How retirement works on paper: you save the money by buying the market and get 20% more when you retire in 40 years. How retirement works in reality: younger people work to supply the old with food and medical care. The real transfer is happening now, while the financial transfer is happening over decades. I don't think this creates a healthy, sustainable dynamic.
This came at high costs: once a large enough part of the population buys houses at inflated prices with the expectation of their price further increasing, the government needs to protect them from housing crashes and depreciation to inflate the bubble further and further.
Now that pretty much everyone has their money invested in the stock market, I see the same thing happening in the US. The Fed needs to keep the interest rate artificially low and guarantee policies to keep the stock market up so that people don't lose money, but also making sociery overall worse.
People focus too much on stocks. The real question is about the real economy, about price stability and unemployment. Especially in case of the Fed ( https://www.chicagofed.org/research/dual-mandate/dual-mandat... , but of course other central banks are also tracking labor markets too, even if de jure it's not their target - https://ideas.repec.org/p/fip/fedbsp/70.html ).
And we can say whatever we like about how the rich get richer, our current economic system do responds to what central banks do. Cheap money (an oversupply of low and even lower interest rate debt) helps persuade people to buy/invest/order things. It helps finance stimulus bills, and so on.
The savings are "just" an indicator. Sure, when the savings crash, the economy crashes too, but the causality is backwards. If/when the economy crashes (when industries stop, when people stop buying, when businesses let people go) savings will also become "worthless", because after all they represent future income, and if the economy tanks its productivity (income) tanks too.
Where did this number come from? At 4% compounding over 40 years, you will have at least 130% again over what you put in.
But yes, it would be more than 20%, though a lot less than 130%.
The shift in risk should be accompanied by changes to the portfolio mix, of course.
Sure, if you have sufficient income to be able to save up enough for retirement just as soon as you get a job, that works. But that's not the reality for the average person. Most people don't get a high-paying job straight out of school.
All of these other issues you raise have nothing to do with the financial illiteracy leading to the idea that you save for retirement just to get an incremental return rather than a multiple (or two, really, depending on timing) of what you put in. Perhaps if this were more well known, people would invest more at age 22.
tl;dr we’re talking about “on paper” here, investment works as advertised (In fact, much much better than the original poster believes it advertised). All of the things you bring up here are about scenarios that aren’t “on paper” any more.
That's why to some degree I think asset-hoarding (S&P, real estate, cashflow-positive businesses etc.) is a good idea and actually my preferred plan, because I fundamentally don't trust the governments (they're all delusional with their long-term plans re: pension obligations, education, family planning & birth rates, immigration, ...), but at the same time I'm aware of the fact that while this strategy works individually (i.e. if I own more property, I'm better off than the next retiree), it doesn't quite work for the whole society. Pension as a social transfer really is the only way to go.
The recent $5 trillion injection from the Fed (buying bad debt/assets) and Treasury (stimulus/PPP) may simply show that we could afford universal healthcare and a bunch of other programs that cost $$$. Now is the time to spend that money and, at least it appears, avoid some long term costs. I'd argue the benefits of things like expanding education, investing in mental and physical health, and doing more to support our youth will have a much greater return than potential long term inflation or other issues from the $5 trillion.
I commented more on this last week here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23778819
This is a dangerous trend. The rich (who tend to own those assets) get richer and and the poor (who rent/live paycheck to paycheck) get more and more desperate. If we don't find a way to reduce the inequality, this is going to mean serious trouble down the line.
Mainly just the west coast and that's because their cities are built in valleys with a fixed amount of land, restrictive zoning on said land causing a fixed amount of housing and thus the bidding up housing prices.
For the rest of the country, inflation adjusted price per square foot hasn't really changed [0].
> the stock market has been on an epic bull run. It's obvious that the inflation is in the asset prices.
Inflation adjusted Annualized S&P 500 Returns with Dividends Reinvested for the past 15 years are 6.738% versus 7.690% for the 15 years before that [1]. Albeit, if you just started in 2009, it has been quite epic considering it was the longest bull run in US history.
