News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Drakim on Sunday October 08, 2017 @01:52PM (#15429160)
It always puzzled me that internet companies can simply say that the speed is "up to" a certain number. Especially since, they will often sell various tiers of speed, proving that they ARE capable of delivering a faster speed.

Imagine paying for 50mb/s internet and only getting 23mb/s. So you upgrade to the 75mb/s plan and now your real speed is 46mb/s. Why couldn't you get that higher speed for the original plan? It seems bizarre that this setup would be legal anywhere in any country.

If you can simply provide "up to" on something, then I wanna sell you a box for ten bucks that contains up to a million dollars!

Edit: Obviously speed depends on a million factors, but I don't know if I've ever experienced even half the speed I was paying for, even when I control both end points.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by wmf on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:30PM (#15429317)
Imagine paying for 50mb/s internet and only getting 23mb/s. So you upgrade to the 75mb/s plan and now your real speed is 46mb/s.

In reality you'd probably still get 23 after upgrading. The state of New York is suing Spectrum over this issue; customers complained about slow speeds so Spectrum told them to upgrade to a faster plan but their speeds didn't improve at all because the congestion was still there.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by SerLava on Sunday October 08, 2017 @06:13PM (#15430299)
They should force the cable companies to automatically discount the monthly cost if, say, 30%+ of the actual use falls more than, say, 10% below the advertised speed.

I mean it makes perfect sense. And oh, what fire it would light under their asses.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by m12k on Monday October 09, 2017 @09:25AM (#15433547)
Yeah, it'd be perfectly reasonable if it was prorated. So if during a month they managed to provide an average of 70% of the promised speed, I should pay them 70% of the subscription cost.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday October 09, 2017 @10:32AM (#15434089)
Average is not a good measure for that, because there are lots of hours during the day where even the worst ISPs don't have any congestion, and still the connection can be unusable during peak hours. The right measure would be the minimum throughput that you achieved, maybe minus a few minutes of congestion per month that are ignored. If they sell you a 100 Mb/s pipe, that should mean that you should essentially never notice that it's not actually reserved 100 Mb/s. People don't buy 100 Mb/s because they want 100 Mb/s at 3 am, they buy 100 Mb/s because they want 100 Mb/s when they need it, which in most cases is during peak load times (which is why those are the peak load times).
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by foota on Sunday October 08, 2017 @09:37PM (#15431071)
I don't think this would work since you can't effectively measure bandwidth available without stressing the system?
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by wtallis on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:37AM (#15431608)
You can't do it properly from an endpoint, but the ISPs are already monitoring it internally. They know when and where they have serious congestion.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by notyourwork on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:53AM (#15431658)
This is precisely why ISP's should have to operate more transparently as a common carrier and not as a private business milking a cash cow.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by chii on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:26AM (#15432085)
If an electric utility company did the same, with 'up-to 240volts' - they'd get their ass sued out of existence. Why can't the gov't establish standards for such things, like a minimum speed (from the IPS's own servers of course, you cannot expect that they control it all).
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by hueving on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:02AM (#15432186)
They would just game it then and underinvest on peering (similar to what happened in the netflix/Comcast scenario). What good is 1gbit guaranteed to your ISP if the entire ISP only has 10mbps to the rest of the world?
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by wmf on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:05PM (#15435554)
Presumably peering congestion would be one of the regulated metrics, just like voltage would be for an electric utility.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by maccard on Monday October 09, 2017 @05:41AM (#15432512)
Better than having 10mbps to your ISP and your ISP having 10mbps to the rest of the world, if you're paying for 100
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by gsich on Monday October 09, 2017 @06:15AM (#15432647)
Why not? If the ISP provides a server you can download a file from, you can see your speed, the ISP can see the speed. Yes there might be issues with your PC and such, but this can be easily tested.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by foota on Monday October 09, 2017 @10:30AM (#15434067)
That would be stressing the system. My point is as a consumer, you can't continuously measure your maximum bandwidth without using it all.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by gsich on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:35PM (#15435284)
Well you always have Layer 1/2 data. DSL modems, cable, LTE ... will show diagnostic information on which you can estimate some bandwidth, more or less.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by wtallis on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:49PM (#15436872)
That doesn't help you figure out if there's congestion two hops away in the ISPs network due to them oversubscribing their backhaul links.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by gsich on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:05PM (#15438151)
True. That's what speedtests are for. Ideally you have your own server, so that you can factor out at least one third party.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by SomeStupidPoint on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:17PM (#15431177)
You are correct in theory.

