News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by casca on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:03PM (#6857631)
Mandela reminds us that it's possible for a single man to create peace amidst a huge push for war. Forgiveness is the first step in changing a society, without it we are doomed to repeat the failures of our ancestors.

He continues to be an inspiration, particularly us Africans. Rest in peace Madiba.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mathieuh on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:16PM (#6857739)
Do not allow liberals to sanitise history. Mandela was a symbol of non-peaceful resistance and of the progress that it can bring.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by casca on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:30PM (#6857845)
Can you please elaborate on this? The ANC (Mandela's political party) including Mandela himself certainly committed a wide range of violent acts in response to a vast display of vile force from the ruling South African government. However the respect that Mandela receives is for his actions after he was released from prison. After winning political power democratically, he was in a strong position to take retribution on those that had imprisoned him and caused such misery and hardship to his people.

But he didn't. He tried to bridge the huge divide. At the time, and I speak as someone who was living through it, there was a real fear that the country would erupt into a civil war. There was so much hate on both sides. It is widely believed by people from all South African political views that Mandela was responsible for reconciling the opposing sides and beginning a path of building a new country.

Was he perfect? Of course not. But he achieved what so many deemed impossible in a noble manner and this is extremely rare in political leaders anywhere in the world.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by moultano on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:09PM (#6858082)
What I found interesting from reading his autobiography is that he didn't consider non-violence to be an end in itself. Rather he viewed it as one tool among many.

Edit: found the citation. http://books.google.com/books?id=RHwLqVrnXgIC&lpg=PT189&dq=l...

>Others said that we should approach this issue not from the point of view of principles but of tactics, and that we should employ the method demanded by the conditions. If a particular method or tactic enabled us to defeat the enemy, then it should be used. In this case, the state was far more powerful than we, and any attempts at violence by us would be devastatingly crushed. This made nonviolence a practical necessity rather than an option. This was my view, and I saw nonviolence in the Gandhian model not as an inviolable principle but as a tactic to be used as the situation demanded. The principle was not so important that the strategy should be used even when it was self- defeating, as Gandhi himself believed. I called for nonviolent protest for as long as it was effective. This view prevailed, despite Manilal Gandhi's strong objections.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by treenyc on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:53PM (#6859090)
Effective exercise of leadership is more like a dance than doing steps. Rather than doing one step correctly, try to dance to music.

There is no ONE correct solution for every situation. Sometime peaceful non-violence is required, sometimes using high tech solution is appropriate to make things more productive, and sometime military force is required to defend one self.

Rather than standing behind one principle, try addressing the concerns of relevant parties.

Leadership is granted by those people who lead you and those whom you lead.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by read on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:22AM (#6860731)

  "Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to
   change the world."

   - Nelson Mandela
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by djKianoosh on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:32AM (#6861156)
"Resentment is like drinking poison and then hoping it will kill your enemies." - Nelson Mandela
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:32PM (#6858478)
Mandela founded the MK, a terrorist organization that bombed both military and civilian targets.

Mandela: "...without violence ... no way ... to succeed in .. struggle against ... white supremacy."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umkhonto_we_Sizwe#Motivation_fo...

He might have turned into a pacifist, at some point, but he certainly gained political capital, intially, through violence. As with Arafat, I think he reached a point where violence as a tactic wasn't possible or useful.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by azernik on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:35AM (#6859588)
That's a lot of ellipses.

In full:

  Secondly, we felt that without violence there would be
  no way open to the African people to succeed in their
  struggle against the principle of white supremacy. All
  lawful modes of expressing opposition to this principle
  had been closed by legislation, and we were placed in a
  position in which we had either to accept a permanent
  state of inferiority, or take over the Government.
Not that it changes the immediate political meaning much, but it shows some of the thought processes involved.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:11AM (#6860362)
The point of quoting it was simply to show that Mandela considers violence a legitimate tactic. Mandela, unlike Western pacifist activists, has never claimed violence should be ruled out as an option.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by eaurouge on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:29PM (#6859005)
That's cute. A man dedicates his life to freeing his people from their oppressors, including spending 27 years in jail on principle, and upon release (and with overwhelming support) calls for "truth and reconciliation". We're talking about an entire life spent resisting an oppressive and violent regime. Many of us can't even begin to comprehend what that means, or what actions we may choose if in the same situation. Yet here you are with the benefit of hindsight, in relative comfort, analyzing a statement he made decades before his death. If you're going to judge, the least you can do is judge the man on the totality of his actions.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:38PM (#6859036)
I'm more interested in simply highlighting the whole truth rather than making a value judgement. The truth is that Mandela was a pragmatist in regards to tactics. When bombing fast food restaurants was tactically viable his organization did that. When the situation changed, he advocated an alternative approach.

"If the oppressor uses violence, the oppressed have no alternative but to respond violently." - Mandela (Long Walk to Freedom, p.537)

"If the state decided to use peaceful methods, the ANC would also use peaceful means. It is up to you... not us to renounce violence.” p.537

Looking at things tactically, it's a question of where your opponent is vulnerable: internally or externally. Pacifism is necessary to create the perception of legitimacy needed to mobilize external political support.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by eaurouge on Friday December 06, 2013 @03:41AM (#6860116)
I'm more interested in simply highlighting the whole truth rather than making a value judgement. The truth is that Mandela was a pragmatist in regards to tactics. When bombing fast food restaurants was tactically viable his organization did that. When the situation changed, he advocated an alternative approach.

No, you're attempting to portray him as someone who employed peaceful protest only when it proved convenient, or as a last resort. One only needs compare your 'quote' (all ellipses and no context) with the full quote posted by azernik.

He might have turned into a pacifist, at some point, but he certainly gained political capital, intially, through violence.

The opposite, you've got the wrong order. Read the link you posted on motivation for the formation of MK, then watch his interview in 1961, here (first posted by Q_the_Novice): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WrBCgiFhmNA.

As Q_the_Novice put it, "first educate yourself ... before posting ...".

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:35AM (#6860275)
I'm pointing out facts about him, nothing more. My quote was brief because I'd tweeted it and ended up copying the abbreviated form, but the substance of it is clear: it is a statement advocating militant struggle. The video clip you posted for some reason expresses a similar sentiment. And the quotes from his book I mentioned earlier, advocating violence in certain conditions, were from his book published in 1994.

