News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:40PM (#6857917)
Could you explain why you think that "liberals" are trying to sanitise history more than anyone else?
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Joeboy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:52PM (#6857980)
They didn't say that. Misrepresenting popular / successful struggles as peaceful and overstating the effectiveness of pacifism are liberal tendencies though.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:53PM (#6857994)
The parent poster, mathieuh, says exactly that: "Do not allow liberals to sanitise history."
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Joeboy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:02PM (#6858045)
'Do not allow liberals to sanitise history.' vs '"liberals" are trying to sanitise history more than anyone else'

It is possible [Edit: and, I think, reasonable] to think the former but not the latter.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by alan_cx on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:33PM (#6858191)
He had to include the word "liberals". In other words, excluding every one else. Given the tone of the use of the word liberal and the unfounded accusation, its reasonable to assume he is a right wing type, and there for means to exclude the right from the accusation. There for he must be suggesting the "liberals" alone are likely to try to rewrite history, because, you know, the right would never do such a thing...

From here in the UK, Americans sneering the word liberal is a give away for a right wing nut job. Glen Beck etc. To us, well, me at least, it is highly amusing that so called right wing patriots wet them selves over the USA which is supposed to champion liberty, while using the word liberal as some sort of insult. Mean while, the right seem to actually support liberty in gun ownership etc. Very strange. Actually, very funny.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mathieuh on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:45PM (#6858252)
I am neither a right-winger nor an American. I am very much left-wing.

You should be aware that the left is vehemently against liberalism, as it presents such a rosy view of current society that it reduces the terrible things happening to being some floaty idea that doesn't apply to Me. As liberal media are doing currently by saying that Mandela was just a peaceful protestor.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:48PM (#6858262)
> You should be aware that the left is vehemently against liberalism

What does that statement even mean?

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Crito on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:23PM (#6858427)
Much of this terminology is muddled, particularly in America, which makes this difficult to talk about in a clear manner, but my understanding is that some leftists believe that liberals stand in the way of the true reform that leftist's want, and often take credit for the achievements of leftists to boot.

(Perhaps it is easier to consider that right wingers and conservatives are not necessarily the same thing, and can very easily be in conflict with each other. I'm not entirely sure if that helps..)

In this instance, it seems to me that mathieuh is very much a leftist, and likely considers Mandela to be the same. Certainly he seems to approve of what Mandela did (I think several people here are misinterpreting what mathieuh has said as criticism of Mandela). He thinks that liberals are attempting to co-opt Mandela as one of their own and apply ideologies associated with liberalism (nonviolence as an ends of its own) to Mandela, even if those associations are not grounded in history. In doing this, they obscure Mandela's true leftist ideologies, which were exceedingly successful. By rewriting leftist victories as liberal victories, diminishing the perceived value of leftist techniques, they present a threat to leftists.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:35PM (#6858491)
> some leftists believe that liberals stand in the way

I'm still not 100% sure if mathieuh (and you) are using the word "liberal" to mean "left" or "not left". I first assumed "left" but he's not making much sense that way.

I suggest that if you insist on using that word, be aware for the potential for great misunderstanding and confusion, and define somewhere what you mean by it. matthieuh's statement "I meant only what I wrote" is really not that, it presupposes that we speak the same language. And we don't.

> mathieuh is very much a leftist, and likely considers Mandela to be the same.

I also consider Mandela a leftist. This is due to the fact that his political party, the ANC, was in alliance with the South African Communist Party, and produced the Freedom charter http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=72 (see particularly nationalisation advocated in the section "The People Shall Share in the Country`s Wealth").

So it's not really a subjective matter, it's historic fact.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Crito on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:23PM (#6858762)
I believe the way mathieuh is using the word "liberal", a liberal would be under the general umbrella of leftism, or at least presents itself that way, but has interests that are not compatible/aligned with other brands of leftism, or the tactics employed by other leftists.

So in more concrete terms, mathieuh thinks that liberals oppose violent resistance, instead insisting on forms of nonviolent resistance such as civil disobedience (perhaps even when that proves ineffective). Liberals, wanting to claim Mandel as one of their own, "rewrite history" to make Mandel align with nonviolent resistance in a more strict way.

I believe mathieuh views liberalism as the enemy in the same way a Lamborghini owner might rage at a minivan in the fast lane. That is being a bit uncharitable though.

(I am trying hard not to inject my own opinion on what liberalism and leftism are; I am trying to explain how mathieuh is using these words, while remaining relatively charitable to his point of view. As such, I may be incorrect about what mathieuh thinks but the things I think he thinks might be correct. Similarly, I might be correct about what he thinks, but the things that he thinks may be incorrect. It would be best if he just gave a clear explanation of what he thinks...)

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dragonwriter on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:03PM (#6858641)
> I'm still not 100% sure if mathieuh (and you) are using the word "liberal" to mean "left" or "not left".

