Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by m12k on Monday October 09, 2017 @09:25AM
(#15433547)
Yeah, it'd be perfectly reasonable if it was prorated. So if during a month they managed to provide an average of 70% of the promised speed, I should pay them 70% of the subscription cost.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday October 09, 2017 @10:32AM
(#15434089)
Average is not a good measure for that, because there are lots of hours during the day where even the worst ISPs don't have any congestion, and still the connection can be unusable during peak hours. The right measure would be the minimum throughput that you achieved, maybe minus a few minutes of congestion per month that are ignored. If they sell you a 100 Mb/s pipe, that should mean that you should essentially never notice that it's not actually reserved 100 Mb/s. People don't buy 100 Mb/s because they want 100 Mb/s at 3 am, they buy 100 Mb/s because they want 100 Mb/s when they need it, which in most cases is during peak load times (which is why those are the peak load times).
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by foota on Sunday October 08, 2017 @09:37PM
(#15431071)
I don't think this would work since you can't effectively measure bandwidth available without stressing the system?
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by wtallis on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:37AM
(#15431608)
You can't do it properly from an endpoint, but the ISPs are already monitoring it internally. They know when and where they have serious congestion.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by notyourwork on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:53AM
(#15431658)
This is precisely why ISP's should have to operate more transparently as a common carrier and not as a private business milking a cash cow.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by chii on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:26AM
(#15432085)
If an electric utility company did the same, with 'up-to 240volts' - they'd get their ass sued out of existence. Why can't the gov't establish standards for such things, like a minimum speed (from the IPS's own servers of course, you cannot expect that they control it all).
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by hueving on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:02AM
(#15432186)
They would just game it then and underinvest on peering (similar to what happened in the netflix/Comcast scenario). What good is 1gbit guaranteed to your ISP if the entire ISP only has 10mbps to the rest of the world?
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by wmf on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:05PM
(#15435554)
Presumably peering congestion would be one of the regulated metrics, just like voltage would be for an electric utility.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by maccard on Monday October 09, 2017 @05:41AM
(#15432512)
Better than having 10mbps to your ISP and your ISP having 10mbps to the rest of the world, if you're paying for 100
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by gsich on Monday October 09, 2017 @06:15AM
(#15432647)
Why not? If the ISP provides a server you can download a file from, you can see your speed, the ISP can see the speed.
Yes there might be issues with your PC and such, but this can be easily tested.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by foota on Monday October 09, 2017 @10:30AM
(#15434067)
That would be stressing the system. My point is as a consumer, you can't continuously measure your maximum bandwidth without using it all.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by gsich on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:35PM
(#15435284)
Well you always have Layer 1/2 data. DSL modems, cable, LTE ... will show diagnostic information on which you can estimate some bandwidth, more or less.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by wtallis on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:49PM
(#15436872)
That doesn't help you figure out if there's congestion two hops away in the ISPs network due to them oversubscribing their backhaul links.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by gsich on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:05PM
(#15438151)
True. That's what speedtests are for. Ideally you have your own server, so that you can factor out at least one third party.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by SomeStupidPoint on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:17PM
(#15431177)
You are correct in theory.
However, the present system is so bad that it routinely fails at (eg) streaming Netflix even though this uses less than your advertised bandwidth (by a wide margin).
So at present, it would just be a matter of automatic documentation of failures -- and the situation would be much improved if we were up against the limit you propose.
I mean it makes perfect sense. And oh, what fire it would light under their asses.