The solution for individuals: cash, gold, options, etc, aren't viable solutions for institutional investors.
Imagine that you're in charge of a $1 billion fund, what are you going to do? You can't put that into gold, cash or treasury notes. But all sectors are affected by this so you can't simply rebalance your portfolio. You can't go out and buy an obscene amount of call options because those would still way too risky at the institutional level.
For me this is why the stock market right now is deeply troubling. Not because "the elite's are out of touch", I know quite a few people in finance, people managing these billion dollar portfolios and they also have no clue what's going on. None of these people are delusional about what's going on, they just don't know what to do.
What's troubling is that this detachment from reality seems to be based on the fact that the entire financial system is effected and there's no way for it to react in a sane way anymore.
I don't claim to have any clue as to how this will play out, but when this reality bubble bursts it's going to be a very extreme event.
The government has been printing money for a long time, to stimulate the economy, provide spending money, etc. Due to 80/20 rule, rich get richer effects, etc, a large portion of money the government prints ends up in the hands of a relatively small group who doesn't spend it but rather tries to invest it to get more money. Government prints money again trying to stimulate the economy and again most of it ends up in a few hands. At some point don't you have what we have today? A 1% that owns lots of wealth and doesn't know where to put it while the majority of the economy is still relatively broke? How does it play out? Do the 1% just buy all the assets at some point?
I am not trying to make a statement about inequality but rather curious about the result of printing money for 70 years and having that money end up with relatively few parties each round. Perhaps someone with more knowledge can speak to this.
How retirement works on paper: you save the money by buying the market and get 20% more when you retire in 40 years. How retirement works in reality: younger people work to supply the old with food and medical care. The real transfer is happening now, while the financial transfer is happening over decades. I don't think this creates a healthy, sustainable dynamic.
This came at high costs: once a large enough part of the population buys houses at inflated prices with the expectation of their price further increasing, the government needs to protect them from housing crashes and depreciation to inflate the bubble further and further.
Now that pretty much everyone has their money invested in the stock market, I see the same thing happening in the US. The Fed needs to keep the interest rate artificially low and guarantee policies to keep the stock market up so that people don't lose money, but also making sociery overall worse.
People focus too much on stocks. The real question is about the real economy, about price stability and unemployment. Especially in case of the Fed ( https://www.chicagofed.org/research/dual-mandate/dual-mandat... , but of course other central banks are also tracking labor markets too, even if de jure it's not their target - https://ideas.repec.org/p/fip/fedbsp/70.html ).
And we can say whatever we like about how the rich get richer, our current economic system do responds to what central banks do. Cheap money (an oversupply of low and even lower interest rate debt) helps persuade people to buy/invest/order things. It helps finance stimulus bills, and so on.
The savings are "just" an indicator. Sure, when the savings crash, the economy crashes too, but the causality is backwards. If/when the economy crashes (when industries stop, when people stop buying, when businesses let people go) savings will also become "worthless", because after all they represent future income, and if the economy tanks its productivity (income) tanks too.
Where did this number come from? At 4% compounding over 40 years, you will have at least 130% again over what you put in.
But yes, it would be more than 20%, though a lot less than 130%.
The shift in risk should be accompanied by changes to the portfolio mix, of course.
Sure, if you have sufficient income to be able to save up enough for retirement just as soon as you get a job, that works. But that's not the reality for the average person. Most people don't get a high-paying job straight out of school.
All of these other issues you raise have nothing to do with the financial illiteracy leading to the idea that you save for retirement just to get an incremental return rather than a multiple (or two, really, depending on timing) of what you put in. Perhaps if this were more well known, people would invest more at age 22.
tl;dr we’re talking about “on paper” here, investment works as advertised (In fact, much much better than the original poster believes it advertised). All of the things you bring up here are about scenarios that aren’t “on paper” any more.
That's why to some degree I think asset-hoarding (S&P, real estate, cashflow-positive businesses etc.) is a good idea and actually my preferred plan, because I fundamentally don't trust the governments (they're all delusional with their long-term plans re: pension obligations, education, family planning & birth rates, immigration, ...), but at the same time I'm aware of the fact that while this strategy works individually (i.e. if I own more property, I'm better off than the next retiree), it doesn't quite work for the whole society. Pension as a social transfer really is the only way to go.