Pacifism is defined as opposition to violence. Mandela, unlike many Western leftists, never ruled out violence as a tactic. Would his movement have succeeded without killing civilians and torturing enemies? Possibly not.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by booyaa00 on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:03AM (#6860170)
His torrorist organization bombed many civilian targets, such as railway stations. He also cheated on his first wife, and was a member of the communist party.

I'll judge him on that.

edit: Downvote this if you like, but the above are facts. Rather than the liberal whitewash that the media in the west prefers.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:18PM (#6871700)
You don't know much about it. You could start educating yourself here: http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=3430
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Joeboy on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:52AM (#6860320)
> If you're going to judge, the least you can do is judge the man on the totality of his actions.

Which is exactly why it's problematic to present Mandela as a symbol of Peace, Love and Understanding. There are people here trying to represent his advocacy of armed struggle during the apartheid era as some kind of youthful indiscretion for which he should be overlooked or forgiven, which does the man's legacy no favours at all.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by cook1929 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:45PM (#6859064)
That's cute. Now find me one instance of the white apartheid government intentionally bombing innocent civilians like Mandela's ANC did.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by frankzinger on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:10AM (#6859502)
Well, when you control the police and the army, bombing innocent civilians is neither necessary nor logical.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:19AM (#6861097)
If you can't find instances of the apartheid government intentionally doing terrible things to civilians all by yourself, then you don't deserve to be on the internet.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by yetanotherphd on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:00PM (#6859314)
I can see how that kind of logic applies to the Israel-Palestine conflict, but to apply it in this case is horrible and racist. Shame on you.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by cook1929 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:55PM (#6859463)
Wait, it is racist to ask for one instance of white apartheid South Africans intentionally killing women and children like Mandela's ANC did repeatedly?

Well, golly. If you insist.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by welly on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:33AM (#6860564)
The Sharpeville Massacre

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharpeville_massacre

You're welcome.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by DavidWanjiru on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:31AM (#6859570)
Are you specifically interested in bombing as a method of killing innocent people, or are you more generally interested in the killing of innocent people, the method notwithstanding? Coz, surely, you're not implying that white, apartheid South Africans didn't kill innocent people, are you?
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by yetanotherphd on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:25AM (#6859550)
I was employing irony there, which can be a useful tool for those on the right of the political spectrum.

My issue is not really with whether Apartheid is great, or Israel is great.

What my post was about was the way people on the far left or far right get away with their views whatever they are, but people in the center are required to assert that Apartheid is evil, while Israel is OK. You literally cannot call yourself a moderate if you do not believe these two things. And yet Israel and Apartheid South Africa are not very different. Both commit human rights violations against the native population. Both have (had) no clear path for the native population to become politically independent. Both claimed to look after the native population better than they could look after themselves. Both justified the situation because it was necessary to preserve their cultural/ethnic identity, and by claiming their opponents were terrorists.

So I call myself a moderate, but because I cannot accept the discrepancy between the way people are expected to view Israel and Apartheid, I would probably be considered a racist (for thinking that Apartheid was partly understandable) and also and anti-semite (for thinking that the desire for a Jewish state is not different for the desire for a White state).

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by theorique on Friday December 06, 2013 @11:19AM (#6861803)
Both commit human rights violations against the native population.

You mean when Hamas or Islamic Jihad detonates a bus bomb in Tel Aviv?

To pretend that Israeli military and/or police action against the terrorist government in Gaza takes place in a vacuum, or that it is aimed principally at civilians, ignores the reason why Israel is so militarized in the first place - very real security threats against the Israeli people and state.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by yetanotherphd on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:28PM (#6865171)
The South African resistance to apartheid also bombed civilians. And I suspect that they did not recognize the right of South Africa to exist as a White country.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mikebludd on Friday December 06, 2013 @01:42AM (#6859778)
16 JUNE 1976!
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by FridayWithJohn on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:05AM (#6860352)
Cook1929, your name suits you as you are still trapped in the 1920s.

As a white South African who was born in apartheid I saw first hand just how evil the system was. As for your examples you are after with regards to " one instance of white apartheid South Africans intentionally killing women and children" here you go: 1.) Ruth First (Joe Slovo's wife) was killed by a parcel bomb in Maputo. 2.) Soweto Uprising in which about 170 to about 600 people (mainly children) were killed by police... oh and one of the first people to be killed there was not some older man, the poor person was Hector Pieterson, he was only 13.

I know that Nelson Mandela wasn't a saint, (even he said that). However he gave to South Africa what it really needed. Peace and reconciliation, something that is still sorely needed in this world.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by sanderjd on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:37PM (#6858813)
It seems to me that both casca and mathieuh are correct - he was both a symbol of non-peaceful resistance, and a creator of peace amidst a push for war. Furthermore, his post-apartheid actions seem the more historically important, as they were the more novel and their relative success the more surprising.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mbillie1 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:35PM (#6859423)
I think there is a very different perspective (namely one that spans the entirety of Mandela's adult life) from which one can look at this. Yes, under a violent and oppressive racist regime which virtually anyone in the technologically-literate world would condemn, Mandela founded the MK and rebelled violently. He was imprisoned for a long time, released, and became the figurehead for positive, reconciliatory, peaceful change in a tumultuous part of the world. It's important to not deify the man, but it can come across as pedantic to bring to light the long-ago wrongs of someone who did, and stood for, an awful lot of right.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Q_the_Novice on Friday December 06, 2013 @01:15AM (#6859696)
Such short sightedness: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WrBCgiFhmNA . Do you have any idea what it was like to be black or non-white in Apartheid South Africa? First educate yourself about our people's history before posting ignorant public comments.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Friday December 06, 2013 @03:44AM (#6860128)
I am not making a value judgement, simply pointing out facts. Mandela's organization killed innocent people and tortured enemies. Why they did this is entirely understandable, given the circumstances, but pretending it didn't happen and painting Mandela as a pacifist, when he was in fact a pragmatist that never condemned violence wholesale as Western pacifists do, is to distort history.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by BenoitEssiambre on Friday December 06, 2013 @10:33AM (#6861541)
ah yes the mythical "western pacifist" who thinks violence is never justified and that, for example, police forces should not forcefully arrest violent criminals but limit themselves to trying to convince them of going to jail.

You've made yourself quite a frail stawman. You will find that this "western pacifist" you speak of is a figment of your imagination and doesn't exists in any serious form.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Friday December 06, 2013 @11:21AM (#6861816)
The decade or so I spent involved in activism in a variety of organizations is, hopefully, not a figment of my imagination.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by richardjordan on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:26PM (#6857810)
His peaceful assumption of power and non-violent transition of government are his lasting legacies. His violent struggle which resulted in his imprisonment became his advocacy for peaceful transformation. As the movement became focused on peaceful resistance it gained moral weight against the brutal violence perpetrated by the South African government.

