Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by foota on Sunday October 08, 2017 @09:37PM
(#15431071)
I don't think this would work since you can't effectively measure bandwidth available without stressing the system?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by wtallis on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:37AM
(#15431608)
You can't do it properly from an endpoint, but the ISPs are already monitoring it internally. They know when and where they have serious congestion.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by notyourwork on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:53AM
(#15431658)
This is precisely why ISP's should have to operate more transparently as a common carrier and not as a private business milking a cash cow.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by chii on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:26AM
(#15432085)
If an electric utility company did the same, with 'up-to 240volts' - they'd get their ass sued out of existence. Why can't the gov't establish standards for such things, like a minimum speed (from the IPS's own servers of course, you cannot expect that they control it all).
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by hueving on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:02AM
(#15432186)
They would just game it then and underinvest on peering (similar to what happened in the netflix/Comcast scenario). What good is 1gbit guaranteed to your ISP if the entire ISP only has 10mbps to the rest of the world?
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by wmf on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:05PM
(#15435554)
Presumably peering congestion would be one of the regulated metrics, just like voltage would be for an electric utility.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by maccard on Monday October 09, 2017 @05:41AM
(#15432512)
Better than having 10mbps to your ISP and your ISP having 10mbps to the rest of the world, if you're paying for 100
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by gsich on Monday October 09, 2017 @06:15AM
(#15432647)
Why not? If the ISP provides a server you can download a file from, you can see your speed, the ISP can see the speed.
Yes there might be issues with your PC and such, but this can be easily tested.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by foota on Monday October 09, 2017 @10:30AM
(#15434067)
That would be stressing the system. My point is as a consumer, you can't continuously measure your maximum bandwidth without using it all.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by gsich on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:35PM
(#15435284)
Well you always have Layer 1/2 data. DSL modems, cable, LTE ... will show diagnostic information on which you can estimate some bandwidth, more or less.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by wtallis on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:49PM
(#15436872)
That doesn't help you figure out if there's congestion two hops away in the ISPs network due to them oversubscribing their backhaul links.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by gsich on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:05PM
(#15438151)
True. That's what speedtests are for. Ideally you have your own server, so that you can factor out at least one third party.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by SomeStupidPoint on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:17PM
(#15431177)
You are correct in theory.
However, the present system is so bad that it routinely fails at (eg) streaming Netflix even though this uses less than your advertised bandwidth (by a wide margin).
So at present, it would just be a matter of automatic documentation of failures -- and the situation would be much improved if we were up against the limit you propose.