The recent $5 trillion injection from the Fed (buying bad debt/assets) and Treasury (stimulus/PPP) may simply show that we could afford universal healthcare and a bunch of other programs that cost $$$. Now is the time to spend that money and, at least it appears, avoid some long term costs. I'd argue the benefits of things like expanding education, investing in mental and physical health, and doing more to support our youth will have a much greater return than potential long term inflation or other issues from the $5 trillion.
I commented more on this last week here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23778819
This is a dangerous trend. The rich (who tend to own those assets) get richer and and the poor (who rent/live paycheck to paycheck) get more and more desperate. If we don't find a way to reduce the inequality, this is going to mean serious trouble down the line.
Mainly just the west coast and that's because their cities are built in valleys with a fixed amount of land, restrictive zoning on said land causing a fixed amount of housing and thus the bidding up housing prices.
For the rest of the country, inflation adjusted price per square foot hasn't really changed [0].
> the stock market has been on an epic bull run. It's obvious that the inflation is in the asset prices.
Inflation adjusted Annualized S&P 500 Returns with Dividends Reinvested for the past 15 years are 6.738% versus 7.690% for the 15 years before that [1]. Albeit, if you just started in 2009, it has been quite epic considering it was the longest bull run in US history.
[0]: https://www.supermoney.com/inflation-adjusted-home-prices/
So similarly there is probably some sense in trying to counteract low-interest-rate inflated asset bubbles via some kind of tax or other financial structure. (A progressive capital gains tax might help, but that might just make markets less efficient by introducing a chilling effect on the high end.)
In the end this is a purely political question, because obviously the problem is not that it's unfair that some very "desirable" assets price inflates, but that the majority of the population did not have the means to buy into it before the inflation happened to reap the capital gains.
There's already serious trouble due to inequality. (The recent protests about police brutality follow a long series of other symptoms that highlight how socioeconomic inequality manifests and persists on an ethnic level.)
Numbers rising don’t equal values rising, the definition of inflation. It benefits borrowers as well.
The classic economical laws are not broken, they are still in full effect and we see their effect in the inflated share prices.
So who is buying equity (so stocks)? And one argument is, that "retail investors" are driving this. (So end users, the folks on the WallStreetBets subreddit, and whoever uses RobinHood, or anyone that puts money into a passive index fund: https://www.reddit.com/r/econmonitor/comments/hnohi6/us_equi... )
Also savings increased a lot, since people were not spending (they were staying at home), so where to put the money? They put it into index funds.
[0]: https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h41/current/h41.htm
Yes, this means wealthy people will get the same checks as the poor -- but that is a feature, not a bug. Sorry for the soapbox.
The thing that makes a green piece of cloth valuable is the powerful government and the massive reserve bank behind it. If a dollar bill starts to look like an IOU from an entity that has no capacity to pay, it will be valued as such.
It's better to do QE than "wait out" a recession, or wait for Congress. (Plus QE keeps the national debt service costs down too.)
The asset bubbles are not the real signs of inequality. After all, if every US citizen would have some savings and some of that in passive index funds, no one would complain about this. The problem is that people have no money, no disposable income, no savings, no job security, etc.
But still, QE might be here to stay. It's hard to stay, I know very-very little about these things. (Even compared to - let's say - healthcare costs [see https://randomcriticalanalysis.com/ ].)
I was under the impression the last 40 years of US deficit spending has been mostly financed by selling US bonds to China, Japan, etc., while counting on growth and inflation to take the edge off when they come due. And selling more bonds instead of defaulting, so the debt just keeps growing. Printing money causes inflation but not deficits or lingering debt.
I don't know though, I'm not an expert. I would appreciate any corrections or clarifications from anyone.
https://www.khanacademy.org/economics-finance-domain/ap-macr...
"The Fed can indeed create money "out of thin air." To be more precise, it does so with keystrokes on a computer. This was illustrated with its QE program, also known as open market operations. That's when the Fed buys an asset from a financial institution and pays for it with money it simply creates."
they provide price stability (by keeping the money supply corresponding to the demand) and they try to maximize employment (by helping the economy through providing liquidity, every central bank is the "lender of last resort" but that's for emergencies, usually they operate simply by providing forward guidance and conducting open market operations to keep the interbank interest rate close to the target rate).
don't think of them like just a bank, it's more like the Mint, combined with an expert panel that tries to smooth out the fluctuations of the economy ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_business-cycle_theory )
Also, as long as they don't try to get clever - like the Bank of Japan did with strategic loans ("window guidance" back in the 80s).