Emphasizing the non-peaceful roots, and the fact that there was much violence in the struggle against the oppression of apartheid is to ignore his own words on the topic and to only tell half a story.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mathieuh on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:29PM (#6857834)
Mandela's address after being released from prison emphasises the need for continuing struggle against oppression and is completely devoid of pacifist white washing: http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=4520
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by richardjordan on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:38PM (#6857897)
An unfortunate turn of phrase, but it's not about pacifist white washing... his release from prison was into a society where apartheid had yet to be removed and he advocated that in many circumstances people need to use force to defend themselves against oppression for most of his life. The point is that it takes a certain obtuseness to focus on that when his crowning achievement was avoiding a bloodbath on transition away from South Africa, choosing instead a path of peace and reconciliation.

Also your flame-baiting attack on liberals is very confused - the key criticism by conservatives against liberals on this topic, for years, was their support for a terrorist who advocated violence, thereby themselves supporting violence. The truth is nuanced, but not to such a degree that it's incomprehensible to ordinary people.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:39PM (#6857912)
The word "struggle" occurs 16 times in that speech, and while it is not "pacifist", it is not "guerilla" either. The word covers every means of bringing about the end of Apartheid and start of democracy, from campaigning for votes through negotiations and yes, "Armed struggle". e.g. "mass marches and other forms of struggle" It refers to every means of bringing about the right ends.

There's a paragraph near the end starting "Our struggle has reached a decisive moment...". I read it as "keep your guns, they're what's keeping those guys at the negotiating table.". He was a smart politician, neither dogmatically for violence ... or dogmatically against it.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by jessedhillon on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:18PM (#6858395)
Your reading of that speech is incredible -- literally lacking credibility. No person familiar with the English language could reasonably conclude that it is in any way a call to arms. "Struggle" is a word with many connotations, something that you certainly must know already. Therefore, to me it's clear that you're attempting to manufacture a narrative in spite of the facts: the man became president of a majority black nation and could easily, if he was so vengeful as you'd like to portray him, have commanded force against his former jailers.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by ismail on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:28AM (#6859561)
" Our resort to the armed struggle in 1960 with the formation of the military wing of the ANC, Umkhonto we Sizwe, was a purely defensive action against the violence of apartheid. The factors which necessitated the armed struggle still exist today. We have no option but to continue. We express the hope that a climate conducive to a negotiated settlement will be created soon so that there may no longer be the need for the armed struggle.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by 3am on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:16PM (#6858108)
"I have fought against white domination and I have fought against black domination. I've cherished the ideal of a democratic and free society in which all persons live together in harmony and with equal opportunities. It is an ideal which I hope to live for and to achieve. But if needs be, it is an ideal for which I am prepared to die."

-Nelson Mandela

edit: also, "If you want to make peace with your enemy, you have to work with your enemy. Then he becomes your partner."

Your statement on Mandela is un-nuanced and simplistic. We all evolve through life, hopefully for the better. Mandela clearly became one of the great 20th century champions of peace alongside MLK and Gandhi. None of them were perfect human beings, but that doesn't diminish their greatness at all.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by rdl on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:46PM (#6858547)
I wouldn't call Mandela a champion of peace, but of freedom.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by jbooth on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:03PM (#6858638)
AND of peace.

Mandela was in prison for 27 years, oppressed his whole life before and after that, and once he gets power, his watchwords? Truth and Reconciliaton.

That's why he deserved the Nobel Peace Prize, because with any other leader (just pick a country on the same continent, Zimbabwe's right next door) that situation turns into a shitshow at that point.

The fact that he was in the ANC isn't what makes him notable, plenty of other guerilla leaders in Africa who threw out colonialists or white minority rule. That's not why we're talking about him. What he did when he won made him notable.

The "he wasn't peaceful" idiots on this thread are either incapable of seeing the big picture or fighting some dumb US domestic political battle.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by rdl on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:13PM (#6858709)
I agree what he did after he won was amazing, and a great precedent, but I value the victory against Apartheid by ~any means (largely non-violent) more, mainly because if he hadn't won that victory, he wouldn't have been in a position to be noble in victory.

(I don't think the Rhodesia precedent was exact, as the white rulers of Rhodesia were probably far more acceptable, and blacks far less oppressed, than they were in RSA; RSA was sufficiently self-sufficient that this could have gone on indefinitely. The other cases were anti-colonialism, which is also different; the Boers were not particularly tied to any European power, so there was no European state pulling out to end the colonial situation, either.)

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by cook1929 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:49PM (#6859082)
Let me get this right. Your logic is that intentionally bombing and killing mothers and children at civilian shopping malls are perfectly okay as long as apartheid exists.

Did I get that right?

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mbillie1 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:26PM (#6859399)
You have (at the time of my writing this) 3 comments, all in this thread, all anti-Mandela to the point of being almost pro-apartheid. Nice throwaway account!
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by cook1929 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:57PM (#6859466)
Nice ad hominem that completely ignores the argument!
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by netrus on Friday December 06, 2013 @03:09AM (#6860015)
Calling your comments 'pro-apartheid' is certainly not ad hominem.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by RyanZAG on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:16AM (#6860216)
Of course it is, it's the very definition. Obviously he's just trying to justify his stance, but you're still disregarding his argument which could be just as easily made by someone pro-apartheid or anti-apartheid since it's orthogonal.

Blowing up civilians is probably required at times, I don't know, but the exact border line where it moves from acceptable to unacceptable is a difficult one. Some people (justly) hold that it is always unacceptable and there is definitely nothing wrong with that stand. Others are more pragmatic and can accept that killing 10 civilians is preferable to having 10,000 slaves.

It's not an easy answer, don't dismiss it as an ad hominem.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by booyaa00 on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:06AM (#6860178)
You can be anti-apartheid, whilst also disagreeing that a good solution is to start bombing shopping malls and railway stations.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Symmetry on Friday December 06, 2013 @10:46AM (#6861609)
Weren't all those bombings carried out when Mandela was in jail? He was certainly responsible for a lot of industrial sabotage and preparations for armed revolt, but I'd put that in an entirely different category.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by rimantas on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:36AM (#6861186)

  > We all evolve through life, hopefully for the better.
Somehow this does not apply for war criminals who are persecuted even at Mandela's age.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:22PM (#6857787)
> Mandela was a symbol of non-peaceful resistance

Yes, and:

"Umkhonto we Sizwe (translated as "Spear of the Nation") was the armed wing of the African National Congress (ANC), co-founded by Nelson Mandela, fought against the South African government....