However, the present system is so bad that it routinely fails at (eg) streaming Netflix even though this uses less than your advertised bandwidth (by a wide margin).

So at present, it would just be a matter of automatic documentation of failures -- and the situation would be much improved if we were up against the limit you propose.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by foota on Monday October 09, 2017 @10:30AM (#15434070)
Fair point.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by xzel on Sunday October 08, 2017 @11:36PM (#15431420)
God the internet provider racket could be my least favorite thing about NYC. The infra is terrible, ping is pretty terrible, price rates are terrible, providers are terrible and you probably only have one for your building. Its a real shit storm. There are too many people for the current infra there and I'm sure no one want to foot the bill to improve it.

I had Spectrum when I moved from NYC. I probably got 50/50 out of the 100/100 and during times of high traffic (dinner until 11) it was probably more like 20/20. I called, they said eh, you can pay 250 to get a better connection put in.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by ploxiln on Sunday October 08, 2017 @11:54PM (#15431478)
I've never seen a cable company offer 100/100, it was 100/10 or 200/20 or 300/20 (mbps) last I checked.

In my experience, the internet available in NYC is way better than most suburban or rural places in the US. 50/50 is actually pretty good, if that's what you were getting - that's like 5 high-definition video streams both up and down.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by isatty on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:13AM (#15431536)
It's bizarre to me that you think that 50/50 is good. I'm on 1gbps up/down and using slower connections at home is not ideal for me.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by maccard on Monday October 09, 2017 @05:58AM (#15432587)
1gb/1gb is incredible, and probably top 1% in the world of connections. My office connection is 1gbps/1gbps, and my home connection is 15mbps/2mbps, with no possibility to improve. The highest package available in my city with any provider (not available in my area), and probably across most of the uk is 300mbps/30mbps
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by azinman2 on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:50AM (#15431647)
It’s more than sufficient to watch Netflix, download things in reasonable times, and browse the web.

Few have 1gbps...

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by khedoros1 on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:17AM (#15432060)
I would classify 1gbps symmetrical as "stupendous". 50/50 would be "good". I'm paying too much for 50/10, and apparently being delivered about 15/5 (per my ISP's speedtest).
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by BigJono on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:50AM (#15431645)
The median connection in Melbourne, Australia is around 6/1. I'd count your blessings. Last year my house was only serviced by one ISP and the only connection available was 1.5/0.2 ADSL. Half the modern webpages we go to don't even load at those speeds.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by jen729w on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:20AM (#15431888)
Source? I live in Fitzroy and while I’d agree that it’s generally woeful in Oz that seems a tad low. Experience at multiple rental properties puts it closer to 12/1.

I just got my FTTB NBN last week and I’m getting 94/34. I am over the moon, which will doubtless make some here chuckle. That’s an epic connection for Australia.

(Theoretical max for FTTB VDSL is 100/40.)

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by BigJono on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:50AM (#15433050)
My last 4 properties have been 4Mb/s, the aforementioned 1.5Mb/s, a place that had 30Mb/s cable, and now 6Mb/s. All south-eastern suburbs.

I'd say inner suburbs like Fitzroy are probably batting above average. You've got much shorter distances to the DSLAMs there for ADSL2, and more businesses which means more infrastructure.

Obviously the average and median are going to go way up now that they're connecting FTTN and HFC everywhere. From the people I've talked to, the average seems to be around 20-30Mb/s. My parent's house is actually slower now that they've officially installed HFC there (they were getting 30Mb/s on cable, now 20) :/

Woeful is definitely a good word for it. Clusterfuck would be up there too.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by smudgymcscmudge on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:39PM (#15429362)
Our cable internet is sold as "up to 100mbps", so the joke at our house is that if we ever get 101mbps we will sue them for breach of contract.