Printing money to keep up with economic growth is also an important function of central banks.
Deficit spending is ultimately simply financed by paying off the debt in the future via taxes. (And the growing economy and the stable but low inflation helps with this.)
The markets are a wobbling shitpile of unpayable debt just waiting to collapse. That was already true before Covid, but Covid has nailed the coffin shut while the corpse is still alive.
I wouldn't be surprised if the Fed is knowingly goosing the twitching body because the alternative is one of the biggest financial explosions in history. More free speculation vouchers at least buy a little time before the music stops, the bomb goes off, and we all run out of metaphors.
I think there's a lot of people who don't remember or realize this. And it bothers me that having conversations now takes so much effort to address that particular part of the context: "they were having econ troubles before covid was on the radar"
Debt is also not necessarily the time-bomb that everyone thinks it is. Debt is tied closely to the overall money supply, and world productivity has been increasing as has population. World debt is about 69 trillion with a population of 7.8 billion. That's under $9k USD per person.
That's a bizarre way to cut it for a number of reasons. For example, half of the world lives on less than $5.50 per day [0].
The more relevant statistic is the US national debt is $26 trillion [1] and the additional unfunded liabilities dwarf that. There are 143 million US taxpayers. It's something like $160k per US taxpayer [2]. Much of it can/will be printed away but not without other consequences.
[0] https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2018/10/17/n... [1] https://www.usdebtclock.org/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_debt_of_the_United_St...
This block votes and they vote often and if their little pennies are threatened, they will vote people out.
Edit: If you think these market rises are anything other than a way for the rich to rinse their money before the market bombs, I have a bridge to sell you, it's very pretty.
While not great for online discussion, I can understand where the sentiment comes (the evidence is clear older generations strip mined the country economically [and continue to do so], pulled the ladder up behind them, and then are shocked when younger citizens are resentful).
Even if they do something like barter free housing for live-in care instead of selling, you expect a big effect on the rental market and a corresponding effect on the value of investment properties.
Boomers are between 56 and 74, a lot of them already have either liquidated real estate holdings by downsizing even if not explicitly for care, or passed it on, whether inter vivos or by inheritance (because quite a lot of them have died, and you can't take it with you.)
Boomers by definition are going to be in their late 70's at the absolute youngest.
You're talking about their children, who have comparatively little (and is coincidentally why a lot of people hate the Boomer generation).
Apparently date math is hard. You're 100% right.
The implications of this seem mostly sociological to me. Is that a good state of affairs for the world? Could we use those people more productively?
The implications are not about the current stock market.
Amazon and Microsoft are pretty damn likely to keep growing in value for 10+ more years regardless of any coronavirus situation. That’s an amazing / dumbfounding situation. But it still would imply a rational longterm investors sees those stocks as being attractively priced right now.
If you're right about that we're into revolution territory. If COVID reveals that we've built an economy that not only doesn't care, but doesn't even register the existence of 1/3 of the population, the body politic may have had a poison dose.
Using what metric?
I can tell you that if you shut down 1/3 of the machine, you will see a 1/3 drop GDP.
Individuals presented with this crisis could realise the problem, the disastrous future it implies, and turn to philanthropy. Institutions largely can't, and foreign oligarchs won't.
TINA
And who knows what will happen to that market once stimulus checks run out and lots of jobless people start getting evicted.
And then you need to worry about taxes, maintenance, and, if you want to be a landlord, all of those rule & regs.
Or you just drop it in QQQ and try not to think about it too much.
--Charles Prince, Citigroup CEO, 2007
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-04-08/taleb-adv...
I've worked in both a hedge fund and in tech, and I found the former to be less evil and pretentious. People in finance think and say "I want to make a ton of money" while people in tech say "I want to save the world" while thinking "I want to make a ton of money" - resulting in misaligned incentives and imposter syndrome everywhere.