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umkhonto_we_Sizwe

Indeed, let's not allow anyone to sanitise history. It's a fact that Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher and PW Botha all called him a terrorist.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by moocowduckquack on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:44PM (#6857943)
It's a fact that Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher and PW Botha all called him a terrorist.

Is a bit like being called a wanker by Onan.

edit - pekk, it won't let me reply at the moment, but in answer to your comment, Thatcher was no idiot by any stretch of the imagination, but she did send the SAS to train Pol-Pot led forces, while Reagan put up the money, so I think she definitely had more than a little blood on her hands. - http://www.newstatesman.com/node/137397

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by patrickaljord on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:56AM (#6860622)
Margaret Thatcher's rule started in May 1979, the genocide in Cambodia ended in 1979, the Khmer Rouge were defeated in January 1979 by the Vietnamese army. Blaming the genocide on Thatcher is one of the most ridiculous and intellectually dishonest anti-Thatcher argument I've read yet.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khmer_Rouge_rule_of_Cambodia

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Thatcher

Also, if you're going to judge statesmen by the regimes they supported, then you should know that Mandela was a big supporter of Cuba's Castro, Saddam Hussein, Qaddafi and North Korea. Does that make Mandela a horrible man or statesman? Probably not, you'd be hard put to find a single statesman in history who never supported at least one evil regime.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by moocowduckquack on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:39AM (#6860782)
I didn't say that Thatcher was responsible for Cambodia's Year Zero. As you rightly say, she gave Pol-Pot support after Year Zero. At least the folk who gave him support before that have the excuse that they didn't know how he was going to turn out.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by patrickaljord on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:56AM (#6860830)
Year Zero corresponds to 1975, starts of the genocide, saying that she helped Pol Pot after Year Zero is disingenuous. She went into power in May 1979, when the genocide was over and the Khmer Rouge overthrown. So she had nothing to do with the killings. Also, the newstatesmen is highly leftist and the article very messy. I couldn't find any other source verifying all of these claims or to what extend did she personally help anything.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by moocowduckquack on Friday December 06, 2013 @08:15AM (#6860873)
Also, the newstatesmen is highly leftist and the article very messy. I couldn't find any other source

from that article -

Until 1989, the British role in Cambodia remained secret. The first reports appeared in the Sunday Telegraph, written by Simon O'Dwyer-Russell, a diplomatic and defence correspondent with close professional and family contacts with the SAS. He revealed that the SAS was training the Pol Pot-led force. Soon afterwards, Jane's Defence Weekly reported that the British training for the "non-communist" members of the "coalition" had been going on "at secret bases in Thailand for more than four years". The instructors were from the SAS, "all serving military personnel, all veterans of the Falklands conflict, led by a captain".

Or is The Telegraph and Jane's Defence Weekly still too left wing for you?

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by pekk on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:53PM (#6858283)
Margaret Thatcher (to pick one) was a terrible idiot, but not a terrorist.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by jessedhillon on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:25PM (#6858439)
Terrorism is a term used to describe almost exclusively violence conducted at the intersection of non-state endorsement and non-Western. A definition of terrorism which is derived from the impact and motivations of the violence would be impossible: state-sanctioned and non-sanctioned violence are separated by very blurry lines in those dimensions.

Therefore to say Margeret Thatcher is not a terrorist is like saying "blue things are not yellow." Duh. The term exists specifically to describe violence conducted by people who are not Thatchers.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by darkr on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:04AM (#6860658)
> Therefore to say Margeret Thatcher is not a terrorist is like saying "blue things are not yellow." Duh. The term exists specifically to describe violence conducted by people who are not Thatchers.

Unless you're Mark Thatcher

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Thatcher#2004_Equatorial_G...

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:09PM (#6858087)
In hindsight, yes.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by cm2012 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:26PM (#6857812)
While this is true, the remarkable part about Mandela is that his greatest accomplishments came 27 years after leaving the path of violence. He left prison not seeking revenge when it was possible, but offering forgiveness and hope.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:26PM (#6858993)
Mandela was a pragmatist. Non-violence was a tactic that fit the strategic need.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by capex on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:00AM (#6861019)
He could've been out of jail in a moment if he ever wanted to be a pragmatist.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Crito on Friday December 06, 2013 @03:14PM (#6863466)
Would leaving jail under those circumstances have helped his cause? If not, then doing so would not have been pragmatic.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by lennel on Thursday December 05, 2013 @10:49PM (#6859284)
tactic yes, but also a great appeal to his humanist intellectual position.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcv on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:25PM (#6858984)
What's more, he was on the US terrorist list until 2008.

I think the fact that Mandela was on it until 2008 is pretty much all you need to know about the US terrorist list. It can't be a very good list.

One man's freedom fighter is another man's terrorist. But Mandela fought for a very important cause: the freedom of an oppressed people. And he always used the most effective and appropriate weapons to fight that fight.

Anyone who calls him a terrorist is a crook.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by 72deluxe on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:21AM (#6860232)
I have no views on political matters but anyone who feels oppressed and fights back would by your argument be perfectly acceptable and their violence legitimate. If I feel oppressed, is violence by me perfectly acceptable? I suppose it depends who is defining what "oppressed" means.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcv on Saturday December 07, 2013 @04:25AM (#6866021)
It's not about feeling oppressed, it's about being oppressed, and not having any democratic means to change it. Use the soap box and the ballot box first. It's only when they take away your right to vote and your right to express your political ideas, that violence becomes your only option for change.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by tptacek on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:33PM (#6857866)
I'm not sure that being called a terrorist by PW Botha is all that meaningful.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by recusancy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:55PM (#6858009)
I can't reply to your statement below for some reason but Reagan vetoed the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid act. His veto was overridden by congress.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:41PM (#6857923)
True, but Reagan and Thatcher's statements had economic and military impact.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by tptacek on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:45PM (#6857947)
The Reagan administration implemented the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by nashequilibrium on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:58PM (#6858301)
Reagan actually vetoed it, what i find funny is this line: " President Reagan enlisted South African foreign minister Pik Botha to call Republicans on the fence." Pik Botha was one of the hardest apartheid officials, he held out until the end and wanted war. Source below.