Edit: I realize it isn't a good joke.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by hrrsn on Sunday October 08, 2017 @05:39PM (#15430144)
The New Zealand Commerce Commission got grumpy when ISPs started selling gigabit plans as 1000mbit, as it's not realistically possible for consumers to reach those speeds. So, instead of gigabit, we get "up to 900/400Mbps" or more realistically about 800/400, which, you know what, I can live with.

http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/industries/87071149/spark-wa...

http://beta.speedtest.net/result/6671498802.png

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Cyph0n on Sunday October 08, 2017 @09:41PM (#15431079)
Are internet packages better in NZ than in Australia? I'm assuming the connection is heavily metered?
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by ajdlinux on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:54PM (#15431286)
The NZ Ultra Fast Broadband project is delivering a lot more FTTP, whereas the Australian National Broadband Network started out delivering FTTP and switched to a primarily FTTN network after an election caused a change of government, much to the annoyance of anyone who was hoping to finally get decent network infrastructure in this country...
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by UberMouse on Sunday October 08, 2017 @09:59PM (#15431136)
I have an unlimited gigabit connection that I pay $120NZD per month for. And for content on good CDNs or hosted in the country I do get near the advertised speed. It took me just under 4 minutes to download the Star Wars Battlefront 2 beta from Origin which had a size of 23.78GB, averaging 90+ MB/s.

I probably use around 5TB of data per month as well.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by krzyk on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:23AM (#15431571)
Nice, do you have also uplink with gigabit?

In Poland I ave 300/30 Mbit (they connected fiber to my house recently) for 50 PLN (it is about 19 NZD, or 13 USD) per month. They offer 600/60 in some cities (where there is more competition), but I don't know the price, I think is is more in 80PLN range. And plan to start also 1 gbit plan (probably with 100 Mbit uplink).

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by hrrsn on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:02AM (#15432185)
Not the guy you asked, but here the speeds are set by the fibre infrastructure holders, not the ISP. So on residential connections the fastest you'll get is 900/500. I pay $129 NZD (~335 PLN). Not symmetrical, but damn impressive nonetheless.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by chrisper on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:44AM (#15431633)
In Switzerland I have gbit up and down and pay like 90 CHF (92 USD) in a month.

I use the G Suite Google Drive and get nearly full gbit while up and downloading.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by azinman2 on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:53AM (#15431659)
I’m about to get symmetric 1gbit from Sonic in SF for the initial price of $40/Mo... after a while it goes up to $60.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Cyph0n on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:41PM (#15431244)
Damn, that's not bad at all! For comparison, I pay 40 USD for a 20 Mbit connection with Xfinity here in the US. Oh, and I only get 1 TB of data per month.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by chrisper on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:45AM (#15431635)
I am so glad I moved out of Comcast territory.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by hrrsn on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:59AM (#15432174)
Our government has invested a lot more into broadband infrastructure than Australia has. We rolled out FTTN (Fibre to the Node) for improved ADSL/VDSL years ago, and now FTTH is deployed in a lot of places so far. Australia proposed FTTH, then rolled back on that. So yes, we're generally much better for Internet than Australia.

Nope, 100% unlimited. Metered connections were a thing here 5 years ago, nowdays you generally get 80GB or so to start with and can upgrade to unlimited for a little extra. I pay $129 NZD ($91 USD~) per month for my unlimited almost-gigabit connection which is the most expensive residential tier available, and I can pick from any number of ISPs (there's like 5 major ones and plenty of tiny players) as the infrastructure is shared, unlike what you see in the U.S. with the cable companies.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by BrandoElFollito on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:17PM (#15436154)
I pay 45€ for 500/250 in France. I get 950/230.

The move to fiber (it ends on my box) was awesome.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by dboreham on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:28PM (#15429848)
If I may balance things a little here : we have "100Mbit" Charter/Spectrum and for the vast majority of the time we get ...120Mbits/s. True, there are times, usually a Sunday evening, when things go topot on their network and QoS goes down the pan, but those times are rare and the problem seems to get resolved quickly.