Take for example the creation of a market to manipulate the price of commodities most notably wheat.
https://foreignpolicy.com/2011/04/27/how-goldman-sachs-creat...
Sachs is most likely mostly responsible for millions perhaps hundreds of millions of people going hungry and yet a response to outlawing this kind of manipulation provokes this response.
>I asked a handful of wheat brokers what would happen if the U.S. government simply outlawed long–only trading in food commodities for investment banks. Their reaction: laughter. One phone call to a bona-fide hedger like Cargill or Archer Daniels Midland and one secret swap of assets, and a bank’s stake in the futures market is indistinguishable from that of an international wheat buyer. What if the government outlawed all long-only derivative products, I asked? Once again, laughter. Problem solved with another phone call, this time to a trading office in London or Hong Kong; the new food derivative markets have reached supranational proportions, beyond the reach of sovereign law.
This is Bond villain proportions of villainy. We could of course continue in the same vein touching on Banks laundering money for cartels, the housing market collapse, and on and on and on.
Citation needed. The number of people in "tech" who say that is remarkably low -- in my experience in Silicon Valley: zero.
Far more often, I hear employees who are driven by "the mission" of the company/product. I work on a newer generation cybersecurity product because the ones that exist in the space have terrible usability and probably aren't very accurate/comprehensive/ergonomic. I'm not "saving the world", but I am making marginal improvements in a high impact space.
Personally I haven't the foggiest idea of what a Hedge Fund actually is. I've seen The Big Short, Margin Call, Barbarians at the Gate and I don't find myself sympathetic with any of those characters (except the Ben Rickert[1] in The Big Short, but only because he saw how terrible the industry was and got out years before the story takes place).
[1] https://www.bustle.com/articles/128208-what-does-the-real-be...
A part of it might be stereotypes and depictions in pop-culture. The drama Billions shows hedge funds getting their consistent edge from insider info. Not sure how true that is but for people outside the industry that doesn't come off as a good look.
This also explains wacky basketcase unicorns like WeWork, perpetually unprofitable companies raising round after round, the continued existence of the cryptocurrency world in spite of it being like 90%+ scams, real estate going up in cities where >25% of people are behind on their mortgages, etc. There's no "alpha" anywhere. Money is chasing its tail.
All this QE is just going to give us is more asset bubbles. The financial economy is completely detaching from the real economy and becoming a pure fantasy LARP for the rich and of course governments.
People act like the big short guys were geniuses to see this trend come out of nowhere. I was a teenager asking questions like "How can housing prices rise nationally at a multiple of wage increases for any sustained period of time?" and was short down by the "smart money" on forums not unlike this one.
It's seductive to type out the word "simply" to describe a proposed solution but that doesn't mean it's simple in reality. (My previous comment about supposedly "simple" fixes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16698821)
E.g. The employer (the state government) that pays into pension funds for teachers won't simply pay more. The taxpayers aren't sympathetic to raising taxes on themselves to pay for fully funded pensions (even if the pension is underfunded) when they perceive the teachers already getting better benefits than they do. A lot of citizen taxpayers who are not teachers also suffer from underfunded pensions themselves!
But sure, I agree that there are other ways to handle the situation if the fund doesn't achieve its assumed rate of return. There are other options than increasing employer contributions.
You're being uncharitable in reading gp's (erentz) word "required". No, there isn't a statute or law that says the pension fund must get 8% returns or the pension administrators go to jail. Nobody is saying that.
Here's how to interpret the word "required" in a more reasonable manner...
Using Illinois Teachers Pension as an example: the pension fund manages ~$50 billion but they still have a ~$70 billion shortfall.[1] The CIO (Chief Investment Officer) is currently Stan Rupnik. His salary is ~$400k per year and he's responsible for investing the pension fund in a way that balances max returns with safety. If he just sits back and folds his arms in a defiant manner exclaiming, "hey, the pension fund is not _required_ to achieve a given rate of return so I'm just going to invest all $50 billion in T-Bills which returns a negligible 0.19% yada yada yada" ... he's not going to keep his job.
That's what a meaningful interpretation of "required" is for the context of this discussion.
[1] https://www.chicagobusiness.com/finance-banking/teachers-pen...
I don't think it has anything to do with the fact that there's an assumed long-term 8% return. Fund managers in situations where no such assumed returns exist make the same bad decisions all the time too.