'''Veto by President Reagan[edit] Reagan vetoed the compromised bill on September 26, calling it "economic warfare" and alleging that it would mostly hurt the impoverished black majority and lead to more civil strife.[10] He again offered to impose sanctions via executive order, while also working with Senate Republicans on concessions to avoid them overriding his veto. Reagan's veto was attacked harshly by anti-Apartheid leaders like Desmond Tutu who said Reagan would be "judged harshly by history".[11] In the week leading up to the subsequent vote, President Reagan enlisted South African foreign minister Pik Botha to call Republicans on the fence, though this was seen to backfire.[12] Veto override[edit] Reagan's veto was overridden by Congress (by the Senate 78 to 21, the House by 313 to 83) on October 2.[13] This override marked the first time in the twentieth century that a president had a foreign policy veto overridden.[2] Apartheid opponents in America and South Africa applauded the vote, while critics argued that it would be either ineffectual or lead to more violence.[12][14]'''

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:18PM (#6858733)
All true. The American and UK right-wing lead by Reagan and Thatcher were hugely influential in supporting the apartheid regime - they may have been nasty but they were at least anti-communist.

It is not a coincidence that after the Berlin wall fall and the "threat of communism" receded, a political settlement became possible in South Africa. The cold war has a lot to answer for.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by tomjakubowski on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:00PM (#6858035)
The Act that Reagan himself vetoed, yes.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by refurb on Friday December 06, 2013 @01:30AM (#6859743)
Reagan's explanation for vetoing is the same that many on the left use for advocating removal of the Cuba sanctions: they hurt the people more than they help.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:39PM (#6864586)
Reagan's real reason (as opposed to his explanation) was that during the cold war the USA would support any regime even really shitty ones like Pinochet in Chile or the National Party of South Africa that was openly anti-communist.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Baadier_Sydow on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:08PM (#6858077)
Well put.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by statguy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:44PM (#6858245)
> Indeed, let's not allow anyone to sanitise history. It's a fact that Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher and PW Botha all called him a terrorist.

That says more about them than it says about Mandela.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by ottovondog on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:27PM (#6859404)
The US is a symbol of non-peaceful dominance but somehow, thats okay, because 'destroying WMDs' or 'getting rid of the Taliban' are all better reasons to use violence than decades of systematic oppression.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:40PM (#6857917)
Could you explain why you think that "liberals" are trying to sanitise history more than anyone else?
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Joeboy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:52PM (#6857980)
They didn't say that. Misrepresenting popular / successful struggles as peaceful and overstating the effectiveness of pacifism are liberal tendencies though.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:53PM (#6857994)
The parent poster, mathieuh, says exactly that: "Do not allow liberals to sanitise history."
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Joeboy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:02PM (#6858045)
'Do not allow liberals to sanitise history.' vs '"liberals" are trying to sanitise history more than anyone else'

It is possible [Edit: and, I think, reasonable] to think the former but not the latter.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by alan_cx on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:33PM (#6858191)
He had to include the word "liberals". In other words, excluding every one else. Given the tone of the use of the word liberal and the unfounded accusation, its reasonable to assume he is a right wing type, and there for means to exclude the right from the accusation. There for he must be suggesting the "liberals" alone are likely to try to rewrite history, because, you know, the right would never do such a thing...

From here in the UK, Americans sneering the word liberal is a give away for a right wing nut job. Glen Beck etc. To us, well, me at least, it is highly amusing that so called right wing patriots wet them selves over the USA which is supposed to champion liberty, while using the word liberal as some sort of insult. Mean while, the right seem to actually support liberty in gun ownership etc. Very strange. Actually, very funny.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mathieuh on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:45PM (#6858252)
I am neither a right-winger nor an American. I am very much left-wing.

You should be aware that the left is vehemently against liberalism, as it presents such a rosy view of current society that it reduces the terrible things happening to being some floaty idea that doesn't apply to Me. As liberal media are doing currently by saying that Mandela was just a peaceful protestor.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:48PM (#6858262)
> You should be aware that the left is vehemently against liberalism

What does that statement even mean?

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Crito on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:23PM (#6858427)
Much of this terminology is muddled, particularly in America, which makes this difficult to talk about in a clear manner, but my understanding is that some leftists believe that liberals stand in the way of the true reform that leftist's want, and often take credit for the achievements of leftists to boot.

(Perhaps it is easier to consider that right wingers and conservatives are not necessarily the same thing, and can very easily be in conflict with each other. I'm not entirely sure if that helps..)

In this instance, it seems to me that mathieuh is very much a leftist, and likely considers Mandela to be the same. Certainly he seems to approve of what Mandela did (I think several people here are misinterpreting what mathieuh has said as criticism of Mandela). He thinks that liberals are attempting to co-opt Mandela as one of their own and apply ideologies associated with liberalism (nonviolence as an ends of its own) to Mandela, even if those associations are not grounded in history. In doing this, they obscure Mandela's true leftist ideologies, which were exceedingly successful. By rewriting leftist victories as liberal victories, diminishing the perceived value of leftist techniques, they present a threat to leftists.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:35PM (#6858491)
> some leftists believe that liberals stand in the way

I'm still not 100% sure if mathieuh (and you) are using the word "liberal" to mean "left" or "not left". I first assumed "left" but he's not making much sense that way.

I suggest that if you insist on using that word, be aware for the potential for great misunderstanding and confusion, and define somewhere what you mean by it. matthieuh's statement "I meant only what I wrote" is really not that, it presupposes that we speak the same language. And we don't.

> mathieuh is very much a leftist, and likely considers Mandela to be the same.

I also consider Mandela a leftist. This is due to the fact that his political party, the ANC, was in alliance with the South African Communist Party, and produced the Freedom charter http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=72 (see particularly nationalisation advocated in the section "The People Shall Share in the Country`s Wealth").

So it's not really a subjective matter, it's historic fact.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Crito on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:23PM (#6858762)
I believe the way mathieuh is using the word "liberal", a liberal would be under the general umbrella of leftism, or at least presents itself that way, but has interests that are not compatible/aligned with other brands of leftism, or the tactics employed by other leftists.

So in more concrete terms, mathieuh thinks that liberals oppose violent resistance, instead insisting on forms of nonviolent resistance such as civil disobedience (perhaps even when that proves ineffective). Liberals, wanting to claim Mandel as one of their own, "rewrite history" to make Mandel align with nonviolent resistance in a more strict way.

