This also explains wacky basketcase unicorns like WeWork, perpetually unprofitable companies raising round after round, the continued existence of the cryptocurrency world in spite of it being like 90%+ scams, real estate going up in cities where >25% of people are behind on their mortgages, etc. There's no "alpha" anywhere. Money is chasing its tail.
All this QE is just going to give us is more asset bubbles. The financial economy is completely detaching from the real economy and becoming a pure fantasy LARP for the rich and of course governments.
People act like the big short guys were geniuses to see this trend come out of nowhere. I was a teenager asking questions like "How can housing prices rise nationally at a multiple of wage increases for any sustained period of time?" and was short down by the "smart money" on forums not unlike this one.
It's seductive to type out the word "simply" to describe a proposed solution but that doesn't mean it's simple in reality. (My previous comment about supposedly "simple" fixes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16698821)
E.g. The employer (the state government) that pays into pension funds for teachers won't simply pay more. The taxpayers aren't sympathetic to raising taxes on themselves to pay for fully funded pensions (even if the pension is underfunded) when they perceive the teachers already getting better benefits than they do. A lot of citizen taxpayers who are not teachers also suffer from underfunded pensions themselves!
But sure, I agree that there are other ways to handle the situation if the fund doesn't achieve its assumed rate of return. There are other options than increasing employer contributions.
You're being uncharitable in reading gp's (erentz) word "required". No, there isn't a statute or law that says the pension fund must get 8% returns or the pension administrators go to jail. Nobody is saying that.
Here's how to interpret the word "required" in a more reasonable manner...
Using Illinois Teachers Pension as an example: the pension fund manages ~$50 billion but they still have a ~$70 billion shortfall.[1] The CIO (Chief Investment Officer) is currently Stan Rupnik. His salary is ~$400k per year and he's responsible for investing the pension fund in a way that balances max returns with safety. If he just sits back and folds his arms in a defiant manner exclaiming, "hey, the pension fund is not _required_ to achieve a given rate of return so I'm just going to invest all $50 billion in T-Bills which returns a negligible 0.19% yada yada yada" ... he's not going to keep his job.
That's what a meaningful interpretation of "required" is for the context of this discussion.
[1] https://www.chicagobusiness.com/finance-banking/teachers-pen...
I don't think it has anything to do with the fact that there's an assumed long-term 8% return. Fund managers in situations where no such assumed returns exist make the same bad decisions all the time too.
The PBGC was created because this isn't the case. The issues with Social Security are another example of how pay as you go isn't completely sustainable.
And what issues with social security do you mean? The program has taken in more than it's paid out since '83.
Also, social security has required many changes that decrease benefits over the years to remain solvent, such as increasing the expected retirement age.