The PBGC was created because this isn't the case. The issues with Social Security are another example of how pay as you go isn't completely sustainable.
And what issues with social security do you mean? The program has taken in more than it's paid out since '83.
Also, social security has required many changes that decrease benefits over the years to remain solvent, such as increasing the expected retirement age.
parking isn't safe. Parking is guaranteed to lose 20-30% because of the newly printed money and the resulting asset prices rise across the board. Yes, some assets may experience the swings during that money tsunami, yet on average across the board the assets would still rise 20-30% - ie. the amount of the newly printed money.
Economy and market didn't part ways. The stock market is just like speedometer that got "upgraded" from mph to kmh - the number is higher while the car and the speed are still the same.
Because interest rates will never go back up, or if they do, they will be counterbalanced by inflation. This is the view of Ray Dalio at Bridgewater and (presumably) many other very smart people. I'm not that smart, but I agree.
Thus, cash and cash obligations are no longer stores of wealth. Equities are, unfortunately. High volatility is just the price you pay. Equity prices are honestly not that high if this scenario plays out.
[1] https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/ernestliu/...
[2] https://research.stlouisfed.org/publications/economic-synops...
[3] https://web.archive.org/web/20200629061702/https://larrysumm...
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/big-cycles-over-last-500-year...
In other words, we have to actually look at the evidence.
The America of the past 100 years has been quite exceptional. Using its history to predict the future is not a good idea, IMO.
The problem (or uncertainty) is that both the US and Germany left the gold-backed systems during those years and the exchange rate between our currencies changed quite a bit during the 1914-1924 period (which is probably why your parent chose that year).
If you notice your image's description, it is denominated in 3 different currencies, depending on the years you are looking at.
Im sure the result would be much better then.
Understate inflation so real rates are negative, then your savings either dwindle or you give in to the pressure to take more risk.
For equities heavy strategies, there is even an acronym to describe this: TINA ("There Is No Alternative") [2]
[1] https://www.visualcapitalist.com/700-year-decline-of-interes...
[2] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/tina-there-no-alternati... ("On the other hand, if bonds offer low yields. and illiquid assets such as private equity or real estate are also unattractive, investors may hold stocks despite their concerns rather than revert to cash. If enough participants are of the same mind, the market can experience a "Tina Effect," rising gradually despite an apparent lack of drivers since there are no other options for capital increase.")
Hmmm.... One of the things you mentioned though could drop in an instant.
A return of negative is worse than 0.
I suspect many are sitting on cash, waiting for the other shoe to drop (or, you know, the market).
Well, MOST people can't afford an unexpected $500 bill, so most people aren't sitting on cash. Nevertheless, I don't agree that most of the people who can afford an unexpected $500 bill are sitting on large cash sum either either. Personally I have 2/3 in the market, and 1/3 cash (for liquid assets, I also have equity in my home but I am not counting that).
I'm not average for an American (consumer or investor), but people like me exist.
At some point there is going to be a critical mass of people not paying their mortgage, not paying rent, not paying loans, not paying credit cards...and simply no money and unemployment.
I think this week we will begin to see some acknowledgement of the realities because July 15 is the new tax return date, and I think there will be millions and millions of American's who just say F it, I am not filing/paying taxes.
Then again it also wouldn't surprise me if 10s of millions end up homeless before the end of the year while politicians keep parading around unemployment numbers and the stock market record highs, while these people get swept under the rug and never actually acknowledged.
[1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/travel/airline-news/2020/07/0...
[2] https://www.flightglobal.com/strategy/layoffs-expected-when-...
About 20% of renters and homeowners in the USA are worried about evictions/foreclosures in the next 6 months[1] and that number only goes down if the economy makes massive improvements or if Congress stops playing brinksmanship.
[1] https://www.apartmentlist.com/research/july-housing-payments
What I think is far more interesting is what happens internally: the US is a powder keg of economic and racial inequality and our leaders are either throwing lit matches at it or gently disapproving of those doing the throwing. If COVID cases and deaths keep increasing I can't see how we continue without structural changes.
Hyperinflation is one way to throw more fuel on the dire that is American society right now. And Trump said the quiet part out loud during his campaign[1] that we don't have to repay the whole debt (normally something that the most powerful people in a country don't say in public).