I believe mathieuh views liberalism as the enemy in the same way a Lamborghini owner might rage at a minivan in the fast lane. That is being a bit uncharitable though.

(I am trying hard not to inject my own opinion on what liberalism and leftism are; I am trying to explain how mathieuh is using these words, while remaining relatively charitable to his point of view. As such, I may be incorrect about what mathieuh thinks but the things I think he thinks might be correct. Similarly, I might be correct about what he thinks, but the things that he thinks may be incorrect. It would be best if he just gave a clear explanation of what he thinks...)

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dragonwriter on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:03PM (#6858641)
> I'm still not 100% sure if mathieuh (and you) are using the word "liberal" to mean "left" or "not left".

I think, in the sense used in the post at issue:

"Left":"Liberal"::Bolshevik:Menshevik

So liberal is to the left of Center but to the right of Left.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by cdash on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:33PM (#6859017)
Yes, in the US you must also consider the fact that center would actually be described right wing everywhere else. So you can see why a some leftists would deride so called liberals seeing them as fake leftist.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by brc on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:26PM (#6858990)
What it does show is that left v right is a useless axis to try and represent political views. Nobody ever really agrees what the terms even mean.

Also, the word 'liberal' is hopelessly lost for definition when having an international conversation.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by md224 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:15PM (#6858377)
This might help clarify, the semantics can be a bit confusing:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_liberalism_in_the_United...

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:06PM (#6858073)
What reasonable interpretation, "only allow right-wingers to sanitise history"?

I apologise for the clumsy phrase. The semantics of that doesn't matter, I just want to know what mathieuh is trying to say by calling special attention to "liberals" and not mentioning anyone else.

I suspect trolling. Mandela was deeply "liberal".

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mathieuh on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:38PM (#6858216)
I am about as far from the right as is possible to get.

I am calling special attention to liberals because at this moment liberal media are writing him off as having been a 'peaceful protestor' or some such banality.

I don't know why you are reading so much into this, I meant only what I wrote, I wasn't implying anything else.

I am fully aware (as I assumed most people were) that the right has labelled him a terrorist, and that until as recently as 2008 he was officially a terrorist according to the US.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by sanderjd on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:49PM (#6858854)
Language is hard... You appear to be using different definitions for "left" and "liberal" than many of us are familiar with. Perhaps because you are from a different country or culture than those of us who are confused (seems like mostly Americans), or perhaps it is because you usually talk to people in a "bubble" where everybody recognizes the same definitions (I'm personally more familiar with the unique word definitions of more right-leaning "bubbles"). Either way, once confusion arises, saying "I meant what I wrote" is not all that helpful in resolving it.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mikeash on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:52PM (#6858868)
I hope you'll think about what kind of replies you got here the next time you post something like this.

You may have had a point, but your phrasing was atrocious, essentially built to generate conflict and suppress any rational thought.

You could have made your point in a much better way such that people would actually reflect on what you said, rather than start political fights.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:51PM (#6858271)
I read what you wrote, I still have no idea what you meant.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by jessedhillon on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:34PM (#6858485)
matthieuh seems to be saying, don't buy the story that rosy nonviolence accomplished all this. Strategic use of violence, and the threat of it, were necessary to force negotiations and compromise.

So liberals are singled-out apparently because they tend towards this particular narrative of pure nonviolence.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:15PM (#6858717)
Probably, and you are correct about the ANC's "Strategic use of violence, and the threat of it"

But as discussed in other comments, he could mean anything by "liberals" so we have no idea why he calls them out.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Joeboy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:26PM (#6858157)
Presumably mathieuh used the word liberal as they were drawing attention to a liberal fallacy. I have no idea if they're an introspective leftist with a critique of pacifism or a paid Koch shill or something in between. The thing they said seems entirely reasonable to me though.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dragonwriter on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:33PM (#6858192)
> Misrepresenting popular / successful struggles as peaceful and overstating the effectiveness of pacifism are liberal tendencies though.

Seem to be more pacifist tendencies than liberal tendencies. Most pacifists may be liberals, but the converse is not even approximately true.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:06AM (#6860513)
The truth of what you say depend entirely on which of the many meanings of "liberal" you are thinking of.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:30PM (#6859011)
Because the liberal sales wing of the ruling class have the most influence among the segment of the population most likely to advocate change disruptive to the status quo. Pacifism is promoted as the only legitimate strategy in order to promote a political mindset that sees militance as taboo.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dinkumthinkum on Thursday December 05, 2013 @10:23PM (#6859185)
You're just talking partisan jibber jabber. Some people think peace is a useful route as violence tends to be a cycle that is hard to stop. Will peaceful action always work? No, the world is complicated. The fact that you say "the liberal sales wing of the ruling class" just makes you seem ridiculous.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mbillie1 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:41PM (#6859436)
> The fact that you say "the liberal sales wing of the ruling class" just makes you seem ridiculous.

"ridiculous" is generous here.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:19AM (#6859526)
I'm not trying to be partisan, simply implying that both sides are shilling for the same core interests (with social policy as the differentiator).
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dinkumthinkum on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:34AM (#6859585)
What?
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:44AM (#6859603)
I'll try to clarify my thinking here...

An earlier poster asked "Could you explain why you think that 'liberals' are trying to sanitise history more than anyone else?"

The ideas that keep the left and right from posing a political problem to the established order are, respectively, pacifism and patriotism. Pacifism limits conflict to electoral and symbolic efforts. Patriotism does the same by loyalty rather than dissidence. To reenforce the idea of pacifism, for the benefit of the left wing, the mainstream media canonizes pacifist heroes, such as Mandala and Ghandi, downplaying the roles of militants in their self-determination movements.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by kunai on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:59PM (#6858307)
In other words, Gandhi should be shunned because he was a sleazy lawyer who was screwing his wife while his father was dying across the hall.

We respect our heroes not for their flaws, but for their feats. It's no secret to anybody that the ANC used terror for political causes; what followed Mandela's jail term, however, is far more important. He didn't fix South Africa completely. Nobody could have, but the forgiveness he showed during his tenure, to both blacks and whites alike, is the notable part of his life. To myopically describe Mandela's actions as terroristic is to do a disgrace to one of the great leaders of our time.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by afriend4lyfe on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:40PM (#6857922)
He has come to represent forgiveness and peace over time by learning from his past mistakes. No one is saying he never fought fire with fire. It is untrue to say his life "was a symbol of non-peaceful resistance and the progress that it can bring." Especially because his greater achievements were made through peace and reconciliations.