Measured at the demarc Ethernet segment, L2 throughput including framing overhead, with a single TCP stream to a server I control that is about 1000 miles away.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by wmf on Sunday October 08, 2017 @07:34PM (#15430623)
Yes, I get 70 on a 50 plan from Spectrum. This is less awesome once you realize why they're doing it: in some places they have serious congestion during peak hours so they are giving extra performance during off-peak hours to make the average daily throughput of FCC speed measurements equal 100%. This was uncovered in the New York lawsuit.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by bgirard on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:36PM (#15429880)
Would be an interesting defense against a bandwidth overage charge.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by tialaramex on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:19AM (#15432248)
The article is about the UK. Previous OFCOM rules told providers they must advertise only a speed that at least 10% of customers can reach. So yes, people got faster than the advertised speed, about 10% of people. It makes no difference to the whining unfortunately.

The effect is, for say 40MBps VDSL (the service most UK households with "broadband" use, almost always ultimately delivered through a copper telephone cable from BT's Openreach last mile subsidiary) all the ISPs will advertise that as "up to 38Mbps" because at least 10% of their customers can get 38Mbps out of that link. Nobody gets 50Mbps, the link layer is throttled because they're on a 40Mbps product, but plenty of people absolutely will get 40Mbps even though the advert said "up to 38Mbps".

That includes my very tech-savvy ISP which is obliged to say "up to 38Mbps" in big print everywhere even though it explains that you're buying the 40Mbps VDSL service and talks about deep network internals, and even though its customers usually know exactly what speed they'll get (I get 40Mbps) because they're technical people and know how to measure.

Now, suppose you're one of the people getting 30Mbps from the 40Mbps VDSL product. Should you upgrade? There's an "up to 76Mbps" product advertised by your supplier, surely that would be faster? No. All the "up to 76Mbps" product does is change the throttle to 80Mbps, and you aren't impacted by the throttle so the product will simply cost more and achieve nothing.

Now, in fact under those rules an ISP had an incentive NOT to sell you the expensive product, because if they give you the 80Mbps product then you hurt their "up to 76Mbps" averages and make it harder to sell the product.

The result of _that_ change to the market was ISPs would have a headline product advertised heavily e.g. "Guaranteed at least 60Mbps for £24.99 per month" and then if they couldn't meet the guarantee for a particular customer they wouldn't magically fix things to go faster, they would simply say "Ah, you don't qualify for that offer, you can have a refund and the service stops, or pay £9.99 per month for our other product "Guaranteed 10Mbps" which we're meeting.

The ideology behind all this stuff is that our old friend the "invisible hand" will fix it. But er, no. There is actually only one last mile technology involved (for people in most cities there is a competitor, Cable TV cables, but that's a whole separate ball of wax) and it's VDSL offered at speeds set by the wholesaler. It will perform exactly the same whether you buy your "service" from an ISP with a call centre staff in India that uses a purple logo and has a chimp mascot, or you buy "service" from two blokes named James who work out of a rented office in Liverpool, because the "ISP" part is trivial and largely irrelevant except for branding, and the last mile part is a natural monopoly provided always by the exact same engineers, same copper cables, same everything.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by barrkel on Monday October 09, 2017 @08:04AM (#15433111)
There are often bandwidth caps on each tier, which is a different reason to upgrade.

If you consume a lot of video online, the caps can be hit surprisingly quickly.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Chris2048 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:05PM (#15429731)
I found the edit funny though.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by xkpd3 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:06PM (#15429734)
What about turning this logic backwards?

I don't need a guarantee. I want per-mbit prices. Like you pay what you get. Limit the rate by saying: I will pay up to 100mbit for example.

Then the can give you less for less money. But this would not be in their interest anymore.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by zzzcpan on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:08PM (#15429748)
Plans are for marketing purposes only. Broadband ISPs already typically calculate bandwidth as 1-2 mbps per customer.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by e_proxus on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:34AM (#15432983)
Sweden has solved this in a pretty good way I think. As an ISP you have to disclose a range (e.g. 12-24 Mbit/s) and pledge to keep that lower limit. In some areas you see instead the range of 1-XX and then you know as a customer that the connection is less reliable.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by rayiner on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:57PM (#15429689)
They’re selling best effort service at a fraction of the price of what dedicated bandwidth costs. We’ve got a 100/100 symmetric line at work. We can pick from several different business Internet providers, but they all cost many multiples of what my symmetric gigabit line at home costs. It’s a different product offered at a different price.