I think, in the sense used in the post at issue:

"Left":"Liberal"::Bolshevik:Menshevik

So liberal is to the left of Center but to the right of Left.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by cdash on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:33PM (#6859017)
Yes, in the US you must also consider the fact that center would actually be described right wing everywhere else. So you can see why a some leftists would deride so called liberals seeing them as fake leftist.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by brc on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:26PM (#6858990)
What it does show is that left v right is a useless axis to try and represent political views. Nobody ever really agrees what the terms even mean.

Also, the word 'liberal' is hopelessly lost for definition when having an international conversation.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by md224 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:15PM (#6858377)
This might help clarify, the semantics can be a bit confusing:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_liberalism_in_the_United...

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:06PM (#6858073)
What reasonable interpretation, "only allow right-wingers to sanitise history"?

I apologise for the clumsy phrase. The semantics of that doesn't matter, I just want to know what mathieuh is trying to say by calling special attention to "liberals" and not mentioning anyone else.

I suspect trolling. Mandela was deeply "liberal".

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mathieuh on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:38PM (#6858216)
I am about as far from the right as is possible to get.

I am calling special attention to liberals because at this moment liberal media are writing him off as having been a 'peaceful protestor' or some such banality.

I don't know why you are reading so much into this, I meant only what I wrote, I wasn't implying anything else.

I am fully aware (as I assumed most people were) that the right has labelled him a terrorist, and that until as recently as 2008 he was officially a terrorist according to the US.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by sanderjd on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:49PM (#6858854)
Language is hard... You appear to be using different definitions for "left" and "liberal" than many of us are familiar with. Perhaps because you are from a different country or culture than those of us who are confused (seems like mostly Americans), or perhaps it is because you usually talk to people in a "bubble" where everybody recognizes the same definitions (I'm personally more familiar with the unique word definitions of more right-leaning "bubbles"). Either way, once confusion arises, saying "I meant what I wrote" is not all that helpful in resolving it.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mikeash on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:52PM (#6858868)
I hope you'll think about what kind of replies you got here the next time you post something like this.

You may have had a point, but your phrasing was atrocious, essentially built to generate conflict and suppress any rational thought.

You could have made your point in a much better way such that people would actually reflect on what you said, rather than start political fights.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:51PM (#6858271)
I read what you wrote, I still have no idea what you meant.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by jessedhillon on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:34PM (#6858485)
matthieuh seems to be saying, don't buy the story that rosy nonviolence accomplished all this. Strategic use of violence, and the threat of it, were necessary to force negotiations and compromise.

So liberals are singled-out apparently because they tend towards this particular narrative of pure nonviolence.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:15PM (#6858717)
Probably, and you are correct about the ANC's "Strategic use of violence, and the threat of it"

But as discussed in other comments, he could mean anything by "liberals" so we have no idea why he calls them out.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by Joeboy on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:26PM (#6858157)
Presumably mathieuh used the word liberal as they were drawing attention to a liberal fallacy. I have no idea if they're an introspective leftist with a critique of pacifism or a paid Koch shill or something in between. The thing they said seems entirely reasonable to me though.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dragonwriter on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:33PM (#6858192)
> Misrepresenting popular / successful struggles as peaceful and overstating the effectiveness of pacifism are liberal tendencies though.

Seem to be more pacifist tendencies than liberal tendencies. Most pacifists may be liberals, but the converse is not even approximately true.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:06AM (#6860513)
The truth of what you say depend entirely on which of the many meanings of "liberal" you are thinking of.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Thursday December 05, 2013 @09:30PM (#6859011)
Because the liberal sales wing of the ruling class have the most influence among the segment of the population most likely to advocate change disruptive to the status quo. Pacifism is promoted as the only legitimate strategy in order to promote a political mindset that sees militance as taboo.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dinkumthinkum on Thursday December 05, 2013 @10:23PM (#6859185)
You're just talking partisan jibber jabber. Some people think peace is a useful route as violence tends to be a cycle that is hard to stop. Will peaceful action always work? No, the world is complicated. The fact that you say "the liberal sales wing of the ruling class" just makes you seem ridiculous.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mbillie1 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @11:41PM (#6859436)
> The fact that you say "the liberal sales wing of the ruling class" just makes you seem ridiculous.

"ridiculous" is generous here.

Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:19AM (#6859526)
I'm not trying to be partisan, simply implying that both sides are shilling for the same core interests (with social policy as the differentiator).
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by dinkumthinkum on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:34AM (#6859585)
What?
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies by mcantelon on Friday December 06, 2013 @12:44AM (#6859603)
I'll try to clarify my thinking here...

An earlier poster asked "Could you explain why you think that 'liberals' are trying to sanitise history more than anyone else?"

The ideas that keep the left and right from posing a political problem to the established order are, respectively, pacifism and patriotism. Pacifism limits conflict to electoral and symbolic efforts. Patriotism does the same by loyalty rather than dissidence. To reenforce the idea of pacifism, for the benefit of the left wing, the mainstream media canonizes pacifist heroes, such as Mandala and Ghandi, downplaying the roles of militants in their self-determination movements.