No one's perfect but it's unreasonable to only focus on the negative.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Crito on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:47PM (#6858849)
I do not believe that mathieuh considers Mandela's "not always nonviolent" stance to be a negative.

I think the idea is more along the lines of "violence had its place in that conflict, it was for a good cause, and it worked."

Injecting my own opinion here: I think that if we forget the usefulness of violence then we may risk failing to repeat Mandela's success, should the need ever arise. Nonviolence is great, but only when it works. When it doesn't, violence should be embraced. We should embrace whatever is necessary to get the job done, nonviolence should be seen as a (typically very effective) means to an end, not an end in itself.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by eruditely on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:53PM (#6858584)
Except it is you who is projecting his value system over who you are responding to. Nobody implied 'violence' was wrong in this context, violence is at many times necessary and was so in mandela's case, he had to do what he had to do to achieve progress, and when it wasn't necessary he did, but when it was he did as well.

We cannot allow people to only paint him as peaceful completely simply because non-violent struggle is not what brought about long-term peace. Both did.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by nashequilibrium on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:31PM (#6857854)
Let it not be forgotten, Mandela prevented 2 wars! The first war of whites against blacks and a second war amongst blacks as there was a power struggle amongst the different black parties, most notably the IFP. Either of those wars would have been catastrophic.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by chasing on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:12PM (#6858097)
Yes, I also remember the bloody, vicious civil war he advocated after his release from prison that finally brought down Apartheid.

Oh, wait. That's not what happened at all, is it?

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Joeboy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:20PM (#6858126)
> The factors which necessitated the armed struggle still exist today. We have no option but to continue. We express the hope that a climate conducive to a negotiated settlement will be created soon so that there may no longer be the need for the armed struggle.

...is what Mandela said in his first speech after being released from prison. I'm not sure which half of your comment is intended to be sarcasm, but fwiw those are the words he used.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by utopkara on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:52PM (#6857984)
Obama's address points out to his non-peaceful background: "His journey from a prisoner to a president embodied the promise that human beings and countries can change for the better." And, in this case, we are talking about one of the better humans that ever lived.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by philwelch on Friday December 06, 2013 @10:07AM (#6861371)
"Change for the better"? That assumes that change happened at all. There's no inconsistency between using violence to effect political change and being magnanimous in victory.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by crisnoble on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:20PM (#6858408)
I think it is a little more complicated than "he was peaceful" or "he was non-peaceful".

Some great listening on the subject:

http://mandelahistory.com/ -a 5-part radio series documenting the struggle against apartheid through rare sound recordings, the voice of Nelson Mandela himself, as well as those who fought with him, and against him.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcv on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:33PM (#6859019)
> I think it is a little more complicated than "he was peaceful" or "he was non-peaceful".

He used violence when violence was needed, he used peace when peace is needed.

I'd like to be as pacifist as I can possibly be, but there simply are situations where violence is necessary. And severe oppression without non-violent means to end the oppression, is one of them. Some things need to be fought.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by cook1929 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:43PM (#6859059)
You're saying that it's fine to target your bombings at children and women if you're fighting to end something like apartheid?

Wow.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by frankzinger on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:26AM (#6859559)
So what, exactly, is your point? Are you saying that what the Apartheid government did was legal and legitimate? Obviously bombing civilians is wrong, nobody disputes that. But the Apartheid government killed and tortured many innocent people. Both sides did bad things. None of this is news. Why are you pointing this out?

Edit: the thing that makes Mandela special is that, once he became the government, it would have been just as "legitimate" for him to have behaved as the Apartheid government had, but he effected peace instead.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by richardw on Friday December 06, 2013 @05:54AM (#6860486)
The armed struggle went nowhere for decades until international sanctions forced the hand of the ruling party.

What Mandela fully understood at the time of his release was that the country required reconciliation. Nobody expected the power handover to go as smoothly as it did. Mandela was a huge contributor to that.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by brudgers on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:08PM (#6858347)
When did the interpretation of history become the sole prerogative of liberalism?

Auferre, trucidare, rapere, falsis nominibus imperium; atque, ubi solitudinem faciunt, pacem appellant.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by vixen99 on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:40AM (#6860287)
Ignoramuses I know but many us, dare I say, don't understand Latin. Assuming you're not quoting yourself, a source would be appreciated.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by amerika_blog on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:29AM (#6861140)
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by davidgerard on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:34PM (#6857873)
Thank you, Young Conservatives!
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Joeboy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:54PM (#6858001)
Just a reminder of the kind of thing members of the UK's ruling party were up to in the '80s: http://www.leftfootforward.org/images/2011/11/Conservative-F...
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Crito on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:51PM (#6858862)
mathieuh does not seem to be criticizing Mandela's use of violence. Rather, I believe he is criticizing the failure of others to recognize and appreciate Mandela's use of violence.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by diogenescynic on Friday December 06, 2013 @11:34AM (#6861893)
>Do not allow liberals to sanitise history.

It was the right that supported apartheid, almost until the end like Reagan and Thatcher. Dick Cheney voted against a 1986 resolution calling for the release of Mandela from prison. A month before Nelson Mandela was elected president Ron Paul's newsletter warned of a'South African Holocaust.' Get your facts straight.

It seems you're the one right-washing this.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dspeyer on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:51PM (#6858574)
That's part of the point. A single man -- even one who has engaged in violence -- can create peace in a situation where revenge is natural. In fact I wonder if his past willingness to use violence when he thought it justified is what gave him the credibility to say "it's not justified now" at the critical moment.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by alan_cx on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:23PM (#6858146)
Tryanny is the suppression of nuance.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by EliRivers on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:30AM (#6860559)
Is it acceptable to allow non-liberals to sanitise history, or is this your own political bias spilling over into your implied complaint about other people's political bias?
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by gadders on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:19PM (#6857762)
Do not allow liberals to do anything. Safer that way.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by warfangle on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:22PM (#6857786)
Do not allow anyone to do anything. Safer that way.