This is not unique to ISPs. You can buy an over-subscribed VPS for a fraction of the cost of a dedicated server.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Silhouette on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:18PM (#15429800)
They’re selling best effort service at a fraction of the price of what dedicated bandwidth costs.

Unfortunately, what they are advertising is something quite different, and the claims made are often wildly inaccurate.

Over-subscription of shared resources for efficiency is one thing, but misleading advertising is something quite different. Frankly, if they get their maths wrong and consequently fail to provide the expected level of service, that's on them anyway.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by rayiner on Sunday October 08, 2017 @06:20PM (#15430331)
That's why home services are always advertised as "up to" X mbps.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Silhouette on Sunday October 08, 2017 @09:08PM (#15430963)
That's been a sore point for a long time, hence the discussion we're having today. But even with the weasel words, there are misleading practices going on.

For example, if an ISP is offering several levels of service with speeds up to X, Y and Z (in increasing order), it's clearly unexpected from a customer's point of view for an ISP to move them from X to Y or Y to Z if the customer is already getting below the upper bound speed on their current plan and has no prospect of getting a faster speed in return for the presumably higher charge for a "faster" plan.

Likewise, if there is no realistic prospect of a customer achieving anywhere near the X in "up to X", it's misleading for the ISP to offer them service on that basis.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Spivak on Sunday October 08, 2017 @09:15PM (#15430988)
> there are misleading practices going on.

I don't really know how you fix it though. Would selling priority be enough?

Priority 1: "For gaming and other high performance needs. Typical ping: Xms, Typical throughput: Y/Mbps"

Priority 2: "Perfect for causal streaming and general internet usage..."

Priority 3: "Affordable internet and good performance on off-peak hours..."

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:59AM (#15433085)
Just as every other service that uses oversold networks?

The electricity grid is oversold. Do you normally notice that? No!

The flight network is oversold. Do you normally notice that? Not really. And if you do, they have to pay you for failure to perform, cover your costs ...

So, they get to decide whatever bandwidth they want to advertise, possibly they could reserve the right to cancel the contract if the line turns out to be too bad after all (in which case you obviously don't have to pay anything), and then they have to make sure that you never notice that the network is actually oversold by monitoring load and adding capacity to their network as needed to avoid congestion. Up to three minutes of congestion per month is acceptable. Beyond that, they have to reimburse your payment for the month because of failure to perform.

Obviously, it is perfectly fine to advertise different speeds for different times of the day, as long as you don't advertise "1 Gb/s" and then a footnote saying "from 3 am to 4 am, otherwise 10 Mb/s". Or you could advertise burstable service ("100 Mb/s, 10 minutes burstable to 1 Gb/s").

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Spivak on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:57PM (#15435989)
Sure, but if every internet company started advertising their internet packages more transparently as 'best effort, capped at $speed' would you suddenly be happy with your terrible internet?

I don't thing changing the marketing rules will suddenly bring about the sweeping infrastructure changes you imagine.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:40PM (#15436337)
"best effort, capped at $speed" is not transparent, it's just different wording for "up to $speed". "Best effort" is a completely meaningless term in this context, as it is completely up to the ISP to decide how much infrastructure they build, and thus what speed you can achieve. There is no fundamental reason why an ISP could not provide you full 100 Gb/s duplex 24/7 at any point whatsoever on this planet--it is all a matter of how much money they decide to spend on it, which is not your problem as a customer. So, wording of that kind in effect simply means "we don't owe you anything in particular, we will decide after the fact what you get in exchange for the payments that you owe us."

The point of actually transparent marketing is not to directly improve the connectivity you get, but to enable a market to actually work. If customers cannot know what service they will be getting for their money, then competition cannot possibly work. Imagine all packages in the grocery store were labeled with "up to 1 liter" or "up to 1 kg", and no way to weigh them yourself before you buy them ... how would that possibly allow the better product to win out? What if someone truthfully labeled their product "100 g" ... how could people figure out whether that's the better product than the "up to 1 kg" package right next to it?

