduction and feasibility, and indeed, having less than 1% risk for intervals over 100 years starts to get rather difficult. We still require it for schools, police stations, and emergency gathering locations and the like, but not normal houses.
As some have pointed out, wooden buildings are also way, way more ecological than concrete ones. They capture carbon long-term, while concrete production causes major carbon emissions.
Pretend you have two options, you can build a home that lasts forever or a house that will fall apart in a half century but is 10% cheaper. By year 40, you'll have enough wealth accumulated to buy two new replacement homes.
The problem is that much of the US makes it needlessly expensive to do the "tear down and replace with new construction" bit.
The tl;dr: US housing is highly optimized for local conditions, as is the case everywhere. If you built European housing in much of the US it would be destroyed by the ambient environment or not compliant with safety regulations.
In the 70's, it was easy money and full employment for a lot of people and single house income could buy you such house. Some people built houses for themselves that wouldn't last more than a generation and wouldn't care at all about their descendants.
In the US there are things that do not make sense because people density is so low there, even in places like New York, most people live in individual homes, spread over a big area.
When I was living in China I saw lost of things made sense that do not make sense in Europe just by the economic of scale of so much people living in such small areas.
That's patently false. In NYC only 9% of homes are single unit detached and in NY state it's only 41%.
I don't know the exact number, but there are very few cities in Europe with a density higher then NY (10,716.36 people/km2), and i'm pretty sure they're all in France, Greece and Italy
I think it is partly due to tradition, and partly due to climate differences.
IIRC, bricks became popular because wooden house were forbidden in dense cities, and clay beat stone in availability/price/suitability (wouldn’t know which)
Certainly, after London burnt, “much of the old street plan was recreated in the new City, with improvements in hygiene and fire safety: wider streets, open and accessible wharves along the length of the Thames, with no houses obstructing access to the river, and, most importantly, buildings constructed of brick and stone, not wood.” (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Fire_of_London#Aftermath)
Food scarcity was a constant reality of premodern times. I’m not talking about occasional famines, where people literally died en masse, but rather about normal times. The food had to be scarce, otherwise the population wouldn’t have been a small fraction of the current one.
> Also, not all forest land can be used well for agriculture,
Sure, but back then people used even marginal lands if at all possible, precisely because of land scarcity. Ever seen those terraced farms on mountain slopes in China? We don’t do that anymore, but it made sense back then. Moreover, land that wasn’t good enough for farming was mostly used for animal grazing, not forest.
> and if there wasn’t much forest, there weren’t many twigs, either.
No, as I said, you can get twigs from coppiced or pollarded trees, which yield more fuel per acre than normal forest, but don’t yield any structural lumber.
There are small model cities you can visit where several dozen prefabbers exhibit their current model homes, and if you stick to their plan, you will usually pay less than building on your own. Those are often built on wood frames, but are still quite sturdy and supposed to last at least 100 years. Others are built with bricks or aerated concrete just like individually built homes. Savings are probably achieved by bulk orders, prefab, and a well coordinated team who has built the exact same house ten times already.