/reductio-ad-fascism

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by gadders on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:27PM (#6857818)
Ha ha. Fair point.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by pyrocat on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:30PM (#6857844)
U.S. GOP strategy summed up right there.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by gadders on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:35PM (#6857880)
You say it like it's a bad thing.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by aeturnum on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:07PM (#6858667)
Regardless of the success of one side's v.s. the other side's policies, a system which seeks to prevent either political "side" from accomplishing anything can hardly be called democratic. Only by honestly attempting mutually exclusive policies can we discover their efficacy in the real world. I think your eagerness to see a substantial proportion of the population lose their political agency to be far more disturbing than any particular political issue.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dinkumthinkum on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:13AM (#6859511)
Oh, some may want to remain neutral but I assure you, it is a bad thing. I found one of your compatriots on C-SPAN the other day, a member of House, saying he thought the solution to the Iranian problem is a series of "small" tactical nuclear strikes. Sounds like a winner party you have there.

http://santee.patch.com/groups/politics-and-elections/p/dunc...

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by purringmeow on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:39PM (#6858218)
"Long live the Cuban Revolution. Long live comrade Fidel Castro... Cuban internationalists have done so much for African independence, freedom, and justice. We admire the sacrifices of the Cuban people in maintaining their independence and sovereignty in the face of a vicious imperialist campaign designed to destroy the advances of the Cuban revolution. We too want to control our destiny... There can be no surrender. It is a case of freedom or death. The Cuban revolution has been a source of inspiration to all freedom-loving people."

Nelson Mandela, 1991

History is truly written by the victorious ones. I find it funny that people praise a communist guerrilla fighter, responsible for so much violence. That's like praising Che Guevara. Oh wait... And don't get me wrong - I hate the apartheid as much.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by ww520 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:54PM (#6858291)
I really admire his ability to walk away from power. Instead of making himself indispensable and hanging on to power indefinitely, he understood the importance of grooming the next generation, walking away, and letting the others to continue the work.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by srean on Thursday December 05, 2013 @10:47PM (#6859277)
> Forgiveness is the first step in changing a society

Yes, but sometimes it backfires. Sometimes a Nuremberg is necessary.

However, it has to be quick, but within limits of reason and fairness. It also has to be set in motion immediately after a change of hands. It should be more of a "fair compensation and equalization" than merely about retribution.

Although this will be a controversial comment, to see an example of where (Mujib ur Rahman's) "lets forgive, no harm, no foul" did not go down well is Bangladesh's war of independence.

The little that I know of the SA situation, Mandela chose right. But the right choice is not the same in every situation.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Crito on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:07PM (#6859335)
Your comment reminds me of Nicolae Ceaușescu, the brutal dictator of Romania between 1967 and 1989.

In on December 23, 1989 he and his wife were captured while attempting to flee the country. On December 25 they were given a show trial (playing more than a little fast and loose with fairness...), found to be guilty, and shot.

Nearly immediately after the execution, execution was declared to be abolished. This upset some Romanians who thought that more executions were in order, but their new constitution (ratified in 1991) cemented this decision. Nicolae and Elena Ceauşescu remain the last people ever executed in Romania.

From wikipedia:

"The manner in which the trial was conducted was widely criticized inside and outside Romania. However, Ion Iliescu, Romania's provisional president, said in 2009 that the trial was "quite shameful, but necessary" in order to end the state of near-anarchy that had gripped the country in the three days since the Ceaușescus fled Bucharest[23] Similarly, Victor Stănculescu, who had been defense minister before going over to the revolution, said in 2009 that the alternative would have been seeing the Ceaușescus lynched on the streets of Bucharest.[24]"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicolae_Ceau%C8%99escu

I am a bit conflicted on the whole affair, but I think my main take-away is that what needs to be done is not always pleasant, but if it must be done, do it fast and make sure it does not happen again. If you are going to do something unpleasant, make sure that you at least do it to break the cycle.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by capex on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:28AM (#6861136)
Could you explain a bit more on who Bangladesh forgave that didn't go well?
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by paternalist on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:08PM (#6859342)
"I think there are plenty of good people in America, but there are also plenty of bad people in America and the bad ones are the ones who seem to have all the power and be in these positions to block things that you and I need. Because this is the situation, you and I have to preserve the right to do what is necessary to bring an end to that situation, and it doesn't mean that I advocate violence, but at the same time I am not against using violence in self-defense. I don't even call it violence when it's self-defense, I call it intelligence." - Malcolm X
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by GnwbZHiU on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:08PM (#6858936)
> it's possible for a single man to create peace

No it's not possible. Nelson Mandela is a great and admirable man. But he did not work alone. The peace is the work of many men and women, and is still a work in progress.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dpcheng2003 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:23PM (#6858432)
"The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall." - Nelson Mandela

Just some inspiration for everyone here. RIP Madiba.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by lennel on Thursday December 05, 2013 @10:51PM (#6859287)
There was no push for war. The apartheid government just wanted to finish their plundering and not be liable for the economic position they created.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by CmonDev on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:12AM (#6860199)
Reverse apartheid?
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by a8da6b0c91d on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:23PM (#6857797)
> a single man to create peace

Let's keep in mind that South Africa has been very far from a peaceful place over the last 20 years. Many thousands have been murdered, and many thousands more have left the country.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by richardjordan on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:26PM (#6857817)
but it also hasn't been the bloodbath many who lived there expected it to become on the fall of apartheid - and Mandela bears a huge portion of the credit for this
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by rsynnott on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:50PM (#6858859)
South Africa's murder rate peaked before the end of apartheid; it has been on the decline since. It's still very high, but the idea that it's a result of the collapse of apartheid is not plausible.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by kika on Friday December 06, 2013 @02:30AM (#6859922)
I'd say "Rest in a necklace, Madiba".

It completely escapes me how sane people can so seriously worship cannibals like Mandela.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by capex on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:39AM (#6861203)
Can you justify what you said here?
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by kika on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:13PM (#6862155)
sure, like http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necklacing for example?

Moloko said her sister was burned to death with a tire around her neck while attending the funeral of one of the youths. Her body had been scorched by fire and some broken pieces of glass had been inserted into her vagina, Moloko told the committee.

In my book it's a perfect example of "cannibalism".

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by saraid216 on Friday December 06, 2013 @02:29PM (#6863113)
Not sure you have any idea what cannibalism is...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannibalism

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by kika on Saturday December 07, 2013 @03:26AM (#6865934)
Not sure if you have any idea what sarcasm is. I didn't mean he actually eat people, actually even if he did that wouldn't have changed a lot.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:30PM (#6870657)
> I didn't mean he actually eat people

That's not sarcasm. That's lying.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by kika on Sunday December 08, 2013 @09:09PM (#6872538)
When you call some political leader a "butcher" you lie, because he actually doesn't work in a butcher shop and doesn't have a license?

I linked to the wikipedia article about necklacing. Did you find any factual errors in there?