Nothing guarantees that better products would actually happen, but at least, if they do get offered, customers would have some chance to actually know, and thus for the better product to gain customers.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Spivak on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:03PM (#15438986)
> is a completely meaningless term

It's not totally meaningless, and people would understand what it actually means https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Best-effort_delivery.

> There is no fundamental reason why an ISP could not provide you full 100 Gb/s duplex 24/7 at any point whatsoever on this planet

Well yeah... with enough money. I guarantee that you wouldn't like looking your internet bill when you have those kinds of guarantees.

> What if someone truthfully labeled their product "100 g"

The internet version of this would be 100Mb guaranteed with an SLA. Or 'business class internet' which few consumers buy because it's expensive. It's not like it isn't available -- it's popular among streamers.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:52PM (#15439196)
> It's not totally meaningless, and people would understand what it actually means https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Best-effort_delivery.

Please don't quote out of context.

Also, as you claim that it is not totally meaningless in this context: Assume an offer of "best effort internet, capped at 100 Mb/s". Please tell me what actual bandwidth I can expect to achieve 90% of the time, and how you derived that value from that offer.

> Well yeah... with enough money. I guarantee that you wouldn't like looking your internet bill when you have those kinds of guarantees.

You are simply missing the point.

> The internet version of this would be 100Mb guaranteed with an SLA. Or 'business class internet' which few consumers buy because it's expensive. It's not like it isn't available -- it's popular among streamers.

No, it's not. There are other possibilities besides "you have a 100% guarantee that 100 Mb/s is available every second of every day" and "if you are lucky, some of your packets may get delivered".

Also, how exactly would a product become more expensive merely because the ISP told you what the product actually is? If an ISP connects up to 10 1 Gb/s links to one 1 Gb/s uplink, say, how exactly does the price of that product become higher if the ISP told you that informartion (or equivalently, that you have a minimum bandwidth of 100 Mb/s available at all times)?!

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @09:59PM (#15431135)
A good starting point wold be the speed that's available at least 95% of the time.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Spivak on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:54PM (#15435958)
Right, but then customers are going to be either really disappointed at that number or the price is going to skyrocket when basically every internet package becomes dedicated.

Under your rule there would really be no way to sell 'best effort, capped at X' internet packages.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Dylan16807 on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:04PM (#15437008)
You can oversell by quite a lot and still meet an advertised speed with 90 or 95% reliability.

If you want to sell 'best effort, no promises' then don't make promises. Or promise something low, like "2mbps" or "2-20mbps".

The real disappointment comes when you can't reach the advertised speed for multiple hours every day. There is much less disappointment in the end if the advertised speed matches a state of moderate, everyday congestion.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by rayiner on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:26AM (#15431580)
I agree that if you simply can’t get the advertised speed, that’s misleading (though, at least on cable or DSL systems it can be very hard to tell a priori what speeds a given chstomer’s line will be capable of). But whenever this discussion comes up, people push back on the very idea of oversubscription or best-effort service.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by zzzcpan on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:04PM (#15429727)
Home and "business" lines are exactly the same for pretty much every ISP out there. Real difference starts only for other ISPs (or anyone with ISP level bandwidth requirements), still best effort though.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by waffle_ss on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:14PM (#15429779)
I was under the impression business lines typically have a different contention ratio[1], so you are less at the mercy of "noisy neighbors," as well as offering real SLAs (for whatever good those are).

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contention_ratio

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by dboreham on Sunday October 08, 2017 @05:04PM (#15429992)
The parents are I think talking past each other somewhat, because there are really three kinds of Internet service and you're talking about two of them as if they're the same thing:

1. Consumer/Residential: speed is "up to", throughput is highly asymmetrical, QoS is best effort, reliability is "mostly works", if you are lucky you will get a human if you call for support. If you complain about service typically the response is a shrug. Generally the service is whatever the provider defines it to be and you either buy it or you don't. Often static IP is not available. Cost: $20-100/mo.