Neither of these ideas works in practice without significant tradeoffs. The US dollar only keeps its value because people around the world have faith it is worth something. A spike in inflation or a debt default would have investors scramble to move their assets elsewhere.
[1] https://www.npr.org/2016/05/09/477350889/donald-trumps-messy...
https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren...
The only reason store-brand sliced white bread isn't $10 right now is that money only went to investors and businesses.
What do you mean 'start'?
The homeless camp right next to the new Apple spaceship just got a bathroom installed:
https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/06/03/after-months-of-compl...
This stuff has been going on for a few years now.
I'm not downplaying the seriousness of what's happening, as the economic impact will be catastrophic. But physically evicting large percentages of a population with no sudden increase in demand for those properties, seems like an unlikely outcome.
Homeowners will probably find a way to catch up before losing their rear but renters could trivially find themselves in very quick perfunctory hearings where they are quickly told to put up or get out. Many with relatives with a spare couch or even a spare floor to sleep on might see the writing on the wall and get out before they are humiliated by being put out. If most evictions are carried out without a trial or hearing of any variety simply with a note on the door the courts will be able to keep up with the few that contest.
At least on the west coast, in each major city, we have thousands of people living in tents, if not tens of thousands. Seattle has over 10k now officially (and speaking with food bank workers 20 years ago, they said it was that number then, when times were less shit). Los Angeles per their recent count has over 40k.
https://www.lahsa.org/news?article=726-2020-greater-los-ange...
Confidence in this area was restored when the Federal Reserve started doing what are called "stress tests" under the Dodd-Frank Act, where large financial institutions have to prove that even if things turn bad they won't collapse.
On This Week in Virology recently, they said that it would be invaluable to sequence the virus the first time around and the second time around (in patients who recrudesce) to see whether the two infections were caused by the same virus (in genetic terms), or from a new infection by a genetically different virus.
Either way, it's bad if immunity only lasts a few months, for obvious reasons.
It is entirely possible the first infection was a false positive.
>Ditchek said he encountered a second reinfected patient on Wednesday from the same family. This patient had accumulated so many antibodies from his previous COVID-19 infection that he was able to donate plasma to other coronavirus patients two times.
"He'd been negative for seven weeks and sure enough was re-exposed," Ditchek said, and diagnosed positive for COVID-19 this week.
https://dailyvoice.com/new-jersey/monmouth/news/central-jers...
Hospitalizations are still extremely problematic because there is permanent health harm. There is also a massive cost to being in the hospital for an American. COVID hospitalizations seem to take between 1-3+ weeks, which costs more than the net worth of the average American.
Also, the economic impact is severe and has yet to fully show itself. Lots of employees are still "employed" but indefinitely furloughed. They will show up as unemployed when their company finally falls into bankruptcy or takes decisive headcount steps. In September, the PPP strings for employment expire and there will be an employment rate cliff unless Congress acts. 20% of Americans are behind on their rent/mortgage and are worried about an eviction/foreclosure in the next 6 months. This is both bad for the obvious reason and because a consumer-driven economy shrinks quickly when consumers are more judicious about spending.
We still don't understand why deaths per case are dropping yet. Until we know the variables (perhaps the weakest already died off, perhaps the colder weather amplified the worst symptoms, etc) I don't think it's safe to assume the death rate will be monotonically decreasing.
My bet is we see deaths and disabilities skyrocket through the end of the year.
That'd be a pretty bad bet as far as bets go. Look at the trends that are _not_ affected by increased testing.
https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/testing/international-comparison
If you are right and that’s what Wall Streets is looking up to, they are in for the big surprise in the next two weeks.
* US TIPS are up about 7.5% YTD
* Aggregate bond funds (BND, SCHZ, etc.) are up 6-7%
* Intermediate-term bond funds (IEF, etc.) up > 11%
Meanwhile, the S&P 500 is at 6% YTD.
Bonds are sensitive to interest rates, but it seems nobody is expecting those to change this year.
Surely large investment funds aren't entirely in on US stocks alone and are diversified. So isn't one option to just move some money elsewhere? i.e out of the US market - to a place(s) deemed more stable or with better upside.