[0]: https://www.supermoney.com/inflation-adjusted-home-prices/
So similarly there is probably some sense in trying to counteract low-interest-rate inflated asset bubbles via some kind of tax or other financial structure. (A progressive capital gains tax might help, but that might just make markets less efficient by introducing a chilling effect on the high end.)
In the end this is a purely political question, because obviously the problem is not that it's unfair that some very "desirable" assets price inflates, but that the majority of the population did not have the means to buy into it before the inflation happened to reap the capital gains.
There's already serious trouble due to inequality. (The recent protests about police brutality follow a long series of other symptoms that highlight how socioeconomic inequality manifests and persists on an ethnic level.)
Numbers rising don’t equal values rising, the definition of inflation. It benefits borrowers as well.
The classic economical laws are not broken, they are still in full effect and we see their effect in the inflated share prices.
So who is buying equity (so stocks)? And one argument is, that "retail investors" are driving this. (So end users, the folks on the WallStreetBets subreddit, and whoever uses RobinHood, or anyone that puts money into a passive index fund: https://www.reddit.com/r/econmonitor/comments/hnohi6/us_equi... )
Also savings increased a lot, since people were not spending (they were staying at home), so where to put the money? They put it into index funds.
[0]: https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h41/current/h41.htm
Yes, this means wealthy people will get the same checks as the poor -- but that is a feature, not a bug. Sorry for the soapbox.
The thing that makes a green piece of cloth valuable is the powerful government and the massive reserve bank behind it. If a dollar bill starts to look like an IOU from an entity that has no capacity to pay, it will be valued as such.
It's better to do QE than "wait out" a recession, or wait for Congress. (Plus QE keeps the national debt service costs down too.)
The asset bubbles are not the real signs of inequality. After all, if every US citizen would have some savings and some of that in passive index funds, no one would complain about this. The problem is that people have no money, no disposable income, no savings, no job security, etc.
But still, QE might be here to stay. It's hard to stay, I know very-very little about these things. (Even compared to - let's say - healthcare costs [see https://randomcriticalanalysis.com/ ].)
I was under the impression the last 40 years of US deficit spending has been mostly financed by selling US bonds to China, Japan, etc., while counting on growth and inflation to take the edge off when they come due. And selling more bonds instead of defaulting, so the debt just keeps growing. Printing money causes inflation but not deficits or lingering debt.
I don't know though, I'm not an expert. I would appreciate any corrections or clarifications from anyone.
https://www.khanacademy.org/economics-finance-domain/ap-macr...
"The Fed can indeed create money "out of thin air." To be more precise, it does so with keystrokes on a computer. This was illustrated with its QE program, also known as open market operations. That's when the Fed buys an asset from a financial institution and pays for it with money it simply creates."
they provide price stability (by keeping the money supply corresponding to the demand) and they try to maximize employment (by helping the economy through providing liquidity, every central bank is the "lender of last resort" but that's for emergencies, usually they operate simply by providing forward guidance and conducting open market operations to keep the interbank interest rate close to the target rate).
don't think of them like just a bank, it's more like the Mint, combined with an expert panel that tries to smooth out the fluctuations of the economy ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_business-cycle_theory )
Also, as long as they don't try to get clever - like the Bank of Japan did with strategic loans ("window guidance" back in the 80s).
Printing money to keep up with economic growth is also an important function of central banks.
Deficit spending is ultimately simply financed by paying off the debt in the future via taxes. (And the growing economy and the stable but low inflation helps with this.)
The government has been printing money for a long time, to stimulate the economy, provide spending money, etc. Due to 80/20 rule, rich get richer effects, etc, a large portion of money the government prints ends up in the hands of a relatively small group who doesn't spend it but rather tries to invest it to get more money. Government prints money again trying to stimulate the economy and again most of it ends up in a few hands. At some point don't you have what we have today? A 1% that owns lots of wealth and doesn't know where to put it while the majority of the economy is still relatively broke? How does it play out? Do the 1% just buy all the assets at some point?
I am not trying to make a statement about inequality but rather curious about the result of printing money for 70 years and having that money end up with relatively few parties each round. Perhaps someone with more knowledge can speak to this.