2. Business: Sold by the same providers as #1. Much the same service, except (this varies) : dedicated channels on HFC, different traffic shaping, static IP allowed, perhaps even subnets, if you are really lucky reverse DNS is supported. Generally you get a human when you call support. If you complain about service they might do some basic investigation. In the case of our cableco they have different humans knocking on your door for install and trouble shooting (perhaps the more knowledgeable and more senior folks?). Cost: $50-200/mo

ISP upstream/Dedicated/Real Connectivity: The name varies but this what one of the parent posts calls "Business". The service an ISP would get, or a big tech company, etc. You typically get an SLA with specified maximum packet loss rates and latency profile. Throughput is symmetric. Local loop is typically fiber. You can run your own BGP, HSPR etc is supported. IPv6 is always available. You can call the provider's NOC directly and have a conversation about why they're dropping packets in one direction to some obscure peer somewhere in the world. They'll investigate and resolve the problem asap. If you accidentally power off your edge router one of their NOC staff will call your call phone within minutes asking why there's no traffic on your link. Cost: $1000/mo+

Source: I ran an ISP for 10 years.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by rayiner on Sunday October 08, 2017 @06:32PM (#15430386)
There is an entire market segment in-between those: http://www.cogentco.com/en/products-and-services/dedicated-i.... For several hundred to several thousand dollars per month, Cogent, Comcast (Metro-E), Light Tower, etc. will sell you dedicated bandwidth to their backbone and an SLA.

You can't expect $50/month services advertised as offering "up to" a certain amount of bandwidth to give the same level of consistency.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by lostboys67 on Monday October 09, 2017 @09:36AM (#15433635)
you can get ELM (30 /40 MBS) in the UK for £70/month we used it for a stop gap whist our1MBS was provisioned
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Namrog84 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @07:15PM (#15430566)
Where I used to live many years ago. I paid for up to 30. Got about 23. Then I switched to cheaper 10 and still got 23. And told all my friends and they got the same. They had 3 tiers all providing identical service beyond who was willing to pay for 10,30 or 50. Did this for 3+ years.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by kuschku on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:11PM (#15429466)
Actually, this is an interesting topic, because there are court decisions on this in Germany.

So if an ISP has, say, a 25mbps, 50mbps, and 75mbps plan, the 50mbps plan has to provide 25 or more, and the 75mbps plan has to provide 50mbps or more.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by executesorder66 on Monday October 09, 2017 @06:10AM (#15432620)
I decided last year that I want to move to Germany within 5 years. (For various reasons) Since I've made that decision, I keep finding more reasons to do so.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by walshemj on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:11PM (#15429468)
You know how ADSL (and related tech) works the speed you get depends on the distance from the exchange I don't know how it works in the USA but I ca test my line and at 6k yards it said I should get 3.5 ish which is what I get .

I suspect a lot of BB speed complaints are down to poor wifi installations and local congestion in the wifi bands

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Freestyler_3 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:21PM (#15429814)
See, this is what bothers me. There are people who mistake the speed of their internet with the speed of their own network. It bothers me a lot that when I call about slow speeds that the ISP starts troubleshooting my network. I know not to test on the wifi. (mostly test on the modem itself)

I have a 500/500 line, and get guaranteed that it wont fall 10% below that. Most of the time I am really close to it or even above it. Right now I am seeing an anomaly 420/220. Not going to complain though, I only have this line because the other option was 20/2 for 80% of the price im paying now. Does help when getting or sending big files over for projects. edit: speedtest was giving me a slow server, better results now http://www.speedtest.net/my-result/6690112916

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by throw_away_4567 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:00PM (#15429704)
It sort of depends on distance, in reality it depends more on circuit noise and attenuation. If you have a really quiet circuit and high gauge high quality copper you will get a good signal to noise ratio which will give the modem margin to train to.

The curves used to calculate speed over distance make bulk assumptions.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by slipstream- on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:12PM (#15429472)
>If you can simply provide "up to" on something, then I wanna sell you a box for ten bucks that contains up to a million dollars!

So, scratchcards then?

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by drrob on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:51AM (#15432341)
The classic excuse I'm receiving from Virgin Broadband at the moment is "we're currently upgrading the network in your area, there may be some speed disruption for several months." I'm paying for 100mbps, a few weeks back I tested it during one bad spell; I was receiving less than 1mbps.

I was struggling to sync my emails, never mind watch Netflix.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by bostik on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:25AM (#15432933)
Not to mention that right now (and in fact for the past 4-5 days) Virgin Broadband is utterly broken.