The market is acting rationally. You have no choice but to go all in on the market or inflation protected assets or risk loosing everything to inflation in the coming decade.
Paper gold is a bet no different than a stock; it is a bet that the system and your counterparty will both be solvent when you need them.
a) It's a store of wealth. I don't expect to be able to go buy groceries with it, however I do expect to be able to cash it in for fiat post-depression if I need to.
b) I can move it abroad easily enough if I need to. I have immediate access to it.
c) It's cool.
It has also doubled in value since I bought it.
I am old enough to remeber the chaos in the silver market a few years ago, where it went to $50 per ounce and then crashed in two or three days. I'm not one of those morons.
It's fairly trivial to get lots of gold just above spot price. https://www.apmex.com/product/75/10-oz-gold-bar-brand-name
>And if you succeed, try selling it into the system again, without losing 30%.
In the scenario where the markets are collapsing and you need to sell gold for cash it's possible or even likely that it could be worth more than what you bought it for and even if not the discount rate you accept for selling it back may be worth it either way. If the market dropped 50-80% and you are only taking a 30% loss on gold that's clearly worth taking.
What this means is that, at moment in time, if the music stopped, someone would be left without gold - though with the distributed nature of everything, it’s hard to say who.
Fake bars are routinely discovered in storage, collateral, etc, see e.g. https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/chinas-kingold-shares-tank-o... for the most recent high profile (but by no means unique) example.
But that type of mental exercise does not work well for many people. Especially imagining a system where our fiat currency is effectively useless.
I think partial collapse is more likely scenario (of the two).
There's also 1/10 ounce coins and other things.
Not really accurate, you can get rounds down to 1/10 oz which are worth ~$200. In any case the USD value of a gold coin in a collapse situation is obviously irrelevant. If fiat really does collapse barter is obviously going to be the default way to trade goods and gold could easily be used as it was in the past.
I mean, how can you verify if a ring or necklace is actual gold, but not be able to verify a coin?
I guess using the age-old method of density perhaps? do you know what did process to exchange jewelry looked like?
The lesson I took is that a pure gold economy depends upon a level of infrastructure that just isn't present in economic collapse conditions. At best you're holding something that will retain value after things become normal again.
I guess this is one of those things that sound good 'on paper' , but after deeper analysis it's not so straight forward.
Like others said, it's probably easier to trade toilet paper, cans of food or cigarettes than ounces of gold.
I don’t have a sense for how bad things need to get before making your own rings becomes a viable hedge, but I don’t think the US is quite there yet.
There's a significant resale overhead to gold. Who's to say it's not tungsten somewhere in the middle? Are you going to microprobe the whole thing in the post-apocalyptic hellscape?
https://www.apmex.com/product/201564/2020-1-gram-gold-maple-...
If you’re buying gold for the end of the world you’d be better off buying cigarettes and tiny bottles of booze.
Gold does have intrinsic value. It's used for electronics plating and for jewelry. Other precious metals can augment gold as commodities, each having different intrinsic values. An example of a metal which might have no intrinsic value in a post-apocalyptic world is platinum or palladium, which are primarily used as catalysts for emissions equipment on cars (no refined petrol => no driving => no need for platinum/palladium).
I think the statement about cigarettes and booze is correct (as well as toilet paper and ammo), except they have different lifespans and durabilities. Also, consumables will get more rare as time goes on (like dollar bills that erode, tear, burn, or are lost), whereas precious metals may keep in-tact.
But the idea that gold doesn't have some sort of special status is strange to me. People don't talk about doorknobs or topaz when they diversify from financial products (stocks, bonds, cash, etc). Cryptocurrency fails to be useful if there is no reliable electrical grid or network. Gold has for long recent history (until about WW1) backed almost all currencies, so it has significant precedence.
And jewelry is useless to me, but most people carry some form of jewelry and some cultures even store lots of gold in jewelry in case they need to run/escape. It's not useless to have a store of value shaped to fit your body.
An alternative place to put investments will trigger it. When your options are savings accounts paying 0.25% interest, and treasury notes paying nothing, and CD's being garbage, what are your alternatives for investing? If interest rates were 5%+ on savings/CDS's/Treasury notes then you would see a bunch of money move from stocks to these other safer more stable investments. But the safety/stability doesn't mean shit if the return is near 0.