I get 38% average packet loss over long time windows, and see 2500ms+ roundtrips to the next hop. If this area was served by Hyperoptic, I would have changed more than two years ago.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by drrob on Monday October 09, 2017 @08:18AM (#15433181)
If my area was merely served by two tin cans joined by a piece of string I'd have changed years ago.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by mrmondo on Sunday October 08, 2017 @05:03PM (#15429984)
Australia is appalling for this, the average person paying for 24Mbit ADSL2+ gets a messily 7Mbit (and I thought 24Mbit was bad enough!).
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by chrismorgan on Sunday October 08, 2017 @08:24PM (#15430778)
In Melbourne I never experienced sustained speeds of below 9Mbps on ADSL2+ in two locations, normally 11–12Mbps.

But if you want a fast, stable Internet connection, move out into a small country town with a 4G tower (doesn’t need to be NBN). There’s much less congestion. Look around for plans, as most are expensive; I use amaysim’s 50GB/$65/28 days which is about what ADSL2+ would be in the country. Living in Stawell (a few thousand people) I get 20–25/12Mbps with greater reliability than I ever got on ADSL2+. I shall be moving to Navarre soon (~100 people) and get 45/15Mbps there.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by viraptor on Sunday October 08, 2017 @08:52PM (#15430889)
If you can live with the data cap, that's great. Otherwise, 50gb is pretty low for work (remote conferences, download some system images, upgrade your mac and you're done).

Another issue in small towns is that the moment a new tower needs to go up, there may be a low of community pushback (radiation! kids!). It's much better if the current one gets an upgrade.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by dragonsky67 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:12PM (#15431163)
Small towns in Australia tend to be a lot less paranoid about technology than an equivalent sized town in the USA. Comes from being really remote (think 100+Km to the next centre), having to fight for any services at all and a long history of using telecommunication technology to make life better. Think School of the Air using HF radios to provide education to remote children.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by viraptor on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:41PM (#15431245)
Some possibly are. Mount Beauty had a weeks long local Facebook posts about it when wireless NBN was being planned.

Then there are cases like this: https://wangarattachronicle.com.au/2017/08/30/solar-flare-up...

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by mrmondo on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:41AM (#15431620)
Yeah I can't imagine using less than 500GB~ month myself, wireless isn't the answer as it does not scale at all well.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by nathan_long on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:28AM (#15432954)
> It always puzzled me that internet companies can simply say that the speed is "up to" a certain number.

I always imagine it like this:

    Them: "This plan gives you up to 23mb/s."
    Me: "So you're saying you guarantee I will not get more than 23mb/s?"
    Them: "Right."
    Me: "OK. I'll pay you up to $40 a month for that."
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by maxxxxx on Sunday October 08, 2017 @08:57PM (#15430917)
Same for "Unlimited" when it actually has clear limits. Or camera manufacturers sell "Weather resistant" equipment but never specify what it means exactly and will void your warranty if there is water damage.

Having their cake and eating it too!

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by Nition on Sunday October 08, 2017 @07:27PM (#15430601)
Tangentially related: We used to have a bunch of "$2 Shop" stores - I think other countries have the equivalent "dollar store", "pound shop" etc. Due to inflation they've all now become "$2+ Dollar" shops or "$2 and up" etc.

In reality of course they still sell the same sort of cheap stuff but it's funny how the name has gone from a shop that guarantees cheap prices, to one that guarantees not to be really cheap, since any price is now valid except ones below $2.

Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by richev on Sunday October 08, 2017 @07:00PM (#15430509)
It's because the law hasn't yet caught up with their spurious marketing claims.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by BrandoElFollito on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:14PM (#15436136)
It would be interesting to pay in x€/Mbps (up to y Mbps). This is how I buy potatoes so this is hardly a revolutionary novelty.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by BenjiWiebe on Sunday October 08, 2017 @05:00PM (#15429972)
I'm aware a lot of people have this problem, but here in a rural area we are paying for 6 Mbps DSL and usually get 6.25 to 6.5.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom by icebraining on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:24PM (#15429532)
They can. I often had 11mbps on my 10mpbs cable line.